As usual, check out parts one through three by clicking their respective links on ye olde sidebar.
What do you do after a catastrophe?
Last time we looked at the wholly remarkable "train wreck" which punctuates (with several exclamation points) the development of the Third Symphony. It is, in short, a total musical catastrophe. The development section, up to the train wreck, is a seething mass of competing themes already. Indeed, even without our catastrophe and the third theme to follow, this development section would have been unusual in Beethoven's time for its length and intensity. But the train wreck raises the bar. It plunges the piece into a warlike chaos, destabilizing any sense of harmonic, melody, or even rhythmic balance.
So what do you do after a catastrophe? Beethoven, in a sense, had written himself into a corner with the train wreck.* So he responds by doing something completely new and different. He plays us a melody.
* In a hilarious understatement and/or misunderstanding and/or ironic quip the editor of the Liszt piano transcription notes, in the space between the train wreck and the theme to which we are, by degrees, coming: "Here the genius of Beethoven saw the necessity of a change." Um, yeah. Considering the entire piece just fell apart, I don't know that it takes a genius to see that something pretty amazing has to happen. No, the genius is the one who can put it back together.**
** Scratch that, the genius is the one who is so confident in his ability that he knows he can put it back together, and therefore chooses to break it in the first place. The "genius of Beethoven" saw this whole thing coming a mile away. Then again, maybe that's the ironic quip: the necessity of a change is not in this piece, but in composition itself.
Not to say that the previous two themes are not melodies. They are, in a rudimentary, arpeggiated kind of way. But this one actually is a melody. It includes tones that are not the one, three, or five of the tonic chord. Said another way, it moves stepwise instead of by chord tones. Said another way, it's something you can actually sing without sounding totally ridiculous.*
*Seriously, try singing the opening theme with this lyric I was cursed enough to hear: "Oh my word, it's Beethoven's Third, again." It may be a fantastic theme, but I defy you to take it seriously as a melody.
What do we make of this melody? Well, on its own it's quite pleasant. It's not harmonically all that complex (just a series of tonic to dominant and back; about as simple as it gets). It's rhythmically straightforward. It's, well, a song. Which is perhaps nothing special in itself, but remember how we got here.
You see, what strikes us as a simple, pleasant, but largely uncomplicated melody on its own is transformed into a kind of symphonic messiah in context. This third theme literally saves the movement from total chaos, swooping in just after some of the most dissonant, ugly, weird chords that any composer has dared write into a symphony. It's simplicity is chief virtue: we are rebuilding a melody. Indeed, we are rebuilding melody itself.
Following the metaphor from the last post, this theme is an attempt to recreate that beautiful life of the Viennese waltz after bombardment has destroyed the city. It is not melancholy, particularly, even if it has a touch of minor tonality. Rather it is resignedly determined, complete with a simple-minded view that everything can and will be alright, that the city can and will be rebuilt.
But war - and music - is never that simple. For where do we go after this theme but once more unto the proverbial breach.
The third theme - as you may have noticed in the first two snippets - doesn't resolve itself. Instead it launches right back into the opening theme. That opening theme, far from being a return to "normal," becomes a catalyst for rapid and unpredictable harmonic motion. We sway from major to minor and back, we change keys, and we end up back at the third theme, only a half step (!) higher. This time the third theme isn't around for long, either, taking a new melodic turn before leading us into a new statement of the opening theme in which it's not clear where our attention should go. Are we meant to follow the broiling flutes, or the arpeggios in the bass?
This potential second train wreck is stopped by a harmonic, melodic, and rhythmic reset that is not quite as intense as the one that introduced the third theme, but is jarring nonetheless. Instead of chaos, we see a kind of sickeningly quiet order, a plucking of pizzicato strings set against the tension of a sustained dominant chord. And then, of course, the horn comes in (early), and we're back to the opening of the symphony in the form of the recapitulation, where things are very much the way they were when we started. Except, they're completely different. All of which will be the subject of part five.
Anyway, the purpose of all that is to give us context for thinking more about this third theme. As a piece of music, this third theme is hardly amazing. As a piece of narrative, it is brilliant. Standing between total destruction and the remainder of the development section, it speaks to a kind of naive optimism that, once beaten down, cannot help but return again (and once against get sent away). Now, I don't think that Beethoven means to discount this theme, but I also don't think that we can take it at face value.
What would taking it at face value look like? Well, I think it would be easy to look at the third theme and to say it's a nice maneuverer, a clever ploy to allow Beethoven to go boom boom and get away with it. It's easy to say it's pretty, and nice, and beautiful. It's easy to say that it's genius. It's a lot harder to say why it's all of those things, however, and harder still to say that, maybe, we're not supposed to actually like this theme.
That is, we are supposed to like it, but only because it's so much nicer to listen to than the noise that came before it (or, for that matter, the strangeness that comes after it). We like it by contrast. But, as mentioned above, it's not a particularly great piece of music, nor does it really get its chance to play itself out. No, I believe this theme is a stand in, a joke, a classic example of Beethoven thumbing his nose at his listeners (especially the uptight ones that would have really hated the train wreck). It's a statement that, no, everything is not alright anymore. In the face of the kinds of harmonic and melodic atrocities - so-called, anyway - Beethoven commits in the development section, the tradition of music cannot be the same.
While examining the opening theme, I talked about the infamous C#. It raises questions about heroism, about music and narrative, about harmonic and melodic function. This third theme, I think, starts to answer those questions, but in a subtle and subversive way. If music is powerful, I asked, is it also dangerous? The answer, in this development section, is yes. Music is dangerous. Music can change mediocrity into greatness, or vice versa. Music can tell a story about power and conflict, music can persuade, music can frustrate and anger, music can inspire. All of that makes music dangerous.
I don't think, to be clear, that it's the train wreck that is dangerous, for all of the chaos that it embodies. No, it's this third theme that's the dangerous one, precisely because it's so perfect. The chance for easy redemption, the opportunity to pretend that a revolution isn't really a big deal, these things are a danger. And music, too, is a danger, if it chooses not to unfurl itself. Before Beethoven composers rarely, if ever, wrote about themselves, about music, about power. They wrote, largely, to be pleasing, to make money, and to praise God. Beethoven does all of those things, but he also drives deeper, and in so doing unearths the flaw of the music of his predecessors (however great much of it was): it can't stand up to true musical force.
We have further to go in this movement, but I want to leave with a glimpse of the entire development section. In the last two posts I've subdivided the development into two parts: pre-train wreck, and post. It's worth listening to the whole thing as one unit. I won't offer any more commentary, since the last two posts have more than enough. Rather, I'll let the music do the talking. Here's the entire development section of the Third Symphony.
Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 27, 2011
Thursday, May 26, 2011
Listening to Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, Part Three: Catastrophe
To get to parts one and two, as well as the introduction, use the handy-dandy side bar. These posts are listed just under the "search" and "subscribe" widgets.
"Catastrophe" is a Greek word, a combination of "strophe" - meaning turn - and "kata" - meaning down. "Strophe" was used primarily to describe the actions of the chorus in Greek plays, with each choral poem either a Strophe or an anti-strophe, a figurative motion in one direction, or in another. Catastrophe, then, is a total interruption of that process, a proverbial wrench in the works, a form-defying event in the course of the narrative.
In the development section of the first movement of Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, the listener confronts what can only be described as a catastrophe. The common name of this section is "the train wreck," and it shows Beethoven at his most intense, most devious, and most, well, catastrophic. Here's the development section of the opening movement, up to and including the "train wreck," but leaving out the resolution that follows (because that's the next post):
As you can hear, the beginning of the development is a tumultuous back and forth between the second theme (see part two) and the opening theme (see part one). I think it's fair to say the development starts out relatively cohesive, but each repeat of either theme adds further and further chaos. The opening theme starts to sway against itself, raising in pitch and intensity, the secondary theme finds itself beset by all kinds of strange counterpoint. New melodies are introduced, adding tension due to their dominant feel and the urgency of the violins playing them. Before long, the back-and-forth of strophe (the militant first theme) and anti-strophe (the pastoral second theme) collapses on itself in what can only be described as catastrophe. As the piece bucks and writhes, it reaches its climax in the "train wreck," separated from the development below:
All semblance of meaningful melody or rhythmic progress disappears from the piece here. While harmonically the progression still makes sense, that's hardly the point. This section is barely, by the classical definition, even music. So many of the chords are dissonant, the entire orchestra is blaring, and there is nothing to do but to push on from one horrible, full-voiced, dissonant chord to the next.
It's too easy to focus just on the train wreck itself, however, and that's why I've included the build-up to it, also. If the first and second themes truly are incompatible - as I suggested earlier in this series of posts - it's no wonder that, once they were really forced to reckon with each other in the development section, they created a kind of musical conflagration. A potentially helpful image, if an imperfect one, would be the Viennese elite at their dancing and partying (the second theme) suddenly beset by an invading revolutionary army. The result is chaos, the destruction of the court itself, and along with it the decomposition (so to speak) of the courtly music to which the nobles were dancing.
A particularly interesting part of this collapse, to my mind, comes not in the loud and flashy places that jump out even during a cursory listening to the development. No, there's a subtle trick Beethoven plays in the buildup to the train wreck, an inversion of the melodic and rhythmic quality of the second theme that says more about what's going on here than just about anything else. Listen again to the last statement of the second theme before the train wreck, and then the passage that follows it and leads into our catastrophe:
Can you hear the rhythmic inversion? Here again is a piece of the theme:
And here's the inversion:
The waltz is still there in the inverted version, but it's hidden behind a strange and different rhythmic emphasis. All that's really different, actually, is that strong beat of the melody used to fall on the first beat of the measure, in the original theme, but instead falls on the second beat of the measure in the "inverted" version. The result of this minor change, however, is a fundamental shift in the feel of the melody, a transformation from Viennese waltz to urgent escape from impending disaster.
That this variation of the second theme leads into the train wreck is telling. Rather than returning to the opening theme, which has found some measure of stability in its back-and-forth washing earlier in the development (perhaps it's not a satisfying kind of stability, but like a pendulum, at least it's not going anywhere), it's the second theme that leads us into catastrophe. And it does so by allowing itself to be broken, by succumbing to the chaos that surrounds it in the development section.
As for the train wreck itself, there's little to say except that it is completely different from anything in any symphony that comes before it. As I said earlier, it would hardly be considered music by Beethoven's contemporaries, chiefly because of its dissonance and lack of melody, but also because it plays more of a narrative role than a musical one. By pointing out the strange motions of the second theme, I hope I've helped you to see how the train wreck is not just a sudden and loud interruption, but rather an inevitable collapse after increasingly strained efforts to put the square peg of the second theme into the round hole of the symphony.
As a wrap-up to this post, I want to ask a couple of questions about meaning. Well, a question anyway. What, really, does all of this mean? In the first couple of posts of this series, I've talked some about potential narrative interpretations we might impose on the symphony, but at the same time I've been hesitant to pick one and stick with it. Even in this post, I've used the "Viennese nobles confront revolutionary army" idea, but I tell you know that it's only a crutch, a way to help getting at the music.
I suppose, as I listen more and more to the Eroica, as I dive deeper (and I'm diving deeper now than I did even when writing my thesis), I truly am starting to feel like the music has its own narrative, its own meaning, and its own mode of communication. I don't think that's purely emotional, because I can trace it with some semblance of literary objectivity. Nor do I think it's purely spiritual, because, while it's mysterious, I'm not sure how meta-physical it is (would, for example, I be able to follow the narrative in the same way were I deaf?).
No, I think the narrative of Beethoven's music is musical, and its meaning equally so. It's unfortunate that we're stuck using words like "meaning" to describe a meaning that is non-linguistic, but then again isn't that exactly the point of this effort, to find a way to bridge that gap? Ah, but the point is also to help bring myself (and my readers) closer to an understanding of that musical meaning, even if that understanding is fundamentally non-linguistic. What I mean is, I will not be able to write a sentence that says: this is what the Eroica means, but I hope that, by sharing the process of trying to understand and - inasmuch as it possible - translate it, we might all get a little better at our music comprehension.
It is no accident, either, that the train wreck raises this conundrum. I know of no moment in any other piece that is so direct an attack on the notion that music has no meaning, no narrative value on its own. Then again, it remains one of the most difficult-to-penetrate moments in Beethoven's oeuvre, precisely because its lack of melodic structure makes it less "musical." Perhaps, then, our next assay into the symphony will help, when we look at the third theme, the resolution of the catastrophe.
"Catastrophe" is a Greek word, a combination of "strophe" - meaning turn - and "kata" - meaning down. "Strophe" was used primarily to describe the actions of the chorus in Greek plays, with each choral poem either a Strophe or an anti-strophe, a figurative motion in one direction, or in another. Catastrophe, then, is a total interruption of that process, a proverbial wrench in the works, a form-defying event in the course of the narrative.
