Sunday, March 27, 2011

The Future of Nuclear Energy

Before we get to the real problems with nuclear power, let's talk about public opinion*.  A well publicized CBS News Poll tells us the following about whether people approve of building new nuclear power plants in the United States**:

2007 - 45% in favor, 47% against, 8% unsure
2008 - 57% in favor, 34% against, 9% unsure
2011 - 43% in favor, 50% against, 7% unsure 

*Polling numbers here come from the invaluable PollingReport.com. 

**It's also worth noting that people have strong opinions about where these new plants are built.  When the same people were asked whether they approve of new nuclear power plants in their communities, responses are somewhat more reserved:

2007 - 36% in favor, 55% against, 5% unsure
2011 - 35% in favor, 62% against, 3% unsure

Don't read too much into the slight changes between 2007 and 2011 here, as margin of error is a bugbear in these opinion polls.  NIMBY is alive and well, thank you very much.  Just build that nuclear power plant over in the other part of town, thank you.

I include the 2007 numbers because they differ significantly from the more widely cited 2008 numbers.  They are, in fact, much closer the the March, 2011 results.

It would be foolish, however, to just look at polls here, as there's a definite buzz around both traditional and social media about nuclear power, and a general sense that the tide is turning politically and socially against more nuclear power.

There is no indication, however, that any major "mainstream" politician is ready to take up the anti-nuclear power banner, in chief because that would mean angering a lot of energy industry big-wigs who have a lot of say in who gets to spend more money in the next campaign.  That, of course, is a post all on its own, but it bears mentioning here.

Public opinion is our chief concern here.  Obviously the fickle masses are easily moved by sensationalism, and there's little more sensationalist than a natural disaster followed by a nuclear meltdown.  It's no wonder that Americans, in addition to hilariously buying up vast stores of potassium iodide, are feeling less sure about nuclear power.

But are they right-headed in this change of face?  Are the dangers of nuclear power really all that different today than they were a month ago?  Of course not.  Nuclear meltdown has always, and will always be, a non-negligible risk of nuclear power.  It may be exceedingly rare, but even one instance can be devastating.  No matter how safe any particular reactor is, the worst-case scenario for nuclear power is disastrous.  And that is what people are currently rallying behind.

That is takes an actual disaster to remind people of this fact is, of course, the silly part.  We humans have notoriously short memories, and as big a deal as the current situation in Japan seems, it has already lost significant momentum (in the face of a new sensational story in Libya and, of course, the triumphs of Butler and Virginia Commonwealth in March Madness).  It's only a matter of time before everyone settles down and forgets how scared they were of nuclear power in March of 2011.

I would argue, though, that it would be foolish to ignore this opportunity to talk about what nuclear power is and isn't.  Now, I'm no expert, but I know enough about chemistry and physics, and have done enough background research of my own that I feel confident putting a few important considerations forward here.  We've all seen, now, what ill can come of nuclear power gone wrong.  What ill, then, can come of nuclear power gone right?

First of all, what is nuclear power gone right?  There's little question that nuclear power is incredibly more efficient than our beloved combustible fossil fuels power.  It takes, not surprisingly, much less uranium to boil water than it does burning oil, and carbon dioxide doesn't get pumped into the atmosphere along the way.  This, however, is the first troubling thing about nuclear power: nuclear waste.  As more and more of the world's energy comes from nuclear sources, more and more waste gets produced.  What happens to this waste?  We store it in vast pools, both because it's still dangerous (check the "legacy waste" section of this Wikipedia article for a heartwarming story about contamination of an aquifer in Ohio) and because we're dealing with half-lives ranging in the 10,000 to 1,000,000 year range.

Yeah.

So, about 10,000 years ago there were a total of, oh, roughly zero cities in the entire world, as human beings had not yet come up with the idea of "civilization."  Let's not even talk about 1,000,000 years.

