Since I'm trying to take a more specialized path in my writing, I've decided to start a more specialized blog. Nicht Diese Tone was always meant to be an all-purpose writing space, a mostly personal combination of thoughts, poems, ideas, analyses, and so on. It was a space for exploration.
As I move in a clearer direction in my research, I find the history at this blog too broad for what I want to talk about. So I'm starting a new blog instead. You'll find it at gameology.us. I plan - at this early point - at being fairly active there, with a combination of analysis, aggregation / curation, and more speculative brainstorming. So, basically, not unlike the style of this blog, but with a more focused topic.
I'm not going to take down this blog, and still may post here from time to time. You know, when I feel particularly poetic or have to share something personal or whatever. Hey, someday I may even finish my Beethoven post series. But in the meantime, if you want to follow my convoluted train of thought, transfer to the other side of the cyber-platform.
Showing posts with label Games. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Games. Show all posts
Wednesday, October 16, 2013
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
4 Books and 4 Games
I recently was charged with putting together a short presentation to introduce myself to the incoming LDT cohort, with the caveat that I shouldn't do the classic academic "here's my research" thing. So I decided instead to highlight four books and four games that have been important to me.
The not-so-subtle hidden message here is that I increasingly believe that games and books belong on the same cultural plane. Game literacy is as much a reality as book literacy. Games are as diverse in purpose, genre, quality, and artistry as books are. Games are, for many people, as important in shaping our selves as books.
But I didn't talk about any of that in my talk. I just shared the titles and a little about why each book or game has been important to me. So that's what I'm going to do here.
Book One - The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Trilogy, by Douglas Adams
Or, "the increasingly inaccurately named Hitchhiker's trilogy," which ended up having five books and vague prospects of a sixth at the time of Adams's unfortunate death. This series of books was what made me a reader. I remember my dad reading them to me when I was little. I also remember picking them up and reading them on my own once I realized that I didn't need someone else to read to me. I still read them once every couple of years. Many of the jokes are old friends, but I'm continually amazed how each time I read the series I find new things to guffaw at that I never fully appreciated before.
For a time, at least, Adams was also a major influence on my writing as well. I'm not as funny as he is, by any stretch, and I fear that becoming more of an academic has in many ways made me a less fluid writer. Even so, deep down a lot of my assumptions about what good writing looks like come from my early experiences as a reader huddled up with Ford and Arthur as they chased Chesterfield sofas across the plains of prehistoric Earth.
Game One - Civilization II, by Microprose
If Hitchhiker's Guide made me a reader, Civilization II made me a gamer. I had played many games prior to discovering Civlization, in truth, but most of those were sports games on an old Sega Genesis. They were fun, but they were also arcade-y and action-y. Not really my style, in the long run. Civilization was my first brush with PC strategy gaming, and like so many young nerds of my generation, my first afternoon with the game quickly turned into my first night, my first gaming all-nighter. I distinctly remember that first session, and my shock at seeing my clock reading 5:00 AM (well passed my bedtime). I remember resolving to play just a few more turns, but ultimately completing an entire game before finally calling it quits at 10 or so in the morning.
The Civilization games aren't just addictive, though. They are deep, complex, strategic. They reward careful planning. They encourage exploration and discovery. It was a revelation to young me that games could be more than just button-mashing. My mind had to work when I played Civilization, and it was glorious. I maintain that strategy games have made me smarter, more strategic in my thinking in the real world, more metacognitive. That started with Civilization II.
Book Two - Phenomenology of the Spirit, by Hegel
Of course I had to pick a program book from St. John's for this list, and with some difficulty I settled on Hegel. Phenomenology of the Spirit is a horrible mess. It reads like a poorly written instruction manual that has been translated from English to German and back several times. But underneath its horrid language it's brilliant, and more importantly, it absolutely permeates the modern Academy. Dialectical materialism - a Marxist offshoot of Hegelian logic - is the basis of almost all modern social and literary criticism, but more to the point the very notion of dialectic and perfectibility underlies the very scientific processes that drive every field of research. Hegelian thought may be strange in many ways, but it is strange in precisely the ways that academic research as a whole is strange. Of all the valuable experiences bestowed upon me by the St. John's program, perhaps none has been so (surprisingly) relevant as those gleaned by reading Hegel.
Game Two - Football Manager, by Sports Interactive
I was never a soccer fan growing up, but after seeing numerous glowing reviews of the FM series on various sports sim forums - especially those of Out of the Part Baseball - I decided to give it a shot. The result: over time, this game has supplanted all other sports simulations in my gaming library. I don't really want to know how much time I've put into my longest running save file, which I started playing back in 2010 and still dip into today.
I especially include this game, though, not because I love it, but because of what it demonstrates about the value of simulations for learning. I literally knew nothing about soccer tactics before I started playing FM. My brother played the sport growing up, sure, but I gained little by osmosis from him. And I've never watched much soccer beyond the World Cup and the occasional European Champions League match or MLS final. And yet I've become totally conversant in the tactics of the game by virtue of my experience with FM. I can watch the sport on TV and recognize the influence of formations, play styles, and approaches to the game that otherwise would be totally invisible to me, and all because of a simulation game. I'm an advocate of games as teachers of metacognition, but I think that some games can also teach content. In this case the content may not "matter" in the way that, say, history or math content does, but it is nevertheless, to me, a proof case.
Book Three - Understanding by Design, by Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe
My advisors would be the first to tell you that I've struggled to pin down my educational identity. What, really, do I specialize in? Well, if I had to pick a sub-area of education that I feel most expert in it would be curriculum design. That's not so much my research area - which is part of my problem as a researcher - as a part of educational practice I'm comfortable with, but it is nevertheless a vital skill in a variety of settings (including in constructing research studies; often curriculum needs to be written before a study can be conducted). Understanding by Design is the book that summarizes where I stand on curriculum. It was enlightening to encounter and read as a Master's student in 2009, and it remains central to my thinking about curriculum today.
Game Three - Journey, by That Game Company
I'm a PC strategy gamer at heart, but that doesn't mean that I haven't played other types of games. An important thread of modern research and debate in gaming has to do with the ability of games to weave narratives. A lot of the hullabaloo over whether games count as art comes down to this question: can they tell a story? I don't think that's a fair question to ask because it leaves out too many types of games. Some games aren't trying to tell a story, and some games are engines for a variety of stories without having a specific agenda. Nevertheless, games that are trying to tell a story can, and they can do it well. Journey, I'd say, is perhaps the best example of a game that is also a work of art and a narrative (even though there is no text in the entire game).
I debated with myself as to whether I should have put the Mass Effect series in this slot, or Shadow of the Colossus. The former is obviously a testament to RPG story-telling on a grand scale, while the latter is perhaps closer to Journey in its haunting beauty and vast landscapes. But both of those games, at their heart, are not made or broken by their story telling. Mass Effect is an RPG with a story, but it's also an action game, a fighting game, a shooter. That doesn't make it bad, but it does mean that there are really two distinct things going on: action game and story. The two rarely intersect.
Shadow of the Colossus is, similarly, a puzzle game at heart. Its puzzles are unbelievably beautiful, and it's not exactly conventional in its approach... but each challenge does have a specific answer that you need to puzzle out. It has a well-constructed story intervening, and a beautiful game world to go with it, and yes, the story and the game mechanics are better integrated than they are in Mass Effect, but you really are trying to solve puzzles.
Journey, on the other hand, really is a story. Inasmuch as it has puzzles - and it does - they are trivial and minimalist. The point of the experience is to have an experience. A literary experience, I'd say. The brilliant multiplayer integration - the most graceful I've ever seen - only adds to that experience. In short, it's a work of art that matches any novel I've read or movie I've seen, and I can't do justice to it in this little space.
Book Four - Invisible Cities, by Italo Calvino
This is my favorite book. I've read it I don't know how many times, I've taught it as part of my creative writing class, and I often pick it up to read a random passage. It's a book about just about everything: love, storytelling, imagination, history, leadership, perception, architectural design. You name it. It's the best book about epistemology that I've ever read.
Above all, at this point in my life, it speaks to me about the challenge of doing social sciences research. People are complex things, learning is a complex process, and making sense of the world doesn't just happen. I often wonder what Calvino's writing process was like for this book; whether he sat at a desk imagining or if he wandered the streets of Venice and composed his passages from actual witnessed scenes. Probably a combination. Regardless, his efforts (or at least his character Marco Polo's) strike me as much like the researcher's: trying to tell the story of a place when there are dozens of stories, trying to communicate with an audience that does not speak your language, trying to master an empire of knowledge when such an empire is inherently unmasterable.
Game Four - Crusader Kings, Europa Universalis, and Victoria series, by Paradox Interactive
These "grand strategy" historical simulation games are among my favorites as a game player, but also signify an important future direction in my research. Increasingly I have come to realize that I can't just leave games to the side. I've often thought that I care too much about games to research them, but I have begun to think that maybe I care too much about games to not research them. True, research in games is expanding rapidly, and there are lots of people excited about, at the very least, the commercial opportunities that games for learning represents. But I think there's also a more idealist opportunity here: there are games which I suspect are good at teaching thinking, and might be good at teaching content too.
Researchers have investigated historical simulation games for teaching history before, but I don't know that they've looked at any of these games. They're too complex, probably, for a traditional classroom. The barriers to entry are too high. They take too long to learn to play.
But difficulty is a poor excuse for ignoring what could be tremendous educational resources. Historical simulations of this scale are fascinating not just because they contain tremendous amounts of historical content, but also because they are consciously designed artifacts that are themselves opportunities for conversation. What is abstracted and in what way? What does the geographical setting or the game mechanics say about the view of history the game designers hold? Do the historical time period divisions between these games make sense? Why or why not?
In short, there's not just history here, there's historiography. As a curriculum designer, that's exciting to me, and as a researcher there's an opportunity to see not just if games generically can support learning generically, but if the very best that games have to offer in historical simulation can teach not just history, but historical thinking.
The not-so-subtle hidden message here is that I increasingly believe that games and books belong on the same cultural plane. Game literacy is as much a reality as book literacy. Games are as diverse in purpose, genre, quality, and artistry as books are. Games are, for many people, as important in shaping our selves as books.
But I didn't talk about any of that in my talk. I just shared the titles and a little about why each book or game has been important to me. So that's what I'm going to do here.
Book One - The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Trilogy, by Douglas Adams
Or, "the increasingly inaccurately named Hitchhiker's trilogy," which ended up having five books and vague prospects of a sixth at the time of Adams's unfortunate death. This series of books was what made me a reader. I remember my dad reading them to me when I was little. I also remember picking them up and reading them on my own once I realized that I didn't need someone else to read to me. I still read them once every couple of years. Many of the jokes are old friends, but I'm continually amazed how each time I read the series I find new things to guffaw at that I never fully appreciated before.
For a time, at least, Adams was also a major influence on my writing as well. I'm not as funny as he is, by any stretch, and I fear that becoming more of an academic has in many ways made me a less fluid writer. Even so, deep down a lot of my assumptions about what good writing looks like come from my early experiences as a reader huddled up with Ford and Arthur as they chased Chesterfield sofas across the plains of prehistoric Earth.
Game One - Civilization II, by Microprose
If Hitchhiker's Guide made me a reader, Civilization II made me a gamer. I had played many games prior to discovering Civlization, in truth, but most of those were sports games on an old Sega Genesis. They were fun, but they were also arcade-y and action-y. Not really my style, in the long run. Civilization was my first brush with PC strategy gaming, and like so many young nerds of my generation, my first afternoon with the game quickly turned into my first night, my first gaming all-nighter. I distinctly remember that first session, and my shock at seeing my clock reading 5:00 AM (well passed my bedtime). I remember resolving to play just a few more turns, but ultimately completing an entire game before finally calling it quits at 10 or so in the morning.
The Civilization games aren't just addictive, though. They are deep, complex, strategic. They reward careful planning. They encourage exploration and discovery. It was a revelation to young me that games could be more than just button-mashing. My mind had to work when I played Civilization, and it was glorious. I maintain that strategy games have made me smarter, more strategic in my thinking in the real world, more metacognitive. That started with Civilization II.
Book Two - Phenomenology of the Spirit, by Hegel
Of course I had to pick a program book from St. John's for this list, and with some difficulty I settled on Hegel. Phenomenology of the Spirit is a horrible mess. It reads like a poorly written instruction manual that has been translated from English to German and back several times. But underneath its horrid language it's brilliant, and more importantly, it absolutely permeates the modern Academy. Dialectical materialism - a Marxist offshoot of Hegelian logic - is the basis of almost all modern social and literary criticism, but more to the point the very notion of dialectic and perfectibility underlies the very scientific processes that drive every field of research. Hegelian thought may be strange in many ways, but it is strange in precisely the ways that academic research as a whole is strange. Of all the valuable experiences bestowed upon me by the St. John's program, perhaps none has been so (surprisingly) relevant as those gleaned by reading Hegel.
Game Two - Football Manager, by Sports Interactive
I was never a soccer fan growing up, but after seeing numerous glowing reviews of the FM series on various sports sim forums - especially those of Out of the Part Baseball - I decided to give it a shot. The result: over time, this game has supplanted all other sports simulations in my gaming library. I don't really want to know how much time I've put into my longest running save file, which I started playing back in 2010 and still dip into today.
I especially include this game, though, not because I love it, but because of what it demonstrates about the value of simulations for learning. I literally knew nothing about soccer tactics before I started playing FM. My brother played the sport growing up, sure, but I gained little by osmosis from him. And I've never watched much soccer beyond the World Cup and the occasional European Champions League match or MLS final. And yet I've become totally conversant in the tactics of the game by virtue of my experience with FM. I can watch the sport on TV and recognize the influence of formations, play styles, and approaches to the game that otherwise would be totally invisible to me, and all because of a simulation game. I'm an advocate of games as teachers of metacognition, but I think that some games can also teach content. In this case the content may not "matter" in the way that, say, history or math content does, but it is nevertheless, to me, a proof case.
Book Three - Understanding by Design, by Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe
My advisors would be the first to tell you that I've struggled to pin down my educational identity. What, really, do I specialize in? Well, if I had to pick a sub-area of education that I feel most expert in it would be curriculum design. That's not so much my research area - which is part of my problem as a researcher - as a part of educational practice I'm comfortable with, but it is nevertheless a vital skill in a variety of settings (including in constructing research studies; often curriculum needs to be written before a study can be conducted). Understanding by Design is the book that summarizes where I stand on curriculum. It was enlightening to encounter and read as a Master's student in 2009, and it remains central to my thinking about curriculum today.
Game Three - Journey, by That Game Company
I'm a PC strategy gamer at heart, but that doesn't mean that I haven't played other types of games. An important thread of modern research and debate in gaming has to do with the ability of games to weave narratives. A lot of the hullabaloo over whether games count as art comes down to this question: can they tell a story? I don't think that's a fair question to ask because it leaves out too many types of games. Some games aren't trying to tell a story, and some games are engines for a variety of stories without having a specific agenda. Nevertheless, games that are trying to tell a story can, and they can do it well. Journey, I'd say, is perhaps the best example of a game that is also a work of art and a narrative (even though there is no text in the entire game).
I debated with myself as to whether I should have put the Mass Effect series in this slot, or Shadow of the Colossus. The former is obviously a testament to RPG story-telling on a grand scale, while the latter is perhaps closer to Journey in its haunting beauty and vast landscapes. But both of those games, at their heart, are not made or broken by their story telling. Mass Effect is an RPG with a story, but it's also an action game, a fighting game, a shooter. That doesn't make it bad, but it does mean that there are really two distinct things going on: action game and story. The two rarely intersect.
