Showing posts with label video games. Show all posts
Showing posts with label video games. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

Mercy

So I've caught the Overwatch bug. It's a fun little game that's perfect for a teacher who can't play all the time, but can catch a match here and there. The main character I play is Mercy. What follows is, I guess, fan fiction? It's silly, but I had fun writing it. Enjoy.

It was with some surprise that I awoke on a brisk September morning in a dimly lit forest. I was surprised that I awoke at all. The last thing I remembered, before the damp, rotting leaves and the swaying branches that greeted me as I regained consciousness, was my death. It wasn’t a dream; it hurt way too much. I had been shot during the battle. The bullet went right through my stomach. I collapsed, and I could feel the strange mix of pain and detachment that comes with the end.

I sat up slowly, looking down at my blood-drenched shirt, but unable to find the bullet wound. I probed the area gently with my hands, but felt no pain there, and no other sign of the wound. And yet, there was the hole in my shirt, and the blood. I could see no one else, no doctor, no way of accounting for my miraculous survival. I guess revival might be a better word. Or resurrection.

I stood up, expecting to be weak and woozy, but I felt strong, aside from the thirst and hunger that I always feel after a battle. But I was very confused. How was I alive? Where was I? What should I do?

I tried to focus on my memories of the battle. We had been fighting in a hilly plains near the planet Julen’s largest city. There were no forests that I knew of anywhere near the drop zone. I hand’t spent much time studying the planet, but as far as I knew there weren’t any forests for miles.

Judging from the scant light piercing through the branches above and the long shadows on the ground, it was late afternoon, but that didn’t mean much to me. It could have been the day of the battle, still, or it could have been weeks later. The dead don’t exactly have a good sense of time passing.

The dead. I was dead, right? I mean, had I woken up in a hospital in intensive care I could have understood what happened. But this forest made no sense. The more I thought through my situation, the more questions I had. What day was it? What planet was I on?

I thought back to the battle. The briefing had said we would meet heavy resistance from the colonial rebels. The Empire was sick of this foolhardy attempt at independence, so they were sending the elite third division – of which I was a newly minted member – to occupy Julen, and to locate and raze the rebel base. We were to land outside of Julen’s capital, then to fight our way into the city. It was a straightforward operation, and the battle had been in our favor when I took the bullet.

As I wondered idly whether we had succeeded in our mission, I heard a voice, “I’ve been watching over you. Your people took the city, but the rebellion fights on.”

Startled, I turned to see a beautiful middle-aged woman emerge from behind the largest nearby tree. “Who are you? What am I doing here? What happened?”

“One question at a time,” She said, laughing, “And I get to ask first. On a scale of 1 to 10, how is your pain?”

“I’m not feeling any pain, just confusion.”

“Good,” she replied, “I prefer to keep this painless, if possible, though sometimes it can’t be avoided. I’m not a miracle worker. Well, not always.”

“Who are you?”

“I’m a doctor. Or I was, before the rebellion. My name is Angela Zeigler.”

“And you, you rescued me?”

“In a manner of speaking. I took you from the battlefield, yes, to these woods.”

“Uh, where exactly are these woods?”

Dr. Zeigler shifted uncomfortably, “I can’t tell you that, actually. We’re on Julen, and we’re near the rebel base.”

“I thought that was in the capital?”

She smiled, “It’s not. But I’m glad to hear you think it is.”

I started to understand, “You’re with the rebellion?”

At this she stiffened, “I abhor war. I wish the rebellion had never happened.” It wasn’t an answer. Not really, anyway. But then again it seems this woman had saved my life, so maybe she wasn’t a rebel. She continued, “When the rebellion started I was in the middle of some fascinating research, research that has particular applications in a war like this one.”

“And this research,” I picked up the thread, “Saved my life.”

“It did. And it saved the life of the man who shot you. He died in the battle as well. I won’t get into the details as to how, but if someone dies, I can revive him if I also revive someone killed by that person. I’m not sure I understand it myself. Stills seems like magic, to be honest, but so far it works.”

It was hard to believe what Zeigler was saying, but then again it was even harder to believe that I was alive.

A man emerged from the same direction I had seen the doctor come from. “It’s time. I have to get back into the fight.”