The thing is, no one is quite sure what to do with nuclear waste, exactly, and that's not really a concern for nuclear energy companies.  Why think about the future when you can think about the present?  Right now there is no question that we need power and we need it from a source other than fossil fuels.  Nuclear power already has an infrastructure, it's efficient, and it's mostly safe most of the time (except when there's an earthquake, or there's a problem with the waste storage, or if someone manages to steal some of the uranium or plutonium being refined).  And you know what, that's exactly right.  For all intents and purposes, nuclear power is what we need to do because, frankly, we've neglected other, better options* for so long that it will take too long and cost too much to replace our massive energy needs with anything else. 

*Namely solar.  Wind energy has non-negligible and often-overlooked problems beyond how hideous it makes once beautiful hills.  The chief among these is the outrageous cost of the lubricants necessary to make the things actually work.  Not only are those lubricants expensive, and not only do turbines need lots of it, but usually lubricants are, you guessed it, oil based.  Not that they have to be petroleum based, necessarily, but almost all industrial lubricants are.

Here's the real kicker though.  Nuclear energy is not a long-term solution to our problems.  I highly recommend the Azimuth Project for its collected wisdom (contributions come from a variety of scientists in a variety of fields) on general planet saving, but their piece on "Peak Uranium" is particularly important to our discussion here.  The Internet is rife with argumentation about how much uranium there is available for future energy production.  Claims range from 10 years to several billion, so obviously someone is lying for political gain.

The Azimuth article offers a simple thought-experiment, instead.  Assume we replaced all other energy consumption and production with nuclear power.  How long could our current stores of uranium support that level of energy use?  Their answer: 10 years.  70 if you count all potential, but not yet mined, sources.

Now that's not saying that there's only 10 (or 70) years of uranium available.  As we know, we're moving towards a hybrid energy world, where nuclear power plays a small role in the bigger.  But it is informative, no?  As we expand our reliance on nuclear power, we have to remember that it is not a renewable source of energy.  Even if we find more than we currently have found (something many scientists believe is likely, as there have been few large-scale prospecting efforts), and even if we also tap all available thorium and plutonium sources, nuclear energy simply cannot last forever.

Now, recall that much nuclear waste will continue to be a problem for 10,000 years.  Does 70 years worth of power - or even, if we're extra generous and double the uranium available and count thorium as a fuel source and ignore rising and increasingly industrialized and digitized populations, 400 years worth of power - justify 10,000 plus years worth of waste?  Does it not seem that the history will deem us barbaric, wanton, and, above all, extremely stupid for making that trade?

As I mentioned above, this doesn't change that we are going to expand the use of nuclear power in both the United States and around the world, nor should it.  We truthfully don't have many other options.  And that's the point: let's not simply celebrate this "solution" to our energy problems.  The nuclear age is a bitter failure on the part of human civilization to plan ahead, to think reasonably, and to act conscientiously towards its future generations.

In short, the immediate future of nuclear energy is bright, indeed, in spite of wavering public opinion.  The distant future?  That's another story.

Friday, March 25, 2011

The Writing Process and Upcoming Posts

On the way to producing even something as innocuous as a blog post, there's a culling process.  Ideas have to be sifted and shifted, weighed and discarded before they make their way to the blank canvas of the input screen.  From there, they turn into the monstrosities that you read (or prudently ignore) in this space here.  Though the actual writing is something I usually do quickly, there is significant meditation, conversation, and consideration on the front end.

Which is all to say that, even though I haven't been writing very much during this visit to San Francisco, there's an awful lot to write about, and I've come up with more ideas for posts in the last couple weeks than I can possibly turn into readable entries anytime soon.  At times of inspiration, this is usually true.  It's not uncommon to run through a good dozen ideas for every one that actually becomes a post.  At other times it can be hard to generate even a single idea.

Nevertheless, I find it important to write even when I struggle to know what to write about.  Why?  Because of something I learned from my piano teacher, Todd Kelly, while I was growing up.  He once told me that, as a pianist, sometimes you're inspired and sometimes your not.  The purpose of practice, then, is to ensure that, when you are inspired, you can harness that creative energy and make your musical dreams into a reality.  It is, in short, no good imagining fantastical glissandos when your hands can't play them.

