Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Goin' To California

Just a quick note to the effect that I'll be traveling in California for most of the rest of the month, meaning there's no guarantee on frequency of blog posts for that time.  Chances are about 50/50 that I'll actually write more during my trip, but no promises.

The purpose of the journey is threefold.  First off, I'll be presenting along with my Mom at the NSTA national conference in San Francisco.  We'll be talking about using Moodle as a tool to support learning - and especially metacognition - in the sciences.  The presentation is at the Marriot San Francisco Marquis, Sierra C room at 3:30, for those of you in the area who are either attending NSTA already or who might want to sneak in to say "hi."

Secondly, I'll be staying in San Francisco to visit friends and to spend my one year anniversary with my wife Jericha during her spring break.  We're looking forward to actually visiting all those places in the city that we neglected during my year at Stanford (neglected mainly due to the distance between Palo Alto and the city, and the workload of getting a Master's degree).

Thirdly, I'll be visiting both Stanford and then traveling to San Diego to visit UCSD (and more friends, of course).  If you recall my list of PhD applications from the fall, you'll recognize that these as two of the five* schools to which I applied.  I have heard affirmatives from both (with funding still pending from Stanford), and will be engaging in the difficult process of choosing which program to attend for the next four plus years.

*As for the other three, I've heard a no from Chicago, and have not heard from UCSC and UH.  UCSC I don't have particularly high expectations at this point, as it's late to receive a positive response from a UC school at this point, as is evidenced by UCSD's offer.  As for UH, they run on a slightly later schedule, and I likely won't hear from them until the summer.

So if I neglect to post anything for awhile, that's why.  But the Beethoven project will continue - especially now that I'm finally getting around to reading Lewis Lockwood's fantastic biography of the composer - and of course dispatches from the Golden State are likely to be forthcoming as well.  I would also recommend popping over to Pitchers and Poets, both because they recently went through an awesome redesign and because a post from yours truly is on the way.  Ok, it's not written yet, but that's what the plane ride is for.

Friday, March 4, 2011

Don't Feed the Troll

I'm sorry to do this, but I just can't hold it back.  American political discourse is such a sham, people on both sides of the alleged two-sided debate believe such nonsense that sometimes I can't help but laugh at the whole thing.  You know there's some kind of problem when the debates of the day concern who's crazier, Keith Olberman or Bill O'Reilly.  Newsflash, America.  They're both out of their minds.  Neither of them (or any of their compatriots, the Rush Limbaughs, the Chris Matthewses, the Sean Hannitys) has any interest in real discourse, in trying to do anything positive for the country or the world.  They just yell, call each other names, and pass it off as politics.  Because, hey, that's what the people will watch on the TV.

Come to think of it, maybe that's all politics is meant to be, but we can dream of a better approach, can't we?  Perhaps it's too simplistic to put it this way, but wouldn't we be better of if real people made up the meat of political discourse, and not media-magnates, corrupt politicians, or for-profit corporations?  Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that what the word "Democracy" means (from the Greek, 'Demos' meaning people, and 'Kratos' meaning rule)?

Anyway, the point here isn't to gripe about our mis-defined terms (we could spend a whole post talking about how words like "liberal," "communist," "socialist," "democracy," "conservative," and "constitution" have acquired meanings very different from their actual definitions).  No, the point is to go against my own advice.  I'm going to feed the troll.

The troll, in this case, is a man who wrote a letter that I received from one of my right-wing relatives via email.  He's one of those people who forwards five emails a day that all say "I rarely forward emails" at the top, and which contain font in at least three different sizes and at least four different colors in the body of the message.  So yeah, that's a sure sign not to take anything too seriously.  Except...  Except the people who believe these kinds of emails win elections.  Which isn't really a big deal, since at least you're putting principled crazy people (instead of the much more dangerous unprincipled sane ones) in office, but still.

This particular email is a gem, so much so that I laughed long and hard when I read it.  Now, you have to recall, I am not a Democrat, and I am not a Republican.  I'm an equal-opportunity critic of both parties, and, in fact, I'm probably all the more critical of the left than the right.  True, I am more "left wing" than "right wing," in that I believe in social freedoms like the right for gays to marry and the right to have an abortion, but economically and politically I am aligned with neither party, and don't believe that I fit along the 2-dimensional spectrum that most of us have been fooled into thinking encompasses all of political thought.

This particular email, though, comes from the right of American politics and is a harsh "criticism," if you can call it that, of Nancy Pelosi.  Now, Pelosi is about as corrupt as they come, but this fine piece takes her on in the most insane, unreasonable, and terrifyingly inaccurate ways possible.  In theory, it's by a man who is a former Assistant District Attorney named Dennis Guthrie, which makes it all the more classic for reasons which will become clear.  Without further ado, here's the email (in bold) with comments inserted.

Dear Ms. Pelosi:

I write to you out of utter disdain! You are as despicable and un-American as the traitor Jane Fonda.

Jane Fonda!  She's so despicable and un-American that she married Ted Turner!  Of course, Dennis is referring to her protest of the Vietnam and Iraq Wars and her self-described feminist ideals.  But Jane Fonda isn't really the point, here.  The point is that this is an absolutely ludicrous way to start a letter.  "Dear Ms. Person, I hate you!  You're just like this other person that I hate!"  Sounds a little like a little kid, no?

I am a soon to be 65 year-old who has voted in every state and local election since 1966. I have voted for both Republicans and Democrats alike. I have worked on campaigns for both Republicans and Democrats, white and black. I served the country that I love in Vietnam, as my son did in the Middle East . I was awarded two bronze stars. I have been involved in politics since age 6 when my father was campaign manager for a truly great American Congressman, Charles Raper Jonas, who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike you.


