Sunday, May 13, 2012

Twenty Seven Worlds

1

Eden was never paradise. The scorched eluvium was proof that Mephistopheles was as much its master as anyone, if one would but dig. The virgin topsoil lied.

2

I sometimes wonder why so many places are named after saints. As if holiness could be inhabited without its deathly menace destroying even the most libidinous heart.

3

Dante, in his descent, came across a mausoleum of dead souls which had ceased to exist, as if this were a more horrible punishment than eternal torture.

4

Wherever I have gone, I have never ceased to carry with me homes I have never seen, let alone inhabited. Somewhere in Inverness Lady MacBeth still washes.

5

The past is no foreign country, nor is it fiction. It is a world much like our own, in which the men and women lived despite history.

6

John was also a poet. The origin of man was reason. The foundation was logic. Principally, there were stories. Translation, it seems, is the apotheosis of deception.

7

In Hawaii there is an island called Maui. Before it was covered in fake grass and tourists, it was fished from the ocean by an unsuspecting demigod.

8

Ought they to have called Venus by Aphrodite instead? The longer name makes up in grace what it loses in pith. Love is better graceful than pithy.

9

A symphony can be a love story, battling nations, or the birth of the universe. Even were it all of these, it might put someone to sleep.

10

The same infinite spaces that terrify Blaise Pascal inspire George Lucas to invent aliens with funny heads. But for each man, those infinite spaces are the same.

11

Perhaps so many movies are bland because no one bothered to come up with a better name than "movie." Or perhaps the causality is hard to decipher.

12

Virtual worlds are as real to those who live in them as fictional ones are to those who invent them. Middle Earth and Facebook matter in nonbeing.

13

I do not say that the soul exists, but I equally do not say that it does not exist. Not saying allows me to inhabit either world.

14

Supposing the Earth were a baseball, it would take a very large being indeed to grab and throw it. And what would such a being stand on?

15

A world can be as small as an automobile, if that automobile is sufficiently unusual. In particular, if it orbits a star and is actually a planet.

16

Euphemia is a dangerous place. Everything sounds more innocent than it is. Watching one's tongue can lead to a harsher world because soft words convey less meaning.

17

What would you say if I told you that Eden was not a place, but the psuedonym of a heavily tattoed adult actress of a kinky persuasion?

18

Jack Kerouac was right about women, beauty, and how you have to swing (and swing and so on). But he was wrong about the handkerchief and Buddhism.

19

Two of the wisest people I have known taught me two wise things. Good teachers know how to lie, and good scholars know how to choose failure.

20

Philosophers are good teachers and good scholars. In Artistotle's world nobody ever bothered to drop a boulder and a marble from a window. Maybe he actually knew.

21

I have driven through New Mexico on I-25, noticing that we make reservations for dinner and for the survivors of genocide. We prefer the former whenever possible.

22

If the objective of being is to achieve nonbeing, as our wantonly Westernized readings of the Buddha suggest, then Wagner may have been as wrong as Kerouac.

23

'On the other hand' is a phrase that proves that language has nothing to do with words, and everything to do with gesture, context, and Hegelian dialectic.

24

The best of the great poets have always been those who concealed beneath their flattery of the world equal measure of contempt and lust for its inhabitants.

25

In my dreams I have loved a woman in whom I saw a better me. Awake I love a woman in whom I see a better humanity.

26

Have you caught my meaning? I pray you, let me know if you have, for I fear I have once again tricked myself into believing I meant.

27

The difference between the living and the dead is that the living fabricate endless beautiful, fantastical, fictional worlds, while the dead compose all of our real ones.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

Creative Writing, Draft Two

This summer I'll be teaching a Creative Writing class at Punahou for the second year in a row. Last year's class was a lot of fun, both because it gave me an opportunity to help my students tap into their creativity and because it compelled me to be creative as well. I'm looking forward to that opportunity this summer, especially as a kind of counter-balance to the kind of writing I have to do for my courses here. With a few notable exceptions, I'm rarely pushed to produce synthetically creative work as a PhD student, as analysis is the touchstone of academic discourse. That is not to condemn the academy by any means, but rather to point out that there are forms of writing it does not necessarily value, but which I still enjoy.

Last year I wrote a post about my curriculum writing process. I outlined the early stages of my backwards design process, the effort to determine an "enduring understanding" for my students, and the pitfalls of biting off too small or too big a goal. The results of this process I captured, at least in part, at the beginning of the course. I don't think I ever got around to writing a retrospective, but suffice to say the course was a blast, the students had a great time, and apparently I was well-behaved enough to be asked back this summer.

Which means that it's time to rewrite and revise. Writing a Creative Writing curriculum is a particularly recursive kind of activity, because the very principles you're trying to teach are - at least in part - the kinds of things you have to employ while constructing the course. Among these is the conviction that revision is necessary. For all of the successes in last year's course, there's so much that I want to do better, so many activities that I want to restructure, so many learning experiences that could be improved.

