Sunday, March 20, 2011
Lacertilian Politics
[A giant robot from outer space] held up a hand.
"I come in peace," it said, adding after a long moment of further grinding, "take me to your Lizard."
Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this ...
"It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see."
[Arthur Dent speaking] "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?"
"No," said Ford ... "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people."
"Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy."
"I did," said Ford. "It is."
"So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't the people get red of the lizards?"
"It honestly doesn't occur to them," said ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want."
"You mean they actually vote for the lizards?"
"Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course."
"But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?"
"Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in."
Needless to say, the next time I'm accused of "wasting my vote" on a third party candidate who has no hope of winning, I think I'll refer the accuser to this passage. At a certain point you just have to stop voting for the lizards, don't you?
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
The Return of More Interesting than it Seems: William Faulkner on Books, Blogs, and Tweets
There's a William Faulkner quotation that I want to lead off this post with. It goes like this: "I'm a failed poet. Maybe every novelist wants to write poetry first, finds he can't and then tries the short story which is the most demanding form after poetry. And failing at that, only then does he take up novel writing."
Something tells me that Dan Brown, for example, isn't really a failed poet. Or maybe he is, but he took up writing (bad) novels for an entirely different reason than Faulkner did. There's really not very much money in poetry these days, while there's still plenty in trashy suspense stories that can be made into movies starring Tom Hanks. There's little question in my mind that Carson Cistulli is a more talented artist - and probably far more sarcastic - than Dan Brown. Hell, the title of his book of poetry, Some Common Weaknesses Illustrated, is way better than the uninspired dribble that most modern novels are adorned with. Of course, it's unfair to call modern novels "novels" in any real sense. They're more like extended sound-bytes, pre-fabricated and totally predictable explorations of human action tailored to what sells, and not what is interesting or revealing of human nature or profound.
Now that I've demonstrated my snobbishness, I want to consider the place of books - novels in particular - in the modern literary world. Despite my cynicism, there are still authors who write real books, novels like The Alchemist or the Amazing Adventures of Cavalier and Clay* which count as real novels written for artistic reasons, and not merely to sell. Of course, they may do both, and any publisher worth his or her salt will not take a book written without the potential to sell (which is why Dune, for example, was turned down by so many publishers; ditto Stranger in a Strange Land). But some books retain artistic merit, are built around fundamental questions about human existence and experience, and, perhaps above all, actually make the reader think.
* I must shamefully admit that I haven't read either of these books yet. They are, however, on my ever-ballooning reading list, and I'll get to them just as soon as I finish the other bazillion books I also intend to read.
Books, however, are a dying media. Oh, there are still more than plenty of books being written - indeed, probably more now than ever - but a smaller and smaller portion of the daily reading of even the staunchest book defender (like myself) is happening on the page. To be clear, I'm not talking about eReaders, which perform the same function as a book. I'm talking about blogs, tweets, forums, and, perhaps most important and most overlooked of all, comments.
The blog is an obvious stand-in for the newspaper, and likely owes to the slow death of papers around the country. Why pay to have a honking, advertisement-ridden jumble of information about topics ranging from who died to who won the hockey game to who murdered who when all you care about is the political editorials? Why recycle 50 pages of unread paper every day when all you want is that fold-out photojournalism special? The blog world provides an opportunity to read just that one section - and probably in more depth, detail, and sophistication thanks to the specialization of most blogs - without having to wade through the rest, without having to pay, without having to recycle, and so on.
The danger here, of course, is self-selection. If all you read are blogs written by fervent Democrats or Republicans, you're liable to take an already biased perspective and subtly tweak it further and further until you can't even recognize the potential for reason in any perspective that differs from your own. Whereas the newspaper may have had subtle biases, but largely strove to be objective, RepublicansSuck.com or TheLeftCanEatIt.com are not likely to present the facts of a story without adjusting them to fit their politic desires. Indeed, they're not likely to present the same stories at all.
Which only means that there's more onus on the reader to be objective and critical, to know when there is a real debate going on, to know when to take the other side seriously, and to know when red herrings are being served to each other's straw men. Unfortunately, most readers seem incapable of doing this - or, worse, are unwilling to try - and so most of our blogly conversations are like attracting like. The conversational power of the Internet turns, not to an integrating or dialogic force, but rather a divisive one.