Shadow of the Colossus is, similarly, a puzzle game at heart. Its puzzles are unbelievably beautiful, and it's not exactly conventional in its approach... but each challenge does have a specific answer that you need to puzzle out. It has a well-constructed story intervening, and a beautiful game world to go with it, and yes, the story and the game mechanics are better integrated than they are in Mass Effect, but you really are trying to solve puzzles.
Journey, on the other hand, really is a story. Inasmuch as it has puzzles - and it does - they are trivial and minimalist. The point of the experience is to have an experience. A literary experience, I'd say. The brilliant multiplayer integration - the most graceful I've ever seen - only adds to that experience. In short, it's a work of art that matches any novel I've read or movie I've seen, and I can't do justice to it in this little space.
Book Four - Invisible Cities, by Italo Calvino
This is my favorite book. I've read it I don't know how many times, I've taught it as part of my creative writing class, and I often pick it up to read a random passage. It's a book about just about everything: love, storytelling, imagination, history, leadership, perception, architectural design. You name it. It's the best book about epistemology that I've ever read.
Above all, at this point in my life, it speaks to me about the challenge of doing social sciences research. People are complex things, learning is a complex process, and making sense of the world doesn't just happen. I often wonder what Calvino's writing process was like for this book; whether he sat at a desk imagining or if he wandered the streets of Venice and composed his passages from actual witnessed scenes. Probably a combination. Regardless, his efforts (or at least his character Marco Polo's) strike me as much like the researcher's: trying to tell the story of a place when there are dozens of stories, trying to communicate with an audience that does not speak your language, trying to master an empire of knowledge when such an empire is inherently unmasterable.
Game Four - Crusader Kings, Europa Universalis, and Victoria series, by Paradox Interactive
These "grand strategy" historical simulation games are among my favorites as a game player, but also signify an important future direction in my research. Increasingly I have come to realize that I can't just leave games to the side. I've often thought that I care too much about games to research them, but I have begun to think that maybe I care too much about games to not research them. True, research in games is expanding rapidly, and there are lots of people excited about, at the very least, the commercial opportunities that games for learning represents. But I think there's also a more idealist opportunity here: there are games which I suspect are good at teaching thinking, and might be good at teaching content too.
Researchers have investigated historical simulation games for teaching history before, but I don't know that they've looked at any of these games. They're too complex, probably, for a traditional classroom. The barriers to entry are too high. They take too long to learn to play.
But difficulty is a poor excuse for ignoring what could be tremendous educational resources. Historical simulations of this scale are fascinating not just because they contain tremendous amounts of historical content, but also because they are consciously designed artifacts that are themselves opportunities for conversation. What is abstracted and in what way? What does the geographical setting or the game mechanics say about the view of history the game designers hold? Do the historical time period divisions between these games make sense? Why or why not?
In short, there's not just history here, there's historiography. As a curriculum designer, that's exciting to me, and as a researcher there's an opportunity to see not just if games generically can support learning generically, but if the very best that games have to offer in historical simulation can teach not just history, but historical thinking.
Friday, September 13, 2013
An Observation about Research on Video Games in Education
I'm hoping to get back into writing on this blog in the near future. In particular, I plan to write some short-ish posts to help collect my thoughts about video games, learning, and education. This first post is a kind of brief overview and problem statement. Others - including, I hope, some analysis of actual games - will follow.
Research on video games in education tends to fall into two broad camps. The first is research on "games for learning," a rebranding of "educational games." While games for learning have come a long way in the past few years, they are still by-and-large less interesting, less polished, and less fun than commercial games. They may be successful at teaching what they are trying to teach, but they have limited appeal beyond the specific curricular situation they were designed for. In some sense they are to commercial games what textbooks are to other books.
The second major camp of video game research in education is on the social aspects of gaming. This includes research on phenomena like guilds in MMORPGs, where under-performing students can sometimes show tremendous mathematical, organizational, and leadership ability within the context of the game whilst failing to exhibit those same qualities in the classroom. It also includes studies on gaming communities and the extend to which they are or are not communities of practice. By-and-large this kind of research focuses on multiplayer and social gaming, though there are exceptions.
In my reading of research from both of these camps, I've seen a general shortcoming that plagues many studies: while games are ostensibly part of the subject of the research, rarely is game genre, quality, or design taken into account by the researchers. It's as if we wanted to research books, and then didn't differentiate between Hamlet, The Lord of the Rings, and Rainbow Six. Those are books of wildly different genres, wildly different styles and time periods, and of various qualities (I doubt even Clancy himself would consider his book worthy of inclusion in a high school curriculum, for example).
I think this problem stems from the generational gap around games. While more and more researchers realize that games are a big deal - Constance Steinkuehler is fond of pointing out that the gaming industry outpaces movies and music combined in revenue these days - there are still precious few researchers who are actually gamers. What's more, the cultural stigma around games is that they are entertainment at best, and at worst social disease. To return to the book analogy, it's as if researchers on literature weren't avid readers, and indeed doubted whether books were legitimate forms of artistic and creative expression. A little skepticism is probably good, but skepticism should be born of familiarity, not ignorance.
Research on video games in education tends to fall into two broad camps. The first is research on "games for learning," a rebranding of "educational games." While games for learning have come a long way in the past few years, they are still by-and-large less interesting, less polished, and less fun than commercial games. They may be successful at teaching what they are trying to teach, but they have limited appeal beyond the specific curricular situation they were designed for. In some sense they are to commercial games what textbooks are to other books.
The second major camp of video game research in education is on the social aspects of gaming. This includes research on phenomena like guilds in MMORPGs, where under-performing students can sometimes show tremendous mathematical, organizational, and leadership ability within the context of the game whilst failing to exhibit those same qualities in the classroom. It also includes studies on gaming communities and the extend to which they are or are not communities of practice. By-and-large this kind of research focuses on multiplayer and social gaming, though there are exceptions.
In my reading of research from both of these camps, I've seen a general shortcoming that plagues many studies: while games are ostensibly part of the subject of the research, rarely is game genre, quality, or design taken into account by the researchers. It's as if we wanted to research books, and then didn't differentiate between Hamlet, The Lord of the Rings, and Rainbow Six. Those are books of wildly different genres, wildly different styles and time periods, and of various qualities (I doubt even Clancy himself would consider his book worthy of inclusion in a high school curriculum, for example).
I think this problem stems from the generational gap around games. While more and more researchers realize that games are a big deal - Constance Steinkuehler is fond of pointing out that the gaming industry outpaces movies and music combined in revenue these days - there are still precious few researchers who are actually gamers. What's more, the cultural stigma around games is that they are entertainment at best, and at worst social disease. To return to the book analogy, it's as if researchers on literature weren't avid readers, and indeed doubted whether books were legitimate forms of artistic and creative expression. A little skepticism is probably good, but skepticism should be born of familiarity, not ignorance.
Labels:
Education,
Games,
Learning,
research,
video games
Monday, November 28, 2011
Response to "Toc"
From my "Future of English Studies" course. Toc is a new-media literature project. Here's the website. Despite my critique below, it is worth taking a look at.
As a piece of writing, Toc has its virtues. As a piece of electronic media, it's a disaster.
Disclaimer: I'm a gamer. I have been since I was young. I grew up on Civilization II, Front Page Sports Baseball, and Doom. As important to me in college as the "Great Books" and the discussions that went with them was the purchase of my first real computer, and the weekend (and wee-morning) hours I poured into Knights of the Old Republic, Neverwinter Nights (1 and 2), and countless other strategy and RPG titles. It is true that video games often do not contain great - or even good - writing, and that their stories, when they have any, are largely derivative. What they do well, however, is interface.
Toc suffers because it is "interactive" without the interaction actually amounting to anything. Sure, there's a certain randomness (and, the authors would likely argue, timelessness) to the order in which you encounter the various fragments of the story, based upon what you click when, but the fragments are sufficiently free standing that the order hardly matters. Instead, the interaction implies the game world - you have to click precisely on the little blue, green, and red lines to get the appropriate media to operate - without embracing it. The experience of the reader remains mostly passive.
A passive reader experience is fine, of course, but in this case it's the "mostly" that's the problem. The experience isn't passive, but what interaction there is either is too limiting, too frustrating, or both. The lack of controls on the videos (mostly they cannot be paused or rewinded) is a UI disaster. Clicking on the little lines is finicky. The "lens" through which the textual parts of the story is read looks bland, at best. The mix of beautiful hand-drawn images and cool 3D effects in the videos with poor and outdated CGI is jarring.
In all, the authors of Toc, it seems to me, couldn't decide whether they were making this story for readers or for users. They embraced technology as a medium without embracing the design principles that go with it. Sure, the video game industry has its faults, but design is not one of them. Sure, UI people don't have all the answers as to how we can best interact with computers, but they have some good ideas. Sure, modern digital distribution of software of all kinds raises copyright questions, but the archaic "insert CD to install" - without even an autorun function! - places Toc several years behind the times (as does its lack of a patch for the few but noticeable bugs).
Worst of all, Toc is doomed by its lack of flexibility. Though ostensibly friendly with both major operating systems, it requires Apple's Quicktime, which has a tenuous and unhappy relationship with Windows. Toc does not run in Linux (I tried), and I suspect it will struggle once the current generation of its dependent technologies has passed (that is, once we're on to OS 11, Windows 8, and Quicktime Whatever). Even if it can run, it will certainly feel outdated (as it already does). This is true for most digital media, of course, but it is particularly ironic here. For a work so sensitive to time and its illusions, Toc is perhaps more vulnerable to time's passage than most works of art and literature.
As a piece of writing, Toc has its virtues. As a piece of electronic media, it's a disaster.
Disclaimer: I'm a gamer. I have been since I was young. I grew up on Civilization II, Front Page Sports Baseball, and Doom. As important to me in college as the "Great Books" and the discussions that went with them was the purchase of my first real computer, and the weekend (and wee-morning) hours I poured into Knights of the Old Republic, Neverwinter Nights (1 and 2), and countless other strategy and RPG titles. It is true that video games often do not contain great - or even good - writing, and that their stories, when they have any, are largely derivative. What they do well, however, is interface.
Toc suffers because it is "interactive" without the interaction actually amounting to anything. Sure, there's a certain randomness (and, the authors would likely argue, timelessness) to the order in which you encounter the various fragments of the story, based upon what you click when, but the fragments are sufficiently free standing that the order hardly matters. Instead, the interaction implies the game world - you have to click precisely on the little blue, green, and red lines to get the appropriate media to operate - without embracing it. The experience of the reader remains mostly passive.
A passive reader experience is fine, of course, but in this case it's the "mostly" that's the problem. The experience isn't passive, but what interaction there is either is too limiting, too frustrating, or both. The lack of controls on the videos (mostly they cannot be paused or rewinded) is a UI disaster. Clicking on the little lines is finicky. The "lens" through which the textual parts of the story is read looks bland, at best. The mix of beautiful hand-drawn images and cool 3D effects in the videos with poor and outdated CGI is jarring.
In all, the authors of Toc, it seems to me, couldn't decide whether they were making this story for readers or for users. They embraced technology as a medium without embracing the design principles that go with it. Sure, the video game industry has its faults, but design is not one of them. Sure, UI people don't have all the answers as to how we can best interact with computers, but they have some good ideas. Sure, modern digital distribution of software of all kinds raises copyright questions, but the archaic "insert CD to install" - without even an autorun function! - places Toc several years behind the times (as does its lack of a patch for the few but noticeable bugs).
Worst of all, Toc is doomed by its lack of flexibility. Though ostensibly friendly with both major operating systems, it requires Apple's Quicktime, which has a tenuous and unhappy relationship with Windows. Toc does not run in Linux (I tried), and I suspect it will struggle once the current generation of its dependent technologies has passed (that is, once we're on to OS 11, Windows 8, and Quicktime Whatever). Even if it can run, it will certainly feel outdated (as it already does). This is true for most digital media, of course, but it is particularly ironic here. For a work so sensitive to time and its illusions, Toc is perhaps more vulnerable to time's passage than most works of art and literature.
Labels:
critique,
design,
Games,
literature,
novels,
technology,
UI,
Windows,
writing
Monday, September 26, 2011
Two Research Ideas
One of my first assignments here at Stanford was to draft a possible research question and propose a methodology to use in answering that question. Because I have multiple interests, I wrote two.
The Dialogic Pedagogy of St. John's College
Questions
What is a dialogue? Obviously there is plenty of research about how to support dialogue in the classroom, and the role of discussions in learning. From my own limited experience, however, as a graduate student and as a teacher, there is a tremendous difference between dialogue as it is conceived in such research and dialogue as it occurs in, particularly, the classrooms of St. John's College.
As a graduate of St. John's, I have first hand experience in those classrooms. Far from providing answers, my experience only raises more questions. What is it about the culture, the pedagogy, and the organization of learning at St. John's that makes their classrooms unique? How is it that students in the St. John's seminar are able to speak so directly to each other about such complicated texts with minimal Professorial intervention? Or are they actually able to do so, after all? What is the relationship between the dialogic pedagogy of the college and its Great Books curriculum? Do they support each other, are they separable, or do they detract from each other? Perhaps most importantly: what, if anything, does the pedagogy – as distinct from the curriculum – have to teach educational systems at large?
All of these questions interest me, and they serve as a backdrop for a possible research agenda. In the short term, however, I want to focus particularly on undergraduate programs and dialogue. That is, I want to address this question: What constitutes a dialogue at St. John's, and how is it distinct from dialogues in other undergraduate academic environments?
Method
In order to begin to answer that questions, an initial qualitative, ethnographic foray into the college would be invaluable. A visit to the Santa Fe campus would allow me to conduct interviews with current students and faculty, as well as observe seminars in action with a researcher's – rather than a student's – eye. Video analysis of seminars could also be helpful, though that would require both the necessary equipment and approval from the school (recording of seminars is traditionally forbidden). While direct observation and interviews would only be possible when present, with permission and help I might be able to record video of a seminar or seminars throughout a semester or more.
In addition to doing qualitative data collection at St. John's, I would want to follow a similar interview and observation (and/or video analysis) protocol at another or other institutions. Perhaps the most feasible option would be to look at undergraduate courses at Stanford, as well as another local college or university (such as San Jose State). I would strive to find courses which describe themselves as “seminars” and which intend to use discussion-based pedagogies. I would strive, at this stage, to match specific content across the colleges in question.
Having collected my data, I would code and analyze in the qualitative tradition, with an eye towards answering my initial question, but also with the hope of discovering the appropriate path towards addressing the deeper questions that inspire my research.
Design in Game Development and Curriculum Construction
Questions
J.P. Gee, among others, has noticed that game developers do an excellent job of scaffolding learning into their products. That is, gamers learn how to play the game from simply playing it, whether because there is a built-in tutorial, or because the mechanics of the game are somehow made obvious by experimentation, or because the game is similar enough to other games in the genre that new players can be expected to transfer skills and strategies. Regardless, learning to play a game is a significant portion of what makes games fun.
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
School environments and activities, on the other hand, are frequently designed with a much more acute eye for learning, but too often without the same success. What, then, is it about the game design process that makes games so effective? How does that process differ from the curriculum and educational design process? Is the difference cultural, mechanical, or philosophical?
I'm particularly interested in an analysis of the design process game and curriculum development, as it pertains to learning in those respective environments. The question is not, then, whether students learn better from games, or what games do so effectively. It is how games are designed and how that process differs in education.