Attempting to rebuild credibility here, because, you know, the whole Jane Fonda thing was a bit of a gamble that didn't really pay off.  So we find out that Dennis is not partisan, not in the slightest.  We also find out that he's not a racist - he's very careful to point out that he has worked on campaigns for both white and black people.

The real key to this credibility argument, of course, is that 6 year-old Dennis (soon to be seven?) was "involved" in politics because his father managed the campaign of Charles Raper Jonas (can we talk to his parents about that middle name?), who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike [Nancy Pelosi].  Let's talk about how tortured this sentence is.  Wait, let's not.  Just read it again.  Non sequiturs abound!  The purpose of the sentence changes no less than twice, beginning with "I've been around politics for a long time," transitioning to "Charles Raper Jonas was a good congressman," and finishing with "You're a scumbag!" Bravo, good sir.

You obviously haven't read the Constitution recently, if ever, the Federalist Papers, or even David McCullough's book on John Adams.

Oh my.  Cue music...  One of these things is not like the other.  Let's see, key documents for a member of congress to read... 1) Constitution, check.  2) Federalist Papers, check. 3) David McCullough's book on John Adams, check?  Now don't get me wrong, I'm guessing that McCullough's book is very good.  He's a two-time Pulitzer winner, and John Adams is one of those winners.  But that still doesn't put it in the same camp as the Constitution and the Federalist Papers, which are, you know, political treatises about the founding of the country, and not historical biographies.

Also, isn't the order wrong here?  It's weird enough that he throws in the McCullough book, but it's the "even" that gets me.  It's like saying "he hasn't read any Shakespeare, even Titus Andronicus," as if that's the one Shakespeare play everyone should read.  I mean, I can imagine Pelosi not reading the Constitution, but David McCullough's John Adams, really now.

You ought to take the time while riding around in your government provided luxury executive jet to do just that. You represent Socialistic and even Marxist principals that our founding fathers tried to avoid when setting out the capitalistic republican form of government represented by our Constitution.

Boom.  This is the best part of the whole thing, right here.  For a man who is, in theory, a former Assistant AD who has read John Adams (by David McCullough) and even the Constitution (see what I did there?), this is a remarkable display of historical ignorance.  Let's not even get into how non-socialist Nancy Pelosi is, and instead let's talk about Karl Marx.

Marx was not a socialist, because socialism and communism are very different, but that's not what's amazing here.  No, simple chronology is the bugbear in this paragraph.  Marx was born in, wait for it, 1818, and he published the Communist Manifesto in 1848.  The Constitution was written, as I'm sure you know, in 1787, a full 31 years before Marx was even born.  The Marxist principles the founding fathers supposedly avoided while setting up our government did not even exist - at least not in name - when the Constitution was written.  Dennis, I suppose, might argue that Marxism existed in spirit, but anyone with even a passing knowledge of history knows that the late 18th century were hardly a time of powerful labor unions.  Hell, when the Constitution was penned the French Revolution hadn't even happened yet.  Indeed, the closest thing (and they weren't particularly close) in the entire world to communism in 1787 was - you guessed it - the American colonies.  Well done, Mr. Guthrie.

We're not done with this yet, either, because Dennis lets us know that, in addition to predicting the invention of communism in half-a-century, the founding fathers also predicted the invention of capitalism.  Now, you no doubt know that Adam Smith published the Wealth of Nations in 1776, but you may not realize that he doesn't call anything "capitalism," therein.  What's more, that which is capitalistic in Wealth of Nations is critiqued heavily, as Smith laments the way that trade corporations conspire to harm their customers.  Like Machiavelli's Prince, Wealth of Nations is historically misunderstood as advocating for a certain system, whereas the works themselves are more descriptive than proscriptive.

In this particular case, Wealth of Nations has little to no bearing on the Constitution (indeed, it's unlikely that many of the founding fathers had even read the book by the time the Constitution was ratified), and the word "capitalism" or the concepts associated therewith even less.  Capitalism, as a term, didn't really come around until after Marx's own descriptive work, Capital, popularized the concept.  The founding fathers, needless to say, weren't particularly concerned with the economic system of the United States, because there weren't really competing theories at the time, and because the Constitution was meant to be a political and governmental user's manual.

The moral of the story?  Before you spout off nonsense about the founding fathers and their motivations, try reading the Federalist Papers and the Constitution first (bazing!).  You'll find the words "capitalist," "Marxist," and "socialist" absent.

I find it interesting that you and your husband are multi-millionaires with much of your fortune being made as a result of your "public service". You have controlled legislation that has enhanced your husband's investments both on and off shore. At the same time you redistributed the wealth of others. Our system of a free market economy is being destroyed by the likes of you, Harry Reid, and now our President. You ride around in a Gulfstream airplane at the tax payer's expense while criticizing the presidents of companies who produced something for the economy. You add nothing to the economy of the United States , you only subtract therefrom.

Ok, the Gulfstream thing is one of those wonderfully false Internet rumors that floats around.  You know, like Barrack Obama being a Muslim born on Neptune who's secretly collaborating with the Cylons in preparation for their invasion.  As for the rest of it, well, I don't really know anything about Pelosi's husband, but I do know that, by the nature of the congress, Pelosi "controlled" nothing.  It's the classic "Great Man" or, in this case, "Great Woman" theory of politics rearing its ugly head again.  The idea that any one person is responsible for legislation of any kind is absurd, given the several hundred members of congress and the several thousand staffers, lobyists, corporate donors, special interest groups, and so on that make the country go.  To say that Pelosi "redistributed the wealth of others" is more than a bit of an exaggeration.

