As an aspiring researcher in a School of Education, it seems almost a foregone conclusion that I should be voting for Barack Obama. The Academy is famously lefty in rhetoric, but center-lefty in its actual electoral practice, which pretty much sums up the President. As a student who is actively being socialized to the academy, I have certainly felt significant pressure (not direct pressure, which is ineffective anyway, but the indirect pressure of assumed common perspective) to support President Obama in this election.
It's not just a matter of social, economic, or foreign policy, you see. It's a matter of our very livelihood in the Academy: research tends to do better under Democrats than Republicans, and especially President Obama, who is bullish on educational technology and the transformative potential of innovations like Learning Analytics (my emerging research area).
So it seems like I should vote for the President. But I'm not going to. I'm voting for Green Party nominee Jill Stein.
The following are a set of perspectives and arguments for why I would do such a crazy thing. You'll note that "I live in California, which is 'safe' for Obama" is not one of my reasons. I might think longer about my vote if I still lived in my native Colorado. But in the end I would still vote for Dr. Stein.
1) I reject the idea that politics can easily be placed on a linear spectrum.
The left-right dichotomy in political discourse serves to marginalize minority perspectives, and to ossify the debate. Because we apply broad categories called "left" and "right" to the Democrats and Republicans respectively, we ignore the complexity of actual policy-based problem solving. The Green Party, if it can be characterized as a fringe left-wing party, is a satellite of the Democrats. In reality, there is no line that can be drawn which contains all three points: Republican, Democrat, and Green. The Green Party does not offer policies "left" of the Democrats. They offer policies fundamentally and categorically different from the Democratic Party in complex ways.
2) Jill Stein is a Doctor, and she would make decisions as scientifically as possible.
Lawyers and businessmen often make good public speakers, and sometimes make good leaders. Barack Obama is both a good speaker and, I think, a good leader. But Dr. Stein is a scientist, who believes in making policy decisions based upon scientific knowledge, and not political expediency. That may be 'impractical,' but even getting the idea of data-driven policy on the table seems worthwhile to me. Too often our political discourse is dictated by sophistical pandering, so much so that we now inhabit a culture in which "you have your facts, I have mine," has become an acceptable rebuttal. It may be a futile fight, but it is worth fighting for a political discourse based on data and scientific reasoning. I don't believe either major party wants to fight that battle.
3) The Green Party has been right about climate change for decades.
Whereas the Democratic Party has certainly used rhetoric about climate change to energize its base, it has shown little to no leadership in actually passing legislation that would curb the potentially catastrophic impact of global warming. The Green Party was formed by and large because of the recognition that combating climate change and other environmental issues caused by overpopulation and international industrialization would require a paradigmatic shift in the way we organize our governments and societies. Though this has been an unpopular insight, it is increasingly proving to be true. Eventually America - and the rest of the planet - will need leaders with the foresight of people like Dr. Stein.
4) The Green Party is international.
Unlike other major political parties, the Green Party is an international organization with local branches. Their international focus is unique in global politics, and is entirely necessary at a time when the world is increasingly interconnected, and what happens in Europe or Asia has as much or more impact on what happens in the United States as what happens in Ohio. Parties that are merely national, who see "foreign policy" as a separate category of political discourse from "domestic policy," are woefully obsolete.
5) The Green Party and Dr. Stein have not been bought and sold.
I believe that Barack Obama is more idealistic than a President can afford to be. And afford is exactly the right word. In order to be elected President in the United States, you need to raise lots and lots of money. In order to raise money, you have to raise money from major corporations, who then have expectations around what kind of policies you will or will not enact. That's vastly oversimplified, of course - it's more about shaping the conversation and determining who gets to come to the table than dictating policy decisions. For example, there were no significant advocates for single payer health care allowed at the table in the Affordable Care Act conversations. That put boundaries on the debate.
Electoral necessity means Democrats and Republicans have to constrain the debate. But innovation does not come from putting narrow boundaries on conversations and limiting acceptable solutions before the conversation even begins. The biggest benefit to politicians who are not awash in corporate money is that they are free to engage in real dialogue and real problem solving.
6) We must change our democratic processes.
Related to the above point, the way we elect Presidents (and other officials) simply does not make sense, and simply is not democratic. There are several problems:
- Wealth has a disproportionate impact on an individual's political clout.
- Corporations count as "individuals," and are wealthier than any real person, and therefore more powerful.
- Politicians are by-and-large more focused on reelection than governance.
- Plurality is a poor way of choosing a winner in an election, and run-off is too expensive. We need Instant Run-off Voting.
- Along with plurality, federal representation by geography alone is outdated, as it ensures that only a limited set of ideologies get represented in the government. Most other first world countries apportion seats by party (also flawed, but better).
- Our current system creates far too much incentive to cynically manipulate voter turnout.
Raising these issues is important, because neither major party stands to gain by doing so. Supporting third parties is - in a wonderful catch-22 - the only way to raise these problems to prominence so they become a part of the discourse.
7) This is not the most important election of my lifetime.
Every single election of my lifetime has been described as the most important election of my lifetime. The truth is, none of them are (I suppose one will be, but it's hard to know now which). While the Democratic and Republican parties do offer stark differences on many issues, it's worth noting that on many fundamental issues of process (see point 6, above) there is no difference between the major parties. Because there is no difference, there is no discourse. Because there is no discourse, there is no opportunity for change. As long as we buy the hype around how important the differences between Democrats and Republicans are (and how vitally close the election is), we continue to push aside the opportunity to raise more fundamental issues. Indeed, it is particularly in states where elections are close where third parties - Green, Libertarian, Constitution, whatever - stand to have the greatest impact on the debate. That is, as long as we don't silence them.
8) Revolutionaries spoil corrupt systems.
I was going to call this point two different things. First, I was going to say: "third parties are often responsible for positive change." Then I was going to say: "third parties are not actually spoilers" (except inasmuch as they open up uncomfortable, but important conversations). I combined them into one.
To the first sub-point: it took a sustained and politically meaningful push by the Socialist Party to get FDR to actually adopt his New Deal reforms. Recall that he was President for a significant amount of time before he even began to implement reforms. Consider, more recently, how President Clinton's economic policies were at least in part shaped by the rise of Ross Perot. It is saddening that the Democratic Party, instead of adopting the pieces of the Green Party platform that made Ralph Nader so (relatively) successful in the late 90s and early 2000s, they actively worked to shut him out of the debates. Again, the lesson from history is: significant third party support demonstrates an avenue for opening up a new conversation. The Democrats of 1996-2012 have chosen instead to work to actively suppress 'marginal left-wing' Greens (see point 1).
To the second sub-point: Nader did not, in fact, cost Gore the election in 2000. For one thing, the logic of apportioning Nader votes to Gore and saying, "see the difference between Bush and Gore was smaller than the number of Nader votes" is deeply flawed. By that very logic, Pat Buchanan cost Bush more electoral votes than Nader cost Gore. But more importantly, exit polls suggest that Nader voters, if they had not voted for Nader, by and large would not have voted, period. It is naive to think that Nader was just a "more left-wing" version of Gore (again, see point 1).
In short, Nader was a "spoiler" because we re-wrote the narrative to describe it that way. In reality, though, what Nader spoiled was an already corrupt system. It was laid bare by virtue of his presence in the race.
9) The Presidency isn't as important as you think.
I am continually amazed at how important Americans think the Presidency is. Simply because the President is the most visible elected office in the country does not mean it is an all-powerful office. In reality, while President Obama may be the most powerful man in America, it would be quite easy to find two people combined (or 538 people...) who wield far more power than the President. Which is to say: even if the President gets to set an agenda in a broad sense, whether that agenda gets enacted or not has a lot to do with the congress, with the weather, with whether or not Greece stays in the Eurozone, with Chinese environmental regulations, with Mexican immigration patterns, with Iranian protesters, and so on. The President has direct control over precious little, so let's not over-emphasize his importance. Our nation was designed to ensure that no one man or woman was so important that his or her decisions would make or break our society.
10) The student debt bubble is as risky as the sub-prime mortgage bubble was.
Perhaps the most compelling argument for Barack Obama, to me, is his forward-thinking approach to education. He has instituted an office of educational technology, and the common core movement has blossomed under his administration. That said, there are still huge swaths of the educational conversation that I feel as though Jill Stein and the Green Party are willing to have that the Democrats and Republicans are not. Chief among these is the student debt bubble, and who ought to pay for education. I am perhaps naive in believing that education is one of those services for which the costs ought to be socialized, simply because an educated populace is a necessity for democracy. While the Democratic Party still uses that rhetoric, it is worth noting that modern public universities are as expensive now as private universities once were. The cost of higher education is unsustainable, as is the issuing of massive (and undischargeable in bankruptcy) student debt.
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Sunday, November 4, 2012
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
Stop SOPA and PIPA
In support of the ongoing blackouts and various web-based protests to ongoing legislation in the US House and Senate, I encourage my readers to go to contact their representatives. This site will tell you who to call. Thank you.
Labels:
censorship,
PIPA,
Politics,
SOPA
Saturday, August 27, 2011
The Corporate Death Penalty
If corporations are people, they should not only have the rights of people, but also the responsibilities. They should be able to suffer the same consequences individual people do for immoral and illegal actions, including, in particularly heinous crimes, the death penalty.
Now what I'm not going to say here is that corporations are not people. It should be obvious that they are not, but the notion that they are has been a legal reality in the United States for over 100 years. So as much as the Democratic Party was ostensibly up-in-arms over Mitt Romney's "Corporations are people" gaffe, they've been on the same bandwagon for over a century (since, in fact, the Democrats were the conservatives and the Republicans the liberals).
No, the point here is that, if corporate personhood is a legal and philosophical reality in the United States already, we ought to extend it to its logical limits. As is, the corporation (capitalized? I think maybe yes)... Ahem, Mr. Corporation is protected by the constitutional rights of individuals. That is, his individual rights are protected under the 1st and 14th amendments, among others.
Obviously, this has created all kinds of problems, not the least of which being the (increasingly less) recent Federal Election Commission vs. Citizen's United Supreme Court ruling that allows corporate entities to give unlimited sums of money to political causes. The result was the meteoric rise in spending in the 2010 midterms, and the even more insane fundraising that has already occurred in the 2012 election cycle (Barack Obama is on pace to shatter George Bush's reelection fundraising totals, and not because of grassroots support). Of course, corporate personhood has been around and caused trouble for a long time before FEC vs. CU, but this particular piece of legal interpretation has dire, self-perpetuating consequences in a way that few previous corporate personhood rulings and legislation have.
How do we get ourselves out of this mess? Well the root of the problem is, in some sense, that we've endowed personhood on entities that have no conscience, no fundamental ethical code, and no accountability to anyone except for shareholders. Because most shareholders are only distantly involved in the companies they are invested in, and because of the cultural maxim that all public companies must maximize profits at all costs,* there is little concern for little stuff like making sure people or the environment aren't harmed by defective (or even effective) products and services. The result is a set of beings with human rights, but without human responsibilities.
* Indeed, they must not only maximize profits, they must actually make more profits than they were expected to make if they are to do well in the market.
Getting rid of corporate personhood is well nigh impossible. There's no political traction for it, no reason that either major party will challenge a nearly two-century old legal statute. What I propose, then, is to force the corporate person to have a conscience by forcing him to be accountable for his actions. There have been a great many well-known cases where corporations knowingly engaged in immoral behavior at the expense of consumers, the environment, or both. While there are repercussions for such actions, they are usually slight and monetary. While there are people held accountable for heinous corporate crimes, their prison sentences are lenient and their fines meaningless (and frequently uncollected).
Rather than approaching corporate responsibility quantitatively, let's approach is qualitatively. When a corporation is convicted of a heinous crime - the intentional killing of a human being (or murder, as we call it in human-speak), for example - it should be subject to the same kinds of penalties an individual is subject to. In particular, I believe we should sometimes put corporations to death.
What does that mean, exactly? It means that the corporation is dissolved, it's assets liquefied and seized, and its board and CEO barred from serving with any other for-profit corporation in the future. Is that too harsh? Ironically, a great many people would say "yes," even though I'm talking about a corporation convicted of murder. "Why," the argument goes, "should the people inside the company (and the shareholders) be legally responsible for the actions of the corporation? The CEO is not the murderer." Too which I respond, yes, but the corporation is being put to death, not the CEO. The CEO and board, however, do share some responsibility for the corporation, and thus should not be allowed to serve with other for-profit corporations in the future.
What about the shareholders? Well, they could conceivably cash out between indictment and conviction. Otherwise, their investment would come to nothing. What about the employees? Well, unfortunately, they'd be out-of-work. Now if that seems harsh and unfair to employees and shareholders (the "little people" in the equation), think about the other side of the equation. If every single employee and every single shareholder of a corporation has that much stake in the corporation not committing heinous crimes, suddenly said company actually does have a conscience. The CEO and board stand to lose plenty under this proposal, but the employees and the shareholders stand to lose even more, which makes them powerful advocates for the moral behavior of the corporation.
While the corporate death penalty - complete with severe professional ramifications for the board, as well as loss of employment for the employees and loss of investment for shareholders - would be a significant step towards ensuring a more ethical moral climate in the corporate world, it's far from a silver bullet. Indeed, the hassle of prosecution, the potential economic ramification of a "too big to fail" company being put to death, and the difficulty of enforcement of the stipulations that would be necessary to stop the most corrupt of CEOs and boards from profiting even from the death of their companies (see Ken Lay at Enron) would prove significant hurdles to implementing such a proposal. Hopefully, however, the very attempt would at least force us to recognize the absurdity of legal corporate personhood to begin with.
The biggest hurdle to the corporate death penalty, however, is that corporations would resist it, just as they resist rescinding corporate personhood in general. Given their political influence, it would be nearly impossible to gain traction on a bill that allowed corporations to be put to death. Given the Supreme Court's political leanings, it is also hard to believe they would uphold such a bill (though, in the process, they might at least be forced to declare the individual death penalty unconstitutional). Nevertheless, I suggest that it might be an easier path to the end of corporate tyranny than any other we have before us.
Now what I'm not going to say here is that corporations are not people. It should be obvious that they are not, but the notion that they are has been a legal reality in the United States for over 100 years. So as much as the Democratic Party was ostensibly up-in-arms over Mitt Romney's "Corporations are people" gaffe, they've been on the same bandwagon for over a century (since, in fact, the Democrats were the conservatives and the Republicans the liberals).
No, the point here is that, if corporate personhood is a legal and philosophical reality in the United States already, we ought to extend it to its logical limits. As is, the corporation (capitalized? I think maybe yes)... Ahem, Mr. Corporation is protected by the constitutional rights of individuals. That is, his individual rights are protected under the 1st and 14th amendments, among others.
Obviously, this has created all kinds of problems, not the least of which being the (increasingly less) recent Federal Election Commission vs. Citizen's United Supreme Court ruling that allows corporate entities to give unlimited sums of money to political causes. The result was the meteoric rise in spending in the 2010 midterms, and the even more insane fundraising that has already occurred in the 2012 election cycle (Barack Obama is on pace to shatter George Bush's reelection fundraising totals, and not because of grassroots support). Of course, corporate personhood has been around and caused trouble for a long time before FEC vs. CU, but this particular piece of legal interpretation has dire, self-perpetuating consequences in a way that few previous corporate personhood rulings and legislation have.
How do we get ourselves out of this mess? Well the root of the problem is, in some sense, that we've endowed personhood on entities that have no conscience, no fundamental ethical code, and no accountability to anyone except for shareholders. Because most shareholders are only distantly involved in the companies they are invested in, and because of the cultural maxim that all public companies must maximize profits at all costs,* there is little concern for little stuff like making sure people or the environment aren't harmed by defective (or even effective) products and services. The result is a set of beings with human rights, but without human responsibilities.
* Indeed, they must not only maximize profits, they must actually make more profits than they were expected to make if they are to do well in the market.