In the development section of the first movement of Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, the listener confronts what can only be described as a catastrophe. The common name of this section is "the train wreck," and it shows Beethoven at his most intense, most devious, and most, well, catastrophic. Here's the development section of the opening movement, up to and including the "train wreck," but leaving out the resolution that follows (because that's the next post):
As you can hear, the beginning of the development is a tumultuous back and forth between the second theme (see part two) and the opening theme (see part one). I think it's fair to say the development starts out relatively cohesive, but each repeat of either theme adds further and further chaos. The opening theme starts to sway against itself, raising in pitch and intensity, the secondary theme finds itself beset by all kinds of strange counterpoint. New melodies are introduced, adding tension due to their dominant feel and the urgency of the violins playing them. Before long, the back-and-forth of strophe (the militant first theme) and anti-strophe (the pastoral second theme) collapses on itself in what can only be described as catastrophe. As the piece bucks and writhes, it reaches its climax in the "train wreck," separated from the development below:
All semblance of meaningful melody or rhythmic progress disappears from the piece here. While harmonically the progression still makes sense, that's hardly the point. This section is barely, by the classical definition, even music. So many of the chords are dissonant, the entire orchestra is blaring, and there is nothing to do but to push on from one horrible, full-voiced, dissonant chord to the next.
It's too easy to focus just on the train wreck itself, however, and that's why I've included the build-up to it, also. If the first and second themes truly are incompatible - as I suggested earlier in this series of posts - it's no wonder that, once they were really forced to reckon with each other in the development section, they created a kind of musical conflagration. A potentially helpful image, if an imperfect one, would be the Viennese elite at their dancing and partying (the second theme) suddenly beset by an invading revolutionary army. The result is chaos, the destruction of the court itself, and along with it the decomposition (so to speak) of the courtly music to which the nobles were dancing.
A particularly interesting part of this collapse, to my mind, comes not in the loud and flashy places that jump out even during a cursory listening to the development. No, there's a subtle trick Beethoven plays in the buildup to the train wreck, an inversion of the melodic and rhythmic quality of the second theme that says more about what's going on here than just about anything else. Listen again to the last statement of the second theme before the train wreck, and then the passage that follows it and leads into our catastrophe:
Can you hear the rhythmic inversion? Here again is a piece of the theme:
And here's the inversion:
The waltz is still there in the inverted version, but it's hidden behind a strange and different rhythmic emphasis. All that's really different, actually, is that strong beat of the melody used to fall on the first beat of the measure, in the original theme, but instead falls on the second beat of the measure in the "inverted" version. The result of this minor change, however, is a fundamental shift in the feel of the melody, a transformation from Viennese waltz to urgent escape from impending disaster.
That this variation of the second theme leads into the train wreck is telling. Rather than returning to the opening theme, which has found some measure of stability in its back-and-forth washing earlier in the development (perhaps it's not a satisfying kind of stability, but like a pendulum, at least it's not going anywhere), it's the second theme that leads us into catastrophe. And it does so by allowing itself to be broken, by succumbing to the chaos that surrounds it in the development section.
As for the train wreck itself, there's little to say except that it is completely different from anything in any symphony that comes before it. As I said earlier, it would hardly be considered music by Beethoven's contemporaries, chiefly because of its dissonance and lack of melody, but also because it plays more of a narrative role than a musical one. By pointing out the strange motions of the second theme, I hope I've helped you to see how the train wreck is not just a sudden and loud interruption, but rather an inevitable collapse after increasingly strained efforts to put the square peg of the second theme into the round hole of the symphony.
As a wrap-up to this post, I want to ask a couple of questions about meaning. Well, a question anyway. What, really, does all of this mean? In the first couple of posts of this series, I've talked some about potential narrative interpretations we might impose on the symphony, but at the same time I've been hesitant to pick one and stick with it. Even in this post, I've used the "Viennese nobles confront revolutionary army" idea, but I tell you know that it's only a crutch, a way to help getting at the music.
I suppose, as I listen more and more to the Eroica, as I dive deeper (and I'm diving deeper now than I did even when writing my thesis), I truly am starting to feel like the music has its own narrative, its own meaning, and its own mode of communication. I don't think that's purely emotional, because I can trace it with some semblance of literary objectivity. Nor do I think it's purely spiritual, because, while it's mysterious, I'm not sure how meta-physical it is (would, for example, I be able to follow the narrative in the same way were I deaf?).
No, I think the narrative of Beethoven's music is musical, and its meaning equally so. It's unfortunate that we're stuck using words like "meaning" to describe a meaning that is non-linguistic, but then again isn't that exactly the point of this effort, to find a way to bridge that gap? Ah, but the point is also to help bring myself (and my readers) closer to an understanding of that musical meaning, even if that understanding is fundamentally non-linguistic. What I mean is, I will not be able to write a sentence that says: this is what the Eroica means, but I hope that, by sharing the process of trying to understand and - inasmuch as it possible - translate it, we might all get a little better at our music comprehension.
It is no accident, either, that the train wreck raises this conundrum. I know of no moment in any other piece that is so direct an attack on the notion that music has no meaning, no narrative value on its own. Then again, it remains one of the most difficult-to-penetrate moments in Beethoven's oeuvre, precisely because its lack of melodic structure makes it less "musical." Perhaps, then, our next assay into the symphony will help, when we look at the third theme, the resolution of the catastrophe.
Labels:
Beethoven,
catastrophe,
Eroica,
harmony,
interpretation,
meaning,
melody,
Music,
narrative,
rhythm,
themes,
train wreck
Monday, April 11, 2011
Listening to Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, Part Two: Themes and Structure
Here's a link to Part One. You can also navigate through the series using the "Beethoven Project Posts" on the right bar of the blog.
In the opening movement of the Eroica Symphony, Beethoven introduces no less than three primary themes. The third theme - which is really the most remarkable one - we're not going to talk about yet, except to mention that it will happen later on at a surprising place in the piece. The first two, however, are fair game even at this early juncture in our listening, because that's where they occur.
A word, before we take a look at those two themes, about sonata form. You've undoubtedly heard the word "sonata" before, but may have assumed it refers to those solo piano (or maybe piano with violin) pieces like the Moonlight, Tempest, or Hammerklavier sonatas by Beethoven. The root of the word, however, refers not to instrumentation, but to formal structure within a piece. That formal structure was, up to and beyond Beethoven's time - usually present in the first movement of a symphony. Sometimes you may even hear an opening movement referred to as "the sonata," but this is rare except among musicologists because of the confusion it causes.
What is "sonata form?" In short, it's an A-A-B-A structure. That is, there's an introductory "A" section - called in classical music the "exposition" - in which themes are introduced and developed, and at least one initial modulation* occurs. That A section is then repeated note-for-note, though some recordings of longer works like the Eroica skip this repeat (including, incidentally, the Dudamel recording in our first post). After playing the A section twice, the B section, or "development," ensues. This is not unlike a "bridge" in modern popular music, in that it usually differs substantially from the original A section, but is still related thematically. Development sections (before Beethoven and the Eroica in particular) were often very short departures from the main ideas of the piece, designed to wedge apart the initial exposition from the recapitulation to follow.
* A modulation is a departure from the original key, accomplished by invoking a dominant feel relative to a key that is not the actual tonic. As a result, modulations usually move around either the circle of fifths or the circle of fourths, because keys a fourth or fifth away are closely related (they share all but one note) with the original tonic, making it easy to suggest a movement to a new key.
The recapitulation, then, is what follows the development. It is a restatement of the introductory A section, for a third time, but usually with modifications. As we'll see in the Eroica, this means there will be a very different treatment of the opening theme. Likewise, where an early modulation usually results in the exposition being played mostly in a key other than the tonic, the recapitulation usually is designed to allow the entire first section to appear in the original key. The result - for a trained listener who can hear such large-scale harmonic motions - is that the recapitulation is the first time the piece really feels like it's in the "right" key.
Sonata form is often bracketed with an introduction and/or a coda. The Eroica does not really have an introduction, per se, except for maybe the first two big Eb Major chords. It does, however, have a lengthy coda that comes after the recapitulation. Indeed, the coda might be the richest, most complex, and most engaging part of the entire piece, so we'll be spending some time there later. The reason for this is that, traditionally, the coda was used as a place to wrap things up and bring a piece to a nice flourishing finish. In the opening of the Eroica, the coda is actually used almost as a second development section. Material is reworked and reintroduced, developed in new ways, and synthesized unexpectedly.
Before we get there, however, we have to understand Beethoven's use of thematic material. As mentioned, the Eroica has three primary themes, two of which appear early in the piece. The first you've already hear, because it appears at the very beginning. I've left in the opening chords, but they aren't properly part of the theme:
The second theme occurs not that much further in, and it sounds like this:
In contrast to the opening theme, it is, well, melodic. Rather than overwhelming the whole orchestra - as the opening theme does after its initial statement* - this theme actually employs a variety of instruments, including winds and strings. It is not quite sweet, and it is followed by, of course, further intensity (including the "horse galloping motif shortly afterwards), but it is still a departure from the rough, militant opening.
* I encourage you to go back to the first post and re-listen to the movement as a whole. You'll see that, shortly before the second theme is introduced, this first theme is played by basically the entire orchestra all at once.
Which calls to mind one of the inherent contradictions of this first movement. These first two themes - introduced a mere minute apart from each other - are so vastly, wildly, different for a reason. That reason is related, furthermore, to the time signature of the piece. We're in 3/4, the tempo of waltzes and minuets. Listen to that second theme again. Doesn't it sound a little like a waltz? What is a dance doing in our little military march?
But, really, what is our military march doing in 3/4 time? Marches - like the second movement - are usually written in 2/4. The Eroica, however, is somewhere in between war-march and courtly-dance, between chaotic battle and refined elegance. There is no question that it comes down, in the end, further on the side of tumult than tranquility, but it nevertheless has these moments, these spontaneous outbursts of simple joy amidst such momentous, revolutionary conflict.
Perhaps some light is shed on this strange duality by the form of the piece. Despite the stretching and bending that Beethoven makes the sonata form do in this movement - pushing each part to its limit - we're still in sonata form. If we take up, once again, questions about meaning and narrative, we might ask what it means to have a revolution that, nevertheless, maintains at least a semblance of the old order. We might also ask who our waltzes are, whether they're Viennese noblemen and noblewomen who simply don't see and won't acknowledge the battles raging outside their courtly walls, or whether they're, instead, maybe the revolutionaries themselves, joyful at the prospect of victory.
As in the first post, I won't commit myself to a single interpretation, but I do want to start to forward a psychological angle here. Beethoven's hero - regardless of his political and social intent - is above all Beethoven himself. The Eroica, famously, is one of the first major pieces Beethoven composed after he learned definitively of his oncoming deafness. It is a piece he intended to write as an affront to musical sensibilities of his time. The revolution, then, is a musical one. It's hero is Beethoven. The themes, the quirks, the tumult and battle, and the sweetness are Beethoven's own.
It is so easy to picture Beethoven as he is in movies like Immortal Beloved, a surly, overwrought archetype of human suffering. Beethoven was not that.* Beethoven was extremely intelligent and witty, fundamentally kind-hearted, if a bit short-tempered, and above all intensely hard-working and devoted to his art. That he found joy in music is unquestionable, as the Ninth Symphony undoubtedly proves, but even here in the third the beginnings of that project are visible. We'll see much more of Beethoven's joy as we move through the other movements (especially the finale), but even here it begins to be present.
* That was Chopin.
The second theme, in this listening, is the dance of Beethoven's spirit, a waltz that - under the oppressive weight of his oncoming deafness and the isolation that will inevitably bring - is brushed aside too easily. While it appears again and again in this first movement, it always feels secondary, so much so that I recall many arguments in my music classes at St. John's as to whether it should really count as the "second theme" at all, it feels so weak and out of place. But that, I suppose, is exactly the point. Unassertive and transitory as it is, this second theme is a linchpin for the piece as a whole, an answer to the roaring questions the first theme asks about the purpose and meaning of human life.
Is it a satisfactory answer to those questions? Maybe, maybe not. Regardless, it certainly isn't acknowledged as such in this movement. And yet it's still there, dancing along throughout the battle, in spite of the battle, or maybe even because of the battle.
And to think, this isn't even the interesting theme.
In the opening movement of the Eroica Symphony, Beethoven introduces no less than three primary themes. The third theme - which is really the most remarkable one - we're not going to talk about yet, except to mention that it will happen later on at a surprising place in the piece. The first two, however, are fair game even at this early juncture in our listening, because that's where they occur.
A word, before we take a look at those two themes, about sonata form. You've undoubtedly heard the word "sonata" before, but may have assumed it refers to those solo piano (or maybe piano with violin) pieces like the Moonlight, Tempest, or Hammerklavier sonatas by Beethoven. The root of the word, however, refers not to instrumentation, but to formal structure within a piece. That formal structure was, up to and beyond Beethoven's time - usually present in the first movement of a symphony. Sometimes you may even hear an opening movement referred to as "the sonata," but this is rare except among musicologists because of the confusion it causes.
