This weekend I drove up from Huntington Beach back to Palo Alto to work as a coach at the Challenge Success fall conference. It's a long drive, and I must admit it was somewhat surreal being back on Stanford's campus for the two days of the conference. Stanford is the kind of place that exists in a bubble, mostly out of time. The inside of the School of Education building, in particular, looks almost exactly as it did when I first arrived at Stanford in 2009, and it probably looked the same in 1979. My sense of awkward familiarity was aided, of course, by the presence of my picture on the "current doctoral students" wall and my still-extant mailbox in the basement (it even had mail in it). Since I'm technically "on leave" I shouldn't have been surprised, but I've become so invested in my new job at LePort that it's hard to remember that part of my identity which is, still, Paul Franz, Stanford PhD Student.
This dual identity was particularly in play while coaching. It is my Stanford background, not my teaching background, that brought me to Challenge Success. Being a teacher has made me a much better coach and facilitator, but it's my connection to educational research and best practice that makes me a quality - and indeed even minimally qualified - coach for CS sessions.
Challenge Success is a non-profit co-founded by Denise Pope, Madeline Levine, and Jim Lobdell. It grew out of what was at the time a very small but poignant strain of research which suggested that "successful" students around the country were actually stressed-out, unhealthy, and unhappy, and furthermore often engaged in manipulation and cheating. Denise's Doing School is an excellent ethnographic study that chronicles the problem. The goal of CS is to address this issue by coaching schools through a process which will help them implement research-based practices to reduce student stress and increase overall well being. At its core, this implies a culture shift away from a strict, zero-sum mentality in which success equals GPA and elite college enrollment to a more holistic view which includes honoring balance and non-academic (or non-traditional academic) achievements.
The suite of policy changes which Challenge Success schools have implemented over the past 10 years is expansive. For example, schools have switched to block schedules or added late days, implemented policies limiting homework, moved towards more authentic or project-based assessments, set aside more time for faculty collaboration (because it's not only successful students that can be over-stressed), started regular parent education programs, and countless other efforts.
It's truly inspiring to be even a small part of a conversation at a school trying to make radical cultural or structural change. The school I coached last year has been trying very hard to implement a test calendar and associated policies, and is now looking to start a series of regular teacher-to-teacher observations with a particular lens on how homework assignments are used in class, all in an effort to increase the quality of homework while decreasing its quantity. My new school this year already plans to pilot a block schedule, but their larger goals are deeply cultural: they want to take on the zero-sum culture of success that they feel has harmed their school community and taken the joy out of learning for their students.
Part of what is so effective about Challenge Success is that, as a coach, it is not my job to advocate wholesale restructuring on day one. Coaching is a process of gently guiding teams towards solutions that will most address their particular contexts, and which will have the largest impact while still remaining feasible in implementation. Tackling a deep-seated school culture problem starts with minor reforms, and with building a community of parents, teachers, students, and administrators who can work together to reach larger goals in the long term. Ultimately, it is the commitment of schools and the stakeholders therein (and, indeed, all of the stakeholders therein) that leads to the success of reform efforts.
As you might imagine, participating in this kind of conference required a pretty significant mind-shift for me after my first month teaching 8th graders. I was amused by how similar running a discussion with administrators, teachers, parents, and students was to running one of my literature discussions, but the content is so different, and the objectives so differently scaled. In my class, I'm trying to make a deep impact on each and every one of 13 students. As a coach, I'm trying to facilitate a process which will impact potentially hundreds (or thousands) of students, and many hundreds (or thousands) of adults, but my particular impact on any one person is immeasurably small. Both kinds of efforts - deep and narrow, and shallow and broad - are important, I think, and they are equally difficult to do well, but the concern with the individual that lies at the heart of teaching simply can't express itself in the same way in the coaching environment.
I'm satisfied that I get to experience both. I'm particularly satisfied because, after spending the weekend talking to people from schools other than LePort, I have an even deeper appreciation for how special my new employer is. Almost every significant, research-based solution that Challenge Success advocates is already in effect at LePort. We use a block schedule. Teachers have time to prepare and to plan, and are engaged in a culture of near-constant observation, feedback, and growth. Homework is minimal and always purposeful, and students have an hour-long homework period at the end of the day after classes are completed. Parent communication and education is one of LePort's greatest strengths. Above all, an emphasis on allowing each student to define their own success - rather than holding every student to the exact same, externally determined standard - is one of our core tenets. I may be the only person who has any kind of intimate knowledge of both Challenge Success and LePort, and it strikes me how much they share for two organizations with no contact. Then again, I likely wouldn't have ended up at LePort if it didn't embody the philosophies and employ the policies that I came to hold dear in my time at Stanford and with CS.
After even a month at LePort it has become easy for me to take for granted that LePort is how a school runs, but returning to the outside world - and returning, in particular, to Stanford at a conference attended by many of the best independent and public schools in California - I was reminded that, if LePort is not wholly unique, it's close. Even most elite schools still carry with them, at the end of the day, the legacy of "this is how education is done" and "this is what success means." I'm fortunate to teach somewhere that doesn't need to attend a Challenge Success conference because they got it right from the start.
On a personal note, I also took heart from a conversation I had in passing with Denise during the busy conference day. Often I felt somewhat out of place, this weekend, because I was no longer a researcher. Wandering around Stanford, it was easy to get caught up in Stanford's culture of success: high-quality, impactful, well-funded research leading to a tenure-track position at an elite institution. That's a path I've put aside, and however much I am satisfied with my choice, a part of me still wants to paint my decision to leave Stanford as a failure on my part, instead of as a healthy response to an untenable emotional situation. When I ran into Denise she sent me the message I needed to hear, surrounded as I was by the Academy writ large. In so many words, her message was that success isn't just about a degree from a prestigious university. She asked me how I felt about teaching, and I told her that I was having a blast, and loving it every day. "Good," she said, "I always knew you would. I'm so happy you found your place." I replied, with a smile, "Me too."
Showing posts with label Stanford. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stanford. Show all posts
Sunday, September 28, 2014
Monday, December 30, 2013
Pursuing a Dream
Today I am a fool. Today I am happy. Today I am stressed and depressed. Today, for the first time in ages, I have hope for my own future.
Today I decided, after months of frustration, countless tears, too many fits of rage, and the worst apathetic bouts of self-loathing and depression I've ever had that I will withdraw from my PhD program at Stanford University.
This is a stupid decision, because I have no job lined up, and no particular prospects for a job. I'm leaving another year and a half of guaranteed funding on the table, and the security that comes with a Stanford degree. Granted, I already have a Master's from Stanford, but a PhD opens more doors, I'm told. The problem for me is that getting a PhD also closes doors. Heck, working on getting a PhD has closed too many doors for me already.
What I'm going to do is this: I'm going to stream video games on Twitch. I have no regular viewers, and there are hundreds (if not thousands) of others who are trying to do exactly this. It's a rough-and-tumble, competitive world (but no more so than the academy), and there is no guarantee of success. And, frankly, success is not a six-figure income and a cushy 35-hour work week. Success as a streamer means hard work for, if I'm lucky, a living wage.
That said, there are other things I can do, too. I have designed, in principal, three games that I simply haven't had time to make. As with streaming, there is no guarantee that any of those three games will sell, and it will be a lot of work to build each of them (one is a board game, which is feasible; the other two are computer games, which means I need to learn to code). I am also a writer - or I used to be - and I believe my streaming could easily turn into a book if I do it right. Would such a book sell? Maybe, maybe not. Finally, I used to be something of a musician. I stopped practicing regularly when I became a PhD student, but somewhere in my brain is enough musical skill to gig at least semi-regularly. Can I make a living, or a part of one, playing music? Maybe, maybe not.
So why give up the prospect of a cushy professorship for an uncertain career as an entertainer and artist? Because being a PhD student has made me miserable, and because I would rather be true to myself and take a chance at pursuing my actual passions than pursue a path which I know ends in unhappiness and cynicism. I am at heart a joyful person, but I have not felt joyful in years. Today, for the first time in I don't know how long, I feel some semblance of that joy.
But I'm also afraid. Realistically, the next few months (or years) will be trying, and expensive. I'm giving up a fairly stable existence for a highly uncertain one, and that's terrifying. And on top of that, because I'm going to pursue my dreams, if I fail the failure will hurt all the more. But I'd rather fail in pursuing my dreams than succeed in denying them. I know what the latter feels like, and it sucks. The cold logic of practicality, the harsh reality of 70 hour work week after 70 hour work week, all doing work for which I have no passion, with no end in sight. Why choose that? I'd rather work 100 hours a week on something I care about than even 30 on something I don't.
And, you know what, I will succeed. It will hurt, letting down all of my friends and family who wanted me to get a PhD. It will be hard streaming with 2 or 3 - or 0 - people watching. It will upset me when I write a blog post or post a YouTube video that gets no views. I will despair when no one buys my first board game, when my first computer game languishes unsold and unsellable. But in time I will succeed, because I will work hard, I will have a passion for what I do, and I will do a good job. I will bring something new and different to the world of casting, and I will do it with joy.
Writing all this is a little surreal. I guess I've let "PhD student" become a part of my identity. Cutting it away is strange, scary. Even if it's a part of my identity that has caused me no end of stress, frustration, and sadness, it's hard to let go. Perhaps that's why I've waited so long to take this step: I've been afraid to lose a part of who I am. Now, as I start to shed the burden of being a PhD student, I can see that I'm gaining so much more. And I also see that I have learned valuable things at Stanford. I'm a more systematic and rigorous thinker. I'm a more careful writer. I'm more skeptical, more aware of the nature of evidence, more scientific. All of those things will serve me as I take on a new identity, an identity that, deep down, is the truest I've ever tried on.
I am not a researcher. I am a gamer, a writer, a musician, and a designer. It's time for me to live my life. Oh friends, not these tones. Let us sing yet more joyfully.
Today I decided, after months of frustration, countless tears, too many fits of rage, and the worst apathetic bouts of self-loathing and depression I've ever had that I will withdraw from my PhD program at Stanford University.
This is a stupid decision, because I have no job lined up, and no particular prospects for a job. I'm leaving another year and a half of guaranteed funding on the table, and the security that comes with a Stanford degree. Granted, I already have a Master's from Stanford, but a PhD opens more doors, I'm told. The problem for me is that getting a PhD also closes doors. Heck, working on getting a PhD has closed too many doors for me already.
What I'm going to do is this: I'm going to stream video games on Twitch. I have no regular viewers, and there are hundreds (if not thousands) of others who are trying to do exactly this. It's a rough-and-tumble, competitive world (but no more so than the academy), and there is no guarantee of success. And, frankly, success is not a six-figure income and a cushy 35-hour work week. Success as a streamer means hard work for, if I'm lucky, a living wage.
That said, there are other things I can do, too. I have designed, in principal, three games that I simply haven't had time to make. As with streaming, there is no guarantee that any of those three games will sell, and it will be a lot of work to build each of them (one is a board game, which is feasible; the other two are computer games, which means I need to learn to code). I am also a writer - or I used to be - and I believe my streaming could easily turn into a book if I do it right. Would such a book sell? Maybe, maybe not. Finally, I used to be something of a musician. I stopped practicing regularly when I became a PhD student, but somewhere in my brain is enough musical skill to gig at least semi-regularly. Can I make a living, or a part of one, playing music? Maybe, maybe not.
So why give up the prospect of a cushy professorship for an uncertain career as an entertainer and artist? Because being a PhD student has made me miserable, and because I would rather be true to myself and take a chance at pursuing my actual passions than pursue a path which I know ends in unhappiness and cynicism. I am at heart a joyful person, but I have not felt joyful in years. Today, for the first time in I don't know how long, I feel some semblance of that joy.
But I'm also afraid. Realistically, the next few months (or years) will be trying, and expensive. I'm giving up a fairly stable existence for a highly uncertain one, and that's terrifying. And on top of that, because I'm going to pursue my dreams, if I fail the failure will hurt all the more. But I'd rather fail in pursuing my dreams than succeed in denying them. I know what the latter feels like, and it sucks. The cold logic of practicality, the harsh reality of 70 hour work week after 70 hour work week, all doing work for which I have no passion, with no end in sight. Why choose that? I'd rather work 100 hours a week on something I care about than even 30 on something I don't.
And, you know what, I will succeed. It will hurt, letting down all of my friends and family who wanted me to get a PhD. It will be hard streaming with 2 or 3 - or 0 - people watching. It will upset me when I write a blog post or post a YouTube video that gets no views. I will despair when no one buys my first board game, when my first computer game languishes unsold and unsellable. But in time I will succeed, because I will work hard, I will have a passion for what I do, and I will do a good job. I will bring something new and different to the world of casting, and I will do it with joy.
Writing all this is a little surreal. I guess I've let "PhD student" become a part of my identity. Cutting it away is strange, scary. Even if it's a part of my identity that has caused me no end of stress, frustration, and sadness, it's hard to let go. Perhaps that's why I've waited so long to take this step: I've been afraid to lose a part of who I am. Now, as I start to shed the burden of being a PhD student, I can see that I'm gaining so much more. And I also see that I have learned valuable things at Stanford. I'm a more systematic and rigorous thinker. I'm a more careful writer. I'm more skeptical, more aware of the nature of evidence, more scientific. All of those things will serve me as I take on a new identity, an identity that, deep down, is the truest I've ever tried on.
I am not a researcher. I am a gamer, a writer, a musician, and a designer. It's time for me to live my life. Oh friends, not these tones. Let us sing yet more joyfully.
Thursday, February 2, 2012
On Choosing to Learn
In my Learning Sciences and Technology Design seminar we recently read a draft of an upcoming book by Dan Schwartz, a Professor here at Stanford. He argues that we need to reconsider our assumptions about assessment in order to better capture the things we actually care about as educators. Instead of evaluating student knowledge, understanding, or even skills, he argues, we should try to assess student choices. That is, what a information or skills a student knows, and even her ability to learn further information or skills is not as important as the decision to learn.
That choices are central to how we move through the world is perhaps obvious, but it is striking how infrequently choice is a core part of any assessment framework (multiple-choice tests certainly do not count as "choice" in the sense that Dr. Schwartz means it). Even forward-thinking educators tend to focus more on acquisition of skills or overly-ambiguous notions of "metacognition" or "critical thinking" than on the specifics of decision making. And specifics are the keys. "Making good choices" is as bad a curricular goal as "being able to organize the following events chronologically." A better option is a synthesis of the two, perhaps something to the effect of: "Given the task of explaining a historical event, choosing to organize parts of that event chronologically."
It seems to me that little education - indeed, even little of my own education, excellent though it has been - is organized around this kind of formulation. I believe that the most successful students end up adopting good strategies and making good choices, but Denise Pope's Doing School (about which I've written previously) suggests that a great many of our most successful students (if grades are our standard for success) in fact make terrible choices, ethically, academically, and even physically.
For my own part, I am struck by how often the schools I've attended - even Stanford - have not only tacitly accepted but in fact actively encouraged poor choices and unhealthy habits. And I don't just mean ambiguous moral choices, but concrete habits of mind and academic practice. For example, in spite of Stanford's ostensible lack of concern over grades, their various administrative policy practically forces students to waste hours of time engaged in a gamey calculus over which courses to take credit/no-credit, and which to take for a grade. If I choose not to engage in this practice, I put myself at a disadvantage in terms of various small-scale political interactions that are inevitable in a graduate school. On the other hand, the process itself, besides consuming intellectual energy better spend elsewhere, has undesirable effects on the way students engage with the particular courses they are not taking for a grade and the way professors engage with those students.