As for our free market economy being destroyed, well, I'd argue that Nancy Pelosi is only a small part of that picture as well.  Even if we agree that a pure free market works, I would argue that what we have now is a kind of reverse-socialism.  That is, common people are taxed so that our money can be given to huge corporations (which pay no tax at all) in the form of bailouts and subsidies.  Is Pelosi a part of that?  Yes, but only because all elected politicians - in order to be elected - almost have to be corrupt.  With the Supreme Court ruling last year that Corporations can give unlimited, anonymous funds to political campaigns, it is nearly impossible to find a congressperson or senator who has not been bought and sold already.

Blaming Pelosi (or any single congressperson) for that is a bit much.  Really, the blame rests with no one person, but the willful ignorance of the American people - who refuse to see that their country is not, in fact, run by their elected representatives - is a major part of the problem.  It's no wonder that we've begun to cycle wildly - the people elect Democrats, find them unresponsive, and then elect Republicans, only to find them equally unresponsive, and so on.

Anyway, bring us home, Dennis baby, with some personal attacks.

I would like to suggest that you return to the city of fruitcakes and nuts and eat your husband's canned tuna and pineapple produced by illegal immigrants and by workers who have been excluded from the protection that 90% of the legal workers in the United States have.
 
Another meandering sentence-with-many-meanings.  To wit:
1) San Francisco has gay people in it, and is thus morally reprehensible (unlike my state of North Carolina, where everyone is straight, white, male, and Christian; at least everyone worth mentioning).
2) Eat some canned tuna and pineapple, bitch!  Seriously, is this some kind of innuendo I don't know about?  "I'm taking my talents to South Beach, where I'll be eating my husband's canned tuna (wink wink)."
3) Damn Mexicans, how dare they try to make a better life for themselves!
4) Honestly, I'm not sure what Dennis is getting at here.  Is he saying that illegal immigrants deserve protection?  Or is he saying that illegal immigrants are robbing other Americans of legal protections?  Or what?  Whatever his point, he's sure worked up about it.

I await your defeat in the next election with glee.

I suppose this means, while he waits for Pelosi to lose in the next election he'll be watching a lot of Glee, starring Lea Michele, Jane Lynch, and Matthew Morrison.  I haven't seen the show, but I hear it's very popular.
 

Don't ever use the term "un-American" again for protesters who love this country and are exercising their rights upon which this country was founded. By the way, while I served in the Army, I was spit on by the same type of lunatics who support you and who you probably supported in the 60's and 70's. You are an embarrassment to all of us who served so that you would have the protected right of free speech to call us un-American. But at the same time, I have the right to write you, to notify you, that I consider you to be un-American, as do the majority of the people of this formerly great country. You are a true disgrace to most of the people who served this country by offering themselves for public service in the United States Congress.

Just when you thought we were done, Dennis pulls out the classic "and another thing" on us.  The best part here is that he criticizes Pelosi for calling town-hall protesters "un-American," and then proceeds to criticize anti-war protesters for the exact same thing.  Does the irony know no bounds?  I mean, let me make Dennis's argument in this paragraph clear:

1) You can't criticize people for protesting because that's the 1st amendment.  They have a right to do it.
2) How dare those protesters in the 60s and 70s rally against the Vietnam War!  That's un-American.  They shouldn't have a right to do that!
3) I, however, have a right to free speech, which is why I'm writing you this letter.  I'm a little confused about what I'm saying, but that's ok, because I can always wrap it up with:
4) You're a scumbag!

Also, let's talk about this "formerly great country" bit.  What does that mean?  Are we talking about the 80s?  I'm guessing not, because there was even more hand-wringing then than there is now.  No, I'm guessing Dennis means the 1950s, back when black people and white people couldn't eat in the same restaurants, back when women weren't allowed to have jobs in science, technology, or mathematics, back when gay men and women were liable to be beat up or killed if people found out about them, back when people lived in constant fear of nuclear war with the USSR...  Don't get me wrong, I don't mean to say the past was awful - rather, it was like any other time, filled with good and bad, filled with justice and injustice, filled with love and hatred.  Humanity is complicated, history is complicated, and the sooner we acknowledge that the sooner we can start having real conversations instead of just yelling at each other.

I feel certain your aides will not share this letter with you, but I intend to share it with many.

Cue passive-aggressive one-liner... And we're done.

Sincerely,
Dennis L. Guthrie 

In the end, you have to love the "Sincerely," don't you?

OK, I know what you're thinking:  "But Paul, isn't what you're doing here exactly what Dennis is guilty of?"  Yes, and no.  The purpose of doing this is, in part, the fun of it (I read too much Fire Joe Morgan back before it went silent).  But more importantly, the purpose is to show that there's a wrong way to have political discourse, and that this wrong way is all-too-prominent.  Dennis Guthrie, believe it or not, means well.  It's just, he doesn't know how to have a conversation, how to engage in a dialogue.  He's become a part of a political discourse that's all rage and anger and hatred - from Democrats and Republicans alike - and that will not get anyone anywhere.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Listening to Beethoven's 3rd Symphony, Part One: A Revolutionary Opening

Does music have meaning outside of its context?  That is, when a piece is so revolutionary, so very different from everything that came before it, can we hear that difference, or do we have to be trained to hear it?  Even with training, even with a knowledge of what came before, doesn't the "new" piece still sound to us like it is decidedly old, that is doesn't even begin to capture the things that came later in the composer's career, much less the things that came after the composer's death?