What is "sonata form?" In short, it's an A-A-B-A structure. That is, there's an introductory "A" section - called in classical music the "exposition" - in which themes are introduced and developed, and at least one initial modulation* occurs. That A section is then repeated note-for-note, though some recordings of longer works like the Eroica skip this repeat (including, incidentally, the Dudamel recording in our first post). After playing the A section twice, the B section, or "development," ensues. This is not unlike a "bridge" in modern popular music, in that it usually differs substantially from the original A section, but is still related thematically. Development sections (before Beethoven and the Eroica in particular) were often very short departures from the main ideas of the piece, designed to wedge apart the initial exposition from the recapitulation to follow.
* A modulation is a departure from the original key, accomplished by invoking a dominant feel relative to a key that is not the actual tonic. As a result, modulations usually move around either the circle of fifths or the circle of fourths, because keys a fourth or fifth away are closely related (they share all but one note) with the original tonic, making it easy to suggest a movement to a new key.
The recapitulation, then, is what follows the development. It is a restatement of the introductory A section, for a third time, but usually with modifications. As we'll see in the Eroica, this means there will be a very different treatment of the opening theme. Likewise, where an early modulation usually results in the exposition being played mostly in a key other than the tonic, the recapitulation usually is designed to allow the entire first section to appear in the original key. The result - for a trained listener who can hear such large-scale harmonic motions - is that the recapitulation is the first time the piece really feels like it's in the "right" key.
Sonata form is often bracketed with an introduction and/or a coda. The Eroica does not really have an introduction, per se, except for maybe the first two big Eb Major chords. It does, however, have a lengthy coda that comes after the recapitulation. Indeed, the coda might be the richest, most complex, and most engaging part of the entire piece, so we'll be spending some time there later. The reason for this is that, traditionally, the coda was used as a place to wrap things up and bring a piece to a nice flourishing finish. In the opening of the Eroica, the coda is actually used almost as a second development section. Material is reworked and reintroduced, developed in new ways, and synthesized unexpectedly.
Before we get there, however, we have to understand Beethoven's use of thematic material. As mentioned, the Eroica has three primary themes, two of which appear early in the piece. The first you've already hear, because it appears at the very beginning. I've left in the opening chords, but they aren't properly part of the theme:
The second theme occurs not that much further in, and it sounds like this:
In contrast to the opening theme, it is, well, melodic. Rather than overwhelming the whole orchestra - as the opening theme does after its initial statement* - this theme actually employs a variety of instruments, including winds and strings. It is not quite sweet, and it is followed by, of course, further intensity (including the "horse galloping motif shortly afterwards), but it is still a departure from the rough, militant opening.
* I encourage you to go back to the first post and re-listen to the movement as a whole. You'll see that, shortly before the second theme is introduced, this first theme is played by basically the entire orchestra all at once.
Which calls to mind one of the inherent contradictions of this first movement. These first two themes - introduced a mere minute apart from each other - are so vastly, wildly, different for a reason. That reason is related, furthermore, to the time signature of the piece. We're in 3/4, the tempo of waltzes and minuets. Listen to that second theme again. Doesn't it sound a little like a waltz? What is a dance doing in our little military march?
But, really, what is our military march doing in 3/4 time? Marches - like the second movement - are usually written in 2/4. The Eroica, however, is somewhere in between war-march and courtly-dance, between chaotic battle and refined elegance. There is no question that it comes down, in the end, further on the side of tumult than tranquility, but it nevertheless has these moments, these spontaneous outbursts of simple joy amidst such momentous, revolutionary conflict.
Perhaps some light is shed on this strange duality by the form of the piece. Despite the stretching and bending that Beethoven makes the sonata form do in this movement - pushing each part to its limit - we're still in sonata form. If we take up, once again, questions about meaning and narrative, we might ask what it means to have a revolution that, nevertheless, maintains at least a semblance of the old order. We might also ask who our waltzes are, whether they're Viennese noblemen and noblewomen who simply don't see and won't acknowledge the battles raging outside their courtly walls, or whether they're, instead, maybe the revolutionaries themselves, joyful at the prospect of victory.
As in the first post, I won't commit myself to a single interpretation, but I do want to start to forward a psychological angle here. Beethoven's hero - regardless of his political and social intent - is above all Beethoven himself. The Eroica, famously, is one of the first major pieces Beethoven composed after he learned definitively of his oncoming deafness. It is a piece he intended to write as an affront to musical sensibilities of his time. The revolution, then, is a musical one. It's hero is Beethoven. The themes, the quirks, the tumult and battle, and the sweetness are Beethoven's own.
It is so easy to picture Beethoven as he is in movies like Immortal Beloved, a surly, overwrought archetype of human suffering. Beethoven was not that.* Beethoven was extremely intelligent and witty, fundamentally kind-hearted, if a bit short-tempered, and above all intensely hard-working and devoted to his art. That he found joy in music is unquestionable, as the Ninth Symphony undoubtedly proves, but even here in the third the beginnings of that project are visible. We'll see much more of Beethoven's joy as we move through the other movements (especially the finale), but even here it begins to be present.
* That was Chopin.
The second theme, in this listening, is the dance of Beethoven's spirit, a waltz that - under the oppressive weight of his oncoming deafness and the isolation that will inevitably bring - is brushed aside too easily. While it appears again and again in this first movement, it always feels secondary, so much so that I recall many arguments in my music classes at St. John's as to whether it should really count as the "second theme" at all, it feels so weak and out of place. But that, I suppose, is exactly the point. Unassertive and transitory as it is, this second theme is a linchpin for the piece as a whole, an answer to the roaring questions the first theme asks about the purpose and meaning of human life.
Is it a satisfactory answer to those questions? Maybe, maybe not. Regardless, it certainly isn't acknowledged as such in this movement. And yet it's still there, dancing along throughout the battle, in spite of the battle, or maybe even because of the battle.
And to think, this isn't even the interesting theme.
Labels:
Beethoven,
dance,
Eroica,
interpretation,
joy,
Music,
music history,
sonata form,
themes
Tuesday, March 1, 2011
Listening to Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, Part One: A Revolutionary Opening
Does music have meaning outside of its context? That is, when a piece is so revolutionary, so very different from everything that came before it, can we hear that difference, or do we have to be trained to hear it? Even with training, even with a knowledge of what came before, doesn't the "new" piece still sound to us like it is decidedly old, that is doesn't even begin to capture the things that came later in the composer's career, much less the things that came after the composer's death?
Those are some of the questions I struggle with when trying to explain Beethoven's Eroica Symphony. It's unlike anything written before it. The first movement alone takes about 15 minutes, making it as long as some Haydn and Mozart symphonies in their entirety. The second movement is another 15 minutes. The thing as a whole takes over a quarter hour, so long that Beethoven advised it not be performed late in a concert program lest the audience become restless.
Length, however, is not always indicative of a revolution. War and Peace is a long book, but it doesn't feel like a particularly revolutionary book as you read it. Don't get me wrong, it deserves its reputation as a great work, and it is extremely ambitious in its storytelling, but it did not fundamentally alter the way that books were written, as far as I know. The Eroica, on the other hand, well, it did fundamentally alter the writing of music. Or, if it did not alone, it was the capstone of a set of works that did.
Can you hear what makes it so outrageous, so different, so offensive, so intense, so awesome? Here's a rendition from the Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra, conducted, at the time, by the incomparable Gustavo Dudamel.
There's a lot in this piece, too much to talk about all at once, so let's start with the beginning. The big, fat, E-flat Major chords that open the piece are perhaps a tad jarring, but it's not unusual for a composer to signal what key he's in to start off a piece. No, what's really odd is what comes after those two chords. Take a listen to the first few seconds of the piece again.
The melody that Beethoven introduces here doesn't sound particularly odd to our modern ears, but it would have been jarring in its time. What's more, it was uncharacteristic even for Beethoven. Why? Because it has a flatted seventh (Db or C#) in it.
After the two chords, what you hear is an outline of the Eb Major triad: Eb - G - Eb - Bb - Eb - G - Bb. That is followed by a chromatic descent to the 7: Eb - D - C#. This is jarring because that C# is not a part of the Eb Major scale. It destabilizes the key, making Eb feel like a dominant, and not a tonic.* As a result, we're pulled away from the tonic, and you can hear it quite clearly in the clip; it sounds incomplete, it sounds like it's going somewhere, and it's not entirely clear where.
* Quick theory 101 lesson: tonic is, generally, the key the piece is in. It feels restful and complete. Think of a simple piece like Mary Had a Little Lamb, or Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. The tonic happens at the very beginning and ending of those pieces. The dominant, meanwhile, is usually the chord on the 5th of the tonic. It feels unstable and pulls you back towards the tonic. Try singing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and stopping on the "how I wonder what you" without singing the "are." That "what you" is the dominant.
Analyzing the experience of hearing this opening harmonically is only a beginning, however. More important is the meaning: what is Beethoven trying to accomplish with this C#? This symphony is called - by Beethoven himself - Eroica, "Heroic." Famously, it was originally written for Napoleon Bonaparte, but rededicated after the French Consul declared himself Emperor to Beethoven's chagrin. Is this a Napoleonic symphony, then, a story of the French Revolution? Or is it, perhaps, meant to stand for an ideal instead? Was it ever, really, about Napoleon at all?
Those are questions we can't answer yet, and some of those questions may not be easy to answer from the music alone. Instead, we need to dive into the narrower questions posed by the infamous C#. What kind of heroism is this piece going to be about? Martial heroism? Political heroism? Populist heroism? Artistic heroism? And what does it mean to have the tonic - the core of the piece - destabilized so early? Perhaps the heroic is a result of instability. We, as listeners, are invited to understand musically the context in which heroism takes place.
On the other hand, some listeners want to make the opening theme stand for the hero, and not heroism or the hero's situation. In that account, the C# is perhaps some kind of Greek tragic flaw, hubris, or a failure of self-awareness. If the piece is about Napoleon, there could be a kind of accidental truth to this interpretation: while it was written before Napoleon's ambition became clear, the piece might nevertheless anticipate his arrogance.
For my part, I do not think there is meant to be a single correct interpretation. Music is not, after all, denotative. There is, however, intent. Beethoven intends, regardless of specific imagery we apply to his C#, to make us uncomfortable, to make us wonder what is going on. This effect is compounded by the meter of the piece. The opening movement, here, is in 3/4, despite its "military march" feel. Indeed, the opening two chords are wholly ambiguous - they could just as easily be in 4/4 - and it is only with the introduction of the very theme that destabilizes harmonically that we realize our rhythmic expectations have been violated as well.
Regardless of specific interpretation, it is worth recognizing that the movement as a whole is very warlike. Particular motifs and themes suggesting a battlefield are frequent. For example, there's this "galloping horses" motif:
And a passage many liken to cannon fire:
This latter passage is particularly notable thanks to the extended "4/4" at the end of it. After a series of "1-2-rest, 1-2-rest" chords we hear a bunch of big fat "bam rest bam rest bam rest" chords that betray the time signature.* This is a particularly warlike device, because it shakes the rhythmic foundations of the piece.
*This moment of undermining the time signature is worth keeping in mind as we progress, because it is a tool Beethoven will use in every movement of the symphony.
These motifs we'll come across as we progress through the first movement, but for now they can lend a hand to our understanding of the opening. In short, there is a revolution afoot. What kind of revolution? It's hard to say. Certainly a musical one - for nothing quite like this symphony has ever been written before - but perhaps a political one and a spiritual one as well. What that looks like, how music can convey that or - perhaps more to the point - help to create that is the question that we'll be confronting throughout this series of posts. For now, it's sufficient to recognize that the opening of the Eroica sets us up to go on a long journey. The destabilization of the tonic here is not something easily resolved, and it may take quite some time to put everything back together again. Indeed, as we wrap up the first movement (in the distant future) we'll have cause to ask whether or not the questions raised by our C# have really been resolved: can you return to the tonic - to the way things were - after such a piece of music? Is the hero of this piece redeemable? Is heroism itself? Is there such a thing as a great man in an egalitarian society?
Beethoven, in his idealism, believed that Napoleon would bring about a Europe filled with equality and freedom and opportunity. But there's more than just boundless optimism in the Eroica, because Beethoven recognized the innate contradiction in Napoleon's project: forcing equality on the world. He believed the General could do it, but his symphony - from its very outset - is very much aware of the challenge. That Napoleon himself did not live up to Beethoven's expectations - or, more properly, his dream - does not change the very nature of the project. If anything, it only reinforces how extremely difficult it is to accomplish what the Eroica suggests: transforming a society for the better.
But we're getting ahead of ourselves. For now, we've set off on the heroic journey of the 3rd Symphony. It's not always pretty, and it's not always easy, but it is exciting and stirring and intense. The fear and indignation with which many of Beethoven's listeners - those disciples of Haydn and Mozart who believed music should be just so - was countered by the excitement and expectation of those listeners who could tell that this was a new, and altogether more powerful kind of music.
