Showing posts with label Pitchers and Poets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pitchers and Poets. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Podcasting
Just wanted to let my readers know that earlier today I joined Eric Nusbaum and Ted Walker from Pitchers and Poets on their regular podcast. Zip over to the post and give it a listen.
Labels:
Pitchers and Poets,
podcast
Thursday, March 31, 2011
Shakespeare Lives in Topeka
Thanks to Pitchers and Poets I just read this somewhat infuriating article by Bill James (general smart guy and honorary father of modern Sabermetrics, for those of you who don't know him). Eric Nusbaum does a nice critique of the salient logical fallacies of the article, but I have my own entirely more pretentious and cultural axe to grind. Upon doing so in the comments, I realized that I had written a blog post, so I transfered the thing over and made a couple edits and additions. Enjoy.
Are we great at producing athletes? Of course we are. But to say that we don't develop great writers or philosophers or artists or whatever in our society is total and utter hogwash. We produce a whole lot of great thinkers, and, thanks to 1) increased access to great ideas of both the past and present, 2) more sophisticated and far-reaching networks, and 3) improved social justice, I would guess that we're producing just as many if not more great thinkers per capita as Shakespeare's London.
Now, it is certainly true that we don't value great thinkers commercially as much as we do athletes, thanks to the nature of consumption of their respective products, but one need only spend a few hours in a university library somewhere to see that there's a whole hell of a lot of darn good writing going on in the world (and, hey, save the gas and spend some time surfing the interwebs or even *gasp* watching television, since a lot of darn good writing is happening both of those mediums, as well; people are writing and reading more now than at any time in history).
Is contemporary writing "great" writing? Well, what does "great" even mean? Doesn't a big part of Shakespeare's greatness come from the hundreds of years of cultural and academic narrative we've built around his work? I'm not arguing against it's inherent quality, but as silly as that would be, it's equally silly to claim that no one writing today is as good as Shakespeare. Indeed, I would argue that there might be dozens or even hundreds (or even, dare I suggest, thousands or tens of thousands) of writers today with both the natural talent and the refined sensibilities to match Shakespeare. The reality is, we don't have the lens of history through which to look at the present, and we don't have the time to compare all of those potential Topekan Shakespeares to old Will, so it's impossible to really know.
What's more, our whole cultural paradigm has shifted. No longer is there a single Canon of great works that everyone reads, certainly not among works produced in the last half-century. Instead, there are sub-cultures and sub-canons. Whereas the work of producing great literature, art, and philosophy was once concentrated in the hands of a select few masters, now that same work is distributed across vast networks of vaguely interconnected domains. The result: umpteen great writers with talent and determination and good educations and so on, most of whom do not fail to be considered great because of the quality of their work, but because they simply never find much of an audience. Remember, most of us had to be forced to read Shakespeare in school, anyway (and many students just read the cliff notes), and that's freaking Shakespeare. How much more likely are we to ignore a modern writer of equal quality, but whose work is not forced down our throats?
In short, it's silly to ignore all of the vast cultural differences between Shakespearean London and modern Topeka (or anywhere else). I'm as much a fan of the notion of something eternal in human experience as anyone, and I also happen to think that reading Shakespeare (and Bacon, and Kant, and Plato, and Hegel, and so on) is a good idea. But you can't just call writers from before 1900 "Great" and write off modernity. You can't claim that some seminal works of the past might be closer to capital-T Truth without acknowledging that the way in which times have changed has had a profound impact on the process of thinking, writing, the organization of society, and our notions of greatness.
Are we great at producing athletes? Of course we are. But to say that we don't develop great writers or philosophers or artists or whatever in our society is total and utter hogwash. We produce a whole lot of great thinkers, and, thanks to 1) increased access to great ideas of both the past and present, 2) more sophisticated and far-reaching networks, and 3) improved social justice, I would guess that we're producing just as many if not more great thinkers per capita as Shakespeare's London.
