Juan Carlos Ferrero used to be the best tennis player in the world. Back in 2003, in the middle of that five-year vacuum between Sampras and Federer, Ferrero joined Andy Roddick, Lleyton Hewitt, and even, briefly, Andre Agassi in taking his turn at the top of the tennis-ranking mountain. Now Ferrero is 31, still young by the standards of society, but positively ancient in the world of tennis.
Ferrero fell short of the quarterfinals at this years U.S. Open after losing to the colorfully named Janko Tipsarevic. And had he managed to win that match, an almost certain defeat at the hands of current world number one Novak Djokovic waited at the other end. Regardless, the Tipsarevic match I have little to say about, except that it was a hard-fought four setter. The match before it was the interesting one.
----------------------------------------------------
On our way to San Diego, my wife and I suddenly found ourselves in bumper-to-bumper traffic. Now that's no surprise in Southern California, but in this case the traffic was particularly bad. The highway, it turns out, was on fire. Or, rather, a fire raged on both sides of I-15 in Victorville, just north of the northern reaches of the Los Angeles metropolitan area. After two and a half hours of trying to find a way around the flames, we turned North instead, setting out on an unexpected path.
We ended up in Lake Isabella, on the doorstep of Sequoia National Forest. Big trees, we thought. We want to see big trees. We rolled into a shabby old motel near the lake at almost 10:00 PM, after starting our day in Flagstaff, Arizona, and called it a minor, if unexpected, victory.
----------------------------------------------------
Gael Monfils might be the most entertaining player on the ATP World Tour. He dives to make his shots, he lopes around the court, he pouts, he yells, he engages in a subtle rope-a-dope that announcers - and, in theory, his opponents - mistake for nonchalance. Above all, he plays with joy and the curse of grace, and so the crowd loves him and is yet frustrated by his failure to be better.
The "curse of grace" is a term Joe Posnanski uses to describe Carlos Beltran. Some athletes are so gifted, so refined, so graceful at what they do that they appear not to be trying. If only, we think, he would try a little harder, he'd be truly great. Gael Mofils tries hard. You don't become as good a tennis player as he is (#7 in the World entering the U.S. Open) without practicing hours and hours and hours a day, without pushing yourself, without learning how to give more than you think you have. And yet he looks like he's not trying, because he's just that graceful, and because - despite the criticism it brings - he wants you to think that he's not trying.
Juan Carlos Ferrero, whose own grace is largely a memory by now, beat Gael Monfils in five sets last week.
----------------------------------------------------
After a long drive through the Kern River valley, up into the mountains, we finally arrived at the big trees. The first one lurked behind a turn on the road, eliciting cries of surprise and awe as we passed. Even if you've watched Planet Earth, even if you've seen one of the countless pictures of the Giant Sequoias, nothing can prepare you for actually seeing one.
We happily paid to park next to the somewhat touristy Trail of 100 Giants trailhead. Rarely - though moreso in National Parks than anywhere else - the touristy vibe of a place is irrelevant to its own internal grace. The Giant Sequoias along the trail we walked were in no way lessened by the paved path that weaved between them, nor by the screaming of children unaccustomed to a screen-less walk through a natural monument.
One child in particular screamed and screamed and screamed. He didn't want to go towards the leaning tree, or away from something he liked, or along a path near so many bees. The exact nature of his protest was hard to make out, but it was, I'm certain, directional. It seemed to me, above all, that he didn't want to confront the Sequoias. No child is able to comprehend those trees. Indeed, probably no adult can really understand what it means for a tree to be 1,500 years old. Constantine is ancient history; the birth of a Sequoia, even more so.
Infinity is not nearly as overwhelming a concept as finite but large. The Sequoias are giants - too big to see the top of, over a dozen feet in diameter at the base, sometimes scarred with burn marks as large as an entire cedar tree - but it is their relationship to time, more than space, that truly impresses. What can a child do but cry when confronted with a 75-year-old baby of a Sequoia that's older than Granpa, and yet at only the beginning of its young life?
----------------------------------------------------
Monfils played as Monfils plays. Ferrero played as he is forced to at his age. After a gritty first set tiebreaker, Monfils power and agility won out in tight second and third sets. He looked to be in command of the match, but he plays an expensive brand of tennis. Every dive, every collapse, the effort of chasing down so many of Ferrero's well-placed shots caught up with Monfils. He still held serve in most every game down the stretch of the final two sets, but a break here and a break there, and Ferrero closed out the match 6-4, 6-4 in the final two sets.