In other words, by separating this seemingly administrative cultural artifact from the curriculum, we've set up a situation where knowledge and skills are within the purview of the course, but where the most important actual decision making is made at an institutional level. In graduate school - which is at least theoretically preparation for a life in the academy - this is perhaps not overly troubling, but as we shift our gaze to undergraduate or k-12 education, it's easy to see that students are often well-taught to make bad learning choices by the broader curricula and institutions in which they find themselves. My rule of thumb for this kind of supposition is simple: if Stanford's graduate programs have a fundamental pedagogical or curricular problem, odds are that same problem can be found - and, indeed, is probably worse - at earlier stages of the education system.
So what is there to do? Unfortunately, it seems to me that this problem is virtually intractable in our current education system because it is endemic not merely to our curricula and pedagogy, but to our very culture, our policies, our institutions, and even our economics. That is, there is a good reason we teach bad choices in schools: because our political, economic, and social systems are built upon the majority of people making bad choices.
That choices are central to how we move through the world is perhaps obvious, but it is striking how infrequently choice is a core part of any assessment framework (multiple-choice tests certainly do not count as "choice" in the sense that Dr. Schwartz means it). Even forward-thinking educators tend to focus more on acquisition of skills or overly-ambiguous notions of "metacognition" or "critical thinking" than on the specifics of decision making. And specifics are the keys. "Making good choices" is as bad a curricular goal as "being able to organize the following events chronologically." A better option is a synthesis of the two, perhaps something to the effect of: "Given the task of explaining a historical event, choosing to organize parts of that event chronologically."
It seems to me that little education - indeed, even little of my own education, excellent though it has been - is organized around this kind of formulation. I believe that the most successful students end up adopting good strategies and making good choices, but Denise Pope's Doing School (about which I've written previously) suggests that a great many of our most successful students (if grades are our standard for success) in fact make terrible choices, ethically, academically, and even physically.
For my own part, I am struck by how often the schools I've attended - even Stanford - have not only tacitly accepted but in fact actively encouraged poor choices and unhealthy habits. And I don't just mean ambiguous moral choices, but concrete habits of mind and academic practice. For example, in spite of Stanford's ostensible lack of concern over grades, their various administrative policy practically forces students to waste hours of time engaged in a gamey calculus over which courses to take credit/no-credit, and which to take for a grade. If I choose not to engage in this practice, I put myself at a disadvantage in terms of various small-scale political interactions that are inevitable in a graduate school. On the other hand, the process itself, besides consuming intellectual energy better spend elsewhere, has undesirable effects on the way students engage with the particular courses they are not taking for a grade and the way professors engage with those students.
In other words, by separating this seemingly administrative cultural artifact from the curriculum, we've set up a situation where knowledge and skills are within the purview of the course, but where the most important actual decision making is made at an institutional level. In graduate school - which is at least theoretically preparation for a life in the academy - this is perhaps not overly troubling, but as we shift our gaze to undergraduate or k-12 education, it's easy to see that students are often well-taught to make bad learning choices by the broader curricula and institutions in which they find themselves. My rule of thumb for this kind of supposition is simple: if Stanford's graduate programs have a fundamental pedagogical or curricular problem, odds are that same problem can be found - and, indeed, is probably worse - at earlier stages of the education system.
So what is there to do? Unfortunately, it seems to me that this problem is virtually intractable in our current education system because it is endemic not merely to our curricula and pedagogy, but to our very culture, our policies, our institutions, and even our economics. That is, there is a good reason we teach bad choices in schools: because our political, economic, and social systems are built upon the majority of people making bad choices.
Labels:
academia,
assessment,
choices,
culture,
Dan Schwartz,
denise pope,
Education,
LSTD,
society,
Stanford
Monday, November 21, 2011
Questions for the Liberal Arts Major
The title is a bit misleading here. Basically, I'm working on drafting a dialogue (of all things) about the future of liberal arts education for my "Future of English Studies" course. The goal is, in short, to reimagine the St. John's College Great Books program - or something like it - with an eye towards important modern concepts like multiculturalism and technology. The fundamental question is, how much do you lose from the radical dialogic pedagogy of the college in modernizing it (or post-modernizing* it, I guess).
* Post-modernism still makes me viscerally uncomfortable, even as I recognize that almost everyone - including myself - with any semblance of education in the modern world believes in it implicitly. Truth is relative? Of course. Context matters? Duh. Moral sensibilities have more to do with culture than with eternal, Platonic forms? Yeah, I guess so. That doesn't change, though, that I also dislike post-modernism. I think this is in part due to its horrible name. Someone should have foreseen a problem with future naming of philosophical movements when they called their own time "modern." Someone else should have realized that calling the next movement "post-modernism" was also silly. What comes next? Post-post-modernism?
The goal in this post is not to write my draft, but to pose questions. That is, I don't even plan on trying to answer or discuss those questions here: that's what the dialogue will do. I just want to pose questions. So without further ado, here are, in no particular order, questions for the liberal arts major:
- Is it desirable for every student in a college to share a reading list with every other student?
- Is it possible to share a reading list in a multicultural curriculum?
- What makes for a good classroom discussion, and how important is a shared reading list - or even a shared reading - to that project?
- How could a St. John's-like program teach writing effectively without abandoning its pedagogical roots?
- What is more important to St. John's pedagogy: the illusion of equality in the classroom, the apparent absence of grades, the commitment to the shared reading (and no outside sources), or the participation of a sufficient percentage of the students in the class?
- How many students and tutors is ideal?
- What is the purpose of a liberal arts education? How can we justify it in the modern world?
- Could St. John's work as a multicultural institution? That is, is it merely the reading list, or is it the entire structure that is racist and sexist? (Can the subaltern speak?)
- Indeed, is higher education in general (not just St. John's) not culturally hegemonic?
- What subjects should make up "tutorials?" At St. John's we do Math, Laboratory, Music, and Language. Are these the best options? What is the goal of the tutorial?
- If Husserl's "Crisis of the European Sciences" organizes the traditional St. John's, what text or texts would best organize a modern St. John's?
- How should a student be assessed in a dialogic classroom?
- Is it possible to just update the reading list and keep everything else about St. John's the same?
- If we did update the reading list, what would be thrown out or condensed, and what would be added? Isn't it too ironic to have a multicultural, post-modern canon?
- What about increasingly prominent non-textual works of art and philosophy, like movies, documentaries, albums, and born-digital documents like blogs or video games? What would it mean to study these, and would it be possible to do so in a dialogic classroom?
- Can elements of the St. John's program be recreated online?
- What would a fully digital St. John's seminar look like; what would it gain over the traditional model, and what would it lose?
- How important is the credential to a liberal arts education? Practically and theoretically.
- How should questions like these even be decided? That is, how should a modern liberal arts program be run politically and socially?
I'm sure I could pose more questions, but this seems to me a good start. Of course, if you have any thoughts, I'm happy to hear them.
* Post-modernism still makes me viscerally uncomfortable, even as I recognize that almost everyone - including myself - with any semblance of education in the modern world believes in it implicitly. Truth is relative? Of course. Context matters? Duh. Moral sensibilities have more to do with culture than with eternal, Platonic forms? Yeah, I guess so. That doesn't change, though, that I also dislike post-modernism. I think this is in part due to its horrible name. Someone should have foreseen a problem with future naming of philosophical movements when they called their own time "modern." Someone else should have realized that calling the next movement "post-modernism" was also silly. What comes next? Post-post-modernism?
The goal in this post is not to write my draft, but to pose questions. That is, I don't even plan on trying to answer or discuss those questions here: that's what the dialogue will do. I just want to pose questions. So without further ado, here are, in no particular order, questions for the liberal arts major:
- Is it desirable for every student in a college to share a reading list with every other student?
- Is it possible to share a reading list in a multicultural curriculum?
- What makes for a good classroom discussion, and how important is a shared reading list - or even a shared reading - to that project?
- How could a St. John's-like program teach writing effectively without abandoning its pedagogical roots?
- What is more important to St. John's pedagogy: the illusion of equality in the classroom, the apparent absence of grades, the commitment to the shared reading (and no outside sources), or the participation of a sufficient percentage of the students in the class?
- How many students and tutors is ideal?
- What is the purpose of a liberal arts education? How can we justify it in the modern world?
- Could St. John's work as a multicultural institution? That is, is it merely the reading list, or is it the entire structure that is racist and sexist? (Can the subaltern speak?)
- Indeed, is higher education in general (not just St. John's) not culturally hegemonic?
- What subjects should make up "tutorials?" At St. John's we do Math, Laboratory, Music, and Language. Are these the best options? What is the goal of the tutorial?
- If Husserl's "Crisis of the European Sciences" organizes the traditional St. John's, what text or texts would best organize a modern St. John's?
- How should a student be assessed in a dialogic classroom?
- Is it possible to just update the reading list and keep everything else about St. John's the same?
- If we did update the reading list, what would be thrown out or condensed, and what would be added? Isn't it too ironic to have a multicultural, post-modern canon?
- What about increasingly prominent non-textual works of art and philosophy, like movies, documentaries, albums, and born-digital documents like blogs or video games? What would it mean to study these, and would it be possible to do so in a dialogic classroom?
- Can elements of the St. John's program be recreated online?
- What would a fully digital St. John's seminar look like; what would it gain over the traditional model, and what would it lose?
- How important is the credential to a liberal arts education? Practically and theoretically.
- How should questions like these even be decided? That is, how should a modern liberal arts program be run politically and socially?
I'm sure I could pose more questions, but this seems to me a good start. Of course, if you have any thoughts, I'm happy to hear them.
Labels:
classes,
dialogue,
Education,
higher education,
pedagogy,
personal,
St. John's,
Stanford
Monday, November 7, 2011
Reading Asterios Polyp's Chart
In my "Future of English Studies" course this week we read David Mazzucchelli's Asterios Polyp. It's a wonderful graphic novel that you should go read. Then you can come back and read this post. I'll do my best, as always, to explain my astrological analysis in non-astrological terms.
Doing a natal chart for a fictional character is always tricky business, but in the case of Asterios Polyp I feel justified. The book itself draws attention to Asterios's birthday and sign, as one of his key companions in the story is a self-proclaimed "Goddess" who studies astrology and, hilariously, lets Asterios know not to worry "if you fall in love with me, everyone does." She's a Pisces, we're told, but she must be an Aquarius cusp or a Leo rising the way she comes across in the book. She's, uh, forward. And one of only two other characters as opinionated as Asterios.
While Asterios, as a rational thinker, dismisses astrology and its nebulous determinations and interpretations, I thought it might be interesting to see whether his chart tells us anything more about him than "he's a Cancer-Gemini cusp." Now, the book tells us a few things - birth date, and a number of significant life events - but it gives no time or place, so we have to do a little rectification. Guessing at place is easy enough. Asterios lives and works in New York, and his parents are immigrants from Eastern Europe (hence the "Polyp," a shortening of a longer, presumably Greek, name). Assuming that Asterios was born in New York City seems safe enough.
Time is a little trickier. I ended up deciding on 5AM, for a number of reasons. First off, we learn that Asterios is born a twin - his brother dies - after a 30+ hour labor. For whatever reason, I imagine the doctor's decision to perform a c-section as happening at the end of a second long night of labor. As for astrological reasons, the first argument for this birth time is that it puts most of Asterios's planets on the Eastern side of his chart. Asterios is a fairly self-absorbed character who, moreover, is an architect used to shaping his own world. That jives better with Eastern hemisphere of self-determination than Western. Moreover, we learn that Asterios has not yet designed something that was actually built, so he's more of a theoretical architect. That his Northern hemisphere is stronger than his Southern with a 5AM birth time supports this facet of his personality: despite his vociferousness and manifest brilliance, much of his work (Saturn) remains below the horizon (in the fourth house).
The other virtues of a 5AM birth time include a Piscean midheaven, supported by the positive and, I think, transformative relationship he has with our aforementioned Goddess and her family. Also, Sagittarius - the sign of philosophy and higher education - fills most of the 6th house of work, another sensible configuration given that Asterios works in Academia. Finally, and most importantly, this birth time puts his Sun in Cancer in the first house, but keeps his ascendant as Gemini. The book as a whole is largely concerned with how Asterios deals with duality, and so a Gemini ascendant makes sense, as does a first house Sun, as Asterios is extremely self-absorbed for much of the book (it is worth noting that he is a progressed Leo, too, making him something of a showman).
Ultimately, we can't rely too heavily on the houses here, despite how sensible the rectified chart looks. Nevertheless, they can serve as guideposts for interpreting the signs and planets.
Without further ado, here's the chart.
I won't go into too much detail here. There's a lot here and, to even my surprise, it fits Asterios extremely well. Indeed, the chart's correlation to what we know about Asterios as a character is strong enough that I wonder whether Mazzucchelli consulted an astrologer while he was writing. Anyway, let's look at the highlights. What really jumps out here?
Short (technical) answer: T-Squares. Big, messy t-squares. Mercury in Gemini squares a Saturn-Moon Conjunction, Squares Chairon. Indeed, throw in Jupiter and you're on the verge of a Grand Cross.
Non-technical answer: Asterios has serious conflict and difficult in his chart. His workmanlike attitude belies the difficulty he has in translating his work into reality. Nevertheless, he's so deeply invested in what he does that he makes it a part of his home. He has a strong aesthetic that he must see realized in his home, and even slight deviation from his expected and desired order of things is profoundly upsetting to him.
This quality he has a hard time expressing and understanding, tending to overwhelm his interlocutors precisely because he's not as self-assured as he seems. He struggles to communicate how deeply he is what he does and says. That is, ideas are not merely ideas to Asterios, but are rather a core part of his personality. This multi-faceted sense of self is so upsetting to Asterios that he subsumes it in his subconscious, refusing to realize that the way he lives is peculiar and personal, instead externalizing it as a philosophical position.
Because of this internal conflict, duality takes the place of complexity in Asterios's thought. In a beautiful piece of astrological serendipity, Chairon sets off both the internal and external senses of self with a deep, personal wound. For Asterios, this wound is his dead brother. Indeed, his splitting the world into dualities is his attempt to heal the loss of his twin. Not only that, in healing himself - so he thinks - he finds a means by which he might heal others. That is, he can bring them a simplifying dualism.
That Asterios does not understand that dualism is, of course, the irony at the heart of his character, and the quality that sets the plot in motion. The story is very much an effort by Asterios to better connect with complexity. Fittingly, this is represented by the place to which his t-cross opens up: Pisces in the 10th house. Asterios has Jupiter - a planet of growth - in Pisces, and it is no surprise that his growth throughout the book is both Piscean - in the sense of embracing emotional complexity - and social, as signified by the 10th house.
There are other interesting aspects in Asterios's chart, but this t-cross (which is nearly a grand cross) is really the heart of the thing. How well it fits perhaps raises a question: how much am I mapping the book onto the chart, and how much am I mapping the chart onto the book? That is, which is prior?
The answer, of course, is neither. Yes, my familiarity with Asterios as a character colors my reading of his chart, but should I know nothing about him, I would come to similar, if more abstract, conclusions. The forces at work here - the important planets, signs, and houses - have very broad meanings that, nevertheless, are narrow enough to allow only particular interpretations. That the events of Asterios Polyp fit so well with that interpretive baseline, yielding a rich, specific chart seems to me no accident.
Now, the question is, does this tell us anything about Asterios we didn't already know? Perhaps not. But it does give me a different language through which I might explain the things I sensed in reading. Just like writing a reflection on a text, doing a chart might open up linguistic and artistic interpretive pathways that would otherwise stay closed.