Getting rid of corporate personhood is well nigh impossible. There's no political traction for it, no reason that either major party will challenge a nearly two-century old legal statute. What I propose, then, is to force the corporate person to have a conscience by forcing him to be accountable for his actions. There have been a great many well-known cases where corporations knowingly engaged in immoral behavior at the expense of consumers, the environment, or both. While there are repercussions for such actions, they are usually slight and monetary. While there are people held accountable for heinous corporate crimes, their prison sentences are lenient and their fines meaningless (and frequently uncollected).
Rather than approaching corporate responsibility quantitatively, let's approach is qualitatively. When a corporation is convicted of a heinous crime - the intentional killing of a human being (or murder, as we call it in human-speak), for example - it should be subject to the same kinds of penalties an individual is subject to. In particular, I believe we should sometimes put corporations to death.
What does that mean, exactly? It means that the corporation is dissolved, it's assets liquefied and seized, and its board and CEO barred from serving with any other for-profit corporation in the future. Is that too harsh? Ironically, a great many people would say "yes," even though I'm talking about a corporation convicted of murder. "Why," the argument goes, "should the people inside the company (and the shareholders) be legally responsible for the actions of the corporation? The CEO is not the murderer." Too which I respond, yes, but the corporation is being put to death, not the CEO. The CEO and board, however, do share some responsibility for the corporation, and thus should not be allowed to serve with other for-profit corporations in the future.
What about the shareholders? Well, they could conceivably cash out between indictment and conviction. Otherwise, their investment would come to nothing. What about the employees? Well, unfortunately, they'd be out-of-work. Now if that seems harsh and unfair to employees and shareholders (the "little people" in the equation), think about the other side of the equation. If every single employee and every single shareholder of a corporation has that much stake in the corporation not committing heinous crimes, suddenly said company actually does have a conscience. The CEO and board stand to lose plenty under this proposal, but the employees and the shareholders stand to lose even more, which makes them powerful advocates for the moral behavior of the corporation.
While the corporate death penalty - complete with severe professional ramifications for the board, as well as loss of employment for the employees and loss of investment for shareholders - would be a significant step towards ensuring a more ethical moral climate in the corporate world, it's far from a silver bullet. Indeed, the hassle of prosecution, the potential economic ramification of a "too big to fail" company being put to death, and the difficulty of enforcement of the stipulations that would be necessary to stop the most corrupt of CEOs and boards from profiting even from the death of their companies (see Ken Lay at Enron) would prove significant hurdles to implementing such a proposal. Hopefully, however, the very attempt would at least force us to recognize the absurdity of legal corporate personhood to begin with.
The biggest hurdle to the corporate death penalty, however, is that corporations would resist it, just as they resist rescinding corporate personhood in general. Given their political influence, it would be nearly impossible to gain traction on a bill that allowed corporations to be put to death. Given the Supreme Court's political leanings, it is also hard to believe they would uphold such a bill (though, in the process, they might at least be forced to declare the individual death penalty unconstitutional). Nevertheless, I suggest that it might be an easier path to the end of corporate tyranny than any other we have before us.
Labels:
CEOs,
corporate personhood,
corporations,
death penalty,
Enron,
government,
law,
legislation,
Politics
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
Fuzzy Fundraising Math
This New York Times article is a wonderful example of the old adage about lies, damn lies, and statistics. Apparently relying upon widespread lack of understanding of mathematics and an inability or unwillingness to think critically about information, Jim Messina - President Obama's campaign manager - presents some shady numbers, and then points to them as evidence of “more grassroots support at this point in the process than any campaign in political history.” He's not lying, just statistic-ing.
The numbers are as follows:
- $86 million raised for the DNC and Obama's reelection campaign in the second quarter.
- 552,462 separate donors.
- Average contribution of $69.
- 98% of contributions under $250.
Well let's break out our calculators, shall we? 552,462 donors times an average donation of $69 equals... $38.1 million. But wait, Obama has raised $86 million! Huh? Where did the other $47.9 million come from?
Reading more closely tells you that the average contribution may be $69, but there's no indication as to how many donors have written multiple smaller checks, instead of one big one. In order for the math to work out, that $86 million required about 1.25 million separate donations, even if there were 552.462 separate donors. The actual average contribution per donor, meanwhile, is over $150.
That's starting to sound a little less "grassroots," no? Don't get me wrong, the sheer number of contributors here is impressive, and a great many of those - maybe as many as 98% - are average Joes and Johns contributing $20. But that's not where the bulk of Obama's funding comes from.
Unfortunately, given the numbers we have to work with here, we can't draw any certain conclusions about the percentage or amount of Obama's current campaign money that comes from corporate sources. For that matter, the Citizen's United vs. FEC ruling makes it nigh impossible to track that corporate money anyway. What we can do, however, is hypothesize. Let's assume that those 98% of donors giving $250 or less per donation are only donating once. After all, we're still over a year from the election, and I'm guessing Mr. Middle Class Obama Supporter isn't cutting multiple $50 checks to reelect the President right now.
If we assume that 98% of donors, then, are contributing an average of $69 overall (instead of per donation), we get the following:
- 98% of 552,462 donors is 541,412. An undeniably impressive number of grassroots donors, but far from the full story.
- Those donors have provided, following this hypothesis, about $37.4 million.
- That means the remaining 11,050 donors have contributed, across multiple donations each, $48.6 million.
- The average, then, amount of money donated by each of those 11,050 donors is roughly $4,400 dollars.
Remember that we're still well over a year away from the election. That's a lot of money from a small number of people for just one fiscal quarter's worth of fundraising. It's not unreasonable to assume that a small subset of those 10,000 donors - whether they be individuals, oil companies, financial firms, or health insurance providers - will be contributing as much as $50,000 each by the end of the election cycle. Perhaps the President should be careful whilst pushing for closing loopholes and levying higher taxes on the wealthiest wage earners, lest they lose the ability to contribute so much to his campaign.
For all of the talk about "grassroots" and "yes we can," it's worth remembering that those grassroots contributions, no matter how you slice it, are not the bulk of Obama's campaign money. And when executive push comes to legislative shove, the golden rule wins out: he who has the gold, makes the rules.
The numbers are as follows:
- $86 million raised for the DNC and Obama's reelection campaign in the second quarter.
- 552,462 separate donors.
- Average contribution of $69.
- 98% of contributions under $250.
Well let's break out our calculators, shall we? 552,462 donors times an average donation of $69 equals... $38.1 million. But wait, Obama has raised $86 million! Huh? Where did the other $47.9 million come from?
Reading more closely tells you that the average contribution may be $69, but there's no indication as to how many donors have written multiple smaller checks, instead of one big one. In order for the math to work out, that $86 million required about 1.25 million separate donations, even if there were 552.462 separate donors. The actual average contribution per donor, meanwhile, is over $150.
That's starting to sound a little less "grassroots," no? Don't get me wrong, the sheer number of contributors here is impressive, and a great many of those - maybe as many as 98% - are average Joes and Johns contributing $20. But that's not where the bulk of Obama's funding comes from.
Unfortunately, given the numbers we have to work with here, we can't draw any certain conclusions about the percentage or amount of Obama's current campaign money that comes from corporate sources. For that matter, the Citizen's United vs. FEC ruling makes it nigh impossible to track that corporate money anyway. What we can do, however, is hypothesize. Let's assume that those 98% of donors giving $250 or less per donation are only donating once. After all, we're still over a year from the election, and I'm guessing Mr. Middle Class Obama Supporter isn't cutting multiple $50 checks to reelect the President right now.
If we assume that 98% of donors, then, are contributing an average of $69 overall (instead of per donation), we get the following:
- 98% of 552,462 donors is 541,412. An undeniably impressive number of grassroots donors, but far from the full story.
- Those donors have provided, following this hypothesis, about $37.4 million.
- That means the remaining 11,050 donors have contributed, across multiple donations each, $48.6 million.
- The average, then, amount of money donated by each of those 11,050 donors is roughly $4,400 dollars.
Remember that we're still well over a year away from the election. That's a lot of money from a small number of people for just one fiscal quarter's worth of fundraising. It's not unreasonable to assume that a small subset of those 10,000 donors - whether they be individuals, oil companies, financial firms, or health insurance providers - will be contributing as much as $50,000 each by the end of the election cycle. Perhaps the President should be careful whilst pushing for closing loopholes and levying higher taxes on the wealthiest wage earners, lest they lose the ability to contribute so much to his campaign.
For all of the talk about "grassroots" and "yes we can," it's worth remembering that those grassroots contributions, no matter how you slice it, are not the bulk of Obama's campaign money. And when executive push comes to legislative shove, the golden rule wins out: he who has the gold, makes the rules.
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Where Does the Money Go?
| A breakdown of US Government spending in 2010, from Wikipedia |
I'm not going to offer much commentary, here, especially since my last post was a tad, um, long. What I want to point out, though, is that our Congresspeople and President have recently been fighting over a budget for the coming year. Mostly - as I understand it - the discussion about where to make cuts is focused on the upper-left quadrant of this graph. My question is, what about that gigantic maroon section? What about the 18.74% (in 2010, almost $700 billion) we're spending on our military every year? In 2010 the USA's military operations - that is, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan - budget ($283 billion) alone was larger than our Education, Justice, Agriculture, Energy, Labor, Commerce, and Environmental (EPA and Interior) spending combined. What does that say about our priorities, as a nation? What does that say about the parties that we enthusiastically vote for?
Keep in mind, while you listen to the news talk about the vehement arguments between Democrats and Republicans over a hundred million dollars here and a hundred million there that neither party - including the President - supports a reduction in our military spending, even though a mere 10% cut therein would more than cover the total discrepancy between the Republican and Democratic budgets for 2012. Keep in mind, while your state cuts pension programs for government employees, including teachers, and slashes non-core education programs like the arts and physical education, that most state budget shortfalls are dwarfed by our defense spending. Keep in mind, when you go to vote in 2012, that neither major political party will do anything to change that.
Labels:
budget,
Democrats,
military spending,
Politics,
Republicans,
voting
Sunday, March 27, 2011
The Future of Nuclear Energy
Before we get to the real problems with nuclear power, let's talk about public opinion*. A well publicized CBS News Poll tells us the following about whether people approve of building new nuclear power plants in the United States**:
2007 - 45% in favor, 47% against, 8% unsure
2008 - 57% in favor, 34% against, 9% unsure
2011 - 43% in favor, 50% against, 7% unsure
*Polling numbers here come from the invaluable PollingReport.com.
**It's also worth noting that people have strong opinions about where these new plants are built. When the same people were asked whether they approve of new nuclear power plants in their communities, responses are somewhat more reserved:
2007 - 36% in favor, 55% against, 5% unsure
2011 - 35% in favor, 62% against, 3% unsure
Don't read too much into the slight changes between 2007 and 2011 here, as margin of error is a bugbear in these opinion polls. NIMBY is alive and well, thank you very much. Just build that nuclear power plant over in the other part of town, thank you.
I include the 2007 numbers because they differ significantly from the more widely cited 2008 numbers. They are, in fact, much closer the the March, 2011 results.
It would be foolish, however, to just look at polls here, as there's a definite buzz around both traditional and social media about nuclear power, and a general sense that the tide is turning politically and socially against more nuclear power.
There is no indication, however, that any major "mainstream" politician is ready to take up the anti-nuclear power banner, in chief because that would mean angering a lot of energy industry big-wigs who have a lot of say in who gets to spend more money in the next campaign. That, of course, is a post all on its own, but it bears mentioning here.
Public opinion is our chief concern here. Obviously the fickle masses are easily moved by sensationalism, and there's little more sensationalist than a natural disaster followed by a nuclear meltdown. It's no wonder that Americans, in addition to hilariously buying up vast stores of potassium iodide, are feeling less sure about nuclear power.
But are they right-headed in this change of face? Are the dangers of nuclear power really all that different today than they were a month ago? Of course not. Nuclear meltdown has always, and will always be, a non-negligible risk of nuclear power. It may be exceedingly rare, but even one instance can be devastating. No matter how safe any particular reactor is, the worst-case scenario for nuclear power is disastrous. And that is what people are currently rallying behind.
That is takes an actual disaster to remind people of this fact is, of course, the silly part. We humans have notoriously short memories, and as big a deal as the current situation in Japan seems, it has already lost significant momentum (in the face of a new sensational story in Libya and, of course, the triumphs of Butler and Virginia Commonwealth in March Madness). It's only a matter of time before everyone settles down and forgets how scared they were of nuclear power in March of 2011.
I would argue, though, that it would be foolish to ignore this opportunity to talk about what nuclear power is and isn't. Now, I'm no expert, but I know enough about chemistry and physics, and have done enough background research of my own that I feel confident putting a few important considerations forward here. We've all seen, now, what ill can come of nuclear power gone wrong. What ill, then, can come of nuclear power gone right?
First of all, what is nuclear power gone right? There's little question that nuclear power is incredibly more efficient than our beloved combustible fossil fuels power. It takes, not surprisingly, much less uranium to boil water than it does burning oil, and carbon dioxide doesn't get pumped into the atmosphere along the way. This, however, is the first troubling thing about nuclear power: nuclear waste. As more and more of the world's energy comes from nuclear sources, more and more waste gets produced. What happens to this waste? We store it in vast pools, both because it's still dangerous (check the "legacy waste" section of this Wikipedia article for a heartwarming story about contamination of an aquifer in Ohio) and because we're dealing with half-lives ranging in the 10,000 to 1,000,000 year range.
Yeah.
So, about 10,000 years ago there were a total of, oh, roughly zero cities in the entire world, as human beings had not yet come up with the idea of "civilization." Let's not even talk about 1,000,000 years.
The thing is, no one is quite sure what to do with nuclear waste, exactly, and that's not really a concern for nuclear energy companies. Why think about the future when you can think about the present? Right now there is no question that we need power and we need it from a source other than fossil fuels. Nuclear power already has an infrastructure, it's efficient, and it's mostly safe most of the time (except when there's an earthquake, or there's a problem with the waste storage, or if someone manages to steal some of the uranium or plutonium being refined). And you know what, that's exactly right. For all intents and purposes, nuclear power is what we need to do because, frankly, we've neglected other, better options* for so long that it will take too long and cost too much to replace our massive energy needs with anything else.
*Namely solar. Wind energy has non-negligible and often-overlooked problems beyond how hideous it makes once beautiful hills. The chief among these is the outrageous cost of the lubricants necessary to make the things actually work. Not only are those lubricants expensive, and not only do turbines need lots of it, but usually lubricants are, you guessed it, oil based. Not that they have to be petroleum based, necessarily, but almost all industrial lubricants are.
Here's the real kicker though. Nuclear energy is not a long-term solution to our problems. I highly recommend the Azimuth Project for its collected wisdom (contributions come from a variety of scientists in a variety of fields) on general planet saving, but their piece on "Peak Uranium" is particularly important to our discussion here. The Internet is rife with argumentation about how much uranium there is available for future energy production. Claims range from 10 years to several billion, so obviously someone is lying for political gain.
The Azimuth article offers a simple thought-experiment, instead. Assume we replaced all other energy consumption and production with nuclear power. How long could our current stores of uranium support that level of energy use? Their answer: 10 years. 70 if you count all potential, but not yet mined, sources.
Now that's not saying that there's only 10 (or 70) years of uranium available. As we know, we're moving towards a hybrid energy world, where nuclear power plays a small role in the bigger. But it is informative, no? As we expand our reliance on nuclear power, we have to remember that it is not a renewable source of energy. Even if we find more than we currently have found (something many scientists believe is likely, as there have been few large-scale prospecting efforts), and even if we also tap all available thorium and plutonium sources, nuclear energy simply cannot last forever.
Now, recall that much nuclear waste will continue to be a problem for 10,000 years. Does 70 years worth of power - or even, if we're extra generous and double the uranium available and count thorium as a fuel source and ignore rising and increasingly industrialized and digitized populations, 400 years worth of power - justify 10,000 plus years worth of waste? Does it not seem that the history will deem us barbaric, wanton, and, above all, extremely stupid for making that trade?
As I mentioned above, this doesn't change that we are going to expand the use of nuclear power in both the United States and around the world, nor should it. We truthfully don't have many other options. And that's the point: let's not simply celebrate this "solution" to our energy problems. The nuclear age is a bitter failure on the part of human civilization to plan ahead, to think reasonably, and to act conscientiously towards its future generations.
