Let's get all the chips on the table. Networking is the purpose of this series. Or, more accurately, the distinction between networking and communication. You see, in the early days of the web I feel like there was a rampant philosophical debate about the value of this new technology. What would dominate the web, the question went, information or communication? In one camp firmly sat Google and Yahoo, the early bastions of information search. In the other camp sat AOL and, to a lesser degree, Microsoft (with MSN and Hotmail leading the charge), services that connected people through instant messaging and email.
In the years that have followed it has become clear that the Internet had room - perhaps infinite room - for both communication and information, along with the added and not-totally-unexpected third wheel of commerce. In my last few posts, I've talked - in broad and inexpert strokes - about commerce and information. Because we are increasingly natives of the digital landscape, I felt it was worthwhile to point out the obvious, to challenge us to remember aspects of the Internet that we now take for granted or ignore. For example, information on the web is rarely unbiased, even when it strives to be, and is sometimes wildly inaccurate. At the very least, search engines do little or nothing to filter results for reliability or accuracy, rather choosing to filter based on more arcane algorithmic criteria like "relevance" as determined by computational linguistics or, more simply, the criteria of the dollar.
That money underpins everything on the Internet, even free networking services like Facebook or Twitter, is another important reminder. Increasingly we feel entitled, I suspect, to the long range (in time and space) contact that social networking has made possible. That the services are "free" only increases our sense of entitlement. But they are not free, no less than a phone, a radio, or a television is. That does not, in itself, corrupt said services any less than charging for a book corrupts the book, but corruption is not the point. The point is that we forget too easily that Facebook is not just a website, but a company trying to make a profit. For day-to-day use, that may not impact us much, but it has implications for a philosophical discussion of the platform.
Before we venture too far down that road, however, let's return to communication and networking. What do I mean by each of those words, and why have I gone to pains to distinguish between them? I'll start with networking, since it's the easier of the two to capture.
By "networking," I mean making connections. When two people network, they try to assess each other's position, and contribute resources - intellectual, physical, or otherwise - to each other in an effort to be of mutual use in the effort to meet emotional, psychological, physical, or professional needs. Networking is, in short, a kind of poking at each other and shoving stuff (whether tangible or intangible) in each other's direction. Building a network, then, is about creating a vast web of people to whom one can go for such assistance, and from whom one expects requests of a similar nature.
The beauty of the Internet - as opposed to previous incarnations of the same concept, all the way down to bartering at the local swap meet - is that it makes the whole thing both asynchronous and distributed. Asynchrony is important because the exchange between one node on a network and another need not be simultaneous, so I might borrow emotional support from a friend or borrow a potentially useful business contact from a mentor without needing to engage in immediate payback. Granted, this asynchrony of networked exchange is not unique to the Internet, as the phrase "I owe you one" indicates, but it is particularly strong on the web because no face-to-face meeting is even necessary. "I owe you one" is built into the structure, rather than something that has to be said after an arrangement has been reached.
That networks are distributed on the Internet is by far the more revolutionary and vital of its differences with traditional networks. What I mean by "distributed" is simply this: it is not important that the person who "owes you one" be the person who pays you (metaphorically) back. In a sufficiently advanced network redundancies abound. "You and Connor have 82 friends in common." If you, then, help out Connor by connecting him with a potential employer, it is not fully necessary, in a world where networks are distributed, asynchronous, and - a third important piece that warrants mention, if not discussion - instantaneous, for Connor to provide a similar service to you. It is taken as granted that he might, and maybe even will try to do so, but when you have needs that become paramount, you will not seek Connor on the basis of him owing you, but rather only if he is the member of your network most able to help you.
As a result, in a distributed network, there is ample commerce, but it is not always direct. A cynic would point out that, in the long history of mankind (and especially in the last 300 years), almost every human interaction can be characterized according to political economy. The debits and credits of that political economy are what made up the networks of the past. That cynic, then, in order to understand the Internet and the kind of networking that the web has created, would have to decentralize the political economy, shifting it away from the exchange of capital (be it fiscal, emotional, spiritual, or whatever) from one person to another and towards a new model where exchange remains individualized, but the reserves, so to speak, are more communal.
Despite that shift from individual to community, however, the Internet is far from socialist or communist. It is innately capitalist, innately concerned with individualism and personal gain. Modern networking is in some sense the epitome of the capitalistic notion of the "invisible hand," where each person looking out for himself allows things to work out for the good of everyone, where the rising tide does, indeed, lift all boats.
Wither communication, in that picture? Before I can answer that, I need to distinguish communication from networking. Communication, as I imagine it, is an actual exchange of ideas, an effort not merely to assess the material or emotional needs of oneself and one's interlocutor, but to actually understand the spirit and mind of that person. Communication is what happens when neither party in a conversation is looking out for his own advancement or the advancement of the other, but rather the shared effort of the two people is dialogue: a talking, thinking, and reasoning through difficult questions about meaning, purpose, and truth. A modern cynic will say that such a conversation is not possible, because we're all too myopic and too self-absorbed to achieve the level of objectivity necessary for such a conversation to occur. Moreover, said modernist (or, really, post-modernist) will argue that never in history have such conversation occurred; they have only seemed to do so because of the narrowness of the perspectives of those culturally hegemonic (or, at least, culturally isolated) societies in which conversations are said to have happened.
I suppose, on some level, the capacity for real empathy and, thereby, true dialogue is an article of faith. Once convinced that such a thing does not exist, it is impossible to be persuaded otherwise, because the opinion itself precludes any evidence to the contrary. Nevertheless, I believe firmly that such communication can and does happen. Indeed, while this blog is hardly dialogic, in that I write all of these posts by myself, at its heart is the belief in ideas and communication, despite my doubts that such is possible over the Internet.