To the skeptic, then, that opening up of new pathways is the value of astrology. It is not about fate. It is about understanding.
Doing a natal chart for a fictional character is always tricky business, but in the case of Asterios Polyp I feel justified. The book itself draws attention to Asterios's birthday and sign, as one of his key companions in the story is a self-proclaimed "Goddess" who studies astrology and, hilariously, lets Asterios know not to worry "if you fall in love with me, everyone does." She's a Pisces, we're told, but she must be an Aquarius cusp or a Leo rising the way she comes across in the book. She's, uh, forward. And one of only two other characters as opinionated as Asterios.
While Asterios, as a rational thinker, dismisses astrology and its nebulous determinations and interpretations, I thought it might be interesting to see whether his chart tells us anything more about him than "he's a Cancer-Gemini cusp." Now, the book tells us a few things - birth date, and a number of significant life events - but it gives no time or place, so we have to do a little rectification. Guessing at place is easy enough. Asterios lives and works in New York, and his parents are immigrants from Eastern Europe (hence the "Polyp," a shortening of a longer, presumably Greek, name). Assuming that Asterios was born in New York City seems safe enough.
Time is a little trickier. I ended up deciding on 5AM, for a number of reasons. First off, we learn that Asterios is born a twin - his brother dies - after a 30+ hour labor. For whatever reason, I imagine the doctor's decision to perform a c-section as happening at the end of a second long night of labor. As for astrological reasons, the first argument for this birth time is that it puts most of Asterios's planets on the Eastern side of his chart. Asterios is a fairly self-absorbed character who, moreover, is an architect used to shaping his own world. That jives better with Eastern hemisphere of self-determination than Western. Moreover, we learn that Asterios has not yet designed something that was actually built, so he's more of a theoretical architect. That his Northern hemisphere is stronger than his Southern with a 5AM birth time supports this facet of his personality: despite his vociferousness and manifest brilliance, much of his work (Saturn) remains below the horizon (in the fourth house).
The other virtues of a 5AM birth time include a Piscean midheaven, supported by the positive and, I think, transformative relationship he has with our aforementioned Goddess and her family. Also, Sagittarius - the sign of philosophy and higher education - fills most of the 6th house of work, another sensible configuration given that Asterios works in Academia. Finally, and most importantly, this birth time puts his Sun in Cancer in the first house, but keeps his ascendant as Gemini. The book as a whole is largely concerned with how Asterios deals with duality, and so a Gemini ascendant makes sense, as does a first house Sun, as Asterios is extremely self-absorbed for much of the book (it is worth noting that he is a progressed Leo, too, making him something of a showman).
Ultimately, we can't rely too heavily on the houses here, despite how sensible the rectified chart looks. Nevertheless, they can serve as guideposts for interpreting the signs and planets.
Without further ado, here's the chart.
![]() |
| Asterios Polyp Rectified Chart - Generated by OpenAstro |
I won't go into too much detail here. There's a lot here and, to even my surprise, it fits Asterios extremely well. Indeed, the chart's correlation to what we know about Asterios as a character is strong enough that I wonder whether Mazzucchelli consulted an astrologer while he was writing. Anyway, let's look at the highlights. What really jumps out here?
Short (technical) answer: T-Squares. Big, messy t-squares. Mercury in Gemini squares a Saturn-Moon Conjunction, Squares Chairon. Indeed, throw in Jupiter and you're on the verge of a Grand Cross.
Non-technical answer: Asterios has serious conflict and difficult in his chart. His workmanlike attitude belies the difficulty he has in translating his work into reality. Nevertheless, he's so deeply invested in what he does that he makes it a part of his home. He has a strong aesthetic that he must see realized in his home, and even slight deviation from his expected and desired order of things is profoundly upsetting to him.
This quality he has a hard time expressing and understanding, tending to overwhelm his interlocutors precisely because he's not as self-assured as he seems. He struggles to communicate how deeply he is what he does and says. That is, ideas are not merely ideas to Asterios, but are rather a core part of his personality. This multi-faceted sense of self is so upsetting to Asterios that he subsumes it in his subconscious, refusing to realize that the way he lives is peculiar and personal, instead externalizing it as a philosophical position.
Because of this internal conflict, duality takes the place of complexity in Asterios's thought. In a beautiful piece of astrological serendipity, Chairon sets off both the internal and external senses of self with a deep, personal wound. For Asterios, this wound is his dead brother. Indeed, his splitting the world into dualities is his attempt to heal the loss of his twin. Not only that, in healing himself - so he thinks - he finds a means by which he might heal others. That is, he can bring them a simplifying dualism.
That Asterios does not understand that dualism is, of course, the irony at the heart of his character, and the quality that sets the plot in motion. The story is very much an effort by Asterios to better connect with complexity. Fittingly, this is represented by the place to which his t-cross opens up: Pisces in the 10th house. Asterios has Jupiter - a planet of growth - in Pisces, and it is no surprise that his growth throughout the book is both Piscean - in the sense of embracing emotional complexity - and social, as signified by the 10th house.
There are other interesting aspects in Asterios's chart, but this t-cross (which is nearly a grand cross) is really the heart of the thing. How well it fits perhaps raises a question: how much am I mapping the book onto the chart, and how much am I mapping the chart onto the book? That is, which is prior?
The answer, of course, is neither. Yes, my familiarity with Asterios as a character colors my reading of his chart, but should I know nothing about him, I would come to similar, if more abstract, conclusions. The forces at work here - the important planets, signs, and houses - have very broad meanings that, nevertheless, are narrow enough to allow only particular interpretations. That the events of Asterios Polyp fit so well with that interpretive baseline, yielding a rich, specific chart seems to me no accident.
Now, the question is, does this tell us anything about Asterios we didn't already know? Perhaps not. But it does give me a different language through which I might explain the things I sensed in reading. Just like writing a reflection on a text, doing a chart might open up linguistic and artistic interpretive pathways that would otherwise stay closed.
To the skeptic, then, that opening up of new pathways is the value of astrology. It is not about fate. It is about understanding.
Wednesday, October 12, 2011
An Alternative Pedagogy for the PhD Core
Introduction
Because my last post was a little bit negative, and perhaps somewhat dramatic,* I want to offer a constructive follow-up. Let me make explicit, first, the criticism that is really at the heart of yesterday's post. Then, I'll offer an alternative.
* I never, ever write overly-dramatic posts, do I?
The problem with my two required courses is that they are not, at least so far, good courses. One is a Doctoral Proseminar that every first year PhD student has to take. Its stated objectives are, in part, taking a broad look at the field of education research and, in part, getting to know the rest of the cohort. The other required course - the spark for yesterday's existential angst - is the first leg of a three course series of introductory research methods courses required within the first two years by all Education PhD students.
The How
How are these courses bad? Well, they are both co-taught, but there is not even a semblance of collaboration between the Professors co-teaching the courses. In both sections, one Professor gets up and lectures while the other sits around looking bored, only occasionally interjecting. At some point the Professors might switch places when the topic changes, but that's really it. There's no dynamic interaction, there's no prior planning, there's no engagement.
The lack of interaction is perhaps not damning, but the lack of student participation is. Now, a student in one of these courses might very well object that, yes, we do participate some. This is true. The lecture style in both classes is not pure, incessant blather. There is some opportunity for back-and-forth. But there is no room for dialogue, even so. The path of the "conversation" is, if not predetermined by the Professor, managed in its entirety by him.* Students don't have the opportunity to speak to each other without Professorial interpolation. That's not dialogue, that's Q&A.
* I say 'him' because three of the four Professors in question are male, and the three men are the chief pontificates.
A word on the classroom that both of these courses take place in. It's not exactly conducive to dialogue. It's basically a small-to-medium sized meeting hall, perfect for a breakfast get-together. There are a number of round tables that fit four people each, with a longer desk at the front of the room, in front of a SmartBoard (that, incidentally, none of the Professors knows how to use). At the back of the room is a blackboard. Notably, one wall contains creative artifacts made by STEP (Stanford Teacher Education Program) students, who use this same room more dynamically.
For a typical class, students will read a few articles and do a kind of preparation activity. In the Proseminar these are basically note-taking activities designed to reinforce good reading skills. In the methods course, these are writing activities, some of which have proven interesting and valuable, and others, well, yeah. My last post addresses that. Regardless, with the rare exception of some small-group work at the tables, whether a student has done the reading or not has no particular bearing on the course because the Professor simply stands around expounding about said reading for far too long, asking theoretically probing questions that the same five students answer.
In short, it's a typical University class. But what is striking is how different it is from my experience at this very University as a Master's student. It is said that the difference between the Master's level and the PhD level is that the latter is more focused on research. It seems that, in addition, because research is the important thing, pedagogy goes totally out the window as well.
A final note on the how and why of the problems with these required courses. In addition to troubling pedagogical practices, the curricula of both courses are far from compelling. There is no clear "this is what you're getting out of this class." That means that, while the assessments are fairly good, there's not a strong sense of how said assessments measure whatever it is that we as students are supposed to be learning. For example, the book review required in Proseminar may develop good habits of mind, but it does not connect in any meaningful way with the readings or the lectures, at least so far. In the methods course, we're supposed to design a study around our research interests and questions, but in the first three weeks (30% of the quarter), we've not even spoken about research questions, research design, or what makes for a good study, let alone actually done anything.*
* It's becoming a source of personal amusement that, in a certain sense, my tennis course is pedagogically superior to my other courses. Each session we show up, we warm up by working on whatever part of our skill set we want to, then the instructor shows us a new skill or a wrinkle on an old one and we go practice it for a half-hour as he wanders around giving pointers. And you know what? My ability to play tennis is improving much faster than my ability to research. I know it's not a totally fair analogy, but that doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about.
The Why
Why are these courses the way they are? Perhaps the Professors teaching these courses are doing it because they're trying to curry favor with the administration, and thus they don't want to invest in designing a strong curriculum or practicing good pedagogy. Perhaps the course curriculum, because it is designed by committee and not by the teacher, is innately unfocused. Perhaps no one has recognized the problems with the room the courses are housed in, and therefore hasn't tried to come up with a more engaging way of using the space.
Whatever the reason, at its heart is this: Stanford University, like most institutions of higher education, is primarily interested in research.* While many Professors like to teach, they frequently have little to no actual teaching training, and their jobs are in no way dependent on the quality of their teaching. Students, similarly, are generally less invested in classes** because they're wrapped up in research agendas and assistantships and meeting other requirements and trying to survive in the Bay Area on the roughly $20,000 a year they make as PhD students.
* Well, research and football, anyway.
** A quotation from a Doctoral student well-along on her path: "Your classes don't matter." In that case, I wonder, why do we have them at all?
In summary, Professors are not accountable to their employers for their teaching. They are accountable to their students, but their students don't particularly care whether they teach well or not. As a result, there's no particular motivation to improve a course, no particular need to assess whether it is "working" or not,* and no particular place for a student who does care about the quality of his courses (and the pedagogy therein) to voice concerns. It's a self-perpetuating, broken system. Except it's not broken at all: it's exactly what almost everyone involved wants it to be, which indicates that maybe the real problem is much, much deeper. But we'll have to leave that for another time.
* At Stanford in particular such an assessment would be confounded by the fact that most students here are extremely good at doing well in and taking as much as they can from poorly taught classes. Otherwise they wouldn't have made it to Stanford in the first place.
An Alternative Pedagogy
Vogon Guard: "Alright, so what's the alternative?"
Ford Prefect: "Well, stop doing it, of course! Tell them you're not going to do it anymore. Stand up to them!"
Vogon Guard: "Doesn't sound that great to me."
- Douglas Adams, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
The alternative to lecturing is, simply enough, not lecturing. The alternative to none - or few - students participating is getting them all to participate. Perhaps this is my St. John's education speaking, but I still think there's a lot to be gained from students talking to each other, and there's no reason that can't happen in these required courses.
How does that work? First of all, no more powerpoint slides. No more prepared lectures or conversational agendas. No more "this is what this article means" declarations. Questions - even pointed ones - to shape a conservation are fine, but presupposed answers are death to inquiry. If the goal is for new doctoral students to learn to interpret research, to discuss or analyze a text, and to be able to construct and argument as to what that text means, then it's imperative that they get practice at actually doing it. That does not mean "write a summary," that means dialogue, conversation, and argumentation.
So instead of two Professors trading off droning - with occasional interruption - at 30 students, let's put all of the manpower and brainpower in the classroom to work. Split the class into two groups of fifteen,* and send one Professor off with each group.** Sit in one great big circle, let the Professor ask a question about the text, and let the students work together to try to answer that question. Have, in other words, a dialogue.
* And rotate the groups around each week, so there's always a different mix in each group.
** Alternatively, split into even smaller groups - say five groups of six - and let the Professors float around, or put them into different groups each session.
Does that sound like St. John's? Of course it does. And why do I suggest it? Because it works. Stanford PhD students are smart people. If you put fifteen of them in a room with a text and ask them to figure out what it means and why it's important, odds are they're going to succeed. So why not give it a chance? They'll be developing interpretive skills, learning to talk to each other about research (which, vitally, may not even be in their area), and getting to know each other much better than they can when they're sitting four-to-a-table and being lectured at for two hours.
It is true that Professors are generally experts in these fields while students are not, but their wealth of experience does not mean that they are innately better readers than their students, or that they can say something more insightful about a text. What's more, even if they are better at those things, students will not learn simply by watching them talk. I cannot learn tennis without swinging for myself (and sometimes hitting it into the net), so how can I be expected to learn to speak to my future colleagues about research without being given a chance to do so, even if sometimes our interpretations are wrong, or we cut each other off, or we oversimplify? By doing will we learn, not by watching.
The Professor's role in this picture is to be the net. When I hit a tennis ball too short, I can tell. When I say something stupid, the Professor can chime in. But here's the really cool part: even that can be given over to students. If you let us talk to each other, we'll learn how to point out each other's mistakes, as much as highlight each other's strengths. In short, we'll form and learn to be a part of an intellectual community much like the one we're supposedly entering as future PhD-holding scholars.
Perhaps the objection could be raised that dialogue doesn't happen among Professors, either, and that therefore such a pedagogical system would not prepare students for the Academy. If that's so, then this alternative to lecturing becomes doubly important: we need academics who do more than merely pontificate, but who can actually communicate. The only way we'll get them is by training them to do so from the beginning. And anyway, it's a lot easier to transfer the ability to dialogue into giving a good lecture than the other way around.
A St. John's-ian dialogue, of course, is not the only valid alternative to a lecture class. Not all good classes are discussion classes. I do, however, pose it as a radical opposite pole. Somewhere in between is an equally good place where co-teachers actually work together, where the affordances of the room are taken into consideration when shaping the curriculum, and where the students are allowed to practice and be engaged with the material (and each other) for the whole two to three hours. Such pedagogical strategies exist. I wish that some enterprising Professor teaching a required, core course would use them.
Because my last post was a little bit negative, and perhaps somewhat dramatic,* I want to offer a constructive follow-up. Let me make explicit, first, the criticism that is really at the heart of yesterday's post. Then, I'll offer an alternative.
* I never, ever write overly-dramatic posts, do I?
The problem with my two required courses is that they are not, at least so far, good courses. One is a Doctoral Proseminar that every first year PhD student has to take. Its stated objectives are, in part, taking a broad look at the field of education research and, in part, getting to know the rest of the cohort. The other required course - the spark for yesterday's existential angst - is the first leg of a three course series of introductory research methods courses required within the first two years by all Education PhD students.