Now, it is certainly true that we don't value great thinkers commercially as much as we do athletes, thanks to the nature of consumption of their respective products, but one need only spend a few hours in a university library somewhere to see that there's a whole hell of a lot of darn good writing going on in the world (and, hey, save the gas and spend some time surfing the interwebs or even *gasp* watching television, since a lot of darn good writing is happening both of those mediums, as well; people are writing and reading more now than at any time in history).
Is contemporary writing "great" writing? Well, what does "great" even mean? Doesn't a big part of Shakespeare's greatness come from the hundreds of years of cultural and academic narrative we've built around his work? I'm not arguing against it's inherent quality, but as silly as that would be, it's equally silly to claim that no one writing today is as good as Shakespeare. Indeed, I would argue that there might be dozens or even hundreds (or even, dare I suggest, thousands or tens of thousands) of writers today with both the natural talent and the refined sensibilities to match Shakespeare. The reality is, we don't have the lens of history through which to look at the present, and we don't have the time to compare all of those potential Topekan Shakespeares to old Will, so it's impossible to really know.
What's more, our whole cultural paradigm has shifted. No longer is there a single Canon of great works that everyone reads, certainly not among works produced in the last half-century. Instead, there are sub-cultures and sub-canons. Whereas the work of producing great literature, art, and philosophy was once concentrated in the hands of a select few masters, now that same work is distributed across vast networks of vaguely interconnected domains. The result: umpteen great writers with talent and determination and good educations and so on, most of whom do not fail to be considered great because of the quality of their work, but because they simply never find much of an audience. Remember, most of us had to be forced to read Shakespeare in school, anyway (and many students just read the cliff notes), and that's freaking Shakespeare. How much more likely are we to ignore a modern writer of equal quality, but whose work is not forced down our throats?
In short, it's silly to ignore all of the vast cultural differences between Shakespearean London and modern Topeka (or anywhere else). I'm as much a fan of the notion of something eternal in human experience as anyone, and I also happen to think that reading Shakespeare (and Bacon, and Kant, and Plato, and Hegel, and so on) is a good idea. But you can't just call writers from before 1900 "Great" and write off modernity. You can't claim that some seminal works of the past might be closer to capital-T Truth without acknowledging that the way in which times have changed has had a profound impact on the process of thinking, writing, the organization of society, and our notions of greatness.
Labels:
Bill James,
culture,
Great Books,
greatness,
literature,
Pitchers and Poets,
Shakespeare,
society,
sports,
writing
Wednesday, November 3, 2010
New Pitchers and Poets Post
Venture over to Pitchers and Poets for a new post by yours truly! That is all.
Labels:
Pitchers and Poets
Thursday, September 2, 2010
The Specialist and the Generalist
A recent Pitchers and Poets podcast spoke to an issue about which I have a strong opinion. I suppose I have a great many strong opinions - or at least I present them strongly - but I would argue that the vast majority of those remain conditional. It is important, I think, to be open-minded enough to be persuaded by a contrary, or more likely, an entirely new perspective on an issue.
For my own part, my political convictions - which were (and are) quite strong - have undergone quite a few radical shifts since I first was granted the right to vote. The outcome of that was, in the 2008 election, a ballot which included at least one vote for a member of each of the following parties: Democrat, Republican, Libertarian, Green, and Independent. Why? Because I felt, in each of those races, that the party in question was irrelevant, and that the person most capable of doing the job was worthy of my vote. Anyway, the point here is not to discuss politics, but to point out that even what seems a fervent position on my part is liable to change if I am confronted with a valid alternative that seems compelling enough. At the very least, I am easily persuaded by nuance, especially nuance that takes on accepted cultural narratives.
There is, however, one duality which I reluctantly accept, and about which I firmly and probably irrevocably believe in one position. That duality is specialization versus generalization, or the competing ideas that a person should focus on learning a small number of things exceedingly well, on the one hand, or a large number of things in less depth. Of course, as Ted and Eric point out in their podcast, we live in a time where being a generalist is almost impossible. Specialization has so much won the day that it's practically a sin to have too many interests.