Those are some of the questions I struggle with when trying to explain Beethoven's Eroica Symphony.  It's unlike anything written before it.  The first movement alone takes about 15 minutes, making it as long as some Haydn and Mozart symphonies in their entirety.  The second movement is another 15 minutes.  The thing as a whole takes over a quarter hour, so long that Beethoven advised it not be performed late in a concert program lest the audience become restless.

Length, however, is not always indicative of a revolution.  War and Peace is a long book, but it doesn't feel like a particularly revolutionary book as you read it.  Don't get me wrong, it deserves its reputation as a great work, and it is extremely ambitious in its storytelling, but it did not fundamentally alter the way that books were written, as far as I know.  The Eroica, on the other hand, well, it did fundamentally alter the writing of music.  Or, if it did not alone, it was the capstone of a set of works that did.

Can you hear what makes it so outrageous, so different, so offensive, so intense, so awesome?  Here's a rendition from the Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra, conducted, at the time, by the incomparable Gustavo Dudamel.



There's a lot in this piece, too much to talk about all at once, so let's start with the beginning.  The big, fat, E-flat Major chords that open the piece are perhaps a tad jarring, but it's not unusual for a composer to signal what key he's in to start off a piece.  No, what's really odd is what comes after those two chords.  Take a listen to the first few seconds of the piece again.



The melody that Beethoven introduces here doesn't sound particularly odd to our modern ears, but it would have been jarring in its time.  What's more, it was uncharacteristic even for Beethoven.  Why?  Because it has a flatted seventh (Db or C#) in it.

After the two chords, what you hear is an outline of the Eb Major triad: Eb - G - Eb - Bb - Eb - G - Bb.  That is followed by a chromatic descent to the 7: Eb - D - C#.  This is jarring because that C# is not a part of the Eb Major scale.  It destabilizes the key, making Eb feel like a dominant, and not a tonic.*  As a result, we're pulled away from the tonic, and you can hear it quite clearly in the clip; it sounds incomplete, it sounds like it's going somewhere, and it's not entirely clear where.

* Quick theory 101 lesson: tonic is, generally, the key the piece is in.  It feels restful and complete.  Think of a simple piece like Mary Had a Little Lamb, or Twinkle Twinkle Little Star.  The tonic happens at the very beginning and ending of those pieces.  The dominant, meanwhile, is usually the chord on the 5th of the tonic.  It feels unstable and pulls you back towards the tonic.  Try singing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and stopping on the "how I wonder what you" without singing the "are."  That "what you" is the dominant.

Analyzing the experience of hearing this opening harmonically is only a beginning, however.  More important is the meaning: what is Beethoven trying to accomplish with this C#?  This symphony is called - by Beethoven himself - Eroica, "Heroic."  Famously, it was originally written for Napoleon Bonaparte, but rededicated after the French Consul declared himself Emperor to Beethoven's chagrin.  Is this a Napoleonic symphony, then, a story of the French Revolution?  Or is it, perhaps, meant to stand for an ideal instead?  Was it ever, really, about Napoleon at all?

Those are questions we can't answer yet, and some of those questions may not be easy to answer from the music alone.  Instead, we need to dive into the narrower questions posed by the infamous C#.  What kind of heroism is this piece going to be about?  Martial heroism?  Political heroism?  Populist heroism?  Artistic heroism?  And what does it mean to have the tonic - the core of the piece - destabilized so early?  Perhaps the heroic is a result of instability.  We, as listeners, are invited to understand musically the context in which heroism takes place.

On the other hand, some listeners want to make the opening theme stand for the hero, and not heroism or the hero's situation.  In that account, the C# is perhaps some kind of Greek tragic flaw, hubris, or a failure of self-awareness.  If the piece is about Napoleon, there could be a kind of accidental truth to this interpretation: while it was written before Napoleon's ambition became clear, the piece might nevertheless anticipate his arrogance.

For my part, I do not think there is meant to be a single correct interpretation.  Music is not, after all, denotative.  There is, however, intent.  Beethoven intends, regardless of specific imagery we apply to his C#, to make us uncomfortable, to make us wonder what is going on.  This effect is compounded by the meter of the piece.  The opening movement, here, is in 3/4, despite its "military march" feel.  Indeed, the opening two chords are wholly ambiguous - they could just as easily be in 4/4 - and it is only with the introduction of the very theme that destabilizes harmonically that we realize our rhythmic expectations have been violated as well.

Regardless of specific interpretation, it is worth recognizing that the movement as a whole is very warlike.  Particular motifs and themes suggesting a battlefield are frequent.  For example, there's this "galloping horses" motif:



And a passage many liken to cannon fire:



This latter passage is particularly notable thanks to the extended "4/4" at the end of it.  After a series of "1-2-rest, 1-2-rest" chords we hear a bunch of big fat "bam rest bam rest bam rest" chords that betray the time signature.*  This is a particularly warlike device, because it shakes the rhythmic foundations of the piece.

*This moment of undermining the time signature is worth keeping in mind as we progress, because it is a tool Beethoven will use in every movement of the symphony.

These motifs we'll come across as we progress through the first movement, but for now they can lend a hand to our understanding of the opening.  In short, there is a revolution afoot.  What kind of revolution?  It's hard to say.  Certainly a musical one - for nothing quite like this symphony has ever been written before - but perhaps a political one and a spiritual one as well.  What that looks like, how music can convey that or - perhaps more to the point - help to create that is the question that we'll be confronting throughout this series of posts.  For now, it's sufficient to recognize that the opening of the Eroica sets us up to go on a long journey.  The destabilization of the tonic here is not something easily resolved, and it may take quite some time to put everything back together again.  Indeed, as we wrap up the first movement (in the distant future) we'll have cause to ask whether or not the questions raised by our C# have really been resolved: can you return to the tonic - to the way things were - after such a piece of music?  Is the hero of this piece redeemable?  Is heroism itself?  Is there such a thing as a great man in an egalitarian society?