The How
How are these courses bad? Well, they are both co-taught, but there is not even a semblance of collaboration between the Professors co-teaching the courses. In both sections, one Professor gets up and lectures while the other sits around looking bored, only occasionally interjecting. At some point the Professors might switch places when the topic changes, but that's really it. There's no dynamic interaction, there's no prior planning, there's no engagement.
The lack of interaction is perhaps not damning, but the lack of student participation is. Now, a student in one of these courses might very well object that, yes, we do participate some. This is true. The lecture style in both classes is not pure, incessant blather. There is some opportunity for back-and-forth. But there is no room for dialogue, even so. The path of the "conversation" is, if not predetermined by the Professor, managed in its entirety by him.* Students don't have the opportunity to speak to each other without Professorial interpolation. That's not dialogue, that's Q&A.
* I say 'him' because three of the four Professors in question are male, and the three men are the chief pontificates.
A word on the classroom that both of these courses take place in. It's not exactly conducive to dialogue. It's basically a small-to-medium sized meeting hall, perfect for a breakfast get-together. There are a number of round tables that fit four people each, with a longer desk at the front of the room, in front of a SmartBoard (that, incidentally, none of the Professors knows how to use). At the back of the room is a blackboard. Notably, one wall contains creative artifacts made by STEP (Stanford Teacher Education Program) students, who use this same room more dynamically.
For a typical class, students will read a few articles and do a kind of preparation activity. In the Proseminar these are basically note-taking activities designed to reinforce good reading skills. In the methods course, these are writing activities, some of which have proven interesting and valuable, and others, well, yeah. My last post addresses that. Regardless, with the rare exception of some small-group work at the tables, whether a student has done the reading or not has no particular bearing on the course because the Professor simply stands around expounding about said reading for far too long, asking theoretically probing questions that the same five students answer.
In short, it's a typical University class. But what is striking is how different it is from my experience at this very University as a Master's student. It is said that the difference between the Master's level and the PhD level is that the latter is more focused on research. It seems that, in addition, because research is the important thing, pedagogy goes totally out the window as well.
A final note on the how and why of the problems with these required courses. In addition to troubling pedagogical practices, the curricula of both courses are far from compelling. There is no clear "this is what you're getting out of this class." That means that, while the assessments are fairly good, there's not a strong sense of how said assessments measure whatever it is that we as students are supposed to be learning. For example, the book review required in Proseminar may develop good habits of mind, but it does not connect in any meaningful way with the readings or the lectures, at least so far. In the methods course, we're supposed to design a study around our research interests and questions, but in the first three weeks (30% of the quarter), we've not even spoken about research questions, research design, or what makes for a good study, let alone actually done anything.*
* It's becoming a source of personal amusement that, in a certain sense, my tennis course is pedagogically superior to my other courses. Each session we show up, we warm up by working on whatever part of our skill set we want to, then the instructor shows us a new skill or a wrinkle on an old one and we go practice it for a half-hour as he wanders around giving pointers. And you know what? My ability to play tennis is improving much faster than my ability to research. I know it's not a totally fair analogy, but that doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about.
The Why
Why are these courses the way they are? Perhaps the Professors teaching these courses are doing it because they're trying to curry favor with the administration, and thus they don't want to invest in designing a strong curriculum or practicing good pedagogy. Perhaps the course curriculum, because it is designed by committee and not by the teacher, is innately unfocused. Perhaps no one has recognized the problems with the room the courses are housed in, and therefore hasn't tried to come up with a more engaging way of using the space.
Whatever the reason, at its heart is this: Stanford University, like most institutions of higher education, is primarily interested in research.* While many Professors like to teach, they frequently have little to no actual teaching training, and their jobs are in no way dependent on the quality of their teaching. Students, similarly, are generally less invested in classes** because they're wrapped up in research agendas and assistantships and meeting other requirements and trying to survive in the Bay Area on the roughly $20,000 a year they make as PhD students.
* Well, research and football, anyway.
** A quotation from a Doctoral student well-along on her path: "Your classes don't matter." In that case, I wonder, why do we have them at all?
In summary, Professors are not accountable to their employers for their teaching. They are accountable to their students, but their students don't particularly care whether they teach well or not. As a result, there's no particular motivation to improve a course, no particular need to assess whether it is "working" or not,* and no particular place for a student who does care about the quality of his courses (and the pedagogy therein) to voice concerns. It's a self-perpetuating, broken system. Except it's not broken at all: it's exactly what almost everyone involved wants it to be, which indicates that maybe the real problem is much, much deeper. But we'll have to leave that for another time.
* At Stanford in particular such an assessment would be confounded by the fact that most students here are extremely good at doing well in and taking as much as they can from poorly taught classes. Otherwise they wouldn't have made it to Stanford in the first place.
An Alternative Pedagogy
Vogon Guard: "Alright, so what's the alternative?"
Ford Prefect: "Well, stop doing it, of course! Tell them you're not going to do it anymore. Stand up to them!"
Vogon Guard: "Doesn't sound that great to me."
- Douglas Adams, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
The alternative to lecturing is, simply enough, not lecturing. The alternative to none - or few - students participating is getting them all to participate. Perhaps this is my St. John's education speaking, but I still think there's a lot to be gained from students talking to each other, and there's no reason that can't happen in these required courses.
How does that work? First of all, no more powerpoint slides. No more prepared lectures or conversational agendas. No more "this is what this article means" declarations. Questions - even pointed ones - to shape a conservation are fine, but presupposed answers are death to inquiry. If the goal is for new doctoral students to learn to interpret research, to discuss or analyze a text, and to be able to construct and argument as to what that text means, then it's imperative that they get practice at actually doing it. That does not mean "write a summary," that means dialogue, conversation, and argumentation.
So instead of two Professors trading off droning - with occasional interruption - at 30 students, let's put all of the manpower and brainpower in the classroom to work. Split the class into two groups of fifteen,* and send one Professor off with each group.** Sit in one great big circle, let the Professor ask a question about the text, and let the students work together to try to answer that question. Have, in other words, a dialogue.
* And rotate the groups around each week, so there's always a different mix in each group.
** Alternatively, split into even smaller groups - say five groups of six - and let the Professors float around, or put them into different groups each session.
Does that sound like St. John's? Of course it does. And why do I suggest it? Because it works. Stanford PhD students are smart people. If you put fifteen of them in a room with a text and ask them to figure out what it means and why it's important, odds are they're going to succeed. So why not give it a chance? They'll be developing interpretive skills, learning to talk to each other about research (which, vitally, may not even be in their area), and getting to know each other much better than they can when they're sitting four-to-a-table and being lectured at for two hours.
It is true that Professors are generally experts in these fields while students are not, but their wealth of experience does not mean that they are innately better readers than their students, or that they can say something more insightful about a text. What's more, even if they are better at those things, students will not learn simply by watching them talk. I cannot learn tennis without swinging for myself (and sometimes hitting it into the net), so how can I be expected to learn to speak to my future colleagues about research without being given a chance to do so, even if sometimes our interpretations are wrong, or we cut each other off, or we oversimplify? By doing will we learn, not by watching.
The Professor's role in this picture is to be the net. When I hit a tennis ball too short, I can tell. When I say something stupid, the Professor can chime in. But here's the really cool part: even that can be given over to students. If you let us talk to each other, we'll learn how to point out each other's mistakes, as much as highlight each other's strengths. In short, we'll form and learn to be a part of an intellectual community much like the one we're supposedly entering as future PhD-holding scholars.
Perhaps the objection could be raised that dialogue doesn't happen among Professors, either, and that therefore such a pedagogical system would not prepare students for the Academy. If that's so, then this alternative to lecturing becomes doubly important: we need academics who do more than merely pontificate, but who can actually communicate. The only way we'll get them is by training them to do so from the beginning. And anyway, it's a lot easier to transfer the ability to dialogue into giving a good lecture than the other way around.
A St. John's-ian dialogue, of course, is not the only valid alternative to a lecture class. Not all good classes are discussion classes. I do, however, pose it as a radical opposite pole. Somewhere in between is an equally good place where co-teachers actually work together, where the affordances of the room are taken into consideration when shaping the curriculum, and where the students are allowed to practice and be engaged with the material (and each other) for the whole two to three hours. Such pedagogical strategies exist. I wish that some enterprising Professor teaching a required, core course would use them.
Labels:
curriculum,
dialogue,
Education,
Learning,
lectures,
pedagogy,
phd,
professors,
Stanford
Tuesday, October 11, 2011
When Doing Poorly on an Assignment is a Crisis
I knew, when I decided to come to Stanford, that there would be days I would wish I had gone to UCSD instead (just as the reverse would have been true). I did not expect that one of those days would come so early.
Those that know me know that I care little for grades. I am perfectly capable of assessing my own learning. What I desire, instead, is feedback, constructive criticism, helpful advice. Harsh doesn't hurt. On the contrary, the more direct the feedback, the more specific the criticism, the better. I want to be a better writer, a better thinker, a more skilled lover of wisdom.
In one (or two) of my courses this quarter, however, I'm feeling something of a crisis of purpose. The course is a core requirement for all Stanford PhD students, a course that, in principle anyway, is at the heart of what we're doing and learning as future researchers. The course is a methods course, an introduction to research methodology and thinking.
It is in this course that we recently read a piece by Jerome Kagan. The piece was the first chapter of his "The Three Cultures," and, frankly, it's one of the worst pieces of writing I've read in a long time. Its point - that different research methodologies* have different cultures - was blindingly obvious, but its construction was totally inane, ranging from disorganized to grossly oversimplified to needlessly complex. Phrases like "the critical point is" appeared over and over, often referring to disparate ideas, while the phrase "to put it simply" appeared in front of one of the most complex formulations in the text. A single paragraph mentioned algae, bees, and ferrets in an effort to make a point about language, but the point got lost in the bestiary.
* That is, the hard sciences, the social sciences, and the humanities.
All of this was prefaced by two inexcusable writing decisions. The first was a table that shouldn't have been a table. The table charted "dimensions of research cultures" against those cultures, with the horrifying result that some cells contained whole sentences formatted like bad poems. Note to self: anytime you put a 20 word sentence in a table, try to make the cells wide enough so that you do not to have one word per line.
The other decision - perhaps graver - was an invocation of Ludwig Wittgenstein near the opening of the text. Wittgenstein, if you don't know, is famous for destabilizing theories of language and meaning with his not-always-clear, fragmentary texts. He challenged the assumption that words meant the same thing all the time, and ultimately convinced everyone from philosophers to linguists to social scientists that context is really important - perhaps the only thing that is important - to meaning.
Kagan uses Wittgenstein, then, to begin his treatise on the three cultures. His citation of the philosopher is made to preface his own observation that, within different research paradigms, different words have different meanings. Fear, for example, means a different thing to an English professor than to a Behavioral Psychologist.
Which is all well and good, of course, if blindingly obvious. No, the offense here was pointing to Wittgenstein as the divider of the disciplines. It perhaps did not strike Kagan as supremely ironic that Wittgenstein himself probably would not have been all that excited by the theoretical division of the "three cultures" of modern academic research, that Wittgenstein's ways of thinking were in equal part scientific, social, and humanistic, that his methodology was not easy to categorize by the very system that Kagan found Wittgenstein to be the father of.
Behind my disgust at reading page after page (after page) of the drivel in "The Three Cultures"* was a lurking fear. You see, this was not something I was reading on my own. No, this was one of the first pieces that I was meant to read as a PhD student at Stanford University. In some sense, this was canonical, brilliant, an important work for me to contemplate and consider.
* I prefer to be a generous reader, but in this case I cannot think of a single redeeming quality of the piece.
With even greater horror I turned to my assignment: I must summarize this monster and, what's more, apply its reasoning to my own potential research interests. The written summary is, I think, a poor piece of pedagogy and assessment as is, but it's doubly hard when the work in question is of such poor quality.
Being the contrarian that I am (nicht diese tone, after all), I decided to write a poem. I suspected this might get me in trouble, to a degree, but I have always tested academic limits (often to my benefit) throughout my time as a student. This was not, for example, the first poem I've turned in on a non-poetry assignment, and historically my assessors have appreciated the change of pace, as well as the effort at creative insight. Some have leveled a warranted "don't do that again" at me, as well, but at least there was respect for the process.
In this case, I borrowed some of Kagan's language, inserted a one-sentence statement of the simple fact - that different research cultures are different, basically - and ended with the observation that "somebody misappropriated the Wittgenstein." It was, in my opinion, a funny but not inaccurate piece of analytical and synthetic work considering the quite dull material with which I was presented. It was not a good poem, but it was not meant to be. Good poems (and perhaps good writing of any kind) need subject matter worth writing about. Of course I could have, in less time and probably with better results - at least from the Professorial point of view - done a traditional summary, but if I'm going to spend hours reading a piece of drivel, I intend not to bore myself by writing the same kind of drivel in response.*
* It is worth noting that the Kagan piece was poor writing by academic standards as well. It was flowery and full of needless metaphors. It was organized so that multiple and unclear ideas populated each sentence. It was a mess.
In response to my poem (and, for the other reading, an interpolation of the reading into Plato's Meno; another, I thought, interesting and synthetic attempt to summarize the work without driving myself totally mad at the grade-school-book-reportiness of it all), I received a "check-minus" with a note that I did not summarize Kagan, and that I should look at my classmate's example passages for help.
Hence my crisis. I know how to summarize a piece of writing. I can write a clear and concise sentence when it is worth writing. But I am not here to learn how to regurgitate simple information poorly presented. And yet, increasingly, that is how I feel my classes are designed. Classes taught ostensibly by critical pedagogues - who believe in student-run classrooms and dialogue and activity - are two-hour lectures.* Courses in research methodology involve no training in research or methodology, but rather middle-school level assignments that ask primarily that I demonstrate not that I understand the ideas of a text or am striving to make them my own, but rather that I have done the reading, and am able to copy and paste important ideas into equally vapid academic jargon.**
* A fact that would amuse me were it not so sad. It is a shocking revelation that the people who teach teachers to teach (and teach education researchers to assess good teaching) - that is, School of Education Professors - are such poor teachers.
** Perhaps that is "methodology" to the modern researcher? If so, academia is in worse trouble than I thought.
Perhaps I was mistaken in thinking that Education research was open to people who value ideas as much as research, people who value creativity, process, and inspiration as much as method and practice. It is not that I discount research, method, or practice, it is rather that I see so little of the other stuff that I'm beginning to wonder, well, whether wonder is a part of the equation at all.
Again, I don't really care about grades. I could get a check-double-minus or a D or whatever and that wouldn't bother me. No, what bothers me is that the feedback I received misses the point entirely. It bothers me that the conversation is one way. That the pedagogy is so deeply flawed. That the underlying philosophy is so undemocratic. That the value system is so blindly accepted that it cannot see that, maybe, a whimsical, irreverent, and sarcastic spark might have merit beyond "not being a summary." Of course it wasn't a summary; it was a condemnation.
If a summary had been worth writing, I would have written one. Give me an assignment worth doing, an article worth reading, a conversation to have (instead of a lecture to attend to), and I will produce high quality work.* Give me a class worth taking - do not waste my time for three hours at a time with your pontificating and your holier-than-thou elitism (tenure alone does not make you interesting). I, too, am an intellectual. I, too, love ideas, perhaps more than you would believe. I, too, can speak and listen. I, in my own way, am well-read. I have stood in front of students and shut myself up so that they might speak, and it was wondrous. Yet, if no such thing can happen even here, at Stanford University, in a PhD program, in Education, can we hope for it to happen anywhere else?