Which brings me back to Mr. Faulkner, who wrote charged books that are extremely difficult for even a well-read, intelligent person to understand. He intentionally confuses, complicates, draws complex images and connections, and uses symbolism that is self-developed (rather than cultural stock). He is, indeed, a kind of poet writing novels. Or, as he has it, a failed poet. His quotation - with which this post began - is fascinating to me not just because Faulkner is regarded as one of the finest novelists in American history, but because of all novelists his novels are some of the most poetic.
If we draw Faulkner's line from poem to story to novel, I wonder where we put our modern forms of composition. Where does the email go? Where the blog post? Where the tweet? Perhaps Faulkner's continuum has nothing to do with what we're writing these days, because so much of our writing and so much of our reading have become communicative instead of artistic. Are people on Twitter trying to say something about anything other than themselves? Then again, are writers of novels and poems any different, except in that they take more time to do it? Good writing is both impersonal - applicable and interesting to a wide audience - and intensely personal. Without the latter, there's no impulse, no passion for the subject matter. Without passion, there's no writing at all.
It seems to me that there is passion in the blog world. After all, no one pays the vast majority of bloggers to write their missives, and while a great many of those posts are not particularly interesting, a great many - more than any one person can read, in fact - are extremely well-written, engaging, and often profound. The same could be said, I suspect, of Twitter. Most tweets may be little more than glorified status updates or text messages, but the occasional 160 character (or whatever) salvo might be just as profound as a well-written haiku. Indeed, I understand there's a whole set of people devoted to writing Twitter haikus.
What separates Faulkner, then, is not the medium, like you might suppose, but rather his self-awareness. It seems to me that the map of Faulkner's continuum need not be overly complicated: tweets are - or can be - poems, blog posts can be short stories, emails can be either - and, occasionally, novels in their own right. It's just that, most of the time, they aren't, and have no desire to be. There are, however, those who do desire to write well, to even be great writers in one sense or another, but what we lack in our myopic times are not avenues to be great, but an audience that recognizes the difference between great, good, ok, and boring. Most of all, what we lack is the self-awareness that says "I am a failed poet," and uses that to become a great novelist. Instead we all keep hammering out at the poetry, reading and writing and digesting a sentence at a time, forgetting that sometimes it is easier and better to try to express or understand the soul of another human being in sentences, paragraphs, and chapters.
Thursday, August 26, 2010
Stealth More Interesting: Ralph Waldo Emerson
In reality, of course, no story is so simple as to be about a single man or woman. At the most basic level, the massive network of personal interactions and cultural influences that any given "hero" experiences means that no one is shaped solely by himself. Even the most stubborn, self-assured, and rebellious personality stands in contrast to something, and so the lone voice of a Galileo or a Lucretius hardly exists in isolation. Those voices were alone - though not entirely, of course, even that gets overblown - because they contravened excepted dogmas and cultural narratives so strong as to be unquestionable.
What makes such people memorable, however, is rarely their genius. In that regard, I suspect that there have been and are many more people capable of great fame than have achieved it. What's more, even genius may be culturally mitigated, and one time's luminary may be another's villain, or, worse, Average Joe. No, fame is mostly about luck, about being in the right place at the right time, to use a tired phrase. Even an unquestionably great man like Gandhi would not have been Gandhi without South Africa, and without a colonial oppression so vile that a nation of a billion wanted desperately to fight against it. Without his context, Gandhi is just another deeply spiritual man, and not a man who changed the world.
Which is not to say that the fact of fame is accidental, but rather that the bestowal of fame on particular people is. We, as Westerners, and likely as human beings, much prefer to condense our stories into manageable chunks. Without some synthesis of the vast account of a particular bit of history, how could we possibly build an understanding of meaning? Leave the detailed examinations to the experts, we say, and let the school-house narrative of George Washington and the Founding Fathers suffice when the Fourth of July roles around. There is, frankly, nothing to be done about the simplifications we make, because they are necessary in order for us to accomplish much of anything. To study the thousands of years of recorded history across the many different cradles of civilization that exist in depth is the work of dozens or hundreds of lives.
Nevertheless, it is easy to forget that we are reducing, reducing, reducing. It is easy to forget that even Galileo was not solitary, and that even Beethoven's music was impossible without his interactions with his father, with Haydn, with the music of Mozart, with the women he lusted after, with the countless unnamed and unremembered princes and patrons and musicians. I as much as anyone am guilty of letting the name of some famous person stand in for an unimaginably complex situation which I don't understand, and more often than not I forget that I am doing it and come to a conclusion about that bit of history that supports my own biases and ideals.