Which leads me to the end point of this series of posts. Twitter and Facebook are two of the most successful and revolutionary services on the Internet. We might also lump in email, skype, Linkedin, or any of a number of other networking services. Regardless, however, we will be talking about networking. It is undoubtedly the case that there is no online service which actively promotes communication in the sense I've talked about it above. My question is, is there any service that does not, actually, actively prevent communication, in favor of networking? What's more, is it possibly the case that some networking services begin to trick us into believing that we are communicating when we are actually networking?
Those are questions to which I do not have answers, even if I pose them rhetorically (as if I do have answers). Regardless, it is clear to me that communication - or, we might also say, learning (a connection that might require a whole post to itself) - have been largely ignored, harried, or even battled against by the political economy of the last 300 or so years. That dialogue has held on - if only in a few places - is a testament to how important it is to actual human progress. That it has not yet, to my knowledge, broken through in the digital world is a testament to how powerful the myopic impulse for networking (we might as well say, for personal gain) is.
I leave with an analogy. Networking is not merely with people, but with ideas. Increasingly, we are concerned with what ideas link to other ideas. While there is evidence that learning happens largely through making connections, and that building networks of thoughts and definitions and concepts is an important part of thinking critically, I wonder when we synthesize. Building a network - of people or ideas - does not seem innately good or bad, any less than a blueprint or a scaffold for a building is innately functional. Rather, the question is what do we do with that network. If we merely connect ideas (or people) to each other, but never bore into them, try to discern their meaning and import, try to improve ourselves and our world, what good is that network? It is as if we have made a blueprint for a building but have never actually built it, instead going from room to imaginary room, thinking about how we might decorate them, instead of how we might live in them.
Showing posts with label ideas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ideas. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Friday, March 25, 2011
The Writing Process and Upcoming Posts
On the way to producing even something as innocuous as a blog post, there's a culling process. Ideas have to be sifted and shifted, weighed and discarded before they make their way to the blank canvas of the input screen. From there, they turn into the monstrosities that you read (or prudently ignore) in this space here. Though the actual writing is something I usually do quickly, there is significant meditation, conversation, and consideration on the front end.
Which is all to say that, even though I haven't been writing very much during this visit to San Francisco, there's an awful lot to write about, and I've come up with more ideas for posts in the last couple weeks than I can possibly turn into readable entries anytime soon. At times of inspiration, this is usually true. It's not uncommon to run through a good dozen ideas for every one that actually becomes a post. At other times it can be hard to generate even a single idea.
Nevertheless, I find it important to write even when I struggle to know what to write about. Why? Because of something I learned from my piano teacher, Todd Kelly, while I was growing up. He once told me that, as a pianist, sometimes you're inspired and sometimes your not. The purpose of practice, then, is to ensure that, when you are inspired, you can harness that creative energy and make your musical dreams into a reality. It is, in short, no good imagining fantastical glissandos when your hands can't play them.
What's more, if you practice enough, it's likely that you'll find yourself being inspired more often, too. Though I also would caution against over-specialization. Focus on practice alone, to the exclusion of the world, might stop you from ever being inspired by, you know, the world, which is frankly more inspiring a place than a practice room.
Anyway, as you can tell, all of that is transferable to writing (or to any other pursuit, really). If you don't slough through those ugly times when you can't think of anything to write about, and you don't want to write, and you wonder what's the point, you'll struggle to write when you do have a bright idea. There's a kind of learning that goes on when you struggle to succeed that, I believe, fills in the cracks in the learning that comes easily.
So with that in mind, I want to expose a little bit of my own writing process by sharing a slew of ideas that I've been contemplating these last few days while zipping from museum to symphony to restaurant without a chance to even turn on my computer. Not all of these will become posts, and those that do, I suspect, will end up very different than how I imagine them working now. Some will turn out to not have enough meat for a full post, while others will have to be cut into pieces. Part of the point of blogging in the first place is that it's not immediately clear which is which. Only writing will tell.
My Decision - Not a riff on the LeBron James motif, much fun as that would be. My current choice between attending UCSD or Stanford to do my PhD work is, as far as I can tell, the most important decision I've had to make in my life so far. While we certainly face countless momentous decisions every day, rarely are we conscious ahead of time that any given crossroads is truly life altering.
Rough Dissertation Ideas - This is related to the above. In order to help make this decision, I was advised by a Professor at Stanford to run through my current top 4 or 5 dissertation ideas, and to see which school would better fit with those possibilities.
Defining Learning Sciences and Communications - The last iteration of the decision theme, this would be a high-level attempt to understand what the two programs I've been admitted to really are. Stanford's "Learning Sciences and Technology Design" program practically demands an attempt at definition, while "Communications" is so broad and ambiguous a field that it would be valuable for me to place myself within it.
Drawing an Aging Curve - I'm fascinated and, in some ways, terrified, by the human life-cycle. Joe Posnanski sometimes writes about athletes and how they believe they will never get worse, or, even more improbably, that they will continue to improve indefinitely. I'm curious as to how that maps to non-athletes as well (from a theoretical and speculative perspective, anyway; I don't know the research on this stuff).
What is Art? - Inspired by the ongoing conversation Jericha and I have had here in San Francisco, I want to explore thoughts on narrative, meaning, categories, and specialization as they relate to artistic creation and artistic consumption. Painting, music, literature, games, and so on are all possible angles. So is - be forewarned - Schopenhauer.
Beethoven's Eroica, Part 2 - I haven't forgotten the music project, either. Part two (and beyond) is in the works.
Darren Waterston's Clearing - Of all the art I've seen in the past week or so, there are a small set of pieces that particularly stand out to me. This is one of them, and while it is abstract, I think it lends itself well to some layman analysis and interpretation.