Method
I believe this question lends itself to an ethnographic approach. On the one hand, ethnography of a game development studio – or, indeed, a multitude of studios, as different studios likely have different design processes – and on the other, a similar ethnography of a school or other academic institution engaged in curriculum and activity design. Many public schools, of course, have little say in the details of their curricula, so perhaps a textbook company or other curriculum developer (Foss, for example) would serve as an interesting foil instead.
Spending time observing and interviewing participants in the design processes in these two environments, I would hope to discover what, if any, vocabulary is shared, and what is different. I would also hope to see to what degree learning is an explicit or implicit part of the design process. I expect a variety of other notable differences might arise as well, in terms of relationship to prototyping, the degree to which the process itself arises organically during development, and the passion and engagement of the people working on the design, among other things.
Purpose
Ultimately, my hope is that the game design process might hold some keys as to how educators might help to unlock the powerful learning potential of games in education, without forcing us to conclude that boring “educational games,” irrelevant commercial games, or tacky gamification are the only options. That is, perhaps traditional learning might be benefit at the level of design from contact with the game design world. And, in reverse, perhaps the game design world can benefit from contact with the education design process.
Tuesday, June 28, 2011
Little Big Planet in the Classroom
Today we played Little Big Planet.
No, seriously. We pulled the couches out from the walls, sat down, and engaged in epic 3-player platforming action.* The students, needless to say, were thrilled, even if none of them had played Little Big Planet previously.** They scuffled along through the first few levels, each group of three getting just enough play time to whet their appetites and to become comfortable with the basic controls. Meanwhile their classmates played games of their own: Apples to Apples, Chess, and "Trumps," a card game similar to Whist or Spades.
* It would have been four, but the fourth controlled wouldn't recognize the PlayStation, and I didn't have the USB cable to plug it in with.
** Isn't this generation supposed to be all game all the time? How have they not played LBP? I was even more shocked to discover this than I was when I heard they had not seen The Princess Bride.
Now hold on, you're thinking, how could you possibly get away with doing that in a high school creative writing class? Games are for wasting time, for eating away at kids' brains and turning them into useless zombie-people, right?
To which I can only respond: yes, and soon my zombie army will be complete.
Actually, my reasons for playing Little Big Planet stem from the core values of the class: collaboration, dialogue, and metacognition. The playing itself doesn't really hit those - there's a degree of collaboration, but the other two are limited - but it's not what you do that counts, it's how you do it. On the front end of our LBP adventure we used LBP's character creator to imagine a story snippet involving a zombie-pirate, and then worked on a (seemingly unrelated) mini Design project. On the back end, we designed games of our own using the materials available in the classroom (from Apples to Apples to dice, cards, chess pieces, and so on). Tomorrow, the students will be writing essays about the design of LBP, their learning while playing it, and their own experience designing a game. And then we'll be talking about how all of that connects to creative writing.
How does it connect to creative writing? Easy, it's creative, and it's writing. Playing a game is constructing a narrative. Designing a game is even more so, because you have to build into your design the learning and narrative-building of your potential player. Is that any different from writing, where you have to build a narrative, ensure that your audience can read (and sometimes learn to read) your work, and be engaged? Perhaps the outcome is different - indeed, there's no question that the outcomes of game design and creative writing differ - but the processes might have a lot in common, after all.
That's certainly my bias, and that's a big part of why I've made design a pivotal part of my curriculum. But it's no good doing design and restricting it to writing in the narrowest sense of poems, short stories, and essays. The real value of design, to a writer, is taking it to other areas: games, architecture, movies, and even other-class-interrupting-presentations (about which I will remain mysterious). Thinking outside the box - letting "writing" become bigger than just words on a page and letting "design" replace "creativity" - is a great way to become a better writer (and maybe even a better, or at least more interesting, person?). And, what's more, a great way to learn how to become a better writer, which is the real thing.
It's no accident then, that as we wrap up our mini design projects - including game design - tomorrow with finished products, an essay, and a discussion (see, playing PlayStation can lead to actual work) we'll start looking at Invisible Cities,* start trying to repaint the campus and the city and the world in which we live in terms of both design and literature. Having digested, or at least partially chewed, all of that, the students will be drafting a proposal for a final project. My hope? Collaboration, and a shortage of traditional short stories and poems. If the lot of them want to, say, write an interactive fiction computer game as a team and publish it on the Kongregate Arcade... Frankly, I'd be thrilled.
* For the longest time I couldn't decide whether I should do this work in the prose week or the poetry week. And then I realized that, duh, it belongs in the design week. It is, really, a quintessential "design literature" book. Heck, they even read it in architecture programs, or so I've heard.
So why Little Big Planet? Well, it fits into what I'm doing. But I used it not just because it fits, but because I want to model imagination, stepping beyond the bounds of what's expected, breaking "the rules." We played Little Big Planet today because it was fun, but also because it was a small, trivial, and totally essential step towards a set of entirely original, creative, and against "the rules" final projects.*
* Or at least I hope so...
No, seriously. We pulled the couches out from the walls, sat down, and engaged in epic 3-player platforming action.* The students, needless to say, were thrilled, even if none of them had played Little Big Planet previously.** They scuffled along through the first few levels, each group of three getting just enough play time to whet their appetites and to become comfortable with the basic controls. Meanwhile their classmates played games of their own: Apples to Apples, Chess, and "Trumps," a card game similar to Whist or Spades.
* It would have been four, but the fourth controlled wouldn't recognize the PlayStation, and I didn't have the USB cable to plug it in with.
** Isn't this generation supposed to be all game all the time? How have they not played LBP? I was even more shocked to discover this than I was when I heard they had not seen The Princess Bride.
Now hold on, you're thinking, how could you possibly get away with doing that in a high school creative writing class? Games are for wasting time, for eating away at kids' brains and turning them into useless zombie-people, right?
To which I can only respond: yes, and soon my zombie army will be complete.
Actually, my reasons for playing Little Big Planet stem from the core values of the class: collaboration, dialogue, and metacognition. The playing itself doesn't really hit those - there's a degree of collaboration, but the other two are limited - but it's not what you do that counts, it's how you do it. On the front end of our LBP adventure we used LBP's character creator to imagine a story snippet involving a zombie-pirate, and then worked on a (seemingly unrelated) mini Design project. On the back end, we designed games of our own using the materials available in the classroom (from Apples to Apples to dice, cards, chess pieces, and so on). Tomorrow, the students will be writing essays about the design of LBP, their learning while playing it, and their own experience designing a game. And then we'll be talking about how all of that connects to creative writing.
How does it connect to creative writing? Easy, it's creative, and it's writing. Playing a game is constructing a narrative. Designing a game is even more so, because you have to build into your design the learning and narrative-building of your potential player. Is that any different from writing, where you have to build a narrative, ensure that your audience can read (and sometimes learn to read) your work, and be engaged? Perhaps the outcome is different - indeed, there's no question that the outcomes of game design and creative writing differ - but the processes might have a lot in common, after all.
That's certainly my bias, and that's a big part of why I've made design a pivotal part of my curriculum. But it's no good doing design and restricting it to writing in the narrowest sense of poems, short stories, and essays. The real value of design, to a writer, is taking it to other areas: games, architecture, movies, and even other-class-interrupting-presentations (about which I will remain mysterious). Thinking outside the box - letting "writing" become bigger than just words on a page and letting "design" replace "creativity" - is a great way to become a better writer (and maybe even a better, or at least more interesting, person?). And, what's more, a great way to learn how to become a better writer, which is the real thing.
It's no accident then, that as we wrap up our mini design projects - including game design - tomorrow with finished products, an essay, and a discussion (see, playing PlayStation can lead to actual work) we'll start looking at Invisible Cities,* start trying to repaint the campus and the city and the world in which we live in terms of both design and literature. Having digested, or at least partially chewed, all of that, the students will be drafting a proposal for a final project. My hope? Collaboration, and a shortage of traditional short stories and poems. If the lot of them want to, say, write an interactive fiction computer game as a team and publish it on the Kongregate Arcade... Frankly, I'd be thrilled.
* For the longest time I couldn't decide whether I should do this work in the prose week or the poetry week. And then I realized that, duh, it belongs in the design week. It is, really, a quintessential "design literature" book. Heck, they even read it in architecture programs, or so I've heard.
So why Little Big Planet? Well, it fits into what I'm doing. But I used it not just because it fits, but because I want to model imagination, stepping beyond the bounds of what's expected, breaking "the rules." We played Little Big Planet today because it was fun, but also because it was a small, trivial, and totally essential step towards a set of entirely original, creative, and against "the rules" final projects.*
* Or at least I hope so...
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Designing Learning
It's easy to think that learning is what happens at school. It's not particularly difficult to imagine other places of learning to go alongside the classroom: museums, for example, or (many years ago) libraries. It's a little more challenging to imagine learning taking place while watching TV or playing a video game, sending a text message or reading an email. But as long as the mind is remotely active, I would argue that learning, in some form, happens.
Now, it's not particularly interesting that learning happens all the time. In some ways, it's so obvious that it's hardly worth mentioning, and so much of our learning is so mundane that we'd rather not hear or think about it for fear of choking on our boredom. Learning, for example, that it's slightly faster - or at least more pleasant - to walk to the left of the science building on the way to class in the morning, is not particularly groundbreaking for anyone, including the learner (unless he were to fall through an unnoticed but open manhole, but that's not the point).
No, what's particularly interesting about this learning that happens all the time is how much of it is designed, despite how incidental it seems. That is, even the route from car to classroom is designed in some sense, if not with learning in mind, with learning as a kind of ancillary and unanticipated outcome. Of course, a science building on the whole very much is designed with learning in mind in a much more direct way. And that's only the beginning.
Rather than list all of the myriad areas where learning design is potentially relevant, I want to talk about a couple in particular, an obvious one and a not-so-obvious one. The first is the school, the classroom, the curriculum. The second, video games, and not those horrid "educational games," so many of which pollute the game-o-sphere with their terrible controls, their convoluted plots, and their utter disdain for fun. No, I mean real games, games like Portal or Final Fantasy, Civilization or Little Big Planet.
What do I want to say about each of the very different worlds of game design, on the one hand, and traditional education, on the other? Well, I want to say that, at their hearts, they share a fundamental commonality: they are both designed, and they are both deeply concerned with learning. Now, education might shun the "design" label and games might shun the "learning," but words are just words, and the actual actions behind these particular words bridge the vocabulary gap with or without my help.
That game design and curriculum construction have much in common is hardly a unique idea. James Gee's career, for example, is largely built on recognizing the parallels between gaming and more traditional teaching and learning. It is my opinion, however, that there's more that could be done here, not just in recognizing and defining those parallels, but in uncovering how the two might inform each other better, seeing what game design has to teach educators, and what educators have to teach game design. I would not be surprised, moreover, if the expected conversation - that is, with game design bringing an understanding of design, and education bringing an understanding of learning - is totally reversed. Game designers may know a lot more about learning than we'd like to give them credit for,* and educators more about design, even if they're using different language.
* Consider the challenge they face daily: make a game that is just hard enough to keep the player's interest, and make sure that difficulty scales well as the player gets more advanced. In doing so, however, the designer must take into account the learning of the player - that is, the rate at which he or she improves - as well as the wide variety of potential play styles, learning styles, and personalities that might come in contact with the game. In many ways, that's very much what a teacher does, with the added difficulty that the game designer has to code his game ahead of time. He has to anticipate, because he won't be there to fix it on the fly, except in the abstract way of writing patches.
These suspicions of mine, however, about the potential exchange of information, ideas, and learning design between two very different industries are not sufficient or advanced enough to be beliefs or even arguments. Rather, they are questions. What explicit and hidden learning design processes does the gaming industry use? What about education, both formal and informal? What are their vocabularies? What are their objectives, and how do those objectives aid or detract from improving learning (for example, does making learning itself your core objective make it harder to produce good learning)?
Within the gaming industry - as within the world of education - there are, I'm sure, an infinite variety of approaches. There are certainly a variety of types of studios, from the major AAA production companies like Electronic Arts or Sega to the smaller, lesser-known mid-market studios like Paradox or Stardock, all the way to the miniature independent producers like 2D Boy (makers of the wildly popular World of Goo). In addition to wondering about the game industry as a whole, I think it's fair to ask about the differences within the game industry.
I suppose what I'm suggesting is a kind of ethnography of learning design in the video game industry, and in traditional education. The value of such an effort seems to me to hinge on the observation that learning - if only learning how to play the game - is built into each and every game that gets put on the market. Failure to do so means failure to sell and, thus, failure to survive. Despite the (mostly) non-profit incentives in education, failure to adequately design for learning has much more dire and far-reaching consequences, and yet the conceit of the educator (or education policy maker, or education researcher) is too often to assume that no one else has faced the question of how to design for learning.
Now, it's not particularly interesting that learning happens all the time. In some ways, it's so obvious that it's hardly worth mentioning, and so much of our learning is so mundane that we'd rather not hear or think about it for fear of choking on our boredom. Learning, for example, that it's slightly faster - or at least more pleasant - to walk to the left of the science building on the way to class in the morning, is not particularly groundbreaking for anyone, including the learner (unless he were to fall through an unnoticed but open manhole, but that's not the point).
No, what's particularly interesting about this learning that happens all the time is how much of it is designed, despite how incidental it seems. That is, even the route from car to classroom is designed in some sense, if not with learning in mind, with learning as a kind of ancillary and unanticipated outcome. Of course, a science building on the whole very much is designed with learning in mind in a much more direct way. And that's only the beginning.
Rather than list all of the myriad areas where learning design is potentially relevant, I want to talk about a couple in particular, an obvious one and a not-so-obvious one. The first is the school, the classroom, the curriculum. The second, video games, and not those horrid "educational games," so many of which pollute the game-o-sphere with their terrible controls, their convoluted plots, and their utter disdain for fun. No, I mean real games, games like Portal or Final Fantasy, Civilization or Little Big Planet.
What do I want to say about each of the very different worlds of game design, on the one hand, and traditional education, on the other? Well, I want to say that, at their hearts, they share a fundamental commonality: they are both designed, and they are both deeply concerned with learning. Now, education might shun the "design" label and games might shun the "learning," but words are just words, and the actual actions behind these particular words bridge the vocabulary gap with or without my help.
That game design and curriculum construction have much in common is hardly a unique idea. James Gee's career, for example, is largely built on recognizing the parallels between gaming and more traditional teaching and learning. It is my opinion, however, that there's more that could be done here, not just in recognizing and defining those parallels, but in uncovering how the two might inform each other better, seeing what game design has to teach educators, and what educators have to teach game design. I would not be surprised, moreover, if the expected conversation - that is, with game design bringing an understanding of design, and education bringing an understanding of learning - is totally reversed. Game designers may know a lot more about learning than we'd like to give them credit for,* and educators more about design, even if they're using different language.
* Consider the challenge they face daily: make a game that is just hard enough to keep the player's interest, and make sure that difficulty scales well as the player gets more advanced. In doing so, however, the designer must take into account the learning of the player - that is, the rate at which he or she improves - as well as the wide variety of potential play styles, learning styles, and personalities that might come in contact with the game. In many ways, that's very much what a teacher does, with the added difficulty that the game designer has to code his game ahead of time. He has to anticipate, because he won't be there to fix it on the fly, except in the abstract way of writing patches.
These suspicions of mine, however, about the potential exchange of information, ideas, and learning design between two very different industries are not sufficient or advanced enough to be beliefs or even arguments. Rather, they are questions. What explicit and hidden learning design processes does the gaming industry use? What about education, both formal and informal? What are their vocabularies? What are their objectives, and how do those objectives aid or detract from improving learning (for example, does making learning itself your core objective make it harder to produce good learning)?