* I might as well say the same for any and every student, and yet this lesson learned so well in research has not been learned in practice even by the very researchers who teach it.
It is not my assignment that makes me wonder about all of this. That is but a small and ultimately meaningless symptom of a much deeper problem. Nevertheless, it is an indicative example of the bigger picture: a case in which, it now seems obvious to me, the result was destined both because of how I was inevitably to respond to the assignment, and how the assignment, so to speak, was going to respond back to me. And so the deeper culture becomes the question, and leaves me with an exhortation.
Instead of demanding that I fit into your narrow boxes, academia, you would do well to invite and celebrate your radicals, your creative thinkers, your irreverent teachers, your trouble-makers. I know that UCSD does, and yet I chose Stanford, in part, because I believed that it did as well. Now I'm not so sure.
Those that know me know that I care little for grades. I am perfectly capable of assessing my own learning. What I desire, instead, is feedback, constructive criticism, helpful advice. Harsh doesn't hurt. On the contrary, the more direct the feedback, the more specific the criticism, the better. I want to be a better writer, a better thinker, a more skilled lover of wisdom.
In one (or two) of my courses this quarter, however, I'm feeling something of a crisis of purpose. The course is a core requirement for all Stanford PhD students, a course that, in principle anyway, is at the heart of what we're doing and learning as future researchers. The course is a methods course, an introduction to research methodology and thinking.
It is in this course that we recently read a piece by Jerome Kagan. The piece was the first chapter of his "The Three Cultures," and, frankly, it's one of the worst pieces of writing I've read in a long time. Its point - that different research methodologies* have different cultures - was blindingly obvious, but its construction was totally inane, ranging from disorganized to grossly oversimplified to needlessly complex. Phrases like "the critical point is" appeared over and over, often referring to disparate ideas, while the phrase "to put it simply" appeared in front of one of the most complex formulations in the text. A single paragraph mentioned algae, bees, and ferrets in an effort to make a point about language, but the point got lost in the bestiary.
* That is, the hard sciences, the social sciences, and the humanities.
All of this was prefaced by two inexcusable writing decisions. The first was a table that shouldn't have been a table. The table charted "dimensions of research cultures" against those cultures, with the horrifying result that some cells contained whole sentences formatted like bad poems. Note to self: anytime you put a 20 word sentence in a table, try to make the cells wide enough so that you do not to have one word per line.
The other decision - perhaps graver - was an invocation of Ludwig Wittgenstein near the opening of the text. Wittgenstein, if you don't know, is famous for destabilizing theories of language and meaning with his not-always-clear, fragmentary texts. He challenged the assumption that words meant the same thing all the time, and ultimately convinced everyone from philosophers to linguists to social scientists that context is really important - perhaps the only thing that is important - to meaning.
Kagan uses Wittgenstein, then, to begin his treatise on the three cultures. His citation of the philosopher is made to preface his own observation that, within different research paradigms, different words have different meanings. Fear, for example, means a different thing to an English professor than to a Behavioral Psychologist.
Which is all well and good, of course, if blindingly obvious. No, the offense here was pointing to Wittgenstein as the divider of the disciplines. It perhaps did not strike Kagan as supremely ironic that Wittgenstein himself probably would not have been all that excited by the theoretical division of the "three cultures" of modern academic research, that Wittgenstein's ways of thinking were in equal part scientific, social, and humanistic, that his methodology was not easy to categorize by the very system that Kagan found Wittgenstein to be the father of.
Behind my disgust at reading page after page (after page) of the drivel in "The Three Cultures"* was a lurking fear. You see, this was not something I was reading on my own. No, this was one of the first pieces that I was meant to read as a PhD student at Stanford University. In some sense, this was canonical, brilliant, an important work for me to contemplate and consider.
* I prefer to be a generous reader, but in this case I cannot think of a single redeeming quality of the piece.
With even greater horror I turned to my assignment: I must summarize this monster and, what's more, apply its reasoning to my own potential research interests. The written summary is, I think, a poor piece of pedagogy and assessment as is, but it's doubly hard when the work in question is of such poor quality.
Being the contrarian that I am (nicht diese tone, after all), I decided to write a poem. I suspected this might get me in trouble, to a degree, but I have always tested academic limits (often to my benefit) throughout my time as a student. This was not, for example, the first poem I've turned in on a non-poetry assignment, and historically my assessors have appreciated the change of pace, as well as the effort at creative insight. Some have leveled a warranted "don't do that again" at me, as well, but at least there was respect for the process.
In this case, I borrowed some of Kagan's language, inserted a one-sentence statement of the simple fact - that different research cultures are different, basically - and ended with the observation that "somebody misappropriated the Wittgenstein." It was, in my opinion, a funny but not inaccurate piece of analytical and synthetic work considering the quite dull material with which I was presented. It was not a good poem, but it was not meant to be. Good poems (and perhaps good writing of any kind) need subject matter worth writing about. Of course I could have, in less time and probably with better results - at least from the Professorial point of view - done a traditional summary, but if I'm going to spend hours reading a piece of drivel, I intend not to bore myself by writing the same kind of drivel in response.*
* It is worth noting that the Kagan piece was poor writing by academic standards as well. It was flowery and full of needless metaphors. It was organized so that multiple and unclear ideas populated each sentence. It was a mess.
In response to my poem (and, for the other reading, an interpolation of the reading into Plato's Meno; another, I thought, interesting and synthetic attempt to summarize the work without driving myself totally mad at the grade-school-book-reportiness of it all), I received a "check-minus" with a note that I did not summarize Kagan, and that I should look at my classmate's example passages for help.
Hence my crisis. I know how to summarize a piece of writing. I can write a clear and concise sentence when it is worth writing. But I am not here to learn how to regurgitate simple information poorly presented. And yet, increasingly, that is how I feel my classes are designed. Classes taught ostensibly by critical pedagogues - who believe in student-run classrooms and dialogue and activity - are two-hour lectures.* Courses in research methodology involve no training in research or methodology, but rather middle-school level assignments that ask primarily that I demonstrate not that I understand the ideas of a text or am striving to make them my own, but rather that I have done the reading, and am able to copy and paste important ideas into equally vapid academic jargon.**
* A fact that would amuse me were it not so sad. It is a shocking revelation that the people who teach teachers to teach (and teach education researchers to assess good teaching) - that is, School of Education Professors - are such poor teachers.
** Perhaps that is "methodology" to the modern researcher? If so, academia is in worse trouble than I thought.
Perhaps I was mistaken in thinking that Education research was open to people who value ideas as much as research, people who value creativity, process, and inspiration as much as method and practice. It is not that I discount research, method, or practice, it is rather that I see so little of the other stuff that I'm beginning to wonder, well, whether wonder is a part of the equation at all.
Again, I don't really care about grades. I could get a check-double-minus or a D or whatever and that wouldn't bother me. No, what bothers me is that the feedback I received misses the point entirely. It bothers me that the conversation is one way. That the pedagogy is so deeply flawed. That the underlying philosophy is so undemocratic. That the value system is so blindly accepted that it cannot see that, maybe, a whimsical, irreverent, and sarcastic spark might have merit beyond "not being a summary." Of course it wasn't a summary; it was a condemnation.
If a summary had been worth writing, I would have written one. Give me an assignment worth doing, an article worth reading, a conversation to have (instead of a lecture to attend to), and I will produce high quality work.* Give me a class worth taking - do not waste my time for three hours at a time with your pontificating and your holier-than-thou elitism (tenure alone does not make you interesting). I, too, am an intellectual. I, too, love ideas, perhaps more than you would believe. I, too, can speak and listen. I, in my own way, am well-read. I have stood in front of students and shut myself up so that they might speak, and it was wondrous. Yet, if no such thing can happen even here, at Stanford University, in a PhD program, in Education, can we hope for it to happen anywhere else?
* I might as well say the same for any and every student, and yet this lesson learned so well in research has not been learned in practice even by the very researchers who teach it.
It is not my assignment that makes me wonder about all of this. That is but a small and ultimately meaningless symptom of a much deeper problem. Nevertheless, it is an indicative example of the bigger picture: a case in which, it now seems obvious to me, the result was destined both because of how I was inevitably to respond to the assignment, and how the assignment, so to speak, was going to respond back to me. And so the deeper culture becomes the question, and leaves me with an exhortation.
Instead of demanding that I fit into your narrow boxes, academia, you would do well to invite and celebrate your radicals, your creative thinkers, your irreverent teachers, your trouble-makers. I know that UCSD does, and yet I chose Stanford, in part, because I believed that it did as well. Now I'm not so sure.
Labels:
academia,
assignments,
courses,
homework,
jerome kagan,
pedagogy,
personal,
Poetry,
Stanford,
three cultures,
writing
Monday, September 26, 2011
Two Research Ideas
One of my first assignments here at Stanford was to draft a possible research question and propose a methodology to use in answering that question. Because I have multiple interests, I wrote two.
The Dialogic Pedagogy of St. John's College
Questions
What is a dialogue? Obviously there is plenty of research about how to support dialogue in the classroom, and the role of discussions in learning. From my own limited experience, however, as a graduate student and as a teacher, there is a tremendous difference between dialogue as it is conceived in such research and dialogue as it occurs in, particularly, the classrooms of St. John's College.
As a graduate of St. John's, I have first hand experience in those classrooms. Far from providing answers, my experience only raises more questions. What is it about the culture, the pedagogy, and the organization of learning at St. John's that makes their classrooms unique? How is it that students in the St. John's seminar are able to speak so directly to each other about such complicated texts with minimal Professorial intervention? Or are they actually able to do so, after all? What is the relationship between the dialogic pedagogy of the college and its Great Books curriculum? Do they support each other, are they separable, or do they detract from each other? Perhaps most importantly: what, if anything, does the pedagogy – as distinct from the curriculum – have to teach educational systems at large?
All of these questions interest me, and they serve as a backdrop for a possible research agenda. In the short term, however, I want to focus particularly on undergraduate programs and dialogue. That is, I want to address this question: What constitutes a dialogue at St. John's, and how is it distinct from dialogues in other undergraduate academic environments?
Method
In order to begin to answer that questions, an initial qualitative, ethnographic foray into the college would be invaluable. A visit to the Santa Fe campus would allow me to conduct interviews with current students and faculty, as well as observe seminars in action with a researcher's – rather than a student's – eye. Video analysis of seminars could also be helpful, though that would require both the necessary equipment and approval from the school (recording of seminars is traditionally forbidden). While direct observation and interviews would only be possible when present, with permission and help I might be able to record video of a seminar or seminars throughout a semester or more.
In addition to doing qualitative data collection at St. John's, I would want to follow a similar interview and observation (and/or video analysis) protocol at another or other institutions. Perhaps the most feasible option would be to look at undergraduate courses at Stanford, as well as another local college or university (such as San Jose State). I would strive to find courses which describe themselves as “seminars” and which intend to use discussion-based pedagogies. I would strive, at this stage, to match specific content across the colleges in question.
Having collected my data, I would code and analyze in the qualitative tradition, with an eye towards answering my initial question, but also with the hope of discovering the appropriate path towards addressing the deeper questions that inspire my research.
Design in Game Development and Curriculum Construction
Questions
J.P. Gee, among others, has noticed that game developers do an excellent job of scaffolding learning into their products. That is, gamers learn how to play the game from simply playing it, whether because there is a built-in tutorial, or because the mechanics of the game are somehow made obvious by experimentation, or because the game is similar enough to other games in the genre that new players can be expected to transfer skills and strategies. Regardless, learning to play a game is a significant portion of what makes games fun.
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
I'm particularly interested in an analysis of the design process game and curriculum development, as it pertains to learning in those respective environments. The question is not, then, whether students learn better from games, or what games do so effectively. It is how games are designed and how that process differs in education.
Method
I believe this question lends itself to an ethnographic approach. On the one hand, ethnography of a game development studio – or, indeed, a multitude of studios, as different studios likely have different design processes – and on the other, a similar ethnography of a school or other academic institution engaged in curriculum and activity design. Many public schools, of course, have little say in the details of their curricula, so perhaps a textbook company or other curriculum developer (Foss, for example) would serve as an interesting foil instead.
Spending time observing and interviewing participants in the design processes in these two environments, I would hope to discover what, if any, vocabulary is shared, and what is different. I would also hope to see to what degree learning is an explicit or implicit part of the design process. I expect a variety of other notable differences might arise as well, in terms of relationship to prototyping, the degree to which the process itself arises organically during development, and the passion and engagement of the people working on the design, among other things.
Purpose
Ultimately, my hope is that the game design process might hold some keys as to how educators might help to unlock the powerful learning potential of games in education, without forcing us to conclude that boring “educational games,” irrelevant commercial games, or tacky gamification are the only options. That is, perhaps traditional learning might be benefit at the level of design from contact with the game design world. And, in reverse, perhaps the game design world can benefit from contact with the education design process.
Thursday, September 15, 2011
The Future of the Blog
As I am about to begin working on my PhD in Education at Stanford University, I have been reflecting on this blog and the role it will play in my studies. While I was an MA student I wrote here frequently, and I expect I'll continue to write frequently as a PhD student. I feel, however, that I put an undue amount of pressure on myself to produce content for this blog at a fairly regular rate. Undue because, ultimately, I have a very small readership (though I very much appreciate those of you who do read the blog regularly), and thus mostly am writing for myself.
The upshot of all of this reflection is that, while I'm not planning on discontinuing the blog by any stretch, I'm planning on scaling it back significantly. Instead of my target of two posts a week, I'm hoping to get to a post every now and again... Maybe one every couple of weeks. I'm still going to work on my Beethoven project, of course, as time and willpower permit, and likewise with my still nascent novel (which has been more difficult than I anticipated), and I fully anticipate occasional game ravings, political rants, and educational reflections to make their way to this space. But the pace at which I've tried to write here over the past couple of years will be lessened because, well, there's just too much else to do.
In particular, there's too much else to read. Not only will I be taking on a heavy PhD reading load, but I've found that the Internet is bustling with great writing, and the decision to be an active producer of writing sometimes gets in the way of my desire to read more. With that in mind, I want to encourage my readers to take a look at Dirk Hayhurst, at Eric Nusbaum, at Joe Posnanski. These are writers who I follow (or have recently begun to follow) and who are teaching me - whether they intend to or not - to write better.
Perhaps what I'm trying to say is this. As an undergraduate I read a lot and wrote a little. Since then, I've written a lot and read not as much. Now I think it's time for the pendulum to swing back in the other direction, and a few years from now I'll pick up the pen (or the keyboard) and become a writer again. Of course, that's not really a dichotomy - one may write and read a lot at the same time - but I nevertheless feel that one's focus naturally tends towards one or the other at any given time. For now, it's back to being a reader and a student.
The upshot of all of this reflection is that, while I'm not planning on discontinuing the blog by any stretch, I'm planning on scaling it back significantly. Instead of my target of two posts a week, I'm hoping to get to a post every now and again... Maybe one every couple of weeks. I'm still going to work on my Beethoven project, of course, as time and willpower permit, and likewise with my still nascent novel (which has been more difficult than I anticipated), and I fully anticipate occasional game ravings, political rants, and educational reflections to make their way to this space. But the pace at which I've tried to write here over the past couple of years will be lessened because, well, there's just too much else to do.