Tennis - especially at a Major Tournament like the Open - is a grueling sport. As important as power, speed, and agility are, stamina and the ability to pace oneself are just as important. Ferrero rarely overexerted himself in his match with Monfils, playing just hard enough to push the Frenchman, just pesky enough to stay in the first three sets and steal one of them. Then, by the time the fourth set rolled around the match was already well over three hours old, and Monfils's grace and nonchalance turned into fatigue, and Ferrero showed the instinct that allows you to be the best in the world, if only for a short time.
----------------------------------------------------
The tree we spent the most time with was dead. It had fallen well over 100 years ago, and yet it had barely decayed. For the Sequoias even death moves in slow motion. Lying on the ground, it's easier to appreciate the sheer size of one of these Giants. Walking from base to tip is roughly equivalent to traversing three tennis courts. Climbing onto the curved peak affords one a view of a dangerous fall. Bringing the virtually imperceptible giants to human scale only further reinforces how unfathomably huge they are standing up.
On the exposed faces of the fallen Sequoia people had scrawled initials, expressions of undying love, crude jokes, and brief political rants. It's tempting to be upset about the human need to spoil natural beauty, but in this case anger is as perfectly irrelevant as the illegible carvings. These trees do not exist on any human scale, and our petty efforts to make them ours - by writing on them, or by protecting them from writing - misses their point. Indeed, they do not have, in any human sense, a point. They are merely trees. What power we exert over or in service of them says more about us than it does about them.
----------------------------------------------------
I wonder about players like Juan Carlos Ferrero. What motivates him to keep playing when he knows that he stands little chance against the Roger Federers and Rafael Nadals and Novak Djokovics of the modern game? As time passes the gap between himself and the top players grows, and as new top players find their way to the peak of their own games, Ferrero will continue to be the same Ferrero who reached his peak in 2003, and has been fighting to maintain a semblance of that greatness ever since. Sure, another big paycheck, another endorsement deal or two can't hurt, but defeat does hurt for a champion.
"The love of the game" is a hackneyed and inadequate response to the question. Of course Ferrero loves the game, and of course he believes in himself. Somewhere, though, in the back of his mind, he has to know that the victories left to him are the ones that are not won during prime time, with the lights shining on him and the TV cameras rolling. He might beat Gael Monfils, who is number seven in the world, but that is still a minor, unexpected victory. Maybe, though, even for a former world champion, that's all that matters sometimes.
----------------------------------------------------
Now we're searching for a home in the South Bay. The trees are behind us. Their monolithic presence has given way to human concerns: a place to sleep, food to eat, a toilet to shit in. As we search we've been forced to reconnect with commerce, with the artificial rules and regulations of the social contract, with the cultural codes that run even deeper than that, with the games that you have to play. The U.S. Open is still on TV.
And what is a home, really? It's a place to stay, but - as the saying goes - you can carry it on your back. It's a transitory phenomenon, a place defined by its residents, a moment. And yet the question "Where do you live" usually elicits a one word response: Honolulu, Denver, San Francisco. These capital-letter stand-ins for the particular moments we spend in our homes speak to eternity, a time that spans our own lives. In the end, a home is both the moment and the eternity, the place and the Place. Perhaps we don't always look for these things, but we find them anyway. Or, anyway, they find us.
----------------------------------------------------
What does Juan Carlos Ferrero have to do with the Sequoias? Nothing, really. Ferrero operates on a human scale, searching for a victory this week, and another one next week. His career as a tennis player will be over soon, even though it only just started, even by the standards of a normal human "career." The Sequoias, on the other hand, lie mostly outside of human perception. Comprehending what it means for anything to exist for 1,500 years is essentially impossible for a creature that lives less than 100 years. Eternity is not the precise word, but it might as well be.
As I search for a home, I'm really searching for a place where I can filter my perceptions, understand my interactions, and ground my existence. Wrapped up in a home is an understanding of home in its moments and in its eternities. Ferrero and the Sequoias are experiences I filter through myself, and as I look for a home, I look for a way of understanding not the meaning of tennis or really big trees, but rather something about myself. I know where I am going, what I am going to do, and perhaps even a little bit about who I am. Still, there's something else that a home represents in time, in space, and in understanding.