How much more so media, politicians, advertisers, text books and teachers, who are in the business, to varying degrees, not only of informing, but of convincing as well? How much of our understanding of the world shaped by our confirmation bias? Because we grew up with a certain narrative, and from that narrative - be it historical, religious, moral, or some combination of all of those (and more) - we have each built a set of ideals and expectations, our own schema for interpreting and defining and rewriting complex events to make them comprehensible, we tend to find that the world either agrees with our preconceptions, or is not worth bothering about. Approaching history from any other way is not only difficult, it may very well be impossible.
What is there to do, then? Well, ignoring the problem is perfectly valid. I say that without irony, because frankly, it is not in the least bit upsetting to me to imagine a world where we tell wonderful stories about the exploits and tribulations of great men and women. Though we call such things history and myth based upon their supposed accuracy, they are more often than not the same thing, and regardless both excite the imagination, inspire the heart, and stimulate critical thought. I am just as likely to talk about Beethoven as a paragon as I am to talk about him as situated within his cultural and society. Indeed, I am more likely to do the former, because it's a more compelling and more entertaining story.
On the other hand, I do have some interest in the truth, and while ignoring complexity is valid, so it charging headlong into it. That is a more complicated task, granted, but a rewarding one as well. Indeed, many of the stories of greatness we have come from people who did exactly that: consider, again, Galileo's challenge to our most fundamental beliefs about the nature of the world. Consider the development of calculus by Newton and Leibniz, who violated the established principles of mathematical truth to do so. Consider more modern examples like Erving Goffman, who challenge the very notion that gender is anything but a socially and culturally mediated display of differences, and not nearly so rooted in biology and neurology as we like to think. Consider Stanford's Ray McDermott, who argues that learning disabilities acquire kids more than kids acquire learning disabilities.
Yes, there's certainly something to be said for challenging accepted narratives in order to, just maybe, get closer to something that is true. But even in so doing we tend to find a similar set of biases and ideologies. The dogmatic belief in being anti-dogmatic is itself dogmatic; the insistence on challenging established cultural and historical narratives can itself become (and has, in some circles) an entrenched cultural and historical narrative. So what is there to do? Nothing, and everything. Who can really say? It's a too tangled web to unravel in a mere blog post. Rather, I'll make reference to Emerson in Self-Reliance: "Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind."
Thursday, August 19, 2010
Some Bertrand Russell Quotations
Reading Russell is always enjoyable for me, because I find him so eminently reasonable. Of course, he get pinned into the "liberal socialist" camp, and is thus something of a polarizing figure in the history of both theoretical and popular philosophy, but no one would find that more absurd than Russell himself. In fact, he was very much a man who believed that dogma of any kind was dangerous; the idea that he represents any particular ideology - except perhaps the ideology of avoiding ideology - is a reach. Certainly he had a great many opinions which are classified in our modern era as liberal, but - and I would say the same about myself - those are, on the one hand, conditional ideas that don't represent "The Answer" to anything, and, on the other hand, are usually more nuanced than the expression of them as 'liberal' can possibly capture.
Russell was eminently quotable, as well, even though he is the kind of thinker who would resist the idea of summarizing someone's ideas with mere quotation. With that in mind, I want to share a couple quotations of his - not necessarily from "Unpopular Essays" - and explicate them a bit. Consider this the next post in the "More Interesting Than It Seems" series.
Philosophy
Russell is well known as a philosopher, as well as an historian of philosophy. Though he himself in fact pursued a great many philosophical thoughts, he was irreverent in his efforts.
"That Plato's Republic should have been admired, on its political side, by decent people is perhaps the most astonishing example of literary snobbery in all history."
I think he found, in the existing academic structures in the world of philosophy, the same deference and refusal to think that he so much despised in politics. It was too easy to simply believe that Plato, because he was Plato, was making a good point about how societies should be organized. Hence the dogmatism among philosophers that Plato is some kind of political all-father.
"I think we ought always to entertain our opinions with some measure of doubt. I shouldn't wish people dogmatically to believe any philosophy, not even mine."
One of the biggest critiques of Russell was that, while he was anti-dogmatic, he often spoke persuasively rather than inquiringly. He, in fact, came across as extremely dogmatic about his anti-dogmatism. That's a fair criticism, but I also think it does a bit of a disservice to Russell. Ultimately it's not that satisfying to read an essay that begins every sentence with "I might be wrong about this but..."