In particular, there's too much else to read. Not only will I be taking on a heavy PhD reading load, but I've found that the Internet is bustling with great writing, and the decision to be an active producer of writing sometimes gets in the way of my desire to read more. With that in mind, I want to encourage my readers to take a look at Dirk Hayhurst, at Eric Nusbaum, at Joe Posnanski. These are writers who I follow (or have recently begun to follow) and who are teaching me - whether they intend to or not - to write better.
Perhaps what I'm trying to say is this. As an undergraduate I read a lot and wrote a little. Since then, I've written a lot and read not as much. Now I think it's time for the pendulum to swing back in the other direction, and a few years from now I'll pick up the pen (or the keyboard) and become a writer again. Of course, that's not really a dichotomy - one may write and read a lot at the same time - but I nevertheless feel that one's focus naturally tends towards one or the other at any given time. For now, it's back to being a reader and a student.
Sunday, April 3, 2011
Why I Chose Stanford
It's official, I've accepted Stanford's offer to attend their Learning Sciences and Technology Design PhD program starting next fall. Initially I'll be studying under Roy Pea and Hilda Borko, both - since we're talking about, you know, Stanford - renowned researchers and well-respected in their field. I know Roy from my time as a Master's student, during which my friend and co-conspirator Coram and I consulted Professor Pea as often as we felt we could get away with while working on our project. As a result, I'm certain I'll be able to work with him and learn from him.
Ultimately, this decision was not an easy one, even though Stanford is an "obvious choice." To the common layperson, the name Stanford alone is worth so much that, when I have posed my conundrum to certain people the response has been a resounding, "you mean there's actually a question?" My answer is, yes, there is (or was) a question. You see, PhD work is less about prestige and more about fit. My decision, then, was not about trying to find the "best" program, but to find the program that most matched my own learning style, research interests, pedagogical biases, and general outlook on the world in general.
The Communications department at the University of California, San Diego matches me very well in almost all of those areas. Their pedagogical model is highly discussion driven, the amount of reading and writing that students do their lines up well with the amount of reading and writing I do of my own volition, their conversations are lofty and philosophical, and the people are quirky, critical, and equal parts cynical and optimistic. In short, a lot like me. Indeed, had I chosen to attend UCSD I'm sure I'd be having a number of conversations with a variety of people right now in which I would be pointing out exactly that: I definitely fit at UCSD, and that's the most important thing.
So why not UCSD? Well, I also fit at Stanford. In fact, I think I fit better at Stanford.
While the people at UCSD are a perfect match for me, and while I would have the freedom to pursue my research interests, I'm actually not convinced that the general outlook of the department matches my own and that, even more importantly, the pedagogical bent of the program would suit me. I don't mean to say I think there's anything wrong with the outlook or pedagogy at UCSD, I just think they wouldn't work for me.
As a graduate of St. John's College, I come from a strange academic tradition. I'm a student of the so-called "Western Canon" at a time when a lot of the academic world - and places like UCSD in particular - seriously doubt whether there really ought to be such a thing as a canon. The questions at the heart of this objection are valid, and look like this: How can you determine which books are Great, or even if there is such a thing as Greatness? Isn't that a hegemonic, colonial tool to marginalize the values and cultures of all of those people who are not white male Europeans?
By themselves, these are important questions that, frankly, St. John's probably doesn't do a good enough job answering.* The problem, to me, is the double-reversal jiu-jitsu that comes next. Because those are good questions, the answers are assumed to be, basically, that there is no such thing as Greatness, that the Great Books are a total sham, and that any curriculum that reads them and takes them seriously on their own merits (instead of through alternative cultural and contextual lenses) is itself an instrument of intellectual and cultural tyranny. The result, of course, is the laissez-faire, anything goes attitude towards ideas that pervades the post-modern world. That attitude says, "your ideas and my ideas are equally valid, because they each come from our own perspectives. Right and wrong are relative, and meaning is personally constructed, and if we all just agree to disagree and get along the world will be all right." To me, that's a shameful intellectual surrender. Maybe this is a hegemonic idea, but I like to think that there's more value in consensus - and, even more so, the effort to get there - than there is in tolerance.**
* Of course, any graduate of the college who continues in academia will inevitably have to confront these questions anyway, and will be - I think St. John's would argue - equipped to do so because of the critical thinking skills they've gained as Johnnies. I suspect a great many St. John's graduates end up being heavily critical of the curricular content of the Great Books program precisely because it is so Anglo-European centric. So it's hard to criticize the college for picking a narrower curricular goal that it can achieve in four years, instead of trying to bite off more than it can chew when it knows students will get there after-the-fact anyway. That's just good curriculum design.
** That the position of tolerance for differing ideas is also held be many self-proclaimed radicals - many of whom are only actually tolerant up to a point - only serves to remind me of this Eva Brann (St. John's Dean, not wife of Hitler) quotation: "To the radicals we might say: you don't begin to know what radical is; we are the ones who go to the roots."
Now that's not to say that I know anything like enough about UCSD to say where the institution as a whole stands relative to this issue. In reality, I'm sure there are a range of opinions. I did, however, get the sense from the brief time I spent there and the one class I visited that I would likely end up very frustrated by the "make connections" instead of "find meaning" model that goes with their post-modernist academic culture. That each week's reading on the syllabi I saw included multiple and intentionally disparate authors in order to build background and force cross-cutting interpretations rubs against my Johnnie sensibilities, in which those things are not exactly bad, but nevertheless can undercut the effort to actually understand a given text's content, instead of just its context or impact.
Again, I'm not sure that there's anything wrong with the way UCSD is doing things, I just don't think it's right for me.
Now you might be thinking that Stanford is vastly different. It isn't. If anything, it's less discussion and dialogue oriented than UCSD, and it is just as much concerned with post-modernist questions and processes. The difference, then, is that Stanford is not just talking and reading and dancing around the theories and philosophies of these issues, but is, in fact, actually out in the world doing. My experience as an LDT student was one of project-based classes and practice-oriented learning, which lines up well with modern learning theory. While not every professor I had was a brilliant teacher using the more cutting edge pedagogy and technology, many - including Roy, incidentally* - were just that. For all of its stuffy, privileged, businessy, ivory tower reputation, Stanford really does strive to practice what it preaches.
*Or not incidentally at all.
Being political (in the root, Greek sense of dealing with society) has its drawbacks. It can be frustrating to try to make a difference. But as much as I'm sure I'll have days and nights when I feel like I'm just a small, insignificant part of a broken system, and I can't do much to improve the situation, I think that Stanford will encourage and support (and, really, actively enlist) me in fighting the good fight. The potential for myopia at UCSD, on the other hand - the ability to remove myself from the world and just do whatever I want - frightens me much more than the frustrations I'm sure I'll feel at Stanford sometimes do. I am, despite myself, equal parts idealism and practicality, and I feel like Stanford understands that dichotomy (and supports both sides of it) better than UCSD does, at least in my case.
There are, I suspect, a great many other things I could say about what draws me to Stanford (including my previous experience there compared to the relative unknown of UCSD), but they would be variations on the theme from above. The truth of the matter is, both programs were the "right decision," but in different ways, and I was fortunate to have an opportunity to pick between the two, even if it meant the decision was a difficult one.
Ultimately, this decision was not an easy one, even though Stanford is an "obvious choice." To the common layperson, the name Stanford alone is worth so much that, when I have posed my conundrum to certain people the response has been a resounding, "you mean there's actually a question?" My answer is, yes, there is (or was) a question. You see, PhD work is less about prestige and more about fit. My decision, then, was not about trying to find the "best" program, but to find the program that most matched my own learning style, research interests, pedagogical biases, and general outlook on the world in general.
The Communications department at the University of California, San Diego matches me very well in almost all of those areas. Their pedagogical model is highly discussion driven, the amount of reading and writing that students do their lines up well with the amount of reading and writing I do of my own volition, their conversations are lofty and philosophical, and the people are quirky, critical, and equal parts cynical and optimistic. In short, a lot like me. Indeed, had I chosen to attend UCSD I'm sure I'd be having a number of conversations with a variety of people right now in which I would be pointing out exactly that: I definitely fit at UCSD, and that's the most important thing.
So why not UCSD? Well, I also fit at Stanford. In fact, I think I fit better at Stanford.
While the people at UCSD are a perfect match for me, and while I would have the freedom to pursue my research interests, I'm actually not convinced that the general outlook of the department matches my own and that, even more importantly, the pedagogical bent of the program would suit me. I don't mean to say I think there's anything wrong with the outlook or pedagogy at UCSD, I just think they wouldn't work for me.
As a graduate of St. John's College, I come from a strange academic tradition. I'm a student of the so-called "Western Canon" at a time when a lot of the academic world - and places like UCSD in particular - seriously doubt whether there really ought to be such a thing as a canon. The questions at the heart of this objection are valid, and look like this: How can you determine which books are Great, or even if there is such a thing as Greatness? Isn't that a hegemonic, colonial tool to marginalize the values and cultures of all of those people who are not white male Europeans?
By themselves, these are important questions that, frankly, St. John's probably doesn't do a good enough job answering.* The problem, to me, is the double-reversal jiu-jitsu that comes next. Because those are good questions, the answers are assumed to be, basically, that there is no such thing as Greatness, that the Great Books are a total sham, and that any curriculum that reads them and takes them seriously on their own merits (instead of through alternative cultural and contextual lenses) is itself an instrument of intellectual and cultural tyranny. The result, of course, is the laissez-faire, anything goes attitude towards ideas that pervades the post-modern world. That attitude says, "your ideas and my ideas are equally valid, because they each come from our own perspectives. Right and wrong are relative, and meaning is personally constructed, and if we all just agree to disagree and get along the world will be all right." To me, that's a shameful intellectual surrender. Maybe this is a hegemonic idea, but I like to think that there's more value in consensus - and, even more so, the effort to get there - than there is in tolerance.**
* Of course, any graduate of the college who continues in academia will inevitably have to confront these questions anyway, and will be - I think St. John's would argue - equipped to do so because of the critical thinking skills they've gained as Johnnies. I suspect a great many St. John's graduates end up being heavily critical of the curricular content of the Great Books program precisely because it is so Anglo-European centric. So it's hard to criticize the college for picking a narrower curricular goal that it can achieve in four years, instead of trying to bite off more than it can chew when it knows students will get there after-the-fact anyway. That's just good curriculum design.
** That the position of tolerance for differing ideas is also held be many self-proclaimed radicals - many of whom are only actually tolerant up to a point - only serves to remind me of this Eva Brann (St. John's Dean, not wife of Hitler) quotation: "To the radicals we might say: you don't begin to know what radical is; we are the ones who go to the roots."
Now that's not to say that I know anything like enough about UCSD to say where the institution as a whole stands relative to this issue. In reality, I'm sure there are a range of opinions. I did, however, get the sense from the brief time I spent there and the one class I visited that I would likely end up very frustrated by the "make connections" instead of "find meaning" model that goes with their post-modernist academic culture. That each week's reading on the syllabi I saw included multiple and intentionally disparate authors in order to build background and force cross-cutting interpretations rubs against my Johnnie sensibilities, in which those things are not exactly bad, but nevertheless can undercut the effort to actually understand a given text's content, instead of just its context or impact.
Again, I'm not sure that there's anything wrong with the way UCSD is doing things, I just don't think it's right for me.
Now you might be thinking that Stanford is vastly different. It isn't. If anything, it's less discussion and dialogue oriented than UCSD, and it is just as much concerned with post-modernist questions and processes. The difference, then, is that Stanford is not just talking and reading and dancing around the theories and philosophies of these issues, but is, in fact, actually out in the world doing. My experience as an LDT student was one of project-based classes and practice-oriented learning, which lines up well with modern learning theory. While not every professor I had was a brilliant teacher using the more cutting edge pedagogy and technology, many - including Roy, incidentally* - were just that. For all of its stuffy, privileged, businessy, ivory tower reputation, Stanford really does strive to practice what it preaches.
*Or not incidentally at all.
Being political (in the root, Greek sense of dealing with society) has its drawbacks. It can be frustrating to try to make a difference. But as much as I'm sure I'll have days and nights when I feel like I'm just a small, insignificant part of a broken system, and I can't do much to improve the situation, I think that Stanford will encourage and support (and, really, actively enlist) me in fighting the good fight. The potential for myopia at UCSD, on the other hand - the ability to remove myself from the world and just do whatever I want - frightens me much more than the frustrations I'm sure I'll feel at Stanford sometimes do. I am, despite myself, equal parts idealism and practicality, and I feel like Stanford understands that dichotomy (and supports both sides of it) better than UCSD does, at least in my case.
There are, I suspect, a great many other things I could say about what draws me to Stanford (including my previous experience there compared to the relative unknown of UCSD), but they would be variations on the theme from above. The truth of the matter is, both programs were the "right decision," but in different ways, and I was fortunate to have an opportunity to pick between the two, even if it meant the decision was a difficult one.
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Goin' To California
Just a quick note to the effect that I'll be traveling in California for most of the rest of the month, meaning there's no guarantee on frequency of blog posts for that time. Chances are about 50/50 that I'll actually write more during my trip, but no promises.
The purpose of the journey is threefold. First off, I'll be presenting along with my Mom at the NSTA national conference in San Francisco. We'll be talking about using Moodle as a tool to support learning - and especially metacognition - in the sciences. The presentation is at the Marriot San Francisco Marquis, Sierra C room at 3:30, for those of you in the area who are either attending NSTA already or who might want to sneak in to say "hi."
Secondly, I'll be staying in San Francisco to visit friends and to spend my one year anniversary with my wife Jericha during her spring break. We're looking forward to actually visiting all those places in the city that we neglected during my year at Stanford (neglected mainly due to the distance between Palo Alto and the city, and the workload of getting a Master's degree).
Thirdly, I'll be visiting both Stanford and then traveling to San Diego to visit UCSD (and more friends, of course). If you recall my list of PhD applications from the fall, you'll recognize that these as two of the five* schools to which I applied. I have heard affirmatives from both (with funding still pending from Stanford), and will be engaging in the difficult process of choosing which program to attend for the next four plus years.
*As for the other three, I've heard a no from Chicago, and have not heard from UCSC and UH. UCSC I don't have particularly high expectations at this point, as it's late to receive a positive response from a UC school at this point, as is evidenced by UCSD's offer. As for UH, they run on a slightly later schedule, and I likely won't hear from them until the summer.
So if I neglect to post anything for awhile, that's why. But the Beethoven project will continue - especially now that I'm finally getting around to reading Lewis Lockwood's fantastic biography of the composer - and of course dispatches from the Golden State are likely to be forthcoming as well. I would also recommend popping over to Pitchers and Poets, both because they recently went through an awesome redesign and because a post from yours truly is on the way. Ok, it's not written yet, but that's what the plane ride is for.
The purpose of the journey is threefold. First off, I'll be presenting along with my Mom at the NSTA national conference in San Francisco. We'll be talking about using Moodle as a tool to support learning - and especially metacognition - in the sciences. The presentation is at the Marriot San Francisco Marquis, Sierra C room at 3:30, for those of you in the area who are either attending NSTA already or who might want to sneak in to say "hi."
Secondly, I'll be staying in San Francisco to visit friends and to spend my one year anniversary with my wife Jericha during her spring break. We're looking forward to actually visiting all those places in the city that we neglected during my year at Stanford (neglected mainly due to the distance between Palo Alto and the city, and the workload of getting a Master's degree).
Thirdly, I'll be visiting both Stanford and then traveling to San Diego to visit UCSD (and more friends, of course). If you recall my list of PhD applications from the fall, you'll recognize that these as two of the five* schools to which I applied. I have heard affirmatives from both (with funding still pending from Stanford), and will be engaging in the difficult process of choosing which program to attend for the next four plus years.