Dr. Zeigler sighed, “If we must, Jackson”

“We must. You know that better than anyone,” the man, Jackson, replied.

“Who are you?” I asked.

“I’m a hero buddy. A hero of the rebellion, and thanks to you I get to keep being a hero. We’re going to win this war.”

I spat at him. “You’re just a bunch of hopped up idealists who think you can beat the empire.”

“Boys,” Dr. Zeigler cut in, “This isn’t the time to argue. Jackson, he only just woke up, I haven’t even explained everything to him yet.”

“I don’t care. I’ve got to get to the front lines,” the man replied.

I looked on in confusion. Dr. Zeigler looked me in the eyes, resigned. I saw sadness, and also firm resolve.  “I’ll explain more next time. For now, just know that Heroes never die, for a price.”

“I’m no hero,” I replied.

“No,” she agreed. “You’re the price.”

Terror grasped me as I finally understood. Jackson looked into my eyes, pulled his gun, and aimed it at my torso.

“Mercy! Mercy! Please don’t do this.” I screamed, falling to my knees.

Dr. Zeigler kneeled down and grabbed my hand. “I’m here. I’m sorry.”

Jackson pulled the trigger and I felt the pain of dying for the second, and not the last, time. As I collapsed, consciousness fading, I saw Jackson walking away. Zeigler was still by my side. “How barbaric,” she said. Jackson had shot me in the stomach again. My death would be slow. Mercy took out a pistol and aimed it at my head. Again, she said, “I’m sorry.” Then, “It has to be done.” She aimed at my head and pulled the trigger. I suppose that was her idea of mercy.

Monday, September 23, 2013

Video Games and Curriculum

There are three ways that I'm interested in thinking about the intersection of video games and curriculum. I'll discuss each briefly here, starting from the most-researched to the least-researched.

1) Video Games as Curriculum Support

Most of the early research on video games and learning has been about "educational games" or the less baggage-laden rebranding "games for learning." The idea is, in short, that students enjoy playing games, and so we can trick them into learning by putting curriculum into a game. If, like me, you grew up with Math Blaster, Where in the World is Carmen San Diego, or Mario Teaches Typing you know what these games are like: enjoyable to a point, but ultimately limited in their appeal to the particular curricular situations in which they are employed.* Rarely are educational games - even the best of them - actually all that great as games. They are often closer to gamified curriculum than game for learning.

* OK, I get that Carmen San Diego in particular has some appeal beyond the classroom, but it really is one of the most exceptional educational games ever created.

It is fair to say that games for learning have come a long way in the past 20 years, however, and today there are many exceptionally enjoyable games that are explicitly designed to encourage learning. For example, the work of Motion Math (founded by fellow LDT students) shows the potential to engage students in a learning experience that still has good game design.

A related idea involves commercial games instead of games for learning. A recent Stanford graduate named Dylan Arena wrote his dissertation on commercial video games as preparation for future learning. The idea is that, by engaging students in a good game experience, you give them motivation and a reference point for understanding curricular material. His results are fascinating, demonstrating that we can, in fact, use games like Civilization and even the much-maligned Call of Duty to motivate students as they learn history.

In all, this is a vitally important area of research and innovation, and only good things can be said about the improvement of games for learning. The issue, to my mind, is that for many researchers the intersection of games and curriculum stops here. The question is an important one: How can we use games to teach what we already teach? But it's far from the only question we should be asking about learning and games.

2) Game Design as a Subject

As the game industry grows, there are more and more people who wish to become game designers, or to study game design and development. Game design programs are cropping up everywhere, but these are rarely founded upon principles of good curriculum development. In part this is because game design is a moving target. How can we design backwards when we don't really know what the end point should be?

Needless to say, there's a research opportunity here: how can we best teach game design? There are texts out there, but I don't think any are grounded in data about the outcomes of potential designers who go through game design programs.

I don't want to get bogged down, however, in thinking that game design should be exclusively a post-secondary and specialized study. I would rephrase the research question in this way, then: how can we best teach game design in such a way that any student at any level can better understand games and their role in society? Game design is a practical discipline and a career, in some sense, but it is also a theoretical subject with implications for just about everybody (because who doesn't play or watch games of some kind?). In this sense, game design is less about job training and more about learning to think.