Within the gaming industry - as within the world of education - there are, I'm sure, an infinite variety of approaches. There are certainly a variety of types of studios, from the major AAA production companies like Electronic Arts or Sega to the smaller, lesser-known mid-market studios like Paradox or Stardock, all the way to the miniature independent producers like 2D Boy (makers of the wildly popular World of Goo). In addition to wondering about the game industry as a whole, I think it's fair to ask about the differences within the game industry.
I suppose what I'm suggesting is a kind of ethnography of learning design in the video game industry, and in traditional education. The value of such an effort seems to me to hinge on the observation that learning - if only learning how to play the game - is built into each and every game that gets put on the market. Failure to do so means failure to sell and, thus, failure to survive. Despite the (mostly) non-profit incentives in education, failure to adequately design for learning has much more dire and far-reaching consequences, and yet the conceit of the educator (or education policy maker, or education researcher) is too often to assume that no one else has faced the question of how to design for learning.
Labels:
2D Boy,
Education,
Electronic Arts,
game design,
Games,
LDT,
Learning,
Paradox Interactive,
research,
Sega,
Stardock
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
Josiah's Journal - Manifest Destiny
The following is the journal of Josiah (last name not given). I found it on a journey of my own, mere months after the events recorded here.
March 18, 1848 - Independence, Missouri
Living and teaching in Independence wasn't what I wanted to do with my life. I suppose that's why I want leave. I've saved up some four hundred dollars - the most I've ever had at once in my life - over the last couple of years, and I let the administration at the school know that I'm leaving. Soon.
Only lately - since dad's death - had wanderlust and a desire for something better started to get the better of me. There is little left for my in Independence, excepting my job and my family. The former is all too easy to give up, the latter easy to bring with me.
My wife Annabell and I went down to the general store today, intending to spend most of the money I had saved up. We purchased extra clothing, spare wagon parts, cans and cans of food - more than I'd ever seen - and of course about a dozen boxes of bullets. Most important - and most expensive - were the six oxen we procured from the local ranch. "Good and strong," he said. "They'll get you to Oregon no trouble."
I'm ready to leave today, but my friends advise waiting, lest we get caught in a snow storm. I can see the wisdom in that. Still, I'm itching to leave.
April 1, 1848 - Independence, Missouri
It's a brisk morning, but I hardly care. Finally, I'm going to hit the trail, to escape the town that has been my life, my prison, for years. At 45 I am no spring chicken any more, but I have enough years and enough spirit left in me to tame the wild frontier, to move to a land of forests and mountains and fishing and hunting. My wife Annabell and my three children - 19 year old Jacob, 17 year old Savanah, and "Baby Xavier," who just turned 10 - are eager to get going, ready for the adventure of their lifetimes.
We set out around noon at a brisk pace, knowing that our provisions were limited and that we'd have to make good time. Hopefully the early spring weather will be kind to us as we made our way across the plains. We left in high spirits, Xavier beaming as he ran around our wagon, playing with the oxen while Jacob practiced with the new gun. Even our brooding daughter couldn't help but smile when the town was out of sight, over the horizon behind us.
April 5, 1848 - One of the oxen ran away. Jacob and I looking for it frantically, as we really need six to pull the wagon... Found the ox. Frustrating, because it went to the Kansas River, which is where we need to go. We had to pull it all the way back to the wagon, and then go all the way back to the river. Oh well, minor set back.
April 8, 1848 - Kansas River Crossing
Fortune favors the bold, they say, and so it did for us today. A ferryman asked us for five dollars (Five!) for safe passage across the river. I told him no, we only have 30, and we'll need it for food and supplies later. What's more, that five dollars gets you a spot in the longest line I've ever seen. We'd have been waiting for days just to cross. So Jacob and I caulked the wagon, and rode it across instead. It was a bumpy ride, but the river was fairly calm today, and we made it across just fine. Just goes to show, people are always after you hard earned money.
April 10, 1848 - We lost the trail on the other side of the river, but we back tracked and found it quickly. Onward!
April 13, 1848 - Big Blue River Crossing
Another successful journey across a river. The Big Blue was much narrower and shallower than the Kansas, but it is satisfying nonetheless to have made it across safely. Still, these river crossings make the kids anxious. Let's hope we won't see another for a while.
April 17, 1848 - Fort Kearney
Complain, complain, complain. For three days, all I've heard is complaining. "Daddy, why can't we have more food to eat?" "Daddy, why do we have to go so fast?" "Daddy, when will we get there?" I've tried to explain - without success - that we need to go so fast and eat so little so that we can get there sooner, and hopefully with some money left over, so we can start a new life. But no, all the kids care about is today. Oh, and to top it off, the same damn ox that wandered away is now sick. We should just shoot it and get a new one. And I would too, if I had the means.
April 26, 1848 - Chimney Rock
We've made good time over the last nine days, even with a sick ox. It seems to be doing a little better now that we've stopped to rest for a spell, but I can't say the same about Jacob. He's worked so hard, and I think he's been passing off parts of his rations to Xavier the whole trip, and now he's starting to look a little ill. I saw it coming on a few days ago, but didn't say anything. Now that we've arrived at Chimney Rock, however, I went out and found another traveler who used to run a clinic in Illinois, and he says it's almost certainly dysentery. I guess we can only hope and pray, and push forward to a place where he can be treated.
May 2, 1848 - That sonofabitch ox died! And Jacob is still sick, too. I won't describe the symptoms. Suffice to say, they aren't pleasant. At least we're close to Fort Laramie. I hope.
May 5, 1848 - Fort Laramie
The last three days have been the most trying of our journey so far. Our progress was unbelievably slow thanks to the dead ox, Jacob was coughing continuously, and Savanah's incessant complaining became incessant crying, instead. Hardly an improvement. Now, though, we've made it to a fort, where we can resupply and buy a new ox. Hallelujah.
Just got back from the store... A single ox costs $30 out here! That's all of my remaining money! I don't really have a choice, but I fear only ill can come of our newfound lack of funds.
May 7, 1848 - We found about 20 pounds of fruit today, which helps our dwindling food stores. But now Baby Xavier is looking absolutely horrible. Hopefully the fruit and resting at the back of the wagon will help him regain strength.
May 9, 1848 - Killed a buffalo today. Too much food to carry. Stores much better now.
May 16, 1848 - Xavier is looking much better. I think all the buffalo meat we've been eating is cheering him up. Complaining is also improving with larger rations. I figure an occasional buffalo hunt now and then will give us plenty of food to make it to Oregon.
May 21, 1848 - We passed Independence Rock a few days ago, and refilled our water stores while we were there. Now, though, I'm starting to think there's something wrong with the water we got. It doesn't taste right, and I'm afraid someone might get sick. Problem is, it's the only water we have.
May 23, 1848 - Things are going from bad to worse. There's practically no grass on the ground here, and the oxen are making it known that they are hungry. What's more, we haven't seen rain, a stream, or another source of water for days, and just this morning Xavier poured out the rest of the water because it tastes so bad. Maybe one of those Indians can teach us a rain dance.
May 24, 1848 - South Pass
Ask and ye shall receive! Not only did it rain this morning, but we made it to South Pass, where the river is clear and glistening. Now we have a decision to make, albeit an easy one. We can take the shortcut through to Green River, or head out-of-the-way to the nearest fort. The kids all want to go to the fort, but seeing as we don't have any money, I figure we should just charge on. Hopefully we can get to Oregon with enough of our supplies left that we can sell them off there.
May 26, 1848 - I'm not a religious man, but I am praying today. My wife, my love, my life... Annabell has cholera. That damn tainted water must have something to do with it. God, why? We're halfway to Oregon, halfway from Independence, and I wish we could turn back. But now it would take just as long to return as it would to make it. In the meantime, I'll be hoping and praying for Annabell's health. God have mercy on us.
May 31, 1848 - We went for a hunt today, and didn't see a single buffalo. I guess they don't live this far north. We still shot plenty of deer and elk. The bad news, however, is that Baby Xavier came with Jacob and I, and while we were hunting proceded to climb and fall out of a tree, breaking his leg. Foolish boy. His injury will make things that much harder on the rest of us.
June 1, 1848 - Green River
Oh God! Oh Jesus! My wife, my daughter, my son... All dead! Such hubris, such damned arrogance.
I knew running out of money would be the end of us. The ferryman wanted five dollars, again, to cross Green River. This time I would have paid, had I the means. The river is large, deep, and treacherous. Jacob assured me that we could do it, that we could make it across. And I believed him, because I knew we didn't have any other choice. But when the wagon started to shake the Xavier and Savanah panicked, and before we knew it the wagon had capsized. Annabell, my sweet, loving wife... Annabell was too weak to escape the wagon, her Cholera too advanced. Xavier's broken leg rendered him helpless as well. And Savanah has never learned to swim.
Jacob and I have agreed to rest for a few days before moving on, but we have already agreed that we must. There may be nothing left for me in this world, but he is still a young man, and if I can help him to make it to Oregon, I can at least be content with that small victory in the face of the overwhelming loss of my wife and my younger children.
June 5, 1848 - As if it wasn't enough, Jacob has contracted typhoid, leaving me to run the wagon alone. He is a strong young man, and I believe he'll pull through. He has to pull through. But our progress will be slowed. I just... I don't know what to do. Oh, if only Annabell were here.
June 7, 1848 - Jacob died early this afternoon. I am now alone, in the middle of the wild plains. My family is dead, I am over a thousand miles from my home, and I have no will to go on. Yet, what else can I do, but go on? I am exhausted. Indeed, it might be more accurate to say that I have exhaustion. But it is either go onward, or die, and I am not ready to choose death yet.
June 11, 1848 - Soda Springs
I met an Indian man today who was willing to trade one of Savanah's sets of clothes for fifteen dollars. Oh, how I could have used such a deal a fortnight ago! I am resting here for a day before going forward. Hopefully my body will be rejuvinated by the rest. As for my spirit, my soul... That is broken, and will never be repaired.
June 13, 1848 (Last Entry) - Am so tired, so lost, so desparate. I cannot stand the loneliness of the hills at night, and the oxen provide such meager company. Sometimes, I just want it all to end. There is comfort, at least, in the knowledge that, though my family could not make it to the western frontier, at least we might be reunited in Elysium. Oh sweet Annabell, I'm coming!
March 18, 1848 - Independence, Missouri
Living and teaching in Independence wasn't what I wanted to do with my life. I suppose that's why I want leave. I've saved up some four hundred dollars - the most I've ever had at once in my life - over the last couple of years, and I let the administration at the school know that I'm leaving. Soon.
Only lately - since dad's death - had wanderlust and a desire for something better started to get the better of me. There is little left for my in Independence, excepting my job and my family. The former is all too easy to give up, the latter easy to bring with me.
My wife Annabell and I went down to the general store today, intending to spend most of the money I had saved up. We purchased extra clothing, spare wagon parts, cans and cans of food - more than I'd ever seen - and of course about a dozen boxes of bullets. Most important - and most expensive - were the six oxen we procured from the local ranch. "Good and strong," he said. "They'll get you to Oregon no trouble."
I'm ready to leave today, but my friends advise waiting, lest we get caught in a snow storm. I can see the wisdom in that. Still, I'm itching to leave.
April 1, 1848 - Independence, Missouri
It's a brisk morning, but I hardly care. Finally, I'm going to hit the trail, to escape the town that has been my life, my prison, for years. At 45 I am no spring chicken any more, but I have enough years and enough spirit left in me to tame the wild frontier, to move to a land of forests and mountains and fishing and hunting. My wife Annabell and my three children - 19 year old Jacob, 17 year old Savanah, and "Baby Xavier," who just turned 10 - are eager to get going, ready for the adventure of their lifetimes.
We set out around noon at a brisk pace, knowing that our provisions were limited and that we'd have to make good time. Hopefully the early spring weather will be kind to us as we made our way across the plains. We left in high spirits, Xavier beaming as he ran around our wagon, playing with the oxen while Jacob practiced with the new gun. Even our brooding daughter couldn't help but smile when the town was out of sight, over the horizon behind us.
April 5, 1848 - One of the oxen ran away. Jacob and I looking for it frantically, as we really need six to pull the wagon... Found the ox. Frustrating, because it went to the Kansas River, which is where we need to go. We had to pull it all the way back to the wagon, and then go all the way back to the river. Oh well, minor set back.
April 8, 1848 - Kansas River Crossing
Fortune favors the bold, they say, and so it did for us today. A ferryman asked us for five dollars (Five!) for safe passage across the river. I told him no, we only have 30, and we'll need it for food and supplies later. What's more, that five dollars gets you a spot in the longest line I've ever seen. We'd have been waiting for days just to cross. So Jacob and I caulked the wagon, and rode it across instead. It was a bumpy ride, but the river was fairly calm today, and we made it across just fine. Just goes to show, people are always after you hard earned money.
April 10, 1848 - We lost the trail on the other side of the river, but we back tracked and found it quickly. Onward!
April 13, 1848 - Big Blue River Crossing
Another successful journey across a river. The Big Blue was much narrower and shallower than the Kansas, but it is satisfying nonetheless to have made it across safely. Still, these river crossings make the kids anxious. Let's hope we won't see another for a while.
April 17, 1848 - Fort Kearney
Complain, complain, complain. For three days, all I've heard is complaining. "Daddy, why can't we have more food to eat?" "Daddy, why do we have to go so fast?" "Daddy, when will we get there?" I've tried to explain - without success - that we need to go so fast and eat so little so that we can get there sooner, and hopefully with some money left over, so we can start a new life. But no, all the kids care about is today. Oh, and to top it off, the same damn ox that wandered away is now sick. We should just shoot it and get a new one. And I would too, if I had the means.
April 26, 1848 - Chimney Rock
We've made good time over the last nine days, even with a sick ox. It seems to be doing a little better now that we've stopped to rest for a spell, but I can't say the same about Jacob. He's worked so hard, and I think he's been passing off parts of his rations to Xavier the whole trip, and now he's starting to look a little ill. I saw it coming on a few days ago, but didn't say anything. Now that we've arrived at Chimney Rock, however, I went out and found another traveler who used to run a clinic in Illinois, and he says it's almost certainly dysentery. I guess we can only hope and pray, and push forward to a place where he can be treated.
May 2, 1848 - That sonofabitch ox died! And Jacob is still sick, too. I won't describe the symptoms. Suffice to say, they aren't pleasant. At least we're close to Fort Laramie. I hope.
May 5, 1848 - Fort Laramie
The last three days have been the most trying of our journey so far. Our progress was unbelievably slow thanks to the dead ox, Jacob was coughing continuously, and Savanah's incessant complaining became incessant crying, instead. Hardly an improvement. Now, though, we've made it to a fort, where we can resupply and buy a new ox. Hallelujah.
Just got back from the store... A single ox costs $30 out here! That's all of my remaining money! I don't really have a choice, but I fear only ill can come of our newfound lack of funds.
May 7, 1848 - We found about 20 pounds of fruit today, which helps our dwindling food stores. But now Baby Xavier is looking absolutely horrible. Hopefully the fruit and resting at the back of the wagon will help him regain strength.
May 9, 1848 - Killed a buffalo today. Too much food to carry. Stores much better now.
May 16, 1848 - Xavier is looking much better. I think all the buffalo meat we've been eating is cheering him up. Complaining is also improving with larger rations. I figure an occasional buffalo hunt now and then will give us plenty of food to make it to Oregon.