Perhaps the biggest weakness of my curriculum last summer was its overly workshop-y feel. That is, I treated the course more like a summer camp than a class. On some level this was appropriate, especially because I did select individual activities such that they all revolved around a small number of central themes. However, I believe that the summer school affords the opportunity for a more sustained engagement with a particular text or project than I attempted last year. With that in mind, I'm planning on expanding on a small set of activities I used last year concerning Italo Calvino's Invisible Cities.

In addition to being one of my favorite books, Invisible Cities is a wonderful jumping-off point for creative writing. It stands at the intersection of poetry and prose, traditional storytelling and vignette, abstraction and minute, concrete detail. My students struggled to understand the bits of it we tried to read in class last year. Until I sent them out to campus and had them write their own vignettes about Punahou. Invisible Punahou has been percolating in my mind ever since, and I think this year's class will create it.

So we'll spend more than a day with Calvino. We'll read him carefully, try to understand what he's doing and how he's doing it, and, most importantly, create our own version of the story. The purpose of doing so is to collaboratively create, through sustained engagement with a particular text and with a series of writing tasks and activities, a story that describes the campus that these students have spent the better part of their academic lives wandering.

There will be other revisions to the course as well, though none so significant as this sustained project. I have revamped and reworded my central purposes, making them more forceful and more meaningful. I have cut activities that didn't work last year, expanded those that needed it, and substituted in some new ideas. Above all, I have made space to better walk the tightrope that all teachers must walk between careful design and student freedom. I plan to enforce sustained engagement with Calvino, but the project will proceed very much on my students' terms. They will be the authors of whatever it is we produce. They will wield the creative power.

Monday, April 16, 2012

A Unifying Thread

Note: Long time no-see here on the blog. Such is PhD student life.


I had a conversation with my advisor yesterday in which I asked him what the unifying idea that runs through his research is. Roy has studied math, writing, science, and a host of other topics in his research, and has been at times a philosopher, at times a psychologist, and at times something resembling an ethnographer. He's a guru of video data analysis, but that's far from his only analytical methodology. In short, he's as multi-faceted as they come, and among his current advisees alone there is a huge range of interests and projects.

It should come as no surprise, however, that he could condense his work into a single sentence. He studies the way that emerging symbols and representations of knowledge can change student learning and understanding (that's not exactly what he said, but it's close). This got me thinking. One of my biggest struggles as an early PhD student has been defining my research interests. In short, I have too many. Almost no interesting question is unappealing to me, in a range of areas.

There are, however, some ideas that have started to rise to the top of my focus. In particular, I'm becoming very interested in the possibilities of two branches of what gets called "computational social science." The first is natural language processing (NLP), and the second is agent-based modeling (ABM). I won't go into detail about what those entail here, as a cursory web search will give at least a decent idea. Rather, I want to talk a little about how I've started to use these techniques, and to observe something about them that I think is salient to defining what my unifying thread is and will be.

Both NLP and ABM are ways of reconceptualizing what counts as data and how to analyze it. NLP takes text - a form of data which we usually look at according to some theory of reading (like hermeneutics) - and redefines it as a "big data" set. That is, instead of looking at specific meaning in specific places in a text, NLP can help uncover aggregate trends in the use of language. For example, a recent paper I wrote for a doctoral proseminar included an analysis of how Salman Khan uses language in his first four lessons about fractions. Watching those videos certainly tells you a lot, but even something as simple as word counts uncovers surprising information, like Khan's almost non-existent use of interrogative words like "what" or "why." That alone says nothing about his quality as a teacher, but it does say something about how he teaches, and what the technology he uses affords him from a linguistic standpoint. Needless to say, this is a project I'm hoping to expand upon.

ABM, on the other hand, is less about analyzing data and more about performing complex though-experiments that you would not otherwise be able to undertake. ABM is known in the social sciences and hard sciences for overthrowing misconceived paradigms of both human and animal activity. The classic example is bird flocking behavior. For a long time, it was believed that birds followed a "leader" bird while flocking, and that they traded off being the leader. Essentially, the hypothesis was that each individual bird just did as he was told by the leader via some arcane communication system. Enter ABM. A new hypothesis suggested that, instead of a leader, each bird followed a very small set of simple rules (namely, get closer to other birds, but not too close; move away from another bird if too close; turn to try to face the same direction as nearby other birds). Creating hundreds of randomized agents in a computer program and giving them these rules to follow produces, in a short amount of time, an almost perfect analogue to the flocking behavior we see in nature.

There has been little work using ABM in education, but another student and I are adopting and adapting some of the work of Paulo Blikstein as a part of our research assistantship. We've been working on a model that represents the process of sharing a technological artifact in a classroom task. One of Paulo's papers using ABM alongside empirical data suggests that collaborative classroom tasks often lead to the assigning of roles based upon ability, which means that more advanced students end up doing most of the cognition unless specific role sharing is assigned and enforced. Similarly, our model viewed alongside video data suggests that it is vitally important that students share representations of data while doing scientific inquiry, lest the student holding the representation do all of the cognitive work.