In short, the immediate future of nuclear energy is bright, indeed, in spite of wavering public opinion. The distant future? That's another story.
2007 - 45% in favor, 47% against, 8% unsure
2008 - 57% in favor, 34% against, 9% unsure
2011 - 43% in favor, 50% against, 7% unsure
*Polling numbers here come from the invaluable PollingReport.com.
**It's also worth noting that people have strong opinions about where these new plants are built. When the same people were asked whether they approve of new nuclear power plants in their communities, responses are somewhat more reserved:
2007 - 36% in favor, 55% against, 5% unsure
2011 - 35% in favor, 62% against, 3% unsure
Don't read too much into the slight changes between 2007 and 2011 here, as margin of error is a bugbear in these opinion polls. NIMBY is alive and well, thank you very much. Just build that nuclear power plant over in the other part of town, thank you.
I include the 2007 numbers because they differ significantly from the more widely cited 2008 numbers. They are, in fact, much closer the the March, 2011 results.
It would be foolish, however, to just look at polls here, as there's a definite buzz around both traditional and social media about nuclear power, and a general sense that the tide is turning politically and socially against more nuclear power.
There is no indication, however, that any major "mainstream" politician is ready to take up the anti-nuclear power banner, in chief because that would mean angering a lot of energy industry big-wigs who have a lot of say in who gets to spend more money in the next campaign. That, of course, is a post all on its own, but it bears mentioning here.
Public opinion is our chief concern here. Obviously the fickle masses are easily moved by sensationalism, and there's little more sensationalist than a natural disaster followed by a nuclear meltdown. It's no wonder that Americans, in addition to hilariously buying up vast stores of potassium iodide, are feeling less sure about nuclear power.
But are they right-headed in this change of face? Are the dangers of nuclear power really all that different today than they were a month ago? Of course not. Nuclear meltdown has always, and will always be, a non-negligible risk of nuclear power. It may be exceedingly rare, but even one instance can be devastating. No matter how safe any particular reactor is, the worst-case scenario for nuclear power is disastrous. And that is what people are currently rallying behind.
That is takes an actual disaster to remind people of this fact is, of course, the silly part. We humans have notoriously short memories, and as big a deal as the current situation in Japan seems, it has already lost significant momentum (in the face of a new sensational story in Libya and, of course, the triumphs of Butler and Virginia Commonwealth in March Madness). It's only a matter of time before everyone settles down and forgets how scared they were of nuclear power in March of 2011.
I would argue, though, that it would be foolish to ignore this opportunity to talk about what nuclear power is and isn't. Now, I'm no expert, but I know enough about chemistry and physics, and have done enough background research of my own that I feel confident putting a few important considerations forward here. We've all seen, now, what ill can come of nuclear power gone wrong. What ill, then, can come of nuclear power gone right?
First of all, what is nuclear power gone right? There's little question that nuclear power is incredibly more efficient than our beloved combustible fossil fuels power. It takes, not surprisingly, much less uranium to boil water than it does burning oil, and carbon dioxide doesn't get pumped into the atmosphere along the way. This, however, is the first troubling thing about nuclear power: nuclear waste. As more and more of the world's energy comes from nuclear sources, more and more waste gets produced. What happens to this waste? We store it in vast pools, both because it's still dangerous (check the "legacy waste" section of this Wikipedia article for a heartwarming story about contamination of an aquifer in Ohio) and because we're dealing with half-lives ranging in the 10,000 to 1,000,000 year range.
Yeah.
So, about 10,000 years ago there were a total of, oh, roughly zero cities in the entire world, as human beings had not yet come up with the idea of "civilization." Let's not even talk about 1,000,000 years.
The thing is, no one is quite sure what to do with nuclear waste, exactly, and that's not really a concern for nuclear energy companies. Why think about the future when you can think about the present? Right now there is no question that we need power and we need it from a source other than fossil fuels. Nuclear power already has an infrastructure, it's efficient, and it's mostly safe most of the time (except when there's an earthquake, or there's a problem with the waste storage, or if someone manages to steal some of the uranium or plutonium being refined). And you know what, that's exactly right. For all intents and purposes, nuclear power is what we need to do because, frankly, we've neglected other, better options* for so long that it will take too long and cost too much to replace our massive energy needs with anything else.
*Namely solar. Wind energy has non-negligible and often-overlooked problems beyond how hideous it makes once beautiful hills. The chief among these is the outrageous cost of the lubricants necessary to make the things actually work. Not only are those lubricants expensive, and not only do turbines need lots of it, but usually lubricants are, you guessed it, oil based. Not that they have to be petroleum based, necessarily, but almost all industrial lubricants are.
Here's the real kicker though. Nuclear energy is not a long-term solution to our problems. I highly recommend the Azimuth Project for its collected wisdom (contributions come from a variety of scientists in a variety of fields) on general planet saving, but their piece on "Peak Uranium" is particularly important to our discussion here. The Internet is rife with argumentation about how much uranium there is available for future energy production. Claims range from 10 years to several billion, so obviously someone is lying for political gain.
The Azimuth article offers a simple thought-experiment, instead. Assume we replaced all other energy consumption and production with nuclear power. How long could our current stores of uranium support that level of energy use? Their answer: 10 years. 70 if you count all potential, but not yet mined, sources.
Now that's not saying that there's only 10 (or 70) years of uranium available. As we know, we're moving towards a hybrid energy world, where nuclear power plays a small role in the bigger. But it is informative, no? As we expand our reliance on nuclear power, we have to remember that it is not a renewable source of energy. Even if we find more than we currently have found (something many scientists believe is likely, as there have been few large-scale prospecting efforts), and even if we also tap all available thorium and plutonium sources, nuclear energy simply cannot last forever.
Now, recall that much nuclear waste will continue to be a problem for 10,000 years. Does 70 years worth of power - or even, if we're extra generous and double the uranium available and count thorium as a fuel source and ignore rising and increasingly industrialized and digitized populations, 400 years worth of power - justify 10,000 plus years worth of waste? Does it not seem that the history will deem us barbaric, wanton, and, above all, extremely stupid for making that trade?
As I mentioned above, this doesn't change that we are going to expand the use of nuclear power in both the United States and around the world, nor should it. We truthfully don't have many other options. And that's the point: let's not simply celebrate this "solution" to our energy problems. The nuclear age is a bitter failure on the part of human civilization to plan ahead, to think reasonably, and to act conscientiously towards its future generations.
In short, the immediate future of nuclear energy is bright, indeed, in spite of wavering public opinion. The distant future? That's another story.
Labels:
energy,
environmentalism,
nuclear power,
Politics,
public opinion,
Science,
solar power,
wind power
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Lacertilian Politics
In the process of rereading (for the so-embarrassingly-many-I-can't-remembereth time) the 5-book long Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy "trilogy," I stumbled across a passage I did not particularly remember, but which I think is as good a summary of electoral politics as you'll find anywhere. It goes thus:
[A giant robot from outer space] held up a hand.
"I come in peace," it said, adding after a long moment of further grinding, "take me to your Lizard."
Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this ...
"It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see."
[Arthur Dent speaking] "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?"
"No," said Ford ... "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people."
"Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy."
"I did," said Ford. "It is."
"So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't the people get red of the lizards?"
"It honestly doesn't occur to them," said ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want."
"You mean they actually vote for the lizards?"
"Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course."
"But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?"
"Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in."
Needless to say, the next time I'm accused of "wasting my vote" on a third party candidate who has no hope of winning, I think I'll refer the accuser to this passage. At a certain point you just have to stop voting for the lizards, don't you?
[A giant robot from outer space] held up a hand.
"I come in peace," it said, adding after a long moment of further grinding, "take me to your Lizard."
Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this ...
"It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see."
[Arthur Dent speaking] "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?"
"No," said Ford ... "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people."
"Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy."
"I did," said Ford. "It is."
"So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't the people get red of the lizards?"
"It honestly doesn't occur to them," said ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want."
"You mean they actually vote for the lizards?"
"Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course."
"But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?"
"Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in."
Needless to say, the next time I'm accused of "wasting my vote" on a third party candidate who has no hope of winning, I think I'll refer the accuser to this passage. At a certain point you just have to stop voting for the lizards, don't you?
Labels:
books,
Douglas Adams,
Hitchhiker Trilogy,
Politics,
quotations
Friday, March 4, 2011
Don't Feed the Troll
I'm sorry to do this, but I just can't hold it back. American political discourse is such a sham, people on both sides of the alleged two-sided debate believe such nonsense that sometimes I can't help but laugh at the whole thing. You know there's some kind of problem when the debates of the day concern who's crazier, Keith Olberman or Bill O'Reilly. Newsflash, America. They're both out of their minds. Neither of them (or any of their compatriots, the Rush Limbaughs, the Chris Matthewses, the Sean Hannitys) has any interest in real discourse, in trying to do anything positive for the country or the world. They just yell, call each other names, and pass it off as politics. Because, hey, that's what the people will watch on the TV.
Come to think of it, maybe that's all politics is meant to be, but we can dream of a better approach, can't we? Perhaps it's too simplistic to put it this way, but wouldn't we be better of if real people made up the meat of political discourse, and not media-magnates, corrupt politicians, or for-profit corporations? Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that what the word "Democracy" means (from the Greek, 'Demos' meaning people, and 'Kratos' meaning rule)?
Anyway, the point here isn't to gripe about our mis-defined terms (we could spend a whole post talking about how words like "liberal," "communist," "socialist," "democracy," "conservative," and "constitution" have acquired meanings very different from their actual definitions). No, the point is to go against my own advice. I'm going to feed the troll.
The troll, in this case, is a man who wrote a letter that I received from one of my right-wing relatives via email. He's one of those people who forwards five emails a day that all say "I rarely forward emails" at the top, and which contain font in at least three different sizes and at least four different colors in the body of the message. So yeah, that's a sure sign not to take anything too seriously. Except... Except the people who believe these kinds of emails win elections. Which isn't really a big deal, since at least you're putting principled crazy people (instead of the much more dangerous unprincipled sane ones) in office, but still.
This particular email is a gem, so much so that I laughed long and hard when I read it. Now, you have to recall, I am not a Democrat, and I am not a Republican. I'm an equal-opportunity critic of both parties, and, in fact, I'm probably all the more critical of the left than the right. True, I am more "left wing" than "right wing," in that I believe in social freedoms like the right for gays to marry and the right to have an abortion, but economically and politically I am aligned with neither party, and don't believe that I fit along the 2-dimensional spectrum that most of us have been fooled into thinking encompasses all of political thought.
This particular email, though, comes from the right of American politics and is a harsh "criticism," if you can call it that, of Nancy Pelosi. Now, Pelosi is about as corrupt as they come, but this fine piece takes her on in the most insane, unreasonable, and terrifyingly inaccurate ways possible. In theory, it's by a man who is a former Assistant District Attorney named Dennis Guthrie, which makes it all the more classic for reasons which will become clear. Without further ado, here's the email (in bold) with comments inserted.
Dear Ms. Pelosi:
I write to you out of utter disdain! You are as despicable and un-American as the traitor Jane Fonda.
Jane Fonda! She's so despicable and un-American that she married Ted Turner! Of course, Dennis is referring to her protest of the Vietnam and Iraq Wars and her self-described feminist ideals. But Jane Fonda isn't really the point, here. The point is that this is an absolutely ludicrous way to start a letter. "Dear Ms. Person, I hate you! You're just like this other person that I hate!" Sounds a little like a little kid, no?
I am a soon to be 65 year-old who has voted in every state and local election since 1966. I have voted for both Republicans and Democrats alike. I have worked on campaigns for both Republicans and Democrats, white and black. I served the country that I love in Vietnam, as my son did in the Middle East . I was awarded two bronze stars. I have been involved in politics since age 6 when my father was campaign manager for a truly great American Congressman, Charles Raper Jonas, who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike you.
Attempting to rebuild credibility here, because, you know, the whole Jane Fonda thing was a bit of a gamble that didn't really pay off. So we find out that Dennis is not partisan, not in the slightest. We also find out that he's not a racist - he's very careful to point out that he has worked on campaigns for both white and black people.
The real key to this credibility argument, of course, is that 6 year-old Dennis (soon to be seven?) was "involved" in politics because his father managed the campaign of Charles Raper Jonas (can we talk to his parents about that middle name?), who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike [Nancy Pelosi]. Let's talk about how tortured this sentence is. Wait, let's not. Just read it again. Non sequiturs abound! The purpose of the sentence changes no less than twice, beginning with "I've been around politics for a long time," transitioning to "Charles Raper Jonas was a good congressman," and finishing with "You're a scumbag!" Bravo, good sir.
You obviously haven't read the Constitution recently, if ever, the Federalist Papers, or even David McCullough's book on John Adams.
Oh my. Cue music... One of these things is not like the other. Let's see, key documents for a member of congress to read... 1) Constitution, check. 2) Federalist Papers, check. 3) David McCullough's book on John Adams, check? Now don't get me wrong, I'm guessing that McCullough's book is very good. He's a two-time Pulitzer winner, and John Adams is one of those winners. But that still doesn't put it in the same camp as the Constitution and the Federalist Papers, which are, you know, political treatises about the founding of the country, and not historical biographies.
Also, isn't the order wrong here? It's weird enough that he throws in the McCullough book, but it's the "even" that gets me. It's like saying "he hasn't read any Shakespeare, even Titus Andronicus," as if that's the one Shakespeare play everyone should read. I mean, I can imagine Pelosi not reading the Constitution, but David McCullough's John Adams, really now.
You ought to take the time while riding around in your government provided luxury executive jet to do just that. You represent Socialistic and even Marxist principals that our founding fathers tried to avoid when setting out the capitalistic republican form of government represented by our Constitution.
Boom. This is the best part of the whole thing, right here. For a man who is, in theory, a former Assistant AD who has read John Adams (by David McCullough) and even the Constitution (see what I did there?), this is a remarkable display of historical ignorance. Let's not even get into how non-socialist Nancy Pelosi is, and instead let's talk about Karl Marx.
Marx was not a socialist, because socialism and communism are very different, but that's not what's amazing here. No, simple chronology is the bugbear in this paragraph. Marx was born in, wait for it, 1818, and he published the Communist Manifesto in 1848. The Constitution was written, as I'm sure you know, in 1787, a full 31 years before Marx was even born. The Marxist principles the founding fathers supposedly avoided while setting up our government did not even exist - at least not in name - when the Constitution was written. Dennis, I suppose, might argue that Marxism existed in spirit, but anyone with even a passing knowledge of history knows that the late 18th century were hardly a time of powerful labor unions. Hell, when the Constitution was penned the French Revolution hadn't even happened yet. Indeed, the closest thing (and they weren't particularly close) in the entire world to communism in 1787 was - you guessed it - the American colonies. Well done, Mr. Guthrie.
We're not done with this yet, either, because Dennis lets us know that, in addition to predicting the invention of communism in half-a-century, the founding fathers also predicted the invention of capitalism. Now, you no doubt know that Adam Smith published the Wealth of Nations in 1776, but you may not realize that he doesn't call anything "capitalism," therein. What's more, that which is capitalistic in Wealth of Nations is critiqued heavily, as Smith laments the way that trade corporations conspire to harm their customers. Like Machiavelli's Prince, Wealth of Nations is historically misunderstood as advocating for a certain system, whereas the works themselves are more descriptive than proscriptive.
In this particular case, Wealth of Nations has little to no bearing on the Constitution (indeed, it's unlikely that many of the founding fathers had even read the book by the time the Constitution was ratified), and the word "capitalism" or the concepts associated therewith even less. Capitalism, as a term, didn't really come around until after Marx's own descriptive work, Capital, popularized the concept. The founding fathers, needless to say, weren't particularly concerned with the economic system of the United States, because there weren't really competing theories at the time, and because the Constitution was meant to be a political and governmental user's manual.
The moral of the story? Before you spout off nonsense about the founding fathers and their motivations, try reading the Federalist Papers and the Constitution first (bazing!). You'll find the words "capitalist," "Marxist," and "socialist" absent.