May 21, 1848 - We passed Independence Rock a few days ago, and refilled our water stores while we were there. Now, though, I'm starting to think there's something wrong with the water we got. It doesn't taste right, and I'm afraid someone might get sick. Problem is, it's the only water we have.
May 23, 1848 - Things are going from bad to worse. There's practically no grass on the ground here, and the oxen are making it known that they are hungry. What's more, we haven't seen rain, a stream, or another source of water for days, and just this morning Xavier poured out the rest of the water because it tastes so bad. Maybe one of those Indians can teach us a rain dance.
May 24, 1848 - South Pass
Ask and ye shall receive! Not only did it rain this morning, but we made it to South Pass, where the river is clear and glistening. Now we have a decision to make, albeit an easy one. We can take the shortcut through to Green River, or head out-of-the-way to the nearest fort. The kids all want to go to the fort, but seeing as we don't have any money, I figure we should just charge on. Hopefully we can get to Oregon with enough of our supplies left that we can sell them off there.
May 26, 1848 - I'm not a religious man, but I am praying today. My wife, my love, my life... Annabell has cholera. That damn tainted water must have something to do with it. God, why? We're halfway to Oregon, halfway from Independence, and I wish we could turn back. But now it would take just as long to return as it would to make it. In the meantime, I'll be hoping and praying for Annabell's health. God have mercy on us.
May 31, 1848 - We went for a hunt today, and didn't see a single buffalo. I guess they don't live this far north. We still shot plenty of deer and elk. The bad news, however, is that Baby Xavier came with Jacob and I, and while we were hunting proceded to climb and fall out of a tree, breaking his leg. Foolish boy. His injury will make things that much harder on the rest of us.
June 1, 1848 - Green River
Oh God! Oh Jesus! My wife, my daughter, my son... All dead! Such hubris, such damned arrogance.
I knew running out of money would be the end of us. The ferryman wanted five dollars, again, to cross Green River. This time I would have paid, had I the means. The river is large, deep, and treacherous. Jacob assured me that we could do it, that we could make it across. And I believed him, because I knew we didn't have any other choice. But when the wagon started to shake the Xavier and Savanah panicked, and before we knew it the wagon had capsized. Annabell, my sweet, loving wife... Annabell was too weak to escape the wagon, her Cholera too advanced. Xavier's broken leg rendered him helpless as well. And Savanah has never learned to swim.
Jacob and I have agreed to rest for a few days before moving on, but we have already agreed that we must. There may be nothing left for me in this world, but he is still a young man, and if I can help him to make it to Oregon, I can at least be content with that small victory in the face of the overwhelming loss of my wife and my younger children.
June 5, 1848 - As if it wasn't enough, Jacob has contracted typhoid, leaving me to run the wagon alone. He is a strong young man, and I believe he'll pull through. He has to pull through. But our progress will be slowed. I just... I don't know what to do. Oh, if only Annabell were here.
June 7, 1848 - Jacob died early this afternoon. I am now alone, in the middle of the wild plains. My family is dead, I am over a thousand miles from my home, and I have no will to go on. Yet, what else can I do, but go on? I am exhausted. Indeed, it might be more accurate to say that I have exhaustion. But it is either go onward, or die, and I am not ready to choose death yet.
June 11, 1848 - Soda Springs
I met an Indian man today who was willing to trade one of Savanah's sets of clothes for fifteen dollars. Oh, how I could have used such a deal a fortnight ago! I am resting here for a day before going forward. Hopefully my body will be rejuvinated by the rest. As for my spirit, my soul... That is broken, and will never be repaired.
June 13, 1848 (Last Entry) - Am so tired, so lost, so desparate. I cannot stand the loneliness of the hills at night, and the oxen provide such meager company. Sometimes, I just want it all to end. There is comfort, at least, in the knowledge that, though my family could not make it to the western frontier, at least we might be reunited in Elysium. Oh sweet Annabell, I'm coming!
Labels:
AAR,
fiction,
Games,
manifest destiny,
oregon trail
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
Graphics or Gameplay
I loathe dichotomies, because it seems to me that usually the things we see as opposed are more complementary than we think. Opposition itself is a kind of relationship, after all, and a close one at that. Up and down, I am fond of saying, are a lot closer to each other than up and penguin are.
Given my distaste for things which are allegedly, but not actually, "mutually exclusive," you may not be surprised to learn that I believe that good games often have both good graphics and good gameplay. Often, in the modern gaming world, it seems to me that you get one or the other; the development team blows its budget on good graphics designers or good game designers, but rarely both. And, what's more, even if they want to do both, hardware may not be up to the challenge. Really good gameplay - and especially a strong AI - might take up too much processor power and memory to make it possible for really nice, anti-aliased, 3D, shiny graphics to be feasible, even on a super-machine.
Of course, my natural position is to reconcile the paradox of gameplay and graphics by pointing out that graphics are a part of gameplay. It's easy for a gamer to get caught up in thinking about the graphics as being icing on the cake, but graphics go beyond what's happening in the center of the screen. The UI (user interface) is a part of graphics and gameplay, for example. The PC (player character), if there is one, should look good, but also serves a the vital gameplay function of telling the player where he is. That maybe goes without saying, but I think that many in the gaming world - or at least game players - have largely forgotten about the importance of functionality in graphics.
To me, then, good graphics are functional graphics. Age of Wonders may not be the flashiest, most beautiful game every made - and no wonder, since it's some 10 years old now - but the graphics are extremely functional. The player can tell, at a glance, what his army's composition is, where they are on the map, where the nearest towns are and how big those towns are, and even how much income those towns have in the form of farmland. All of that is modeled in 2D sprites, of course, but the advantage of 2D sprites is not to be ignored: they free up processor and memory resources for other things, like running the AI.
In the modern computing world - as we've gone to multi-core processors - this is even more important. A game like, for example, Elemental: War of Magic (in many ways a spiritual successor to the Age of Wonders series) is modeled in 3D, but with low-intensity graphics and the option to play on an essentially 2D cloth map. The relatively non-taxing graphics, compared with multi-core, threaded processing support allows the AI to run in the background (to plan its next move) while the player is playing. Hence both a better AI and quicker turn times, both leading to improved gameplay.
I want to talk about four games I've played recently, and how they manage the graphics / gameplay issue. All four, I think, do a good job (if for different reasons), and all four are from genres I prefer: rpg, strategy, and simulation. I'm not going to bash graphics-happy, but fundamentally crappy FPS games (oops, I just did), or lament about how they are destroying PC gaming or how gameplay is dead or anything like that. No, all four of these games are contemporary, and while they may not sell like the flashier, more braindead fare that even the least game-happy of you hear about (games like Call of Duty, Civilization Revolutions, or World of Warcraft), they are an indication of the way in which PC gaming is improving, even in the face of graphics-first consoles.*
* This isn't totally fair either. While AAA titles on the consoles certainly tend to be dumbed down, there are also fantastic innovations happening on XBox and PS3. Games like Flower and Flow, for example, are fantastic implementations of console technology. Likewise, small developers like Penny Arcade are making hilarious and amazing cross-platform RPGs. Not everything on console is FPS or the latest Madden game.
Avencast: Rise of the Mage
Avencast is an action RPG made by a very small team of programmers and artists. The voice acting is mediocre, the story is a bit predictable, and while the graphics are nice enough, they're not going to blow anyone away. What makes Avencast good, then, is its gameplay.
I'm not an action RPG buff by any means. Generally speaking, the "action" there means no thinking, no strategy. It means clicking on enemies to kill them, over and over and over. That is still true in Avencast, to a degree, but not in the way you're used to if you're a Diablo fanatic. Rather, in Avencast you are - not surprisingly - a young Mage, and your endless clicking casts a variety of spells, ranging from the tactical (freeze your opponent for no damange) to the devastating (unleash a meteor shower on your foes and wipe them all out).
The spell casting system is fun, because it's all key-combination based. Rather than queuing spell one to the "1" key, and spell 2 to the "2" key, you press a combination of movement keys in succession, and then cast the spell. This feels a bit more magical - if only marginally so - than many similar games. Taking into account the motions, tactics, and vulnerabilities and resistances of your enemies, you have to be careful about what spells you use when, meaning the gameplay isn't just hack and slash.
But it mostly is. I don't think Avencast is a great game, by any stretch, but it's a good one. There is one thing that is great about it, however: the graphical rendering of spells. Spells in Avencast look great, but, beyond that, they look how they should. That's an important distinction. Many magic-based games have generic spell effects that do little to differentiate a fire spell from an ice spell, or a shielding buff from a stat-raising one. In Avencast, on the other hand, every single spell looks exactly right. Your fire-wall looks like fire, and then when it gets upgraded to be half-fire, half "soul magic," it retains its fire billows but blanches to a white, soul-magicy hue instead of red. The aforementioned meteors hit randomly in a wide area, and where they hit randomly really matters. Sometimes they miss, and you can tell. The quick, "oh no I'm about to get hit" shield that you can cast blocks incoming attacks or effects for exactly as long as it is visible.
All of that sounds like a no brainer, but not all games do it. Avencast does it so brilliantly that, in the rare event that you fight another mage, you really feel like you know what spells the mage is casting (even if you've never seen the spells before) simply from the animations. That's a good use of graphics to improve gameplay. Attractive and functional is the right combination.
Europa Universalis III
Paradox Interactive recently released a 5th expansion for Europa Universalis 3, a game that has been around since before I graduated from college. Indeed, "Divine Wind," the newest add-on, is the second since Europa Universalis Complete was released.
Though still in need of patching, Divine Wind improves the graphics of EU3 considerably (if subtly), and also adds even more depth to what is already one of the deepest games there is. I've written about EU3 before, but to summarize, it's a grand strategy/simulation game based upon the history of the world from 1400 until the mid-19th century. The player leads a historical world power starting any time during that period (and ending any time), and plays without victory conditions, in an attempt to mimic or distort real history by expanding, fighting wars, engaging in diplomacy, colonizing, getting caught up in the reformation, and so on.
What makes EU3 so impressive is how much is going on in the background. There are literally hundreds of nations, each with their own AI plugging away and making decisions. The computing power needed to pull this off means no fancy 3D graphics. But, as you can see in the screenshot, the game still looks attractive - if you like nice maps, anyway. Armies and navies are easy to command, and indicators pop up to tell you which provinces are doing what. Perhaps most useful is the menu system - which hardly looks or feels like menus at all - that you use to manage the nuts and bolts of your empire / merchant republic / monarchy / tribal despotism. Information on your current ruler and heir is presented succinctly and conveniently, hiring new advisors is made easy, with all the information you need on one page, and managing your economy - while an art that takes practice - is only hard because of the game mechanics, and not because of the interface.
EU3 has one of the steepest learning curves of any game I have every played. Indeed, I have owned various versions of it for almost four years now, and I'm still learning to play. Only recently, for example, have I fully understood the drawbacks of expanding (the hit your research takes, for example, with more provinces, especially those that are of a different culture). But one thing is clear: the folks at Paradox chose gameplay first, and then chose graphics that are not bad, but rather that complement that gameplay and are immersive to the armchair-leader who is more fascinated by changing borders and movements of armies than by individual soldiers wiping their noses.
Football Manager
Football Manager is probably the best selling simulation game in the world. You may not have heard of it, because it's huge in Europe and relatively small in the USA, where soccer is still a fringe sport. But a recent interview with a SEGA executive in Game Informer would let you know that FM is in the same stratosphere as the Total War series in terms of profitability. Which, if you consider how soccer-happy Europe is, should come as no surprise. Who, after all, doesn't want to manage their favorite sports team?
I'm still playing FM 2010, despite the release of FM 2011, because I'm still wrapped up in a career I started in the earlier game. As you can see, I'm currently coaching Canvey Island, a small English semi-professional team. The screenshot comes from inside a match against Dartford, and while the majority of the game takes place in a menu-driven, text-based interface, this, I think, is the heart of Football Manager.
In any sports simulation, the match or game engine is what makes the thing go. It's all well and good to have a solid high-level system, but if the games themselves are unrealistic and clunky, the game falls short. Bowl Bound College Football, for example, had an intolerably bad play-calling system. Most EA games, as another example, are horribly unrealistic, and thus make bad simulations. Current online games like those at WhatIfSports are great because of the competition inherent in facing other humans, but their match and game engines are extremely opaque, entirely textual, and not very accurate.
Football Manager is in a class by itself, then. While it's not perfect, the match engine is ever-improving, and what's best about it is that you can watch, as you coach, your players actually execute your tactics. Now, for a non-European the learning curve here was very high, because I had to learn soccer tactics first, and then I had to learn the game, but over time I've come to see what a brilliant engine FM has.
Now, Football Manager currently does support 3D rendering of matches, but I choose not to use it. I do lose a little in terms of seeing who really tripped who (circles don't do a good job of indicating who's on the ground), but I stay with the 2D view for two reasons. First, it's a lot easier to survey the entire field, so I know not just what's happening on the ball, but what my, for example, left back is doing while my striker moves in to score. Second, the 2D graphics are better than the 3D ones anyway.
Football Manager's 3D graphics are choppy and clunky. Watching them, I feel like I'm playing a soccer simulation game. The 2D graphics make me feel like I'm coaching a soccer team. Odd? Perhaps, but I think it gets to the deeper point: graphics, in a game, are not a substitution for imagination. I can suspend disbelief a lot easier with circles running around, because I know it's an abstraction, than I can with clunky 3D models that don't really look like people, but look enough like them to ruin the abstraction. Immersion doesn't just come from pretty pictures: even mere text can do the job, and 2D is sometimes better than 3D.
Distant Worlds
Last but not least, I want to mention Distant Worlds, a game that is so massive, so complex, and so wonderfully fun that it could only work in 2D. Huh? Look at it. It's ugly. The ships are small, the space station looks horrible, and the planet is bland. The space looks empty, and everything is so dark.
Distant Worlds is a classic "don't judge a book by its cover" kind of game. The screenshots look unimpressive, but the reason the game looks so flat is because it has to, because in 3D it would be nigh unplayable. Whereas with other games we've discussed here there's a kind of interplay between sacrificing graphics for gameplay, in Distant Worlds there's actually a synergy. Simply put, there's so much to do in DW that 3D graphics would only disorient the player, making an already complex game needlessly more complicated.
What makes DW special? Scale. In a way, this is almost EU3 in space, only with ship design and without historical basis. DW takes place in galaxies ranging from the hundreds to the thousands of stars, each of which has planets or asteroids that - if they are not inhabitable - may have resources vital to the success of your empire. Indeed, economics drive DW, but they do so in the background. In a fantastic innovation, Codeforce - makers of the game - set up an automation system that takes care of huge swatches of your empire for you. No matter what, there is always a civilian economy that runs in the background of your military empire, collecting and exchanging resources, migrating between planets, and even visiting resort bases. But you can also let the AI take care of research and/or ship design and/or fighting wars and/or engaging in diplomacy and/or espionage and/or construction and/or colonization. The result: an incredibly complex 4X strategy game (that runs in real time, no less, though it can be paused) that is easy to learn because you can simply automate anything you don't want to worry about.
And, above all, the game looks right. It's easy to tell where your ships are, which colonies are yours, what kinds of ships you're using, and even how much commerce is going on (if you choose to let the game display civilian ships; which makes the game run very slowly on large maps). Above all, though, the abstraction of playing in 2 dimensions - instead of the 3 of, for example, Sword of the Stars - prevents the player from getting disoriented, and allows for seamless zooming from one side of your empire to another to address whatever problem might arise. In short, the graphics may not look like much, but they're supremely functional, and they're supported by such in-depth gameplay that they're almost irrelevant.