These two projects - running Khan's teaching through some NLP paces and analyzing inquiry data through ABM - on the surface have little in common. Except that both are ways of reconceptualizing data, as I said above, and both are computational. This, then, forms an important part of the thread that I see running through both the work that I'm doing now and the work that I've done in the past. It's not data, per se, that I'm oriented towards, but rather re-imagining the bounds of what we can do with a given idea.

The thread that unifies my thinking is this: I hope to find and use new ways of thinking about and representing ideas and questions such that seemingly oppositional knowledge structures can be synthesized so that they can become more meaningful. Essentially, I'm describing a dialectical process. However, I don't believe that its an entirely phenomenological one. That is, I don't follow Hegel the whole way: there's more than interpretation here, there's also creativity.

Necessarily, the synthesis of oppositional knowledge structures requires pulling away from the depths of either. Hyper-specialization in the pejorative sense of knowing more and more about less and less has always been counterproductive, but here is is particularly problematic. Too often, increasingly detailed knowledge about a given area does not move the area forward, except by a very narrow definition of "forward" that applies only within the field. Rather, the most important innovations in the history of almost any science come from moving backward so far that previously separate knowledge structures collide, get blown apart, and reintegrate facing a new and altogether more productive direction.

That's all oversimplified, on the one hand, and hopelessly unclear on the other. Nevertheless, I think it's a good starting point for defining an academic identity for myself that incorporates both my wide range of passions and the need to have a clear self-definition.

On a somewhat different note, I also hope that I won't be away from the blog for two full months this time. I've been struggling with where this blog fits in my academic life, whether to continue it at all, whether to start a new one, or what. For now, anyway, I've decided that this one can stay. In fact, "Nicht Diese Tone," while not the most marketable slogan, ultimately does capture very well the core of my intellectual project.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

On Choosing to Learn

In my Learning Sciences and Technology Design seminar we recently read a draft of an upcoming book by Dan Schwartz, a Professor here at Stanford. He argues that we need to reconsider our assumptions about assessment in order to better capture the things we actually care about as educators. Instead of evaluating student knowledge, understanding, or even skills, he argues, we should try to assess student choices. That is, what a information or skills a student knows, and even her ability to learn further information or skills is not as important as the decision to learn.

That choices are central to how we move through the world is perhaps obvious, but it is striking how infrequently choice is a core part of any assessment framework (multiple-choice tests certainly do not count as "choice" in the sense that Dr. Schwartz means it). Even forward-thinking educators tend to focus more on acquisition of skills or overly-ambiguous notions of "metacognition" or "critical thinking" than on the specifics of decision making.  And specifics are the keys.  "Making good choices" is as bad a curricular goal as "being able to organize the following events chronologically."  A better option is a synthesis of the two, perhaps something to the effect of: "Given the task of explaining a historical event, choosing to organize parts of that event chronologically."

It seems to me that little education - indeed, even little of my own education, excellent though it has been - is organized around this kind of formulation. I believe that the most successful students end up adopting good strategies and making good choices, but Denise Pope's Doing School (about which I've written previously) suggests that a great many of our most successful students (if grades are our standard for success) in fact make terrible choices, ethically, academically, and even physically.

For my own part, I am struck by how often the schools I've attended - even Stanford - have not only tacitly accepted but in fact actively encouraged poor choices and unhealthy habits.  And I don't just mean ambiguous moral choices, but concrete habits of mind and academic practice. For example, in spite of Stanford's ostensible lack of concern over grades, their various administrative policy practically forces students to waste hours of time engaged in a gamey calculus over which courses to take credit/no-credit, and which to take for a grade. If I choose not to engage in this practice, I put myself at a disadvantage in terms of various small-scale political interactions that are inevitable in a graduate school.   On the other hand, the process itself, besides consuming intellectual energy better spend elsewhere, has undesirable effects on the way students engage with the particular courses they are not taking for a grade and the way professors engage with those students.

In other words, by separating this seemingly administrative cultural artifact from the curriculum, we've set up a situation where knowledge and skills are within the purview of the course, but where the most important actual decision making is made at an institutional level.  In graduate school - which is at least theoretically preparation for a life in the academy - this is perhaps not overly troubling, but as we shift our gaze to undergraduate or k-12 education, it's easy to see that students are often well-taught to make bad learning choices by the broader curricula and institutions in which they find themselves.  My rule of thumb for this kind of supposition is simple: if Stanford's graduate programs have a fundamental pedagogical or curricular problem, odds are that same problem can be found - and, indeed, is probably worse - at earlier stages of the education system.

So what is there to do? Unfortunately, it seems to me that this problem is virtually intractable in our current education system because it is endemic not merely to our curricula and pedagogy, but to our very culture, our policies, our institutions, and even our economics.  That is, there is a good reason we teach bad choices in schools: because our political, economic, and social systems are built upon the majority of people making bad choices.

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Stop SOPA and PIPA

In support of the ongoing blackouts and various web-based protests to ongoing legislation in the US House and Senate, I encourage my readers to go to contact their representatives.  This site will tell you who to call.  Thank you.