This weekend I drove up from Huntington Beach back to Palo Alto to work as a coach at the Challenge Success fall conference. It's a long drive, and I must admit it was somewhat surreal being back on Stanford's campus for the two days of the conference. Stanford is the kind of place that exists in a bubble, mostly out of time. The inside of the School of Education building, in particular, looks almost exactly as it did when I first arrived at Stanford in 2009, and it probably looked the same in 1979. My sense of awkward familiarity was aided, of course, by the presence of my picture on the "current doctoral students" wall and my still-extant mailbox in the basement (it even had mail in it). Since I'm technically "on leave" I shouldn't have been surprised, but I've become so invested in my new job at LePort that it's hard to remember that part of my identity which is, still, Paul Franz, Stanford PhD Student.
This dual identity was particularly in play while coaching. It is my Stanford background, not my teaching background, that brought me to Challenge Success. Being a teacher has made me a much better coach and facilitator, but it's my connection to educational research and best practice that makes me a quality - and indeed even minimally qualified - coach for CS sessions.
Challenge Success is a non-profit co-founded by Denise Pope, Madeline Levine, and Jim Lobdell. It grew out of what was at the time a very small but poignant strain of research which suggested that "successful" students around the country were actually stressed-out, unhealthy, and unhappy, and furthermore often engaged in manipulation and cheating. Denise's Doing School is an excellent ethnographic study that chronicles the problem. The goal of CS is to address this issue by coaching schools through a process which will help them implement research-based practices to reduce student stress and increase overall well being. At its core, this implies a culture shift away from a strict, zero-sum mentality in which success equals GPA and elite college enrollment to a more holistic view which includes honoring balance and non-academic (or non-traditional academic) achievements.
The suite of policy changes which Challenge Success schools have implemented over the past 10 years is expansive. For example, schools have switched to block schedules or added late days, implemented policies limiting homework, moved towards more authentic or project-based assessments, set aside more time for faculty collaboration (because it's not only successful students that can be over-stressed), started regular parent education programs, and countless other efforts.
It's truly inspiring to be even a small part of a conversation at a school trying to make radical cultural or structural change. The school I coached last year has been trying very hard to implement a test calendar and associated policies, and is now looking to start a series of regular teacher-to-teacher observations with a particular lens on how homework assignments are used in class, all in an effort to increase the quality of homework while decreasing its quantity. My new school this year already plans to pilot a block schedule, but their larger goals are deeply cultural: they want to take on the zero-sum culture of success that they feel has harmed their school community and taken the joy out of learning for their students.
Part of what is so effective about Challenge Success is that, as a coach, it is not my job to advocate wholesale restructuring on day one. Coaching is a process of gently guiding teams towards solutions that will most address their particular contexts, and which will have the largest impact while still remaining feasible in implementation. Tackling a deep-seated school culture problem starts with minor reforms, and with building a community of parents, teachers, students, and administrators who can work together to reach larger goals in the long term. Ultimately, it is the commitment of schools and the stakeholders therein (and, indeed, all of the stakeholders therein) that leads to the success of reform efforts.
As you might imagine, participating in this kind of conference required a pretty significant mind-shift for me after my first month teaching 8th graders. I was amused by how similar running a discussion with administrators, teachers, parents, and students was to running one of my literature discussions, but the content is so different, and the objectives so differently scaled. In my class, I'm trying to make a deep impact on each and every one of 13 students. As a coach, I'm trying to facilitate a process which will impact potentially hundreds (or thousands) of students, and many hundreds (or thousands) of adults, but my particular impact on any one person is immeasurably small. Both kinds of efforts - deep and narrow, and shallow and broad - are important, I think, and they are equally difficult to do well, but the concern with the individual that lies at the heart of teaching simply can't express itself in the same way in the coaching environment.
I'm satisfied that I get to experience both. I'm particularly satisfied because, after spending the weekend talking to people from schools other than LePort, I have an even deeper appreciation for how special my new employer is. Almost every significant, research-based solution that Challenge Success advocates is already in effect at LePort. We use a block schedule. Teachers have time to prepare and to plan, and are engaged in a culture of near-constant observation, feedback, and growth. Homework is minimal and always purposeful, and students have an hour-long homework period at the end of the day after classes are completed. Parent communication and education is one of LePort's greatest strengths. Above all, an emphasis on allowing each student to define their own success - rather than holding every student to the exact same, externally determined standard - is one of our core tenets. I may be the only person who has any kind of intimate knowledge of both Challenge Success and LePort, and it strikes me how much they share for two organizations with no contact. Then again, I likely wouldn't have ended up at LePort if it didn't embody the philosophies and employ the policies that I came to hold dear in my time at Stanford and with CS.
After even a month at LePort it has become easy for me to take for granted that LePort is how a school runs, but returning to the outside world - and returning, in particular, to Stanford at a conference attended by many of the best independent and public schools in California - I was reminded that, if LePort is not wholly unique, it's close. Even most elite schools still carry with them, at the end of the day, the legacy of "this is how education is done" and "this is what success means." I'm fortunate to teach somewhere that doesn't need to attend a Challenge Success conference because they got it right from the start.
On a personal note, I also took heart from a conversation I had in passing with Denise during the busy conference day. Often I felt somewhat out of place, this weekend, because I was no longer a researcher. Wandering around Stanford, it was easy to get caught up in Stanford's culture of success: high-quality, impactful, well-funded research leading to a tenure-track position at an elite institution. That's a path I've put aside, and however much I am satisfied with my choice, a part of me still wants to paint my decision to leave Stanford as a failure on my part, instead of as a healthy response to an untenable emotional situation. When I ran into Denise she sent me the message I needed to hear, surrounded as I was by the Academy writ large. In so many words, her message was that success isn't just about a degree from a prestigious university. She asked me how I felt about teaching, and I told her that I was having a blast, and loving it every day. "Good," she said, "I always knew you would. I'm so happy you found your place." I replied, with a smile, "Me too."
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Sunday, September 28, 2014
Friday, September 13, 2013
An Observation about Research on Video Games in Education
I'm hoping to get back into writing on this blog in the near future. In particular, I plan to write some short-ish posts to help collect my thoughts about video games, learning, and education. This first post is a kind of brief overview and problem statement. Others - including, I hope, some analysis of actual games - will follow.
Research on video games in education tends to fall into two broad camps. The first is research on "games for learning," a rebranding of "educational games." While games for learning have come a long way in the past few years, they are still by-and-large less interesting, less polished, and less fun than commercial games. They may be successful at teaching what they are trying to teach, but they have limited appeal beyond the specific curricular situation they were designed for. In some sense they are to commercial games what textbooks are to other books.
The second major camp of video game research in education is on the social aspects of gaming. This includes research on phenomena like guilds in MMORPGs, where under-performing students can sometimes show tremendous mathematical, organizational, and leadership ability within the context of the game whilst failing to exhibit those same qualities in the classroom. It also includes studies on gaming communities and the extend to which they are or are not communities of practice. By-and-large this kind of research focuses on multiplayer and social gaming, though there are exceptions.
In my reading of research from both of these camps, I've seen a general shortcoming that plagues many studies: while games are ostensibly part of the subject of the research, rarely is game genre, quality, or design taken into account by the researchers. It's as if we wanted to research books, and then didn't differentiate between Hamlet, The Lord of the Rings, and Rainbow Six. Those are books of wildly different genres, wildly different styles and time periods, and of various qualities (I doubt even Clancy himself would consider his book worthy of inclusion in a high school curriculum, for example).
I think this problem stems from the generational gap around games. While more and more researchers realize that games are a big deal - Constance Steinkuehler is fond of pointing out that the gaming industry outpaces movies and music combined in revenue these days - there are still precious few researchers who are actually gamers. What's more, the cultural stigma around games is that they are entertainment at best, and at worst social disease. To return to the book analogy, it's as if researchers on literature weren't avid readers, and indeed doubted whether books were legitimate forms of artistic and creative expression. A little skepticism is probably good, but skepticism should be born of familiarity, not ignorance.
Research on video games in education tends to fall into two broad camps. The first is research on "games for learning," a rebranding of "educational games." While games for learning have come a long way in the past few years, they are still by-and-large less interesting, less polished, and less fun than commercial games. They may be successful at teaching what they are trying to teach, but they have limited appeal beyond the specific curricular situation they were designed for. In some sense they are to commercial games what textbooks are to other books.
The second major camp of video game research in education is on the social aspects of gaming. This includes research on phenomena like guilds in MMORPGs, where under-performing students can sometimes show tremendous mathematical, organizational, and leadership ability within the context of the game whilst failing to exhibit those same qualities in the classroom. It also includes studies on gaming communities and the extend to which they are or are not communities of practice. By-and-large this kind of research focuses on multiplayer and social gaming, though there are exceptions.
In my reading of research from both of these camps, I've seen a general shortcoming that plagues many studies: while games are ostensibly part of the subject of the research, rarely is game genre, quality, or design taken into account by the researchers. It's as if we wanted to research books, and then didn't differentiate between Hamlet, The Lord of the Rings, and Rainbow Six. Those are books of wildly different genres, wildly different styles and time periods, and of various qualities (I doubt even Clancy himself would consider his book worthy of inclusion in a high school curriculum, for example).
I think this problem stems from the generational gap around games. While more and more researchers realize that games are a big deal - Constance Steinkuehler is fond of pointing out that the gaming industry outpaces movies and music combined in revenue these days - there are still precious few researchers who are actually gamers. What's more, the cultural stigma around games is that they are entertainment at best, and at worst social disease. To return to the book analogy, it's as if researchers on literature weren't avid readers, and indeed doubted whether books were legitimate forms of artistic and creative expression. A little skepticism is probably good, but skepticism should be born of familiarity, not ignorance.
Labels:
Education,
Games,
Learning,
research,
video games
Friday, November 30, 2012
The Challenge of New Research
Since last spring quarter, I’ve found myself in an awkward place as I try to work on my Qualifying Paper (QP). The ideal case, as one of my Advisors recently stated, is for students to decide on a QP topic during the spring of the 1st year, to read and conceptualize over the summer, to write a proposal in the fall, to collect data in the winter, and to write up the research in the form of a QP in the spring of the 2nd year. Very few students follow this idealized path, but my process is especially odd because there are a number of fundamental assumptions about the research process built not only into the pathway as a whole, but in the particular (and particularly ordered) milestones along the way.
Over the last year, I’ve increasingly come to identify myself as a Learning Analytics (LA) researcher. LA is a field which is in its infancy, and as such has very few established norms, seminal papers, and codified methods. My belief is that, like in other areas that have undergone data revolutions, education and education research will be totally upended by LA as it matures. In a world of easily available big data, in short, it’s increasingly difficult to justify research that ignores big data, especially if the primary reason for ignoring it is discomfort or a lack of expertise, and not its irrelevance (since it can be relevant to almost any research agenda).
The implications of a coming data revolution in education for an individual researcher who is still very much “in training” are many. I find myself torn in multiple directions, needing not only to develop a broad and deep understanding of existing literature in educational research – particularly on topics that interest me – but also needing urgently to develop computational and statistical competencies that go well beyond what is traditionally taught in schools of education. Regression models don’t cut it anymore.
This raises an essential point about the research process – particularly for an apprentice researcher – at this stage in the development of LA as a field. In traditional education research, tremendous emphasis is put on the development of good research questions. This is equally important in LA research, but with a key difference: in LA the most important and interesting questions are liable to arise well after data has been collected and analysis has already begun. In traditional research, collecting data before articulating, motivating, and conceptualizing key research questions and developing or appropriating instruments would be insanity. In LA – at least for a beginner who is still developing technical competencies, in addition to conceptual ones – it’s sometimes impossible to ask the question without first knowing what the data looks like, how it can be manipulated, and what kinds of questions are liable to yield interesting results.
Now, I’ve heard in my first year and a half as a PhD student the admonition that research should never be driven by methods. But research is always driven by methods. It’s a fine ideal to say that we should ask the most important and interesting questions, regardless of the methods necessary to answer that question, but in practice that’s an impossible way to do research. Now, what I’m not talking about here is the narrow refusal of so-called “quantitative” and “qualitative” researchers to use each other’s methods to answer questions. It is patently absurd for a researcher to refuse to ask a certain type of research question, generating the answer to which would require conducting interviews, simply because his own professional expertise is in regression models. That’s what collaboration is for.
No, what I mean is that in the very definition of what makes a good research question in Education there are implicit methodological biases that go well beyond the quantitative / qualitative divide. There are a set of methods which, though vastly different from each other, generally constrain the entirety of modern educational research. These are effective methods, no doubt, in many cases. They are tried and true, tested and approved, beloved and practiced. They are what any first year PhD student in a school of Education will be trained in, or at least exposed to, as a part of the core curriculum. They are what Advisors teach their advisees. I speak, of course, of regression modeling, of survey design, of psychological 2-by-2s, of “think alouds” and semi-structured interviews, of observation protocols, of video capture, of discourse analysis, of… you get the idea: the bread and butter of research in education. This set of methods for data collection and analysis constrains research questions, not because researchers cannot ask questions that these methods cannot answer, but rather because researchers do not call such questions research questions.
If I want to know how students use language in a Massive Open Online Course, broadly, I cannot use any of those existing methodologies without significantly altering my question. Such was my first pass at developing a research question, in which I planned to do discourse analysis on a sub-set of threads in the forums, sampled based on certain key elements (namely, debates around a particular problem from one of the problem sets). To do that research, however, would have been arbitrarily limiting, driven by the methods of traditional educational research. But the data set is so much richer than that. The problem is that there is no existing literature from which to borrow research questions, and no set of accepted methods for this kind of data that can help scope a research agenda. In falling back on traditional educational research, my first efforts at crafting a study were arbitrarily limiting, driven by a lack of technical expertise.
So what is the best question to pose? The answer is: the first question that an LA researcher needs to ask is exactly, “what is the best question to pose?” The first pass at data analysis ought to be driven by theory, of course, and a sense of what questions might be interesting, but the wonder of computation and massive data sets is that it is relatively cheap to get data, relatively cheap to test hypotheses with it, and relatively easy to totally change one’s research questions. In contrast to traditional educational research, where a change in research question may totally invalidate all of the collected data, in LA research there is so much data that ignoring significant chunks of it is essential to making progress in the first place.
In my case, in particular, the question generation process is even more emergent because my computational and statistical abilities are a work in progress. I know I am interested in language use, in one form or another, but I am still a novice in the area of Natural Language Processing (NLP), and thus do not know what questions are answerable and what are not. Every time I learn to do something new computationally, the possible research questions I might be able to ask change. As research questions change with technical skill, so to do the needs and demands for conceptual literature reviews. I’ve been hesitant to commit to a single conceptual framing, therefore, and to do an in-depth literature review because almost every week the interesting and important questions look so different that the literature I need to review changes.
What’s more, I can think of only one researcher / research team in LA so far that has done much NLP (Simon Buckingham Shum’s group at the Open University in the UK). Of course I should learn from Simon, but his research alone hardly constitutes a field from which I can draw on accepted norms, best practices, and a technical or conceptual training regimen. NLP itself is a fairly well-developed field, but as I begin to learn its methods and apply them to my big educational data sets I am faced with a conundrum: spend more time building technical expertise, or use my current expertise – limited though it is – to begin to do educational research. This is an important point: LA is not, in the end, a computer science field. It uses computer science, it uses NLP, it uses machine learning, it uses database management… but at the end of the day it’s a branch of educational research, with its roots in the Learning Sciences. I suspect many LA researchers – and particularly Educational Data Mining (EDM) researchers – would disagree with that statement, valuing the higher prestige ties to computer sciences and mathematics over the less sexy relationship with education, but I think it is vitally important that we don’t let computational power totally overwhelm the theoretical and scientific knowledge generated by the last century of research in education, lest we make the classic mistake of assuming that learning is simpler than it is.