I find it interesting that you and your husband are multi-millionaires with much of your fortune being made as a result of your "public service". You have controlled legislation that has enhanced your husband's investments both on and off shore. At the same time you redistributed the wealth of others. Our system of a free market economy is being destroyed by the likes of you, Harry Reid, and now our President. You ride around in a Gulfstream airplane at the tax payer's expense while criticizing the presidents of companies who produced something for the economy. You add nothing to the economy of the United States , you only subtract therefrom.
Ok, the Gulfstream thing is one of those wonderfully false Internet rumors that floats around. You know, like Barrack Obama being a Muslim born on Neptune who's secretly collaborating with the Cylons in preparation for their invasion. As for the rest of it, well, I don't really know anything about Pelosi's husband, but I do know that, by the nature of the congress, Pelosi "controlled" nothing. It's the classic "Great Man" or, in this case, "Great Woman" theory of politics rearing its ugly head again. The idea that any one person is responsible for legislation of any kind is absurd, given the several hundred members of congress and the several thousand staffers, lobyists, corporate donors, special interest groups, and so on that make the country go. To say that Pelosi "redistributed the wealth of others" is more than a bit of an exaggeration.
As for our free market economy being destroyed, well, I'd argue that Nancy Pelosi is only a small part of that picture as well. Even if we agree that a pure free market works, I would argue that what we have now is a kind of reverse-socialism. That is, common people are taxed so that our money can be given to huge corporations (which pay no tax at all) in the form of bailouts and subsidies. Is Pelosi a part of that? Yes, but only because all elected politicians - in order to be elected - almost have to be corrupt. With the Supreme Court ruling last year that Corporations can give unlimited, anonymous funds to political campaigns, it is nearly impossible to find a congressperson or senator who has not been bought and sold already.
Blaming Pelosi (or any single congressperson) for that is a bit much. Really, the blame rests with no one person, but the willful ignorance of the American people - who refuse to see that their country is not, in fact, run by their elected representatives - is a major part of the problem. It's no wonder that we've begun to cycle wildly - the people elect Democrats, find them unresponsive, and then elect Republicans, only to find them equally unresponsive, and so on.
Anyway, bring us home, Dennis baby, with some personal attacks.
I would like to suggest that you return to the city of fruitcakes and nuts and eat your husband's canned tuna and pineapple produced by illegal immigrants and by workers who have been excluded from the protection that 90% of the legal workers in the United States have.
Another meandering sentence-with-many-meanings. To wit:
1) San Francisco has gay people in it, and is thus morally reprehensible (unlike my state of North Carolina, where everyone is straight, white, male, and Christian; at least everyone worth mentioning).
2) Eat some canned tuna and pineapple, bitch! Seriously, is this some kind of innuendo I don't know about? "I'm taking my talents to South Beach, where I'll be eating my husband's canned tuna (wink wink)."
3) Damn Mexicans, how dare they try to make a better life for themselves!
4) Honestly, I'm not sure what Dennis is getting at here. Is he saying that illegal immigrants deserve protection? Or is he saying that illegal immigrants are robbing other Americans of legal protections? Or what? Whatever his point, he's sure worked up about it.
I await your defeat in the next election with glee.
I suppose this means, while he waits for Pelosi to lose in the next election he'll be watching a lot of Glee, starring Lea Michele, Jane Lynch, and Matthew Morrison. I haven't seen the show, but I hear it's very popular.
Don't ever use the term "un-American" again for protesters who love this country and are exercising their rights upon which this country was founded. By the way, while I served in the Army, I was spit on by the same type of lunatics who support you and who you probably supported in the 60's and 70's. You are an embarrassment to all of us who served so that you would have the protected right of free speech to call us un-American. But at the same time, I have the right to write you, to notify you, that I consider you to be un-American, as do the majority of the people of this formerly great country. You are a true disgrace to most of the people who served this country by offering themselves for public service in the United States Congress.
Just when you thought we were done, Dennis pulls out the classic "and another thing" on us. The best part here is that he criticizes Pelosi for calling town-hall protesters "un-American," and then proceeds to criticize anti-war protesters for the exact same thing. Does the irony know no bounds? I mean, let me make Dennis's argument in this paragraph clear:
1) You can't criticize people for protesting because that's the 1st amendment. They have a right to do it.
2) How dare those protesters in the 60s and 70s rally against the Vietnam War! That's un-American. They shouldn't have a right to do that!
3) I, however, have a right to free speech, which is why I'm writing you this letter. I'm a little confused about what I'm saying, but that's ok, because I can always wrap it up with:
4) You're a scumbag!
Also, let's talk about this "formerly great country" bit. What does that mean? Are we talking about the 80s? I'm guessing not, because there was even more hand-wringing then than there is now. No, I'm guessing Dennis means the 1950s, back when black people and white people couldn't eat in the same restaurants, back when women weren't allowed to have jobs in science, technology, or mathematics, back when gay men and women were liable to be beat up or killed if people found out about them, back when people lived in constant fear of nuclear war with the USSR... Don't get me wrong, I don't mean to say the past was awful - rather, it was like any other time, filled with good and bad, filled with justice and injustice, filled with love and hatred. Humanity is complicated, history is complicated, and the sooner we acknowledge that the sooner we can start having real conversations instead of just yelling at each other.
I feel certain your aides will not share this letter with you, but I intend to share it with many.
Cue passive-aggressive one-liner... And we're done.
Sincerely,
Dennis L. Guthrie
In the end, you have to love the "Sincerely," don't you?
OK, I know what you're thinking: "But Paul, isn't what you're doing here exactly what Dennis is guilty of?" Yes, and no. The purpose of doing this is, in part, the fun of it (I read too much Fire Joe Morgan back before it went silent). But more importantly, the purpose is to show that there's a wrong way to have political discourse, and that this wrong way is all-too-prominent. Dennis Guthrie, believe it or not, means well. It's just, he doesn't know how to have a conversation, how to engage in a dialogue. He's become a part of a political discourse that's all rage and anger and hatred - from Democrats and Republicans alike - and that will not get anyone anywhere.
Come to think of it, maybe that's all politics is meant to be, but we can dream of a better approach, can't we? Perhaps it's too simplistic to put it this way, but wouldn't we be better of if real people made up the meat of political discourse, and not media-magnates, corrupt politicians, or for-profit corporations? Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that what the word "Democracy" means (from the Greek, 'Demos' meaning people, and 'Kratos' meaning rule)?
Anyway, the point here isn't to gripe about our mis-defined terms (we could spend a whole post talking about how words like "liberal," "communist," "socialist," "democracy," "conservative," and "constitution" have acquired meanings very different from their actual definitions). No, the point is to go against my own advice. I'm going to feed the troll.
The troll, in this case, is a man who wrote a letter that I received from one of my right-wing relatives via email. He's one of those people who forwards five emails a day that all say "I rarely forward emails" at the top, and which contain font in at least three different sizes and at least four different colors in the body of the message. So yeah, that's a sure sign not to take anything too seriously. Except... Except the people who believe these kinds of emails win elections. Which isn't really a big deal, since at least you're putting principled crazy people (instead of the much more dangerous unprincipled sane ones) in office, but still.
This particular email is a gem, so much so that I laughed long and hard when I read it. Now, you have to recall, I am not a Democrat, and I am not a Republican. I'm an equal-opportunity critic of both parties, and, in fact, I'm probably all the more critical of the left than the right. True, I am more "left wing" than "right wing," in that I believe in social freedoms like the right for gays to marry and the right to have an abortion, but economically and politically I am aligned with neither party, and don't believe that I fit along the 2-dimensional spectrum that most of us have been fooled into thinking encompasses all of political thought.
This particular email, though, comes from the right of American politics and is a harsh "criticism," if you can call it that, of Nancy Pelosi. Now, Pelosi is about as corrupt as they come, but this fine piece takes her on in the most insane, unreasonable, and terrifyingly inaccurate ways possible. In theory, it's by a man who is a former Assistant District Attorney named Dennis Guthrie, which makes it all the more classic for reasons which will become clear. Without further ado, here's the email (in bold) with comments inserted.
Dear Ms. Pelosi:
I write to you out of utter disdain! You are as despicable and un-American as the traitor Jane Fonda.
Jane Fonda! She's so despicable and un-American that she married Ted Turner! Of course, Dennis is referring to her protest of the Vietnam and Iraq Wars and her self-described feminist ideals. But Jane Fonda isn't really the point, here. The point is that this is an absolutely ludicrous way to start a letter. "Dear Ms. Person, I hate you! You're just like this other person that I hate!" Sounds a little like a little kid, no?
I am a soon to be 65 year-old who has voted in every state and local election since 1966. I have voted for both Republicans and Democrats alike. I have worked on campaigns for both Republicans and Democrats, white and black. I served the country that I love in Vietnam, as my son did in the Middle East . I was awarded two bronze stars. I have been involved in politics since age 6 when my father was campaign manager for a truly great American Congressman, Charles Raper Jonas, who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike you.
Attempting to rebuild credibility here, because, you know, the whole Jane Fonda thing was a bit of a gamble that didn't really pay off. So we find out that Dennis is not partisan, not in the slightest. We also find out that he's not a racist - he's very careful to point out that he has worked on campaigns for both white and black people.
The real key to this credibility argument, of course, is that 6 year-old Dennis (soon to be seven?) was "involved" in politics because his father managed the campaign of Charles Raper Jonas (can we talk to his parents about that middle name?), who worked for his constituents and his country, and was to be admired, unlike [Nancy Pelosi]. Let's talk about how tortured this sentence is. Wait, let's not. Just read it again. Non sequiturs abound! The purpose of the sentence changes no less than twice, beginning with "I've been around politics for a long time," transitioning to "Charles Raper Jonas was a good congressman," and finishing with "You're a scumbag!" Bravo, good sir.
You obviously haven't read the Constitution recently, if ever, the Federalist Papers, or even David McCullough's book on John Adams.
Oh my. Cue music... One of these things is not like the other. Let's see, key documents for a member of congress to read... 1) Constitution, check. 2) Federalist Papers, check. 3) David McCullough's book on John Adams, check? Now don't get me wrong, I'm guessing that McCullough's book is very good. He's a two-time Pulitzer winner, and John Adams is one of those winners. But that still doesn't put it in the same camp as the Constitution and the Federalist Papers, which are, you know, political treatises about the founding of the country, and not historical biographies.
Also, isn't the order wrong here? It's weird enough that he throws in the McCullough book, but it's the "even" that gets me. It's like saying "he hasn't read any Shakespeare, even Titus Andronicus," as if that's the one Shakespeare play everyone should read. I mean, I can imagine Pelosi not reading the Constitution, but David McCullough's John Adams, really now.
You ought to take the time while riding around in your government provided luxury executive jet to do just that. You represent Socialistic and even Marxist principals that our founding fathers tried to avoid when setting out the capitalistic republican form of government represented by our Constitution.
Boom. This is the best part of the whole thing, right here. For a man who is, in theory, a former Assistant AD who has read John Adams (by David McCullough) and even the Constitution (see what I did there?), this is a remarkable display of historical ignorance. Let's not even get into how non-socialist Nancy Pelosi is, and instead let's talk about Karl Marx.
Marx was not a socialist, because socialism and communism are very different, but that's not what's amazing here. No, simple chronology is the bugbear in this paragraph. Marx was born in, wait for it, 1818, and he published the Communist Manifesto in 1848. The Constitution was written, as I'm sure you know, in 1787, a full 31 years before Marx was even born. The Marxist principles the founding fathers supposedly avoided while setting up our government did not even exist - at least not in name - when the Constitution was written. Dennis, I suppose, might argue that Marxism existed in spirit, but anyone with even a passing knowledge of history knows that the late 18th century were hardly a time of powerful labor unions. Hell, when the Constitution was penned the French Revolution hadn't even happened yet. Indeed, the closest thing (and they weren't particularly close) in the entire world to communism in 1787 was - you guessed it - the American colonies. Well done, Mr. Guthrie.
We're not done with this yet, either, because Dennis lets us know that, in addition to predicting the invention of communism in half-a-century, the founding fathers also predicted the invention of capitalism. Now, you no doubt know that Adam Smith published the Wealth of Nations in 1776, but you may not realize that he doesn't call anything "capitalism," therein. What's more, that which is capitalistic in Wealth of Nations is critiqued heavily, as Smith laments the way that trade corporations conspire to harm their customers. Like Machiavelli's Prince, Wealth of Nations is historically misunderstood as advocating for a certain system, whereas the works themselves are more descriptive than proscriptive.
In this particular case, Wealth of Nations has little to no bearing on the Constitution (indeed, it's unlikely that many of the founding fathers had even read the book by the time the Constitution was ratified), and the word "capitalism" or the concepts associated therewith even less. Capitalism, as a term, didn't really come around until after Marx's own descriptive work, Capital, popularized the concept. The founding fathers, needless to say, weren't particularly concerned with the economic system of the United States, because there weren't really competing theories at the time, and because the Constitution was meant to be a political and governmental user's manual.
The moral of the story? Before you spout off nonsense about the founding fathers and their motivations, try reading the Federalist Papers and the Constitution first (bazing!). You'll find the words "capitalist," "Marxist," and "socialist" absent.
I find it interesting that you and your husband are multi-millionaires with much of your fortune being made as a result of your "public service". You have controlled legislation that has enhanced your husband's investments both on and off shore. At the same time you redistributed the wealth of others. Our system of a free market economy is being destroyed by the likes of you, Harry Reid, and now our President. You ride around in a Gulfstream airplane at the tax payer's expense while criticizing the presidents of companies who produced something for the economy. You add nothing to the economy of the United States , you only subtract therefrom.
Ok, the Gulfstream thing is one of those wonderfully false Internet rumors that floats around. You know, like Barrack Obama being a Muslim born on Neptune who's secretly collaborating with the Cylons in preparation for their invasion. As for the rest of it, well, I don't really know anything about Pelosi's husband, but I do know that, by the nature of the congress, Pelosi "controlled" nothing. It's the classic "Great Man" or, in this case, "Great Woman" theory of politics rearing its ugly head again. The idea that any one person is responsible for legislation of any kind is absurd, given the several hundred members of congress and the several thousand staffers, lobyists, corporate donors, special interest groups, and so on that make the country go. To say that Pelosi "redistributed the wealth of others" is more than a bit of an exaggeration.
As for our free market economy being destroyed, well, I'd argue that Nancy Pelosi is only a small part of that picture as well. Even if we agree that a pure free market works, I would argue that what we have now is a kind of reverse-socialism. That is, common people are taxed so that our money can be given to huge corporations (which pay no tax at all) in the form of bailouts and subsidies. Is Pelosi a part of that? Yes, but only because all elected politicians - in order to be elected - almost have to be corrupt. With the Supreme Court ruling last year that Corporations can give unlimited, anonymous funds to political campaigns, it is nearly impossible to find a congressperson or senator who has not been bought and sold already.
Blaming Pelosi (or any single congressperson) for that is a bit much. Really, the blame rests with no one person, but the willful ignorance of the American people - who refuse to see that their country is not, in fact, run by their elected representatives - is a major part of the problem. It's no wonder that we've begun to cycle wildly - the people elect Democrats, find them unresponsive, and then elect Republicans, only to find them equally unresponsive, and so on.
Anyway, bring us home, Dennis baby, with some personal attacks.
I would like to suggest that you return to the city of fruitcakes and nuts and eat your husband's canned tuna and pineapple produced by illegal immigrants and by workers who have been excluded from the protection that 90% of the legal workers in the United States have.
Another meandering sentence-with-many-meanings. To wit:
1) San Francisco has gay people in it, and is thus morally reprehensible (unlike my state of North Carolina, where everyone is straight, white, male, and Christian; at least everyone worth mentioning).
2) Eat some canned tuna and pineapple, bitch! Seriously, is this some kind of innuendo I don't know about? "I'm taking my talents to South Beach, where I'll be eating my husband's canned tuna (wink wink)."