That something is wrapped up in eternity and in moments, in trees and tennis courts, and, above all, in the way we move through it all.
Showing posts with label tennis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tennis. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 6, 2011
Wednesday, August 31, 2011
Win Probability and Tennis
As a huge baseball statistics nerd, I love Fangraphs.com. Well, I don't really read many of their articles, nor do I engage in their often contentious comment threads. Rather, I love the thing that made it famous: win probability graphs. If you haven't seen one, they look like this.
The premise is simple. Given any game situation, you can calculate - based on the number of expected runs scored for both the remainder of the inning and the remainder of the game - how likely each team is to win. Certain events, like home runs, tend to increase your odds significantly, while others, like strikeouts with the bases loaded and two outs, tend to hurt them. Of course, context becomes extremely important, and the graph will fluctuate more in closer games like the Royals versus Tigers game above.
Now the cool part is not even the graph itself, but the "Leverage Index" beneath it. Basically, the amount of change that is possible/likely in any given situation is mapped beneath the graph. This leads to a clear, quantitative mapping of high and low leverage situations. This in turn, leads to cool calculations of things like "clutch," which fangraphs calculates by comparing a player's performance in low leverage situations to his performance in high leverage ones (instead of the standard, and unsatisfying "close and late").
All of this is old hat to baseball fans, and my point isn't to recap what you already know or could find on fangraphs. Rather, I want to put out a call to coders, web developers, and tennis fans to do this for tennis. I've seen a man named Jeff Sackmann produce a "Tennis Win Expectancy Graph" for a particular match, but as far as I know, there is no widely available tool to let tennis fans calculate win probability on their own, much less a live scoreboard like on fangraphs.
If anything, win probability for tennis should be simpler than for baseball. Rather than having to calculate run expectancies, your set of variables are much, much smaller. If you use the tour wide statistic, as Sackmann does, that the server will win 64% of points, you can, theoretically, easily produce a win probability algorithm. Turning that into a graph is obviously not too difficult, given Sackmann's own work.
So let's make it happen! Tennis needs would benefit from win probability graphs as much as baseball. Questions that win probability (and leverage index) could help answer include:
1) Do great players "raise their level" on key points, or are they just always better?
2) How much of a difference in point-by-point leverage is there between a three and five set match?
3) What is the "most important" point in a given match?
There are countless others, so I won't list them all. But even these should whet the appetite of the statistically-minded tennis fan.
Now you're probably thinking: "great, so do it yourself." If only I could. I have spent most of the day watching the U.S. Open and playing around with Excel. But while the mathematics are not beyond me (though they are harrier than you might think), the coding is. Perhaps someone else wants to take the baton? If so, I'd be a happy contributor, cheerleader, partner in the process, to whatever degree I can.
Hey, fangraphs isn't just graphs, it's also writers. If someone starts "tennisgraphs," I'll be happy to write for it.
| Hey look, the Royals lost a game they should have won! |
The premise is simple. Given any game situation, you can calculate - based on the number of expected runs scored for both the remainder of the inning and the remainder of the game - how likely each team is to win. Certain events, like home runs, tend to increase your odds significantly, while others, like strikeouts with the bases loaded and two outs, tend to hurt them. Of course, context becomes extremely important, and the graph will fluctuate more in closer games like the Royals versus Tigers game above.
Now the cool part is not even the graph itself, but the "Leverage Index" beneath it. Basically, the amount of change that is possible/likely in any given situation is mapped beneath the graph. This leads to a clear, quantitative mapping of high and low leverage situations. This in turn, leads to cool calculations of things like "clutch," which fangraphs calculates by comparing a player's performance in low leverage situations to his performance in high leverage ones (instead of the standard, and unsatisfying "close and late").
All of this is old hat to baseball fans, and my point isn't to recap what you already know or could find on fangraphs. Rather, I want to put out a call to coders, web developers, and tennis fans to do this for tennis. I've seen a man named Jeff Sackmann produce a "Tennis Win Expectancy Graph" for a particular match, but as far as I know, there is no widely available tool to let tennis fans calculate win probability on their own, much less a live scoreboard like on fangraphs.