So the question is unresolved: draw on expertise from NLP and other computational fields (data visualization, for example, and data mining for the purposes of clustering before performing NLP analyses) and thereby invest my time and energy into expanding my technical base, which in turn opens up richer and more interesting avenues for research, or begin to develop a stronger conceptual base for the kinds of research questions I feel I can ask now, and make progress on completing the QP. The answer, of course, is both. The problem, of course, is that each step in the former direction heretofore has forced a (totally unanticipated) redefinition of the problem in the latter. Add to this that the process of LA research is almost necessarily collaborative (in my case it is), and the problem becomes even more intractable. I cannot arbitrarily stop my collaborators from developing new and exciting questions simply because I have now invested time and energy into better conceptualizing a prior question. Ultimately, as I build my technical expertise, and as the field adopts norms and expectations, and as training in LA becomes more formal and less ad-hoc, this problem begins to go away, both for me and those who will come after me. But for now there is a tension.
Such is the challenge of doing new research.
Over the last year, I’ve increasingly come to identify myself as a Learning Analytics (LA) researcher. LA is a field which is in its infancy, and as such has very few established norms, seminal papers, and codified methods. My belief is that, like in other areas that have undergone data revolutions, education and education research will be totally upended by LA as it matures. In a world of easily available big data, in short, it’s increasingly difficult to justify research that ignores big data, especially if the primary reason for ignoring it is discomfort or a lack of expertise, and not its irrelevance (since it can be relevant to almost any research agenda).
The implications of a coming data revolution in education for an individual researcher who is still very much “in training” are many. I find myself torn in multiple directions, needing not only to develop a broad and deep understanding of existing literature in educational research – particularly on topics that interest me – but also needing urgently to develop computational and statistical competencies that go well beyond what is traditionally taught in schools of education. Regression models don’t cut it anymore.
This raises an essential point about the research process – particularly for an apprentice researcher – at this stage in the development of LA as a field. In traditional education research, tremendous emphasis is put on the development of good research questions. This is equally important in LA research, but with a key difference: in LA the most important and interesting questions are liable to arise well after data has been collected and analysis has already begun. In traditional research, collecting data before articulating, motivating, and conceptualizing key research questions and developing or appropriating instruments would be insanity. In LA – at least for a beginner who is still developing technical competencies, in addition to conceptual ones – it’s sometimes impossible to ask the question without first knowing what the data looks like, how it can be manipulated, and what kinds of questions are liable to yield interesting results.
Now, I’ve heard in my first year and a half as a PhD student the admonition that research should never be driven by methods. But research is always driven by methods. It’s a fine ideal to say that we should ask the most important and interesting questions, regardless of the methods necessary to answer that question, but in practice that’s an impossible way to do research. Now, what I’m not talking about here is the narrow refusal of so-called “quantitative” and “qualitative” researchers to use each other’s methods to answer questions. It is patently absurd for a researcher to refuse to ask a certain type of research question, generating the answer to which would require conducting interviews, simply because his own professional expertise is in regression models. That’s what collaboration is for.
No, what I mean is that in the very definition of what makes a good research question in Education there are implicit methodological biases that go well beyond the quantitative / qualitative divide. There are a set of methods which, though vastly different from each other, generally constrain the entirety of modern educational research. These are effective methods, no doubt, in many cases. They are tried and true, tested and approved, beloved and practiced. They are what any first year PhD student in a school of Education will be trained in, or at least exposed to, as a part of the core curriculum. They are what Advisors teach their advisees. I speak, of course, of regression modeling, of survey design, of psychological 2-by-2s, of “think alouds” and semi-structured interviews, of observation protocols, of video capture, of discourse analysis, of… you get the idea: the bread and butter of research in education. This set of methods for data collection and analysis constrains research questions, not because researchers cannot ask questions that these methods cannot answer, but rather because researchers do not call such questions research questions.
If I want to know how students use language in a Massive Open Online Course, broadly, I cannot use any of those existing methodologies without significantly altering my question. Such was my first pass at developing a research question, in which I planned to do discourse analysis on a sub-set of threads in the forums, sampled based on certain key elements (namely, debates around a particular problem from one of the problem sets). To do that research, however, would have been arbitrarily limiting, driven by the methods of traditional educational research. But the data set is so much richer than that. The problem is that there is no existing literature from which to borrow research questions, and no set of accepted methods for this kind of data that can help scope a research agenda. In falling back on traditional educational research, my first efforts at crafting a study were arbitrarily limiting, driven by a lack of technical expertise.
So what is the best question to pose? The answer is: the first question that an LA researcher needs to ask is exactly, “what is the best question to pose?” The first pass at data analysis ought to be driven by theory, of course, and a sense of what questions might be interesting, but the wonder of computation and massive data sets is that it is relatively cheap to get data, relatively cheap to test hypotheses with it, and relatively easy to totally change one’s research questions. In contrast to traditional educational research, where a change in research question may totally invalidate all of the collected data, in LA research there is so much data that ignoring significant chunks of it is essential to making progress in the first place.
In my case, in particular, the question generation process is even more emergent because my computational and statistical abilities are a work in progress. I know I am interested in language use, in one form or another, but I am still a novice in the area of Natural Language Processing (NLP), and thus do not know what questions are answerable and what are not. Every time I learn to do something new computationally, the possible research questions I might be able to ask change. As research questions change with technical skill, so to do the needs and demands for conceptual literature reviews. I’ve been hesitant to commit to a single conceptual framing, therefore, and to do an in-depth literature review because almost every week the interesting and important questions look so different that the literature I need to review changes.
What’s more, I can think of only one researcher / research team in LA so far that has done much NLP (Simon Buckingham Shum’s group at the Open University in the UK). Of course I should learn from Simon, but his research alone hardly constitutes a field from which I can draw on accepted norms, best practices, and a technical or conceptual training regimen. NLP itself is a fairly well-developed field, but as I begin to learn its methods and apply them to my big educational data sets I am faced with a conundrum: spend more time building technical expertise, or use my current expertise – limited though it is – to begin to do educational research. This is an important point: LA is not, in the end, a computer science field. It uses computer science, it uses NLP, it uses machine learning, it uses database management… but at the end of the day it’s a branch of educational research, with its roots in the Learning Sciences. I suspect many LA researchers – and particularly Educational Data Mining (EDM) researchers – would disagree with that statement, valuing the higher prestige ties to computer sciences and mathematics over the less sexy relationship with education, but I think it is vitally important that we don’t let computational power totally overwhelm the theoretical and scientific knowledge generated by the last century of research in education, lest we make the classic mistake of assuming that learning is simpler than it is.
So the question is unresolved: draw on expertise from NLP and other computational fields (data visualization, for example, and data mining for the purposes of clustering before performing NLP analyses) and thereby invest my time and energy into expanding my technical base, which in turn opens up richer and more interesting avenues for research, or begin to develop a stronger conceptual base for the kinds of research questions I feel I can ask now, and make progress on completing the QP. The answer, of course, is both. The problem, of course, is that each step in the former direction heretofore has forced a (totally unanticipated) redefinition of the problem in the latter. Add to this that the process of LA research is almost necessarily collaborative (in my case it is), and the problem becomes even more intractable. I cannot arbitrarily stop my collaborators from developing new and exciting questions simply because I have now invested time and energy into better conceptualizing a prior question. Ultimately, as I build my technical expertise, and as the field adopts norms and expectations, and as training in LA becomes more formal and less ad-hoc, this problem begins to go away, both for me and those who will come after me. But for now there is a tension.
Such is the challenge of doing new research.
Labels:
Education,
learning analytics,
process,
qualifying paper,
research
Thursday, February 2, 2012
On Choosing to Learn
In my Learning Sciences and Technology Design seminar we recently read a draft of an upcoming book by Dan Schwartz, a Professor here at Stanford. He argues that we need to reconsider our assumptions about assessment in order to better capture the things we actually care about as educators. Instead of evaluating student knowledge, understanding, or even skills, he argues, we should try to assess student choices. That is, what a information or skills a student knows, and even her ability to learn further information or skills is not as important as the decision to learn.
That choices are central to how we move through the world is perhaps obvious, but it is striking how infrequently choice is a core part of any assessment framework (multiple-choice tests certainly do not count as "choice" in the sense that Dr. Schwartz means it). Even forward-thinking educators tend to focus more on acquisition of skills or overly-ambiguous notions of "metacognition" or "critical thinking" than on the specifics of decision making. And specifics are the keys. "Making good choices" is as bad a curricular goal as "being able to organize the following events chronologically." A better option is a synthesis of the two, perhaps something to the effect of: "Given the task of explaining a historical event, choosing to organize parts of that event chronologically."
It seems to me that little education - indeed, even little of my own education, excellent though it has been - is organized around this kind of formulation. I believe that the most successful students end up adopting good strategies and making good choices, but Denise Pope's Doing School (about which I've written previously) suggests that a great many of our most successful students (if grades are our standard for success) in fact make terrible choices, ethically, academically, and even physically.
For my own part, I am struck by how often the schools I've attended - even Stanford - have not only tacitly accepted but in fact actively encouraged poor choices and unhealthy habits. And I don't just mean ambiguous moral choices, but concrete habits of mind and academic practice. For example, in spite of Stanford's ostensible lack of concern over grades, their various administrative policy practically forces students to waste hours of time engaged in a gamey calculus over which courses to take credit/no-credit, and which to take for a grade. If I choose not to engage in this practice, I put myself at a disadvantage in terms of various small-scale political interactions that are inevitable in a graduate school. On the other hand, the process itself, besides consuming intellectual energy better spend elsewhere, has undesirable effects on the way students engage with the particular courses they are not taking for a grade and the way professors engage with those students.
In other words, by separating this seemingly administrative cultural artifact from the curriculum, we've set up a situation where knowledge and skills are within the purview of the course, but where the most important actual decision making is made at an institutional level. In graduate school - which is at least theoretically preparation for a life in the academy - this is perhaps not overly troubling, but as we shift our gaze to undergraduate or k-12 education, it's easy to see that students are often well-taught to make bad learning choices by the broader curricula and institutions in which they find themselves. My rule of thumb for this kind of supposition is simple: if Stanford's graduate programs have a fundamental pedagogical or curricular problem, odds are that same problem can be found - and, indeed, is probably worse - at earlier stages of the education system.
So what is there to do? Unfortunately, it seems to me that this problem is virtually intractable in our current education system because it is endemic not merely to our curricula and pedagogy, but to our very culture, our policies, our institutions, and even our economics. That is, there is a good reason we teach bad choices in schools: because our political, economic, and social systems are built upon the majority of people making bad choices.
That choices are central to how we move through the world is perhaps obvious, but it is striking how infrequently choice is a core part of any assessment framework (multiple-choice tests certainly do not count as "choice" in the sense that Dr. Schwartz means it). Even forward-thinking educators tend to focus more on acquisition of skills or overly-ambiguous notions of "metacognition" or "critical thinking" than on the specifics of decision making. And specifics are the keys. "Making good choices" is as bad a curricular goal as "being able to organize the following events chronologically." A better option is a synthesis of the two, perhaps something to the effect of: "Given the task of explaining a historical event, choosing to organize parts of that event chronologically."
It seems to me that little education - indeed, even little of my own education, excellent though it has been - is organized around this kind of formulation. I believe that the most successful students end up adopting good strategies and making good choices, but Denise Pope's Doing School (about which I've written previously) suggests that a great many of our most successful students (if grades are our standard for success) in fact make terrible choices, ethically, academically, and even physically.
For my own part, I am struck by how often the schools I've attended - even Stanford - have not only tacitly accepted but in fact actively encouraged poor choices and unhealthy habits. And I don't just mean ambiguous moral choices, but concrete habits of mind and academic practice. For example, in spite of Stanford's ostensible lack of concern over grades, their various administrative policy practically forces students to waste hours of time engaged in a gamey calculus over which courses to take credit/no-credit, and which to take for a grade. If I choose not to engage in this practice, I put myself at a disadvantage in terms of various small-scale political interactions that are inevitable in a graduate school. On the other hand, the process itself, besides consuming intellectual energy better spend elsewhere, has undesirable effects on the way students engage with the particular courses they are not taking for a grade and the way professors engage with those students.
In other words, by separating this seemingly administrative cultural artifact from the curriculum, we've set up a situation where knowledge and skills are within the purview of the course, but where the most important actual decision making is made at an institutional level. In graduate school - which is at least theoretically preparation for a life in the academy - this is perhaps not overly troubling, but as we shift our gaze to undergraduate or k-12 education, it's easy to see that students are often well-taught to make bad learning choices by the broader curricula and institutions in which they find themselves. My rule of thumb for this kind of supposition is simple: if Stanford's graduate programs have a fundamental pedagogical or curricular problem, odds are that same problem can be found - and, indeed, is probably worse - at earlier stages of the education system.
So what is there to do? Unfortunately, it seems to me that this problem is virtually intractable in our current education system because it is endemic not merely to our curricula and pedagogy, but to our very culture, our policies, our institutions, and even our economics. That is, there is a good reason we teach bad choices in schools: because our political, economic, and social systems are built upon the majority of people making bad choices.
Labels:
academia,
assessment,
choices,
culture,
Dan Schwartz,
denise pope,
Education,
LSTD,
society,
Stanford
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
College Education, College Sports
The United States is the only country in the world that weds higher education and amateur athletics inextricably together. The University of Michigan, to most of us, is not just an elite post-secondary research institution, but a football team, the home of Denard Robinson, famous rival of Ohio State. If I type "michi" into Google, auto-complete suggests "Michigan Football," "Michigan State Football," and "Michigan Football Schedule." Somehow, this doesn't strike us as odd.
A narrow view of the phenomenon suggests that football is primarily a marketing mechanism. Schools like Michigan attract both perspective applicants and alumni donors by virtue of having a competitive and successful football program. Defeating rivals, landing in major bowls, and fielding exciting players are all a boon to the University as a whole because, like any good marketing, successful football leads to more visibility and more positive emotional associations with the school on the part of donors and prospectives. All of which is true. Football, in particular, is a wonderful way for American colleges and universities to promote their brand.
Branding alone, however, does not account for the phenomenon as a whole. Any given university may want a great football program - or a great athletics program broadly - for branding and marketing reasons, but does the system on the whole really benefit higher education all that much? While the University of Michigan may be better off with a great football team than with a bad one, is the entire state university system better off by virtue of their football programs? I don't have an answer for that question, but it's worth posing.
Now, it's well-nigh impossible to imagine American higher education without competitive athletics. College football won't be going away, even if we could somehow prove that college football is bad for universities and colleges. That said, a better understanding of where sports fits into the ecology of higher education in the United States might help us think about hot-button issues in college athletics, including the debate over whether or not athletes should be paid.
The argument over paying college athletes - and especially big-time football and basketball players - has been hashed and rehashed in popular media. In short, the argument for paying players is, essentially, that they are making tons of money for their schools (and for media companies) with almost no compensation. The argument, at its heart, is capitalistic: college athletes do not get to participate in the free market for their services and skills, and that is unfair because there is a substantial market that others are participating in (coaches, ADs, ESPN, etc) built upon those very skills. The argument against paying college athletes is, broadly, that college sports are supposed to be an amateur endeavor, and that colleges and universities are primarily geared towards educational missions. Enrolling in a university - even on a football scholarship - means that you are a student first and foremost. Paying athletes for playing college sports, then, would further degrade the educational mission of the university. At its heart, what this argument really says is, "colleges and universities are not a capitalistic free market; they're a socialized public service."