"The most savage controversies are those about matters as to which there is no good evidence either way."
However much he was irreverent, Russell was also well-aware of the history of philosophy, though the above quotation could just as easily apply in politics or religion. Nevertheless, there's a Kantian notion* here. In his Critique of Pure Reason Kant comes to very much this conclusion, that some especially metaphysical questions are impossible to answer, and that those same questions are also likely to have vehement debates surrounding them.
* See what I did there?
"The point of philosophy is to start with something so simple as not to seem worth stating, and to end with something so paradoxical that no one will believe it."
Of course, this quotation could easily apply to Kant, as well as a great many other philosophers. For his own part, Russell was rarely taken seriously as a pure philosopher, probably because he found the pure, academic efforts of contemporaries like Husserl to be, shall we say, ridiculous. His moral, political, and social writings may not have been as academic, but were they less valuable?
Society
Russell was no apologist for the world in which he lived, however. Though he was certainly an idealist, who believed very much in the capacity of people to be good, he approached his political and social philosophy with a great deal of cynicism.
"If there were in the world today any large number of people who desired their own happiness more than they desired the unhappiness of others, we could have paradise in a few years."
While not an anthropologist, Russell certainly does strive to undermine existing paradigms. The above quotations tells a different story than the one we traditionally hear. Usually, the problem is that we're too caught up in ourselves, and that we should care more about the happiness of others, but I think he makes a good point: people who sacrifice their own happiness entirely make a grave mistake as well. We should, instead, find a better way to encourage individual happiness that comes not at the expense of others. Which is really just the other half of the golden rule, so often (and ironically) shortened to "do unto others." Let's not forget the "as you would have them do unto yourself."
"It is a waste of energy to be angry with a man who behaves badly, just as it is to be angry with a car that won't go."
Nevertheless, Russell did not blame people for their shortsightedness. The influence of culture, social norms, and political structures is extreme. While this quotation is a bit too behaviorist for my liking, I appreciate the point: it's silly to rage against the man who is merely a symptom of a bigger problem, and not the disease itself.
Work and Leisure
I've left out a number of good quotations that could go well here in favor of three particularly good ones. In short, Russell was very much of the opinion that entirely too much work gets done in the world, and that we, in general, spend far too little time and effort thinking about what we want and ought to do with our spare time.
"The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time."
Not being dogmatic, Russell lacks the moralizing that comes with our modern conceptions of leisure. Reading books is good, being on Facebook all the time is bad, we say. Writing essays is good, playing computer games is bad. I could go on. The point is, though, that maybe the time you enjoy wasting, well, yeah.
"Work is of two kinds: first, altering the position of matter at or near the earth's surface relatively to other such matter; second, telling other people to do so. The first kind is unpleasant and ill paid; the second is pleasant and highly paid."
This quotation and the one after it are related. The above trivializes work by showing what it is, in its essence. While it is true that, in order to survive, we have to move matter at or near the earth's surface, it is also true that we get extremely caught up in how, why, where, and by whom all of that is done.
"One of the symptoms of an approaching nervous breakdown is the belief that one's work is terribly important."
I suspect you know someone for whom this applies. You may even be someone for whom this applies. Regardless, I think the point is a good one; even the most serious work in the world should be taken with proper perspective, not just because it makes life a little better, but also because you might be more effective anyway if you're not having a nervous breakdown.
Thought
As an ardent thinker and believer in thinking, Russell has a lot to say about thought as such. In particular, Russell is frequently distraught by the surprisingly negative relationship the majority of the world has with the process of thinking.
"Many people would sooner die than think; In fact, they do so."
I don't think this quotation is meant to mean that people don't think during their lives and then die. Rather, I think it means that people, given the palpable choice between thinking and dieing, often actively choose death. Cynical? Extremely, but also likely true. For example, consider how many people consume vast quantities of high fructose corn syrup every day.
"Men fear thought as they fear nothing else on earth -- more than ruin -- more even than death.... Thought is subversive and revolutionary, destructive and terrible, thought is merciless to privilege, established institutions, and comfortable habit. Thought looks into the pit of hell and is not afraid. Thought is great and swift and free, the light of the world, and the chief glory of man."
Of course, if the short form of the quotation isn't enough, the long form is here to spell it out. How ironic, in Russell's view, that the greatest accomplishment of mankind is also terrifying.
"Science may set limits to knowledge, but should not set limits to imagination."