In summary, then, graphics do not make the game. Or, rather, graphics are how the player and the game interact, but they need not be fancy or high tech to do their job. Indeed, sometimes 3D is less immersive than 2D. Sometimes more flashy and fancy takes away from good gameplay. In PC gaming, in particular, it's important for developers and players to remember that the more complex interface (keyboard and mouse versus controller) and the more powerful hardware allows for games that are deeper, more engaging, and, ironically, maybe less pretty than games made for the consol. Kalos and agathos aren't always the same thing.
Given my distaste for things which are allegedly, but not actually, "mutually exclusive," you may not be surprised to learn that I believe that good games often have both good graphics and good gameplay. Often, in the modern gaming world, it seems to me that you get one or the other; the development team blows its budget on good graphics designers or good game designers, but rarely both. And, what's more, even if they want to do both, hardware may not be up to the challenge. Really good gameplay - and especially a strong AI - might take up too much processor power and memory to make it possible for really nice, anti-aliased, 3D, shiny graphics to be feasible, even on a super-machine.
Of course, my natural position is to reconcile the paradox of gameplay and graphics by pointing out that graphics are a part of gameplay. It's easy for a gamer to get caught up in thinking about the graphics as being icing on the cake, but graphics go beyond what's happening in the center of the screen. The UI (user interface) is a part of graphics and gameplay, for example. The PC (player character), if there is one, should look good, but also serves a the vital gameplay function of telling the player where he is. That maybe goes without saying, but I think that many in the gaming world - or at least game players - have largely forgotten about the importance of functionality in graphics.
![]() |
| The dragon on the menu screen might be a bit much |
In the modern computing world - as we've gone to multi-core processors - this is even more important. A game like, for example, Elemental: War of Magic (in many ways a spiritual successor to the Age of Wonders series) is modeled in 3D, but with low-intensity graphics and the option to play on an essentially 2D cloth map. The relatively non-taxing graphics, compared with multi-core, threaded processing support allows the AI to run in the background (to plan its next move) while the player is playing. Hence both a better AI and quicker turn times, both leading to improved gameplay.
I want to talk about four games I've played recently, and how they manage the graphics / gameplay issue. All four, I think, do a good job (if for different reasons), and all four are from genres I prefer: rpg, strategy, and simulation. I'm not going to bash graphics-happy, but fundamentally crappy FPS games (oops, I just did), or lament about how they are destroying PC gaming or how gameplay is dead or anything like that. No, all four of these games are contemporary, and while they may not sell like the flashier, more braindead fare that even the least game-happy of you hear about (games like Call of Duty, Civilization Revolutions, or World of Warcraft), they are an indication of the way in which PC gaming is improving, even in the face of graphics-first consoles.*
* This isn't totally fair either. While AAA titles on the consoles certainly tend to be dumbed down, there are also fantastic innovations happening on XBox and PS3. Games like Flower and Flow, for example, are fantastic implementations of console technology. Likewise, small developers like Penny Arcade are making hilarious and amazing cross-platform RPGs. Not everything on console is FPS or the latest Madden game.
Avencast: Rise of the Mage
| Wandering the Kyranian Wastes in search of demons |
I'm not an action RPG buff by any means. Generally speaking, the "action" there means no thinking, no strategy. It means clicking on enemies to kill them, over and over and over. That is still true in Avencast, to a degree, but not in the way you're used to if you're a Diablo fanatic. Rather, in Avencast you are - not surprisingly - a young Mage, and your endless clicking casts a variety of spells, ranging from the tactical (freeze your opponent for no damange) to the devastating (unleash a meteor shower on your foes and wipe them all out).
The spell casting system is fun, because it's all key-combination based. Rather than queuing spell one to the "1" key, and spell 2 to the "2" key, you press a combination of movement keys in succession, and then cast the spell. This feels a bit more magical - if only marginally so - than many similar games. Taking into account the motions, tactics, and vulnerabilities and resistances of your enemies, you have to be careful about what spells you use when, meaning the gameplay isn't just hack and slash.
But it mostly is. I don't think Avencast is a great game, by any stretch, but it's a good one. There is one thing that is great about it, however: the graphical rendering of spells. Spells in Avencast look great, but, beyond that, they look how they should. That's an important distinction. Many magic-based games have generic spell effects that do little to differentiate a fire spell from an ice spell, or a shielding buff from a stat-raising one. In Avencast, on the other hand, every single spell looks exactly right. Your fire-wall looks like fire, and then when it gets upgraded to be half-fire, half "soul magic," it retains its fire billows but blanches to a white, soul-magicy hue instead of red. The aforementioned meteors hit randomly in a wide area, and where they hit randomly really matters. Sometimes they miss, and you can tell. The quick, "oh no I'm about to get hit" shield that you can cast blocks incoming attacks or effects for exactly as long as it is visible.
All of that sounds like a no brainer, but not all games do it. Avencast does it so brilliantly that, in the rare event that you fight another mage, you really feel like you know what spells the mage is casting (even if you've never seen the spells before) simply from the animations. That's a good use of graphics to improve gameplay. Attractive and functional is the right combination.
Europa Universalis III
![]() |
| China has always been huge |
Though still in need of patching, Divine Wind improves the graphics of EU3 considerably (if subtly), and also adds even more depth to what is already one of the deepest games there is. I've written about EU3 before, but to summarize, it's a grand strategy/simulation game based upon the history of the world from 1400 until the mid-19th century. The player leads a historical world power starting any time during that period (and ending any time), and plays without victory conditions, in an attempt to mimic or distort real history by expanding, fighting wars, engaging in diplomacy, colonizing, getting caught up in the reformation, and so on.
What makes EU3 so impressive is how much is going on in the background. There are literally hundreds of nations, each with their own AI plugging away and making decisions. The computing power needed to pull this off means no fancy 3D graphics. But, as you can see in the screenshot, the game still looks attractive - if you like nice maps, anyway. Armies and navies are easy to command, and indicators pop up to tell you which provinces are doing what. Perhaps most useful is the menu system - which hardly looks or feels like menus at all - that you use to manage the nuts and bolts of your empire / merchant republic / monarchy / tribal despotism. Information on your current ruler and heir is presented succinctly and conveniently, hiring new advisors is made easy, with all the information you need on one page, and managing your economy - while an art that takes practice - is only hard because of the game mechanics, and not because of the interface.
EU3 has one of the steepest learning curves of any game I have every played. Indeed, I have owned various versions of it for almost four years now, and I'm still learning to play. Only recently, for example, have I fully understood the drawbacks of expanding (the hit your research takes, for example, with more provinces, especially those that are of a different culture). But one thing is clear: the folks at Paradox chose gameplay first, and then chose graphics that are not bad, but rather that complement that gameplay and are immersive to the armchair-leader who is more fascinated by changing borders and movements of armies than by individual soldiers wiping their noses.
Football Manager
Football Manager is probably the best selling simulation game in the world. You may not have heard of it, because it's huge in Europe and relatively small in the USA, where soccer is still a fringe sport. But a recent interview with a SEGA executive in Game Informer would let you know that FM is in the same stratosphere as the Total War series in terms of profitability. Which, if you consider how soccer-happy Europe is, should come as no surprise. Who, after all, doesn't want to manage their favorite sports team?
I'm still playing FM 2010, despite the release of FM 2011, because I'm still wrapped up in a career I started in the earlier game. As you can see, I'm currently coaching Canvey Island, a small English semi-professional team. The screenshot comes from inside a match against Dartford, and while the majority of the game takes place in a menu-driven, text-based interface, this, I think, is the heart of Football Manager.
![]() |
| Hooray for scoring goals |
In any sports simulation, the match or game engine is what makes the thing go. It's all well and good to have a solid high-level system, but if the games themselves are unrealistic and clunky, the game falls short. Bowl Bound College Football, for example, had an intolerably bad play-calling system. Most EA games, as another example, are horribly unrealistic, and thus make bad simulations. Current online games like those at WhatIfSports are great because of the competition inherent in facing other humans, but their match and game engines are extremely opaque, entirely textual, and not very accurate.
Football Manager is in a class by itself, then. While it's not perfect, the match engine is ever-improving, and what's best about it is that you can watch, as you coach, your players actually execute your tactics. Now, for a non-European the learning curve here was very high, because I had to learn soccer tactics first, and then I had to learn the game, but over time I've come to see what a brilliant engine FM has.
Now, Football Manager currently does support 3D rendering of matches, but I choose not to use it. I do lose a little in terms of seeing who really tripped who (circles don't do a good job of indicating who's on the ground), but I stay with the 2D view for two reasons. First, it's a lot easier to survey the entire field, so I know not just what's happening on the ball, but what my, for example, left back is doing while my striker moves in to score. Second, the 2D graphics are better than the 3D ones anyway.
Football Manager's 3D graphics are choppy and clunky. Watching them, I feel like I'm playing a soccer simulation game. The 2D graphics make me feel like I'm coaching a soccer team. Odd? Perhaps, but I think it gets to the deeper point: graphics, in a game, are not a substitution for imagination. I can suspend disbelief a lot easier with circles running around, because I know it's an abstraction, than I can with clunky 3D models that don't really look like people, but look enough like them to ruin the abstraction. Immersion doesn't just come from pretty pictures: even mere text can do the job, and 2D is sometimes better than 3D.
Distant Worlds
| 2D + Space = lots of ugly stacking; also, amazing gameplay |
Last but not least, I want to mention Distant Worlds, a game that is so massive, so complex, and so wonderfully fun that it could only work in 2D. Huh? Look at it. It's ugly. The ships are small, the space station looks horrible, and the planet is bland. The space looks empty, and everything is so dark.
Distant Worlds is a classic "don't judge a book by its cover" kind of game. The screenshots look unimpressive, but the reason the game looks so flat is because it has to, because in 3D it would be nigh unplayable. Whereas with other games we've discussed here there's a kind of interplay between sacrificing graphics for gameplay, in Distant Worlds there's actually a synergy. Simply put, there's so much to do in DW that 3D graphics would only disorient the player, making an already complex game needlessly more complicated.
What makes DW special? Scale. In a way, this is almost EU3 in space, only with ship design and without historical basis. DW takes place in galaxies ranging from the hundreds to the thousands of stars, each of which has planets or asteroids that - if they are not inhabitable - may have resources vital to the success of your empire. Indeed, economics drive DW, but they do so in the background. In a fantastic innovation, Codeforce - makers of the game - set up an automation system that takes care of huge swatches of your empire for you. No matter what, there is always a civilian economy that runs in the background of your military empire, collecting and exchanging resources, migrating between planets, and even visiting resort bases. But you can also let the AI take care of research and/or ship design and/or fighting wars and/or engaging in diplomacy and/or espionage and/or construction and/or colonization. The result: an incredibly complex 4X strategy game (that runs in real time, no less, though it can be paused) that is easy to learn because you can simply automate anything you don't want to worry about.
And, above all, the game looks right. It's easy to tell where your ships are, which colonies are yours, what kinds of ships you're using, and even how much commerce is going on (if you choose to let the game display civilian ships; which makes the game run very slowly on large maps). Above all, though, the abstraction of playing in 2 dimensions - instead of the 3 of, for example, Sword of the Stars - prevents the player from getting disoriented, and allows for seamless zooming from one side of your empire to another to address whatever problem might arise. In short, the graphics may not look like much, but they're supremely functional, and they're supported by such in-depth gameplay that they're almost irrelevant.
In summary, then, graphics do not make the game. Or, rather, graphics are how the player and the game interact, but they need not be fancy or high tech to do their job. Indeed, sometimes 3D is less immersive than 2D. Sometimes more flashy and fancy takes away from good gameplay. In PC gaming, in particular, it's important for developers and players to remember that the more complex interface (keyboard and mouse versus controller) and the more powerful hardware allows for games that are deeper, more engaging, and, ironically, maybe less pretty than games made for the consol. Kalos and agathos aren't always the same thing.
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Reviewing Final Fantasy XIII
As a person who has played a great many games, it may sound surprising that Final Fantasy XIII is the first FF title I've played in full. Oh, I dabbled in a PC port of the infamous sixth edition, and played a significant portion of 12 back when I had access to a PS2. Now, however, I actually have a *gasp* console in the form of a PS3 (which, I'll add, doubles as a DVD player, and connects to the Internet), and Final Fantasy and I were made for each other.
Why is that? Because the hallmark of the series has always been innovative and clever tactical battles, combined with excellent story telling. You may recall the place that Mass Effect holds in my gamer's heart (though I have not yet played ME2), thanks largely to its story telling and its deceptively tactical - for an FPS - gameplay. Add into that Final Fantasy's usually creative leveling systems, and you have the making of some of the best roll playing games in the world.
Now I've been told that, because I'm not a veteran of the series, XIII would not seem disappointing to me in the way it would to die-hards. I think that's probably right. Final Fantasy XIII is an exceptionally well polished game, well-told, beautiful, with excellent music and decent voice acting, an engaging enough story, and compelling characters. But, despite all of that, it's extremely railroaded, teetering somewhere in between pure adventure-gaming story telling and epic RPG awesomeness. Failing to decide either way is its biggest flaw, and what ultimately made it an experience I have no interest returning to.
Final Fantasy XIII begins slowly. The early battles - and, frankly, the game is essentially a series of battles and cutscenes, meaning these have to carry the title - are so simple and boring that it's tempting to give up. It takes hours of gameplay before things open up, before the tactics start to really flesh themselves out. Once they do, the game suddenly becomes fascinating and engaging, as you have to actually plan for each opponent and adjust on the fly rapidly when fighting, but it takes far too long for this to happen.
The battle mechanic is as follows: you control a single character, but have a party of up to three with you. You don't control the other characters, but you do assign roles for each character. Combinations of roles are called "paradigms," and heading into a battle you can select six paradigms to switch between as you fight. Early on, your paradigm choices are limited because your characters are still weak and can only execute one or two roles each, and your party is often limited to only two members. The six paradigms, then, are the only six possible.
Later, the game not only expands your party to three, but shortly thereafter gives you the option to compose your party as you wish. Suddenly the four or five valid options turns into dozens, and its not clear who should be in your party, let alone which paradigms will serve you best.
This, I would say, is the best part of the game. Once you have access to your whole party (and even with the silly artificial limitation of only using three members at once, even though the whole party is in theory traveling together), the experimentation in battle team composition, equipment, and paradigm usage is a lot of fun. For a while anyway.
Around the same time you finally end up on Pulse, a real planet below the orbiting world of Cocoon where the game begins. Pulse has more open gameplay - or at least is better at pretending to be open - and for the first time you can take on side quests away from the main plot. These side quests, however, are not especially engaging, as they are all in the "move here and kill this" vein. I completed only a couple before returning to the main plot, at which point I also found an unstoppable battle team and paradigm setup that won me almost every battle for the last 20 hours of the game.
That, above all, was the most disappointing thing. As my characters became more advanced, it became increasingly clear that there was little need to mix and match. The specific strengths and weaknesses of my opponents were insufficient to challenge my combination of Fang (physical attack), Vanille (magical healing), and Sazh (magical buffing and attack). I stomped my way through the ending portions of the game, restarting only a small handful of battles due to defeat. Most battles were over in a fraction of the target time.
If anything, my biggest critique of Final Fantasy XIII is that it was too user friendly, too easy to dominate. Sazh's haste spell made my team an unstoppable force, especially combined with how easy it was to boost Fang's strength to twice everyone else on my team. We attacked quickly and ferociously, and I wondered where the challenge lay. In many ways, having set up my paradigms for the end game, I simply let the game play itself and watched the cutscenes when they came.