Now, I'm not going to weigh in on either of those arguments, because the debate seems to me to be taking place in the wrong arena. There's no question that college athletes ought - in a capitalist system - to be compensated at market value for the benefits they bring to their institutions. There's also no question that colleges and universities do not by-and-large operate in anything resembling a true capitalist system. The reality is, both sides are right because neither is willing to admit the systematic and philosophical assumptions of the other.
The debate, however, is academic, because the route we're traveling down is unequivocally the capitalistic one. So what is that likely to look like?
In a purely capitalistic, free market higher education system institutions would have to pay their own players according to their market value. Instead of offering a scholarship to a desired recruit, a football program would have to offer a scholarship plus a salary or contract. In essence, college athletics would become professional, and colleges and universities would create professional athletics teams that operate alongside the University. Realistically, a great many of the current D1 college athletics programs would not be able to afford the competition this would create, and so we'd be left with a small number of elite athletics programs at wealthy schools that can afford to fund not only athletic scholarships, but also player salaries. As a result, the little money that travels from athletic departments to other parts of the university - in the form of both media contracts and donations - would almost certainly disappear (hence athletics would truly be "alongside" and not really "part" of the university).
From the athlete's perspective, there's nothing particularly wrong with this. He is likely to be better off in this system than in the current one. Unless, of course, he is a she. Or plays a sport other than basketball and football. Or isn't quite good enough to warrant anything beyond a scholarship. In our current system, very few athletic departments are profitable, thanks in large part to the many sports that college athletes play but no one watches. In a system with increased payouts to athletes in high-profile sports, it seems unlikely that those unprofitable sports programs would continue. And in a free market, that's as it should be. If women's volleyball can't turn a profit - or at least break even - it shouldn't exist.
Now, all of my analysis here is built upon the assumption that colleges, and not media outlets or other companies, will be paying student-athlete salaries. I think that's a safe assumption, but someone might argue that an elimination of the amateur status of college athletes would have little effect on institutions themselves, as very very few college athletes would warrant exorbitant salaries that schools could not afford. Rather, they might say, companies like ESPN or Nike or whoever would be the real payees in the form of sponsorships and commercial spots and so on. That's a fair assumption, but free agency in other American - and international - sports leagues suggests to me that institutions overpaying for marginal players is a more likely outcome.
As for the educational missions of institutions of higher learning in the truly free market system, it seems to me that they will be little changed. The biggest change is happening already anyway: less and less public money would go towards colleges and universities, which in turn would search for new revenue streams, including, most importantly, increased tuition and decreased financial aid. Professionalization of college athletics might infuse new revenues into the higher education system, but those revenues would almost certainly be dedicated primarily (or exclusively) towards funding the professional athletics programs. More and more universities would have to adopt the D3 sports model, where every player is a walk-on and no athletic scholarships are awarded because of how expensive it would be to field a competitive (and therefore economically viable) athletics program.
There is a good argument for this kind of system: it would allow the great majority of institutions the chance to essentially do away with one of their biggest expenses (both in terms of money and human capital). In a free market, if the University of Hawaii cannot really afford a D1 football program (let alone D1 basketball, baseball, volleyball, etc), it simply won't have one. In the end, that might actually be better for the university.
It's not hard to see, of course, that this is the direction we're going. The super-conference phenomenon is a consolidation of the most economically robust football programs into a bloq that effectively excludes the University of Hawaiis of the world from the most meaningful and, therefore, lucrative events like big-time bowl games and high-profile rivalries. It is probably only a matter of time before athlete compensation becomes a reality, and college sports is professionalized, as the institutions that can afford to pay their football players will already have divided themselves from those that cannot. The end of the whole process is, ultimately, that college sports will be an extremely visible part of higher education, with very little actual bearing on the educational missions of those schools.
While the professionalization of college athletics may not have too direct a bearing on the educational missions of colleges and universities, the underlying trend towards increased capitalization will. That's it's own post, but some of the results are already apparent: increased tuition, more and more course content moving online (though frequently with only dubious credentials, if any at all, available to graduates), an increasingly large access divide among socio-economic classes (that is, rich white kids who can afford tuition go to elite states schools or liberal arts colleges, while poor minority students go to vocational schools or online for-profits), and an ever-growing student debt bubble. Which all raises a significant question that the sports debate largely ignores, but shouldn't: what is the purpose of college education, both for the student and for society at large?
A narrow view of the phenomenon suggests that football is primarily a marketing mechanism. Schools like Michigan attract both perspective applicants and alumni donors by virtue of having a competitive and successful football program. Defeating rivals, landing in major bowls, and fielding exciting players are all a boon to the University as a whole because, like any good marketing, successful football leads to more visibility and more positive emotional associations with the school on the part of donors and prospectives. All of which is true. Football, in particular, is a wonderful way for American colleges and universities to promote their brand.
Branding alone, however, does not account for the phenomenon as a whole. Any given university may want a great football program - or a great athletics program broadly - for branding and marketing reasons, but does the system on the whole really benefit higher education all that much? While the University of Michigan may be better off with a great football team than with a bad one, is the entire state university system better off by virtue of their football programs? I don't have an answer for that question, but it's worth posing.
Now, it's well-nigh impossible to imagine American higher education without competitive athletics. College football won't be going away, even if we could somehow prove that college football is bad for universities and colleges. That said, a better understanding of where sports fits into the ecology of higher education in the United States might help us think about hot-button issues in college athletics, including the debate over whether or not athletes should be paid.
The argument over paying college athletes - and especially big-time football and basketball players - has been hashed and rehashed in popular media. In short, the argument for paying players is, essentially, that they are making tons of money for their schools (and for media companies) with almost no compensation. The argument, at its heart, is capitalistic: college athletes do not get to participate in the free market for their services and skills, and that is unfair because there is a substantial market that others are participating in (coaches, ADs, ESPN, etc) built upon those very skills. The argument against paying college athletes is, broadly, that college sports are supposed to be an amateur endeavor, and that colleges and universities are primarily geared towards educational missions. Enrolling in a university - even on a football scholarship - means that you are a student first and foremost. Paying athletes for playing college sports, then, would further degrade the educational mission of the university. At its heart, what this argument really says is, "colleges and universities are not a capitalistic free market; they're a socialized public service."
Now, I'm not going to weigh in on either of those arguments, because the debate seems to me to be taking place in the wrong arena. There's no question that college athletes ought - in a capitalist system - to be compensated at market value for the benefits they bring to their institutions. There's also no question that colleges and universities do not by-and-large operate in anything resembling a true capitalist system. The reality is, both sides are right because neither is willing to admit the systematic and philosophical assumptions of the other.
The debate, however, is academic, because the route we're traveling down is unequivocally the capitalistic one. So what is that likely to look like?
In a purely capitalistic, free market higher education system institutions would have to pay their own players according to their market value. Instead of offering a scholarship to a desired recruit, a football program would have to offer a scholarship plus a salary or contract. In essence, college athletics would become professional, and colleges and universities would create professional athletics teams that operate alongside the University. Realistically, a great many of the current D1 college athletics programs would not be able to afford the competition this would create, and so we'd be left with a small number of elite athletics programs at wealthy schools that can afford to fund not only athletic scholarships, but also player salaries. As a result, the little money that travels from athletic departments to other parts of the university - in the form of both media contracts and donations - would almost certainly disappear (hence athletics would truly be "alongside" and not really "part" of the university).
From the athlete's perspective, there's nothing particularly wrong with this. He is likely to be better off in this system than in the current one. Unless, of course, he is a she. Or plays a sport other than basketball and football. Or isn't quite good enough to warrant anything beyond a scholarship. In our current system, very few athletic departments are profitable, thanks in large part to the many sports that college athletes play but no one watches. In a system with increased payouts to athletes in high-profile sports, it seems unlikely that those unprofitable sports programs would continue. And in a free market, that's as it should be. If women's volleyball can't turn a profit - or at least break even - it shouldn't exist.
Now, all of my analysis here is built upon the assumption that colleges, and not media outlets or other companies, will be paying student-athlete salaries. I think that's a safe assumption, but someone might argue that an elimination of the amateur status of college athletes would have little effect on institutions themselves, as very very few college athletes would warrant exorbitant salaries that schools could not afford. Rather, they might say, companies like ESPN or Nike or whoever would be the real payees in the form of sponsorships and commercial spots and so on. That's a fair assumption, but free agency in other American - and international - sports leagues suggests to me that institutions overpaying for marginal players is a more likely outcome.
As for the educational missions of institutions of higher learning in the truly free market system, it seems to me that they will be little changed. The biggest change is happening already anyway: less and less public money would go towards colleges and universities, which in turn would search for new revenue streams, including, most importantly, increased tuition and decreased financial aid. Professionalization of college athletics might infuse new revenues into the higher education system, but those revenues would almost certainly be dedicated primarily (or exclusively) towards funding the professional athletics programs. More and more universities would have to adopt the D3 sports model, where every player is a walk-on and no athletic scholarships are awarded because of how expensive it would be to field a competitive (and therefore economically viable) athletics program.
There is a good argument for this kind of system: it would allow the great majority of institutions the chance to essentially do away with one of their biggest expenses (both in terms of money and human capital). In a free market, if the University of Hawaii cannot really afford a D1 football program (let alone D1 basketball, baseball, volleyball, etc), it simply won't have one. In the end, that might actually be better for the university.
It's not hard to see, of course, that this is the direction we're going. The super-conference phenomenon is a consolidation of the most economically robust football programs into a bloq that effectively excludes the University of Hawaiis of the world from the most meaningful and, therefore, lucrative events like big-time bowl games and high-profile rivalries. It is probably only a matter of time before athlete compensation becomes a reality, and college sports is professionalized, as the institutions that can afford to pay their football players will already have divided themselves from those that cannot. The end of the whole process is, ultimately, that college sports will be an extremely visible part of higher education, with very little actual bearing on the educational missions of those schools.
While the professionalization of college athletics may not have too direct a bearing on the educational missions of colleges and universities, the underlying trend towards increased capitalization will. That's it's own post, but some of the results are already apparent: increased tuition, more and more course content moving online (though frequently with only dubious credentials, if any at all, available to graduates), an increasingly large access divide among socio-economic classes (that is, rich white kids who can afford tuition go to elite states schools or liberal arts colleges, while poor minority students go to vocational schools or online for-profits), and an ever-growing student debt bubble. Which all raises a significant question that the sports debate largely ignores, but shouldn't: what is the purpose of college education, both for the student and for society at large?
Monday, November 21, 2011
Questions for the Liberal Arts Major
The title is a bit misleading here. Basically, I'm working on drafting a dialogue (of all things) about the future of liberal arts education for my "Future of English Studies" course. The goal is, in short, to reimagine the St. John's College Great Books program - or something like it - with an eye towards important modern concepts like multiculturalism and technology. The fundamental question is, how much do you lose from the radical dialogic pedagogy of the college in modernizing it (or post-modernizing* it, I guess).
* Post-modernism still makes me viscerally uncomfortable, even as I recognize that almost everyone - including myself - with any semblance of education in the modern world believes in it implicitly. Truth is relative? Of course. Context matters? Duh. Moral sensibilities have more to do with culture than with eternal, Platonic forms? Yeah, I guess so. That doesn't change, though, that I also dislike post-modernism. I think this is in part due to its horrible name. Someone should have foreseen a problem with future naming of philosophical movements when they called their own time "modern." Someone else should have realized that calling the next movement "post-modernism" was also silly. What comes next? Post-post-modernism?
The goal in this post is not to write my draft, but to pose questions. That is, I don't even plan on trying to answer or discuss those questions here: that's what the dialogue will do. I just want to pose questions. So without further ado, here are, in no particular order, questions for the liberal arts major:
- Is it desirable for every student in a college to share a reading list with every other student?
- Is it possible to share a reading list in a multicultural curriculum?
- What makes for a good classroom discussion, and how important is a shared reading list - or even a shared reading - to that project?
- How could a St. John's-like program teach writing effectively without abandoning its pedagogical roots?
- What is more important to St. John's pedagogy: the illusion of equality in the classroom, the apparent absence of grades, the commitment to the shared reading (and no outside sources), or the participation of a sufficient percentage of the students in the class?
- How many students and tutors is ideal?
- What is the purpose of a liberal arts education? How can we justify it in the modern world?
- Could St. John's work as a multicultural institution? That is, is it merely the reading list, or is it the entire structure that is racist and sexist? (Can the subaltern speak?)
- Indeed, is higher education in general (not just St. John's) not culturally hegemonic?
- What subjects should make up "tutorials?" At St. John's we do Math, Laboratory, Music, and Language. Are these the best options? What is the goal of the tutorial?
- If Husserl's "Crisis of the European Sciences" organizes the traditional St. John's, what text or texts would best organize a modern St. John's?
- How should a student be assessed in a dialogic classroom?
- Is it possible to just update the reading list and keep everything else about St. John's the same?
- If we did update the reading list, what would be thrown out or condensed, and what would be added? Isn't it too ironic to have a multicultural, post-modern canon?
- What about increasingly prominent non-textual works of art and philosophy, like movies, documentaries, albums, and born-digital documents like blogs or video games? What would it mean to study these, and would it be possible to do so in a dialogic classroom?
- Can elements of the St. John's program be recreated online?
- What would a fully digital St. John's seminar look like; what would it gain over the traditional model, and what would it lose?
- How important is the credential to a liberal arts education? Practically and theoretically.
- How should questions like these even be decided? That is, how should a modern liberal arts program be run politically and socially?
I'm sure I could pose more questions, but this seems to me a good start. Of course, if you have any thoughts, I'm happy to hear them.
* Post-modernism still makes me viscerally uncomfortable, even as I recognize that almost everyone - including myself - with any semblance of education in the modern world believes in it implicitly. Truth is relative? Of course. Context matters? Duh. Moral sensibilities have more to do with culture than with eternal, Platonic forms? Yeah, I guess so. That doesn't change, though, that I also dislike post-modernism. I think this is in part due to its horrible name. Someone should have foreseen a problem with future naming of philosophical movements when they called their own time "modern." Someone else should have realized that calling the next movement "post-modernism" was also silly. What comes next? Post-post-modernism?
The goal in this post is not to write my draft, but to pose questions. That is, I don't even plan on trying to answer or discuss those questions here: that's what the dialogue will do. I just want to pose questions. So without further ado, here are, in no particular order, questions for the liberal arts major:
- Is it desirable for every student in a college to share a reading list with every other student?
- Is it possible to share a reading list in a multicultural curriculum?
- What makes for a good classroom discussion, and how important is a shared reading list - or even a shared reading - to that project?
- How could a St. John's-like program teach writing effectively without abandoning its pedagogical roots?
- What is more important to St. John's pedagogy: the illusion of equality in the classroom, the apparent absence of grades, the commitment to the shared reading (and no outside sources), or the participation of a sufficient percentage of the students in the class?
- How many students and tutors is ideal?
- What is the purpose of a liberal arts education? How can we justify it in the modern world?
- Could St. John's work as a multicultural institution? That is, is it merely the reading list, or is it the entire structure that is racist and sexist? (Can the subaltern speak?)
- Indeed, is higher education in general (not just St. John's) not culturally hegemonic?
- What subjects should make up "tutorials?" At St. John's we do Math, Laboratory, Music, and Language. Are these the best options? What is the goal of the tutorial?
- If Husserl's "Crisis of the European Sciences" organizes the traditional St. John's, what text or texts would best organize a modern St. John's?
- How should a student be assessed in a dialogic classroom?
- Is it possible to just update the reading list and keep everything else about St. John's the same?
- If we did update the reading list, what would be thrown out or condensed, and what would be added? Isn't it too ironic to have a multicultural, post-modern canon?
- What about increasingly prominent non-textual works of art and philosophy, like movies, documentaries, albums, and born-digital documents like blogs or video games? What would it mean to study these, and would it be possible to do so in a dialogic classroom?