3) Damn Mexicans, how dare they try to make a better life for themselves!
4) Honestly, I'm not sure what Dennis is getting at here. Is he saying that illegal immigrants deserve protection? Or is he saying that illegal immigrants are robbing other Americans of legal protections? Or what? Whatever his point, he's sure worked up about it.
I await your defeat in the next election with glee.
I suppose this means, while he waits for Pelosi to lose in the next election he'll be watching a lot of Glee, starring Lea Michele, Jane Lynch, and Matthew Morrison. I haven't seen the show, but I hear it's very popular.
Don't ever use the term "un-American" again for protesters who love this country and are exercising their rights upon which this country was founded. By the way, while I served in the Army, I was spit on by the same type of lunatics who support you and who you probably supported in the 60's and 70's. You are an embarrassment to all of us who served so that you would have the protected right of free speech to call us un-American. But at the same time, I have the right to write you, to notify you, that I consider you to be un-American, as do the majority of the people of this formerly great country. You are a true disgrace to most of the people who served this country by offering themselves for public service in the United States Congress.
Just when you thought we were done, Dennis pulls out the classic "and another thing" on us. The best part here is that he criticizes Pelosi for calling town-hall protesters "un-American," and then proceeds to criticize anti-war protesters for the exact same thing. Does the irony know no bounds? I mean, let me make Dennis's argument in this paragraph clear:
1) You can't criticize people for protesting because that's the 1st amendment. They have a right to do it.
2) How dare those protesters in the 60s and 70s rally against the Vietnam War! That's un-American. They shouldn't have a right to do that!
3) I, however, have a right to free speech, which is why I'm writing you this letter. I'm a little confused about what I'm saying, but that's ok, because I can always wrap it up with:
4) You're a scumbag!
Also, let's talk about this "formerly great country" bit. What does that mean? Are we talking about the 80s? I'm guessing not, because there was even more hand-wringing then than there is now. No, I'm guessing Dennis means the 1950s, back when black people and white people couldn't eat in the same restaurants, back when women weren't allowed to have jobs in science, technology, or mathematics, back when gay men and women were liable to be beat up or killed if people found out about them, back when people lived in constant fear of nuclear war with the USSR... Don't get me wrong, I don't mean to say the past was awful - rather, it was like any other time, filled with good and bad, filled with justice and injustice, filled with love and hatred. Humanity is complicated, history is complicated, and the sooner we acknowledge that the sooner we can start having real conversations instead of just yelling at each other.
I feel certain your aides will not share this letter with you, but I intend to share it with many.
Cue passive-aggressive one-liner... And we're done.
Sincerely,
Dennis L. Guthrie
In the end, you have to love the "Sincerely," don't you?
OK, I know what you're thinking: "But Paul, isn't what you're doing here exactly what Dennis is guilty of?" Yes, and no. The purpose of doing this is, in part, the fun of it (I read too much Fire Joe Morgan back before it went silent). But more importantly, the purpose is to show that there's a wrong way to have political discourse, and that this wrong way is all-too-prominent. Dennis Guthrie, believe it or not, means well. It's just, he doesn't know how to have a conversation, how to engage in a dialogue. He's become a part of a political discourse that's all rage and anger and hatred - from Democrats and Republicans alike - and that will not get anyone anywhere.
Friday, December 31, 2010
The Status of Meaning and Truth in the 21st Century
Philosophers, poets, and lawyers throughout history have argued over what constitutes the truth. Or the Truth. Or the "Truth." You see, it's one of those words that changes its meaning based upon whether or not the first letter is capitalized or not, and some people are liable to accompany the sound with air quotations whenever possible. The reason? Truth is a complicated concept, an ideal that, nevertheless, seems to have some bearing on the real world. Truth is a thing most people think it is worth striving towards, and yet, it's also a thing that's incredibly difficult to actually find.
You could say the same things, pretty much, about "meaning," except that it rarely gets capitalized. The search for truth and the search for meaning are in many ways related, though in our modern parlance the latter seems to have replaced the former, as we've come into contact with more and more disparate ideas about what truth might be. As Truth (with a capital T) has lost its luster - as fewer and fewer people believe there is such a thing - more and more people are content to find meaning, knowing that truth - if it even exists - is probably not worth the effort.
In our modern age, what with Wikipedia, Twitter, email, and smart phones, it seems to me that the status of meaning and truth are changing in our society. That is not to say that truth itself is changing - if, again, there is such a thing - or that meaning is becoming harder (or easier) to find. No, what it means is that the status of those concepts and the way we use those words is changing in a way that is uncommon. Hegel has it that human history is effectively a long series of reversals in the status of meaning and truth resulting in socio-political and spiritual transformations leading humanity towards a brighter and eventually perfect future. I'm not sure I buy all of that, but part of it is fair: we, as a society (or a society of societies) are constantly redefining our purposes and goals.
That is not to say there's not a great deal of constancy in human pursuits. It would be foolish to ignore, in spite of all the radical differences between modern computer-happy man and a hunter-gatherer, the many similarities. Sure, our conflicts and desires are more sophisticated and/or fetishized than they once were, but they are still more or less the same. We still want to eat food and drink water, we still want to sleep safely, and - perhaps most important - we still are subject to strong reproductive urges that a cynic might say dictate somewhere between 90 and 100 percent of our actions. In some ways, things never change.
Ah, but what does change is understanding. Understanding is not truth, of course, nor is it necessarily meaning. Rather, understanding is a very human attempt to put construct something sensible around the chaotic mess that is the world we experience every day. Hegel would argue that, just as an individual has understanding, so too does a society as a whole. And even if Hegel wouldn't argue that, I will. From an anthropological perspective, we might just call that social understanding a "culture." That is, we establish expectations and shared experiences that are so ingrained into our world-view that generally we don't even believe that things could be any different.
Consider, as a simple (and classic) example, standard American elevator behavior. We stand, facing the door, head and hands down, quietly. Most of us engage in this socially expected behavior without even thinking about it. There are, however, examples of more consequence as well. Things like facial expressions, gestures, and intonation when we ask a question versus when we make a statement are vital to our conceptions of meaning, but yet go largely unexamined except by a select group of social scientists (who, it should be added, are mostly ridiculed). Even more important are our shared assumptions about morality and practicality, assumptions which spill over into political and religious beliefs. Indeed, perhaps the biggest reason why our political and religious disagreements tend to be so violent and irrational is because our beliefs in those areas are cultural and not rational; that is, they come from an understanding of the world that is vestigial, subtly inherited from the world we live in.
Despite those ingrained assumptions about everything from how to shake hands to how to argue about elections, it remains the case that things do change. I am not persuaded that human beings are purely rational creatures, but it does seem to me that reason and assumption dance with each other in a complex tango, leading to refined and re-defined understandings, which in turn change the possibilities for how we understand things like meaning and truth. An optimist, like Hegel, might call this process evolutionary, pushing humanity towards further refinement and perfection, while a pessimist might call it corruption. But regardless, there is change.
So where do we stand, in the year 2011, with regards to meaning and truth? Well, certainly we have destroyed "Capital T" truth. Our social reality is such that it's impossible for any reasonable person to argue that anyone in particular has access to the Truth, and while that doesn't mean there isn't one, it does mean that determining what it is is impossible. Faith still exists, of course, and a reasonable person might very well acknowledge that it is not intellectually inconsistent to have faith in a given system of truth - whether that be scientific, religious, political, or otherwise - but then again, while faith itself is not intellectually dishonest, faith without acknowledging the possibility that it is misguided probably is. Indeed, I, for one, take a very cynical view of religious strife: it seems to me like the insecurity of a bully, who will say he believes in his strength, but who secretly understands that he is not, necessarily, the strongest guy there is. So too the religious fanatic: the more fanatical, the less certain, fundamentally, he is about his faith.
"Truth," then, has become a kind of rallying call for the refusal to consider another person's perspective. "You have your facts, and I have mine," is a refrain you have likely heard. Ironically, while this means that the status of truth is undoubtedly in question, it does nothing to undermine the philosopher's ideal that Truth is worth trying to uncover. That people refuse to converse with each other and consider alternative opinions is perhaps the best indication not that there is no truth, but rather that no one is particularly working hard enough to get to it. A tutor of mine at St. John's was fond of saying that perhaps the Truth is very, very, very, very, very hard to get to, while even the most devoted lover of wisdom is only willing to work very, very hard to get there. It seems to me that Truth, if there is such a thing, is something right now we're not even willing to work hard for. If it's not on Wikipedia, it's not worth knowing. Of course, that assumes that Truth is knowledge, when it might be that Truth is, in fact, a way of thinking or a way of being.
Now that we're getting Taoist about things, I think it's time to dive into the deeper linguistic issues that are at play here. The biggest problem with Truth is not its distance or the difficulty of the search to find it, but rather its ambiguous metaphysical status. What do we mean by truth? This is why meaning is so important, and why Wittgenstein was such a crazy person.
Meaning, generally, refers to the desire we have for our lives not to be a miserable waste of time. But beyond the personal meaning we also use meaning to denote, well, what things mean. You see, the problem with talking about meaning is that it tends to be a circular conversation. Meaning is the truth of a thing, truth is the meaning of a thing, and so on. In the end, a lot of words spew out, but we don't get anywhere. Again, read Wittgenstein and you'll see what I'm talking about.
So, rather than trying to define meaning, let's talk about the status of meaning in 2011. Meaning is, in short, becoming more and more individualized, whilst simultaneously becoming more and more standardized. That is, modern technology is making a kind of paradox that even Husserl in his worst nightmares could never have imagined. Increasingly, we are encouraged to define and express our own meaning; we live in a knowledge producing, and not knowledge consuming culture (I am as guilty as this as anyone, seeing as I write a blog with very few readers, but read very few blogs myself). We are all shouting in a crowded room with our Twitter accounts and Facebook status updates. We, in short, are given a lot of leeway to define and understand what meaning means to us.
That's hardly a bad thing; indeed, more opinions and ideas is probably more likely to lead us to, if not truth, at least somewhere interesting than fewer opinions and ideas. No, the troubling part is that the variety of opinions and ideas - the individuality - we honor so much is essentially an illusion. We like, in our culture, to believe that the message and the medium are different, that the content and the form of a thing are only incidentally related. I think that's foolish. While we all have the freedom to individually express ourselves, that our media are so constricted means that the possibilities for our opinions are similarly constricted. Twitter may allow for a huge range of expressions of meaning, for example, but how huge, really? Is there not a limit to what you can say in fewer than 200 characters?
Similarly the blog, which allows for imbedding videos or songs or pictures, and thus can do things that writing alone could never do. Nevertheless, it's still limited, it's still restricting in ways that I can't express or imagine. Of course, you might argue that this has always been true, and you'd be right to do so. Humanity has never - or rarely, anyway - been able to imagine expressing meaning in ways that reach beyond the restrictions of whatever the contemporary media may be. But the danger we get into, now, that we haven't in the past, is the assumption that things are supposed to be the way they are, that modern structures are inherently good because they are modern.
Take one of my favorite examples: politics. While major parties have always been more powerful than minor ones (hence, major parties), it used to be that people found it possible to believe that neither of the two major parties were adequate expressions of their understanding of the meaning of a democratic nation. In such cases, significant - sometimes in the 20 percent range - swatches of the population voted for third parties. Now, however, we have narrowed the spectrum so far that we refuse to believe that something outside of that spectrum could possibly make sense. Voting for a third party is practically a mark of insanity, which only goes to show how dangerous constricting the form (the parties) and not the content (actual issues) can really be.
We might do this with political systems, as well. Regardless of political affiliation, it's generally considered nonsensical to believe in any kind of government but a Democratic Republic, if you live in the USA. Indeed, you have to support not just a Democratic Republic, but specifically the archaic American Constitution. It's not that we can't argue for other systems; it's that we can't even conceive of those systems.
If such is the case in something as simple as politics, imagine how much more pernicious the result of this artificial constriction of meaning is in spirituality, or music, or philosophy, or emotion. Now I'm not arguing that there should be no systems at all, or that it would be better if we had completely unchecked emotional expression (because, hey, hello murders everywhere). No, the point is that we have artificially limiting systems that people don't realize are artificial and limiting. That, again, has always been true, but never at the scale - and thus with the homogeneity - that we have now. The process of defining meaning (though not meaning itself), principally because anyone can share theirs with anyone else, is in danger of becoming homogenized. And anytime processes become homogeneous, it seems to me, you see stagnation.
Ironically - paradoxically even - we live in a time where meaning is exploding, but where the processes behind meaning are atrophied. This is a crisis much more poignant than Husserl's fear that science would destroy meaning altogether. Rather than the broad, soul-crushing forces of an Orwellian totalitarian world, we're trending towards a Brave New World in which we share a wonderful illusion of freedom, meaning, truth, and beauty. What Huxley missed, however, was that you need not restrict access to ideas or thoughts or even processes: you need only provide systems that are sufficiently limiting in form, but boundless in content. Given the proper impetus, people will restrict themselves willingly.
The status of meaning and truth in the 21st Century? Perilous, but expansive. Paradoxically healthier and sicker than ever. But that should come as no surprise. The truth of the matter is, complexity and paradox have always been present in human experience, its just that we avoid acknowledging it. Now we live in a time where refusal to acknowledge paradox is much more dangerous than it ever has been, whilst the opportunity to benefit from acknowledging paradox is larger than ever. Color me pessimistic, of course, but hopeful.
You could say the same things, pretty much, about "meaning," except that it rarely gets capitalized. The search for truth and the search for meaning are in many ways related, though in our modern parlance the latter seems to have replaced the former, as we've come into contact with more and more disparate ideas about what truth might be. As Truth (with a capital T) has lost its luster - as fewer and fewer people believe there is such a thing - more and more people are content to find meaning, knowing that truth - if it even exists - is probably not worth the effort.
In our modern age, what with Wikipedia, Twitter, email, and smart phones, it seems to me that the status of meaning and truth are changing in our society. That is not to say that truth itself is changing - if, again, there is such a thing - or that meaning is becoming harder (or easier) to find. No, what it means is that the status of those concepts and the way we use those words is changing in a way that is uncommon. Hegel has it that human history is effectively a long series of reversals in the status of meaning and truth resulting in socio-political and spiritual transformations leading humanity towards a brighter and eventually perfect future. I'm not sure I buy all of that, but part of it is fair: we, as a society (or a society of societies) are constantly redefining our purposes and goals.
That is not to say there's not a great deal of constancy in human pursuits. It would be foolish to ignore, in spite of all the radical differences between modern computer-happy man and a hunter-gatherer, the many similarities. Sure, our conflicts and desires are more sophisticated and/or fetishized than they once were, but they are still more or less the same. We still want to eat food and drink water, we still want to sleep safely, and - perhaps most important - we still are subject to strong reproductive urges that a cynic might say dictate somewhere between 90 and 100 percent of our actions. In some ways, things never change.
Ah, but what does change is understanding. Understanding is not truth, of course, nor is it necessarily meaning. Rather, understanding is a very human attempt to put construct something sensible around the chaotic mess that is the world we experience every day. Hegel would argue that, just as an individual has understanding, so too does a society as a whole. And even if Hegel wouldn't argue that, I will. From an anthropological perspective, we might just call that social understanding a "culture." That is, we establish expectations and shared experiences that are so ingrained into our world-view that generally we don't even believe that things could be any different.
Consider, as a simple (and classic) example, standard American elevator behavior. We stand, facing the door, head and hands down, quietly. Most of us engage in this socially expected behavior without even thinking about it. There are, however, examples of more consequence as well. Things like facial expressions, gestures, and intonation when we ask a question versus when we make a statement are vital to our conceptions of meaning, but yet go largely unexamined except by a select group of social scientists (who, it should be added, are mostly ridiculed). Even more important are our shared assumptions about morality and practicality, assumptions which spill over into political and religious beliefs. Indeed, perhaps the biggest reason why our political and religious disagreements tend to be so violent and irrational is because our beliefs in those areas are cultural and not rational; that is, they come from an understanding of the world that is vestigial, subtly inherited from the world we live in.