Changing gears, this quotation makes me think of Einstein's famous sayings about imagination. In much the same vein, Russell speaks to the desirability of imagination, and I would say elevates it over knowledge in the process. Indeed, it may very well be that science is actually, at its core, about both.
Morality
Russell was raised in a Christian household, and actually did hold that most of the traditional Christian virtues were good ones (except, for example, sexual abstinence, which he found absurd). Even so, he was a staunch atheist - or at least a staunch agnostic, being generally undogmatic - and held that morality could be arrived at logically.
"The good life, as I conceive it, is a happy life. I do not mean that if you are good you will be happy - I mean that if you are happy you will be good."
Here is an example of a practical philosophy of morality, and also an example of a fantastic reversal of expectations. The opening of the quotation seems innocuous enough, but his conception is non-traditional. The point is well-taken, however. It may very well be that if we focused more on making people happy, then they would be good more easily, rather than trying to make people good and hoping they'll also be happy. The idea here is related to one authors and philosophers have been expressing for a long time: it's much rarer for wealthy - or at least comfortable - people to be thieves. If so much is true with money, why not with morals as well?
"The people who are regarded as moral luminaries are those who forego ordinary pleasures themselves and find compensation in interfering with the pleasures of others."
I think this is the most controversial quotation in the set, and I love it. It takes on both the "Great Man" theory of history - if tangentially - and the unchallenged (and, really, almost unchallengeable) notion that self-sacrifice is desirable. Moral luminaries are, as we often forget, people, and Russell sees in their willingness to give up their own pleasures a kind of sick desire to rob the same from others. He is, of course, mainly challenging Christianity here, but we could say the same about any number of areas of human experience. Consider the over-worked teacher who gives up everything so that her students might become stressed-out, over-worked adults themselves. Consider the monk who surrenders sexual company in the hope of motivating others to do the same. Consider the insurance executive who works 15 hours a day, so that he might better ensure that his profit margins are high (and therefore his coverage more scant).
In all, it's a polarizing quotation, but the seeds are visible even in some of the more mundane thoughts about happiness. Of course, Russell would not be phased by the offense that many of his readers would take at such an idea, if only because he recognized that most popular opinions today were once extremely unpopular, to the point of being absurd. And, on the balance, it's not really worth it to get angry with a dead philosopher, is it? That sounds dangerously like wishing for the unhappiness of another more than wishing for the happiness of oneself. Or, worse yet, confusing the two.
Sunday, August 8, 2010
More Interesting Than It Seems: Arthur C. Clarke
What makes a quotation "more interesting" than it seems is largely subjective, but that's part of the point. By the time a famous quotation becomes famous, it has undergone various permutations in context, intonation, and sometimes even diction and syntax to the point that it might not have anything in particular to do with the actual thoughts of the speaker of that quotation. Add to that the sine qua non of famous quotations - that they almost uniformly come from famous people - and it's no wonder famous quotations are easily abused.
So let's begin our own abuse with one of my favorite quotations from Arthur C. Clarke:* "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."
*That until just recently I mistakenly thought this quotation was Isaac Asimov's just goes to show how easily and often unwittingly manipulated these things are.
On the surface, this is a wonderful, if somewhat obvious, thing for a science fiction author to say. There is certainly something fantastical about the way we interact with science fiction stories, and for the most part we're not apt to hold the author's feet to the fire when he or she describes the technologies that make the setting possible. Star Trek fans would not get far if they needed a scientifically plausible explanation for the transporter, holodeck, or warp drive. Fortunately for us, those technologies are sufficiently advanced that they are like magic, and understanding is not important.
What makes the quotation more interesting, however, upon closer inspection is that it contains within it a bit of a cautionary tone.* While Coram and I were working on our Master's Project, one of the students we talked to described his own laboratory experience as being "like magic," and this quotation jumped to my mind. Magic may be fanciful and fun, but it can also be a dangerous stand-in for "lack of understanding."
*Or, at least, we can read a cautionary tone into it.
I think the word "magic" isn't the real locus of interest, though. Rather, "sufficiently advanced" is what really counts. What, exactly, qualifies as "sufficiently advanced." What is advanced to me or you is obviously different than what would be advanced to our great grandparents, or to the ancient Greeks. But I cannot help but feel that, even for us, there's a certain magic that goes into most of the technology we use on a day to day basis. Sure, there are people who understand cars, people who understand computers, people who understand WiFi, people who understand cellphones, people who understand microwaves, and people who understand the electric watch, but there are very very few people indeed for whom at least one of those things is not, in a very real sense, magic.