If powerful, then also dangerous, perhaps? That's another question we'll have to pursue as we go along. Before we get there, however, let's first learn how to hear the optimism, the idealism, the joy, along with the frustration and the violence in the Eroica. Without hearing those things, first, the question of danger and power is meaningless.
Those are some of the questions I struggle with when trying to explain Beethoven's Eroica Symphony. It's unlike anything written before it. The first movement alone takes about 15 minutes, making it as long as some Haydn and Mozart symphonies in their entirety. The second movement is another 15 minutes. The thing as a whole takes over a quarter hour, so long that Beethoven advised it not be performed late in a concert program lest the audience become restless.
Length, however, is not always indicative of a revolution. War and Peace is a long book, but it doesn't feel like a particularly revolutionary book as you read it. Don't get me wrong, it deserves its reputation as a great work, and it is extremely ambitious in its storytelling, but it did not fundamentally alter the way that books were written, as far as I know. The Eroica, on the other hand, well, it did fundamentally alter the writing of music. Or, if it did not alone, it was the capstone of a set of works that did.
Can you hear what makes it so outrageous, so different, so offensive, so intense, so awesome? Here's a rendition from the Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra, conducted, at the time, by the incomparable Gustavo Dudamel.
There's a lot in this piece, too much to talk about all at once, so let's start with the beginning. The big, fat, E-flat Major chords that open the piece are perhaps a tad jarring, but it's not unusual for a composer to signal what key he's in to start off a piece. No, what's really odd is what comes after those two chords. Take a listen to the first few seconds of the piece again.
The melody that Beethoven introduces here doesn't sound particularly odd to our modern ears, but it would have been jarring in its time. What's more, it was uncharacteristic even for Beethoven. Why? Because it has a flatted seventh (Db or C#) in it.
After the two chords, what you hear is an outline of the Eb Major triad: Eb - G - Eb - Bb - Eb - G - Bb. That is followed by a chromatic descent to the 7: Eb - D - C#. This is jarring because that C# is not a part of the Eb Major scale. It destabilizes the key, making Eb feel like a dominant, and not a tonic.* As a result, we're pulled away from the tonic, and you can hear it quite clearly in the clip; it sounds incomplete, it sounds like it's going somewhere, and it's not entirely clear where.
* Quick theory 101 lesson: tonic is, generally, the key the piece is in. It feels restful and complete. Think of a simple piece like Mary Had a Little Lamb, or Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. The tonic happens at the very beginning and ending of those pieces. The dominant, meanwhile, is usually the chord on the 5th of the tonic. It feels unstable and pulls you back towards the tonic. Try singing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and stopping on the "how I wonder what you" without singing the "are." That "what you" is the dominant.
Analyzing the experience of hearing this opening harmonically is only a beginning, however. More important is the meaning: what is Beethoven trying to accomplish with this C#? This symphony is called - by Beethoven himself - Eroica, "Heroic." Famously, it was originally written for Napoleon Bonaparte, but rededicated after the French Consul declared himself Emperor to Beethoven's chagrin. Is this a Napoleonic symphony, then, a story of the French Revolution? Or is it, perhaps, meant to stand for an ideal instead? Was it ever, really, about Napoleon at all?
Those are questions we can't answer yet, and some of those questions may not be easy to answer from the music alone. Instead, we need to dive into the narrower questions posed by the infamous C#. What kind of heroism is this piece going to be about? Martial heroism? Political heroism? Populist heroism? Artistic heroism? And what does it mean to have the tonic - the core of the piece - destabilized so early? Perhaps the heroic is a result of instability. We, as listeners, are invited to understand musically the context in which heroism takes place.
On the other hand, some listeners want to make the opening theme stand for the hero, and not heroism or the hero's situation. In that account, the C# is perhaps some kind of Greek tragic flaw, hubris, or a failure of self-awareness. If the piece is about Napoleon, there could be a kind of accidental truth to this interpretation: while it was written before Napoleon's ambition became clear, the piece might nevertheless anticipate his arrogance.
For my part, I do not think there is meant to be a single correct interpretation. Music is not, after all, denotative. There is, however, intent. Beethoven intends, regardless of specific imagery we apply to his C#, to make us uncomfortable, to make us wonder what is going on. This effect is compounded by the meter of the piece. The opening movement, here, is in 3/4, despite its "military march" feel. Indeed, the opening two chords are wholly ambiguous - they could just as easily be in 4/4 - and it is only with the introduction of the very theme that destabilizes harmonically that we realize our rhythmic expectations have been violated as well.
Regardless of specific interpretation, it is worth recognizing that the movement as a whole is very warlike. Particular motifs and themes suggesting a battlefield are frequent. For example, there's this "galloping horses" motif:
And a passage many liken to cannon fire:
This latter passage is particularly notable thanks to the extended "4/4" at the end of it. After a series of "1-2-rest, 1-2-rest" chords we hear a bunch of big fat "bam rest bam rest bam rest" chords that betray the time signature.* This is a particularly warlike device, because it shakes the rhythmic foundations of the piece.
*This moment of undermining the time signature is worth keeping in mind as we progress, because it is a tool Beethoven will use in every movement of the symphony.
These motifs we'll come across as we progress through the first movement, but for now they can lend a hand to our understanding of the opening. In short, there is a revolution afoot. What kind of revolution? It's hard to say. Certainly a musical one - for nothing quite like this symphony has ever been written before - but perhaps a political one and a spiritual one as well. What that looks like, how music can convey that or - perhaps more to the point - help to create that is the question that we'll be confronting throughout this series of posts. For now, it's sufficient to recognize that the opening of the Eroica sets us up to go on a long journey. The destabilization of the tonic here is not something easily resolved, and it may take quite some time to put everything back together again. Indeed, as we wrap up the first movement (in the distant future) we'll have cause to ask whether or not the questions raised by our C# have really been resolved: can you return to the tonic - to the way things were - after such a piece of music? Is the hero of this piece redeemable? Is heroism itself? Is there such a thing as a great man in an egalitarian society?
Beethoven, in his idealism, believed that Napoleon would bring about a Europe filled with equality and freedom and opportunity. But there's more than just boundless optimism in the Eroica, because Beethoven recognized the innate contradiction in Napoleon's project: forcing equality on the world. He believed the General could do it, but his symphony - from its very outset - is very much aware of the challenge. That Napoleon himself did not live up to Beethoven's expectations - or, more properly, his dream - does not change the very nature of the project. If anything, it only reinforces how extremely difficult it is to accomplish what the Eroica suggests: transforming a society for the better.
But we're getting ahead of ourselves. For now, we've set off on the heroic journey of the 3rd Symphony. It's not always pretty, and it's not always easy, but it is exciting and stirring and intense. The fear and indignation with which many of Beethoven's listeners - those disciples of Haydn and Mozart who believed music should be just so - was countered by the excitement and expectation of those listeners who could tell that this was a new, and altogether more powerful kind of music.
If powerful, then also dangerous, perhaps? That's another question we'll have to pursue as we go along. Before we get there, however, let's first learn how to hear the optimism, the idealism, the joy, along with the frustration and the violence in the Eroica. Without hearing those things, first, the question of danger and power is meaningless.
Labels:
Beethoven,
C#,
Eroica,
French Revolution,
Gustavo Dudamel,
heroism,
meaning,
Music,
music history,
music theory,
Napoleon
Thursday, February 24, 2011
A Music Project
I cannot tell you how many times I've started to work on my Beethoven-Wagner post and stopped, unsure as to how exactly to proceed. You see, the problem is, every time I try to put the thoughts together, I end up falling back to all of the work I did for my undergraduate thesis, tracing the spiritual and political motions of Beethoven's 3rd and 9th Symphonies. More importantly, I reflect on how many holes I left in that project. Even though the result was a nearly 40 page paper (cut down from a maximum of over 50 thanks to the wisdom of my advisor), it was a synopsis of what I really wanted to accomplish.
In reality, what I wanted to write was a book and not an essay. Not a normal book about music, either. Like the St. John's music curriculum that I went through three years in a row as an assistant, I wanted to think about and write about and talk about music at the intersection of rigorous music theory, simple music appreciation, real music history, and, perhaps above all, music philosophy. I suppose you could call all of that, in short, "musicology," but that only obscures the particulars.
The problem is, my Beethoven-Wagner post - which, really, could be a one paragraph long "isn't this cool?" - hinges upon at least some semblance of musical knowledge from all of the above fields. On some level my perception of the link between Tristan und Isolde and the 9th Symphony is merely "feeling," but there's so much history, music theory, and, perhaps above all, a philosophy of how to understand the meaning of music tied up in my understanding of the two works. That makes it impossible, as T.S. Eliot says in Prufrock, to say exactly what I mean.
Does all that sound pretentious? Perhaps, but this is one area where I don't care about sounding pretentious. I respect that musical tastes differ, of course, but I also think that the ad-hoc dismissal of the project of understanding music - and especially classical music - smacks of willful ignorance. Too often I have heard - from people who love baroque music to people who love hip hop - that to study music is to rob it of its life, its passion, and its power. To me, that is an excuse.* It is a shameful agreement to disagree. For example, the tired "classical music is boring but I'm ok if you like it" argument strikes me as being lazy, principally because even a cursory study of classical music will demonstrate that it is certainly not boring. Perhaps classical music concerts are boring, and the stuffy culture surrounding the music is often boring, and writing about classical music is frequently boring, but the music itself is intricate and complex, full of (objectively) more harmonic, rhythmic, formal, and melodic variation than the vast majority of modern music. That means it might be more difficult, more complex, and thus less immediately accessible - all legitimate complaints - but hardly more boring.
*Furthermore, it misses the point. One's appreciation of music increases with its study, just as in every other field. It is difficult to find a cosmologist who is not even more awestruck by the universe than an amateur stargazer. There are few sabermetricians who are less avid baseball fans than the RBI-junkie. Few musicians, composers, and even music critics are not violently passionate about music, despite, and indeed because of, their knowledge.**
**OK, total tangent on this one. Have you ever noticed that "despite" can usually be substituted for "because of," even though the two are, in principal, opposites? It is an interesting quality of the narratives we build about success and failure that the two are so often interchangeable. For example, "despite his speech impediment, the child grew up to be a successful politician." Perhaps true, but "because of" fits well, too, because it is often the case, in such stories, that overcoming the speech impediment is what gave the child the confidence and drive to become a politician in the first place. At the very least, the "victory despite impossible odds" story gets told because of the impossible odds. Which is perhaps more to the point; that "despite" is the reason the story exists in the first place, and thus, while it may not be that success owes to the thing being overcome, that success is noteworthy at all is.
Phew, where were we?
All of which brings me to the project: learning to listen to and talk about classical music. Now, I have already begun that process - a process which inspired my thesis, and which was a significant factor in my decision to apply to UCSD's Communications program (with the aim of studying the learning and cultural acquisition of music) for my PhD - but I am no expert. I am, I would argue, an expert learner, however, and that means that maybe, just maybe, I can drag someone somewhere along with me. Or, at the very least - and more precisely, in any case - I can chronicle my learning so that it is traceable. The project, then, is to listen, and in listening, to learn to listen, to Beethoven's 3rd. If all goes well, then we can launch into the 9th and Tristan und Isolde, and perhaps other pieces as well (indeed, I have already done this with other posts on Bizet's Farandole and Brahms's Variations on a Theme by Haydn, and even Sacris Solemnis, a setting of Beethoven's 7th, but not as well as I would have liked).
Now this is not a one post project, or even a five post project.* The Eroica's first movement, alone, might take a half dozen posts. Nor will these posts be continuous. You can still expect political wranglings, game reviews and observations, philosophical or literary musings, and of course, now that the season is coming, baseball analysis in this space. Some might say that's a weakness of this blog: it lacks focus. But I consider it a strength: it is vast, it contains multitudes.
*Indeed, the secret goal, here, is to write a book. Perhaps a book no one would read, or - more importantly in our commerical age - no one would publish, but a book nonetheless. Ambitious? Perhaps, but you have to start somewhere, and whereas aspiring writers used to toil in anonymity for years before having their writing rejected by publishers, modern writers at least have the benefit of toiling publically.
Regardless of the number of posts, or the amount of time, however, we'll be forming a narrative. Perhaps not a perfectly linear one, and perhaps not a perfectally literary one. Rather, I'm hoping to build - for myself and for my readers - a mythology of music, a philosophy of music, and, most importantly, a deeper understanding not only of how music works, but why it works, and why, above all, it matters. That's no small goal, I realize, but it is a goal I believe in, and a goal that I think we forget too easily in a world where music is everywhere, and largely unexamined. Let us examine it, friends, that we might more joy in it that way.