Despite those ingrained assumptions about everything from how to shake hands to how to argue about elections, it remains the case that things do change. I am not persuaded that human beings are purely rational creatures, but it does seem to me that reason and assumption dance with each other in a complex tango, leading to refined and re-defined understandings, which in turn change the possibilities for how we understand things like meaning and truth. An optimist, like Hegel, might call this process evolutionary, pushing humanity towards further refinement and perfection, while a pessimist might call it corruption. But regardless, there is change.
So where do we stand, in the year 2011, with regards to meaning and truth? Well, certainly we have destroyed "Capital T" truth. Our social reality is such that it's impossible for any reasonable person to argue that anyone in particular has access to the Truth, and while that doesn't mean there isn't one, it does mean that determining what it is is impossible. Faith still exists, of course, and a reasonable person might very well acknowledge that it is not intellectually inconsistent to have faith in a given system of truth - whether that be scientific, religious, political, or otherwise - but then again, while faith itself is not intellectually dishonest, faith without acknowledging the possibility that it is misguided probably is. Indeed, I, for one, take a very cynical view of religious strife: it seems to me like the insecurity of a bully, who will say he believes in his strength, but who secretly understands that he is not, necessarily, the strongest guy there is. So too the religious fanatic: the more fanatical, the less certain, fundamentally, he is about his faith.
"Truth," then, has become a kind of rallying call for the refusal to consider another person's perspective. "You have your facts, and I have mine," is a refrain you have likely heard. Ironically, while this means that the status of truth is undoubtedly in question, it does nothing to undermine the philosopher's ideal that Truth is worth trying to uncover. That people refuse to converse with each other and consider alternative opinions is perhaps the best indication not that there is no truth, but rather that no one is particularly working hard enough to get to it. A tutor of mine at St. John's was fond of saying that perhaps the Truth is very, very, very, very, very hard to get to, while even the most devoted lover of wisdom is only willing to work very, very hard to get there. It seems to me that Truth, if there is such a thing, is something right now we're not even willing to work hard for. If it's not on Wikipedia, it's not worth knowing. Of course, that assumes that Truth is knowledge, when it might be that Truth is, in fact, a way of thinking or a way of being.
Now that we're getting Taoist about things, I think it's time to dive into the deeper linguistic issues that are at play here. The biggest problem with Truth is not its distance or the difficulty of the search to find it, but rather its ambiguous metaphysical status. What do we mean by truth? This is why meaning is so important, and why Wittgenstein was such a crazy person.
Meaning, generally, refers to the desire we have for our lives not to be a miserable waste of time. But beyond the personal meaning we also use meaning to denote, well, what things mean. You see, the problem with talking about meaning is that it tends to be a circular conversation. Meaning is the truth of a thing, truth is the meaning of a thing, and so on. In the end, a lot of words spew out, but we don't get anywhere. Again, read Wittgenstein and you'll see what I'm talking about.
So, rather than trying to define meaning, let's talk about the status of meaning in 2011. Meaning is, in short, becoming more and more individualized, whilst simultaneously becoming more and more standardized. That is, modern technology is making a kind of paradox that even Husserl in his worst nightmares could never have imagined. Increasingly, we are encouraged to define and express our own meaning; we live in a knowledge producing, and not knowledge consuming culture (I am as guilty as this as anyone, seeing as I write a blog with very few readers, but read very few blogs myself). We are all shouting in a crowded room with our Twitter accounts and Facebook status updates. We, in short, are given a lot of leeway to define and understand what meaning means to us.
That's hardly a bad thing; indeed, more opinions and ideas is probably more likely to lead us to, if not truth, at least somewhere interesting than fewer opinions and ideas. No, the troubling part is that the variety of opinions and ideas - the individuality - we honor so much is essentially an illusion. We like, in our culture, to believe that the message and the medium are different, that the content and the form of a thing are only incidentally related. I think that's foolish. While we all have the freedom to individually express ourselves, that our media are so constricted means that the possibilities for our opinions are similarly constricted. Twitter may allow for a huge range of expressions of meaning, for example, but how huge, really? Is there not a limit to what you can say in fewer than 200 characters?
Similarly the blog, which allows for imbedding videos or songs or pictures, and thus can do things that writing alone could never do. Nevertheless, it's still limited, it's still restricting in ways that I can't express or imagine. Of course, you might argue that this has always been true, and you'd be right to do so. Humanity has never - or rarely, anyway - been able to imagine expressing meaning in ways that reach beyond the restrictions of whatever the contemporary media may be. But the danger we get into, now, that we haven't in the past, is the assumption that things are supposed to be the way they are, that modern structures are inherently good because they are modern.
Take one of my favorite examples: politics. While major parties have always been more powerful than minor ones (hence, major parties), it used to be that people found it possible to believe that neither of the two major parties were adequate expressions of their understanding of the meaning of a democratic nation. In such cases, significant - sometimes in the 20 percent range - swatches of the population voted for third parties. Now, however, we have narrowed the spectrum so far that we refuse to believe that something outside of that spectrum could possibly make sense. Voting for a third party is practically a mark of insanity, which only goes to show how dangerous constricting the form (the parties) and not the content (actual issues) can really be.
We might do this with political systems, as well. Regardless of political affiliation, it's generally considered nonsensical to believe in any kind of government but a Democratic Republic, if you live in the USA. Indeed, you have to support not just a Democratic Republic, but specifically the archaic American Constitution. It's not that we can't argue for other systems; it's that we can't even conceive of those systems.
If such is the case in something as simple as politics, imagine how much more pernicious the result of this artificial constriction of meaning is in spirituality, or music, or philosophy, or emotion. Now I'm not arguing that there should be no systems at all, or that it would be better if we had completely unchecked emotional expression (because, hey, hello murders everywhere). No, the point is that we have artificially limiting systems that people don't realize are artificial and limiting. That, again, has always been true, but never at the scale - and thus with the homogeneity - that we have now. The process of defining meaning (though not meaning itself), principally because anyone can share theirs with anyone else, is in danger of becoming homogenized. And anytime processes become homogeneous, it seems to me, you see stagnation.
Ironically - paradoxically even - we live in a time where meaning is exploding, but where the processes behind meaning are atrophied. This is a crisis much more poignant than Husserl's fear that science would destroy meaning altogether. Rather than the broad, soul-crushing forces of an Orwellian totalitarian world, we're trending towards a Brave New World in which we share a wonderful illusion of freedom, meaning, truth, and beauty. What Huxley missed, however, was that you need not restrict access to ideas or thoughts or even processes: you need only provide systems that are sufficiently limiting in form, but boundless in content. Given the proper impetus, people will restrict themselves willingly.
The status of meaning and truth in the 21st Century? Perilous, but expansive. Paradoxically healthier and sicker than ever. But that should come as no surprise. The truth of the matter is, complexity and paradox have always been present in human experience, its just that we avoid acknowledging it. Now we live in a time where refusal to acknowledge paradox is much more dangerous than it ever has been, whilst the opportunity to benefit from acknowledging paradox is larger than ever. Color me pessimistic, of course, but hopeful.
Labels:
culture,
Facebook,
meaning,
Paradoxes,
philosophy,
Politics,
technology,
truth,
Twitter
Sunday, October 31, 2010
Of Mice and Straw Men
If you have ever watched a television debate show (or, worse, a political advertisement), if you have read a blog, if you have listened to your crazy neighbor rant about the local football coach's stupid decisions, you've probably come in contact with a straw man or two. Even my previous post is an example of arguing against a straw man. Basically, instead of trying to explain a valid opposing opinion, the "straw man" argument-style relies on setting up a mock opponent, and then destroying that mock opponent thoroughly.
It's an extremely effective way to anger people, more than anything, because it doesn't take a lot of insight to see when someone is misrepresenting a position. For example, if a Republican wants to argue against, say, the pro-choice position, he's likely to represent not the valid, rational arguments for abortion, but rather he'll represent and take on the more emotional, ambiguous, and sometimes absurd ones (for example, he'll argue that Mr. Abortion doesn't value life, or that he's an atheist and a fascist, or that he hates America, or some such). Instead of engaging with ideas, setting up a straw man is more about taking down people by implying that they have only flimsy (at best) or immoral (at worst) arguments in their favor.
Despite how it seems, I nevertheless feel as though there is a place for the infamous straw-man style. Of course, in real conversation it's worse than useless. But sometimes it's easiest to represent a position by explaining what it is not. And sometimes it's important to persuade by a kind of rhetorical force - or to reinforce a sense of camaraderie with an audience - rather than to explore nuance. We might rightly wonder if there's not a broader social issue here, in that there might be something off-kilter in a world where persuasion by rhetoric is more important than persuasion by insight and fact, but it's hardly news that how it's said is more important than what is said.
I guess the point is, however, that the straw man argument is a mouse's argument in a lion's world. There are far subtler and more effective ways to persuade in almost any situation. Rather, it seems to me that the straw man is reserved for times when one's own emotions get in the way. For example, in my latest post I was concerned not so much with my actual audience as an imagined one, and in particular a small handful of people with whom I have recently had contact. I don't even believe that my straw-man represents their understanding of science education, but because I do believe in the position I advocate, I didn't care too much to get into the nuances of their position.
Ah, so the lesson here has something to do with remembering when and where and for whom you are writing. But it goes deeper than that. There's also a dash of the vague-but-essential "critical thinking" that has to happen here. A writer owes nothing to his audience, really. If they read, it is by choice. A reader, on the other hand, owes much to himself, and perhaps the most important part of being a reader is, in fact, not being persuaded. If we agree with the writer, how much more important to retain a sense of objectivity, so that we don't miss the real essence of the writing for its style or its seeming alignment with our own beliefs. At the very least, we ought not miss the opportunity for a conversation simply because we think we already know what the author is saying.
That's the irony, to me, of my own writing style, which is often reflective and exploratory, but more often (I suspect) polemical or persuasive. I don't actually want to persuade, and I would never want to be understood to be "certain" about things. What I write in any given post is, usually, a perspective or a position I'm trying out, something I'd like to explore and something I think my audience - limited though it is - might be interested in exploring as well.
Does that excuse straw men? Should it? I don't know. What I do know is the satisfaction in taking down an argument without having to fight is not a trivial one. No wonder there are so many arguing so loudly against positions no one really holds. No wonder, even in our seeming duopoly of a political system, neither side seems to ever actually argue with the other. No wonder debates are exchanges of monologues instead of conversations. It's just so much easier that way. It's just so much easier to be mice, hiding inside of straw men.
It's an extremely effective way to anger people, more than anything, because it doesn't take a lot of insight to see when someone is misrepresenting a position. For example, if a Republican wants to argue against, say, the pro-choice position, he's likely to represent not the valid, rational arguments for abortion, but rather he'll represent and take on the more emotional, ambiguous, and sometimes absurd ones (for example, he'll argue that Mr. Abortion doesn't value life, or that he's an atheist and a fascist, or that he hates America, or some such). Instead of engaging with ideas, setting up a straw man is more about taking down people by implying that they have only flimsy (at best) or immoral (at worst) arguments in their favor.
Despite how it seems, I nevertheless feel as though there is a place for the infamous straw-man style. Of course, in real conversation it's worse than useless. But sometimes it's easiest to represent a position by explaining what it is not. And sometimes it's important to persuade by a kind of rhetorical force - or to reinforce a sense of camaraderie with an audience - rather than to explore nuance. We might rightly wonder if there's not a broader social issue here, in that there might be something off-kilter in a world where persuasion by rhetoric is more important than persuasion by insight and fact, but it's hardly news that how it's said is more important than what is said.
I guess the point is, however, that the straw man argument is a mouse's argument in a lion's world. There are far subtler and more effective ways to persuade in almost any situation. Rather, it seems to me that the straw man is reserved for times when one's own emotions get in the way. For example, in my latest post I was concerned not so much with my actual audience as an imagined one, and in particular a small handful of people with whom I have recently had contact. I don't even believe that my straw-man represents their understanding of science education, but because I do believe in the position I advocate, I didn't care too much to get into the nuances of their position.
Ah, so the lesson here has something to do with remembering when and where and for whom you are writing. But it goes deeper than that. There's also a dash of the vague-but-essential "critical thinking" that has to happen here. A writer owes nothing to his audience, really. If they read, it is by choice. A reader, on the other hand, owes much to himself, and perhaps the most important part of being a reader is, in fact, not being persuaded. If we agree with the writer, how much more important to retain a sense of objectivity, so that we don't miss the real essence of the writing for its style or its seeming alignment with our own beliefs. At the very least, we ought not miss the opportunity for a conversation simply because we think we already know what the author is saying.
That's the irony, to me, of my own writing style, which is often reflective and exploratory, but more often (I suspect) polemical or persuasive. I don't actually want to persuade, and I would never want to be understood to be "certain" about things. What I write in any given post is, usually, a perspective or a position I'm trying out, something I'd like to explore and something I think my audience - limited though it is - might be interested in exploring as well.
Does that excuse straw men? Should it? I don't know. What I do know is the satisfaction in taking down an argument without having to fight is not a trivial one. No wonder there are so many arguing so loudly against positions no one really holds. No wonder, even in our seeming duopoly of a political system, neither side seems to ever actually argue with the other. No wonder debates are exchanges of monologues instead of conversations. It's just so much easier that way. It's just so much easier to be mice, hiding inside of straw men.
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
The Politics of Complacency
In an electoral system like ours, it's awfully easy to get caught up in voting. We make ourselves heard at the ballot box, and thereby shape, as citizens, the direction of our country. There is no need, to our minds, to do anything else. We need only decide which candidate better represents our views - and, lets face it, for most people that decision has been made well before the primaries even begin, thanks to party allegiances - show up on election day, and punch the ballot. Civic duty exercised, it's time to watch CNN, MSNBC, or Fox News (depending on who we voted for) and gloat or agonize over the results.
The notion that there might be more to politics has been lost on us. Oh sure, there are protesters and Tea Parties and so on, but those are usually anything but meaningful political activity. They're, rather, a kind of political catharsis, a release of pent up anger that channel Macbeth, "Full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." Much like the discourse on television, there is a kind of procedural extremism in most political action in the United States. It is not, in fact, the case that most "extremist" protesters actually hold views which are extremely different from the mainstream, but rather that their methods of getting those views heard are more petulant.
In some sense, this kind of protest works, but only because it fits so well into the Keith Olberman, Bill O'Reilly, Chris Matthews, and Glen Beck world of political ranting that we've grown accustomed to. There is, simply put, no outlet for reasonable conversation about politics because there is no model of reasonable discourse within politics. I suspect the reason for this is that we disagree about such trifling issues (people scream and foam at the mouth over a 3% tax hike or cut for people making over $200,000 a year?) that we're trying harder to define our differences than we are to actually persuade anyone to our position.
Because of the structures we have in place, politically, it is much, much easier to say and vote than to say and do. What, exactly, does a politically active or passionate person do? Does she run for office? Does he go to protests? Do he and she watch a lot of CNN together? None satisfies because none works. In the end, the project of political change is far too unwieldy to have any kind of accessible entry point beyond the most bland, culturally acceptable ones. That's why, I suspect, so many politically passionate young men and women voted for Barrack Obama with so much fervor in 2008: it was all they knew to do.
I don't want to get too deep into the President, but I think the way that we, as a nation, engage with our leaders culturally is telling. Consider that the recent healthcare bill has been called, by many, "Obamacare." Consider that any changes to environmental efforts or tax law or are a reflection of Obama. Consider that the same was true for Bush, for Clinton, and so on. We still have terms like "Reaganomics" from the 80s, and, going way back, "The Monroe Doctrine."
There's a great passage from Douglas Adams's Hitchiker's Guide series that comes to mind:
"It might not even have made much difference to them if they'd known exactly how much power the President of the Galaxy actually wielded: none at all. Only six people in the Galaxy knew that the job of the Galactic President was not to wield power but to attract attention away from it. Zaphod Beeblebrox was amazingly good at his job."