If anything, win probability for tennis should be simpler than for baseball. Rather than having to calculate run expectancies, your set of variables are much, much smaller. If you use the tour wide statistic, as Sackmann does, that the server will win 64% of points, you can, theoretically, easily produce a win probability algorithm. Turning that into a graph is obviously not too difficult, given Sackmann's own work.
So let's make it happen! Tennis needs would benefit from win probability graphs as much as baseball. Questions that win probability (and leverage index) could help answer include:
1) Do great players "raise their level" on key points, or are they just always better?
2) How much of a difference in point-by-point leverage is there between a three and five set match?
3) What is the "most important" point in a given match?
There are countless others, so I won't list them all. But even these should whet the appetite of the statistically-minded tennis fan.
Now you're probably thinking: "great, so do it yourself." If only I could. I have spent most of the day watching the U.S. Open and playing around with Excel. But while the mathematics are not beyond me (though they are harrier than you might think), the coding is. Perhaps someone else wants to take the baton? If so, I'd be a happy contributor, cheerleader, partner in the process, to whatever degree I can.
Hey, fangraphs isn't just graphs, it's also writers. If someone starts "tennisgraphs," I'll be happy to write for it.
Labels:
Jeff Sackmann,
Questions,
sports,
statistics,
tennis,
win probability
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
Winning and Losing with Rafael Nadal
Now that I've returned from Portland,* I've also returned to watching the Australian open. That means that, last night, I watched Rafael Nadal do something he almost never does. I watched Rafa lose.
* Portland is an unusual place. Upon returning to Honolulu, I feel very much like the guy in this TV show trailer.
Rafa's opponent was David Ferrer, a fellow Spaniard ranked number seven in the world. Ferrer plays - or at least played last night - with ferocity and physicality despite his advancing age. At 28, he is reaching the end of his productive tennis-playing years, and indeed much as broadcasters and writers lament the possibility that a Roger Federer or Andy Roddick might not have many more chances to win a Major, it's players like Ferrer - who has never won a Major or Grand Slam event, but finds himself in the top ten late in his career - who remind me of the cruelty of a sport so devastating to the body that players only rarely remain in form past 30.
Last night Ferrer was on top of his game, however, obviously far from imagining the inevitable end of his career within the next few seasons. He was every bit Nadal's match, taking the game to him in a marathon, 20+ minute second game in which he eventually broke Rafa's serve. More importantly, however, Nadal injured his hamstring, likely due to the virus he had been fighting throughout the tournament, leaving him more vulnerable to other injuries.
I'm not writing to extol the virtues of tennis as a one-on-one sport,* nor to recount the stories of Ferrer or Nadal (the latter of which, if you watch any tennis at all, you probably know). Rather, I want to talk briefly about what happened after Nadal hurt himself, about how he lost to Ferrer, but simultaneously demonstrated why he wins so much.
* It does seem to me that only the pitcher-batter matchup in baseball comes close to the one-on-one intensity of tennis. Most of our other popular sports are built around working together as a team, about exploiting weak players by matching them against strong ones. In tennis, there is only you and the other guy, and in the Majors especially, where matches are best 3 sets out of 5, the competition can go on for four or five hours of running, pivoting, and swinging with everything you have. It's grueling physically and psychologically.
With his hamstring bothering him, Nadal took a lengthy injury timeout, and was consistently seeing a trainer between service games for the rest of the three-set sweep by Ferrer. The announcers speculated that Nadal would forfeit, as did the tournament organizers, who contacted the mixed doubles players who were next to go on the court and told them to "be read" as early as the first set. Nadal's body language was bad, to say the least. He was glancing at his box of coaches and supporters almost every point, grimacing and shaking his head. Ferrer, meanwhile, was showing no mercy, attacking hard and swinging with abandon, trying to knock Nadal out of the match.
Ultimately, Nadal was able only to win a couple of games along the way, losing 6-4, 6-3, 6-2, each set tilting further towards Ferrer. What was impressive, then, wasn't how Nadal played, but that he played, that he still tried to hold serve in his games, and that he fought to break an opponent moving and hitting better than he had any hope of doing with his leg hurt. All the while, on change-overs, when the players switch ends of the court, Nadal would sit and stretch and receive treatment, nearly crying at the lost opportunity that defeat last night meant (he had won 3 Grand Slam events in a row, meaning a win in the Aussie Open would have given him a "Rafa Slam," as the media had called it, as he would be defending champion of all for of the biggest tournaments simultaneously).