Also disappointing was the end of the story. Without ruining it, I'll say that I had high hopes for a dark and sinister ending, or at least a major plot twist. My experience as a Knights of the Old Republic veteran, in particular, had me on guard for sudden surprises, and I fully expected that the Fal'cie (basically deities who run society) who had been manipulating us the whole way would turn out to have really out maneuvered us in the end. But it wasn't so. Rather, our final epic battle was against exactly who I thought it would be against, in more or less the way I expected since the midpoint of the game. In a story with so much potential, being so obvious was disappointing.
Overall, Final Fantasy XIII is a well-made game, and a console game. It lacks the sophistication of PC strategy and top-down rpg titles, and while it does have an engaging combat system, it's also easy to beat that system. Its greatest strength is its polish, its amazing visuals and audios, and its good story-telling. Unfortunately, it falls short in far too many areas to be a great game, and must be satisfied rather with being a merely good one. Which is sad, because the resources and sales that the Final Fantasy series has at its disposal means its capable of so much more.
I've read elsewhere that Final Fantasy XIII is a "failed experiment," that Square Enix is trying to innovate, and that this time they got it wrong. I think that's not fair, because FF XIII is, in the end, not innovative enough. It fails, not to deliver on its promise, but rather to set its ambitions high enough. I hope, come the 14th edition of the game, that Square Enix will reclaim its throne in the console-based RPG world, but it will only do so if it sets its aim higher.
Why is that? Because the hallmark of the series has always been innovative and clever tactical battles, combined with excellent story telling. You may recall the place that Mass Effect holds in my gamer's heart (though I have not yet played ME2), thanks largely to its story telling and its deceptively tactical - for an FPS - gameplay. Add into that Final Fantasy's usually creative leveling systems, and you have the making of some of the best roll playing games in the world.
Now I've been told that, because I'm not a veteran of the series, XIII would not seem disappointing to me in the way it would to die-hards. I think that's probably right. Final Fantasy XIII is an exceptionally well polished game, well-told, beautiful, with excellent music and decent voice acting, an engaging enough story, and compelling characters. But, despite all of that, it's extremely railroaded, teetering somewhere in between pure adventure-gaming story telling and epic RPG awesomeness. Failing to decide either way is its biggest flaw, and what ultimately made it an experience I have no interest returning to.
Final Fantasy XIII begins slowly. The early battles - and, frankly, the game is essentially a series of battles and cutscenes, meaning these have to carry the title - are so simple and boring that it's tempting to give up. It takes hours of gameplay before things open up, before the tactics start to really flesh themselves out. Once they do, the game suddenly becomes fascinating and engaging, as you have to actually plan for each opponent and adjust on the fly rapidly when fighting, but it takes far too long for this to happen.
The battle mechanic is as follows: you control a single character, but have a party of up to three with you. You don't control the other characters, but you do assign roles for each character. Combinations of roles are called "paradigms," and heading into a battle you can select six paradigms to switch between as you fight. Early on, your paradigm choices are limited because your characters are still weak and can only execute one or two roles each, and your party is often limited to only two members. The six paradigms, then, are the only six possible.
Later, the game not only expands your party to three, but shortly thereafter gives you the option to compose your party as you wish. Suddenly the four or five valid options turns into dozens, and its not clear who should be in your party, let alone which paradigms will serve you best.
This, I would say, is the best part of the game. Once you have access to your whole party (and even with the silly artificial limitation of only using three members at once, even though the whole party is in theory traveling together), the experimentation in battle team composition, equipment, and paradigm usage is a lot of fun. For a while anyway.
Around the same time you finally end up on Pulse, a real planet below the orbiting world of Cocoon where the game begins. Pulse has more open gameplay - or at least is better at pretending to be open - and for the first time you can take on side quests away from the main plot. These side quests, however, are not especially engaging, as they are all in the "move here and kill this" vein. I completed only a couple before returning to the main plot, at which point I also found an unstoppable battle team and paradigm setup that won me almost every battle for the last 20 hours of the game.
That, above all, was the most disappointing thing. As my characters became more advanced, it became increasingly clear that there was little need to mix and match. The specific strengths and weaknesses of my opponents were insufficient to challenge my combination of Fang (physical attack), Vanille (magical healing), and Sazh (magical buffing and attack). I stomped my way through the ending portions of the game, restarting only a small handful of battles due to defeat. Most battles were over in a fraction of the target time.
If anything, my biggest critique of Final Fantasy XIII is that it was too user friendly, too easy to dominate. Sazh's haste spell made my team an unstoppable force, especially combined with how easy it was to boost Fang's strength to twice everyone else on my team. We attacked quickly and ferociously, and I wondered where the challenge lay. In many ways, having set up my paradigms for the end game, I simply let the game play itself and watched the cutscenes when they came.
Also disappointing was the end of the story. Without ruining it, I'll say that I had high hopes for a dark and sinister ending, or at least a major plot twist. My experience as a Knights of the Old Republic veteran, in particular, had me on guard for sudden surprises, and I fully expected that the Fal'cie (basically deities who run society) who had been manipulating us the whole way would turn out to have really out maneuvered us in the end. But it wasn't so. Rather, our final epic battle was against exactly who I thought it would be against, in more or less the way I expected since the midpoint of the game. In a story with so much potential, being so obvious was disappointing.
Overall, Final Fantasy XIII is a well-made game, and a console game. It lacks the sophistication of PC strategy and top-down rpg titles, and while it does have an engaging combat system, it's also easy to beat that system. Its greatest strength is its polish, its amazing visuals and audios, and its good story-telling. Unfortunately, it falls short in far too many areas to be a great game, and must be satisfied rather with being a merely good one. Which is sad, because the resources and sales that the Final Fantasy series has at its disposal means its capable of so much more.
I've read elsewhere that Final Fantasy XIII is a "failed experiment," that Square Enix is trying to innovate, and that this time they got it wrong. I think that's not fair, because FF XIII is, in the end, not innovative enough. It fails, not to deliver on its promise, but rather to set its ambitions high enough. I hope, come the 14th edition of the game, that Square Enix will reclaim its throne in the console-based RPG world, but it will only do so if it sets its aim higher.
Labels:
Final Fantasy XIII,
Games,
play station,
reviews,
Square Enix
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Ping Pong
I suppose that most people watching, say, an NFL football game are well aware of how impossible it would be for them to step on the field and even pretend to play with the pros. Not only are the small NFL players bigger than the vast majority of us, it's pretty clear from watching them play that they're incredibly skilled and focused, not to mention propped up by countless mystery medicines and steroids and assorted body armor that they barely even count as people any more. And for good reason; the sport they play is far too brutal for any sane human being to participate in.
Nevertheless, because it's so ingrained in our culture, there's a kind of natural intuition as to whether a football player is doing it right, with the result that fans and pundits alike are quick to point out who sucks, who's good, who messed up, and who is so bad that he earns the adjective 'mediocre.'* The same is true in baseball, and generally speaking, while no rational fan honestly believes he or she could do just as well as the pro, there's kind of this latent, subconscious feeling that, yes, in fact, player X is so bad and messed up so much that I probably could do better.
* Is it just me, or had mediocre come to mean something even worse than awful, terrible, or bad? I mean, every team in every sport has lots of 'terrible' players, but only a particular kind of talent earns the moniker mediocre. While certainly a player everyone calls mediocre is probably better than the guy they say sucks, odds are the mediocre guy also plays an important role on the team. No one ever calls the back-up safety mediocre, for example. Mediocre is reserved for the QB, for the clean-up hitter, for the ace of the pitching staff, for the coach. I guess, all in all, mediocre is more damning because, while its fine to have a bad assistant special teams coach, a mediocre head coach in a world of good and great head coaches spells doom. Or at least mediocrity.
A classic example of the "I could do better" notion that immediately jumps to mind is the USA's goal against England keeper Robert Green in the World Cup. In case you don't remember, here it is (along with other highlights from the same game) in glorious LEGO:
Anyway, the point is, this is the kind of event that most sports fans look at and say, "Well I could do better than that." Fair or not, we have enough acquaintance with the game to believe that we could execute the basic fundamentals with as much precision as a pro.
Not so - and we're getting to the post title - in ping pong. Now I know the serious ping pongers out there will tell you it's supposed to be called "table tennis," and we'll get back to that. For now, the important thing is that, even though ping pong is a game almost everyone has played, and an extremely simple one with much more straightforward rules than, say, football or baseball, I think it's pretty much impossible to watch a professional ping pong match and feel like you could do better. Even a good amateur ping pong player generally approaches the game in a way that is so different from the way the pros do it that it's hard to imagine matching up.
Of course, that is true in other sports, too, but the odd thing is that in ping pong the illusion of being able to perform at a high level would take, it seems to me, a much higher level of self-deception. I don't even hold the paddle all backwards and upside down, and can't imagine that I would play better if I did. And yet, that's how the real ping pongers do it. I can't imagine serving with any degree of accuracy the way a real ping pong player serves. I certainly can't imagine hitting the ball from so far away from the table.
I think the key here, however, is that even someone like me who has been playing a fair (ok, perhaps alarming) amount of ping pong for the last two months now, can't even really follow what's going on in a serious ping pong match. The points are so fast, the strategy so blurred, the reactions so automatic, that it doesn't exactly make compelling viewing. Consider this video of the "Top 10 ping pong shots of all time:"
I can't even tell what's going on in half of these! Who's winning these shots? What makes them so good? I don't understand!
This is a chicken and egg thing, of course. We don't understand ping pong intuitively because we don't watch it, and vice versa. What's more, we find ping pong impossible to watch because it's too fast, but if we watched it enough maybe it would start to make sense. Then again, it might just stay weird and impossible to follow (what with the tiny ball and speed of the game), which might be part of why it has never been all that popular to begin with. That is, popular to watch. It's extremely popular to play by comparison. I think ping pong, darts, and pool are probably the three most prominent game-sports* that more people play than watch.
*As opposed to sports like running or skiing or swimming or surfing, which aren't really games.
Which all brings me to the name "ping pong." My extremely cursory research tells me that ping pong - the term - originated with Parker Brothers around 1900, around the same time as the name "table tennis." Apparently no one wanted to stick with the game's original name "Wiff-Waff," and I can't imagine why not. Regardless, the name ping pong seems to me much more appropriate, because table tennis makes the whole thing sound like tennis on a table.
Which, you're probably thinking, is exactly what it is. Except it's not. Sure, there's a passing resemblance to tennis, but ping pong is as much like tennis as volley ball is, I would argue. The differences are far more pronounced than the presence of a table. For example, the ball is plastic instead of felt and rubber, the paddles hard instead of strung, and the game is played from outside of the playing area (instead of inside). Serves have to bounce on the servers side of the table, but don't have to go cross court. Players have to pivot a lot, but rarely do they ever have to run. Most of all, the strategy is completely different. Oh, there are analogies, just as there are between other net-and-ball games and tennis, but trying to play like Rafael Nadal won't make you a better ping pong player.
Which is why ping pong needs a different name than tennis, and table tennis is so much less inventive. Ping pong is colorful, absurd, and impossible to take seriously. Which is how it should be. After all, this is no sport of gridiron tactics and bone-crushing hits, nor is it a sport of last at-bat high drama. It's just ping pong.
Nevertheless, because it's so ingrained in our culture, there's a kind of natural intuition as to whether a football player is doing it right, with the result that fans and pundits alike are quick to point out who sucks, who's good, who messed up, and who is so bad that he earns the adjective 'mediocre.'* The same is true in baseball, and generally speaking, while no rational fan honestly believes he or she could do just as well as the pro, there's kind of this latent, subconscious feeling that, yes, in fact, player X is so bad and messed up so much that I probably could do better.
* Is it just me, or had mediocre come to mean something even worse than awful, terrible, or bad? I mean, every team in every sport has lots of 'terrible' players, but only a particular kind of talent earns the moniker mediocre. While certainly a player everyone calls mediocre is probably better than the guy they say sucks, odds are the mediocre guy also plays an important role on the team. No one ever calls the back-up safety mediocre, for example. Mediocre is reserved for the QB, for the clean-up hitter, for the ace of the pitching staff, for the coach. I guess, all in all, mediocre is more damning because, while its fine to have a bad assistant special teams coach, a mediocre head coach in a world of good and great head coaches spells doom. Or at least mediocrity.
A classic example of the "I could do better" notion that immediately jumps to mind is the USA's goal against England keeper Robert Green in the World Cup. In case you don't remember, here it is (along with other highlights from the same game) in glorious LEGO:
Anyway, the point is, this is the kind of event that most sports fans look at and say, "Well I could do better than that." Fair or not, we have enough acquaintance with the game to believe that we could execute the basic fundamentals with as much precision as a pro.
Not so - and we're getting to the post title - in ping pong. Now I know the serious ping pongers out there will tell you it's supposed to be called "table tennis," and we'll get back to that. For now, the important thing is that, even though ping pong is a game almost everyone has played, and an extremely simple one with much more straightforward rules than, say, football or baseball, I think it's pretty much impossible to watch a professional ping pong match and feel like you could do better. Even a good amateur ping pong player generally approaches the game in a way that is so different from the way the pros do it that it's hard to imagine matching up.
Of course, that is true in other sports, too, but the odd thing is that in ping pong the illusion of being able to perform at a high level would take, it seems to me, a much higher level of self-deception. I don't even hold the paddle all backwards and upside down, and can't imagine that I would play better if I did. And yet, that's how the real ping pongers do it. I can't imagine serving with any degree of accuracy the way a real ping pong player serves. I certainly can't imagine hitting the ball from so far away from the table.
I think the key here, however, is that even someone like me who has been playing a fair (ok, perhaps alarming) amount of ping pong for the last two months now, can't even really follow what's going on in a serious ping pong match. The points are so fast, the strategy so blurred, the reactions so automatic, that it doesn't exactly make compelling viewing. Consider this video of the "Top 10 ping pong shots of all time:"
I can't even tell what's going on in half of these! Who's winning these shots? What makes them so good? I don't understand!
This is a chicken and egg thing, of course. We don't understand ping pong intuitively because we don't watch it, and vice versa. What's more, we find ping pong impossible to watch because it's too fast, but if we watched it enough maybe it would start to make sense. Then again, it might just stay weird and impossible to follow (what with the tiny ball and speed of the game), which might be part of why it has never been all that popular to begin with. That is, popular to watch. It's extremely popular to play by comparison. I think ping pong, darts, and pool are probably the three most prominent game-sports* that more people play than watch.
*As opposed to sports like running or skiing or swimming or surfing, which aren't really games.
Which all brings me to the name "ping pong." My extremely cursory research tells me that ping pong - the term - originated with Parker Brothers around 1900, around the same time as the name "table tennis." Apparently no one wanted to stick with the game's original name "Wiff-Waff," and I can't imagine why not. Regardless, the name ping pong seems to me much more appropriate, because table tennis makes the whole thing sound like tennis on a table.
Which, you're probably thinking, is exactly what it is. Except it's not. Sure, there's a passing resemblance to tennis, but ping pong is as much like tennis as volley ball is, I would argue. The differences are far more pronounced than the presence of a table. For example, the ball is plastic instead of felt and rubber, the paddles hard instead of strung, and the game is played from outside of the playing area (instead of inside). Serves have to bounce on the servers side of the table, but don't have to go cross court. Players have to pivot a lot, but rarely do they ever have to run. Most of all, the strategy is completely different. Oh, there are analogies, just as there are between other net-and-ball games and tennis, but trying to play like Rafael Nadal won't make you a better ping pong player.