Caius (sic) Marius on the Ruins of Carthage - A John Vanderlyn painting from 1807, this piece is another worth writing about. I find it surprisingly prescient.
The Symphony from the New World Live - It may surprise you that I spent a year at Stanford without ever seeing the San Francisco Symphony live. During this trip I've remedied the oversight with the help of Dvorák. His most famous piece is a both very accessible and deceptively subtle and complex. Definitely worth a listen and some analysis. Also worth mention is the quality of the symphony and the symphony hall in San Francisco.
San Francisco (and Stanford) Retrospective - I already wrote an in situ poetic rambling about my experience of staying in San Francisco earlier in my visit, but I feel like there's still plenty more snobbish waxing I might do.
Cities and Invisible Cities - Italo Calvino is one of my favorite authors, and Invisible Cities is on my "Best Books Ever" shortlist.* Why not, instead of just gibbering about my own experience, bring in the expert. Of course, talking about Invisible Cities means talking about design and emotion and love and desire and meaning and civilization and religion and, well, yeah, just about everything.
* How short is that list? Frankly, Invisible Cities might very well be on the list even if I cut it down to one. Which gives me an idea for another post...
What Makes a Good Museum? - One last San Francisco inspired post, taking a broad view of the museums I've visited during my trip. What makes them work (or not), from my uninformed perspective as a simple museum-goer?
Science and Optimism - A response to the eminent Joe Spotts's recent post, Science is Optimism. I would tell you more, but I haven't actually read the whole thing yet (I've been busy, and it is tagged with "absurdly long winded posts"). Anyway, don't tell him and maybe I can get away with writing a response without reading it. You know, kind of like everyone else on the Internet.
Watson, Computer Overlord - I did recently watch the IBM computer Watson "compete" on Jeopardy. I say "compete" because, frankly, it completely crushed its opposition, which included two of the most successful Jeopardy contestants ever. While the whole thing is a little sensationalist and, of course, not nearly as big a jump in computing as the IBM people make it sound, a computer that can deal with common language statements has profound implications.
Baseball Team Names - Inspired in part by a Pitchers and Poets post (which in turn was inspired by a Cardboard Connection post) about current MLB hats, I think it would be fun to do a run down of MLB team names. There are a lot of potential angles here, but the ones that interest me most are:
1) Pure Poetry - wherein we lament the loss of the sonorous Montreal Expos and shame the atrocity that is the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
2) Appropriateness - wherein the Los Angeles Dodgers don't make a bit of sense, while the Philadelphia Phillies is perhaps a bit too obvious.
3) Historical Significance - wherein the New York Yankees are as iconic as they come, whereas the Tampa Bay (Devil?) Rays can't even decide who they are.
Nuclear Power - In the aftermath of the Japan earthquake and Nuclear disaster, public opinions is quickly turning against expanded nuclear power (not that it matters, since big wigs from both major parties are still firmly in favor). The problem is, people are changing their minds for all the wrong reasons. Nuclear power is terrible, but not because of the threat of meltdown. How is it terrible, then? Let me count the ways (and, of course, we'll also count the not inconsequential ways in which it is not terrible).
The FEC vs. Citizens United - For those of you who aren't aware, the Supreme Court ruled prior to the 2010 elections that corporations could effectively give infinite sums of money to political campaigns. The truth of the matter is, most people from both parties believe that corporations have too much influence in politics already, and that influence is only growing. So let's talk about corporations, law, precedent, and the effort to reverse the trend.
The Man Who Arranges the Blocks - I don't know if there's a post in this, but I love it.
So there you have it, almost 20 ideas for posts. I'd say the odds are roughly even that my next post is none of these.
Which is all to say that, even though I haven't been writing very much during this visit to San Francisco, there's an awful lot to write about, and I've come up with more ideas for posts in the last couple weeks than I can possibly turn into readable entries anytime soon. At times of inspiration, this is usually true. It's not uncommon to run through a good dozen ideas for every one that actually becomes a post. At other times it can be hard to generate even a single idea.
Nevertheless, I find it important to write even when I struggle to know what to write about. Why? Because of something I learned from my piano teacher, Todd Kelly, while I was growing up. He once told me that, as a pianist, sometimes you're inspired and sometimes your not. The purpose of practice, then, is to ensure that, when you are inspired, you can harness that creative energy and make your musical dreams into a reality. It is, in short, no good imagining fantastical glissandos when your hands can't play them.
What's more, if you practice enough, it's likely that you'll find yourself being inspired more often, too. Though I also would caution against over-specialization. Focus on practice alone, to the exclusion of the world, might stop you from ever being inspired by, you know, the world, which is frankly more inspiring a place than a practice room.
Anyway, as you can tell, all of that is transferable to writing (or to any other pursuit, really). If you don't slough through those ugly times when you can't think of anything to write about, and you don't want to write, and you wonder what's the point, you'll struggle to write when you do have a bright idea. There's a kind of learning that goes on when you struggle to succeed that, I believe, fills in the cracks in the learning that comes easily.
So with that in mind, I want to expose a little bit of my own writing process by sharing a slew of ideas that I've been contemplating these last few days while zipping from museum to symphony to restaurant without a chance to even turn on my computer. Not all of these will become posts, and those that do, I suspect, will end up very different than how I imagine them working now. Some will turn out to not have enough meat for a full post, while others will have to be cut into pieces. Part of the point of blogging in the first place is that it's not immediately clear which is which. Only writing will tell.
My Decision - Not a riff on the LeBron James motif, much fun as that would be. My current choice between attending UCSD or Stanford to do my PhD work is, as far as I can tell, the most important decision I've had to make in my life so far. While we certainly face countless momentous decisions every day, rarely are we conscious ahead of time that any given crossroads is truly life altering.