Because tennis is such a physical game, even a minor injury can be the difference between easy victory and total defeat. One can only imagine that Nadal's injury was not so bad, because he continued to play. But watching him play, it was hard not to imagine that his hamstring was worse than almost anyone else would dare to play on. He could barely move to try to get to Ferrer's smashes down the line, shots that a healthy Rafa would return easily. Perhaps more telling than any physical sign, however, was that he looked defeated.
What separates Rafael Nadal from the rest of the tennis world, then, is that he played anyway. He played because he was on the biggest court at prime time, because his was the most anticipated match of the day. He played out of respect for tennis as a sport, and for Ferrer - his countryman and Davis Cup teammate - as a player. He played because, deep down, I think a part of him believed he could still win, believed that if he just hung in there and put enough shots in play Ferrer would start making mistakes, would start missing on those shots that were just barely clipping the baseline.
In short, Rafael Nadal showed why he has won so much in his career, even though he suffered one of his most difficult losses. It's almost a cliche in sports, but even the best players lose, and often how a player confronts losing tells you a lot more about their ability to win than anything else. In contrast to his first round opponent - who forfeited the match to Nadal midway through the second set thanks to the beating he was receiving, Nadal stood in and took his beating, demonstrating why - in addition to his physical gifts - he has become the best player in the world. He showed the psyche of a great player last night, the mind and determination of a winner.
It would have been so easy for Nadal to give up, to forfeit the match to Ferrer in the second set, by which time it was clear that he was going to lose. But he didn't. He kept fighting, he played as hard as he could with his leg barely working, he hit winners and pumped his fist. I'm fond of saying that one of the most important qualities in a professional baseball player is that, even though they make an out some 60 to 70 percent of the time, they legitimately believe they will get a hit every at bat. The same is true for tennis players; even though, on this night, Nadal knew he would struggle to win points, deep down he undoubtedly believed - without fooling himself - that he would win every point. Or, at the last, that he would make Ferrer earn every point.
* Portland is an unusual place. Upon returning to Honolulu, I feel very much like the guy in this TV show trailer.
Rafa's opponent was David Ferrer, a fellow Spaniard ranked number seven in the world. Ferrer plays - or at least played last night - with ferocity and physicality despite his advancing age. At 28, he is reaching the end of his productive tennis-playing years, and indeed much as broadcasters and writers lament the possibility that a Roger Federer or Andy Roddick might not have many more chances to win a Major, it's players like Ferrer - who has never won a Major or Grand Slam event, but finds himself in the top ten late in his career - who remind me of the cruelty of a sport so devastating to the body that players only rarely remain in form past 30.
Last night Ferrer was on top of his game, however, obviously far from imagining the inevitable end of his career within the next few seasons. He was every bit Nadal's match, taking the game to him in a marathon, 20+ minute second game in which he eventually broke Rafa's serve. More importantly, however, Nadal injured his hamstring, likely due to the virus he had been fighting throughout the tournament, leaving him more vulnerable to other injuries.
I'm not writing to extol the virtues of tennis as a one-on-one sport,* nor to recount the stories of Ferrer or Nadal (the latter of which, if you watch any tennis at all, you probably know). Rather, I want to talk briefly about what happened after Nadal hurt himself, about how he lost to Ferrer, but simultaneously demonstrated why he wins so much.
* It does seem to me that only the pitcher-batter matchup in baseball comes close to the one-on-one intensity of tennis. Most of our other popular sports are built around working together as a team, about exploiting weak players by matching them against strong ones. In tennis, there is only you and the other guy, and in the Majors especially, where matches are best 3 sets out of 5, the competition can go on for four or five hours of running, pivoting, and swinging with everything you have. It's grueling physically and psychologically.
With his hamstring bothering him, Nadal took a lengthy injury timeout, and was consistently seeing a trainer between service games for the rest of the three-set sweep by Ferrer. The announcers speculated that Nadal would forfeit, as did the tournament organizers, who contacted the mixed doubles players who were next to go on the court and told them to "be read" as early as the first set. Nadal's body language was bad, to say the least. He was glancing at his box of coaches and supporters almost every point, grimacing and shaking his head. Ferrer, meanwhile, was showing no mercy, attacking hard and swinging with abandon, trying to knock Nadal out of the match.