3) Video Games as Curricular Artifacts

In some sense this is a related idea to the above, but I want to make a distinction between studying game design and studying games. In the above, game design is a vehicle for teaching creativity and critical thinking, but the subject is still the design process. This final idea is about games as art. Games as literature. Games as intrinsically valuable and interesting curricular artifacts. In much the way that we ask students to read books, to analyze them, to discuss them and write about them, I propose that we could and should do the same with games. Not all games, or any game, but certain games.

Why should we do this? Well, why should we study literature? Because games, like literature, can be insightful and profound, can teach us more about what it means to be human, can offend us, can expose us to other ways of thinking about the world, can allow us to imagine living lives very different from our own. And like literature, it is a waste to play (as with books, some) games unthinkingly. But when and where do we teach students to play games well? Not just to be good at games, but to be a good and critical reader/player of games? At present, the closest we get is by reading books in English class. But this is learning by analogy, when we could use games as artifacts in their own right.

The counter-argument here, of course, is that games are not worthy of the status we bestow upon books. But that is a position with which I cannot agree. True, there are a great many games which are far from great literature, but there are also a great many books which are unworthy of deep study. Why condemn games as a genre because some - and some of the most successful commercially - are philosophically, literately, or creatively deficient? There are gems (Journey, Shadow of the Colossus, To The Moon to name three) that are every bit as interesting as any text. And what's more, they afford conversations about more than just narrative: they invite questions about interactivity, about design, about linearity and non-linearity of experience. It is my conviction that a well-designed curriculum that studies games as art would be at least as effective - if not more so - at teaching the kinds of thinking, writing, and speaking skills - as well as the qualities of introspection, skepticism, and critique - we want students to acquire in humanities courses in their K-12 and college experiences.

Perhaps I should voice that conviction as a question: are video games valuable curricular artifacts in their own right? I may believe so, but I suspect few do. Most importantly, I know of anyone who has any data or research that supports either position.

Friday, September 13, 2013

An Observation about Research on Video Games in Education

I'm hoping to get back into writing on this blog in the near future. In particular, I plan to write some short-ish posts to help collect my thoughts about video games, learning, and education. This first post is a kind of brief overview and problem statement. Others - including, I hope, some analysis of actual games - will follow.

Research on video games in education tends to fall into two broad camps. The first is research on "games for learning," a rebranding of "educational games." While games for learning have come a long way in the past few years, they are still by-and-large less interesting, less polished, and less fun than commercial games. They may be successful at teaching what they are trying to teach, but they have limited appeal beyond the specific curricular situation they were designed for. In some sense they are to commercial games what textbooks are to other books.

The second major camp of video game research in education is on the social aspects of gaming. This includes research on phenomena like guilds in MMORPGs, where under-performing students can sometimes show tremendous mathematical, organizational, and leadership ability within the context of the game whilst failing to exhibit those same qualities in the classroom. It also includes studies on gaming communities and the extend to which they are or are not communities of practice. By-and-large this kind of research focuses on multiplayer and social gaming, though there are exceptions.

In my reading of research from both of these camps, I've seen a general shortcoming that plagues many studies: while games are ostensibly part of the subject of the research, rarely is game genre, quality, or design taken into account by the researchers. It's as if we wanted to research books, and then didn't differentiate between Hamlet, The Lord of the Rings, and Rainbow Six. Those are books of wildly different genres, wildly different styles and time periods, and of various qualities (I doubt even Clancy himself would consider his book worthy of inclusion in a high school curriculum, for example).

I think this problem stems from the generational gap around games. While more and more researchers realize that games are a big deal - Constance Steinkuehler is fond of pointing out that the gaming industry outpaces movies and music combined in revenue these days - there are still precious few researchers who are actually gamers. What's more, the cultural stigma around games is that they are entertainment at best, and at worst social disease. To return to the book analogy, it's as if researchers on literature weren't avid readers, and indeed doubted whether books were legitimate forms of artistic and creative expression. A little skepticism is probably good, but skepticism should be born of familiarity, not ignorance.