Beethoven, in his idealism, believed that Napoleon would bring about a Europe filled with equality and freedom and opportunity.  But there's more than just boundless optimism in the Eroica, because Beethoven recognized the innate contradiction in Napoleon's project: forcing equality on the world.  He believed the General could do it, but his symphony - from its very outset - is very much aware of the challenge.  That Napoleon himself did not live up to Beethoven's expectations - or, more properly, his dream - does not change the very nature of the project.  If anything, it only reinforces how extremely difficult it is to accomplish what the Eroica suggests: transforming a society for the better.

But we're getting ahead of ourselves.  For now, we've set off on the heroic journey of the 3rd Symphony.  It's not always pretty, and it's not always easy, but it is exciting and stirring and intense.  The fear and indignation with which many of Beethoven's listeners - those disciples of Haydn and Mozart who believed music should be just so - was countered by the excitement and expectation of those listeners who could tell that this was a new, and altogether more powerful kind of music.

If powerful, then also dangerous, perhaps?  That's another question we'll have to pursue as we go along.  Before we get there, however, let's first learn how to hear the optimism, the idealism, the joy, along with the frustration and the violence in the Eroica.  Without hearing those things, first, the question of danger and power is meaningless.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

A Music Project

I cannot tell you how many times I've started to work on my Beethoven-Wagner post and stopped, unsure as to how exactly to proceed.  You see, the problem is, every time I try to put the thoughts together, I end up falling back to all of the work I did for my undergraduate thesis, tracing the spiritual and political motions of Beethoven's 3rd and 9th Symphonies.  More importantly, I reflect on how many holes I left in that project.  Even though the result was a nearly 40 page paper (cut down from a maximum of over 50 thanks to the wisdom of my advisor), it was a synopsis of what I really wanted to accomplish.

In reality, what I wanted to write was a book and not an essay.  Not a normal book about music, either.  Like the St. John's music curriculum that I went through three years in a row as an assistant, I wanted to think about and write about and talk about music at the intersection of rigorous music theory, simple music appreciation, real music history, and, perhaps above all, music philosophy.  I suppose you could call all of that, in short, "musicology," but that only obscures the particulars.

The problem is, my Beethoven-Wagner post - which, really, could be a one paragraph long "isn't this cool?" - hinges upon at least some semblance of musical knowledge from all of the above fields.  On some level my perception of the link between Tristan und Isolde and the 9th Symphony is merely "feeling," but there's so much history, music theory, and, perhaps above all, a philosophy of how to understand the meaning of music tied up in my understanding of the two works.  That makes it impossible, as T.S. Eliot says in Prufrock, to say exactly what I mean.

Does all that sound pretentious?  Perhaps, but this is one area where I don't care about sounding pretentious.  I respect that musical tastes differ, of course, but I also think that the ad-hoc dismissal of the project of understanding music - and especially classical music - smacks of willful ignorance.  Too often I have heard - from people who love baroque music to people who love hip hop - that to study music is to rob it of its life, its passion, and its power.  To me, that is an excuse.*  It is a shameful agreement to disagree.  For example, the tired "classical music is boring but I'm ok if you like it" argument strikes me as being lazy, principally because even a cursory study of classical music will demonstrate that it is certainly not boring.  Perhaps classical music concerts are boring, and the stuffy culture surrounding the music is often boring, and writing about classical music is frequently boring, but the music itself is intricate and complex, full of (objectively) more harmonic, rhythmic, formal, and melodic variation than the vast majority of modern music.  That means it might be more difficult, more complex, and thus less immediately accessible - all legitimate complaints - but hardly more boring.

*Furthermore, it misses the point.  One's appreciation of music increases with its study, just as in every other field.  It is difficult to find a cosmologist who is not even more awestruck by the universe than an amateur stargazer.  There are few sabermetricians who are less avid baseball fans than the RBI-junkie.  Few musicians, composers, and even music critics are not violently passionate about music, despite, and indeed because of, their knowledge.**

**OK, total tangent on this one.  Have you ever noticed that "despite" can usually be substituted for "because of," even though the two are, in principal, opposites?  It is an interesting quality of the narratives we build about success and failure that the two are so often interchangeable.  For example, "despite his speech impediment, the child grew up to be a successful politician."  Perhaps true, but "because of" fits well, too, because it is often the case, in such stories, that overcoming the speech impediment is what gave the child the confidence and drive to become a politician in the first place.  At the very least, the "victory despite impossible odds" story gets told because of the impossible odds.  Which is perhaps more to the point; that "despite" is the reason the story exists in the first place, and thus, while it may not be that success owes to the thing being overcome, that success is noteworthy at all is.

Phew, where were we?

All of which brings me to the project: learning to listen to and talk about classical music.  Now, I have already begun that process - a process which inspired my thesis, and which was a significant factor in my decision to apply to UCSD's Communications program (with the aim of studying the learning and cultural acquisition of music) for my PhD - but I am no expert.  I am, I would argue, an expert learner, however, and that means that maybe, just maybe, I can drag someone somewhere along with me.  Or, at the very least - and more precisely, in any case - I can chronicle my learning so that it is traceable.  The project, then, is to listen, and in listening, to learn to listen, to Beethoven's 3rd.  If all goes well, then we can launch into the 9th and Tristan und Isolde, and perhaps other pieces as well (indeed, I have already done this with other posts on Bizet's Farandole and Brahms's Variations on a Theme by Haydn, and even Sacris Solemnis, a setting of Beethoven's 7th, but not as well as I would have liked).