I don't think I'd go quite that far in American politics, but the point is that Obama doesn't have half the power that we attribute to him. To his supporters (and detractors), Barrack Obama isn't even a person; he's a symbol of all that is good (or evil), an embodiment of their hopes and dreams. Indeed, the need to have a single word to connote one's political perspective (the word: Obama) is so strong, that it might not make much of a difference to them if they knew exactly how much power the President of United States actually wields.
It is because we idolize so easily that the election of a President of roughly our ideology turns us into compliant supplicants while the election of a member of the opposing party turns us into ravenous wolves. Consider that Bush's presidency saw protest over protest, about the wars, about the environment, about almost everything. Consider that Obama's presidency has seen a disappearance of anti-war rallies, but a sudden surge of right-wing Tea Parites. The irony, of course, is that the wars continue and the environmental law doesn't change in any meaningful way. Likewise, under Bush, the kinds of issues the Tea Party people are so upset about were being largely ignored or even flaunted, but the illusion that the President represented their interests was enough to keep them docile.
Perhaps this is a broken record, but whenever I am exposed to political discourse, or what passes for it, either because I happen by a television or get an email or read an article online, I cannot help but notice how outrageously narrow the debate is. Complacency is assured in the majority when being politically active means being rabid and passionate to the point of violence about things that we don't care that much about. Complacency is assured when we have a symbol, an idol that we can look to and say, "Everything is all right, our guy is in the White House." Complacency is assured when voting always carries the promise - as yet undelivered - to bring about meaningful change.
The problem, it seems to me, is not that our policies are wrong, but that the very foundation of our political system is rotten, that the culture is irredeemably backwards, corrupt, and stupid. What I don't mean is that there are too many people who disagree with my political views. My political views - like those of any individual citizen in a country of 300 million - don't really matter. What I mean is this: in politics there is too much shouting and not enough dialogue, too much complaining and not enough ideas, too much money and not enough people. The whole structure is built on innuendo, lies, bribes, and ideologies. The whole discourse is determined by wealthy media companies, political parties, and special interest groups that don't care - that can't afford to care - about the big picture.
All of this is nothing new, of course, and I suppose if the emperors are always naked, eventually it doesn't help to point it out anymore. But sometimes I think we get complacent, and we get so wrapped up in what is practical (that is, doing our jobs, watching CNN, and voting once every four years) that we forget that being just a little idealistic is, in fact, a fundamental part of being practical. Without a vision as to how things ought to be, how do we know what to do? Or do we just do what we always have, vote for who we always vote for, and hope for some miraculous superhero-cum-messiah to save us from our corrupt political world? If being eminently practical means being that complacent, and, what's more, that stupid, I'll pass.
The notion that there might be more to politics has been lost on us. Oh sure, there are protesters and Tea Parties and so on, but those are usually anything but meaningful political activity. They're, rather, a kind of political catharsis, a release of pent up anger that channel Macbeth, "Full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." Much like the discourse on television, there is a kind of procedural extremism in most political action in the United States. It is not, in fact, the case that most "extremist" protesters actually hold views which are extremely different from the mainstream, but rather that their methods of getting those views heard are more petulant.
In some sense, this kind of protest works, but only because it fits so well into the Keith Olberman, Bill O'Reilly, Chris Matthews, and Glen Beck world of political ranting that we've grown accustomed to. There is, simply put, no outlet for reasonable conversation about politics because there is no model of reasonable discourse within politics. I suspect the reason for this is that we disagree about such trifling issues (people scream and foam at the mouth over a 3% tax hike or cut for people making over $200,000 a year?) that we're trying harder to define our differences than we are to actually persuade anyone to our position.
Because of the structures we have in place, politically, it is much, much easier to say and vote than to say and do. What, exactly, does a politically active or passionate person do? Does she run for office? Does he go to protests? Do he and she watch a lot of CNN together? None satisfies because none works. In the end, the project of political change is far too unwieldy to have any kind of accessible entry point beyond the most bland, culturally acceptable ones. That's why, I suspect, so many politically passionate young men and women voted for Barrack Obama with so much fervor in 2008: it was all they knew to do.
I don't want to get too deep into the President, but I think the way that we, as a nation, engage with our leaders culturally is telling. Consider that the recent healthcare bill has been called, by many, "Obamacare." Consider that any changes to environmental efforts or tax law or are a reflection of Obama. Consider that the same was true for Bush, for Clinton, and so on. We still have terms like "Reaganomics" from the 80s, and, going way back, "The Monroe Doctrine."
There's a great passage from Douglas Adams's Hitchiker's Guide series that comes to mind:
"It might not even have made much difference to them if they'd known exactly how much power the President of the Galaxy actually wielded: none at all. Only six people in the Galaxy knew that the job of the Galactic President was not to wield power but to attract attention away from it. Zaphod Beeblebrox was amazingly good at his job."
I don't think I'd go quite that far in American politics, but the point is that Obama doesn't have half the power that we attribute to him. To his supporters (and detractors), Barrack Obama isn't even a person; he's a symbol of all that is good (or evil), an embodiment of their hopes and dreams. Indeed, the need to have a single word to connote one's political perspective (the word: Obama) is so strong, that it might not make much of a difference to them if they knew exactly how much power the President of United States actually wields.
It is because we idolize so easily that the election of a President of roughly our ideology turns us into compliant supplicants while the election of a member of the opposing party turns us into ravenous wolves. Consider that Bush's presidency saw protest over protest, about the wars, about the environment, about almost everything. Consider that Obama's presidency has seen a disappearance of anti-war rallies, but a sudden surge of right-wing Tea Parites. The irony, of course, is that the wars continue and the environmental law doesn't change in any meaningful way. Likewise, under Bush, the kinds of issues the Tea Party people are so upset about were being largely ignored or even flaunted, but the illusion that the President represented their interests was enough to keep them docile.
Perhaps this is a broken record, but whenever I am exposed to political discourse, or what passes for it, either because I happen by a television or get an email or read an article online, I cannot help but notice how outrageously narrow the debate is. Complacency is assured in the majority when being politically active means being rabid and passionate to the point of violence about things that we don't care that much about. Complacency is assured when we have a symbol, an idol that we can look to and say, "Everything is all right, our guy is in the White House." Complacency is assured when voting always carries the promise - as yet undelivered - to bring about meaningful change.
The problem, it seems to me, is not that our policies are wrong, but that the very foundation of our political system is rotten, that the culture is irredeemably backwards, corrupt, and stupid. What I don't mean is that there are too many people who disagree with my political views. My political views - like those of any individual citizen in a country of 300 million - don't really matter. What I mean is this: in politics there is too much shouting and not enough dialogue, too much complaining and not enough ideas, too much money and not enough people. The whole structure is built on innuendo, lies, bribes, and ideologies. The whole discourse is determined by wealthy media companies, political parties, and special interest groups that don't care - that can't afford to care - about the big picture.
All of this is nothing new, of course, and I suppose if the emperors are always naked, eventually it doesn't help to point it out anymore. But sometimes I think we get complacent, and we get so wrapped up in what is practical (that is, doing our jobs, watching CNN, and voting once every four years) that we forget that being just a little idealistic is, in fact, a fundamental part of being practical. Without a vision as to how things ought to be, how do we know what to do? Or do we just do what we always have, vote for who we always vote for, and hope for some miraculous superhero-cum-messiah to save us from our corrupt political world? If being eminently practical means being that complacent, and, what's more, that stupid, I'll pass.
Saturday, May 29, 2010
The Role of Language in Politics
As any reader of this blog likely knows, I am generally displeased with the nature of political discourse in the United States. Thanks to major, for-profit media outlets like CNN, Fox, and MSNBC, our national discourse is shaped and our language is carefully selected to represent primarily the interests of the few extremely wealthy men who run those companies. As a result, we spend a lot of time talking about issues like abortion, stem cell research, and immigration policy - all admittedly important - and not much time talking about things like the structure of power, voting policies, and income distribution. Of course, we talk about those latter things some, but with those issues, as with the more popular and sensational issues listed before, the whole debate is framed by major media outlets. And that's the real point: the range of acceptable opinion has almost nothing to do with the range of possible solutions.
Perhaps the biggest reason for this is the brilliant associations the so-called right and left have made around each others' positions. Anything strongly conservative is "fascist," and anything strongly liberal is "socialist, communist, or Marxist." None of those words is used according to their actual meaning, but rather they have become bugbears, denoting some vague sense of evil and despair that comes from running a government that is not, as we call it, "moderate."
Moderate is much more a myth than words like Socialist and Fascist. How so? Because the concept of moderate depends upon a linear model of political discourse. For some reason we've all bought into the Facebook Likert scale of politics; each position is scored from strongly liberal to strongly conservative, with the middle being moderate. Why should this be? What is so linear about politics? On a superficial level, sure, it makes sense: if I believe the government should take measures to prevent illegal immigration, it is fairly easy to draw a straight line from there to the opposite position, which says that illegal immigrants should be granted amnesty. But does it really make sense to draw that line? Even if we can turn the general sense of what should be done into a linear continuum, surely there's room for debate on the how?
Consider: one person might argue that we need to build a big wall along the Mexican-American border. Another might say we need to round up all of the illegal immigrants in the country and deport them. Yet another might argue that we should work closely with the Mexican government to improve working conditions there, so as to minimize the incentives for immigration. Still another might argue that we ought to do our best to simplify immigration law so that it is easier to determine who is legal and who is not. And so on. The thing is, many of these positions are not mutually exclusive for any reason other than where they stand in our perceived left-right linear model of politics. Yet, if you were to ask most Americans, they would think that the border fence idea and the simplified immigration law idea are irreconcilable.
This is just a single example, but we could do the same with almost any issue. Try it yourself. Take a major, hot-button issue. Map out the conservative position and the liberal one. Then determine possible solutions, and see whether they are mutually exclusive.
I should say, what I'm talking about is not a moderate position, because that implies finding the midpoint of a line. My point here is that we are imagining - we believe almost unquestioningly - in a line that does not exist. There is no linearity in political solutions. Even a yes or no question like "should the USA reduce its military budget" cannot be answered by liberal-says-yes and conservative-says-no. The issue is more complicated than that. The issue is not, fundamentally, linear.
With all that in mind, I want to return to the words we use in politics to denigrate opposing positions. "That's socialism!" is the cry around which - ironically - many people rally when talking about President Obama (ironic because Obama is about as far from being a socialist as everyone who derides him for it; indeed, he probably has fewer socialist beliefs than most of the people who criticize him). No explanation is needed. No examination of why socialism is bad, how it works and doesn't work, and why we have to fear socialist reforms is offered in the national discourse. We take for granted that socialism is evil, that it has been tried and does not work, that income and wealth should never never never be distributed throughout the population.
In 1967, the median income in the United States was roughly $33,000. Someone in the 95th percentile, on the other hand, made roughly $89,000 per year. That's significant disparity, but not outrageous.
By 2003, the median income in the United States was roughly $43,000, while the 95th percentile had risen to $154,000.
I don't have the more recent numbers, but I suspect the gap is still growing. And here I wonder, when we start talking about economic policy, why we talk about socialism in such evil terms. Does the richest 5 percent of the country really need to make 4 or 5 times as much as the median (and lets not talk about the bottom 20 to 25 percent, who make less than a living wage)? Is it not possible and, perhaps, reasonable to change the way that income is distributed, not in some bizarre pseudo-Marxist equal way, but simply so that everyone can survive?
Here's the point. I'm guessing that, if you take out all political language, almost everyone will agree that, yes, everyone should have a chance to make it. Hell, it's in the declaration of independence. The thing is, we've been hoodwinked into thinking that equal opportunity exists under our current economic and social structures when it certainly does not. We've been fooled into thinking that we have a "welfare state," where people at the bottom are there only because they are lazy and incompetent. We've succumbed to the idea that there is no alternative - in the best of all possible worlds, to quote Voltaire - to what is increasingly a reverse-socialism in our economic policy.*
*That is, we have socialized losses and privatized gains, a truly despicable situation. Remember that the bailout was paid for by tax payers and paid out to large investment and insurance companies. In other words, a problem caused, at least in part,** by income disparity, was "solved" by increasing income disparity. Brilliant!
**It is worth noting that the biggest economic collapses of the last century occurred at the times of greatest income disparity; that is, in 1929, in 1987, and in 2008. Hmm...
All this because there is no language available to have a rational discourse around economic (or almost any other) policy. You believe in changing the tax structure so that it is more progressive? You're a socialist-communist-Marxist pig who doesn't deserve to be in the country, let alone the conversation. How much worse if you use the word - socialism - yourself? Gone are the days when Albert Einstein, Bertrand Russell, and John Dewey proudly called themselves socialists. Today you have to apologize, all because of the power of language.
What terms are available, however, is not the issue. The issue is that we have an entire political and social and culture machine that uses language to force us to think of politics as linear, and forces us to continually reinvent meaningful terms because the ones we try to use continually get twisted and saddled with innuendos and connotations they don't, in themselves, warrant. Language is a powerful thing - maybe the most powerful thing there is - and it seems we don't know how and don't want to use it responsibly.
Perhaps the biggest reason for this is the brilliant associations the so-called right and left have made around each others' positions. Anything strongly conservative is "fascist," and anything strongly liberal is "socialist, communist, or Marxist." None of those words is used according to their actual meaning, but rather they have become bugbears, denoting some vague sense of evil and despair that comes from running a government that is not, as we call it, "moderate."
Moderate is much more a myth than words like Socialist and Fascist. How so? Because the concept of moderate depends upon a linear model of political discourse. For some reason we've all bought into the Facebook Likert scale of politics; each position is scored from strongly liberal to strongly conservative, with the middle being moderate. Why should this be? What is so linear about politics? On a superficial level, sure, it makes sense: if I believe the government should take measures to prevent illegal immigration, it is fairly easy to draw a straight line from there to the opposite position, which says that illegal immigrants should be granted amnesty. But does it really make sense to draw that line? Even if we can turn the general sense of what should be done into a linear continuum, surely there's room for debate on the how?
Consider: one person might argue that we need to build a big wall along the Mexican-American border. Another might say we need to round up all of the illegal immigrants in the country and deport them. Yet another might argue that we should work closely with the Mexican government to improve working conditions there, so as to minimize the incentives for immigration. Still another might argue that we ought to do our best to simplify immigration law so that it is easier to determine who is legal and who is not. And so on. The thing is, many of these positions are not mutually exclusive for any reason other than where they stand in our perceived left-right linear model of politics. Yet, if you were to ask most Americans, they would think that the border fence idea and the simplified immigration law idea are irreconcilable.
This is just a single example, but we could do the same with almost any issue. Try it yourself. Take a major, hot-button issue. Map out the conservative position and the liberal one. Then determine possible solutions, and see whether they are mutually exclusive.
I should say, what I'm talking about is not a moderate position, because that implies finding the midpoint of a line. My point here is that we are imagining - we believe almost unquestioningly - in a line that does not exist. There is no linearity in political solutions. Even a yes or no question like "should the USA reduce its military budget" cannot be answered by liberal-says-yes and conservative-says-no. The issue is more complicated than that. The issue is not, fundamentally, linear.
With all that in mind, I want to return to the words we use in politics to denigrate opposing positions. "That's socialism!" is the cry around which - ironically - many people rally when talking about President Obama (ironic because Obama is about as far from being a socialist as everyone who derides him for it; indeed, he probably has fewer socialist beliefs than most of the people who criticize him). No explanation is needed. No examination of why socialism is bad, how it works and doesn't work, and why we have to fear socialist reforms is offered in the national discourse. We take for granted that socialism is evil, that it has been tried and does not work, that income and wealth should never never never be distributed throughout the population.
In 1967, the median income in the United States was roughly $33,000. Someone in the 95th percentile, on the other hand, made roughly $89,000 per year. That's significant disparity, but not outrageous.
By 2003, the median income in the United States was roughly $43,000, while the 95th percentile had risen to $154,000.
I don't have the more recent numbers, but I suspect the gap is still growing. And here I wonder, when we start talking about economic policy, why we talk about socialism in such evil terms. Does the richest 5 percent of the country really need to make 4 or 5 times as much as the median (and lets not talk about the bottom 20 to 25 percent, who make less than a living wage)? Is it not possible and, perhaps, reasonable to change the way that income is distributed, not in some bizarre pseudo-Marxist equal way, but simply so that everyone can survive?