Ultimately, Nadal was able only to win a couple of games along the way, losing 6-4, 6-3, 6-2, each set tilting further towards Ferrer. What was impressive, then, wasn't how Nadal played, but that he played, that he still tried to hold serve in his games, and that he fought to break an opponent moving and hitting better than he had any hope of doing with his leg hurt. All the while, on change-overs, when the players switch ends of the court, Nadal would sit and stretch and receive treatment, nearly crying at the lost opportunity that defeat last night meant (he had won 3 Grand Slam events in a row, meaning a win in the Aussie Open would have given him a "Rafa Slam," as the media had called it, as he would be defending champion of all for of the biggest tournaments simultaneously).
Because tennis is such a physical game, even a minor injury can be the difference between easy victory and total defeat. One can only imagine that Nadal's injury was not so bad, because he continued to play. But watching him play, it was hard not to imagine that his hamstring was worse than almost anyone else would dare to play on. He could barely move to try to get to Ferrer's smashes down the line, shots that a healthy Rafa would return easily. Perhaps more telling than any physical sign, however, was that he looked defeated.
What separates Rafael Nadal from the rest of the tennis world, then, is that he played anyway. He played because he was on the biggest court at prime time, because his was the most anticipated match of the day. He played out of respect for tennis as a sport, and for Ferrer - his countryman and Davis Cup teammate - as a player. He played because, deep down, I think a part of him believed he could still win, believed that if he just hung in there and put enough shots in play Ferrer would start making mistakes, would start missing on those shots that were just barely clipping the baseline.
In short, Rafael Nadal showed why he has won so much in his career, even though he suffered one of his most difficult losses. It's almost a cliche in sports, but even the best players lose, and often how a player confronts losing tells you a lot more about their ability to win than anything else. In contrast to his first round opponent - who forfeited the match to Nadal midway through the second set thanks to the beating he was receiving, Nadal stood in and took his beating, demonstrating why - in addition to his physical gifts - he has become the best player in the world. He showed the psyche of a great player last night, the mind and determination of a winner.
It would have been so easy for Nadal to give up, to forfeit the match to Ferrer in the second set, by which time it was clear that he was going to lose. But he didn't. He kept fighting, he played as hard as he could with his leg barely working, he hit winners and pumped his fist. I'm fond of saying that one of the most important qualities in a professional baseball player is that, even though they make an out some 60 to 70 percent of the time, they legitimately believe they will get a hit every at bat. The same is true for tennis players; even though, on this night, Nadal knew he would struggle to win points, deep down he undoubtedly believed - without fooling himself - that he would win every point. Or, at the last, that he would make Ferrer earn every point.
Labels:
Australian Open,
david ferrer,
rafael nadal,
sports,
tennis
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Ping Pong
I suppose that most people watching, say, an NFL football game are well aware of how impossible it would be for them to step on the field and even pretend to play with the pros. Not only are the small NFL players bigger than the vast majority of us, it's pretty clear from watching them play that they're incredibly skilled and focused, not to mention propped up by countless mystery medicines and steroids and assorted body armor that they barely even count as people any more. And for good reason; the sport they play is far too brutal for any sane human being to participate in.
Nevertheless, because it's so ingrained in our culture, there's a kind of natural intuition as to whether a football player is doing it right, with the result that fans and pundits alike are quick to point out who sucks, who's good, who messed up, and who is so bad that he earns the adjective 'mediocre.'* The same is true in baseball, and generally speaking, while no rational fan honestly believes he or she could do just as well as the pro, there's kind of this latent, subconscious feeling that, yes, in fact, player X is so bad and messed up so much that I probably could do better.
* Is it just me, or had mediocre come to mean something even worse than awful, terrible, or bad? I mean, every team in every sport has lots of 'terrible' players, but only a particular kind of talent earns the moniker mediocre. While certainly a player everyone calls mediocre is probably better than the guy they say sucks, odds are the mediocre guy also plays an important role on the team. No one ever calls the back-up safety mediocre, for example. Mediocre is reserved for the QB, for the clean-up hitter, for the ace of the pitching staff, for the coach. I guess, all in all, mediocre is more damning because, while its fine to have a bad assistant special teams coach, a mediocre head coach in a world of good and great head coaches spells doom. Or at least mediocrity.