Rough Dissertation Ideas - This is related to the above. In order to help make this decision, I was advised by a Professor at Stanford to run through my current top 4 or 5 dissertation ideas, and to see which school would better fit with those possibilities.
Defining Learning Sciences and Communications - The last iteration of the decision theme, this would be a high-level attempt to understand what the two programs I've been admitted to really are. Stanford's "Learning Sciences and Technology Design" program practically demands an attempt at definition, while "Communications" is so broad and ambiguous a field that it would be valuable for me to place myself within it.
Drawing an Aging Curve - I'm fascinated and, in some ways, terrified, by the human life-cycle. Joe Posnanski sometimes writes about athletes and how they believe they will never get worse, or, even more improbably, that they will continue to improve indefinitely. I'm curious as to how that maps to non-athletes as well (from a theoretical and speculative perspective, anyway; I don't know the research on this stuff).
What is Art? - Inspired by the ongoing conversation Jericha and I have had here in San Francisco, I want to explore thoughts on narrative, meaning, categories, and specialization as they relate to artistic creation and artistic consumption. Painting, music, literature, games, and so on are all possible angles. So is - be forewarned - Schopenhauer.
Beethoven's Eroica, Part 2 - I haven't forgotten the music project, either. Part two (and beyond) is in the works.
Darren Waterston's Clearing - Of all the art I've seen in the past week or so, there are a small set of pieces that particularly stand out to me. This is one of them, and while it is abstract, I think it lends itself well to some layman analysis and interpretation.
Caius (sic) Marius on the Ruins of Carthage - A John Vanderlyn painting from 1807, this piece is another worth writing about. I find it surprisingly prescient.
The Symphony from the New World Live - It may surprise you that I spent a year at Stanford without ever seeing the San Francisco Symphony live. During this trip I've remedied the oversight with the help of Dvorák. His most famous piece is a both very accessible and deceptively subtle and complex. Definitely worth a listen and some analysis. Also worth mention is the quality of the symphony and the symphony hall in San Francisco.
San Francisco (and Stanford) Retrospective - I already wrote an in situ poetic rambling about my experience of staying in San Francisco earlier in my visit, but I feel like there's still plenty more snobbish waxing I might do.
Cities and Invisible Cities - Italo Calvino is one of my favorite authors, and Invisible Cities is on my "Best Books Ever" shortlist.* Why not, instead of just gibbering about my own experience, bring in the expert. Of course, talking about Invisible Cities means talking about design and emotion and love and desire and meaning and civilization and religion and, well, yeah, just about everything.
* How short is that list? Frankly, Invisible Cities might very well be on the list even if I cut it down to one. Which gives me an idea for another post...
What Makes a Good Museum? - One last San Francisco inspired post, taking a broad view of the museums I've visited during my trip. What makes them work (or not), from my uninformed perspective as a simple museum-goer?
Science and Optimism - A response to the eminent Joe Spotts's recent post, Science is Optimism. I would tell you more, but I haven't actually read the whole thing yet (I've been busy, and it is tagged with "absurdly long winded posts"). Anyway, don't tell him and maybe I can get away with writing a response without reading it. You know, kind of like everyone else on the Internet.
Watson, Computer Overlord - I did recently watch the IBM computer Watson "compete" on Jeopardy. I say "compete" because, frankly, it completely crushed its opposition, which included two of the most successful Jeopardy contestants ever. While the whole thing is a little sensationalist and, of course, not nearly as big a jump in computing as the IBM people make it sound, a computer that can deal with common language statements has profound implications.
Baseball Team Names - Inspired in part by a Pitchers and Poets post (which in turn was inspired by a Cardboard Connection post) about current MLB hats, I think it would be fun to do a run down of MLB team names. There are a lot of potential angles here, but the ones that interest me most are:
1) Pure Poetry - wherein we lament the loss of the sonorous Montreal Expos and shame the atrocity that is the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
2) Appropriateness - wherein the Los Angeles Dodgers don't make a bit of sense, while the Philadelphia Phillies is perhaps a bit too obvious.
3) Historical Significance - wherein the New York Yankees are as iconic as they come, whereas the Tampa Bay (Devil?) Rays can't even decide who they are.
Nuclear Power - In the aftermath of the Japan earthquake and Nuclear disaster, public opinions is quickly turning against expanded nuclear power (not that it matters, since big wigs from both major parties are still firmly in favor). The problem is, people are changing their minds for all the wrong reasons. Nuclear power is terrible, but not because of the threat of meltdown. How is it terrible, then? Let me count the ways (and, of course, we'll also count the not inconsequential ways in which it is not terrible).
The FEC vs. Citizens United - For those of you who aren't aware, the Supreme Court ruled prior to the 2010 elections that corporations could effectively give infinite sums of money to political campaigns. The truth of the matter is, most people from both parties believe that corporations have too much influence in politics already, and that influence is only growing. So let's talk about corporations, law, precedent, and the effort to reverse the trend.
The Man Who Arranges the Blocks - I don't know if there's a post in this, but I love it.
So there you have it, almost 20 ideas for posts. I'd say the odds are roughly even that my next post is none of these.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Exploring Research Questions
Having effectively joined the ranks of the unemployed following my resignation as Director of NALU Studies, I have begun not only looking at other jobs - which is lots of fun in the current market - but also looking at PhD programs. In the case of the former, my range is fairly narrow. I'm looking, basically, for work with schools that want to do technology integration in their curricula because, after all, that's what I got my Master's in. In the latter case, the angle is much more obtuse.
Pursuing a PhD is something that makes sense to me, as an avid writer, reader, and thinker. While the politics of the University world are somewhat abhorrent, the intellectual community is appealing nonetheless, and a doctoral degree hardly means that I'd have to stay in academia if I found it too distasteful. On the other hand, the real challenge here is not navigating politics or soft money, but rather defining an area of interest sufficiently narrow to ensure finding a fitting advisor and, ultimately, a fruitful dissertation.