Now this is not a one post project, or even a five post project.*  The Eroica's first movement, alone, might take a half dozen posts.  Nor will these posts be continuous.  You can still expect political wranglings, game reviews and observations, philosophical or literary musings, and of course, now that the season is coming, baseball analysis in this space.  Some might say that's a weakness of this blog: it lacks focus.  But I consider it a strength: it is vast, it contains multitudes.

*Indeed, the secret goal, here, is to write a book.  Perhaps a book no one would read, or - more importantly in our commerical age - no one would publish, but a book nonetheless.  Ambitious?  Perhaps, but you have to start somewhere, and whereas aspiring writers used to toil in anonymity for years before having their writing rejected by publishers, modern writers at least have the benefit of toiling publically.

Regardless of the number of posts, or the amount of time, however, we'll be forming a narrative.  Perhaps not a perfectly linear one, and perhaps not a perfectally literary one.  Rather, I'm hoping to build - for myself and for my readers - a mythology of music, a philosophy of music, and, most importantly, a deeper understanding not only of how music works, but why it works, and why, above all, it matters.  That's no small goal, I realize, but it is a goal I believe in, and a goal that I think we forget too easily in a world where music is everywhere, and largely unexamined.  Let us examine it, friends, that we might more joy in it that way.

Sunday, February 20, 2011

Losing the WAR: Rockies Pitchers

Last time we looked at the worst single-season offensive performances by Rockies players, putting together 13 man team that would give the modern day Pittsburgh Pirates a run for their money.  Today we'll fill out the roster with the 12 worst pitchers in Rockies history, beginning with the worst of the worst.

Starting Pitcher - Mike Hampton, 2002, -1.5 WAR
Other Stats: 7-15, 6.15 ERA, 78 ERA+, 74 Ks, 91 BBs, Silver Slugger Award (best hitting pitcher), $9.5 million salary

Yeah, he walked more hitters than he struck out.  Actually, Hampton was worth -0.6 WAR total if you count his positive 0.9 WAR offensive performance in 2002, but even with that boost Hampton would still crack this list.  I don't know what's more damning for Hampton, that he was a significantly more valuable offensive player than pitcher for the Rockies in 2002, or that he was, at the time, playing with the richest contract ever given to a pitcher.  The Rockies may have only paid $9.5 million for Hampton's considerable talents in 2002, but they continued to play $10+ million a year to Hampton until 2008.  That's a lot of money for a guy who put up a negative WAR in his Rockies career.

Really, there's no question that Hampton deserves to be the "ace" of this team.  No player had a more disappointing career with the Rockies.  After Hampton was signed in 2001 - coming off of a career season for the Astros in 1999 and another solid season in 2000 with the New York Mets - expectations were extremely high for the Rockies.  There was talk of contending for a playoff spot or even a World Series title.  There was talk about the Rockies finally being able to attract high-quality free agents to Denver.  There was talk of the Monforts opening up the checkbook.  And then Hampton struggled through 2001 and collapsed in 2002, and the Rockies traded him in 2003, setting the franchise back five years.

Starting Pitcher - Pedro Astacio, 1998, -0.7 WAR
Other Stats: 13-14, 6.23 ERA, 83 ERA+, 39 HR surrendered (league leader), 17 HBP (league leader)

Pedro Astacio was the best pitcher on the Rockies from 1997 until he was traded in 2001, but the 1998 season was an exception.  Astacio was still figuring out pitching at Coors - evidenced by the 39 homers he surrendered in '98 (and the 38 in '99) - and the Rockies had not hatched the humidor idea.  Add to that some bad luck - Astacio's FIP was 5.24, still bad, but much better than his 6.23 ERA - and Astacio's season looks much worse than it really was.

Despite a rough '98, it's tough to criticize Astacio overmuch because all of those things that went wrong for him in '98 went right in '99 (except the home runs).  He finished 17-11 with a 5.04 ERA, (actually a 115 ERA+) recorded 210 strikeouts, and put up a 4.56 FIP at the height of the Coors Field bandbox era.  In all, Astacio amassed 5.3 WAR in '99, easily compensating for his '98 debacle.  Which really goes to show, it was - and is - far too easy to misinterpret pitching performances by Rockies pitchers.

Starting Pitcher - Jamey Wright, 2005, -0.6 WAR
Other Stats: 8-16, 5.46 ERA, 88 ERA+, 171.1 IP, 201 H, 101 K, 81 BB

Jamey Wright owns the dubious distinction of being one of only 15 pitchers in all of major league history with a career ERA of 5.00 or higher whilst pitching at least 1000 innings.  A part of that comes from pitching for the Rockies for 6 seasons, but Wright has spent 9 seasons on other teams, so it's not all Coors's fault.  Jamey's 2005 was, needless to say, pretty bad, but not spectacularly so.  Really, the Rockies couldn't have expected much more from Wright than what he gave them: over 150 innings of below average pitching, good enough to not be completely embarrassing, but not good enough to actually contribute to a winning team.  At the time the Rockies were still a couple years away from competing, so there was little harm in turning the ball over to Wright every fifth day, especially given his under $1 million salary.