- Can elements of the St. John's program be recreated online?
- What would a fully digital St. John's seminar look like; what would it gain over the traditional model, and what would it lose?
- How important is the credential to a liberal arts education? Practically and theoretically.
- How should questions like these even be decided? That is, how should a modern liberal arts program be run politically and socially?
I'm sure I could pose more questions, but this seems to me a good start. Of course, if you have any thoughts, I'm happy to hear them.
Labels:
classes,
dialogue,
Education,
higher education,
pedagogy,
personal,
St. John's,
Stanford
Sunday, October 23, 2011
Backwards Design and Higher Education
A note about the title: it's actually a joke. There really isn't any meaningful backwards design in higher education. But I'm not here to complain. No, there's actually very little backwards design at every level of education, and for the most part I've managed to enjoy being a student throughout my life. Even without backwards design, schools are wonderful places to establish networks, to have conversations, to try out ideas, and, if you put yourself in the right mental space, to learn by failing.*
* That could be its own post, but we'll save it for now.
Before I can say anything about higher education, I need to talk about backwards design, briefly. Back in 1998, Grant Wiggins - who happened to go to a very good Great Books college - and Jay McTighe wrote a book called "Understanding by Design." It's essentially a handbook for curriculum writers, advocating an approach that starts at the end and works its way backwards. This idea was hardly new to educational theory by 1998 - indeed, in one of my courses this week we've been reading a piece from 1949 that advocates the same idea - but for whatever reason the formulation by Wiggins and McTighe grabbed ahold of the world of educational practice.
The essence of the concept is this. First, you figure out what core idea or ability you want students to finish a class with, then you figure out how you're going to know whether they have it. And voila, you're curriculum is done!
That's not entirely true, but it's pretty close. Sure, you can import a handful of secondary and tertiary ideas or abilities with which students should gain familiarity, if not mastery. And sure, there's still the work of actually writing the curriculum after that. But figuring out the end goal and the assessment really is more than half the battle. I would say that, in writing my creative writing curriculum this summer, for example, I spent a good two or three weeks decided on an end goal and an assessment, and maybe a day or two on writing the actual curriculum from there. That is, once you know what you're trying to do, it's not so hard to figure out whether any particular activity or lesson plan fits into that bigger frame.
The funny thing is, in higher education this doesn't seem to happen at all. I could speak to my current classes - though a couple are better than others on this front - but rather I want to point out a deeper and less personal issue. It should seem obvious to anyone who has been to college or graduate school that the vast majority of Professors do not use anything resembling backwards design in their curricula (heck, most of them just stand up and lecture every week, and then have their TAs administer and grade a content-knowledge test at the end). The question is, why?
At the heart of the problem, it seems to me, is a dichotomous conflict between research and pedagogy. The difference between a Professor and a researcher at a think tank or consulting firm is, primarily, this: the Professor, in addition to doing research, teaches. Perhaps it is easier to find Professor jobs than pure research jobs, or perhaps Professors like the idea of and prestige associated with University positions. Regardless, once in the Academy, Professors do not, actually, get to choose one or the other. Or, rather, they are not assessed, themselves, on both fronts.
For the most part, academic survival depends upon research and publishing. While a great many people will defend the "publish or perish" mentality of the academic market as a necessary part of a meritocracy, it has an unintended side effect. Professors, because they are evaluated almost entirely on research, do not spend time or energy designing or executing their pedagogical functions. They are, in short, bad teachers. And they are not necessarily bad teacher by choice, but rather by necessity. A Lecturer (not a full Professor) at Stanford I spoke with this week related a story of a colleague whose Dean told him not to spend so much time teaching. "If you ever want to get tenure," he (more or less) said, "You have to cut back on your teaching and get to work doing research and publishing."
It's important to note that "cut back on your teaching" does not mean teach fewer courses. No, the admonition is to take your teaching less seriously, to spend less time and effort on designing a good curriculum, on employing effective pedagogy, on evaluating whether your students are understanding the material. The result, for students, is long, boring lectures and even longer, even more boring reading assignments that float aimlessly in an ethereal mist, never to be connected to their studies except in their own minds. In short, none of the habits of mind - design, making informed connections, creative generation of questions, and so on - that make for good research are modeled for students in the classroom.
So what does that have to do with backwards design? While Wiggins and McTighe talk mostly about courses, I think there's an argument to be made that educational structures as a whole can be subjected to a similar analysis. In the case of higher education - and especially graduate studies - the analysis leads to disturbing revelations.
- At the level of the individual course, there is no clear sense of what a student ought to be getting out of the course, nor how anyone (except maybe the student) will know whether the course succeeded.
- Institutionally, there is little coherence to the student experience except what the student is capable of bringing to it herself.
- It is not clear that the assessment procedures we have in place - that is, the dissertation - are effective measures of whether students are adequately prepared to do meaningful research.
I've hit on the first of these above, but the second two deserve quick explication.
Institutional incoherence is a big problem in the humanities in particular, where students routinely take ten years or more before they finish their studies. While there are many factors that cause this problem, one of the most important is the lack of clear objective for graduate students at an institutional level. That is, Universities do a very poor job of saying "what we want out of our PhDs in English is _____." Of course, they do generally have something to fill in that blank with, but it's rarely something that makes sense, or that would be agreeable across the department (let alone amongst students). Now, that may not be a problem, per se, except it leads to our other issue.
How do you assess outcomes (or processes, even) when you do not know what outcomes (or processes) you desire? In the case of the University, the dissertation has long been the be-all-end-all. Why? Because of tradition. Oh, sure, there's more to it than that, but not much more.
In the modern world, I think it's fair to ask whether the dissertation is an adequate reflection of whatever kind of learning students are meant to do. That is, the dissertation exists, primarily, as a kind of pre-monograph, a preface to a first book. But is our goal to turn all PhD students into writers of books, anymore? How many graduate school programs define their success based on whether or not graduates go on to publish books? While that may have been the model in the past, that publishing itself is undergoing rapid transformation in the modern age demonstrates that its probably not the best model for the future.
What's more, the dissertation is written, published, and defended individually. It is, perhaps, in some ancillary sense a collaborative experience, but it is still held up as an indication of individual achievement. The problem is, Professorial research is decreasingly individual. Collaboration has taken hold in much of the academy, and, indeed, part of the goal of graduate studies probably ought to be habituating students - many of whom have been stuck in highly uncollaborative environments through the whole of their academic lives - to working in teams. And yet, our final assessment is monolithic, and, what's more, it's almost unimaginable that it be anything but the work of a single person.
All of which shows not only a disconnect between purpose and assessment in higher education,* but a total lack of consideration of that disconnect. What is the purpose of a graduate education? How do we know that we've achieved that purpose?
* We haven't even touched undergraduate, which is its own messy can of worms.
A great many institutions obviously do a fine job creating future scholars, and so the system is working fine on a certain level. The question is not, however, if it has worked or if it is working, but rather how does it work and will it continue to work? Despite missing the kind of clear curricular structure I've mentioned above, the Academy has always has a resilience, thanks largely to its clever, self-motivated members. It is not clear, however, that survival alone means that the system actually works.
* That could be its own post, but we'll save it for now.
Before I can say anything about higher education, I need to talk about backwards design, briefly. Back in 1998, Grant Wiggins - who happened to go to a very good Great Books college - and Jay McTighe wrote a book called "Understanding by Design." It's essentially a handbook for curriculum writers, advocating an approach that starts at the end and works its way backwards. This idea was hardly new to educational theory by 1998 - indeed, in one of my courses this week we've been reading a piece from 1949 that advocates the same idea - but for whatever reason the formulation by Wiggins and McTighe grabbed ahold of the world of educational practice.
The essence of the concept is this. First, you figure out what core idea or ability you want students to finish a class with, then you figure out how you're going to know whether they have it. And voila, you're curriculum is done!
That's not entirely true, but it's pretty close. Sure, you can import a handful of secondary and tertiary ideas or abilities with which students should gain familiarity, if not mastery. And sure, there's still the work of actually writing the curriculum after that. But figuring out the end goal and the assessment really is more than half the battle. I would say that, in writing my creative writing curriculum this summer, for example, I spent a good two or three weeks decided on an end goal and an assessment, and maybe a day or two on writing the actual curriculum from there. That is, once you know what you're trying to do, it's not so hard to figure out whether any particular activity or lesson plan fits into that bigger frame.
The funny thing is, in higher education this doesn't seem to happen at all. I could speak to my current classes - though a couple are better than others on this front - but rather I want to point out a deeper and less personal issue. It should seem obvious to anyone who has been to college or graduate school that the vast majority of Professors do not use anything resembling backwards design in their curricula (heck, most of them just stand up and lecture every week, and then have their TAs administer and grade a content-knowledge test at the end). The question is, why?
At the heart of the problem, it seems to me, is a dichotomous conflict between research and pedagogy. The difference between a Professor and a researcher at a think tank or consulting firm is, primarily, this: the Professor, in addition to doing research, teaches. Perhaps it is easier to find Professor jobs than pure research jobs, or perhaps Professors like the idea of and prestige associated with University positions. Regardless, once in the Academy, Professors do not, actually, get to choose one or the other. Or, rather, they are not assessed, themselves, on both fronts.
For the most part, academic survival depends upon research and publishing. While a great many people will defend the "publish or perish" mentality of the academic market as a necessary part of a meritocracy, it has an unintended side effect. Professors, because they are evaluated almost entirely on research, do not spend time or energy designing or executing their pedagogical functions. They are, in short, bad teachers. And they are not necessarily bad teacher by choice, but rather by necessity. A Lecturer (not a full Professor) at Stanford I spoke with this week related a story of a colleague whose Dean told him not to spend so much time teaching. "If you ever want to get tenure," he (more or less) said, "You have to cut back on your teaching and get to work doing research and publishing."
It's important to note that "cut back on your teaching" does not mean teach fewer courses. No, the admonition is to take your teaching less seriously, to spend less time and effort on designing a good curriculum, on employing effective pedagogy, on evaluating whether your students are understanding the material. The result, for students, is long, boring lectures and even longer, even more boring reading assignments that float aimlessly in an ethereal mist, never to be connected to their studies except in their own minds. In short, none of the habits of mind - design, making informed connections, creative generation of questions, and so on - that make for good research are modeled for students in the classroom.
So what does that have to do with backwards design? While Wiggins and McTighe talk mostly about courses, I think there's an argument to be made that educational structures as a whole can be subjected to a similar analysis. In the case of higher education - and especially graduate studies - the analysis leads to disturbing revelations.
- At the level of the individual course, there is no clear sense of what a student ought to be getting out of the course, nor how anyone (except maybe the student) will know whether the course succeeded.
- Institutionally, there is little coherence to the student experience except what the student is capable of bringing to it herself.
- It is not clear that the assessment procedures we have in place - that is, the dissertation - are effective measures of whether students are adequately prepared to do meaningful research.
I've hit on the first of these above, but the second two deserve quick explication.
Institutional incoherence is a big problem in the humanities in particular, where students routinely take ten years or more before they finish their studies. While there are many factors that cause this problem, one of the most important is the lack of clear objective for graduate students at an institutional level. That is, Universities do a very poor job of saying "what we want out of our PhDs in English is _____." Of course, they do generally have something to fill in that blank with, but it's rarely something that makes sense, or that would be agreeable across the department (let alone amongst students). Now, that may not be a problem, per se, except it leads to our other issue.
How do you assess outcomes (or processes, even) when you do not know what outcomes (or processes) you desire? In the case of the University, the dissertation has long been the be-all-end-all. Why? Because of tradition. Oh, sure, there's more to it than that, but not much more.
In the modern world, I think it's fair to ask whether the dissertation is an adequate reflection of whatever kind of learning students are meant to do. That is, the dissertation exists, primarily, as a kind of pre-monograph, a preface to a first book. But is our goal to turn all PhD students into writers of books, anymore? How many graduate school programs define their success based on whether or not graduates go on to publish books? While that may have been the model in the past, that publishing itself is undergoing rapid transformation in the modern age demonstrates that its probably not the best model for the future.
What's more, the dissertation is written, published, and defended individually. It is, perhaps, in some ancillary sense a collaborative experience, but it is still held up as an indication of individual achievement. The problem is, Professorial research is decreasingly individual. Collaboration has taken hold in much of the academy, and, indeed, part of the goal of graduate studies probably ought to be habituating students - many of whom have been stuck in highly uncollaborative environments through the whole of their academic lives - to working in teams. And yet, our final assessment is monolithic, and, what's more, it's almost unimaginable that it be anything but the work of a single person.
All of which shows not only a disconnect between purpose and assessment in higher education,* but a total lack of consideration of that disconnect. What is the purpose of a graduate education? How do we know that we've achieved that purpose?
* We haven't even touched undergraduate, which is its own messy can of worms.
A great many institutions obviously do a fine job creating future scholars, and so the system is working fine on a certain level. The question is not, however, if it has worked or if it is working, but rather how does it work and will it continue to work? Despite missing the kind of clear curricular structure I've mentioned above, the Academy has always has a resilience, thanks largely to its clever, self-motivated members. It is not clear, however, that survival alone means that the system actually works.
Wednesday, October 12, 2011
An Alternative Pedagogy for the PhD Core
Introduction
Because my last post was a little bit negative, and perhaps somewhat dramatic,* I want to offer a constructive follow-up. Let me make explicit, first, the criticism that is really at the heart of yesterday's post. Then, I'll offer an alternative.
* I never, ever write overly-dramatic posts, do I?
The problem with my two required courses is that they are not, at least so far, good courses. One is a Doctoral Proseminar that every first year PhD student has to take. Its stated objectives are, in part, taking a broad look at the field of education research and, in part, getting to know the rest of the cohort. The other required course - the spark for yesterday's existential angst - is the first leg of a three course series of introductory research methods courses required within the first two years by all Education PhD students.
The How
How are these courses bad? Well, they are both co-taught, but there is not even a semblance of collaboration between the Professors co-teaching the courses. In both sections, one Professor gets up and lectures while the other sits around looking bored, only occasionally interjecting. At some point the Professors might switch places when the topic changes, but that's really it. There's no dynamic interaction, there's no prior planning, there's no engagement.
The lack of interaction is perhaps not damning, but the lack of student participation is. Now, a student in one of these courses might very well object that, yes, we do participate some. This is true. The lecture style in both classes is not pure, incessant blather. There is some opportunity for back-and-forth. But there is no room for dialogue, even so. The path of the "conversation" is, if not predetermined by the Professor, managed in its entirety by him.* Students don't have the opportunity to speak to each other without Professorial interpolation. That's not dialogue, that's Q&A.
* I say 'him' because three of the four Professors in question are male, and the three men are the chief pontificates.
A word on the classroom that both of these courses take place in. It's not exactly conducive to dialogue. It's basically a small-to-medium sized meeting hall, perfect for a breakfast get-together. There are a number of round tables that fit four people each, with a longer desk at the front of the room, in front of a SmartBoard (that, incidentally, none of the Professors knows how to use). At the back of the room is a blackboard. Notably, one wall contains creative artifacts made by STEP (Stanford Teacher Education Program) students, who use this same room more dynamically.
For a typical class, students will read a few articles and do a kind of preparation activity. In the Proseminar these are basically note-taking activities designed to reinforce good reading skills. In the methods course, these are writing activities, some of which have proven interesting and valuable, and others, well, yeah. My last post addresses that. Regardless, with the rare exception of some small-group work at the tables, whether a student has done the reading or not has no particular bearing on the course because the Professor simply stands around expounding about said reading for far too long, asking theoretically probing questions that the same five students answer.
In short, it's a typical University class. But what is striking is how different it is from my experience at this very University as a Master's student. It is said that the difference between the Master's level and the PhD level is that the latter is more focused on research. It seems that, in addition, because research is the important thing, pedagogy goes totally out the window as well.