In reality, what I wanted to write was a book and not an essay. Not a normal book about music, either. Like the St. John's music curriculum that I went through three years in a row as an assistant, I wanted to think about and write about and talk about music at the intersection of rigorous music theory, simple music appreciation, real music history, and, perhaps above all, music philosophy. I suppose you could call all of that, in short, "musicology," but that only obscures the particulars.
The problem is, my Beethoven-Wagner post - which, really, could be a one paragraph long "isn't this cool?" - hinges upon at least some semblance of musical knowledge from all of the above fields. On some level my perception of the link between Tristan und Isolde and the 9th Symphony is merely "feeling," but there's so much history, music theory, and, perhaps above all, a philosophy of how to understand the meaning of music tied up in my understanding of the two works. That makes it impossible, as T.S. Eliot says in Prufrock, to say exactly what I mean.
Does all that sound pretentious? Perhaps, but this is one area where I don't care about sounding pretentious. I respect that musical tastes differ, of course, but I also think that the ad-hoc dismissal of the project of understanding music - and especially classical music - smacks of willful ignorance. Too often I have heard - from people who love baroque music to people who love hip hop - that to study music is to rob it of its life, its passion, and its power. To me, that is an excuse.* It is a shameful agreement to disagree. For example, the tired "classical music is boring but I'm ok if you like it" argument strikes me as being lazy, principally because even a cursory study of classical music will demonstrate that it is certainly not boring. Perhaps classical music concerts are boring, and the stuffy culture surrounding the music is often boring, and writing about classical music is frequently boring, but the music itself is intricate and complex, full of (objectively) more harmonic, rhythmic, formal, and melodic variation than the vast majority of modern music. That means it might be more difficult, more complex, and thus less immediately accessible - all legitimate complaints - but hardly more boring.
*Furthermore, it misses the point. One's appreciation of music increases with its study, just as in every other field. It is difficult to find a cosmologist who is not even more awestruck by the universe than an amateur stargazer. There are few sabermetricians who are less avid baseball fans than the RBI-junkie. Few musicians, composers, and even music critics are not violently passionate about music, despite, and indeed because of, their knowledge.**
**OK, total tangent on this one. Have you ever noticed that "despite" can usually be substituted for "because of," even though the two are, in principal, opposites? It is an interesting quality of the narratives we build about success and failure that the two are so often interchangeable. For example, "despite his speech impediment, the child grew up to be a successful politician." Perhaps true, but "because of" fits well, too, because it is often the case, in such stories, that overcoming the speech impediment is what gave the child the confidence and drive to become a politician in the first place. At the very least, the "victory despite impossible odds" story gets told because of the impossible odds. Which is perhaps more to the point; that "despite" is the reason the story exists in the first place, and thus, while it may not be that success owes to the thing being overcome, that success is noteworthy at all is.
Phew, where were we?
All of which brings me to the project: learning to listen to and talk about classical music. Now, I have already begun that process - a process which inspired my thesis, and which was a significant factor in my decision to apply to UCSD's Communications program (with the aim of studying the learning and cultural acquisition of music) for my PhD - but I am no expert. I am, I would argue, an expert learner, however, and that means that maybe, just maybe, I can drag someone somewhere along with me. Or, at the very least - and more precisely, in any case - I can chronicle my learning so that it is traceable. The project, then, is to listen, and in listening, to learn to listen, to Beethoven's 3rd. If all goes well, then we can launch into the 9th and Tristan und Isolde, and perhaps other pieces as well (indeed, I have already done this with other posts on Bizet's Farandole and Brahms's Variations on a Theme by Haydn, and even Sacris Solemnis, a setting of Beethoven's 7th, but not as well as I would have liked).
Now this is not a one post project, or even a five post project.* The Eroica's first movement, alone, might take a half dozen posts. Nor will these posts be continuous. You can still expect political wranglings, game reviews and observations, philosophical or literary musings, and of course, now that the season is coming, baseball analysis in this space. Some might say that's a weakness of this blog: it lacks focus. But I consider it a strength: it is vast, it contains multitudes.
*Indeed, the secret goal, here, is to write a book. Perhaps a book no one would read, or - more importantly in our commerical age - no one would publish, but a book nonetheless. Ambitious? Perhaps, but you have to start somewhere, and whereas aspiring writers used to toil in anonymity for years before having their writing rejected by publishers, modern writers at least have the benefit of toiling publically.
Regardless of the number of posts, or the amount of time, however, we'll be forming a narrative. Perhaps not a perfectly linear one, and perhaps not a perfectally literary one. Rather, I'm hoping to build - for myself and for my readers - a mythology of music, a philosophy of music, and, most importantly, a deeper understanding not only of how music works, but why it works, and why, above all, it matters. That's no small goal, I realize, but it is a goal I believe in, and a goal that I think we forget too easily in a world where music is everywhere, and largely unexamined. Let us examine it, friends, that we might more joy in it that way.
Labels:
9th symphony,
Beethoven,
Eroica,
Music,
music theory,
personal,
philosophy,
Projects,
St. John's,
Tristan und Isolde,
Wagner,
writing
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
Sacris Solemnis
Not long ago I heard a fascinating rendition of the second movement of Beethoven's 7th Symphony on the radio. If you're not familiar with the original, here's a passable version from Youtube:
Obviously it's an intense piece, and very intricately constructed. It's in A-Minor (the 7th Symphony as a whole is in A-Major), and it heavily relies upon the tonic to dominant and back movement that starts the piece. More than the harmony, however, what makes this piece so effective is its rhythm. The whole 7th Symphony feels like dance,* from the celebratory and springy first movement to the hectic races of the 3rd and 4th movements, dance rhythms are pervasive. This movement is no different, and while it is certainly sedate and may even come across - especially on first listening - as profoundly sad, if it is a lamentation it's a dancing one. The repeated rhythmic meme of One-Two-and-Three-Four gives it a measured, dancing feel, a driving force that pushes the movement onward.
* Indeed, Wagner called it "the apotheosis of the dance."
I could go on about the 7th Symphony, but that's not my object. Rather, I want to introduce the fascinating rendition I heard on the radio. Give it a listen:
Now some classical music people are not fond of this kind of pirating of a famous piece. I, however, think that's a bit stuffy and closed-minded. Beethoven would maybe be offended by a re-rendition of his work, but, then again, he also re-rendered some of Mozart's themes in his own variations. If nothing else, Beethoven would appreciate the choice of lyrics Libera leader Robert Prizeman elected to set against Beethoven's work.
You see, the 2nd Movement of the 7th Symphony is easy to understand as a dour, overwhelmingly depressing display of emotion. I don't believe, however, that such was Beethoven's intent. Indeed, this movement strikes me as just as joyful as the remainder of the symphony. If anything, the difference is that this movement is more reverential - or at least reverential in a different way. Where the other movements are like whirling dervishes, showing their devotion to life, love, and happiness by swinging about wildly, this movement is a wiser, quieter, more intense and personal display.
What perhaps the Libera version loses most is the build-up. Beethoven's version starts with just chords, and piece by piece introduces further harmonies and a wonderful contrapuntal (and highly chromatic) melody. He then moves that melody up through the instruments until it reaches the violins, singing above the rest of the orchestra's pounding harmonic and rhythmic core. Libera can't and doesn't try to recreate that effect, choosing rather to focus on the simple interplay of melody and harmony that a novice might lose sight of in Beethoven's work.
Adding in a percussion part and an original "bridge" in the middle of the piece only further brings out the power of Beethoven's harmonies and rhythms. The added bits feel, to me anyway, very natural, especially because they are so-well situated in the piece. They help the listener forget that the Beethoven original contains more themes and development that would be unwieldy - if not downright ugly - performed by voice. Those orchestral developments become unnecessary against the dynamic crescendo employed by Prizeman in his rendition.
But the lyrics. This is what fascinates me most. Prizeman chooses a hymn - Sacris Solemnis - as his text. Now, Beethoven is ironically famous for introducing lyrics to orchestral music in his 9th Symphony, but the recognition of Beethoven as an innovator for the voice comes despite his disinterest in writing for the voice throughout his life as a composer. In a time when opera was still very much the rage, Beethoven composed one, better-known for its preludes and overtures than its arias. It seems to me that Beethoven was concerned, generally, with matters to weighty for lyrics. Or, rather, his work was always singing in a language more expressive than German or Latin or Italian already, so why spoil it with words? In some sense, his 9th Symphony seems to me to be an effort to teach we listeners his language of joy, present throughout his musical oeuvre.
So what lyrics did Prizeman select for his setting of the 7th Symphony? The Latin goes like this:*
Sacris solemnis, Juncta sint gaudia
Corda, et voces, et opera.
Recedant vitera, nova sint omnia.
Sacris solemnis, gaudia.
Te trina Deitas unique Poscimus:
Sacris solemnis, gaudia.
* The bridge is: "Lucem, lucem ad inhabitas," which translates as "The light wherein You dwell."
I'm no Latin scholar, so I have to rely on the translations of others and a little bit of guesswork, but roughly this means something like:
At this our solemn feast, let holy joys abound
In every heart, and voice, and act.
Let ancient rites depart,* and all be new around.
At this our solemn feast, let there be joy.
We implore Thee, God, the Trinity:
At this our solemn feast, let there be joy.
* Reminds me of the opening lyrics of the 9th: "Oh fruende, nicht diese tone."
Even if the translation isn't perfect, could there be a better set of lyrics? They capture the solemnity and reverence of the piece, but also understand that the occasion is fundamentally a joyful one.
I think, with Beethoven in particular, but also with Chopin and Wagner and a great many other composers of the 18th and 19th centuries, it's easy to get lost in the emotional force of the music. The Romantic era, in particular, earns its name for its desirous, pining melodies and its adventures far from the tonic, through streams of dominants, making us positively lust after some resolution. But, even though we might call such music childish - or, worse, adolescent - it is not. I believe it cheapens those musicians to call their music "angry" or "sad" when, in reality, the story is much more complicated than that, the emotional investment much more nuanced.
Beethoven's music is joyful, not because he was always joyful, but because the act of writing music was, to him, a divine one, and one which brought him joy. Even his most tempestuous works have a streak of the kind of melancholic joy that comes with understanding one's sadness and frustration to be only a part - and a vital one - of the emotional canvass of a joyful life. I would argue that Chopin's "sad" music, for example, may come from the heart of a depressed invalid, but that depressed invalid was truly joyful in his heart when he composed music.
The 7th Symphony - and in particular the 2nd movement - is more, however, than just melancholy written with joy, but expressing melancholy. No, it's exactly how Prizeman describes, a solemn plea and prayer for joy. That may seem paradoxical, but I don't think it has to be. I think joy and solemnity often exist side-by-side, and, what's more, that joy is sometimes its most poignant in a minor key. Listen again and see if you can hear it.
Obviously it's an intense piece, and very intricately constructed. It's in A-Minor (the 7th Symphony as a whole is in A-Major), and it heavily relies upon the tonic to dominant and back movement that starts the piece. More than the harmony, however, what makes this piece so effective is its rhythm. The whole 7th Symphony feels like dance,* from the celebratory and springy first movement to the hectic races of the 3rd and 4th movements, dance rhythms are pervasive. This movement is no different, and while it is certainly sedate and may even come across - especially on first listening - as profoundly sad, if it is a lamentation it's a dancing one. The repeated rhythmic meme of One-Two-and-Three-Four gives it a measured, dancing feel, a driving force that pushes the movement onward.
* Indeed, Wagner called it "the apotheosis of the dance."
I could go on about the 7th Symphony, but that's not my object. Rather, I want to introduce the fascinating rendition I heard on the radio. Give it a listen:
Now some classical music people are not fond of this kind of pirating of a famous piece. I, however, think that's a bit stuffy and closed-minded. Beethoven would maybe be offended by a re-rendition of his work, but, then again, he also re-rendered some of Mozart's themes in his own variations. If nothing else, Beethoven would appreciate the choice of lyrics Libera leader Robert Prizeman elected to set against Beethoven's work.
You see, the 2nd Movement of the 7th Symphony is easy to understand as a dour, overwhelmingly depressing display of emotion. I don't believe, however, that such was Beethoven's intent. Indeed, this movement strikes me as just as joyful as the remainder of the symphony. If anything, the difference is that this movement is more reverential - or at least reverential in a different way. Where the other movements are like whirling dervishes, showing their devotion to life, love, and happiness by swinging about wildly, this movement is a wiser, quieter, more intense and personal display.
What perhaps the Libera version loses most is the build-up. Beethoven's version starts with just chords, and piece by piece introduces further harmonies and a wonderful contrapuntal (and highly chromatic) melody. He then moves that melody up through the instruments until it reaches the violins, singing above the rest of the orchestra's pounding harmonic and rhythmic core. Libera can't and doesn't try to recreate that effect, choosing rather to focus on the simple interplay of melody and harmony that a novice might lose sight of in Beethoven's work.