Of course, I think it's difficult to draw an exact line between the specialist and the generalist. How many fields must one study to be a generalist? How advanced must a person's knowledge of a particular field be in order to qualify as a specialist? What about people who are somewhere in between? And, moreover, isn't the true generalist also a specialist in some sense?
All of those are valid questions, and I think the duality here is - like most dualities - not totally fair. I believe there are a great many people who are, in fact, both generalists and specialists, and there's no reason those things have to be mutually exclusive. I think there is, however, a marked difference in mentality between the two. It is especially rare to find someone who will advocate specialization whilst also celebrating the "Renaissance Man," as we like to call generalists (implying their anachronism).
It seems to me, however, that this is a horrible mistake, and particularly important in education. A lot of what people say is "wrong" with education amounts to this: it's not specialized enough. Certainly it's not fair to look at students and to say that they all need the exact same, incredibly broad education, but it's also not fair to say that we should tailor everything we teach to some appropriate and predetermined career pathway for each student. Specialization, at its extreme, suggests that students should not learn anything that isn't directly relevant to what they're going to do in their lives. Of course, the extreme generalist learns anything completely regardless of its value, which is equally silly, but that's the point. Going to an extreme here is bad, and these days, as we cut arts programs, recess time, and gym class, we're much closer to the extreme of specialization.
The reason this debate is important in education, however, reaches far beyond the classroom. It is in our adult lives where we, generally speaking, are forced to specialize most. Indeed, the older we get and the further along we go in our career paths, the more and more narrow our focus becomes. Professors at most Universities don't just study a field (like Sociology) or even a sub-field (like the Sociology of Business), but a specific aspect of that sub-field (like gender relations in rural small businesses, or some such). At a certain point, the robust thought processes that shaped the original study become so fine that, I would argue, they are no longer useful.
The same could be said in the business world. One of the reasons we have such a strongly established hierarchical structure in business - besides being a vestige of feudalism - is the fact that all of the specialists that make multi-national corporations go can't speak to each other without an interpreter. The fact of being able to talk to the IT guy, the operations guy, the finances guy, and the engineer, and the ability to translate between those branches is, as far as I'm concerned, the primary function of most executives at major companies. Making decisions and selling the company are of minor importance by comparison.
Unlike in academia, however, in business there is an established method for getting specialists to interact, and it mostly works. Indeed, if specialization didn't work, we wouldn't use it. It's almost impossible to argue with specialization, in fact, from within our existing social and economic system, because of how effective it is. The point, however, is that if we step outside of the specialized world and look at the other consequences of a society built around the extreme specialist, it's not quite as pretty as it seems from the inside.
Bertrand Russell was fond of pointing out that things like useless knowledge and idle inquiry are vital to a person's happiness. A child does not ask questions because he wants to master his world, but merely because he is curious. Over time, curiosity tends to diminish and ambition increase, and as a result people become more successful and less happy. Education, from my perspective, works best not when it forwards a person's professional goals, but when it reminds him or her that there are other important goals as well. What good is money if you are so specialized that you don't know where and when to spend it? What good is success if you are so specialized that you can't have a conversation with anyone?
From the individual point of view, specialization, I think, can be somewhat soul-crushing. A professor I had at Stanford told me that the day he got tenure was one of the best and saddest of his life. Best because he was secure and successful, saddest because it meant he was locked in, all of the potential paths he might take had been narrowed to one that he had taken and would take from then on. Why must we do that to people? Does our society benefit so much that taking away the wonder of exploration and inquiry into ideas unknown and unconsidered is necessary?
The answer, I think, is clearly no. Our society may benefit from specialization in that we are able to produce more goods, more "knowledge" (which so few people can use, because it's highly specialized), and more advertising. But isn't one of the biggest problems we face as a world that we produce too much? There are too many people on the world, eating too much food, using too much plastic, guzzling too much gas, and wasting too much electricity. It's all well and good to address those problems by creating legions of conservation specialists, I suppose, but wouldn't it be better to just ease up off the ever-racing production line? Indeed, it seems to me a self-perpetuating cycle. Less specialized work means more generalization, more "Renaissance Men" who can step back and see that, hey, the world is a better place when we communicate more and produce less.