A final note on the how and why of the problems with these required courses. In addition to troubling pedagogical practices, the curricula of both courses are far from compelling. There is no clear "this is what you're getting out of this class." That means that, while the assessments are fairly good, there's not a strong sense of how said assessments measure whatever it is that we as students are supposed to be learning. For example, the book review required in Proseminar may develop good habits of mind, but it does not connect in any meaningful way with the readings or the lectures, at least so far. In the methods course, we're supposed to design a study around our research interests and questions, but in the first three weeks (30% of the quarter), we've not even spoken about research questions, research design, or what makes for a good study, let alone actually done anything.*
* It's becoming a source of personal amusement that, in a certain sense, my tennis course is pedagogically superior to my other courses. Each session we show up, we warm up by working on whatever part of our skill set we want to, then the instructor shows us a new skill or a wrinkle on an old one and we go practice it for a half-hour as he wanders around giving pointers. And you know what? My ability to play tennis is improving much faster than my ability to research. I know it's not a totally fair analogy, but that doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about.
The Why
Why are these courses the way they are? Perhaps the Professors teaching these courses are doing it because they're trying to curry favor with the administration, and thus they don't want to invest in designing a strong curriculum or practicing good pedagogy. Perhaps the course curriculum, because it is designed by committee and not by the teacher, is innately unfocused. Perhaps no one has recognized the problems with the room the courses are housed in, and therefore hasn't tried to come up with a more engaging way of using the space.
Whatever the reason, at its heart is this: Stanford University, like most institutions of higher education, is primarily interested in research.* While many Professors like to teach, they frequently have little to no actual teaching training, and their jobs are in no way dependent on the quality of their teaching. Students, similarly, are generally less invested in classes** because they're wrapped up in research agendas and assistantships and meeting other requirements and trying to survive in the Bay Area on the roughly $20,000 a year they make as PhD students.
* Well, research and football, anyway.
** A quotation from a Doctoral student well-along on her path: "Your classes don't matter." In that case, I wonder, why do we have them at all?
In summary, Professors are not accountable to their employers for their teaching. They are accountable to their students, but their students don't particularly care whether they teach well or not. As a result, there's no particular motivation to improve a course, no particular need to assess whether it is "working" or not,* and no particular place for a student who does care about the quality of his courses (and the pedagogy therein) to voice concerns. It's a self-perpetuating, broken system. Except it's not broken at all: it's exactly what almost everyone involved wants it to be, which indicates that maybe the real problem is much, much deeper. But we'll have to leave that for another time.
* At Stanford in particular such an assessment would be confounded by the fact that most students here are extremely good at doing well in and taking as much as they can from poorly taught classes. Otherwise they wouldn't have made it to Stanford in the first place.
An Alternative Pedagogy
Vogon Guard: "Alright, so what's the alternative?"
Ford Prefect: "Well, stop doing it, of course! Tell them you're not going to do it anymore. Stand up to them!"
Vogon Guard: "Doesn't sound that great to me."
- Douglas Adams, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
The alternative to lecturing is, simply enough, not lecturing. The alternative to none - or few - students participating is getting them all to participate. Perhaps this is my St. John's education speaking, but I still think there's a lot to be gained from students talking to each other, and there's no reason that can't happen in these required courses.
How does that work? First of all, no more powerpoint slides. No more prepared lectures or conversational agendas. No more "this is what this article means" declarations. Questions - even pointed ones - to shape a conservation are fine, but presupposed answers are death to inquiry. If the goal is for new doctoral students to learn to interpret research, to discuss or analyze a text, and to be able to construct and argument as to what that text means, then it's imperative that they get practice at actually doing it. That does not mean "write a summary," that means dialogue, conversation, and argumentation.
So instead of two Professors trading off droning - with occasional interruption - at 30 students, let's put all of the manpower and brainpower in the classroom to work. Split the class into two groups of fifteen,* and send one Professor off with each group.** Sit in one great big circle, let the Professor ask a question about the text, and let the students work together to try to answer that question. Have, in other words, a dialogue.
* And rotate the groups around each week, so there's always a different mix in each group.
** Alternatively, split into even smaller groups - say five groups of six - and let the Professors float around, or put them into different groups each session.
Does that sound like St. John's? Of course it does. And why do I suggest it? Because it works. Stanford PhD students are smart people. If you put fifteen of them in a room with a text and ask them to figure out what it means and why it's important, odds are they're going to succeed. So why not give it a chance? They'll be developing interpretive skills, learning to talk to each other about research (which, vitally, may not even be in their area), and getting to know each other much better than they can when they're sitting four-to-a-table and being lectured at for two hours.
It is true that Professors are generally experts in these fields while students are not, but their wealth of experience does not mean that they are innately better readers than their students, or that they can say something more insightful about a text. What's more, even if they are better at those things, students will not learn simply by watching them talk. I cannot learn tennis without swinging for myself (and sometimes hitting it into the net), so how can I be expected to learn to speak to my future colleagues about research without being given a chance to do so, even if sometimes our interpretations are wrong, or we cut each other off, or we oversimplify? By doing will we learn, not by watching.
The Professor's role in this picture is to be the net. When I hit a tennis ball too short, I can tell. When I say something stupid, the Professor can chime in. But here's the really cool part: even that can be given over to students. If you let us talk to each other, we'll learn how to point out each other's mistakes, as much as highlight each other's strengths. In short, we'll form and learn to be a part of an intellectual community much like the one we're supposedly entering as future PhD-holding scholars.
Perhaps the objection could be raised that dialogue doesn't happen among Professors, either, and that therefore such a pedagogical system would not prepare students for the Academy. If that's so, then this alternative to lecturing becomes doubly important: we need academics who do more than merely pontificate, but who can actually communicate. The only way we'll get them is by training them to do so from the beginning. And anyway, it's a lot easier to transfer the ability to dialogue into giving a good lecture than the other way around.
A St. John's-ian dialogue, of course, is not the only valid alternative to a lecture class. Not all good classes are discussion classes. I do, however, pose it as a radical opposite pole. Somewhere in between is an equally good place where co-teachers actually work together, where the affordances of the room are taken into consideration when shaping the curriculum, and where the students are allowed to practice and be engaged with the material (and each other) for the whole two to three hours. Such pedagogical strategies exist. I wish that some enterprising Professor teaching a required, core course would use them.
Because my last post was a little bit negative, and perhaps somewhat dramatic,* I want to offer a constructive follow-up. Let me make explicit, first, the criticism that is really at the heart of yesterday's post. Then, I'll offer an alternative.
* I never, ever write overly-dramatic posts, do I?
The problem with my two required courses is that they are not, at least so far, good courses. One is a Doctoral Proseminar that every first year PhD student has to take. Its stated objectives are, in part, taking a broad look at the field of education research and, in part, getting to know the rest of the cohort. The other required course - the spark for yesterday's existential angst - is the first leg of a three course series of introductory research methods courses required within the first two years by all Education PhD students.
The How
How are these courses bad? Well, they are both co-taught, but there is not even a semblance of collaboration between the Professors co-teaching the courses. In both sections, one Professor gets up and lectures while the other sits around looking bored, only occasionally interjecting. At some point the Professors might switch places when the topic changes, but that's really it. There's no dynamic interaction, there's no prior planning, there's no engagement.
The lack of interaction is perhaps not damning, but the lack of student participation is. Now, a student in one of these courses might very well object that, yes, we do participate some. This is true. The lecture style in both classes is not pure, incessant blather. There is some opportunity for back-and-forth. But there is no room for dialogue, even so. The path of the "conversation" is, if not predetermined by the Professor, managed in its entirety by him.* Students don't have the opportunity to speak to each other without Professorial interpolation. That's not dialogue, that's Q&A.
* I say 'him' because three of the four Professors in question are male, and the three men are the chief pontificates.
A word on the classroom that both of these courses take place in. It's not exactly conducive to dialogue. It's basically a small-to-medium sized meeting hall, perfect for a breakfast get-together. There are a number of round tables that fit four people each, with a longer desk at the front of the room, in front of a SmartBoard (that, incidentally, none of the Professors knows how to use). At the back of the room is a blackboard. Notably, one wall contains creative artifacts made by STEP (Stanford Teacher Education Program) students, who use this same room more dynamically.
For a typical class, students will read a few articles and do a kind of preparation activity. In the Proseminar these are basically note-taking activities designed to reinforce good reading skills. In the methods course, these are writing activities, some of which have proven interesting and valuable, and others, well, yeah. My last post addresses that. Regardless, with the rare exception of some small-group work at the tables, whether a student has done the reading or not has no particular bearing on the course because the Professor simply stands around expounding about said reading for far too long, asking theoretically probing questions that the same five students answer.
In short, it's a typical University class. But what is striking is how different it is from my experience at this very University as a Master's student. It is said that the difference between the Master's level and the PhD level is that the latter is more focused on research. It seems that, in addition, because research is the important thing, pedagogy goes totally out the window as well.
A final note on the how and why of the problems with these required courses. In addition to troubling pedagogical practices, the curricula of both courses are far from compelling. There is no clear "this is what you're getting out of this class." That means that, while the assessments are fairly good, there's not a strong sense of how said assessments measure whatever it is that we as students are supposed to be learning. For example, the book review required in Proseminar may develop good habits of mind, but it does not connect in any meaningful way with the readings or the lectures, at least so far. In the methods course, we're supposed to design a study around our research interests and questions, but in the first three weeks (30% of the quarter), we've not even spoken about research questions, research design, or what makes for a good study, let alone actually done anything.*
* It's becoming a source of personal amusement that, in a certain sense, my tennis course is pedagogically superior to my other courses. Each session we show up, we warm up by working on whatever part of our skill set we want to, then the instructor shows us a new skill or a wrinkle on an old one and we go practice it for a half-hour as he wanders around giving pointers. And you know what? My ability to play tennis is improving much faster than my ability to research. I know it's not a totally fair analogy, but that doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about.
The Why
Why are these courses the way they are? Perhaps the Professors teaching these courses are doing it because they're trying to curry favor with the administration, and thus they don't want to invest in designing a strong curriculum or practicing good pedagogy. Perhaps the course curriculum, because it is designed by committee and not by the teacher, is innately unfocused. Perhaps no one has recognized the problems with the room the courses are housed in, and therefore hasn't tried to come up with a more engaging way of using the space.
Whatever the reason, at its heart is this: Stanford University, like most institutions of higher education, is primarily interested in research.* While many Professors like to teach, they frequently have little to no actual teaching training, and their jobs are in no way dependent on the quality of their teaching. Students, similarly, are generally less invested in classes** because they're wrapped up in research agendas and assistantships and meeting other requirements and trying to survive in the Bay Area on the roughly $20,000 a year they make as PhD students.
* Well, research and football, anyway.
** A quotation from a Doctoral student well-along on her path: "Your classes don't matter." In that case, I wonder, why do we have them at all?
In summary, Professors are not accountable to their employers for their teaching. They are accountable to their students, but their students don't particularly care whether they teach well or not. As a result, there's no particular motivation to improve a course, no particular need to assess whether it is "working" or not,* and no particular place for a student who does care about the quality of his courses (and the pedagogy therein) to voice concerns. It's a self-perpetuating, broken system. Except it's not broken at all: it's exactly what almost everyone involved wants it to be, which indicates that maybe the real problem is much, much deeper. But we'll have to leave that for another time.
* At Stanford in particular such an assessment would be confounded by the fact that most students here are extremely good at doing well in and taking as much as they can from poorly taught classes. Otherwise they wouldn't have made it to Stanford in the first place.
An Alternative Pedagogy
Vogon Guard: "Alright, so what's the alternative?"
Ford Prefect: "Well, stop doing it, of course! Tell them you're not going to do it anymore. Stand up to them!"
Vogon Guard: "Doesn't sound that great to me."
- Douglas Adams, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
The alternative to lecturing is, simply enough, not lecturing. The alternative to none - or few - students participating is getting them all to participate. Perhaps this is my St. John's education speaking, but I still think there's a lot to be gained from students talking to each other, and there's no reason that can't happen in these required courses.
How does that work? First of all, no more powerpoint slides. No more prepared lectures or conversational agendas. No more "this is what this article means" declarations. Questions - even pointed ones - to shape a conservation are fine, but presupposed answers are death to inquiry. If the goal is for new doctoral students to learn to interpret research, to discuss or analyze a text, and to be able to construct and argument as to what that text means, then it's imperative that they get practice at actually doing it. That does not mean "write a summary," that means dialogue, conversation, and argumentation.
So instead of two Professors trading off droning - with occasional interruption - at 30 students, let's put all of the manpower and brainpower in the classroom to work. Split the class into two groups of fifteen,* and send one Professor off with each group.** Sit in one great big circle, let the Professor ask a question about the text, and let the students work together to try to answer that question. Have, in other words, a dialogue.
* And rotate the groups around each week, so there's always a different mix in each group.
** Alternatively, split into even smaller groups - say five groups of six - and let the Professors float around, or put them into different groups each session.
Does that sound like St. John's? Of course it does. And why do I suggest it? Because it works. Stanford PhD students are smart people. If you put fifteen of them in a room with a text and ask them to figure out what it means and why it's important, odds are they're going to succeed. So why not give it a chance? They'll be developing interpretive skills, learning to talk to each other about research (which, vitally, may not even be in their area), and getting to know each other much better than they can when they're sitting four-to-a-table and being lectured at for two hours.
It is true that Professors are generally experts in these fields while students are not, but their wealth of experience does not mean that they are innately better readers than their students, or that they can say something more insightful about a text. What's more, even if they are better at those things, students will not learn simply by watching them talk. I cannot learn tennis without swinging for myself (and sometimes hitting it into the net), so how can I be expected to learn to speak to my future colleagues about research without being given a chance to do so, even if sometimes our interpretations are wrong, or we cut each other off, or we oversimplify? By doing will we learn, not by watching.
The Professor's role in this picture is to be the net. When I hit a tennis ball too short, I can tell. When I say something stupid, the Professor can chime in. But here's the really cool part: even that can be given over to students. If you let us talk to each other, we'll learn how to point out each other's mistakes, as much as highlight each other's strengths. In short, we'll form and learn to be a part of an intellectual community much like the one we're supposedly entering as future PhD-holding scholars.
Perhaps the objection could be raised that dialogue doesn't happen among Professors, either, and that therefore such a pedagogical system would not prepare students for the Academy. If that's so, then this alternative to lecturing becomes doubly important: we need academics who do more than merely pontificate, but who can actually communicate. The only way we'll get them is by training them to do so from the beginning. And anyway, it's a lot easier to transfer the ability to dialogue into giving a good lecture than the other way around.
A St. John's-ian dialogue, of course, is not the only valid alternative to a lecture class. Not all good classes are discussion classes. I do, however, pose it as a radical opposite pole. Somewhere in between is an equally good place where co-teachers actually work together, where the affordances of the room are taken into consideration when shaping the curriculum, and where the students are allowed to practice and be engaged with the material (and each other) for the whole two to three hours. Such pedagogical strategies exist. I wish that some enterprising Professor teaching a required, core course would use them.
Labels:
curriculum,
dialogue,
Education,
Learning,
lectures,
pedagogy,
phd,
professors,
Stanford
Monday, September 26, 2011
Two Research Ideas
One of my first assignments here at Stanford was to draft a possible research question and propose a methodology to use in answering that question. Because I have multiple interests, I wrote two.
The Dialogic Pedagogy of St. John's College
Questions
What is a dialogue? Obviously there is plenty of research about how to support dialogue in the classroom, and the role of discussions in learning. From my own limited experience, however, as a graduate student and as a teacher, there is a tremendous difference between dialogue as it is conceived in such research and dialogue as it occurs in, particularly, the classrooms of St. John's College.