*As for the other three, I've heard a no from Chicago, and have not heard from UCSC and UH. UCSC I don't have particularly high expectations at this point, as it's late to receive a positive response from a UC school at this point, as is evidenced by UCSD's offer. As for UH, they run on a slightly later schedule, and I likely won't hear from them until the summer.
So if I neglect to post anything for awhile, that's why. But the Beethoven project will continue - especially now that I'm finally getting around to reading Lewis Lockwood's fantastic biography of the composer - and of course dispatches from the Golden State are likely to be forthcoming as well. I would also recommend popping over to Pitchers and Poets, both because they recently went through an awesome redesign and because a post from yours truly is on the way. Ok, it's not written yet, but that's what the plane ride is for.
Labels:
California,
NSTA,
personal,
San Francisco,
Stanford,
travel,
UCSC,
UCSD,
UH,
University of Chicago
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
The List
For the past few weeks - since my resignation at NALU - I've been mired in a search for an appropriate PhD program. If you know anything about academia, you know that my timing is particularly awkward, because most programs put their deadlines smack dab in the middle of December, which is, you know, very soon. So I've been exploring research angles, having conversations, browsing websites, sending emails, and doing all the legwork I need to do as quickly as possible.
The result is that, as of today, I've made my decision as to where I'm applying, and for what. I don't think it's a perfect list, but it's a list, it's actionable, and I know - or at least strongly suspect - I would be happy in any of the programs I've narrowed my search down to. So, without further ado, here are the five programs.
Stanford University, Learning Sciences and Technology Design
I'll be applying to LSTD for the third time, and from a third completely different angle. When I was accepted to LDT I applied at both the Master's and PhD levels, but my application was broad and vague to a degree that made me an undesirable PhD candidate. Last year, I wrote a more specific statement of purpose, but unfortunately my specific interests didn't align with anyone at the University. This time, and now that I know the Professors better (and they know me better), I feel I can write an even better statement of purpose, and potentially latch on with a suitable advisor.
In short, the question I'm pushing will be this: what is the most effective design in terms of providing students access to secondary, tertiary, and contextual sources? There are more than a few angles here, including whether it's better to simply let students surf the Internet for contextual information about the books they're reading or the history they're learning, or whether there are ways to specifically limit that vast set of information. Likewise, one might focus on the difference between learning from primary source materials alone versus learning from primary source material supplemented by secondary sources, interpretations, and contextual information. Regardless, it is vital to consider pedagogy here, as well, and what kind of teaching goes best with what kind of information.
So yeah, that's jargony, I know. But it's also the kind of focused question that not only might help me get into a school that I do love, but also would set me up to be a successful doctoral student there, with a sufficiently nuanced, but also sufficiently broad research question.
University of Chicago, Committee on Social Thought
Now I haven't really chosen a specific research focus here yet, but the program is fascinating to me. Perhaps the most appealing part of this program is its breadth, and its inherent similarity to the St. John's education I received as an undergraduate. Indeed, the program shares common roots with St. John's and the "Great Books" curriculum - as well as the dialogic pedagogy - they use.
The Committee on Social Thought website states that students are encouraged to come without a specific dissertation topic already in mind, but rather a broader area. The purpose of the first two years, then, is to study a variety of works in that area, to select a dozen-ish of them, and then to begin laying the groundwork for doing a dissertation on the confluence of themes and ideas in those dozen books. So, really, it's like a Johnny's dream.
The broader area, however, is something I still need to think about. The application asks me to check a box: philosophy, literature, history, classics, or art history. I'm inclined towards literature and/or art history, and perhaps even the combination of the two. Peter Quince at the Clavier is, of course, an example of that intersection, and something I felt compelled to write about for fun. I'm leaning, however, towards an explicit study of art history in the form of music. That would be in line with my undergraduate thesis, on the one hand, but would allow me to reach far beyond the narrow scope that I began to explore in my paper about Beethoven's 3rd and 9th Symphonies.
Needless to say, this won't be as specific and jargony an application as my Stanford one will be, but I dare say it's not supposed to be. Rather, this program would signal a return to my educational roots, but at a much higher level of sophistication. And, armed with some knowledge of education and technology design, who knows what fun ways I'll come up with to synthesize my learning.
University of California Santa Clara, History of Consciousness
Besides having an awesome name, this program fulfills the requirement of being sufficiently cross-disciplinary and creative for my liking. The website notes that the program is "in transition," and that the next cohort will be a smaller-than-usual one, which doesn't necessarily bode well. But, on the other hand, that means that if I am not a good fit, it's extremely unlikely I'd get in.
I'm applying, however, because my intuition says that I am a good fit. Unlike Chicago, UCSC asks for applicants to have a fairly specific project in mind, and of the faculty research interests they list perhaps the most interesting to me is "global capitalism and cultural process." Now, I have almost no economics background, but culture and I spend a fair amount of time with each other, and the relationship between the two is the kind of question that I could easily get lost in for a few years.
That said I'm also intrigued by the possibility of formulating some of my own questions about culture and learning. More than any non-education program, it strikes me that I might be able to formulate the intersection of my questions about culture, learning, and technology into a single actionable research path. The question, of course, is if anyone at UCSC is interested in that kind of thing. If not, well, that's why I'm applying to five schools. If so, then maybe this is the place.
University of California San Diego, Communications
Yes, that is half of a green telephone at the top of their website.
The program here was described by someone I trust very much as "the only good communications program in the country." So I figure it's worth an application. Back before I enrolled in the LDT program, I looked long and hard at communications as a field that I might want to do graduate work in. I think that education ended up being the right choice in the short term, but now that I have at least some education background, branching out into a cross-disciplinary communications program makes sense.
One of UCSD's Communications listed sub-genres is, in fact, "mediational theories of mind and of learning." UCSD might be, for that reason, the perfect place to pursue something along the lines of a study of how people learn music, and in what role "communication" plays in that learning. That would be an outgrowth, in some ways, of my undergraduate studies combined with my graduate work at Stanford. In short, it would be wonderfully synthetic of what I have already done, meaning I can write a compelling application, and I would enjoy the hell out of studying it because I could go so much deeper into the issues at hand than I had an opportunity to as an undergraduate (or Master's student).
University of Hawaii, Educational Foundations
Perhaps the least "ambitious" of my applications, I nevertheless feel as though there are significant benefits to potentially staying in Hawaii and receiving a PhD from the School of Education at UH. For one thing, if Jericha and I want to live and work in Hawaii in the long term, I could do worse than getting a degree from UH. It's hard to explain, but I honestly believe that a PhD at UH will get you further in Hawaii than a degree from Stanford, Harvard, Yale, Oxford, or any other school. That's just the way it is here.
Beyond the practical, however, I'm happy to note that UH has a very interesting School of Education. Like all of UH's programs, the Educational Foundations program is cross-cultural. And, moreover, it strikes me as fairly interdisciplinary as well. That is, the goal is to understand what is at the heart of education, and how to build meaningful thought and learning processes that serve as a foundation for further learning. The question "How do we learn?" may be too broad for PhD work, but it's a good entry point, especially coupled with the cultural question: "In what ways do different people's learning differ, and what do various cultures and peoples have in common?"
In summary, I am legitimately excited about the possibilities in all five of these programs. What's more, the geography is agreeable as well. The three California schools are, of course, in the good parts of the state (two in the Bay Area, one in San Diego), the Hawaii school is, well, yeah. And the University of Chicago may be in Chicago, which would test my anti-Cubs patience, but is also the location of the Baha'i National Assembly for the United States, which would make Jericha very happy. Plus, a lot of people do swear by Chicago, and it does have a good reputation as big cities go.
Unfortunately, deadlines loom, and so I'll be holed up working for the next couple of weeks. Then, once I'm done, I'll be waiting for a few months. Ah, academia.
The result is that, as of today, I've made my decision as to where I'm applying, and for what. I don't think it's a perfect list, but it's a list, it's actionable, and I know - or at least strongly suspect - I would be happy in any of the programs I've narrowed my search down to. So, without further ado, here are the five programs.
Stanford University, Learning Sciences and Technology Design
I'll be applying to LSTD for the third time, and from a third completely different angle. When I was accepted to LDT I applied at both the Master's and PhD levels, but my application was broad and vague to a degree that made me an undesirable PhD candidate. Last year, I wrote a more specific statement of purpose, but unfortunately my specific interests didn't align with anyone at the University. This time, and now that I know the Professors better (and they know me better), I feel I can write an even better statement of purpose, and potentially latch on with a suitable advisor.
In short, the question I'm pushing will be this: what is the most effective design in terms of providing students access to secondary, tertiary, and contextual sources? There are more than a few angles here, including whether it's better to simply let students surf the Internet for contextual information about the books they're reading or the history they're learning, or whether there are ways to specifically limit that vast set of information. Likewise, one might focus on the difference between learning from primary source materials alone versus learning from primary source material supplemented by secondary sources, interpretations, and contextual information. Regardless, it is vital to consider pedagogy here, as well, and what kind of teaching goes best with what kind of information.
So yeah, that's jargony, I know. But it's also the kind of focused question that not only might help me get into a school that I do love, but also would set me up to be a successful doctoral student there, with a sufficiently nuanced, but also sufficiently broad research question.
University of Chicago, Committee on Social Thought
Now I haven't really chosen a specific research focus here yet, but the program is fascinating to me. Perhaps the most appealing part of this program is its breadth, and its inherent similarity to the St. John's education I received as an undergraduate. Indeed, the program shares common roots with St. John's and the "Great Books" curriculum - as well as the dialogic pedagogy - they use.
The Committee on Social Thought website states that students are encouraged to come without a specific dissertation topic already in mind, but rather a broader area. The purpose of the first two years, then, is to study a variety of works in that area, to select a dozen-ish of them, and then to begin laying the groundwork for doing a dissertation on the confluence of themes and ideas in those dozen books. So, really, it's like a Johnny's dream.
The broader area, however, is something I still need to think about. The application asks me to check a box: philosophy, literature, history, classics, or art history. I'm inclined towards literature and/or art history, and perhaps even the combination of the two. Peter Quince at the Clavier is, of course, an example of that intersection, and something I felt compelled to write about for fun. I'm leaning, however, towards an explicit study of art history in the form of music. That would be in line with my undergraduate thesis, on the one hand, but would allow me to reach far beyond the narrow scope that I began to explore in my paper about Beethoven's 3rd and 9th Symphonies.
Needless to say, this won't be as specific and jargony an application as my Stanford one will be, but I dare say it's not supposed to be. Rather, this program would signal a return to my educational roots, but at a much higher level of sophistication. And, armed with some knowledge of education and technology design, who knows what fun ways I'll come up with to synthesize my learning.
University of California Santa Clara, History of Consciousness
Besides having an awesome name, this program fulfills the requirement of being sufficiently cross-disciplinary and creative for my liking. The website notes that the program is "in transition," and that the next cohort will be a smaller-than-usual one, which doesn't necessarily bode well. But, on the other hand, that means that if I am not a good fit, it's extremely unlikely I'd get in.
I'm applying, however, because my intuition says that I am a good fit. Unlike Chicago, UCSC asks for applicants to have a fairly specific project in mind, and of the faculty research interests they list perhaps the most interesting to me is "global capitalism and cultural process." Now, I have almost no economics background, but culture and I spend a fair amount of time with each other, and the relationship between the two is the kind of question that I could easily get lost in for a few years.
That said I'm also intrigued by the possibility of formulating some of my own questions about culture and learning. More than any non-education program, it strikes me that I might be able to formulate the intersection of my questions about culture, learning, and technology into a single actionable research path. The question, of course, is if anyone at UCSC is interested in that kind of thing. If not, well, that's why I'm applying to five schools. If so, then maybe this is the place.
University of California San Diego, Communications
Yes, that is half of a green telephone at the top of their website.
The program here was described by someone I trust very much as "the only good communications program in the country." So I figure it's worth an application. Back before I enrolled in the LDT program, I looked long and hard at communications as a field that I might want to do graduate work in. I think that education ended up being the right choice in the short term, but now that I have at least some education background, branching out into a cross-disciplinary communications program makes sense.
One of UCSD's Communications listed sub-genres is, in fact, "mediational theories of mind and of learning." UCSD might be, for that reason, the perfect place to pursue something along the lines of a study of how people learn music, and in what role "communication" plays in that learning. That would be an outgrowth, in some ways, of my undergraduate studies combined with my graduate work at Stanford. In short, it would be wonderfully synthetic of what I have already done, meaning I can write a compelling application, and I would enjoy the hell out of studying it because I could go so much deeper into the issues at hand than I had an opportunity to as an undergraduate (or Master's student).
University of Hawaii, Educational Foundations
Perhaps the least "ambitious" of my applications, I nevertheless feel as though there are significant benefits to potentially staying in Hawaii and receiving a PhD from the School of Education at UH. For one thing, if Jericha and I want to live and work in Hawaii in the long term, I could do worse than getting a degree from UH. It's hard to explain, but I honestly believe that a PhD at UH will get you further in Hawaii than a degree from Stanford, Harvard, Yale, Oxford, or any other school. That's just the way it is here.
Beyond the practical, however, I'm happy to note that UH has a very interesting School of Education. Like all of UH's programs, the Educational Foundations program is cross-cultural. And, moreover, it strikes me as fairly interdisciplinary as well. That is, the goal is to understand what is at the heart of education, and how to build meaningful thought and learning processes that serve as a foundation for further learning. The question "How do we learn?" may be too broad for PhD work, but it's a good entry point, especially coupled with the cultural question: "In what ways do different people's learning differ, and what do various cultures and peoples have in common?"
In summary, I am legitimately excited about the possibilities in all five of these programs. What's more, the geography is agreeable as well. The three California schools are, of course, in the good parts of the state (two in the Bay Area, one in San Diego), the Hawaii school is, well, yeah. And the University of Chicago may be in Chicago, which would test my anti-Cubs patience, but is also the location of the Baha'i National Assembly for the United States, which would make Jericha very happy. Plus, a lot of people do swear by Chicago, and it does have a good reputation as big cities go.
Unfortunately, deadlines loom, and so I'll be holed up working for the next couple of weeks. Then, once I'm done, I'll be waiting for a few months. Ah, academia.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Exploring Research Questions
Having effectively joined the ranks of the unemployed following my resignation as Director of NALU Studies, I have begun not only looking at other jobs - which is lots of fun in the current market - but also looking at PhD programs. In the case of the former, my range is fairly narrow. I'm looking, basically, for work with schools that want to do technology integration in their curricula because, after all, that's what I got my Master's in. In the latter case, the angle is much more obtuse.
Pursuing a PhD is something that makes sense to me, as an avid writer, reader, and thinker. While the politics of the University world are somewhat abhorrent, the intellectual community is appealing nonetheless, and a doctoral degree hardly means that I'd have to stay in academia if I found it too distasteful. On the other hand, the real challenge here is not navigating politics or soft money, but rather defining an area of interest sufficiently narrow to ensure finding a fitting advisor and, ultimately, a fruitful dissertation.
For a generalist, however, that is a difficulty that cannot and should not be overlooked. Part of the appeal, indeed, of the specialized job of instructional technology and curriculum support is that it is, in reality, a generalists job. I would be the expert on what tools are available for classroom use, and good implementation practices, but I would (at least in theory) have the opportunity to work with teachers of English, history, science, math, music, foreign language, and anything else a given school offers. In short, I'd be a specialist who nevertheless gets to work across fields, who gets to talk to people who know, between them, know a lot about almost any subject you'd want to know about. Contrast that with most Universities, where the world is more insular, where conversations don't frequently happen across departments, and you'll see the appeal to a generalist and a learner of being able to span multiple disciplines.