Adding in a percussion part and an original "bridge" in the middle of the piece only further brings out the power of Beethoven's harmonies and rhythms. The added bits feel, to me anyway, very natural, especially because they are so-well situated in the piece. They help the listener forget that the Beethoven original contains more themes and development that would be unwieldy - if not downright ugly - performed by voice. Those orchestral developments become unnecessary against the dynamic crescendo employed by Prizeman in his rendition.
But the lyrics. This is what fascinates me most. Prizeman chooses a hymn - Sacris Solemnis - as his text. Now, Beethoven is ironically famous for introducing lyrics to orchestral music in his 9th Symphony, but the recognition of Beethoven as an innovator for the voice comes despite his disinterest in writing for the voice throughout his life as a composer. In a time when opera was still very much the rage, Beethoven composed one, better-known for its preludes and overtures than its arias. It seems to me that Beethoven was concerned, generally, with matters to weighty for lyrics. Or, rather, his work was always singing in a language more expressive than German or Latin or Italian already, so why spoil it with words? In some sense, his 9th Symphony seems to me to be an effort to teach we listeners his language of joy, present throughout his musical oeuvre.
So what lyrics did Prizeman select for his setting of the 7th Symphony? The Latin goes like this:*
Sacris solemnis, Juncta sint gaudia
Corda, et voces, et opera.
Recedant vitera, nova sint omnia.
Sacris solemnis, gaudia.
Te trina Deitas unique Poscimus:
Sacris solemnis, gaudia.
* The bridge is: "Lucem, lucem ad inhabitas," which translates as "The light wherein You dwell."
I'm no Latin scholar, so I have to rely on the translations of others and a little bit of guesswork, but roughly this means something like:
At this our solemn feast, let holy joys abound
In every heart, and voice, and act.
Let ancient rites depart,* and all be new around.
At this our solemn feast, let there be joy.
We implore Thee, God, the Trinity:
At this our solemn feast, let there be joy.
* Reminds me of the opening lyrics of the 9th: "Oh fruende, nicht diese tone."
Even if the translation isn't perfect, could there be a better set of lyrics? They capture the solemnity and reverence of the piece, but also understand that the occasion is fundamentally a joyful one.
I think, with Beethoven in particular, but also with Chopin and Wagner and a great many other composers of the 18th and 19th centuries, it's easy to get lost in the emotional force of the music. The Romantic era, in particular, earns its name for its desirous, pining melodies and its adventures far from the tonic, through streams of dominants, making us positively lust after some resolution. But, even though we might call such music childish - or, worse, adolescent - it is not. I believe it cheapens those musicians to call their music "angry" or "sad" when, in reality, the story is much more complicated than that, the emotional investment much more nuanced.
Beethoven's music is joyful, not because he was always joyful, but because the act of writing music was, to him, a divine one, and one which brought him joy. Even his most tempestuous works have a streak of the kind of melancholic joy that comes with understanding one's sadness and frustration to be only a part - and a vital one - of the emotional canvass of a joyful life. I would argue that Chopin's "sad" music, for example, may come from the heart of a depressed invalid, but that depressed invalid was truly joyful in his heart when he composed music.
The 7th Symphony - and in particular the 2nd movement - is more, however, than just melancholy written with joy, but expressing melancholy. No, it's exactly how Prizeman describes, a solemn plea and prayer for joy. That may seem paradoxical, but I don't think it has to be. I think joy and solemnity often exist side-by-side, and, what's more, that joy is sometimes its most poignant in a minor key. Listen again and see if you can hear it.
Labels:
Beethoven,
libera,
lyrics,
Music,
Robert Prizeman,
Romantic Era,
Sacris Solemnis
Friday, July 23, 2010
The Workshop That Wasn't
In addition to the sabermetrics workshop I taught earlier this summer, I also wrote a curriculum for a poetry workshop that didn't run. Much as I loved teaching sabermetrics, a part of me was even more excited to teach the poetry course. Why? Because I love the idea of reading awful, awkward poetry written by high schoolers.
Actually, I love the thought of introducing high schoolers to great poems, and sparking their own desire to write. Not necessarily poetry, per se, but poetry is as good an entry point into writing as anything. Maybe the best. Why? Because poetry forces you to be conscious of rhythm, forces you to be pithy, and forces you to use precise diction. Even poor poems usually follow some structural and lexiconical (a word I'm inventing because it's the middle of the night) rules. The result is that, even we poor poets of the world (people like me; there's a reason you don't really see my now exceedingly rare poetry on this blog) learn something about writing in the process.
Beyond learning about writing broadly by writing poetry, I think there's also something to be said for reading poetry. Good poetry is, cheesy as it sounds, highly inspirational. Poets like T.S. Eliot or Langston Hughes make you feel like you're getting more out of their words than the words themselves. Indeed, in Eliot's poems sometimes the worlds themselves feel like complete nonsense. But somewhere in those mess of symbolism and metaphor is that grain of magic that makes you smile, stand up, and read aloud. Like the opening of The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock:
Let us go then, you and I
When the evening is spread out against the sky
Like a patient etherized upon a table
Disturbing and surprising? Sure, but awesome too. Eliot rhymes with so much purpose in Prufrock that it's hard not to fall in love with the poem, even though it's so pompous.
I grow old... I grow old...
I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled.
Such lines! That is what separates those precious few great poets from the proverbial masses. Anyone can write a sonnet (or any other form) with enough patience and effort. Anyone, indeed, can even invent their own wild, Anne Sexton-like form. But the inspiration that results in lines so simple, so mundane, yet so effective is a rare gift.
And the afternoon, the evening, sleeps so peacefully!
Smoothed by long fingers,
Asleep... tired... or it malingers
Malingers and fingers! My God, man, where does that come from? We might say that even inspiration is the work of effort and is an acquired ability. Indeed, I am suspicious of the notion of innate talent - pure genius - in the work of the mind. But there is no question that, whether by virtue of some genius or by virtue of the mere acquisition of the mantle of greatness for no particularly good reason, we have such poems as Prufrock and react to them with so much fervor that there must be something there.
The conversation about Prufrock, I promise, would have been more focused than this, because it's too late in the night and the week to get all analytical with poetry. I wouldn't say, however, that analysis and joy are opposed. It's far too easy to say that studying a work of art makes you appreciate it less: makes you lose that innocent, unadulterated love you have for the words by turning you into a cynical, self-righteous, pompous ass (or "connoisseur," you might say). I disagree. Sure, you may become more selective and discerning, and you may abandon some poems and poets (or songs and musicians, or paintings and painters, and so on), but those poems you do love become all the better when you study them closely. I've read Prufrock countless times, and yet I always find something new to love about it, which is a part of why it is great.
The workshop - which this post is about, remember - was not all about Eliot. Indeed, Prufrock was only going to be one day. In addition, we were going to study the following:
Walt Whitman - Song of Myself
We were only going to get to a small part of this one, because it's very long, and it takes a few readings and, I think, a little bit of time to get into those long, rambling lists of images in the middle. The beginning and the end were going to be our focus. Some choice lines:
Do I contradict myself?
Very well, I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)
How brilliant. In a vast, large, rambling poem that undoubtedly offended the poetic sensibilities of many of its original readers, could you find a more perfect statement? How many writers have tried to say this and taken pages to do so? For Whitman, it takes fifteen words.
T.S Eliot - The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock
We've already got some lines from this one, but in the vein of the Whitman quotation, here's one of my favorite lines:
It is impossible to say just what I mean!
Gabriela Mistral - Los Que No Danzan
I planned on using the wonderful translation of Ursula Le Guin, who I have recently decided is clearly a modern Virginia Woolf in that she's so brilliant at so many different things (best-selling, award-winning science fiction and amazing translations of Chilean poems? What gives?). But for the feeling of the poem, the Spanish is better. Since I'm guessing you don't know Mistral, I'll put in the whole poem.
Una niña que es inválida
dijo: -«¿Cómo danzo yo?»
Le dijimos que pusiera
Luego dijo la quebrada:
-«¿Cómo cantaría yo?»
Le dijimos que pusiera
a cantar su corazón...
Dijo el pobre cardo muerto:
-«¿Cómo, cómo danzo yo?»
Le dijimos: -«Pon al viento
a volar tu corazón...»
Dijo Dios desde la altura:
-«¿Cómo bajo del azul?»
Le dijimos que bajara
a danzarnos en la luz.
Todo el valle está danzando
en un corro bajo el sol,
A quien falte se le vuelve
de ceniza el corazón.
I only discovered Mistral - a Nobel winner - in the course of writing this curriculum. Given that the class didn't run, I think finding her poetry is the hidden meaning. This poem in particular stood out to me because I read it first while reading Carol Shloss's biography of Lucia Joyce, a dancer herself who clearly didn't fit into her world. Dancing was taken away from Lucia, but I like to think that, like the girl from the first stanza, she (as Le Guin has it) "did her dancing in her heart."
Edna St. Vincent Millay - Renascence
There's a chance you know Millay, and the opening lines of this poem may sound familiar to you:
All I could see from where I stood
Was three long mountains and a wood;
I turned and looked another way,
And saw three islands in a bay.
From such admittedly mundane beginnings* this poem takes off. Go read it. Seriously. You'll see what I mean. Millay wrote it as a young woman, entered it into a competition, and finished fourth to the outrage of even the poets who finished ahead of her. The winner called his victory "an embarrassment," and with good reason. Renascence may be the work of a young poet, but for that it has an exuberance - a refusal to admit that, even in a highly restrictive formal structure, it can't do everything. It does do everything.
* Though undoubtedly steeped in symbolism, I'm still calling this mundane. Remember that three anythings is usually a dead give away that something funky is going on.
Here's what I mean by "It does do everything:"
I saw and heard, and knew at last
The How and Why of all things, past,
And present, and forevermore.
The universe, cleft to the core,
Lay open to my probing sense.
And that's before it really gets going.
Freidrich Schiller and Ludwig Van Beethoven - Ode to Joy
Yeah, yeah, I couldn't help myself. Actually, the activity I had designed around this poem and song combination was, I think, a highly under-represented part of the writing process: deleting stuff. The idea is this: the Schiller poem is quite long and unwieldy, and even though the last movement of the 9th Symphony is 20+ minutes long, it simply can't get through the whole poem. Beethoven, however, does not simply take the first two stanzas and throw them in. He judiciously picks the stuff he wants, and mixes around the order to fit his needs. How does he decide? That's the real question.
The lesson, then, is that you have to do that with your own work sometimes, too. It's alright to change the order of your paragraphs around sometimes to make the flow better. It's also alright to excise whole sections of text if they don't meet your needs. It's even good to start over. As one of my middle school English teachers said (and yes, I remember my middle school English classes; I'm just like that): "Sometimes you have to kill your babies." That awesome line you wrote might ruin the poem, so take it out and use it in a different one. Or, more to the point, that awesome line you wrote isn't actually awesome. Kill it.
Langston Hughes - A Dream Deferred
I tried, more or less, to avoid horribly cliche high school poems, but I couldn't dodge this one. For one thing, I'm not convinced people actually read this.* For another, even if they do, it's just so amazing that it's worth reading again and again. In case you don't recall, here it is (after the posterisk).
* Don't they? Isn't this poem like a part of getting a drivers license or something? It's only, like, the most iconic poem in American history.
What happens to a dream deferred?
Does it dry up
like a raisin in the sun?
Or fester like a sore--
And then run?
Does it stink like rotten meat?
Or crust and sugar over--
like a syrupy sweet?
Maybe it just sags
like a heavy load.
Or does it explode?
Even without the context this poem was written in, it packs a huge punch. Add in the context, and it's even better.
In a typical Paul move, I was going to pair this with reading the "I Have a Dream" speech, partially because there's a certain, obvious thematic link, but also because the course would have been gearing up towards a final poem-reading symposium, and King was a marvelous public speaker. Best to learn from the best.
I also planned on having a student choice day, which I was going to leave pretty wide open. I'd be fascinated to know what poems students came in to the course interested in, or if, on the other hand, they'd want to take a look at pop-song lyrics. Either way, frankly, I think we could have had a fruitful conversation. Alas, the course did not run, so no conversations.
Nevertheless, writing the curriculum was a worthwhile experience, not only for the practice in curriculum construction, but also because I learned about poetry in the process. Millay and Mistral, for example, were vague names without words or meaning attached to them. A Dream Deferred was "that civil rights poem I read in high school." There's something to be said for returning to those works you weren't ready to read in high school for that reason: as an adult they mean so much more - and sometimes so much less - and you can get so much further into them. There's also something to be said, however, about reading those poems in high school, even if you don't get into them, because without that exposure, how do you even know where to begin to look when you really do want to know what happens to a dream deferred?