As a graduate of St. John's, I have first hand experience in those classrooms. Far from providing answers, my experience only raises more questions. What is it about the culture, the pedagogy, and the organization of learning at St. John's that makes their classrooms unique? How is it that students in the St. John's seminar are able to speak so directly to each other about such complicated texts with minimal Professorial intervention? Or are they actually able to do so, after all? What is the relationship between the dialogic pedagogy of the college and its Great Books curriculum? Do they support each other, are they separable, or do they detract from each other? Perhaps most importantly: what, if anything, does the pedagogy – as distinct from the curriculum – have to teach educational systems at large?
All of these questions interest me, and they serve as a backdrop for a possible research agenda. In the short term, however, I want to focus particularly on undergraduate programs and dialogue. That is, I want to address this question: What constitutes a dialogue at St. John's, and how is it distinct from dialogues in other undergraduate academic environments?
Method
In order to begin to answer that questions, an initial qualitative, ethnographic foray into the college would be invaluable. A visit to the Santa Fe campus would allow me to conduct interviews with current students and faculty, as well as observe seminars in action with a researcher's – rather than a student's – eye. Video analysis of seminars could also be helpful, though that would require both the necessary equipment and approval from the school (recording of seminars is traditionally forbidden). While direct observation and interviews would only be possible when present, with permission and help I might be able to record video of a seminar or seminars throughout a semester or more.
In addition to doing qualitative data collection at St. John's, I would want to follow a similar interview and observation (and/or video analysis) protocol at another or other institutions. Perhaps the most feasible option would be to look at undergraduate courses at Stanford, as well as another local college or university (such as San Jose State). I would strive to find courses which describe themselves as “seminars” and which intend to use discussion-based pedagogies. I would strive, at this stage, to match specific content across the colleges in question.
Having collected my data, I would code and analyze in the qualitative tradition, with an eye towards answering my initial question, but also with the hope of discovering the appropriate path towards addressing the deeper questions that inspire my research.
Design in Game Development and Curriculum Construction
Questions
J.P. Gee, among others, has noticed that game developers do an excellent job of scaffolding learning into their products. That is, gamers learn how to play the game from simply playing it, whether because there is a built-in tutorial, or because the mechanics of the game are somehow made obvious by experimentation, or because the game is similar enough to other games in the genre that new players can be expected to transfer skills and strategies. Regardless, learning to play a game is a significant portion of what makes games fun.
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
I'm particularly interested in an analysis of the design process game and curriculum development, as it pertains to learning in those respective environments. The question is not, then, whether students learn better from games, or what games do so effectively. It is how games are designed and how that process differs in education.
Method
I believe this question lends itself to an ethnographic approach. On the one hand, ethnography of a game development studio – or, indeed, a multitude of studios, as different studios likely have different design processes – and on the other, a similar ethnography of a school or other academic institution engaged in curriculum and activity design. Many public schools, of course, have little say in the details of their curricula, so perhaps a textbook company or other curriculum developer (Foss, for example) would serve as an interesting foil instead.
Spending time observing and interviewing participants in the design processes in these two environments, I would hope to discover what, if any, vocabulary is shared, and what is different. I would also hope to see to what degree learning is an explicit or implicit part of the design process. I expect a variety of other notable differences might arise as well, in terms of relationship to prototyping, the degree to which the process itself arises organically during development, and the passion and engagement of the people working on the design, among other things.
Purpose
Ultimately, my hope is that the game design process might hold some keys as to how educators might help to unlock the powerful learning potential of games in education, without forcing us to conclude that boring “educational games,” irrelevant commercial games, or tacky gamification are the only options. That is, perhaps traditional learning might be benefit at the level of design from contact with the game design world. And, in reverse, perhaps the game design world can benefit from contact with the education design process.
Saturday, August 6, 2011
Economy, Purpose, and the Fallacy of Infinite Growth
Introduction: The Language of Economy
Let's put aside labels and their connotations for a minute. Words like "capitalism," "socialism," "communism," and even "economics" have way too much baggage and innuendo attached to be a part of a rational conversation. We've imbued them with Good and with Evil, and so one cannot be proclaimed a socialist or a capitalist without moral judgment following close behind. Once cannot speak of economics without the intensity of fear, anger, outrage, frustration, hope, and expectation.
Putting aside the labels and building from scratch, what ought the fundamental building blocks of a society be? That is, if we suddenly had the need to create a new nation, how should that nation be organized? I don't mean what branches of government it should have, or what kinds of political parties (if any at all). I mean something more fundamental than all of that. What should the motive force for the people of that society be? What should the implicit goal and purpose of individual and collective life be?
Building a Society
Freedom, it should be said, is not an end goal. There perhaps was a time when it made sense as one, as both the French and American revolutions demonstrate. But what does it mean to organize a life around freedom? It means little, because freedom is a way of doing things, and not a reason for doing things. To act for the sake of freedom is, in some measure, to act just because you can. "Because I can," is rarely a good reason for doing things.
Nevertheless, it goes without saying the people ought to be free, need to be free. While we might debate the meaning of "free," we can, I think, agree that any actual purpose in human life is best achieved when people are free. This has been the mistake of communist (and other) governments of the past: they change the end goal while doing nothing to improve the conditions necessary to make that end goal attainable. Without freedom, people cannot employ their creative energy towards their process, which prevents them from reaching a meaningful and successful outcome. Just as you cannot dictate the learning of a child and expect that child to actually learn, you cannot dictate the life of a man and expect that man to actually live.
So what kinds of goals should a society be organized around? Justice, like freedom, is not an end point, but a means. Peace is the same. How about, then, happiness? Indeed, the American Declaration of Independence suggests as much: "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness" are inalienable rights. Life and liberty are means, the pursuit of happiness is an end. A reasonable and desirable goal for both individual human life and for a society. Of course, we could probably come up with dozens of good goals, and reasons why each of them are flawed. The point, however, is that it makes sense to have a philosophical purpose for a society as an anchor around which laws, governmental systems, and, yes, even economies can be built.
The Constitution, of course, reads "Life, Liberty, and Property." Now, let's resist the urge to use those dirty economic words. Think, instead, about meanings. What, really, does it mean for property to be a right? It does not mean, importantly, that our society need be organized around money. Context does matter, here, however, and so it does mean that our society is not organized around the pursuit of happiness. That was a revolutionary campaign slogan with no power to shape the law.*
* Indeed, it probably sounds absurd to say that the law should be organized around the pursuit of happiness. One might even argue that the right to the pursuit of happiness is built into liberty, in every meaningful legal sense. That very well may be true, but it misses the point. The point is, liberty speaks to process, and pursuit of happiness speaks to outcome. Pursuing happiness is something you do, liberty is something you need in order to do it. In building a society, it does no good to speak solely of the means that people will have without speaking, to some degree, to the goals that will be supported and encouraged. You may argue that supporting and encourage goals is not the work of a government (or a society at large), but of course it is an inevitable outcome of having a society at all. What is a culture if not a set of supported and unsupported (or honored and shunned) actions? Indeed, even the most libertarian states and individuals tend to have a semblance of moral sensibility. If a society says that the pursuit of happiness is both right and a right, I suspect few would object on the grounds that said society is unfairly trying to control people. And if they did object on those grounds, they must be very upset at every other society ever, which have had more obscure and stricter moral goals than happiness.
What, then, is our society built around? There is no constitutional necessity that it be primarily commercial, despite the presence of "property." Increasingly, however, that is our shared end goal. Commerce, money, exchange... Acquisition is the measure of a life in the modern world. Why is this true? Because our culture - with some governmental aid, but let's not shift blame to those who simply enact our cultural will - had decided, globally, that property should be the primary purpose of both individual human life and of our social existence.
Now, I would be surprised if the majority of people would say that money ought to be the end goal of individual human life or society in general. I would also be surprised, however, if a careful examination of any individual life in the modern world would not include some concern for money. You see, regardless of how highly any individual person holds monetary gain, it is a kind of implicit measuring stick in our society, a measuring stick, what's more, that shapes behaviors and determines possible actions based upon a shared cultural understanding that certain amounts of money equate to certain material resources.
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that money is flawed in itself. It's a useful abstraction for many reasons. The problem is not money, but a global (and increasingly globalized) culture in which money is not merely a convenient way of ensuring that people's needs are met, but rather an entire organizing principle and end goal for human social life. Much like grades in school, money is an abstraction of achievement that bears some not inconsequential relationship to actual success, but which also misses the point entirely. If the purpose of going to school is to get good grades, and not to learn, then what good is school? Similarly, if the purpose of life is to acquire property, to hold money, to be rich, then what good is life?*
*Again, I beseech you to stay away from the language of socialism, capitalism, and so on. I am not talking about capitalism, here. I'm talking about the fundamental assumptions of our society and culture, and whether or not they make sense. If those assumptions are capitalist, if I am, therefore, a socialist... Well, then you've missed the point. The point is not to label, but to live.
It would be insanity to create a school where grades supersede learning in importance (and so, of course, in many schools this is the case). Insanity not because it doesn't make sense, but because it fails to go to the root of things. Indeed, it makes a lot of sense for students to pay more attention to grades than their learning, and so most do. What they miss, then, and what their teachers miss, is the opportunity for a more fulfilling, joyful, and meaningful experience.
Now lets take that entire paragraph and do it with society at large.
It would be insanity to create a society where money supersedes happiness in importance (and so, of course, in many societies this is the case). Insanity not because it doesn't make sense, but because it fails to go to the root of things. Indeed, it makes a lot of sense for people to pay more attention to money than to happiness, and so most do. What they miss, then, and their law makers and luminaries miss, is the opportunity for a more fulfilling, joyful, and meaningful experience.
Now you may say that there is no meaning to human existence, so who cares how society is organized? I would argue that that's just the money talking. Because money is so abstract, so inherently meaningless except as a kind of measure of materially full but spiritually empty success, a society built around it tends to produce citizens who find life meaningless. Why? Because they are right. True, they are free to find their own purpose, to organize their own lives around the pursuit of happiness or some other more meaningful goal, but at every turn they will be confronted with commerce, with their own money or lack thereof. It is no accident that many of even the most ardent supporters of a spiritual life live in material comfort (and why shouldn't they?): in a society built around money, it is hard to be seen as spiritually successful if you are not economically successful. We have an innate cultural bias against poverty.*
* Just as the school has an innate cultural bias against students with bad grades. We say those bad grades (that poverty) comes from laziness, from stupidity, from an inability to understand the system. The thing is, we've built the system not only so poverty (so bad grades) are possible, but in fact so that they are necessary. "The poor will be with you always" because, in a system built around money (grades) it is impossible for everyone - or even the majority - to succeed. So whose failure is it?
The Fallacy of Infinite Growth
Little of this, of course, is surprising. A society organized around X will tend to produce citizens who are deeply concerned with X, whether or not they think that X ought to be the purpose or goal of their own life or of society at large. What's more, if X is limited in its availability, it naturally follows that people will try to horde X, even at the expense of other leaving other members of their same society with too little X to survive.
Ah, but there's the problem. Everyone can have enough X. Everyone get an A in this class. Everyone can be rich.
The true, fundamental problem with organizing a society around money is none of what I've written above. Sure, it is troubling and frustrating to watch people (both successful and otherwise) come to believe that their lives are meaningless. Of course it's silly that we've fallen for the argument that money is the best way to assure happiness on a large scale (despite centuries of evidence to the contrary). Yes it's amazingly stupid that we've made even having a conversation about economics well nigh impossible thanks to how loaded the language surrounding it has become, in spite of the actual meaning of the words involved. But in spite of all of those problems, at the real core is this issue, which is tied up in human nature and evolutionary history: the fallacy of infinite growth.
Everyone can be, if not rich, well-off. A rising tide lifts all boats. Everyone can have X.
Except that's not true. There are complex reasons why not everyone can have an A in a class. Similarly, there are complex reasons why not everyone can be "well-off" in society. But there's a simple reason why a money-driven economy makes material comfort for all impossible. Finite resources, and the unsustainable nature of infinite growth.
Human beings evolved in a time and place where the size of the world and the resources in it were effectively infinite relative to the human population. Acquiring material goods made sense for small packs and tribes because, well, there was so much stuff around that was so hard to get that it was crazy not to stockpile, to horde, to protect, to be "rich." We have, built into our evolutionary psyches, a notion that the world will continue to support us no matter how much more of it we use. And for good reason: this has always been true.
The problem is, it's not true. Not at all. The world is manifestly finite in size, and therefore finite in resources. For all of the talk about renewable, sustainable energy and such, the simple fact remains: there is only so much stuff that we have access to. Now think about the assumptions of a society built around money, an economy built around growth... Recall that success and failure of companies in the modern world has less to do with profits, and more to do with growth of profits, with success relative to projections. A growing economy, we believe, is a healthy one. A growing world is a successful one.
Except the world cannot support more people (if it can even support how many we have now), and the economy cannot, fundamentally, grow ad infinitum. Even if there were good philosophical reasons to organize society around commerce (and the first part of this post has argued that there are not), there are practical reasons why it is ludicrous. What happens when we continue growing for the next twenty, fifty, or one hundred years? Where will the people go? Where will the energy come from? What resources will we be able to access?
An assumption of infinite growth may very well be built into human nature, but it's an assumption we need to overcome, nonetheless. Having seen the flaw of that assumption, it's impossible not to see the flaw of modern commerce: it cannot go on forever, because we cannot create ever more goods, ever more energy, ever more stuff when we only have a finite amount of stuff to begin with. It would not only be better to organize our society - our world - around a different principle than money. It will be necessary to do so.
Conclusion: Where Are We Going?
There is little reason to believe that there will be a fundamental change in the political economy of the modern world in the near future, despite the fact that such a chance is ultimately not only desirable, but necessary for the continued success of humanity as a species. The reason such a chance is impossible is cultural and linguistic: we lack the language to have the conversations we need to have in order to restructure our political world. We are stuck in a verbal shouting match, arguing over which deck chair should go where on a sinking ship.
It goes deeper than that, however. Our current political and economic systems are self-perpetuating. They make use of human nature to reinforce their tenets. They make dangerous assumptions that are not only left unexamined, but are in fact are transformed into boons with rhetoric. They serve no one - including the most successful - and yet are defended staunchly by even the least successful. How this is achieved is not totally clear: there's deception, of course, but no vast conspiracy. There's mis-education, but not explicitly. Above all, there's oversimplification and moralizing without any attempt to understand the roots of those processes.
With that in mind, the takeaway here should not be that "Capitalism is Evil." That's exactly not my point. Indeed, the mentality that capitalism, socialism, or any other economic system is innately good or evil is in fact a large part of the problem. True or not, those assessments forget to go to the root. They forget to ask, "How ought a society to be organized, especially in light of the material realities of the modern world (where infinite growth is an illusion that has been dispelled)?" They turn the entire conversation into an ideological shouting match, which, of course, only serves to perpetuate the existing cultural, social, and economic systems as they already are.
So what do I suggest? Well, that's hard to say. I think, above all, we need to engage in a conversation about purpose, about meaning, and about how we can better design a society, a government, and a world. That conversation must challenge assumptions. That conversation must undermine the belief that we should do things a certain way because it's natural to do so, or because we have always done so. As Descartes attempted with philosophy, we need now, in the modern world, to attempt with society: to start with a blank slate. We must ask, how ought we, as human beings, to design a society so that we all might live more fulfilling lives?
Let's put aside labels and their connotations for a minute. Words like "capitalism," "socialism," "communism," and even "economics" have way too much baggage and innuendo attached to be a part of a rational conversation. We've imbued them with Good and with Evil, and so one cannot be proclaimed a socialist or a capitalist without moral judgment following close behind. Once cannot speak of economics without the intensity of fear, anger, outrage, frustration, hope, and expectation.