A classic example of the "I could do better" notion that immediately jumps to mind is the USA's goal against England keeper Robert Green in the World Cup. In case you don't remember, here it is (along with other highlights from the same game) in glorious LEGO:
Anyway, the point is, this is the kind of event that most sports fans look at and say, "Well I could do better than that." Fair or not, we have enough acquaintance with the game to believe that we could execute the basic fundamentals with as much precision as a pro.
Not so - and we're getting to the post title - in ping pong. Now I know the serious ping pongers out there will tell you it's supposed to be called "table tennis," and we'll get back to that. For now, the important thing is that, even though ping pong is a game almost everyone has played, and an extremely simple one with much more straightforward rules than, say, football or baseball, I think it's pretty much impossible to watch a professional ping pong match and feel like you could do better. Even a good amateur ping pong player generally approaches the game in a way that is so different from the way the pros do it that it's hard to imagine matching up.
Of course, that is true in other sports, too, but the odd thing is that in ping pong the illusion of being able to perform at a high level would take, it seems to me, a much higher level of self-deception. I don't even hold the paddle all backwards and upside down, and can't imagine that I would play better if I did. And yet, that's how the real ping pongers do it. I can't imagine serving with any degree of accuracy the way a real ping pong player serves. I certainly can't imagine hitting the ball from so far away from the table.
I think the key here, however, is that even someone like me who has been playing a fair (ok, perhaps alarming) amount of ping pong for the last two months now, can't even really follow what's going on in a serious ping pong match. The points are so fast, the strategy so blurred, the reactions so automatic, that it doesn't exactly make compelling viewing. Consider this video of the "Top 10 ping pong shots of all time:"
I can't even tell what's going on in half of these! Who's winning these shots? What makes them so good? I don't understand!
This is a chicken and egg thing, of course. We don't understand ping pong intuitively because we don't watch it, and vice versa. What's more, we find ping pong impossible to watch because it's too fast, but if we watched it enough maybe it would start to make sense. Then again, it might just stay weird and impossible to follow (what with the tiny ball and speed of the game), which might be part of why it has never been all that popular to begin with. That is, popular to watch. It's extremely popular to play by comparison. I think ping pong, darts, and pool are probably the three most prominent game-sports* that more people play than watch.
*As opposed to sports like running or skiing or swimming or surfing, which aren't really games.
Which all brings me to the name "ping pong." My extremely cursory research tells me that ping pong - the term - originated with Parker Brothers around 1900, around the same time as the name "table tennis." Apparently no one wanted to stick with the game's original name "Wiff-Waff," and I can't imagine why not. Regardless, the name ping pong seems to me much more appropriate, because table tennis makes the whole thing sound like tennis on a table.
Which, you're probably thinking, is exactly what it is. Except it's not. Sure, there's a passing resemblance to tennis, but ping pong is as much like tennis as volley ball is, I would argue. The differences are far more pronounced than the presence of a table. For example, the ball is plastic instead of felt and rubber, the paddles hard instead of strung, and the game is played from outside of the playing area (instead of inside). Serves have to bounce on the servers side of the table, but don't have to go cross court. Players have to pivot a lot, but rarely do they ever have to run. Most of all, the strategy is completely different. Oh, there are analogies, just as there are between other net-and-ball games and tennis, but trying to play like Rafael Nadal won't make you a better ping pong player.
Which is why ping pong needs a different name than tennis, and table tennis is so much less inventive. Ping pong is colorful, absurd, and impossible to take seriously. Which is how it should be. After all, this is no sport of gridiron tactics and bone-crushing hits, nor is it a sport of last at-bat high drama. It's just ping pong.
Nevertheless, because it's so ingrained in our culture, there's a kind of natural intuition as to whether a football player is doing it right, with the result that fans and pundits alike are quick to point out who sucks, who's good, who messed up, and who is so bad that he earns the adjective 'mediocre.'* The same is true in baseball, and generally speaking, while no rational fan honestly believes he or she could do just as well as the pro, there's kind of this latent, subconscious feeling that, yes, in fact, player X is so bad and messed up so much that I probably could do better.