Again, I don't advocate the extreme, here, else nothing at all would get done and we'd all starve, but it seems to me that we've ventured too far in the direction of specialization. What's more, my other fervently held opinions - that process is more important than outcome, and that cooperation is generally a better model than competition - seem to me to be complementary here. Specialization encourages competition, which in turn is concerned with outcomes. Generalization encourages cooperation, which is much more about processes (stuff like how people work together and whether they're doing the right thing) than outcomes.
All told, it's unlikely that we'll see a world of generalists anytime soon. But it is the case, in my experience, that we "Renaissance Men" have serious advantages, even in this society, over extreme specialists. Generalists learn to say "both... and..." while specialists are stuck with "either... or..." As a teacher, there's no bigger selling point: generalists get to be leaders and visionaries, while specialists have to do what they're told. As a human being, I believe my breadth of interests may make it harder for me to define myself to other people, but it makes it easier for me to move around joyfully and inquisitively. And, really, what else is there?
For my own part, my political convictions - which were (and are) quite strong - have undergone quite a few radical shifts since I first was granted the right to vote. The outcome of that was, in the 2008 election, a ballot which included at least one vote for a member of each of the following parties: Democrat, Republican, Libertarian, Green, and Independent. Why? Because I felt, in each of those races, that the party in question was irrelevant, and that the person most capable of doing the job was worthy of my vote. Anyway, the point here is not to discuss politics, but to point out that even what seems a fervent position on my part is liable to change if I am confronted with a valid alternative that seems compelling enough. At the very least, I am easily persuaded by nuance, especially nuance that takes on accepted cultural narratives.
There is, however, one duality which I reluctantly accept, and about which I firmly and probably irrevocably believe in one position. That duality is specialization versus generalization, or the competing ideas that a person should focus on learning a small number of things exceedingly well, on the one hand, or a large number of things in less depth. Of course, as Ted and Eric point out in their podcast, we live in a time where being a generalist is almost impossible. Specialization has so much won the day that it's practically a sin to have too many interests.
Of course, I think it's difficult to draw an exact line between the specialist and the generalist. How many fields must one study to be a generalist? How advanced must a person's knowledge of a particular field be in order to qualify as a specialist? What about people who are somewhere in between? And, moreover, isn't the true generalist also a specialist in some sense?
All of those are valid questions, and I think the duality here is - like most dualities - not totally fair. I believe there are a great many people who are, in fact, both generalists and specialists, and there's no reason those things have to be mutually exclusive. I think there is, however, a marked difference in mentality between the two. It is especially rare to find someone who will advocate specialization whilst also celebrating the "Renaissance Man," as we like to call generalists (implying their anachronism).
It seems to me, however, that this is a horrible mistake, and particularly important in education. A lot of what people say is "wrong" with education amounts to this: it's not specialized enough. Certainly it's not fair to look at students and to say that they all need the exact same, incredibly broad education, but it's also not fair to say that we should tailor everything we teach to some appropriate and predetermined career pathway for each student. Specialization, at its extreme, suggests that students should not learn anything that isn't directly relevant to what they're going to do in their lives. Of course, the extreme generalist learns anything completely regardless of its value, which is equally silly, but that's the point. Going to an extreme here is bad, and these days, as we cut arts programs, recess time, and gym class, we're much closer to the extreme of specialization.
The reason this debate is important in education, however, reaches far beyond the classroom. It is in our adult lives where we, generally speaking, are forced to specialize most. Indeed, the older we get and the further along we go in our career paths, the more and more narrow our focus becomes. Professors at most Universities don't just study a field (like Sociology) or even a sub-field (like the Sociology of Business), but a specific aspect of that sub-field (like gender relations in rural small businesses, or some such). At a certain point, the robust thought processes that shaped the original study become so fine that, I would argue, they are no longer useful.