Putting aside the labels and building from scratch, what ought the fundamental building blocks of a society be? That is, if we suddenly had the need to create a new nation, how should that nation be organized? I don't mean what branches of government it should have, or what kinds of political parties (if any at all). I mean something more fundamental than all of that. What should the motive force for the people of that society be? What should the implicit goal and purpose of individual and collective life be?
Building a Society
Freedom, it should be said, is not an end goal. There perhaps was a time when it made sense as one, as both the French and American revolutions demonstrate. But what does it mean to organize a life around freedom? It means little, because freedom is a way of doing things, and not a reason for doing things. To act for the sake of freedom is, in some measure, to act just because you can. "Because I can," is rarely a good reason for doing things.
Nevertheless, it goes without saying the people ought to be free, need to be free. While we might debate the meaning of "free," we can, I think, agree that any actual purpose in human life is best achieved when people are free. This has been the mistake of communist (and other) governments of the past: they change the end goal while doing nothing to improve the conditions necessary to make that end goal attainable. Without freedom, people cannot employ their creative energy towards their process, which prevents them from reaching a meaningful and successful outcome. Just as you cannot dictate the learning of a child and expect that child to actually learn, you cannot dictate the life of a man and expect that man to actually live.
So what kinds of goals should a society be organized around? Justice, like freedom, is not an end point, but a means. Peace is the same. How about, then, happiness? Indeed, the American Declaration of Independence suggests as much: "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness" are inalienable rights. Life and liberty are means, the pursuit of happiness is an end. A reasonable and desirable goal for both individual human life and for a society. Of course, we could probably come up with dozens of good goals, and reasons why each of them are flawed. The point, however, is that it makes sense to have a philosophical purpose for a society as an anchor around which laws, governmental systems, and, yes, even economies can be built.
The Constitution, of course, reads "Life, Liberty, and Property." Now, let's resist the urge to use those dirty economic words. Think, instead, about meanings. What, really, does it mean for property to be a right? It does not mean, importantly, that our society need be organized around money. Context does matter, here, however, and so it does mean that our society is not organized around the pursuit of happiness. That was a revolutionary campaign slogan with no power to shape the law.*
* Indeed, it probably sounds absurd to say that the law should be organized around the pursuit of happiness. One might even argue that the right to the pursuit of happiness is built into liberty, in every meaningful legal sense. That very well may be true, but it misses the point. The point is, liberty speaks to process, and pursuit of happiness speaks to outcome. Pursuing happiness is something you do, liberty is something you need in order to do it. In building a society, it does no good to speak solely of the means that people will have without speaking, to some degree, to the goals that will be supported and encouraged. You may argue that supporting and encourage goals is not the work of a government (or a society at large), but of course it is an inevitable outcome of having a society at all. What is a culture if not a set of supported and unsupported (or honored and shunned) actions? Indeed, even the most libertarian states and individuals tend to have a semblance of moral sensibility. If a society says that the pursuit of happiness is both right and a right, I suspect few would object on the grounds that said society is unfairly trying to control people. And if they did object on those grounds, they must be very upset at every other society ever, which have had more obscure and stricter moral goals than happiness.
What, then, is our society built around? There is no constitutional necessity that it be primarily commercial, despite the presence of "property." Increasingly, however, that is our shared end goal. Commerce, money, exchange... Acquisition is the measure of a life in the modern world. Why is this true? Because our culture - with some governmental aid, but let's not shift blame to those who simply enact our cultural will - had decided, globally, that property should be the primary purpose of both individual human life and of our social existence.
Now, I would be surprised if the majority of people would say that money ought to be the end goal of individual human life or society in general. I would also be surprised, however, if a careful examination of any individual life in the modern world would not include some concern for money. You see, regardless of how highly any individual person holds monetary gain, it is a kind of implicit measuring stick in our society, a measuring stick, what's more, that shapes behaviors and determines possible actions based upon a shared cultural understanding that certain amounts of money equate to certain material resources.
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that money is flawed in itself. It's a useful abstraction for many reasons. The problem is not money, but a global (and increasingly globalized) culture in which money is not merely a convenient way of ensuring that people's needs are met, but rather an entire organizing principle and end goal for human social life. Much like grades in school, money is an abstraction of achievement that bears some not inconsequential relationship to actual success, but which also misses the point entirely. If the purpose of going to school is to get good grades, and not to learn, then what good is school? Similarly, if the purpose of life is to acquire property, to hold money, to be rich, then what good is life?*
*Again, I beseech you to stay away from the language of socialism, capitalism, and so on. I am not talking about capitalism, here. I'm talking about the fundamental assumptions of our society and culture, and whether or not they make sense. If those assumptions are capitalist, if I am, therefore, a socialist... Well, then you've missed the point. The point is not to label, but to live.
It would be insanity to create a school where grades supersede learning in importance (and so, of course, in many schools this is the case). Insanity not because it doesn't make sense, but because it fails to go to the root of things. Indeed, it makes a lot of sense for students to pay more attention to grades than their learning, and so most do. What they miss, then, and what their teachers miss, is the opportunity for a more fulfilling, joyful, and meaningful experience.
Now lets take that entire paragraph and do it with society at large.
It would be insanity to create a society where money supersedes happiness in importance (and so, of course, in many societies this is the case). Insanity not because it doesn't make sense, but because it fails to go to the root of things. Indeed, it makes a lot of sense for people to pay more attention to money than to happiness, and so most do. What they miss, then, and their law makers and luminaries miss, is the opportunity for a more fulfilling, joyful, and meaningful experience.
Now you may say that there is no meaning to human existence, so who cares how society is organized? I would argue that that's just the money talking. Because money is so abstract, so inherently meaningless except as a kind of measure of materially full but spiritually empty success, a society built around it tends to produce citizens who find life meaningless. Why? Because they are right. True, they are free to find their own purpose, to organize their own lives around the pursuit of happiness or some other more meaningful goal, but at every turn they will be confronted with commerce, with their own money or lack thereof. It is no accident that many of even the most ardent supporters of a spiritual life live in material comfort (and why shouldn't they?): in a society built around money, it is hard to be seen as spiritually successful if you are not economically successful. We have an innate cultural bias against poverty.*
* Just as the school has an innate cultural bias against students with bad grades. We say those bad grades (that poverty) comes from laziness, from stupidity, from an inability to understand the system. The thing is, we've built the system not only so poverty (so bad grades) are possible, but in fact so that they are necessary. "The poor will be with you always" because, in a system built around money (grades) it is impossible for everyone - or even the majority - to succeed. So whose failure is it?
The Fallacy of Infinite Growth
Little of this, of course, is surprising. A society organized around X will tend to produce citizens who are deeply concerned with X, whether or not they think that X ought to be the purpose or goal of their own life or of society at large. What's more, if X is limited in its availability, it naturally follows that people will try to horde X, even at the expense of other leaving other members of their same society with too little X to survive.
Ah, but there's the problem. Everyone can have enough X. Everyone get an A in this class. Everyone can be rich.
The true, fundamental problem with organizing a society around money is none of what I've written above. Sure, it is troubling and frustrating to watch people (both successful and otherwise) come to believe that their lives are meaningless. Of course it's silly that we've fallen for the argument that money is the best way to assure happiness on a large scale (despite centuries of evidence to the contrary). Yes it's amazingly stupid that we've made even having a conversation about economics well nigh impossible thanks to how loaded the language surrounding it has become, in spite of the actual meaning of the words involved. But in spite of all of those problems, at the real core is this issue, which is tied up in human nature and evolutionary history: the fallacy of infinite growth.
Everyone can be, if not rich, well-off. A rising tide lifts all boats. Everyone can have X.
Except that's not true. There are complex reasons why not everyone can have an A in a class. Similarly, there are complex reasons why not everyone can be "well-off" in society. But there's a simple reason why a money-driven economy makes material comfort for all impossible. Finite resources, and the unsustainable nature of infinite growth.
Human beings evolved in a time and place where the size of the world and the resources in it were effectively infinite relative to the human population. Acquiring material goods made sense for small packs and tribes because, well, there was so much stuff around that was so hard to get that it was crazy not to stockpile, to horde, to protect, to be "rich." We have, built into our evolutionary psyches, a notion that the world will continue to support us no matter how much more of it we use. And for good reason: this has always been true.
The problem is, it's not true. Not at all. The world is manifestly finite in size, and therefore finite in resources. For all of the talk about renewable, sustainable energy and such, the simple fact remains: there is only so much stuff that we have access to. Now think about the assumptions of a society built around money, an economy built around growth... Recall that success and failure of companies in the modern world has less to do with profits, and more to do with growth of profits, with success relative to projections. A growing economy, we believe, is a healthy one. A growing world is a successful one.
Except the world cannot support more people (if it can even support how many we have now), and the economy cannot, fundamentally, grow ad infinitum. Even if there were good philosophical reasons to organize society around commerce (and the first part of this post has argued that there are not), there are practical reasons why it is ludicrous. What happens when we continue growing for the next twenty, fifty, or one hundred years? Where will the people go? Where will the energy come from? What resources will we be able to access?
An assumption of infinite growth may very well be built into human nature, but it's an assumption we need to overcome, nonetheless. Having seen the flaw of that assumption, it's impossible not to see the flaw of modern commerce: it cannot go on forever, because we cannot create ever more goods, ever more energy, ever more stuff when we only have a finite amount of stuff to begin with. It would not only be better to organize our society - our world - around a different principle than money. It will be necessary to do so.
Conclusion: Where Are We Going?
There is little reason to believe that there will be a fundamental change in the political economy of the modern world in the near future, despite the fact that such a chance is ultimately not only desirable, but necessary for the continued success of humanity as a species. The reason such a chance is impossible is cultural and linguistic: we lack the language to have the conversations we need to have in order to restructure our political world. We are stuck in a verbal shouting match, arguing over which deck chair should go where on a sinking ship.
It goes deeper than that, however. Our current political and economic systems are self-perpetuating. They make use of human nature to reinforce their tenets. They make dangerous assumptions that are not only left unexamined, but are in fact are transformed into boons with rhetoric. They serve no one - including the most successful - and yet are defended staunchly by even the least successful. How this is achieved is not totally clear: there's deception, of course, but no vast conspiracy. There's mis-education, but not explicitly. Above all, there's oversimplification and moralizing without any attempt to understand the roots of those processes.
With that in mind, the takeaway here should not be that "Capitalism is Evil." That's exactly not my point. Indeed, the mentality that capitalism, socialism, or any other economic system is innately good or evil is in fact a large part of the problem. True or not, those assessments forget to go to the root. They forget to ask, "How ought a society to be organized, especially in light of the material realities of the modern world (where infinite growth is an illusion that has been dispelled)?" They turn the entire conversation into an ideological shouting match, which, of course, only serves to perpetuate the existing cultural, social, and economic systems as they already are.
So what do I suggest? Well, that's hard to say. I think, above all, we need to engage in a conversation about purpose, about meaning, and about how we can better design a society, a government, and a world. That conversation must challenge assumptions. That conversation must undermine the belief that we should do things a certain way because it's natural to do so, or because we have always done so. As Descartes attempted with philosophy, we need now, in the modern world, to attempt with society: to start with a blank slate. We must ask, how ought we, as human beings, to design a society so that we all might live more fulfilling lives?
Labels:
assumptions,
capitalism,
constitution,
Economics,
Education,
history,
Money,
morals,
political economy,
Questions,
socialism,
society
Saturday, July 23, 2011
A Brief Thought on Final Exams
The long-awaited Part Four of the Beethoven series is finally in the works, but in the meantime, I wanted to talk a little about final exams.
In many subjects - particularly science and math - the culminating assessment of student learning is a final exam. Students are meant to demonstrate their understanding of the material by answering a massive collection of multiple choice and free response questions. In principle, this all seems like a good idea: after all, if the subject is really important enough that students should take the class in the first place, we need to make sure students know the material at the end of the course.
The problem is, there's no reason to believe that final exams (or tests in general) really do assess student knowledge in a meaningful way. What do I mean? Well, what is learning? I would argue that, for learning to really have occurred, students should retain the skills and knowledge from that learning well beyond the end of the course. What good is it to memorize the various organelles in a cell if two weeks after the test you won't remember them? Why do we test students on their ability to remember formulas that they will later be able to look up? Why do we force students to test alone when in their real lives they'll almost always be working with others (collaboration is called "cheating" on a final exam)?
My point, however, is not to raise those questions, but this one. How many students from your most recent class in which you had a final would pass that final if they took it again today? Would you pass your high school Chemistry final? Physics? Biology? Could you succeed on an Algebra test? Geometry? US History?
What values do we show when we design assessments that test knowledge that is not actually important or useful? Why do we make students demonstrate their learning by taking tests they will not be able to pass even months - let alone years - later? What good does that do?
Now consider the alternative: project based assessments, collaborative design challenges, even portfolios. I know mathematics and science teachers in particular might find those foreign to their subjects, but they meet a criterion that seems important to me. Students who can succeed at completing a Physics design challenge in high school will likely be able to complete that same challenge with the same level - if not greater - success later on in their lives. Why is that? Because that design challenge is testing the stuff we do care about, like collaboration, the ability to find and filter information, and, yes, physics content knowledge, but in a way that actually matters instead of in abstract and meaningless questions.
As I completed my own creative writing course this summer, I reflected on the wonder of teaching skills-based, instead of content-based courses. Assessment can be about growth, and can be designed in such a way that students could succeed equally well twenty years from now as they did this summer. But the "content-based" excuse for bad assessment is just that, an excuse.
In many subjects - particularly science and math - the culminating assessment of student learning is a final exam. Students are meant to demonstrate their understanding of the material by answering a massive collection of multiple choice and free response questions. In principle, this all seems like a good idea: after all, if the subject is really important enough that students should take the class in the first place, we need to make sure students know the material at the end of the course.
The problem is, there's no reason to believe that final exams (or tests in general) really do assess student knowledge in a meaningful way. What do I mean? Well, what is learning? I would argue that, for learning to really have occurred, students should retain the skills and knowledge from that learning well beyond the end of the course. What good is it to memorize the various organelles in a cell if two weeks after the test you won't remember them? Why do we test students on their ability to remember formulas that they will later be able to look up? Why do we force students to test alone when in their real lives they'll almost always be working with others (collaboration is called "cheating" on a final exam)?
My point, however, is not to raise those questions, but this one. How many students from your most recent class in which you had a final would pass that final if they took it again today? Would you pass your high school Chemistry final? Physics? Biology? Could you succeed on an Algebra test? Geometry? US History?
What values do we show when we design assessments that test knowledge that is not actually important or useful? Why do we make students demonstrate their learning by taking tests they will not be able to pass even months - let alone years - later? What good does that do?
Now consider the alternative: project based assessments, collaborative design challenges, even portfolios. I know mathematics and science teachers in particular might find those foreign to their subjects, but they meet a criterion that seems important to me. Students who can succeed at completing a Physics design challenge in high school will likely be able to complete that same challenge with the same level - if not greater - success later on in their lives. Why is that? Because that design challenge is testing the stuff we do care about, like collaboration, the ability to find and filter information, and, yes, physics content knowledge, but in a way that actually matters instead of in abstract and meaningless questions.
As I completed my own creative writing course this summer, I reflected on the wonder of teaching skills-based, instead of content-based courses. Assessment can be about growth, and can be designed in such a way that students could succeed equally well twenty years from now as they did this summer. But the "content-based" excuse for bad assessment is just that, an excuse.
Labels:
assessment,
collaboration,
Education,
final exams,
Learning,
tests
Thursday, July 7, 2011
Teaching in Gangsta's Paradise
Today in my creative writing class, students wrote essays about songs they brought in, discussing both the meaning and the writing of the lyrics. This is my own take on the assignment.