It's easy to point to authority and say, "ah yes, well, I may not know how a toaster works, but the electrician next door does." The problem is, that's very much what Clarke means by magic. The toaster, even, is sufficiently advanced that we need to call in the local sorcerer to fix it when it goes wrong. And, like magic, it has the power to make yummy food or to burn your house down.
I'm being somewhat facetious, but not entirely. I think, especially from an educational perspective, Clarke's quotation serves to remind us that it's not necessarily a good idea to encourage students to be satisfied with merely calling the local witch-doctor to fix their plumbing. That's not to say we shouldn't employ plumbers, but that we shouldn't simply take for granted that all of this technology we have around us all the time just is. Ultimately, what I'm talking about is two different attitudes towards science (and, subsequently, technology): one is skeptical, empirical, and practical, and the other is dogmatic.
A healthy attitude towards science acknowledges that, hey, we can't all build microwaves, and therefore while it's hardly foolish to use one, it's probably worth spending a little time at least curious about how the darn thing functions. An unhealthy one says, "I don't care, I just want my Instant Ramen." Silly example, sure, but I'll bet you don't have to think that hard to come up with a much more dangerous one. Dogmatic faith in science and the technology it produces is dangerous, after all, because technology is a powerful magic.
Friday, March 26, 2010
Wedding Script
Underlines indicate people's instructions, bold indicates things that were read. Italics represent non-verbal instructions. I have not attempted to recapture the stories that were told or the extemporaneous speeches here. You'll just have to imagine.
------------------------------------------
Guests enter and mingle. At as near 12:30 as is reasonable, Jericha enters as Keahi chants, letting everyone know that the ceremony is about to start.
Joe and Monika; then James and Sagen, walk down aisle and set up.
Keahi chants, leading in Paul and Jericha.
Keahi gives brief introduction and describes his chant.
Paul does brief introduction of ceremony.
Paul reads:
From 'Song of Myself,' by Walt Whitman
All truths wait in all things.
They neither hasten their own delivery nor resist it,
They do not need the obstetric forceps of the surgeon,
The insignificant is as big to me as any,
(What is less or more than a touch?)
Logic and sermons never convince,
The damp of the night drives deeper into my soul.
(Only what proves itself to every man and woman is so,
Only what nobody denies is so.)
A minute and a drop of me settle my brain,
I believe the soggy clods shall become lovers and lamps,
And a compend of compends is the meat of a man or woman,
And a summit and a flower there is the feeling they have for each other,
And they are to branch boundlessly out of that lesson until it becomes omnific,
And until one and all shall delight us, and we them.
Jericha introduces the prayer she will read.
Prayer from Abdu'l-Baha
Jericha reads:
O God! Refresh and gladden my spirit. Purify my heart. Illumine my powers. I lay all my affairs in Thy hand. Thou art my Guide and my Refuge. I will no longer be sorrowful and grieved; I will be a happy and joyful being. O God! I will no longer be full of anxiety, nor will I let trouble harass me. I will not dwell on the unpleasant things of life.
O God! Thou art more friend to me than I am to myself. I dedicate myself to Thee, O Lord.
pause
Paul introduces the passage.
From “The Restaurant at the End of the Universe,” by Douglas Adams
Paul reads:
“There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable. There is another theory which states that this has already happened.”
Paul introduces Joe's passage and story.
Jean Paulhan on Love; and Joe will tell a story.
Joe reads:
"For today we hear seemingly normal people, even those with a level head on their shoulders, blithely speaking of love as though it were some frothy feeling of no real consequence. They say it offers many pleasures, and that this contact of two epidermises is not completely devoid of charm. They go on to say that charm or pleasure is most rewarding for the person who is capable of keeping love imaginative, capricious, and above all natural and free. Far be it from me to object, and if it's all that simple for two people of the opposite sex (or even of the same sex) to give each other a good time, then indeed they should, they would be crazy not to. There are only one or two words in all this which disturb me: the word love, and the word free. Needless to say, it is quite the opposite. Love implies dependence - not only in its pleasure but by its very existence and in what precedes its existence: in our very desire to exist - dependence on half a hundred odd little things: on two lips (and the smile or grimace they make), on a shoulder (and the special way it has of rising or falling), on two eyes (and their expression, a little more flirtatious or forbidding), or, when you come down to it, on the whole foreign body, with the mind and soul enclosed therein - a body which is capable at any moment of becoming more dazzling than the sun, more freezing than a tract of snowy waste. To undergo the experience is no fun, you make me laugh with your entreaties. When this body stoops down to fasten the buckle of her dainty shoe, you tremble, and you have the feeling the whole world is watching you."