The same could be said in the business world. One of the reasons we have such a strongly established hierarchical structure in business - besides being a vestige of feudalism - is the fact that all of the specialists that make multi-national corporations go can't speak to each other without an interpreter. The fact of being able to talk to the IT guy, the operations guy, the finances guy, and the engineer, and the ability to translate between those branches is, as far as I'm concerned, the primary function of most executives at major companies. Making decisions and selling the company are of minor importance by comparison.
Unlike in academia, however, in business there is an established method for getting specialists to interact, and it mostly works. Indeed, if specialization didn't work, we wouldn't use it. It's almost impossible to argue with specialization, in fact, from within our existing social and economic system, because of how effective it is. The point, however, is that if we step outside of the specialized world and look at the other consequences of a society built around the extreme specialist, it's not quite as pretty as it seems from the inside.
Bertrand Russell was fond of pointing out that things like useless knowledge and idle inquiry are vital to a person's happiness. A child does not ask questions because he wants to master his world, but merely because he is curious. Over time, curiosity tends to diminish and ambition increase, and as a result people become more successful and less happy. Education, from my perspective, works best not when it forwards a person's professional goals, but when it reminds him or her that there are other important goals as well. What good is money if you are so specialized that you don't know where and when to spend it? What good is success if you are so specialized that you can't have a conversation with anyone?
From the individual point of view, specialization, I think, can be somewhat soul-crushing. A professor I had at Stanford told me that the day he got tenure was one of the best and saddest of his life. Best because he was secure and successful, saddest because it meant he was locked in, all of the potential paths he might take had been narrowed to one that he had taken and would take from then on. Why must we do that to people? Does our society benefit so much that taking away the wonder of exploration and inquiry into ideas unknown and unconsidered is necessary?
The answer, I think, is clearly no. Our society may benefit from specialization in that we are able to produce more goods, more "knowledge" (which so few people can use, because it's highly specialized), and more advertising. But isn't one of the biggest problems we face as a world that we produce too much? There are too many people on the world, eating too much food, using too much plastic, guzzling too much gas, and wasting too much electricity. It's all well and good to address those problems by creating legions of conservation specialists, I suppose, but wouldn't it be better to just ease up off the ever-racing production line? Indeed, it seems to me a self-perpetuating cycle. Less specialized work means more generalization, more "Renaissance Men" who can step back and see that, hey, the world is a better place when we communicate more and produce less.
Again, I don't advocate the extreme, here, else nothing at all would get done and we'd all starve, but it seems to me that we've ventured too far in the direction of specialization. What's more, my other fervently held opinions - that process is more important than outcome, and that cooperation is generally a better model than competition - seem to me to be complementary here. Specialization encourages competition, which in turn is concerned with outcomes. Generalization encourages cooperation, which is much more about processes (stuff like how people work together and whether they're doing the right thing) than outcomes.
All told, it's unlikely that we'll see a world of generalists anytime soon. But it is the case, in my experience, that we "Renaissance Men" have serious advantages, even in this society, over extreme specialists. Generalists learn to say "both... and..." while specialists are stuck with "either... or..." As a teacher, there's no bigger selling point: generalists get to be leaders and visionaries, while specialists have to do what they're told. As a human being, I believe my breadth of interests may make it harder for me to define myself to other people, but it makes it easier for me to move around joyfully and inquisitively. And, really, what else is there?
Monday, July 19, 2010
Pitchers and Poets
Hopefully I have time to write a proper post this week, but no promises. This is crunch time on the MA project, so I'm fairly busy.
In the meantime, zip over to Pitchers and Poets, one of my favorite baseball blogs. You may recognize the author of their latest post.
In the meantime, zip over to Pitchers and Poets, one of my favorite baseball blogs. You may recognize the author of their latest post.
Labels:
Pitchers and Poets
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)