For a generalist, however, that is a difficulty that cannot and should not be overlooked. Part of the appeal, indeed, of the specialized job of instructional technology and curriculum support is that it is, in reality, a generalists job. I would be the expert on what tools are available for classroom use, and good implementation practices, but I would (at least in theory) have the opportunity to work with teachers of English, history, science, math, music, foreign language, and anything else a given school offers. In short, I'd be a specialist who nevertheless gets to work across fields, who gets to talk to people who know, between them, know a lot about almost any subject you'd want to know about. Contrast that with most Universities, where the world is more insular, where conversations don't frequently happen across departments, and you'll see the appeal to a generalist and a learner of being able to span multiple disciplines.
So the challenge, given the fast approaching deadlines of many PhD programs, is defining not only a question, but even an area of study. Hence this post, which is more for me than my readers, as I try to explore the implications of a few ideas and, hopefully, get some ideas back in return.
Music
One of my first thoughts in my current exploration of graduate programs was, "Why not return to music?" I do love music, as the title of the blog suggests. The biggest challenge is that, though I am a marginally competent pianist, I am no expert, certainly not at the level that PhD programs expect. In the last two years, especially, my practice has been limited, and while I have more or less maintained my skills, I am no better at the piano now than I was as an undergraduate.
Nevertheless, my Senior Thesis at St. John's was a musicology paper, I was an assistant in music courses for three years, and I conducted a chamber orchestra. I don't think selling a program on my background would be easy, but it would be far from impossible. Which leaves the bigger issue of what part of music I'd like to study.
Regardless of the field of study I pursue, integrating some of my Stanford LDT knowledge is a no-brainer. And, ultimately, I'm still passionate about education. So the angle from which studying music is most appealing is the musical-cognition angle. That is, how do people learn to understand music? Perhaps there's a cultural and anthropological bent to that question: how does culture and language effect the learning of music? How, for example, does classical music differ from jazz harmonically, melodically, and rhythmically, and how would a classical musician describe those differences relative to a jazz musician? Beneath all of that, how does learning the music from one or the other perspective (and we could throw in many others, from pop music to modern rock to Hindu chants) influence the comprehension of the others?
It seems to me that there are two chief ways to explore those questions. The first involves neuroscience, studying cognition using brain waves and such. But that science is still in its infancy, and the more interesting angle (though probably the less fund-able one) is the anthropological one. The ethnography necessary to do research into any of those questions would be fascinating and enjoyable.
Another angle, here, is strict musicology, but that seems a little bland and self-serving. At least the above has implications for education, assuming schools ever teach music again, anyway. On the other hand, musicology could also be a curricular focus. Is there a way to teach music to students that combines theory, history, and appreciation. As it is, those are all usually separate classes (as the college level, of course). Why not make a single class that incorporates all of those? The question, I guess, is does that effort even belong in a PhD program, or is it more of a professional deal?
Fellow Johnnies will point out that St. John's does indeed combine those three points, which leads to a possible research project: how do students of St. John's music program compare to students who take music classes at other colleges? But that's a can of worms that leads to a different area of study, as well.
Education
Working towards a PhD in education makes some sense given my Master's in education, and I certainly feel I can ask a more sophisticated and specialized research question in this area than in any other. Of course, the question I'm most fascinated by brings with it certain challenges: St. John's and research are not always friends.
What I mean is, I'd love to study the differences between a St. John's education, a different liberal arts education, and normal University education, and a parochial education. I of course know that the curricula and pedagogy are wildly different, and I more or less know in what way and why. But the question is deeper than that: how do students in those various settings differ? What is the culture of St. John's compared to Williams College, compared to the University of Michigan, compared to a Community College? How much of that owes to geography, how much to pedagogy, how much to some other factor? Of course, the outcome piece is important, too: which graduates are more "successful," and in what ways?
I'm not convinced, however, that St. John's buys the kinds of processes that go into that kind of research project. I'm not sure I do, either. Try as they might, even the most objective education researchers usually have an axe to grind, and have biases built mostly (or even exclusively) on their own educational experiences. "Best practice," in that cynical world view, is "what worked for me." And, without a doubt, that's the challenge I would face. St. John's is, to me, one of the best colleges in the country, if not the best. Could I really overcome that bias and look at it objectively? Would St. John's even want me to? Do they care if they are "effective" in any modern, researchable sense?
Which leads me to narrower questions that might be more researchable, and still fit under education. For example, do students do better working from original source material alone, or do they do better working with secondary sources and interpretations? This question comes from a conversation I had at Stanford with a Professor there, and it still is fascinating to me. It captures a piece of St. John's, without a doubt (since Johnnies are discouraged from using secondary sources and interpretations, so much so that we're often asked not even to consider context). But it also captures high school English, where Hamlet is usually read without any accompanying documents.
The linchpin here is "better." What exactly constitutes "better?" Do secondary sources improve comprehension, interpretation, analysis? Do they improve creativity? Do they improve the level of conversation in the classroom? What's more, is there even a good way, pedagogically, to introduce them without being boring?
There are other rich angles here, as well, such as the differences between high school and college level students (which benefits more from secondary source material). Moreover, we might ask about the cultures of the schools and classrooms involved. Perhaps a lecture class is much better with secondary sources, but a discussion one is not. Or maybe it's the other way around? Who knows?
Needless to say, I could probably generate a good dozen questions that fit under the heading of education, but the underlying theme to all of them is the same: I want to know about the components of a St. John's education, and what makes it work (assuming it does). Discussion versus lecture is the key here, and that's a cultural question, which leads to a whole other kind of thought.