Joe tells story
pause
Jericha introduces her passage.
From Baha'u'llah
Jericha reads:
The hearts that yearn after Thee, O my God, are burnt up with the fire of their longing for Thee, and the eyes of them that love Thee weep sore by reason of their crushing separation from Thy court, and the voice of the lamentation of such as have set their hopes on Thee hath gone forth throughout Thy dominions.
Thou hast Thyself, O my God, protected them, by Thy sovereign might, from both extremities. But for the burning of their souls and the sighing of their hearts, they would be drowned in the midst of their tears, and but for the flood of their tears they would be burnt up by the fire of their hearts and the heat of their souls. Methinks, they are like the angels which Thou hast created of snow and of fire.
Jericha introduces Monika's poem.
A “Rima” from Gustavo Aldofo Becquer; and Monika will tell a story
Monika reads:
¿Qué es poesía?, dices mientras clavas
en mi pupila tu pupila azul;
¡Qué es poesía! ¿Y tú me lo preguntas?
Poesía... eres tú.
Monika tells story
pause
Paul introduces his quotation.
From “Beyond Good and Evil, ” F. Nietszche
Paul reads:
Supposing truth is a woman - what then? Are there not grounds for the suspicion that all philosophers, insofar as they were dogmatists, have been very inexpert about women? That the gruesome seriousness, the clumsy obtrusiveness with which they have usually approached truth so far have been awkward and very improper methods for winning a woman’s heart?
Paul introduces Sagen's poem
I Have Five Things to Say – by Rumi; and Sagen will tell a story
Sagen reads:
The wakened lover speaks directly to the beloved,
“You are the sky my spirit circles in,
the love inside love, the resurrection-place.
Let this window be your ear.
I have lost consciousness many times
with longing for your listening silence,
and your life-quickening smile.
You give attention to the smallest matters,
my suspicious doubts, and to the greatest.
You know my coins are counterfeit,
but you accept them anyway,
my impudence and my pretending!
I have five things to say,
five fingers to give
into your grace.
First, when I was apart from you,
this world did not exist,
nor any other.
Second, whatever I was looking for
was always you.
Third, why did I ever learn to count to three?
Fourth, my cornfield is burning!
Fifth, this finger stands for Rabia,
and this is for someone else.
Is there a difference?
Are these words or tears?
Is weeping speech?
What shall I do, my love?”
So he speaks, and everyone around
begins to cry with him, laughing crazily,
moaning in the spreading union
of lover and beloved.
This is the true religion. All others
are thrown-away bandages beside it.
This is the sema of slavery and mastery
dancing together. This is not-being.
Neither words, nor any natural fact
can express this.
I know these dancers.
Day and night I sing their songs
in this phenomenal cage.
My soul, don't try to answer now!
Find a friend, and hide.
But what can stay hidden?
Love's secret is always lifting its head
out from under the covers,
“Here I am!”
Sagen tells story
pause
Jericha introduces her passage.
From Baha’u’llah
Jericha reads:
In this journey the seeker reacheth a stage wherein he seeth all created things wandering distracted in search of the Friend. How many a Jacob will he see, hunting after his Joseph; he will behold many a lover, hasting to seek the Beloved, he will witness a world of desiring ones searching after the One Desired. At every moment he findeth a weighty matter, in every hour he becometh aware of a mystery; for he hath taken his heart away from both worlds, and set out for the Ka'bih of the Beloved. At every step, aid from the Invisible Realm will attend him and the heat of his search will grow.
One must judge of search by the standard of the Majnun of Love. It is related that one day they came upon Majnun sifting the dust, and his tears flowing down. They said, "What doest thou?" He said, "I seek for Layli." They cried, "Alas for thee! Layli is of pure spirit, and thou seekest her in the dust!" He said, "I seek her everywhere; haply somewhere I shall find her."
Jericha introduces James
James will tell a story and then lead us in a song.
James tells last story
James instructs audience to stand, leads everyone in singing “Simple Gifts / Lord of the Dance / Ode to Joy:”
'Tis a gift to be simple, 'tis a gift to be free,
'Tis a gift to come down where we ought to be,And when we find ourselves in the place just right,
It will be in the valley of love and delight.