Starting Pitcher - Byung-Hyun Kim, 2006, -0.1 WAR
Other Stats: 8-12, 5.57 ERA, 88 ERA+, 1.55 WHIP, 57 priceless at bats

If Jamey Wright somehow had an unembarrassing -0.6 WAR season in 2005, Kim had an extremely embarrassing -0.1 WAR season in 2006.  His pitching was pretty much in line with Wright's in 2005.  He was, in short, an inning-eater (though, because he came up a closer and because he had a propensity for not throwing a lot of strikes, Kim didn't tend to make it very deep in games), a stop-gap while the Rockies waited for Ubaldo Jimenez and company to vault into the Majors in 2007.  What made Kim embarrassing was his hitting.  Of course, you can't dock a pitcher for being a bad hitter, but I have never seen someone look more lost at the plate than Byung-Hyun Kim did.  He tried to hit like Ichiro, and ended up looking like a 5-year-old using a bat about 12 ounces too heavy.*  Miraculously, Kim hit .160 in 2006, in the best offensive season of his career (his career line: .124/.156/.144).  As a fan who watched many of those 8 hits he collected in 2006, I can safely say that he was lucky.

*This is also a reasonable description of how he looked when he pitched.

Starting Pitcher - Josh Fogg, 2006, -0.4 WAR
Other Stats: 11-9, 5.49 ERA, 89 ERA+, 1.55 WHIP, 1 absurd shutout, 93 K, 60 BB, 206 H, 172 IP

Josh Fogg was a thoroughly unremarkable pitcher throughout his Rockies career.  He became a fan favorite in 2007 thanks to a smattering of lucky performances against big name pitchers, earning himself the nickname "Dragon Slayer."  In reality, he was a player who never seemed to be trying all that hard, and who never, in his entire career, managed an ERA+ better than 97 (his 2007 number).  Even so, his pitch-to-contact style - as evidenced by his combined 153 walks and strikeouts in 172 innings in 2006 - led to an improbable shutout.  Against the Seattle Mariners, Fogg pitched a two-hitter, walking one and thus facing the minimum 27 opponent batters thanks to three Mariners double plays.  Needless to say, his game score of 83 was by far his best in an otherwise uninspiring season.


Mop-up / Spot Starter - Jose Acevedo, 2005, -0.9 WAR
Other Stats: 2-4, 6.47 ERA, 1.59 WHIP, 74 ERA+

The Rockies have become somewhat famous for their reclamation projects.  Fogg, Kim, and Jorge De La Rosa (especially De La Rosa) have earned Bob Apodaca a reputation as something of a miracle worker.  The thing is, the Rockies take a flier on about 5 pitchers a year who they hope they can transform from mediocre to passable, or passable to good.*  The reality is, for every De La Rosa or Jason Hammel that Apodaca does manage to set right, there are a dozen Jose Acevedos who never make it.  Which is fine, because they don't really cost anything.  The problem with Acevedo in particular, however, was that he stuck around long enough to put up miserable numbers in 2005.  Not surprisingly, '05 was Acevedo's last season as a Major Leaguer.

* This year's project is John Maine, a former Met who was excellent in 2006 and 2007, good in 2008, and then completely fell off of a cliff.  Keep your eye on him, though, because he's got as much raw talent as anyone 'Dac has had to work with in a long time.

Relief Pitcher - Mike DeJean, 1999, -1.0 WAR
Other Stats: 2-4, 8.41 ERA, 56 G, 61.0 IP, 83 H, 13 HR, 32 BB, 31 K, 1.89 WHIP

No, that's not a typo.  Mike DeJean pitched his way to a 8.41 ERA over 61 innings in 1999.  He really did surrender 13 home runs while facing 288 batters.  DeJean is a case study for evaluating relief pitchers, because while his 1999 is unfathomably bad - and, really, it's tough for relievers to pick up even this much in the way of positive or negative WAR because they pitch so relatively few innings - DeJean was actually a good pitcher for the Rockies in 1997, 1998, and 2000.  What's more, he pitched well for a few other teams before returning to Colorado for some solid performances in 2005.  The moral of the story?  Even one transcendently bad season for a relief pitcher does not mean that pitcher is bad.

Relief Pitcher - Gabe White, 2001, -0.4 WAR
Other Stats: 1-7, 6.25 ERA, 67.2 IP, 18 HR

White was unlucky enough to surrender 18 homers in 2001 against only 290 batters faced.  I say "unlucky," because throughout most of his career White did much better than that.  Indeed, like DeJean White had more good seasons than bad, though because many of his teams used him as a lefty specialist, he rarely accumulated much more than 0.5 WAR in either direction.

White - like Astacio - is the rare player on this list who would make the "best Rockies ever" team, too.  In 2000, the year before his homer-happy debacle that earned him this spot, White put up a career-high 3.3 WAR, finishing 11-2 (out of the bullpen!) with a 2.17 ERA.  That's pretty good, and goes to show how misleading the small sample sizes of relief pitchers can be.  In 2000, for example, White surrendered 5 homers in 83.0 innings, struck out 82 and walked only 14.  In 2001, he gave up 18 (as listed above), struck out 47 and walked 26.  So, three times more homers, about half as many strikeouts, and nearly twice as many walks.  Did he change that much?  Was he burnt out after a busy 2000?  Was he just unlucky in 2001?  Was he exceptionally lucky in 2000?  It's hard to say; probably the answer is some combination of the four, but we don't have enough data to reach a conclusion.