Anthropology
I have never taken a single anthropology class in my life, though the Alienation and Deprivation in Fiction and Education course at Stanford was close. I don't know the language, I don't know the research, and I don't know the questions. Nevertheless, the concepts keep hitting me again and again. Cultural anthropology is the kind of research I keep coming up with, even if it's in music, or education, or literature, or anything else.
Now there's no question that I am a math person, and I don't know what place math has in anthropological research. I'm wary of numbers, because too often we let them stand in for real meanings and real people. That said, mere anecdote does not knowledge make, and so the best bet is to combine the two. I'm sure that anthropology does this, but I simply don't know enough about it.
So what questions do I even have? Well, I don't have archaeological questions. That's not totally true, but I don't want to get a PhD in them. My questions are more about modern cultures, and especially the Internet. Ironically, though I do not use Facebook or Twitter, I'm fascinated by the cultural implications of both. A study of how social networking is effecting people's understanding of self and culture would be extremely interesting to me. And I'm sure it's already happening.
Anyway, that's just one of many questions in the anthropology world that appeals to me. Some of the questions from my music and education sections could probably fall under this heading as well. And that's the rub. How and where can I bring subjects together? What school is cross-disciplinary enough, what advisor enough of a generalist to help lead me through not only doing research, but narrowing my focus enough to be effective without gimping my generalist tendencies overmuch?
The truth is, I'm leaving off disciplines, even here. I've explored Stanford's Modern Thought and Literature program, which runs out of their English department. I've considered Linguistics. I won't rule out Neuroscience, even if I'd have a lot of catching up to do. I'd even consider Statistics!
The trick, to me, is not finding the right field, it's finding the right school and the right advisor, and then breaking the rules. My academic success has always been built upon stretching the limits of what is acceptable, whether that means turning in a poem instead of an essay (but a poem that is still an essay), or taking courses that don't fit into a degree but using them to inform projects, or purposefully trying to break rubrics.
Which is all well and good once I'm in a structured, academic environment, but I'm smart enough to realize that I need that structured environment, too. The rebel has to rebel against something. The innovator is only innovative relative to his surroundings. Finding a good environment, then, is the real key, and the truth of the matter is, I don't know what I'm looking for. Or, rather, I know exactly what I'm looking for, but I don't have the slightest clue how to find it.
But maybe that, more than anything else, suggests to me that I'm ready to work towards a doctorate.
Pursuing a PhD is something that makes sense to me, as an avid writer, reader, and thinker. While the politics of the University world are somewhat abhorrent, the intellectual community is appealing nonetheless, and a doctoral degree hardly means that I'd have to stay in academia if I found it too distasteful. On the other hand, the real challenge here is not navigating politics or soft money, but rather defining an area of interest sufficiently narrow to ensure finding a fitting advisor and, ultimately, a fruitful dissertation.
For a generalist, however, that is a difficulty that cannot and should not be overlooked. Part of the appeal, indeed, of the specialized job of instructional technology and curriculum support is that it is, in reality, a generalists job. I would be the expert on what tools are available for classroom use, and good implementation practices, but I would (at least in theory) have the opportunity to work with teachers of English, history, science, math, music, foreign language, and anything else a given school offers. In short, I'd be a specialist who nevertheless gets to work across fields, who gets to talk to people who know, between them, know a lot about almost any subject you'd want to know about. Contrast that with most Universities, where the world is more insular, where conversations don't frequently happen across departments, and you'll see the appeal to a generalist and a learner of being able to span multiple disciplines.
So the challenge, given the fast approaching deadlines of many PhD programs, is defining not only a question, but even an area of study. Hence this post, which is more for me than my readers, as I try to explore the implications of a few ideas and, hopefully, get some ideas back in return.
Music
One of my first thoughts in my current exploration of graduate programs was, "Why not return to music?" I do love music, as the title of the blog suggests. The biggest challenge is that, though I am a marginally competent pianist, I am no expert, certainly not at the level that PhD programs expect. In the last two years, especially, my practice has been limited, and while I have more or less maintained my skills, I am no better at the piano now than I was as an undergraduate.
Nevertheless, my Senior Thesis at St. John's was a musicology paper, I was an assistant in music courses for three years, and I conducted a chamber orchestra. I don't think selling a program on my background would be easy, but it would be far from impossible. Which leaves the bigger issue of what part of music I'd like to study.
Regardless of the field of study I pursue, integrating some of my Stanford LDT knowledge is a no-brainer. And, ultimately, I'm still passionate about education. So the angle from which studying music is most appealing is the musical-cognition angle. That is, how do people learn to understand music? Perhaps there's a cultural and anthropological bent to that question: how does culture and language effect the learning of music? How, for example, does classical music differ from jazz harmonically, melodically, and rhythmically, and how would a classical musician describe those differences relative to a jazz musician? Beneath all of that, how does learning the music from one or the other perspective (and we could throw in many others, from pop music to modern rock to Hindu chants) influence the comprehension of the others?
It seems to me that there are two chief ways to explore those questions. The first involves neuroscience, studying cognition using brain waves and such. But that science is still in its infancy, and the more interesting angle (though probably the less fund-able one) is the anthropological one. The ethnography necessary to do research into any of those questions would be fascinating and enjoyable.
Another angle, here, is strict musicology, but that seems a little bland and self-serving. At least the above has implications for education, assuming schools ever teach music again, anyway. On the other hand, musicology could also be a curricular focus. Is there a way to teach music to students that combines theory, history, and appreciation. As it is, those are all usually separate classes (as the college level, of course). Why not make a single class that incorporates all of those? The question, I guess, is does that effort even belong in a PhD program, or is it more of a professional deal?
Fellow Johnnies will point out that St. John's does indeed combine those three points, which leads to a possible research project: how do students of St. John's music program compare to students who take music classes at other colleges? But that's a can of worms that leads to a different area of study, as well.