So the challenge, given the fast approaching deadlines of many PhD programs, is defining not only a question, but even an area of study. Hence this post, which is more for me than my readers, as I try to explore the implications of a few ideas and, hopefully, get some ideas back in return.
Music
One of my first thoughts in my current exploration of graduate programs was, "Why not return to music?" I do love music, as the title of the blog suggests. The biggest challenge is that, though I am a marginally competent pianist, I am no expert, certainly not at the level that PhD programs expect. In the last two years, especially, my practice has been limited, and while I have more or less maintained my skills, I am no better at the piano now than I was as an undergraduate.
Nevertheless, my Senior Thesis at St. John's was a musicology paper, I was an assistant in music courses for three years, and I conducted a chamber orchestra. I don't think selling a program on my background would be easy, but it would be far from impossible. Which leaves the bigger issue of what part of music I'd like to study.
Regardless of the field of study I pursue, integrating some of my Stanford LDT knowledge is a no-brainer. And, ultimately, I'm still passionate about education. So the angle from which studying music is most appealing is the musical-cognition angle. That is, how do people learn to understand music? Perhaps there's a cultural and anthropological bent to that question: how does culture and language effect the learning of music? How, for example, does classical music differ from jazz harmonically, melodically, and rhythmically, and how would a classical musician describe those differences relative to a jazz musician? Beneath all of that, how does learning the music from one or the other perspective (and we could throw in many others, from pop music to modern rock to Hindu chants) influence the comprehension of the others?
It seems to me that there are two chief ways to explore those questions. The first involves neuroscience, studying cognition using brain waves and such. But that science is still in its infancy, and the more interesting angle (though probably the less fund-able one) is the anthropological one. The ethnography necessary to do research into any of those questions would be fascinating and enjoyable.
Another angle, here, is strict musicology, but that seems a little bland and self-serving. At least the above has implications for education, assuming schools ever teach music again, anyway. On the other hand, musicology could also be a curricular focus. Is there a way to teach music to students that combines theory, history, and appreciation. As it is, those are all usually separate classes (as the college level, of course). Why not make a single class that incorporates all of those? The question, I guess, is does that effort even belong in a PhD program, or is it more of a professional deal?
Fellow Johnnies will point out that St. John's does indeed combine those three points, which leads to a possible research project: how do students of St. John's music program compare to students who take music classes at other colleges? But that's a can of worms that leads to a different area of study, as well.
Education
Working towards a PhD in education makes some sense given my Master's in education, and I certainly feel I can ask a more sophisticated and specialized research question in this area than in any other. Of course, the question I'm most fascinated by brings with it certain challenges: St. John's and research are not always friends.
What I mean is, I'd love to study the differences between a St. John's education, a different liberal arts education, and normal University education, and a parochial education. I of course know that the curricula and pedagogy are wildly different, and I more or less know in what way and why. But the question is deeper than that: how do students in those various settings differ? What is the culture of St. John's compared to Williams College, compared to the University of Michigan, compared to a Community College? How much of that owes to geography, how much to pedagogy, how much to some other factor? Of course, the outcome piece is important, too: which graduates are more "successful," and in what ways?
I'm not convinced, however, that St. John's buys the kinds of processes that go into that kind of research project. I'm not sure I do, either. Try as they might, even the most objective education researchers usually have an axe to grind, and have biases built mostly (or even exclusively) on their own educational experiences. "Best practice," in that cynical world view, is "what worked for me." And, without a doubt, that's the challenge I would face. St. John's is, to me, one of the best colleges in the country, if not the best. Could I really overcome that bias and look at it objectively? Would St. John's even want me to? Do they care if they are "effective" in any modern, researchable sense?
Which leads me to narrower questions that might be more researchable, and still fit under education. For example, do students do better working from original source material alone, or do they do better working with secondary sources and interpretations? This question comes from a conversation I had at Stanford with a Professor there, and it still is fascinating to me. It captures a piece of St. John's, without a doubt (since Johnnies are discouraged from using secondary sources and interpretations, so much so that we're often asked not even to consider context). But it also captures high school English, where Hamlet is usually read without any accompanying documents.
The linchpin here is "better." What exactly constitutes "better?" Do secondary sources improve comprehension, interpretation, analysis? Do they improve creativity? Do they improve the level of conversation in the classroom? What's more, is there even a good way, pedagogically, to introduce them without being boring?
There are other rich angles here, as well, such as the differences between high school and college level students (which benefits more from secondary source material). Moreover, we might ask about the cultures of the schools and classrooms involved. Perhaps a lecture class is much better with secondary sources, but a discussion one is not. Or maybe it's the other way around? Who knows?
Needless to say, I could probably generate a good dozen questions that fit under the heading of education, but the underlying theme to all of them is the same: I want to know about the components of a St. John's education, and what makes it work (assuming it does). Discussion versus lecture is the key here, and that's a cultural question, which leads to a whole other kind of thought.
Anthropology
I have never taken a single anthropology class in my life, though the Alienation and Deprivation in Fiction and Education course at Stanford was close. I don't know the language, I don't know the research, and I don't know the questions. Nevertheless, the concepts keep hitting me again and again. Cultural anthropology is the kind of research I keep coming up with, even if it's in music, or education, or literature, or anything else.
Now there's no question that I am a math person, and I don't know what place math has in anthropological research. I'm wary of numbers, because too often we let them stand in for real meanings and real people. That said, mere anecdote does not knowledge make, and so the best bet is to combine the two. I'm sure that anthropology does this, but I simply don't know enough about it.
So what questions do I even have? Well, I don't have archaeological questions. That's not totally true, but I don't want to get a PhD in them. My questions are more about modern cultures, and especially the Internet. Ironically, though I do not use Facebook or Twitter, I'm fascinated by the cultural implications of both. A study of how social networking is effecting people's understanding of self and culture would be extremely interesting to me. And I'm sure it's already happening.
Anyway, that's just one of many questions in the anthropology world that appeals to me. Some of the questions from my music and education sections could probably fall under this heading as well. And that's the rub. How and where can I bring subjects together? What school is cross-disciplinary enough, what advisor enough of a generalist to help lead me through not only doing research, but narrowing my focus enough to be effective without gimping my generalist tendencies overmuch?
The truth is, I'm leaving off disciplines, even here. I've explored Stanford's Modern Thought and Literature program, which runs out of their English department. I've considered Linguistics. I won't rule out Neuroscience, even if I'd have a lot of catching up to do. I'd even consider Statistics!
The trick, to me, is not finding the right field, it's finding the right school and the right advisor, and then breaking the rules. My academic success has always been built upon stretching the limits of what is acceptable, whether that means turning in a poem instead of an essay (but a poem that is still an essay), or taking courses that don't fit into a degree but using them to inform projects, or purposefully trying to break rubrics.
Which is all well and good once I'm in a structured, academic environment, but I'm smart enough to realize that I need that structured environment, too. The rebel has to rebel against something. The innovator is only innovative relative to his surroundings. Finding a good environment, then, is the real key, and the truth of the matter is, I don't know what I'm looking for. Or, rather, I know exactly what I'm looking for, but I don't have the slightest clue how to find it.
But maybe that, more than anything else, suggests to me that I'm ready to work towards a doctorate.
Pursuing a PhD is something that makes sense to me, as an avid writer, reader, and thinker. While the politics of the University world are somewhat abhorrent, the intellectual community is appealing nonetheless, and a doctoral degree hardly means that I'd have to stay in academia if I found it too distasteful. On the other hand, the real challenge here is not navigating politics or soft money, but rather defining an area of interest sufficiently narrow to ensure finding a fitting advisor and, ultimately, a fruitful dissertation.
For a generalist, however, that is a difficulty that cannot and should not be overlooked. Part of the appeal, indeed, of the specialized job of instructional technology and curriculum support is that it is, in reality, a generalists job. I would be the expert on what tools are available for classroom use, and good implementation practices, but I would (at least in theory) have the opportunity to work with teachers of English, history, science, math, music, foreign language, and anything else a given school offers. In short, I'd be a specialist who nevertheless gets to work across fields, who gets to talk to people who know, between them, know a lot about almost any subject you'd want to know about. Contrast that with most Universities, where the world is more insular, where conversations don't frequently happen across departments, and you'll see the appeal to a generalist and a learner of being able to span multiple disciplines.
So the challenge, given the fast approaching deadlines of many PhD programs, is defining not only a question, but even an area of study. Hence this post, which is more for me than my readers, as I try to explore the implications of a few ideas and, hopefully, get some ideas back in return.
Music
One of my first thoughts in my current exploration of graduate programs was, "Why not return to music?" I do love music, as the title of the blog suggests. The biggest challenge is that, though I am a marginally competent pianist, I am no expert, certainly not at the level that PhD programs expect. In the last two years, especially, my practice has been limited, and while I have more or less maintained my skills, I am no better at the piano now than I was as an undergraduate.
Nevertheless, my Senior Thesis at St. John's was a musicology paper, I was an assistant in music courses for three years, and I conducted a chamber orchestra. I don't think selling a program on my background would be easy, but it would be far from impossible. Which leaves the bigger issue of what part of music I'd like to study.
Regardless of the field of study I pursue, integrating some of my Stanford LDT knowledge is a no-brainer. And, ultimately, I'm still passionate about education. So the angle from which studying music is most appealing is the musical-cognition angle. That is, how do people learn to understand music? Perhaps there's a cultural and anthropological bent to that question: how does culture and language effect the learning of music? How, for example, does classical music differ from jazz harmonically, melodically, and rhythmically, and how would a classical musician describe those differences relative to a jazz musician? Beneath all of that, how does learning the music from one or the other perspective (and we could throw in many others, from pop music to modern rock to Hindu chants) influence the comprehension of the others?
It seems to me that there are two chief ways to explore those questions. The first involves neuroscience, studying cognition using brain waves and such. But that science is still in its infancy, and the more interesting angle (though probably the less fund-able one) is the anthropological one. The ethnography necessary to do research into any of those questions would be fascinating and enjoyable.
Another angle, here, is strict musicology, but that seems a little bland and self-serving. At least the above has implications for education, assuming schools ever teach music again, anyway. On the other hand, musicology could also be a curricular focus. Is there a way to teach music to students that combines theory, history, and appreciation. As it is, those are all usually separate classes (as the college level, of course). Why not make a single class that incorporates all of those? The question, I guess, is does that effort even belong in a PhD program, or is it more of a professional deal?
Fellow Johnnies will point out that St. John's does indeed combine those three points, which leads to a possible research project: how do students of St. John's music program compare to students who take music classes at other colleges? But that's a can of worms that leads to a different area of study, as well.
Education
Working towards a PhD in education makes some sense given my Master's in education, and I certainly feel I can ask a more sophisticated and specialized research question in this area than in any other. Of course, the question I'm most fascinated by brings with it certain challenges: St. John's and research are not always friends.
What I mean is, I'd love to study the differences between a St. John's education, a different liberal arts education, and normal University education, and a parochial education. I of course know that the curricula and pedagogy are wildly different, and I more or less know in what way and why. But the question is deeper than that: how do students in those various settings differ? What is the culture of St. John's compared to Williams College, compared to the University of Michigan, compared to a Community College? How much of that owes to geography, how much to pedagogy, how much to some other factor? Of course, the outcome piece is important, too: which graduates are more "successful," and in what ways?
I'm not convinced, however, that St. John's buys the kinds of processes that go into that kind of research project. I'm not sure I do, either. Try as they might, even the most objective education researchers usually have an axe to grind, and have biases built mostly (or even exclusively) on their own educational experiences. "Best practice," in that cynical world view, is "what worked for me." And, without a doubt, that's the challenge I would face. St. John's is, to me, one of the best colleges in the country, if not the best. Could I really overcome that bias and look at it objectively? Would St. John's even want me to? Do they care if they are "effective" in any modern, researchable sense?
Which leads me to narrower questions that might be more researchable, and still fit under education. For example, do students do better working from original source material alone, or do they do better working with secondary sources and interpretations? This question comes from a conversation I had at Stanford with a Professor there, and it still is fascinating to me. It captures a piece of St. John's, without a doubt (since Johnnies are discouraged from using secondary sources and interpretations, so much so that we're often asked not even to consider context). But it also captures high school English, where Hamlet is usually read without any accompanying documents.
The linchpin here is "better." What exactly constitutes "better?" Do secondary sources improve comprehension, interpretation, analysis? Do they improve creativity? Do they improve the level of conversation in the classroom? What's more, is there even a good way, pedagogically, to introduce them without being boring?
There are other rich angles here, as well, such as the differences between high school and college level students (which benefits more from secondary source material). Moreover, we might ask about the cultures of the schools and classrooms involved. Perhaps a lecture class is much better with secondary sources, but a discussion one is not. Or maybe it's the other way around? Who knows?
Needless to say, I could probably generate a good dozen questions that fit under the heading of education, but the underlying theme to all of them is the same: I want to know about the components of a St. John's education, and what makes it work (assuming it does). Discussion versus lecture is the key here, and that's a cultural question, which leads to a whole other kind of thought.
Anthropology
I have never taken a single anthropology class in my life, though the Alienation and Deprivation in Fiction and Education course at Stanford was close. I don't know the language, I don't know the research, and I don't know the questions. Nevertheless, the concepts keep hitting me again and again. Cultural anthropology is the kind of research I keep coming up with, even if it's in music, or education, or literature, or anything else.
Now there's no question that I am a math person, and I don't know what place math has in anthropological research. I'm wary of numbers, because too often we let them stand in for real meanings and real people. That said, mere anecdote does not knowledge make, and so the best bet is to combine the two. I'm sure that anthropology does this, but I simply don't know enough about it.
So what questions do I even have? Well, I don't have archaeological questions. That's not totally true, but I don't want to get a PhD in them. My questions are more about modern cultures, and especially the Internet. Ironically, though I do not use Facebook or Twitter, I'm fascinated by the cultural implications of both. A study of how social networking is effecting people's understanding of self and culture would be extremely interesting to me. And I'm sure it's already happening.
Anyway, that's just one of many questions in the anthropology world that appeals to me. Some of the questions from my music and education sections could probably fall under this heading as well. And that's the rub. How and where can I bring subjects together? What school is cross-disciplinary enough, what advisor enough of a generalist to help lead me through not only doing research, but narrowing my focus enough to be effective without gimping my generalist tendencies overmuch?
The truth is, I'm leaving off disciplines, even here. I've explored Stanford's Modern Thought and Literature program, which runs out of their English department. I've considered Linguistics. I won't rule out Neuroscience, even if I'd have a lot of catching up to do. I'd even consider Statistics!
The trick, to me, is not finding the right field, it's finding the right school and the right advisor, and then breaking the rules. My academic success has always been built upon stretching the limits of what is acceptable, whether that means turning in a poem instead of an essay (but a poem that is still an essay), or taking courses that don't fit into a degree but using them to inform projects, or purposefully trying to break rubrics.
Which is all well and good once I'm in a structured, academic environment, but I'm smart enough to realize that I need that structured environment, too. The rebel has to rebel against something. The innovator is only innovative relative to his surroundings. Finding a good environment, then, is the real key, and the truth of the matter is, I don't know what I'm looking for. Or, rather, I know exactly what I'm looking for, but I don't have the slightest clue how to find it.
But maybe that, more than anything else, suggests to me that I'm ready to work towards a doctorate.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