Actually, I love the thought of introducing high schoolers to great poems, and sparking their own desire to write. Not necessarily poetry, per se, but poetry is as good an entry point into writing as anything. Maybe the best. Why? Because poetry forces you to be conscious of rhythm, forces you to be pithy, and forces you to use precise diction. Even poor poems usually follow some structural and lexiconical (a word I'm inventing because it's the middle of the night) rules. The result is that, even we poor poets of the world (people like me; there's a reason you don't really see my now exceedingly rare poetry on this blog) learn something about writing in the process.
Beyond learning about writing broadly by writing poetry, I think there's also something to be said for reading poetry. Good poetry is, cheesy as it sounds, highly inspirational. Poets like T.S. Eliot or Langston Hughes make you feel like you're getting more out of their words than the words themselves. Indeed, in Eliot's poems sometimes the worlds themselves feel like complete nonsense. But somewhere in those mess of symbolism and metaphor is that grain of magic that makes you smile, stand up, and read aloud. Like the opening of The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock:
Let us go then, you and I
When the evening is spread out against the sky
Like a patient etherized upon a table
Disturbing and surprising? Sure, but awesome too. Eliot rhymes with so much purpose in Prufrock that it's hard not to fall in love with the poem, even though it's so pompous.
I grow old... I grow old...
I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled.
Such lines! That is what separates those precious few great poets from the proverbial masses. Anyone can write a sonnet (or any other form) with enough patience and effort. Anyone, indeed, can even invent their own wild, Anne Sexton-like form. But the inspiration that results in lines so simple, so mundane, yet so effective is a rare gift.
And the afternoon, the evening, sleeps so peacefully!
Smoothed by long fingers,
Asleep... tired... or it malingers
Malingers and fingers! My God, man, where does that come from? We might say that even inspiration is the work of effort and is an acquired ability. Indeed, I am suspicious of the notion of innate talent - pure genius - in the work of the mind. But there is no question that, whether by virtue of some genius or by virtue of the mere acquisition of the mantle of greatness for no particularly good reason, we have such poems as Prufrock and react to them with so much fervor that there must be something there.
The conversation about Prufrock, I promise, would have been more focused than this, because it's too late in the night and the week to get all analytical with poetry. I wouldn't say, however, that analysis and joy are opposed. It's far too easy to say that studying a work of art makes you appreciate it less: makes you lose that innocent, unadulterated love you have for the words by turning you into a cynical, self-righteous, pompous ass (or "connoisseur," you might say). I disagree. Sure, you may become more selective and discerning, and you may abandon some poems and poets (or songs and musicians, or paintings and painters, and so on), but those poems you do love become all the better when you study them closely. I've read Prufrock countless times, and yet I always find something new to love about it, which is a part of why it is great.
The workshop - which this post is about, remember - was not all about Eliot. Indeed, Prufrock was only going to be one day. In addition, we were going to study the following:
Walt Whitman - Song of Myself
We were only going to get to a small part of this one, because it's very long, and it takes a few readings and, I think, a little bit of time to get into those long, rambling lists of images in the middle. The beginning and the end were going to be our focus. Some choice lines:
Do I contradict myself?
Very well, I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)
How brilliant. In a vast, large, rambling poem that undoubtedly offended the poetic sensibilities of many of its original readers, could you find a more perfect statement? How many writers have tried to say this and taken pages to do so? For Whitman, it takes fifteen words.
T.S Eliot - The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock
We've already got some lines from this one, but in the vein of the Whitman quotation, here's one of my favorite lines:
It is impossible to say just what I mean!
Gabriela Mistral - Los Que No Danzan
I planned on using the wonderful translation of Ursula Le Guin, who I have recently decided is clearly a modern Virginia Woolf in that she's so brilliant at so many different things (best-selling, award-winning science fiction and amazing translations of Chilean poems? What gives?). But for the feeling of the poem, the Spanish is better. Since I'm guessing you don't know Mistral, I'll put in the whole poem.
Una niña que es inválida
dijo: -«¿Cómo danzo yo?»
Le dijimos que pusiera
| a danzar su corazón... |
Luego dijo la quebrada:
-«¿Cómo cantaría yo?»
Le dijimos que pusiera
a cantar su corazón...
Dijo el pobre cardo muerto:
-«¿Cómo, cómo danzo yo?»
Le dijimos: -«Pon al viento
a volar tu corazón...»
Dijo Dios desde la altura:
-«¿Cómo bajo del azul?»
Le dijimos que bajara
a danzarnos en la luz.
Todo el valle está danzando
en un corro bajo el sol,
A quien falte se le vuelve
de ceniza el corazón.
I only discovered Mistral - a Nobel winner - in the course of writing this curriculum. Given that the class didn't run, I think finding her poetry is the hidden meaning. This poem in particular stood out to me because I read it first while reading Carol Shloss's biography of Lucia Joyce, a dancer herself who clearly didn't fit into her world. Dancing was taken away from Lucia, but I like to think that, like the girl from the first stanza, she (as Le Guin has it) "did her dancing in her heart."
Edna St. Vincent Millay - Renascence
There's a chance you know Millay, and the opening lines of this poem may sound familiar to you:
All I could see from where I stood
Was three long mountains and a wood;
I turned and looked another way,
And saw three islands in a bay.
From such admittedly mundane beginnings* this poem takes off. Go read it. Seriously. You'll see what I mean. Millay wrote it as a young woman, entered it into a competition, and finished fourth to the outrage of even the poets who finished ahead of her. The winner called his victory "an embarrassment," and with good reason. Renascence may be the work of a young poet, but for that it has an exuberance - a refusal to admit that, even in a highly restrictive formal structure, it can't do everything. It does do everything.
* Though undoubtedly steeped in symbolism, I'm still calling this mundane. Remember that three anythings is usually a dead give away that something funky is going on.
Here's what I mean by "It does do everything:"
I saw and heard, and knew at last
The How and Why of all things, past,
And present, and forevermore.
The universe, cleft to the core,
Lay open to my probing sense.
And that's before it really gets going.
Freidrich Schiller and Ludwig Van Beethoven - Ode to Joy
Yeah, yeah, I couldn't help myself. Actually, the activity I had designed around this poem and song combination was, I think, a highly under-represented part of the writing process: deleting stuff. The idea is this: the Schiller poem is quite long and unwieldy, and even though the last movement of the 9th Symphony is 20+ minutes long, it simply can't get through the whole poem. Beethoven, however, does not simply take the first two stanzas and throw them in. He judiciously picks the stuff he wants, and mixes around the order to fit his needs. How does he decide? That's the real question.
The lesson, then, is that you have to do that with your own work sometimes, too. It's alright to change the order of your paragraphs around sometimes to make the flow better. It's also alright to excise whole sections of text if they don't meet your needs. It's even good to start over. As one of my middle school English teachers said (and yes, I remember my middle school English classes; I'm just like that): "Sometimes you have to kill your babies." That awesome line you wrote might ruin the poem, so take it out and use it in a different one. Or, more to the point, that awesome line you wrote isn't actually awesome. Kill it.
Langston Hughes - A Dream Deferred
I tried, more or less, to avoid horribly cliche high school poems, but I couldn't dodge this one. For one thing, I'm not convinced people actually read this.* For another, even if they do, it's just so amazing that it's worth reading again and again. In case you don't recall, here it is (after the posterisk).
* Don't they? Isn't this poem like a part of getting a drivers license or something? It's only, like, the most iconic poem in American history.
What happens to a dream deferred?
Does it dry up
like a raisin in the sun?
Or fester like a sore--
And then run?
Does it stink like rotten meat?
Or crust and sugar over--
like a syrupy sweet?
Maybe it just sags
like a heavy load.
Or does it explode?
Even without the context this poem was written in, it packs a huge punch. Add in the context, and it's even better.
In a typical Paul move, I was going to pair this with reading the "I Have a Dream" speech, partially because there's a certain, obvious thematic link, but also because the course would have been gearing up towards a final poem-reading symposium, and King was a marvelous public speaker. Best to learn from the best.
I also planned on having a student choice day, which I was going to leave pretty wide open. I'd be fascinated to know what poems students came in to the course interested in, or if, on the other hand, they'd want to take a look at pop-song lyrics. Either way, frankly, I think we could have had a fruitful conversation. Alas, the course did not run, so no conversations.
Nevertheless, writing the curriculum was a worthwhile experience, not only for the practice in curriculum construction, but also because I learned about poetry in the process. Millay and Mistral, for example, were vague names without words or meaning attached to them. A Dream Deferred was "that civil rights poem I read in high school." There's something to be said for returning to those works you weren't ready to read in high school for that reason: as an adult they mean so much more - and sometimes so much less - and you can get so much further into them. There's also something to be said, however, about reading those poems in high school, even if you don't get into them, because without that exposure, how do you even know where to begin to look when you really do want to know what happens to a dream deferred?
Sunday, February 21, 2010
Nicht Diese...
Some old fashioned writing this Sunday evening (or Monday morning). A reflection.
There was a time when I kept a journal. As a high schooler, I wrote and wrote and wrote for no one but myself, trying out poetic devices, exploring thoughts on religion and love and politics, rarely, but occasionally, chronicling the day's events. In retrospect there was nothing all that peculiar about this habit of mine; after all, I was a teenager, and aspired even then to be an intellectual because of, and often in spite of, the community of peers that my private high school afforded me.
I say in spite of because there's a certain stigma attached to intellect in our competitive culture. There's nothing quite so satisfying as the smart guy who loses all the same, faced with the hard-working idiot. Mastermind has dark connotations, so too genius, in a more twisted and historical way. At the time - and maybe still today - I was caught in the paradox of intellect. Our culture honors the intellectual, but punishes and chides all the same. We value intellect, but we despise the person who recognizes their own intelligence.
Perhaps, more than anything, we despise the egotism of the self-promoter not because he is selfish - after all, there's a certain synonymity between "selfish" and "conscious" - but because he often refuses to acknowledge that, ultimately, there are always greater minds. In some sense, our fetish for specialization is a rebellion against the great minds of the great generalists throughout history, who strove to know as much as they could about as many different subjects as they could. "How dare they encroach upon my specialty!"
That's not the point, but I'm not sure what the point is. Even though I have become a writer of prose - after one time being a writer mainly of (poor) verse - I still hold a certain lesson from poetry dear: you don't have to have a "point." That's not fair to poetry, because most poems have a point in one sense or another, but there's a kind of beautiful chaos in the endeavor of poetry that prose simply cannot replicate. Even the most pointed and purposeful poetry is clothed, nonetheless, in a poetic diction, a formalism of meter and rhyme, that prevents easy unfolding. A poem may be compelling, then, but hardly in the way that a persuasive essay is.
Not all essays persuade, however. Sometimes they border on poetry. Indeed, John Dryden was one of the founders of the essay, and his Religio Laici, like the majority of his work, is in verse. Though perhaps that's poetry bordering on essay?
It is odd that we draw such a distinction, truly. Poetry comes from the Greek word meaning "to create." What difference, then, between Montaigne and Dryden, Plutarch and Sappho?
Ah, specialization is our specialty. Today we divide not just writing from poetry, but different kinds of writing and poetry from each other. The essay is a form distinct from the story, which is in turn distinct from the academic essay, the memoir, the novel, the novella, the biography, the autobiography, the treatise, the manifesto, the confession. Do we allow more experts, or fewer by such divisions? By that I mean, by splitting our brilliant writers into such camps, do we not maybe lose our brilliant writers?
That's not fair, either. A great many writers straddle such narrow definitions. Indeed, the best writers are the very cause of new terms and genres. The novel sprung into existence as a way to categorize the work of Cervantes, the essay for Montaigne. The same in music, where the Opera became a term necessary to characterize Monteverdi. The same in poetry.
Since I was a high schooler, I have learned a great deal about how little I know. I expect that, now, at a still-young 24, I have a great deal more to learn about how little I know. What is insufferable about intellectuals, it turns out, is not how much they know, but how little. Socrates was killed for it.
A turn of phrase, a turn of phrase. I have collected, in my short life of reading, a great many connections and associations - many of which are historical, and most of which are European, with occasional Hawaiian or Buddhist allusions mixed in - which allow me to express myself without expressing myself. That is another of the intellectual's tricks, and perhaps the heart of the poet's art. T.S. Eliot's Wasteland would not have gotten far without tricky, intellectual allusions. Nor would Joyce's Finnegan's Wake (the longest inside joke in history, perhaps). "Oystery Gods gaggin' Fishy Gods."
For a long time, between high school and graduate school, I stopped writing. Oh, I wrote for classes at St. John's, and I would occasionally pick up a pen ruefully in the time in between then and Stanford. Poetry, never, but occasional essays, arguments for why surfing matters - a concept that only fellow surfers will understand - or a history of the beautiful Platonic romance that closed my Freshman year of college.