Education
Working towards a PhD in education makes some sense given my Master's in education, and I certainly feel I can ask a more sophisticated and specialized research question in this area than in any other. Of course, the question I'm most fascinated by brings with it certain challenges: St. John's and research are not always friends.
What I mean is, I'd love to study the differences between a St. John's education, a different liberal arts education, and normal University education, and a parochial education. I of course know that the curricula and pedagogy are wildly different, and I more or less know in what way and why. But the question is deeper than that: how do students in those various settings differ? What is the culture of St. John's compared to Williams College, compared to the University of Michigan, compared to a Community College? How much of that owes to geography, how much to pedagogy, how much to some other factor? Of course, the outcome piece is important, too: which graduates are more "successful," and in what ways?
I'm not convinced, however, that St. John's buys the kinds of processes that go into that kind of research project. I'm not sure I do, either. Try as they might, even the most objective education researchers usually have an axe to grind, and have biases built mostly (or even exclusively) on their own educational experiences. "Best practice," in that cynical world view, is "what worked for me." And, without a doubt, that's the challenge I would face. St. John's is, to me, one of the best colleges in the country, if not the best. Could I really overcome that bias and look at it objectively? Would St. John's even want me to? Do they care if they are "effective" in any modern, researchable sense?
Which leads me to narrower questions that might be more researchable, and still fit under education. For example, do students do better working from original source material alone, or do they do better working with secondary sources and interpretations? This question comes from a conversation I had at Stanford with a Professor there, and it still is fascinating to me. It captures a piece of St. John's, without a doubt (since Johnnies are discouraged from using secondary sources and interpretations, so much so that we're often asked not even to consider context). But it also captures high school English, where Hamlet is usually read without any accompanying documents.
The linchpin here is "better." What exactly constitutes "better?" Do secondary sources improve comprehension, interpretation, analysis? Do they improve creativity? Do they improve the level of conversation in the classroom? What's more, is there even a good way, pedagogically, to introduce them without being boring?
There are other rich angles here, as well, such as the differences between high school and college level students (which benefits more from secondary source material). Moreover, we might ask about the cultures of the schools and classrooms involved. Perhaps a lecture class is much better with secondary sources, but a discussion one is not. Or maybe it's the other way around? Who knows?
Needless to say, I could probably generate a good dozen questions that fit under the heading of education, but the underlying theme to all of them is the same: I want to know about the components of a St. John's education, and what makes it work (assuming it does). Discussion versus lecture is the key here, and that's a cultural question, which leads to a whole other kind of thought.
Anthropology
I have never taken a single anthropology class in my life, though the Alienation and Deprivation in Fiction and Education course at Stanford was close. I don't know the language, I don't know the research, and I don't know the questions. Nevertheless, the concepts keep hitting me again and again. Cultural anthropology is the kind of research I keep coming up with, even if it's in music, or education, or literature, or anything else.
Now there's no question that I am a math person, and I don't know what place math has in anthropological research. I'm wary of numbers, because too often we let them stand in for real meanings and real people. That said, mere anecdote does not knowledge make, and so the best bet is to combine the two. I'm sure that anthropology does this, but I simply don't know enough about it.
So what questions do I even have? Well, I don't have archaeological questions. That's not totally true, but I don't want to get a PhD in them. My questions are more about modern cultures, and especially the Internet. Ironically, though I do not use Facebook or Twitter, I'm fascinated by the cultural implications of both. A study of how social networking is effecting people's understanding of self and culture would be extremely interesting to me. And I'm sure it's already happening.
Anyway, that's just one of many questions in the anthropology world that appeals to me. Some of the questions from my music and education sections could probably fall under this heading as well. And that's the rub. How and where can I bring subjects together? What school is cross-disciplinary enough, what advisor enough of a generalist to help lead me through not only doing research, but narrowing my focus enough to be effective without gimping my generalist tendencies overmuch?
The truth is, I'm leaving off disciplines, even here. I've explored Stanford's Modern Thought and Literature program, which runs out of their English department. I've considered Linguistics. I won't rule out Neuroscience, even if I'd have a lot of catching up to do. I'd even consider Statistics!
The trick, to me, is not finding the right field, it's finding the right school and the right advisor, and then breaking the rules. My academic success has always been built upon stretching the limits of what is acceptable, whether that means turning in a poem instead of an essay (but a poem that is still an essay), or taking courses that don't fit into a degree but using them to inform projects, or purposefully trying to break rubrics.
Which is all well and good once I'm in a structured, academic environment, but I'm smart enough to realize that I need that structured environment, too. The rebel has to rebel against something. The innovator is only innovative relative to his surroundings. Finding a good environment, then, is the real key, and the truth of the matter is, I don't know what I'm looking for. Or, rather, I know exactly what I'm looking for, but I don't have the slightest clue how to find it.
But maybe that, more than anything else, suggests to me that I'm ready to work towards a doctorate.
Friday, February 19, 2010
Intellectual Property
How can you own an idea?
I know, that's a prompt for a middle school discussion of copyright, but that doesn't mean it's not an important question. Indeed, we have a whole cultural and legal mechanism that allows us to "own" ideas, but the very concept of intellectual property has a far from clear history. Even today, there is a large ideological rift between open intellectual and artistic resources on the one hand and proprietary resources on the other (and, as is common in such debates, the more "practical" side of the argument has co-opted the language of the more idealistic, so that things like Facebook, Twitter, and Google get called "open" when they decidedly are not).
Long before any modern debate, however, Plato confronted the very issue, matter-of-factly stating that, when it comes down to it, owning an idea is essentially impossible. As soon as you hear someone else's idea, understand it, and express it to yourself, it becomes yours. And thank goodness, because the number of original ideas floating around is very small (and those few truly original ideas that do exist are likely insane). There's a particular myopia in believing that any of our ideas have never been thought of before or elsewhere, or even that seemingly new ideas don't come from a huge, continuous background set of repeated ideas. The world is, after all, very old, and people have been on it - and have spoken and written - for a great many generations. There are, at present, well over 6 billion people on the Earth. So show me a completely original idea. And, what's more, show me an idea that is owned.