* Is it just me, or had mediocre come to mean something even worse than awful, terrible, or bad? I mean, every team in every sport has lots of 'terrible' players, but only a particular kind of talent earns the moniker mediocre. While certainly a player everyone calls mediocre is probably better than the guy they say sucks, odds are the mediocre guy also plays an important role on the team. No one ever calls the back-up safety mediocre, for example. Mediocre is reserved for the QB, for the clean-up hitter, for the ace of the pitching staff, for the coach. I guess, all in all, mediocre is more damning because, while its fine to have a bad assistant special teams coach, a mediocre head coach in a world of good and great head coaches spells doom. Or at least mediocrity.
A classic example of the "I could do better" notion that immediately jumps to mind is the USA's goal against England keeper Robert Green in the World Cup. In case you don't remember, here it is (along with other highlights from the same game) in glorious LEGO:
Anyway, the point is, this is the kind of event that most sports fans look at and say, "Well I could do better than that." Fair or not, we have enough acquaintance with the game to believe that we could execute the basic fundamentals with as much precision as a pro.
Not so - and we're getting to the post title - in ping pong. Now I know the serious ping pongers out there will tell you it's supposed to be called "table tennis," and we'll get back to that. For now, the important thing is that, even though ping pong is a game almost everyone has played, and an extremely simple one with much more straightforward rules than, say, football or baseball, I think it's pretty much impossible to watch a professional ping pong match and feel like you could do better. Even a good amateur ping pong player generally approaches the game in a way that is so different from the way the pros do it that it's hard to imagine matching up.
Of course, that is true in other sports, too, but the odd thing is that in ping pong the illusion of being able to perform at a high level would take, it seems to me, a much higher level of self-deception. I don't even hold the paddle all backwards and upside down, and can't imagine that I would play better if I did. And yet, that's how the real ping pongers do it. I can't imagine serving with any degree of accuracy the way a real ping pong player serves. I certainly can't imagine hitting the ball from so far away from the table.
I think the key here, however, is that even someone like me who has been playing a fair (ok, perhaps alarming) amount of ping pong for the last two months now, can't even really follow what's going on in a serious ping pong match. The points are so fast, the strategy so blurred, the reactions so automatic, that it doesn't exactly make compelling viewing. Consider this video of the "Top 10 ping pong shots of all time:"
I can't even tell what's going on in half of these! Who's winning these shots? What makes them so good? I don't understand!
This is a chicken and egg thing, of course. We don't understand ping pong intuitively because we don't watch it, and vice versa. What's more, we find ping pong impossible to watch because it's too fast, but if we watched it enough maybe it would start to make sense. Then again, it might just stay weird and impossible to follow (what with the tiny ball and speed of the game), which might be part of why it has never been all that popular to begin with. That is, popular to watch. It's extremely popular to play by comparison. I think ping pong, darts, and pool are probably the three most prominent game-sports* that more people play than watch.
*As opposed to sports like running or skiing or swimming or surfing, which aren't really games.
Which all brings me to the name "ping pong." My extremely cursory research tells me that ping pong - the term - originated with Parker Brothers around 1900, around the same time as the name "table tennis." Apparently no one wanted to stick with the game's original name "Wiff-Waff," and I can't imagine why not. Regardless, the name ping pong seems to me much more appropriate, because table tennis makes the whole thing sound like tennis on a table.
Which, you're probably thinking, is exactly what it is. Except it's not. Sure, there's a passing resemblance to tennis, but ping pong is as much like tennis as volley ball is, I would argue. The differences are far more pronounced than the presence of a table. For example, the ball is plastic instead of felt and rubber, the paddles hard instead of strung, and the game is played from outside of the playing area (instead of inside). Serves have to bounce on the servers side of the table, but don't have to go cross court. Players have to pivot a lot, but rarely do they ever have to run. Most of all, the strategy is completely different. Oh, there are analogies, just as there are between other net-and-ball games and tennis, but trying to play like Rafael Nadal won't make you a better ping pong player.
Which is why ping pong needs a different name than tennis, and table tennis is so much less inventive. Ping pong is colorful, absurd, and impossible to take seriously. Which is how it should be. After all, this is no sport of gridiron tactics and bone-crushing hits, nor is it a sport of last at-bat high drama. It's just ping pong.
Labels:
Football,
Games,
mediocrity,
ping pong,
sports,
table tennis,
tennis,
wiff waff
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)