Perhaps that is the object of these wanderings. The last of my poetic fervor expended itself in the poems composed for two women. The first, an illusive goddess who rekindled in me the concept of love - albeit in my hoity-toity (spelling?) way - sending me into thralls unmatched by any but my first (and less Platonic) romance. The second, my one-month-from wife, who is so much more real and wise. No goddess - for how long do such relationships last? - but instead a life. There was one poem each way, with Jericha, and that was enough. Indeed, those first poems probably say more about our relationship - even now - than anything else we could write (just as toddlers already display so many of the personality traits they will have as adults).
I suppose, for me, there is too much poetry in living for me to write poetry. I have become polemical, instead, arguing fiercely for a position on education, music, politics, or culture. Usually arguing a position untaken, or untakeable, and explaining why it should not be so neglected. A natural contrarian, I have become, who can turn "because" into "in spite of" and back again. To what end? It profits me little that I oppose so vehemently a great many things which are simply "the way it is." Why oppose, for example, specialization? It leads to such a beautiful, functional world. Why oppose citation? It leads to such easy access to knowledge. If only it were so simple.
I oppose simplicity. Or rather, I suppose simplification, which likely means I oppose myself as a writer. The vast majority of my writing - and probably all writing - is an attempt to simplify, to make expressible the inexpressible nature of being. If writing is an argument, then the most direct, simple argument wins, and the writing that best takes the complex and makes it appear simple will always be favored. I am opposed to sophistry, you might say, even though I will acknowledge that I am as good a sophist as can be found. That's perhaps a bit too self-congratulatory, for there are a great many sophists in this world better than I.
When I allow myself to write honestly - or, at least, without regard for how complicated a narrative I weave - I find that I use the word "perhaps" with astounding frequency. Perhaps. It's a versatile word, but what it does more than anything is act as a crutch. There is no better word for avoiding conclusions than perhaps. Perhaps there is no better word for avoiding conclusions than perhaps. See the difference? One is certain, the other... Perhaps.
Judicious use of "perhaps," (and "seems," and "this suggests," and "I think," and "possibly") might be a mark of intellectual rigor, laziness, or both. Judicious use of perhaps might, also, be my least poetic trait as a writer. Good writers avoid pointless, empty words like "perhaps." It means nothing. Or it means everything.
Now I'm stealing from Demetri Martin* (I run the gamut; Socrates to Important Things), which perhaps indicates that our winding road is nearing its end. What is that end? Hard to say. What the journey? Equally hard.
* To wit: 'Sort of' is such a harmless thing to say. Sort of. It's just a filler. Sort of - it doesn't really mean anything. But after certain things, sort of means everything. Like after 'I love you' or 'You're going to live.'
Nicht Diese Tone, I titled this blog, and though I addressed it in my opening post (gulp, five months and about 60 posts ago), perhaps a return to that theme is in order. The title is German, meaning "not these tones." In retrospect, why a negative? Of all the phrases from Beethoven's Ninth, why this one? I suppose it's the contrarian in me, the intellectual who doubts the value of intellectuals; the liberal who despises the term "liberal;" the musician, astrologer, and student who wants to be everything and, sometimes, just wants to be nothing and play computer for six hours. How to describe these qualities ("and this, and so much more"), how to 'fix myself in a formulated phrase'?
There was a time when poetry was written, and though it is still written, what magic is left after the placing of such lines as "All truths wait in all things," and "It is impossible to say just what I mean." Ginsberg was reduced to a string of "Holy, Holy, Holy ..." Perhaps profound in its own right. Perhaps too self-indulgent.
But we live in self-indulgent times, which I also oppose, and also embody. Maybe paradox is the real lesson. Maybe it always has been. Or rather, maybe paradox and order, chaos and structure, sway ever across some abyss of human meaning. Death, there's the real question, the ultimate contrarian, and the hardest thing for a contrarian to oppose. And yet we have a society built around death (or built around a religion built around death, to paraphrase Nietzsche). Those poems that haunt me and inspire me sit on that precipice. Prufrock, a poem afraid of death, Song of Myself, a poem of celebrating life. Of all the paradoxes of being, that may be the most poignant, and, ironically, the most taboo in our modern age.
In truth, I have little to contribute to such looming questions as "what is the meaning of life?" Ultimately, I resist the question as unsophisticated, at least as it is commonly asked. No, ask it like Eliot, for then it is complicated enough to warrant my austere notice. Or something like that... The true story is, I first recognized the terrible power of the fear of death watching, of all things, Stargate SG-1. How's that for a paradox? What can I say, after all, that is profound?
Nicht Diese, indeed.
There was a time when I kept a journal. As a high schooler, I wrote and wrote and wrote for no one but myself, trying out poetic devices, exploring thoughts on religion and love and politics, rarely, but occasionally, chronicling the day's events. In retrospect there was nothing all that peculiar about this habit of mine; after all, I was a teenager, and aspired even then to be an intellectual because of, and often in spite of, the community of peers that my private high school afforded me.
I say in spite of because there's a certain stigma attached to intellect in our competitive culture. There's nothing quite so satisfying as the smart guy who loses all the same, faced with the hard-working idiot. Mastermind has dark connotations, so too genius, in a more twisted and historical way. At the time - and maybe still today - I was caught in the paradox of intellect. Our culture honors the intellectual, but punishes and chides all the same. We value intellect, but we despise the person who recognizes their own intelligence.
Perhaps, more than anything, we despise the egotism of the self-promoter not because he is selfish - after all, there's a certain synonymity between "selfish" and "conscious" - but because he often refuses to acknowledge that, ultimately, there are always greater minds. In some sense, our fetish for specialization is a rebellion against the great minds of the great generalists throughout history, who strove to know as much as they could about as many different subjects as they could. "How dare they encroach upon my specialty!"
That's not the point, but I'm not sure what the point is. Even though I have become a writer of prose - after one time being a writer mainly of (poor) verse - I still hold a certain lesson from poetry dear: you don't have to have a "point." That's not fair to poetry, because most poems have a point in one sense or another, but there's a kind of beautiful chaos in the endeavor of poetry that prose simply cannot replicate. Even the most pointed and purposeful poetry is clothed, nonetheless, in a poetic diction, a formalism of meter and rhyme, that prevents easy unfolding. A poem may be compelling, then, but hardly in the way that a persuasive essay is.
Not all essays persuade, however. Sometimes they border on poetry. Indeed, John Dryden was one of the founders of the essay, and his Religio Laici, like the majority of his work, is in verse. Though perhaps that's poetry bordering on essay?
It is odd that we draw such a distinction, truly. Poetry comes from the Greek word meaning "to create." What difference, then, between Montaigne and Dryden, Plutarch and Sappho?
Ah, specialization is our specialty. Today we divide not just writing from poetry, but different kinds of writing and poetry from each other. The essay is a form distinct from the story, which is in turn distinct from the academic essay, the memoir, the novel, the novella, the biography, the autobiography, the treatise, the manifesto, the confession. Do we allow more experts, or fewer by such divisions? By that I mean, by splitting our brilliant writers into such camps, do we not maybe lose our brilliant writers?
That's not fair, either. A great many writers straddle such narrow definitions. Indeed, the best writers are the very cause of new terms and genres. The novel sprung into existence as a way to categorize the work of Cervantes, the essay for Montaigne. The same in music, where the Opera became a term necessary to characterize Monteverdi. The same in poetry.
Since I was a high schooler, I have learned a great deal about how little I know. I expect that, now, at a still-young 24, I have a great deal more to learn about how little I know. What is insufferable about intellectuals, it turns out, is not how much they know, but how little. Socrates was killed for it.
A turn of phrase, a turn of phrase. I have collected, in my short life of reading, a great many connections and associations - many of which are historical, and most of which are European, with occasional Hawaiian or Buddhist allusions mixed in - which allow me to express myself without expressing myself. That is another of the intellectual's tricks, and perhaps the heart of the poet's art. T.S. Eliot's Wasteland would not have gotten far without tricky, intellectual allusions. Nor would Joyce's Finnegan's Wake (the longest inside joke in history, perhaps). "Oystery Gods gaggin' Fishy Gods."
For a long time, between high school and graduate school, I stopped writing. Oh, I wrote for classes at St. John's, and I would occasionally pick up a pen ruefully in the time in between then and Stanford. Poetry, never, but occasional essays, arguments for why surfing matters - a concept that only fellow surfers will understand - or a history of the beautiful Platonic romance that closed my Freshman year of college.
Perhaps that is the object of these wanderings. The last of my poetic fervor expended itself in the poems composed for two women. The first, an illusive goddess who rekindled in me the concept of love - albeit in my hoity-toity (spelling?) way - sending me into thralls unmatched by any but my first (and less Platonic) romance. The second, my one-month-from wife, who is so much more real and wise. No goddess - for how long do such relationships last? - but instead a life. There was one poem each way, with Jericha, and that was enough. Indeed, those first poems probably say more about our relationship - even now - than anything else we could write (just as toddlers already display so many of the personality traits they will have as adults).
I suppose, for me, there is too much poetry in living for me to write poetry. I have become polemical, instead, arguing fiercely for a position on education, music, politics, or culture. Usually arguing a position untaken, or untakeable, and explaining why it should not be so neglected. A natural contrarian, I have become, who can turn "because" into "in spite of" and back again. To what end? It profits me little that I oppose so vehemently a great many things which are simply "the way it is." Why oppose, for example, specialization? It leads to such a beautiful, functional world. Why oppose citation? It leads to such easy access to knowledge. If only it were so simple.
I oppose simplicity. Or rather, I suppose simplification, which likely means I oppose myself as a writer. The vast majority of my writing - and probably all writing - is an attempt to simplify, to make expressible the inexpressible nature of being. If writing is an argument, then the most direct, simple argument wins, and the writing that best takes the complex and makes it appear simple will always be favored. I am opposed to sophistry, you might say, even though I will acknowledge that I am as good a sophist as can be found. That's perhaps a bit too self-congratulatory, for there are a great many sophists in this world better than I.
When I allow myself to write honestly - or, at least, without regard for how complicated a narrative I weave - I find that I use the word "perhaps" with astounding frequency. Perhaps. It's a versatile word, but what it does more than anything is act as a crutch. There is no better word for avoiding conclusions than perhaps. Perhaps there is no better word for avoiding conclusions than perhaps. See the difference? One is certain, the other... Perhaps.
Judicious use of "perhaps," (and "seems," and "this suggests," and "I think," and "possibly") might be a mark of intellectual rigor, laziness, or both. Judicious use of perhaps might, also, be my least poetic trait as a writer. Good writers avoid pointless, empty words like "perhaps." It means nothing. Or it means everything.
Now I'm stealing from Demetri Martin* (I run the gamut; Socrates to Important Things), which perhaps indicates that our winding road is nearing its end. What is that end? Hard to say. What the journey? Equally hard.
* To wit: 'Sort of' is such a harmless thing to say. Sort of. It's just a filler. Sort of - it doesn't really mean anything. But after certain things, sort of means everything. Like after 'I love you' or 'You're going to live.'
Nicht Diese Tone, I titled this blog, and though I addressed it in my opening post (gulp, five months and about 60 posts ago), perhaps a return to that theme is in order. The title is German, meaning "not these tones." In retrospect, why a negative? Of all the phrases from Beethoven's Ninth, why this one? I suppose it's the contrarian in me, the intellectual who doubts the value of intellectuals; the liberal who despises the term "liberal;" the musician, astrologer, and student who wants to be everything and, sometimes, just wants to be nothing and play computer for six hours. How to describe these qualities ("and this, and so much more"), how to 'fix myself in a formulated phrase'?
There was a time when poetry was written, and though it is still written, what magic is left after the placing of such lines as "All truths wait in all things," and "It is impossible to say just what I mean." Ginsberg was reduced to a string of "Holy, Holy, Holy ..." Perhaps profound in its own right. Perhaps too self-indulgent.
But we live in self-indulgent times, which I also oppose, and also embody. Maybe paradox is the real lesson. Maybe it always has been. Or rather, maybe paradox and order, chaos and structure, sway ever across some abyss of human meaning. Death, there's the real question, the ultimate contrarian, and the hardest thing for a contrarian to oppose. And yet we have a society built around death (or built around a religion built around death, to paraphrase Nietzsche). Those poems that haunt me and inspire me sit on that precipice. Prufrock, a poem afraid of death, Song of Myself, a poem of celebrating life. Of all the paradoxes of being, that may be the most poignant, and, ironically, the most taboo in our modern age.
In truth, I have little to contribute to such looming questions as "what is the meaning of life?" Ultimately, I resist the question as unsophisticated, at least as it is commonly asked. No, ask it like Eliot, for then it is complicated enough to warrant my austere notice. Or something like that... The true story is, I first recognized the terrible power of the fear of death watching, of all things, Stargate SG-1. How's that for a paradox? What can I say, after all, that is profound?
Nicht Diese, indeed.
Labels:
Beethoven,
death,
Demetri Martin,
Eliot,
genre,
intellectuals,
journaling,
love,
Paradoxes,
perhaps,
personal,
Socrates,
sophists,
Stargate SG1,
Whitman,
why,
writing
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)