Of course, we have a cultural and economic model - as I mentioned - for "owning" ideas, but it has nothing to do with where ideas come from. Intellectual property, like the first forays into physical property, is the domain of the socially and culturally adept. Indeed, one might look at the University (or the Record Label, for that matter) not as a way of generating new thoughts, but as a way of ensuring that you publish your thoughts, protecting your intellectual property. It doesn't matter that most researchers in every field are heavily dependent upon each other and upon the mass of research and theory that predates them, because they have a system of intellectual property built around them to keep all but the most determined students out. Participating in the free flow of ideas in academia, in other words, comes at great cost (all of the journals and reviews and books that academics are forced to produce so that, ironically, their employers can afford to pay for all of the journals and reviews and books they need to provide their faculty). Some academics fight this commercialized view of ideas, but it's a tough fight. After all, their own survival depends, to large degree, on their intellectual property.
Owning ideas, however, contributes to social injustice. When access to the best and brightest is limited to the most able to pay, it's no wonder that rich begets rich and poor begets poor. Meritocracy is maintained, perhaps, in the sense that it is much easier to become a meritorious leader when starting off able to afford and willing to pursue an education. The "American Dream" notwithstanding, there is a strong sense of caste in the United States that rests, in most part, upon our inability to provide free access to the one resource most at the heart of learning: ideas (we might also say wisdom, but that's a more complicated word).
From an individualistic perspective, there seems little point in coming up with ideas if other people have already had them (unless, of course, other people didn't publish them), but that seems to me a mistake. A society with open access to ideas will perhaps produce more redundancy, but will also therefore produce a citizenry ready and able to adapt their thinking to particular situations. New ideas may be few, but the peculiarities of any one problem may require a precise combination of ideas (and skills) heretofore untried. At the very least, the processes (and there are many) of problem solving are ideas that no one should "own," and yet problem solving is so rarely taught.
Ultimately, we are all constrained by the culture of intellectual property, but I believe it is worth it to ask questions of the system sometimes. Indeed, if there was more critical reflection going around, we might find that much of what we do "because we have to," we don't actually have to do.
I know, that's a prompt for a middle school discussion of copyright, but that doesn't mean it's not an important question. Indeed, we have a whole cultural and legal mechanism that allows us to "own" ideas, but the very concept of intellectual property has a far from clear history. Even today, there is a large ideological rift between open intellectual and artistic resources on the one hand and proprietary resources on the other (and, as is common in such debates, the more "practical" side of the argument has co-opted the language of the more idealistic, so that things like Facebook, Twitter, and Google get called "open" when they decidedly are not).
Long before any modern debate, however, Plato confronted the very issue, matter-of-factly stating that, when it comes down to it, owning an idea is essentially impossible. As soon as you hear someone else's idea, understand it, and express it to yourself, it becomes yours. And thank goodness, because the number of original ideas floating around is very small (and those few truly original ideas that do exist are likely insane). There's a particular myopia in believing that any of our ideas have never been thought of before or elsewhere, or even that seemingly new ideas don't come from a huge, continuous background set of repeated ideas. The world is, after all, very old, and people have been on it - and have spoken and written - for a great many generations. There are, at present, well over 6 billion people on the Earth. So show me a completely original idea. And, what's more, show me an idea that is owned.
Of course, we have a cultural and economic model - as I mentioned - for "owning" ideas, but it has nothing to do with where ideas come from. Intellectual property, like the first forays into physical property, is the domain of the socially and culturally adept. Indeed, one might look at the University (or the Record Label, for that matter) not as a way of generating new thoughts, but as a way of ensuring that you publish your thoughts, protecting your intellectual property. It doesn't matter that most researchers in every field are heavily dependent upon each other and upon the mass of research and theory that predates them, because they have a system of intellectual property built around them to keep all but the most determined students out. Participating in the free flow of ideas in academia, in other words, comes at great cost (all of the journals and reviews and books that academics are forced to produce so that, ironically, their employers can afford to pay for all of the journals and reviews and books they need to provide their faculty). Some academics fight this commercialized view of ideas, but it's a tough fight. After all, their own survival depends, to large degree, on their intellectual property.
Owning ideas, however, contributes to social injustice. When access to the best and brightest is limited to the most able to pay, it's no wonder that rich begets rich and poor begets poor. Meritocracy is maintained, perhaps, in the sense that it is much easier to become a meritorious leader when starting off able to afford and willing to pursue an education. The "American Dream" notwithstanding, there is a strong sense of caste in the United States that rests, in most part, upon our inability to provide free access to the one resource most at the heart of learning: ideas (we might also say wisdom, but that's a more complicated word).
From an individualistic perspective, there seems little point in coming up with ideas if other people have already had them (unless, of course, other people didn't publish them), but that seems to me a mistake. A society with open access to ideas will perhaps produce more redundancy, but will also therefore produce a citizenry ready and able to adapt their thinking to particular situations. New ideas may be few, but the peculiarities of any one problem may require a precise combination of ideas (and skills) heretofore untried. At the very least, the processes (and there are many) of problem solving are ideas that no one should "own," and yet problem solving is so rarely taught.
Ultimately, we are all constrained by the culture of intellectual property, but I believe it is worth it to ask questions of the system sometimes. Indeed, if there was more critical reflection going around, we might find that much of what we do "because we have to," we don't actually have to do.
Labels:
academia,
culture,
ideas,
intellectual property,
ownership,
Plato,
publishing
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)