Relief Pitcher - Matt Herges, 2008, -0.4 WAR
Other Stats: 3-4, 5.04 ERA, 93 ERA+, 46 K, 24 BB, 1.60 WHIP, 64.1 IP

Herges, or as a friend calls him, "Hergie Pie," is the definition of a journeyman, barely-above-replacement pitcher.  Taking away his exceptional (for him) first and second full seasons with the Dodgers, he was worth 0.4 WAR over his career, bouncing around so much that he actually ended up playing for every single team in the National League West, as well as the Marlins, the Indians, and the Expos.  While there is little worth mentioning about Herges, it is significant that he did not start his Major League career until he was 29 years old, but managed to last until he was 39.  Unfortunately, the Rockies have him his biggest payday of his career after a solid campaign in the miracle 2007 season, floating him $2 Million for his services in 2008.  Like just about everyone else with the team, he couldn't replicate his 2007 success, and the Rockies were stuck with a (relatively) expensive below-replacement-level, 38-year-old pitcher with the dubious distinction of being mentioned in the Mitchel Report.  Fun.

Lefty Specialist - Mike Munoz, 1995, -0.7 WAR
Other Stats: 2-4, 7.42 ERA, 73 ERA+, 37 K, 27 BB, 9 HR, 43.2 IP, 64 G

Munoz wins the "most unexpected member of this team" award, at least for me.  Perhaps because I was still an optimistic young fan in 1995, far too young to really know much of anything about baseball except that I loved the Rockies and that they were making the playoffs in their third year of existence, I didn't ever consider that maybe some of the players might not be all that good.

Munoz had a better year with Colorado in 2004, but throughout his career he was always a LOOGY (Lefty One Out GuY).  Anyone who appears in over 450 games, but pitches 364 innings is probably facing one or two batters at a time most nights.  And that was Munoz.  The result is that, sometimes a LOOGY has a bad season because of a few bad outings, or because he just happens to miss the strike zone on a few key pitches.  Despite the small sample size and pitching in the inagural season of Coors Field, however, it would be impossible to leave Munoz's '95 off of this team.  For a LOOGY to accumulate -0.7 WAR - in a shortened season no less - is impressive.  In a bad way.

Setup Man - Todd Jones, 2003, -1.4 WAR 
Other Stats: 1-4, 8.24 ERA, 61 ERA+, 39.1 IP, 61 H, 8 HR, 2.01 WHIP

-1.4 WAR in less than forty innings!  I had an unofficial rule that pitchers had to reach 50 innings to be considered for one of these spots (to weed out some of the -0.2 WAR in 10 innings kind of guys), but Jones easily earned this spot despite his midseason release and subsequent signing with Boston.  Jones was a "veteran presence" guy gone wrong for Colorado.  Once upon a time he was a good closer for the Detroit Tigers, but by his mid-30s he was - or looked - done as a Major League pitcher.  Coors Field proved too much for him, and he, to top it off, something of an ass, known for his homophobia, his bigotry, and his general closed-mindedness.  On a team built - for better or worse - around character, Jones did not fit in.  For some reason the Sporting News gave him a column late in his career,* and the writing was (or is, it seems he may still have this gig), well...  It was subpar.

*Indeed, his column began as he was on the Rockies, and while it was called "the closer," he never played that role in Colorado.  Somehow he miraculously became a passable closer again from 2005-2008.

Closer - Shawn Chacon, 2004, -1.7 WAR
Other Stats: 1-9, 7.11 ERA, 70 ERA+, 35 Saves in 44 Chances, 1.94 WHIP

And at least we reach the end.  Assuming this team somehow ever had a lead going into the ninth inning, it would be almost certain to squander it, thanks to Shawn Chacon.  The Greely native was the Rockies golden-child, becoming the first Colorado pitcher to make an All-Star game in 2003.  Thanks to injuries, and in an effort to preserve his arm, the Rockies moved Chacon to the pen in 2004, slotting him in as their closer.  The results were disasterous, and Chacon was gone from the Rockies by mid 2005, traded to the Yankees for Ramon Ramirez.  Of course, Ramirez was later flipped to the Kansas City Royals for Jorge De La Rosa, so it's not all bad.

Anyway, despite his solid 2003, Chacon never really demonstrated that he had the talent to pitch at the Major League level.  Rockies fans and ownership was overly-optimistic about him from day one, and while he may have stuck - had he not faced injury trouble - as a four or five starter, he was overmatched as an ace.  He was also overmatched - or at least misplaced - as a closer, struggling to handle the role, especially in a ballpark as unforgiving as Coors Field.

Wrap-Up

Ironically, the Rockies probably have a much better "worst ever" team than most franchises thanks to their relatively recent entry to the league (the same reason they have a much worse "best ever" team).  Even so, the team we've assembled in these last two posts would be absolutely dreadful.  There are a couple good hitters who can't field and a couple good fielders that can't hit, but mostly it's players who can't hit, field, pitch, or do much of anything else on a baseball field.  Or, at least, players who couldn't do much of anything for a particular season.

Baseball-Reference WAR (as opposed to Fangraphs WAR; we used BR in these posts) is calculated to a standard of 52 wins.  That is, a replacement level team should win roughly 52 games (and lose 110).  This Rockies team, as a whole, is a -21.5 WAR team, meaning they would go about 30-122, a .246 winning percentage.  I also played around with a lineup tool that estimated the offense would produce roughly 750 runs.  Given that total, we can estimate - in order to finish 30-122, that this team would surrender roughly 1300 runs.  Or, in other words, the average score of a Worst Rockies Ever game would be 8 to 4.5.  Eight!  If that seems high, take a look at the pitching staff again, and remember that it has a pretty much terrible defense - especially in the outfield - to back it up.  Eight runs a game might even seem low.

Fortunately, the real Rockies are much, much better than this.  And, even more fortunately, the season is about to start.