Which is why ping pong needs a different name than tennis, and table tennis is so much less inventive. Ping pong is colorful, absurd, and impossible to take seriously. Which is how it should be. After all, this is no sport of gridiron tactics and bone-crushing hits, nor is it a sport of last at-bat high drama. It's just ping pong.
Labels:
Football,
Games,
mediocrity,
ping pong,
sports,
table tennis,
tennis,
wiff waff
Friday, September 10, 2010
The Fascination with Casual Games
When I have the time and space to be so, I'm a fairly serious about my computer games. I don't mean I take games seriously - I reserve that distinction for people who are more committed to their World of Warcraft* characters than their real lives. No, what I mean is, I play games that most people balk at, the kinds of games that people point to when they're talking about why PC gaming is dying (because the games are too complicated for a general audience). For example, I'm a big fan of Europa Universalis III, a game with a practically vertical learning curve, no victory conditions, and one of the most awful, boring combat systems you'll find in a strategy game.
* Blogger, evidently, thinks "warcraft" isn't a word, as angry red squiggles pop up when I type it (it sugests "watercraft," "aircraft," and "hovercraft" as alternatives, among others). This is odd because warcraft was a word far before the series of games came into existence. More hilariously, "Blogger" also induces angry red squiggles.
Another example: Romance of the Three Kingdoms XI. I'm linking to the Metacritic page because the blurbs there tell you a lot. IGN writes, "The considerable investment of time and focus it takes to begin to enjoy Romance of the Three Kingdoms XI is probably enough to turn off most gamers." Absolute Games says, "The pace of this game is laid-back even by the standards of the 4X strategy genre. Most people will hate it for being obscure and boring." A particularly harsh review from PC Zone UK muses, "It lacks the logical connections that most strategy games have."
But I love it! Well, most of it. The problem with Romance, for me anyway, is not its so-called steep learning curve (I found the game quite easy to get into) or its extreme micromanagement. Rather, the problem is an abysmal tactical and strategic AI and the rather shallow limits in the number of choices the player can make as leader of his ancient Chinese faction. The game looks amazing, but its problem is that, far from being too hard, its far too easy. Add in an atrocious interface designed for console (strategy games on console? really?), and you have the makings of a disappointing title, overall, but for all of the opposite reasons from the ones the reviewers give.
I could list more games, but the point is, I prefer deep, strategic, complex games with challenging AIs. I prefer turn-based games over real-time games, I prefer games that ask me to design (in one way or another), rather than games that ask me simply to be awed by beautiful graphics and to kill everything that moves.
It might come as a surprise, then, if I say that I am fascinated by a large number of recent Casual Games. The genre is nothing new - think Bejewelled or even Tetris - but the level to which casual gaming has risen is truly stunning. In addition to the literally thousands of free flash games - some of which quite good - available at dozens of websites, there have been a handful of standout commercial games in the last few years that I want to mention in particular. Why? Because it turns out that a good developer, with some creativity and a good design process, can create a game every bit as deep as a Civilization title without forcing the gamer to spend ten (or twenty, or a hundred) hours playing just to achieve victory.
Osmos is a recent standout. Not only is the game beautiful in all of its 2D splendor, but it's highly intuitive and incredibly relaxing. Also, it's one of the single most difficult games I've ever played. The later levels cannot be defeated by willpower alone; rather, they require intense focus, strategy, and a fairly sophisticated and intuitive understanding of orbital mechanics. One level in particular - which had me screaming, cursing, walking away from the computer - is so difficult that it took me probably in excess of 50 tries to beat it. And yet, even in my frustration, I was happy; this was a challenge worth meeting.
Completing F3C-3 (Epicycles 3) from hemisphere games on Vimeo.
The level in question is "Epicycles 3," in the Force tree of the game. Your goal is to progressively absorb other motes until you're big enough to absorb or otherwise destroy the four "attractors," in the game window. The tricky thing is, in order to move, you have to expel mass, and thus you're in a constant fight to get larger whilst also moving to the right place. In most levels, doing this is fairly straightforward - though cleverness and patience are always virtues - but in Epicycles this is a truly Herculean task. As you can see from the video, the developers of the game realized the level was so difficult that they felt compelled to put up a tutorial just for the level.
Flotilla is a game I haven't played much, but I love that it takes only fifteen minutes or so to complete a play-through. Often, at least for the beginner, much less. What makes Flotilla great is its combat system - which is really the whole game. It's incredibly abstracted, thanks to the wire-frame animations and general lack of graphics, but it has a certain charm to it as well, and the tactical depth is incredible. Casual though this game may be, it's no walk in the park to play. As I said, the beginner (like me) is liable to get blown out of the water repeatedly before he gets the hand of how to effectively pilot his ship. But this is a game where defeat does not weight heavily on you, because you can simply fire up a new ship and get blown to bits by someone else. And even if you do manage to survive your battles, your "Capitan" is on his proverbial last legs anyway, so death is inevitable.
A similar game to Flotilla, though a bit older, is Weird Worlds: Return to Infinite Space. The concept is eerily similar, but the execution very different. Combat is 2D instead of 3D, and you're much more likely to survive the thing. Like Flotilla, Weird Worlds takes minutes, not hours, to play, and there's a certain satisfaction in exploring the entire map you're provided at the beginning of each session. Even better, in Weird Worlds, is all the frankly bizarre stuff that happens. Sometimes the galaxy gets invaded by a freakish alien menace, sometimes stars go supernova, and sometimes you get sucked into a black hole because you thought you could make it around the thing when you actually couldn't. Even in death, however, there's always the opportunity to fire up a new 10 minute session and to see what will happen this time.
Passage is a game you've probably never heard of. It takes five minutes to play, and you'll probably only play it once or twice, but it is truly one of the most fantastic gaming experiences I've ever had. The play area is only 100 pixels by 16 (4 of which are used for a small scoreboard). But what it accomplishes with that space is amazing. It's poetry. It's art.
I don't want to give the game away, because not knowing what it is makes for much of its charm. Download it, play it, and be stunned. You may even cry, it's that good. And once you've had a chance to play it, I promise to do a whole post on it at a later date.
Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords is somewhere between casual game and traditional PC game. I say that because actually beating Puzzle Quest - as I have not done - takes as long as beating a normal RPG. The gameplay is almost all Bejeweled, but the bejeweled puzzles take place as a part of a classic RPG storyline where you, as a young mage/knight/warrior/druid have to fend off some evil nemesis yadda yadda. Actually, the story is more compelling than you'd think, and the artwork throughout the game is charming and fun. There are even some (somewhat simplistic, but fun anyway) strategic elements to the game, including building up your castle and choosing which mount to ride into jewely battle. In all, you don't lose in Puzzle Quest, so it is decidedly casual, but no game is as indicative of the rise of casual gaming in the PC world as it is.
Finally, the crowning jewel of the casual game world, at least to my mind, is 2D Boy's World of Goo. It is brilliant, both in its fantastic level design and in its humor. The mechanic is fairly simple and intuitive, and learning the game takes no time at all, but the twists the game's "story" goes through - and the levels with it - are all so wonderfully unexpected and fresh that one wonders why major developers can't find people this creative. One part in particular - when the goo world suddenly turns into a Tron-like retro 80's look and the gameplay mechanics shift fairly substantially - had me literally jumping up out of my chair in excitement.
What's best about World of Goo, and what makes it perhaps even more emblematic of modern casual gaming than Puzzle Quest, is its wide-ranging appeal. To a true, serious gamer it is hilarious, full of cynicism and barbs intended for both society at large and the gaming world in particular. For the truly casual casual gamer, it is both fun to play and intuitive.
For my part, playing World of Goo is easily one of the best gaming experiences I've ever had, on par with more in-depth games like Civilization IV or Mass Effect. Which surprises me. I suppose the question is, what makes these simple, mostly 2-dimensional, casual games so compelling? Or, perhaps more aptly, why are (mostly independent) casual game developers doing such a better job being creative and innovative than big companies like Electronic Arts, Ubisoft, or Firaxis? That's kind of a leading question of course, because a smaller package means it's easier to take risks, and there are a great many casual games that fail to deliver on their innovative promise. Nevertheless, casual games are becoming more and more prominent, and can deliver - even for a serious gamer - a truly in-depth, strategic, and stimulating gaming experience. Who knew?
* Blogger, evidently, thinks "warcraft" isn't a word, as angry red squiggles pop up when I type it (it sugests "watercraft," "aircraft," and "hovercraft" as alternatives, among others). This is odd because warcraft was a word far before the series of games came into existence. More hilariously, "Blogger" also induces angry red squiggles.
Another example: Romance of the Three Kingdoms XI. I'm linking to the Metacritic page because the blurbs there tell you a lot. IGN writes, "The considerable investment of time and focus it takes to begin to enjoy Romance of the Three Kingdoms XI is probably enough to turn off most gamers." Absolute Games says, "The pace of this game is laid-back even by the standards of the 4X strategy genre. Most people will hate it for being obscure and boring." A particularly harsh review from PC Zone UK muses, "It lacks the logical connections that most strategy games have."
But I love it! Well, most of it. The problem with Romance, for me anyway, is not its so-called steep learning curve (I found the game quite easy to get into) or its extreme micromanagement. Rather, the problem is an abysmal tactical and strategic AI and the rather shallow limits in the number of choices the player can make as leader of his ancient Chinese faction. The game looks amazing, but its problem is that, far from being too hard, its far too easy. Add in an atrocious interface designed for console (strategy games on console? really?), and you have the makings of a disappointing title, overall, but for all of the opposite reasons from the ones the reviewers give.
I could list more games, but the point is, I prefer deep, strategic, complex games with challenging AIs. I prefer turn-based games over real-time games, I prefer games that ask me to design (in one way or another), rather than games that ask me simply to be awed by beautiful graphics and to kill everything that moves.
It might come as a surprise, then, if I say that I am fascinated by a large number of recent Casual Games. The genre is nothing new - think Bejewelled or even Tetris - but the level to which casual gaming has risen is truly stunning. In addition to the literally thousands of free flash games - some of which quite good - available at dozens of websites, there have been a handful of standout commercial games in the last few years that I want to mention in particular. Why? Because it turns out that a good developer, with some creativity and a good design process, can create a game every bit as deep as a Civilization title without forcing the gamer to spend ten (or twenty, or a hundred) hours playing just to achieve victory.
Osmos is a recent standout. Not only is the game beautiful in all of its 2D splendor, but it's highly intuitive and incredibly relaxing. Also, it's one of the single most difficult games I've ever played. The later levels cannot be defeated by willpower alone; rather, they require intense focus, strategy, and a fairly sophisticated and intuitive understanding of orbital mechanics. One level in particular - which had me screaming, cursing, walking away from the computer - is so difficult that it took me probably in excess of 50 tries to beat it. And yet, even in my frustration, I was happy; this was a challenge worth meeting.
Completing F3C-3 (Epicycles 3) from hemisphere games on Vimeo.
The level in question is "Epicycles 3," in the Force tree of the game. Your goal is to progressively absorb other motes until you're big enough to absorb or otherwise destroy the four "attractors," in the game window. The tricky thing is, in order to move, you have to expel mass, and thus you're in a constant fight to get larger whilst also moving to the right place. In most levels, doing this is fairly straightforward - though cleverness and patience are always virtues - but in Epicycles this is a truly Herculean task. As you can see from the video, the developers of the game realized the level was so difficult that they felt compelled to put up a tutorial just for the level.
Flotilla is a game I haven't played much, but I love that it takes only fifteen minutes or so to complete a play-through. Often, at least for the beginner, much less. What makes Flotilla great is its combat system - which is really the whole game. It's incredibly abstracted, thanks to the wire-frame animations and general lack of graphics, but it has a certain charm to it as well, and the tactical depth is incredible. Casual though this game may be, it's no walk in the park to play. As I said, the beginner (like me) is liable to get blown out of the water repeatedly before he gets the hand of how to effectively pilot his ship. But this is a game where defeat does not weight heavily on you, because you can simply fire up a new ship and get blown to bits by someone else. And even if you do manage to survive your battles, your "Capitan" is on his proverbial last legs anyway, so death is inevitable.
A similar game to Flotilla, though a bit older, is Weird Worlds: Return to Infinite Space. The concept is eerily similar, but the execution very different. Combat is 2D instead of 3D, and you're much more likely to survive the thing. Like Flotilla, Weird Worlds takes minutes, not hours, to play, and there's a certain satisfaction in exploring the entire map you're provided at the beginning of each session. Even better, in Weird Worlds, is all the frankly bizarre stuff that happens. Sometimes the galaxy gets invaded by a freakish alien menace, sometimes stars go supernova, and sometimes you get sucked into a black hole because you thought you could make it around the thing when you actually couldn't. Even in death, however, there's always the opportunity to fire up a new 10 minute session and to see what will happen this time.
Passage is a game you've probably never heard of. It takes five minutes to play, and you'll probably only play it once or twice, but it is truly one of the most fantastic gaming experiences I've ever had. The play area is only 100 pixels by 16 (4 of which are used for a small scoreboard). But what it accomplishes with that space is amazing. It's poetry. It's art.
I don't want to give the game away, because not knowing what it is makes for much of its charm. Download it, play it, and be stunned. You may even cry, it's that good. And once you've had a chance to play it, I promise to do a whole post on it at a later date.
Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords is somewhere between casual game and traditional PC game. I say that because actually beating Puzzle Quest - as I have not done - takes as long as beating a normal RPG. The gameplay is almost all Bejeweled, but the bejeweled puzzles take place as a part of a classic RPG storyline where you, as a young mage/knight/warrior/druid have to fend off some evil nemesis yadda yadda. Actually, the story is more compelling than you'd think, and the artwork throughout the game is charming and fun. There are even some (somewhat simplistic, but fun anyway) strategic elements to the game, including building up your castle and choosing which mount to ride into jewely battle. In all, you don't lose in Puzzle Quest, so it is decidedly casual, but no game is as indicative of the rise of casual gaming in the PC world as it is.
Finally, the crowning jewel of the casual game world, at least to my mind, is 2D Boy's World of Goo. It is brilliant, both in its fantastic level design and in its humor. The mechanic is fairly simple and intuitive, and learning the game takes no time at all, but the twists the game's "story" goes through - and the levels with it - are all so wonderfully unexpected and fresh that one wonders why major developers can't find people this creative. One part in particular - when the goo world suddenly turns into a Tron-like retro 80's look and the gameplay mechanics shift fairly substantially - had me literally jumping up out of my chair in excitement.
What's best about World of Goo, and what makes it perhaps even more emblematic of modern casual gaming than Puzzle Quest, is its wide-ranging appeal. To a true, serious gamer it is hilarious, full of cynicism and barbs intended for both society at large and the gaming world in particular. For the truly casual casual gamer, it is both fun to play and intuitive.
For my part, playing World of Goo is easily one of the best gaming experiences I've ever had, on par with more in-depth games like Civilization IV or Mass Effect. Which surprises me. I suppose the question is, what makes these simple, mostly 2-dimensional, casual games so compelling? Or, perhaps more aptly, why are (mostly independent) casual game developers doing such a better job being creative and innovative than big companies like Electronic Arts, Ubisoft, or Firaxis? That's kind of a leading question of course, because a smaller package means it's easier to take risks, and there are a great many casual games that fail to deliver on their innovative promise. Nevertheless, casual games are becoming more and more prominent, and can deliver - even for a serious gamer - a truly in-depth, strategic, and stimulating gaming experience. Who knew?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


.jpg)