When true simplicity is gain'd,
To bow and to bend we will not be asham'd,
To turn and turn will be our delight
'Till by turning, turning we come round right.
The moon in her phases and the tides of the sea
The movement of the Earth and the seasons that will be
Are the rhythm of the dancing and a promise through the year
That the dance goes on through our joy and tears
Dance, then, whoever you may be
I am the Lord of the Dance, said he!
And I'll lead you all, wherever you may be
I will lead you all in the Dance with me.
I danced in the morning when the world was begun
I danced in the moon and the stars and the sun
They buried my body and they thought that I had gone
But I am the Dance and I still go on!
Dance, dance, whoever you may be
I am the Lord of the Dance, said he!
And I'll lead you all, wherever you may be
I will lead you all in the Dance with me.
A moment of joy is a spark divine
When you drink it in your soul begins to shine,
And you'll find yourself full of peace and light,
At last in the valley of love and delight!
Love, peace, and joy will bring
The world's men and women under their wing
And together we will dance and together we will sing
And all through the valley our joy will ring!
Audience cheers, James signals them to sit down. James introduces vows.
Paul and Jericha turn towards each other.
Paul reads to Jericha:
O me! O life! Of the questions of these recurring,
Of the endless trains of the faithless, of cities fill'd with the foolish,
Of myself forever reproaching myself, (for who more foolish than I, and who more faithless?)
Of eyes that vainly crave the light, of the objects mean, of the struggle ever renew'd,
Of the poor results of all, of the plodding and sordid crowds I see around me,
Of the empty and useless years of the rest, with the rest me intertwined,
The question, O me! So sad, recurring – What good amid these, O me, O life?
Answer.
That you are here – that life exists and identity,
That the powerful play goes on, and you may contribute a verse.
Jericha reads to Paul:
Our union is like this:
You feel cold
So I reach for a blanket to cover
Our shivering feet.
A hunger comes into your body
So I run to my garden
And start digging potatoes.
You ask for a few words of comfort and guidance,
I quickly kneel at your side offering you
A whole book--
As a gift.
You ache with loneliness one night
So much you weep
And I say,
Here's a rope,
Tie it around me,
I
Will be your companion
For life.
Paul and Jericha pass books to Joe and Monika.
James and Sagen present rings and leis.
Paul takes Jericha's ring and lei.
Paul says final line:
We will all, verily, abide by the will of God.
Places ring on her finger, and lei around neck.
Jericha takes Paul's ring and lei, turns and says:
We will all, verily, abide by the will of God.
Places ring on his finger, and lei around neck.
Paul and Jericha kiss.
Keahi closes ceremony with brief statement, then chants leading Paul and Jericha off, followed by James and Sagen, then Monika and Joe.
Sunday, November 1, 2009
Beethoven Quotations
"I despise a world which does not feel that music is a higher revelation than all wisdom and philosophy."
“Music is the mediator between the spiritual and the sensual life.”
“Music is the one incorporeal entrance into the higher world of knowledge which comprehends mankind but which mankind cannot comprehend.”
“What you are, you are by accident of birth; what I am, I am by myself. There are and will be a thousand princes; there is only one Beethoven.” - said to a Prince who, as you might guess, elicited the ire of Mr. Beethoven.
“No friend have I. I must live by myself alone; but I know well that God is nearer to me than others in my art, so I will walk fearlessly with Him.”
"The barriers are not erected which can say to aspiring talents and industry, 'Thus far and no farther.'"
And his dying words: "Applaud friends, the comedy is over."
While his music perhaps gives a stronger sense of who Beethoven is than his words do, it is also easy for our modern ears - which have grown accustomed to a different kind of music - to dismiss Beethoven as grumpy, violent, or sad. He is none of those things. His music is some of the most emotionally charged and passionate ever written, but he also composed some of the most humorous, joyful, and spiritual music of his era. What makes Beethoven so remarkable is that he manages to be all of those things - grumpy, humorous, violent, joyful, sad, and spiritual - all at once. He is an exquisitely human composer who knows how to reach into the depths of the human spirit, and to laugh while doing it.
(Though not so much on the joyful, playful side - at least not obviously so - this is an excellent recording of the "Appassionata" sonata. Do yourself a favor and at least listen to the last couple minutes, though of course the whole thing is amazing.)