Here's the point. I'm guessing that, if you take out all political language, almost everyone will agree that, yes, everyone should have a chance to make it. Hell, it's in the declaration of independence. The thing is, we've been hoodwinked into thinking that equal opportunity exists under our current economic and social structures when it certainly does not. We've been fooled into thinking that we have a "welfare state," where people at the bottom are there only because they are lazy and incompetent. We've succumbed to the idea that there is no alternative - in the best of all possible worlds, to quote Voltaire - to what is increasingly a reverse-socialism in our economic policy.*
*That is, we have socialized losses and privatized gains, a truly despicable situation. Remember that the bailout was paid for by tax payers and paid out to large investment and insurance companies. In other words, a problem caused, at least in part,** by income disparity, was "solved" by increasing income disparity. Brilliant!
**It is worth noting that the biggest economic collapses of the last century occurred at the times of greatest income disparity; that is, in 1929, in 1987, and in 2008. Hmm...
All this because there is no language available to have a rational discourse around economic (or almost any other) policy. You believe in changing the tax structure so that it is more progressive? You're a socialist-communist-Marxist pig who doesn't deserve to be in the country, let alone the conversation. How much worse if you use the word - socialism - yourself? Gone are the days when Albert Einstein, Bertrand Russell, and John Dewey proudly called themselves socialists. Today you have to apologize, all because of the power of language.
What terms are available, however, is not the issue. The issue is that we have an entire political and social and culture machine that uses language to force us to think of politics as linear, and forces us to continually reinvent meaningful terms because the ones we try to use continually get twisted and saddled with innuendos and connotations they don't, in themselves, warrant. Language is a powerful thing - maybe the most powerful thing there is - and it seems we don't know how and don't want to use it responsibly.
Labels:
Economics,
immigration,
language,
media,
Politics,
social policy,
socialism
Thursday, April 22, 2010
Earth Day
Ironies first. The United States Military is now working on building "green" aircraft carriers. As if saving a little bit of fuel makes up for the horrendous ecological, economic, and, of course, human harm caused by a massive and ever-growing military budget. There's a big difference between taking meaningful action to remedy the tremendous ecological concerns that trouble our planet (and, more pointedly, the quality of human life upon it) and engaging in empty token political gestures that do nothing but make us feel better about things. Replacing "smog" with "smug," as South Park so aptly observed, only makes things worse.
I have an Earth Day story from way back in 2004, during the Presidential primaries that saw John Kerry (really?) chosen the Democratic nominee. I attended, that day, a rally for Dennis Kucinich held on the top floor of the Mercury Cafe in Denver. It remains the only time I've seen Kucinich speak in person, but what was most notable was not, actually, Kucinich's speech. He was his usual charismatic and hilarious self,* and I was surprised that he really is as short as they say he is.** But what I remember most clearly - besides some very astute answers about Israel and Palestine - was a surprise appearance from none other than John McConnell.
* What is it about "fringe" politicians that makes them so much more endearing than main-stream types? Kucinich is not alone in using humor to engage and build rapport with his audience. Ralph Nader is one of the funniest speakers I've seen live, funnier than many stand-up comedians. Likewise, the Mike Huckabees (since we're not exclusionary at this here blog) and Al Sharptons of the world remind us that, sometimes, there are real people in politics who aren't afraid to tell a joke or to laugh. Heaven forbid we remember that life is a strange and funny thing.
** A fatal flaw in modern politics. Combined with a difficult-to-pronounce name and a Catholic upbringing, Kucinich never stands a chance, and that's before you factor in his refusal to take corporate money and his tendency not to placate a corrupt power-structure.
For those who don't know, McConnell is one of the founders of Earth Day, and a resident of Denver. He came to Kucinich's rally and, slyly, did not announce himself. Towards the end of the session, he popped up and rambled a little bit about the environment, before finally letting fly that he was, in fact, one of the creators of one of our most respectable - though, sadly, one of our most corruptible* - holidays. McConnell presented Kucinich with one of his patented Earth Day flags, and received a warm ovation from the overflowing audience.
* Which is no surprise. Martin Luther King Day, because it has become such a big deal, has become little more than an excuse for people to make political gains on the back of token interest in the actual life of Martin Luther King. Earth Day, similarly, is becoming a way to pretend like you care about the environment, or to forgive yourself for 364 days a year of not caring.
Which is really neither here nor there, except that it goes to show that people who do important work towards a better world are often relegated to unheralded attics of unknown restaurants, until they get big enough that their work ceases to be effective anymore. The real moral of the story is, work smart and small, but don't be afraid to imagine big.
I have an Earth Day story from way back in 2004, during the Presidential primaries that saw John Kerry (really?) chosen the Democratic nominee. I attended, that day, a rally for Dennis Kucinich held on the top floor of the Mercury Cafe in Denver. It remains the only time I've seen Kucinich speak in person, but what was most notable was not, actually, Kucinich's speech. He was his usual charismatic and hilarious self,* and I was surprised that he really is as short as they say he is.** But what I remember most clearly - besides some very astute answers about Israel and Palestine - was a surprise appearance from none other than John McConnell.
* What is it about "fringe" politicians that makes them so much more endearing than main-stream types? Kucinich is not alone in using humor to engage and build rapport with his audience. Ralph Nader is one of the funniest speakers I've seen live, funnier than many stand-up comedians. Likewise, the Mike Huckabees (since we're not exclusionary at this here blog) and Al Sharptons of the world remind us that, sometimes, there are real people in politics who aren't afraid to tell a joke or to laugh. Heaven forbid we remember that life is a strange and funny thing.
** A fatal flaw in modern politics. Combined with a difficult-to-pronounce name and a Catholic upbringing, Kucinich never stands a chance, and that's before you factor in his refusal to take corporate money and his tendency not to placate a corrupt power-structure.
For those who don't know, McConnell is one of the founders of Earth Day, and a resident of Denver. He came to Kucinich's rally and, slyly, did not announce himself. Towards the end of the session, he popped up and rambled a little bit about the environment, before finally letting fly that he was, in fact, one of the creators of one of our most respectable - though, sadly, one of our most corruptible* - holidays. McConnell presented Kucinich with one of his patented Earth Day flags, and received a warm ovation from the overflowing audience.
* Which is no surprise. Martin Luther King Day, because it has become such a big deal, has become little more than an excuse for people to make political gains on the back of token interest in the actual life of Martin Luther King. Earth Day, similarly, is becoming a way to pretend like you care about the environment, or to forgive yourself for 364 days a year of not caring.
Which is really neither here nor there, except that it goes to show that people who do important work towards a better world are often relegated to unheralded attics of unknown restaurants, until they get big enough that their work ceases to be effective anymore. The real moral of the story is, work smart and small, but don't be afraid to imagine big.
Labels:
Dennis Kucinich,
Earth Day,
Holidays,
John McConnell,
Politics
Friday, March 19, 2010
No More Nuance
Check out this article, if you desire, before reading my post.
A lot of self-titled "progressives" say things like this, from Miles Mogulescu of the Huffington Post:
“Progressives need to have a sophisticated and nuanced relationship with elected Democrats. After the 2008 elections, too many progressive organizations demobilized believing their job was simply to take orders from the White House to support Obama’s agenda, whatever it was. That was a mistake. It’s equally a mistake for progressives to overreact in the opposite direction and think they can abandon electoral politics and do nothing to prevent the Republicans from regaining power. What’s needed is a powerful grassroots progressive movement to force elected officials to do the right thing more often and to counter-balance the power of big money in politics. The periods of progressive change in American politics, like the Progressive Era, The New Deal, and the Great Society, have come when strong progressive movements have forced elites and elected officials to enact somewhat progressive legislation.”
Mogulescu advocates voting Democrat, but then creating a "powerful grassroots progressive movement to force elected officials to do the right thing." He claims that voting third party (or not voting) is naive and impractical, that the Democratic Party is our only hope for salvation from the big bad Republicans and their evil plan for destroying the world. Or something to that effect.
What is more naive, though? Voting third party, or expecting that you can create a "powerful grassroots movement to force elected officials to do the right thing." Hello? How, exactly, is that supposed to happen? Elected officials listen to two things, votes and money. Grassroots movements are not likely to compete with corporations (who, thanks to the Supreme Court, can now give indefinite sums of money to political campaigns) on the financial side. So the only power we the people have is the power of the vote. If we say: "Look, Mr. Obama, we want you to pass a health care bill that actually covers everyone and lowers insurance costs, but if you don't we'll still vote for you," what good does that do? If that is our approach, how easy is it for the Democrats to do what corporate interests want them to do, whilst paying lip-service to their cowed supporters?
No, Mr. Mogulescu, yours is a refrain too often heard. Your revision of the history of previous Progressive movements smacks of corporatism. The New Deal succeeded not because Progressive citizens "held their representatives' feet to the fire" in some namby-pamby, "nuanced" way, but rather because they threatened to and did vote for the Socialist Party. Because they were dangerous to the powers that be. Third parties didn't win any elections, but they did win the battles for reform upon which they were based.
Where do we stand today? Our modern news-cycle has, ironically, all but destroyed our once vibrant third-party world. The "impracticality" of voting for a Libertarian, a Green, or an Independent is so manifestly obvious to everyone that we have decided, instead, to lock ourselves into a perpetual cycle of "the lesser of two evils." If two trains are going to Hell, is it really better to hop on the slower one? I tell you, Mr. Mogulsecu, these trains that are the modern major parties don't have a "reverse" switch on them. This is a one way trip.
Unless, of course, we can overwhelm the power of money with the power of votes. Granting your ideal of a grassroots movement large enough to effect change in Washington, I suspect that same movement would be large enough perhaps not to elect a Nader as President, but certainly to elect a Mike Miles (of Colorado) to the Senate, or a Matt Gonzalez (of San Francisco) to the Congress. Indeed, perhaps we can elect a slew of these true, non-corporate progressives to the legislature, rather than hoping and praying that the Nancy Pelosis of the world will see the progressive light and try to make change for the better, simply because we the people asked nicely.
Now is not the time to ask nicely. The current health care bill, the bailouts, the continuing (unending) wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the reaffirmation of the Patriot Act, the passage of FAFSA (before Obama's presidency, but he voted for it as a Senator), the coming ramping-up of the disastrous "No Child Left Behind" bill... What do they have to do to lose your vote, Mr. Mogulescu? Which of these horrifying bits of Washington maneuvering did your nuanced opposition whittle down into a more palatable poison?
To pick one of these targets, the health care bill is now almost certain to pass. It has no public option. It requires that all citizens purchase health care, but does nothing to ensure that health care will be affordable. It even allows businesses to opt-out of providing health insurance for their employees. It is, in short, the wet-dream of the very health-insurance companies that are the root, tree, branches, and leaves of the problem of American health care. Far from constraining the growth of insurance company profits, this bill is a veritable fertilizer for those companies, which is why it stinks so bad.
No more nuance, Mr. Mogulescu. The Democrats have been shoving nuance down our throats for too long. Nuanced support lost Gore the election. It lost Kerry the election. Nuanced support meant that the Great Hope for Change that was Barrack Obama has turned into a second edition of George Bush (I do not exaggerate; show me a policy which has changed). Until we progressives start to scream at our beloved Democratic Party, "We're not going to take it anymore!" they have no reason to listen to us. Until we progressives demonstrate that we have the power to win and lose elections for the Democratic Party, they will not heed our demands. Until we progressives stop voting for Democrats, our votes will not count.
A lot of self-titled "progressives" say things like this, from Miles Mogulescu of the Huffington Post:
“Progressives need to have a sophisticated and nuanced relationship with elected Democrats. After the 2008 elections, too many progressive organizations demobilized believing their job was simply to take orders from the White House to support Obama’s agenda, whatever it was. That was a mistake. It’s equally a mistake for progressives to overreact in the opposite direction and think they can abandon electoral politics and do nothing to prevent the Republicans from regaining power. What’s needed is a powerful grassroots progressive movement to force elected officials to do the right thing more often and to counter-balance the power of big money in politics. The periods of progressive change in American politics, like the Progressive Era, The New Deal, and the Great Society, have come when strong progressive movements have forced elites and elected officials to enact somewhat progressive legislation.”
Mogulescu advocates voting Democrat, but then creating a "powerful grassroots progressive movement to force elected officials to do the right thing." He claims that voting third party (or not voting) is naive and impractical, that the Democratic Party is our only hope for salvation from the big bad Republicans and their evil plan for destroying the world. Or something to that effect.
What is more naive, though? Voting third party, or expecting that you can create a "powerful grassroots movement to force elected officials to do the right thing." Hello? How, exactly, is that supposed to happen? Elected officials listen to two things, votes and money. Grassroots movements are not likely to compete with corporations (who, thanks to the Supreme Court, can now give indefinite sums of money to political campaigns) on the financial side. So the only power we the people have is the power of the vote. If we say: "Look, Mr. Obama, we want you to pass a health care bill that actually covers everyone and lowers insurance costs, but if you don't we'll still vote for you," what good does that do? If that is our approach, how easy is it for the Democrats to do what corporate interests want them to do, whilst paying lip-service to their cowed supporters?
No, Mr. Mogulescu, yours is a refrain too often heard. Your revision of the history of previous Progressive movements smacks of corporatism. The New Deal succeeded not because Progressive citizens "held their representatives' feet to the fire" in some namby-pamby, "nuanced" way, but rather because they threatened to and did vote for the Socialist Party. Because they were dangerous to the powers that be. Third parties didn't win any elections, but they did win the battles for reform upon which they were based.
Where do we stand today? Our modern news-cycle has, ironically, all but destroyed our once vibrant third-party world. The "impracticality" of voting for a Libertarian, a Green, or an Independent is so manifestly obvious to everyone that we have decided, instead, to lock ourselves into a perpetual cycle of "the lesser of two evils." If two trains are going to Hell, is it really better to hop on the slower one? I tell you, Mr. Mogulsecu, these trains that are the modern major parties don't have a "reverse" switch on them. This is a one way trip.
Unless, of course, we can overwhelm the power of money with the power of votes. Granting your ideal of a grassroots movement large enough to effect change in Washington, I suspect that same movement would be large enough perhaps not to elect a Nader as President, but certainly to elect a Mike Miles (of Colorado) to the Senate, or a Matt Gonzalez (of San Francisco) to the Congress. Indeed, perhaps we can elect a slew of these true, non-corporate progressives to the legislature, rather than hoping and praying that the Nancy Pelosis of the world will see the progressive light and try to make change for the better, simply because we the people asked nicely.
Now is not the time to ask nicely. The current health care bill, the bailouts, the continuing (unending) wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the reaffirmation of the Patriot Act, the passage of FAFSA (before Obama's presidency, but he voted for it as a Senator), the coming ramping-up of the disastrous "No Child Left Behind" bill... What do they have to do to lose your vote, Mr. Mogulescu? Which of these horrifying bits of Washington maneuvering did your nuanced opposition whittle down into a more palatable poison?
To pick one of these targets, the health care bill is now almost certain to pass. It has no public option. It requires that all citizens purchase health care, but does nothing to ensure that health care will be affordable. It even allows businesses to opt-out of providing health insurance for their employees. It is, in short, the wet-dream of the very health-insurance companies that are the root, tree, branches, and leaves of the problem of American health care. Far from constraining the growth of insurance company profits, this bill is a veritable fertilizer for those companies, which is why it stinks so bad.
No more nuance, Mr. Mogulescu. The Democrats have been shoving nuance down our throats for too long. Nuanced support lost Gore the election. It lost Kerry the election. Nuanced support meant that the Great Hope for Change that was Barrack Obama has turned into a second edition of George Bush (I do not exaggerate; show me a policy which has changed). Until we progressives start to scream at our beloved Democratic Party, "We're not going to take it anymore!" they have no reason to listen to us. Until we progressives demonstrate that we have the power to win and lose elections for the Democratic Party, they will not heed our demands. Until we progressives stop voting for Democrats, our votes will not count.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)