Coolio's Gangsta's Paradise moves me, precisely because I am the person the song is written to. I am that teacher, that intellectual, that political activist, that, well, white person who once thought it was easy to solve the world's problems. Education is the answer, right?
"They say I gotta learn, but nobody's here to teach me / If they can't understand it, how can they reach me?" Coolio's question towards the end of the song is, to me, the crux of his narrative. Having described life in the gang world – the complex mixture of pride, self-loathing, competition, fear, and brotherhood that comes with the kind of upbringing most eventual gangsters find impossible to escape – Coolio responds to my righteous indignation. He needs to get an education, I say. His response: you don't get it. He's right, I don't. And, what's more, I'm far from alone.
It's easy to take the next two lines as resignation: "I guess they can't; I guess they won't / I guess they front; that's why I know my life is outta luck, fool!" I would argue, however, that there's something else going on here. Indeed, this isn't resignation, but rather frustration and anger at the resignation of those few who are willing to try to teach the otherwise disenfranchised, the gangsters, the "dangerous." The problem is, that effort to teach is usually an effort to conquer, to impose, to "reform." "They can't" and "They won't" because they're afraid to try to understand a life that asks "I'm twenty-three now, but will I live to see twenty-four?" without irony or sarcasm.
What would it mean to be a teacher in a Gangsta's Paradise? There are plenty of teachers there, already. There are the ineffectual schoolteachers, who lament their students' stupidity, disobedience, and laziness, and then there are the brothers and fathers and uncles who teach their kids how to survive on the street, who have a more nuanced view of those students' flaws. Regardless, there's not much communication across those boundaries. The innocent outsider, there to solve the problem, is afraid to actually understand and experience the problem he or she wants to solve. The insider has more important things to worry about that than 19th century European History or Trigonometry.
I don't have solutions, myself. Even as a former teacher of at-risk and high-risk teens in Hawaii, some of whom were well-versed in the gang lifestyle, if only by proxy, there's no magic bullet to becoming a cultural insider. Taking away the expectation that teaching is about distributing knowledge is a start. Eliminating the distinction between teacher and learner is another step. But even the most radical and progressive pedagogy is no guarantee. Because, at the end of the day, you can't "front." You can't bullshit. And that's really hard for teachers to do.
Gangsta's Paradise is a brilliant, well-written song because it's not afraid to address the complexity, to challenge the assumption that access to knowledge and education makes all the difference. Beyond that, though, it's reflective, recognizing that the Paradise of the L.A. (or New York, or Honolulu) gang world has its own responsibility: "Tell my why are we, so blind to see / That the ones we hurt, are you and me." That does not absolve me, or those millions who are afraid to even acknowledge the issue, of responsibility. Rather, it only further illustrates how important it is not to be a conqueror, not to fight gang culture, or to try to "enlighten" the people caught in it. The process is subtler than that, and more risky. I should say, the process is subtler than that on the ground.
Higher up, the problem is starker, and very much analogous to the gang experience: "Power and the money, money and the power / minute after minute, hour after hour / Everybody's runnin, but half of them ain't lookin' / What's going on in the kitchen, but I don't know what's cookin." This could just as easily be about politicians, corporate leaders, banks, insurance companies as about gangsters themselves. What better example of the brilliance of the lyric writing could you find than this? The audience expands; we learn that we're all living in the same Gangsta's Paradise, where the ones we hurt are, far too often, you and me.
Gangsta's Paradise moves me, however, not because I can empathize. The analogy between the gang world and the commercial and corporate world may be apt, but it doesn't mean the experience is the same. No, what is moving is the challenge to my perceptions, the self-awareness and fear of the author, and, in spite of it all, the pride. I don't get it, but I do respect it, and that's a start.
Coolio's Gangsta's Paradise moves me, precisely because I am the person the song is written to. I am that teacher, that intellectual, that political activist, that, well, white person who once thought it was easy to solve the world's problems. Education is the answer, right?
"They say I gotta learn, but nobody's here to teach me / If they can't understand it, how can they reach me?" Coolio's question towards the end of the song is, to me, the crux of his narrative. Having described life in the gang world – the complex mixture of pride, self-loathing, competition, fear, and brotherhood that comes with the kind of upbringing most eventual gangsters find impossible to escape – Coolio responds to my righteous indignation. He needs to get an education, I say. His response: you don't get it. He's right, I don't. And, what's more, I'm far from alone.
It's easy to take the next two lines as resignation: "I guess they can't; I guess they won't / I guess they front; that's why I know my life is outta luck, fool!" I would argue, however, that there's something else going on here. Indeed, this isn't resignation, but rather frustration and anger at the resignation of those few who are willing to try to teach the otherwise disenfranchised, the gangsters, the "dangerous." The problem is, that effort to teach is usually an effort to conquer, to impose, to "reform." "They can't" and "They won't" because they're afraid to try to understand a life that asks "I'm twenty-three now, but will I live to see twenty-four?" without irony or sarcasm.
What would it mean to be a teacher in a Gangsta's Paradise? There are plenty of teachers there, already. There are the ineffectual schoolteachers, who lament their students' stupidity, disobedience, and laziness, and then there are the brothers and fathers and uncles who teach their kids how to survive on the street, who have a more nuanced view of those students' flaws. Regardless, there's not much communication across those boundaries. The innocent outsider, there to solve the problem, is afraid to actually understand and experience the problem he or she wants to solve. The insider has more important things to worry about that than 19th century European History or Trigonometry.
I don't have solutions, myself. Even as a former teacher of at-risk and high-risk teens in Hawaii, some of whom were well-versed in the gang lifestyle, if only by proxy, there's no magic bullet to becoming a cultural insider. Taking away the expectation that teaching is about distributing knowledge is a start. Eliminating the distinction between teacher and learner is another step. But even the most radical and progressive pedagogy is no guarantee. Because, at the end of the day, you can't "front." You can't bullshit. And that's really hard for teachers to do.
Gangsta's Paradise is a brilliant, well-written song because it's not afraid to address the complexity, to challenge the assumption that access to knowledge and education makes all the difference. Beyond that, though, it's reflective, recognizing that the Paradise of the L.A. (or New York, or Honolulu) gang world has its own responsibility: "Tell my why are we, so blind to see / That the ones we hurt, are you and me." That does not absolve me, or those millions who are afraid to even acknowledge the issue, of responsibility. Rather, it only further illustrates how important it is not to be a conqueror, not to fight gang culture, or to try to "enlighten" the people caught in it. The process is subtler than that, and more risky. I should say, the process is subtler than that on the ground.
Higher up, the problem is starker, and very much analogous to the gang experience: "Power and the money, money and the power / minute after minute, hour after hour / Everybody's runnin, but half of them ain't lookin' / What's going on in the kitchen, but I don't know what's cookin." This could just as easily be about politicians, corporate leaders, banks, insurance companies as about gangsters themselves. What better example of the brilliance of the lyric writing could you find than this? The audience expands; we learn that we're all living in the same Gangsta's Paradise, where the ones we hurt are, far too often, you and me.
Gangsta's Paradise moves me, however, not because I can empathize. The analogy between the gang world and the commercial and corporate world may be apt, but it doesn't mean the experience is the same. No, what is moving is the challenge to my perceptions, the self-awareness and fear of the author, and, in spite of it all, the pride. I don't get it, but I do respect it, and that's a start.
Labels:
coolio,
Education,
gangs,
gangsta's paradise,
literature,
lyrics,
Music,
Poetry,
teaching
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Designing Learning
It's easy to think that learning is what happens at school. It's not particularly difficult to imagine other places of learning to go alongside the classroom: museums, for example, or (many years ago) libraries. It's a little more challenging to imagine learning taking place while watching TV or playing a video game, sending a text message or reading an email. But as long as the mind is remotely active, I would argue that learning, in some form, happens.
Now, it's not particularly interesting that learning happens all the time. In some ways, it's so obvious that it's hardly worth mentioning, and so much of our learning is so mundane that we'd rather not hear or think about it for fear of choking on our boredom. Learning, for example, that it's slightly faster - or at least more pleasant - to walk to the left of the science building on the way to class in the morning, is not particularly groundbreaking for anyone, including the learner (unless he were to fall through an unnoticed but open manhole, but that's not the point).
No, what's particularly interesting about this learning that happens all the time is how much of it is designed, despite how incidental it seems. That is, even the route from car to classroom is designed in some sense, if not with learning in mind, with learning as a kind of ancillary and unanticipated outcome. Of course, a science building on the whole very much is designed with learning in mind in a much more direct way. And that's only the beginning.
Rather than list all of the myriad areas where learning design is potentially relevant, I want to talk about a couple in particular, an obvious one and a not-so-obvious one. The first is the school, the classroom, the curriculum. The second, video games, and not those horrid "educational games," so many of which pollute the game-o-sphere with their terrible controls, their convoluted plots, and their utter disdain for fun. No, I mean real games, games like Portal or Final Fantasy, Civilization or Little Big Planet.
What do I want to say about each of the very different worlds of game design, on the one hand, and traditional education, on the other? Well, I want to say that, at their hearts, they share a fundamental commonality: they are both designed, and they are both deeply concerned with learning. Now, education might shun the "design" label and games might shun the "learning," but words are just words, and the actual actions behind these particular words bridge the vocabulary gap with or without my help.
That game design and curriculum construction have much in common is hardly a unique idea. James Gee's career, for example, is largely built on recognizing the parallels between gaming and more traditional teaching and learning. It is my opinion, however, that there's more that could be done here, not just in recognizing and defining those parallels, but in uncovering how the two might inform each other better, seeing what game design has to teach educators, and what educators have to teach game design. I would not be surprised, moreover, if the expected conversation - that is, with game design bringing an understanding of design, and education bringing an understanding of learning - is totally reversed. Game designers may know a lot more about learning than we'd like to give them credit for,* and educators more about design, even if they're using different language.
* Consider the challenge they face daily: make a game that is just hard enough to keep the player's interest, and make sure that difficulty scales well as the player gets more advanced. In doing so, however, the designer must take into account the learning of the player - that is, the rate at which he or she improves - as well as the wide variety of potential play styles, learning styles, and personalities that might come in contact with the game. In many ways, that's very much what a teacher does, with the added difficulty that the game designer has to code his game ahead of time. He has to anticipate, because he won't be there to fix it on the fly, except in the abstract way of writing patches.
These suspicions of mine, however, about the potential exchange of information, ideas, and learning design between two very different industries are not sufficient or advanced enough to be beliefs or even arguments. Rather, they are questions. What explicit and hidden learning design processes does the gaming industry use? What about education, both formal and informal? What are their vocabularies? What are their objectives, and how do those objectives aid or detract from improving learning (for example, does making learning itself your core objective make it harder to produce good learning)?
Within the gaming industry - as within the world of education - there are, I'm sure, an infinite variety of approaches. There are certainly a variety of types of studios, from the major AAA production companies like Electronic Arts or Sega to the smaller, lesser-known mid-market studios like Paradox or Stardock, all the way to the miniature independent producers like 2D Boy (makers of the wildly popular World of Goo). In addition to wondering about the game industry as a whole, I think it's fair to ask about the differences within the game industry.
I suppose what I'm suggesting is a kind of ethnography of learning design in the video game industry, and in traditional education. The value of such an effort seems to me to hinge on the observation that learning - if only learning how to play the game - is built into each and every game that gets put on the market. Failure to do so means failure to sell and, thus, failure to survive. Despite the (mostly) non-profit incentives in education, failure to adequately design for learning has much more dire and far-reaching consequences, and yet the conceit of the educator (or education policy maker, or education researcher) is too often to assume that no one else has faced the question of how to design for learning.
Now, it's not particularly interesting that learning happens all the time. In some ways, it's so obvious that it's hardly worth mentioning, and so much of our learning is so mundane that we'd rather not hear or think about it for fear of choking on our boredom. Learning, for example, that it's slightly faster - or at least more pleasant - to walk to the left of the science building on the way to class in the morning, is not particularly groundbreaking for anyone, including the learner (unless he were to fall through an unnoticed but open manhole, but that's not the point).
No, what's particularly interesting about this learning that happens all the time is how much of it is designed, despite how incidental it seems. That is, even the route from car to classroom is designed in some sense, if not with learning in mind, with learning as a kind of ancillary and unanticipated outcome. Of course, a science building on the whole very much is designed with learning in mind in a much more direct way. And that's only the beginning.
Rather than list all of the myriad areas where learning design is potentially relevant, I want to talk about a couple in particular, an obvious one and a not-so-obvious one. The first is the school, the classroom, the curriculum. The second, video games, and not those horrid "educational games," so many of which pollute the game-o-sphere with their terrible controls, their convoluted plots, and their utter disdain for fun. No, I mean real games, games like Portal or Final Fantasy, Civilization or Little Big Planet.
What do I want to say about each of the very different worlds of game design, on the one hand, and traditional education, on the other? Well, I want to say that, at their hearts, they share a fundamental commonality: they are both designed, and they are both deeply concerned with learning. Now, education might shun the "design" label and games might shun the "learning," but words are just words, and the actual actions behind these particular words bridge the vocabulary gap with or without my help.
That game design and curriculum construction have much in common is hardly a unique idea. James Gee's career, for example, is largely built on recognizing the parallels between gaming and more traditional teaching and learning. It is my opinion, however, that there's more that could be done here, not just in recognizing and defining those parallels, but in uncovering how the two might inform each other better, seeing what game design has to teach educators, and what educators have to teach game design. I would not be surprised, moreover, if the expected conversation - that is, with game design bringing an understanding of design, and education bringing an understanding of learning - is totally reversed. Game designers may know a lot more about learning than we'd like to give them credit for,* and educators more about design, even if they're using different language.
* Consider the challenge they face daily: make a game that is just hard enough to keep the player's interest, and make sure that difficulty scales well as the player gets more advanced. In doing so, however, the designer must take into account the learning of the player - that is, the rate at which he or she improves - as well as the wide variety of potential play styles, learning styles, and personalities that might come in contact with the game. In many ways, that's very much what a teacher does, with the added difficulty that the game designer has to code his game ahead of time. He has to anticipate, because he won't be there to fix it on the fly, except in the abstract way of writing patches.
These suspicions of mine, however, about the potential exchange of information, ideas, and learning design between two very different industries are not sufficient or advanced enough to be beliefs or even arguments. Rather, they are questions. What explicit and hidden learning design processes does the gaming industry use? What about education, both formal and informal? What are their vocabularies? What are their objectives, and how do those objectives aid or detract from improving learning (for example, does making learning itself your core objective make it harder to produce good learning)?
Within the gaming industry - as within the world of education - there are, I'm sure, an infinite variety of approaches. There are certainly a variety of types of studios, from the major AAA production companies like Electronic Arts or Sega to the smaller, lesser-known mid-market studios like Paradox or Stardock, all the way to the miniature independent producers like 2D Boy (makers of the wildly popular World of Goo). In addition to wondering about the game industry as a whole, I think it's fair to ask about the differences within the game industry.
I suppose what I'm suggesting is a kind of ethnography of learning design in the video game industry, and in traditional education. The value of such an effort seems to me to hinge on the observation that learning - if only learning how to play the game - is built into each and every game that gets put on the market. Failure to do so means failure to sell and, thus, failure to survive. Despite the (mostly) non-profit incentives in education, failure to adequately design for learning has much more dire and far-reaching consequences, and yet the conceit of the educator (or education policy maker, or education researcher) is too often to assume that no one else has faced the question of how to design for learning.
Labels:
2D Boy,
Education,
Electronic Arts,
game design,
Games,
LDT,
Learning,
Paradox Interactive,
research,
Sega,
Stardock
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)