What's more, if you practice enough, it's likely that you'll find yourself being inspired more often, too.  Though I also would caution against over-specialization.  Focus on practice alone, to the exclusion of the world, might stop you from ever being inspired by, you know, the world, which is frankly more inspiring a place than a practice room.

Anyway, as you can tell, all of that is transferable to writing (or to any other pursuit, really).  If you don't slough through those ugly times when you can't think of anything to write about, and you don't want to write, and you wonder what's the point, you'll struggle to write when you do have a bright idea.  There's a kind of learning that goes on when you struggle to succeed that, I believe, fills in the cracks in the learning that comes easily.

So with that in mind, I want to expose a little bit of my own writing process by sharing a slew of ideas that I've been contemplating these last few days while zipping from museum to symphony to restaurant without a chance to even turn on my computer.  Not all of these will become posts, and those that do, I suspect, will end up very different than how I imagine them working now.  Some will turn out to not have enough meat for a full post, while others will have to be cut into pieces.  Part of the point of blogging in the first place is that it's not immediately clear which is which.  Only writing will tell.

My Decision - Not a riff on the LeBron James motif, much fun as that would be.  My current choice between attending UCSD or Stanford to do my PhD work is, as far as I can tell, the most important decision I've had to make in my life so far.  While we certainly face countless momentous decisions every day, rarely are we conscious ahead of time that any given crossroads is truly life altering.

Rough Dissertation Ideas -  This is related to the above.  In order to help make this decision, I was advised by a Professor at Stanford to run through my current top 4 or 5 dissertation ideas, and to see which school would better fit with those possibilities.

Defining Learning Sciences and Communications - The last iteration of the decision theme, this would be a high-level attempt to understand what the two programs I've been admitted to really are.  Stanford's "Learning Sciences and Technology Design" program practically demands an attempt at definition, while "Communications" is so broad and ambiguous a field that it would be valuable for me to place myself within it.

Drawing an Aging Curve - I'm fascinated and, in some ways, terrified, by the human life-cycle.  Joe Posnanski sometimes writes about athletes and how they believe they will never get worse, or, even more improbably, that they will continue to improve indefinitely.  I'm curious as to how that maps to non-athletes as well (from a theoretical and speculative perspective, anyway; I don't know the research on this stuff).

What is Art? - Inspired by the ongoing conversation Jericha and I have had here in San Francisco, I want to explore thoughts on narrative, meaning, categories, and specialization as they relate to artistic creation and artistic consumption.  Painting, music, literature, games, and so on are all possible angles.  So is - be forewarned - Schopenhauer.

Beethoven's Eroica, Part 2 - I haven't forgotten the music project, either.  Part two (and beyond) is in the works.

Darren Waterston's Clearing - Of all the art I've seen in the past week or so, there are a small set of pieces that particularly stand out to me.  This is one of them, and while it is abstract, I think it lends itself well to some layman analysis and interpretation.

Caius (sic) Marius on the Ruins of Carthage - A John Vanderlyn painting from 1807, this piece is another worth writing about.  I find it surprisingly prescient.

The Symphony from the New World Live - It may surprise you that I spent a year at Stanford without ever seeing the San Francisco Symphony live.  During this trip I've remedied the oversight with the help of Dvorák.  His most famous piece is a both very accessible and deceptively subtle and complex.  Definitely worth a listen and some analysis.  Also worth mention is the quality of the symphony and the symphony hall in San Francisco.

San Francisco (and Stanford) Retrospective - I already wrote an in situ poetic rambling about my experience of staying in San Francisco earlier in my visit, but I feel like there's still plenty more snobbish waxing I might do.

Cities and Invisible Cities - Italo Calvino is one of my favorite authors, and Invisible Cities is on my "Best Books Ever" shortlist.*  Why not, instead of just gibbering about my own experience, bring in the expert.  Of course, talking about Invisible Cities means talking about design and emotion and love and desire and meaning and civilization and religion and, well, yeah, just about everything.

* How short is that list?  Frankly, Invisible Cities might very well be on the list even if I cut it down to one.  Which gives me an idea for another post...

What Makes a Good Museum? - One last San Francisco inspired post, taking a broad view of the museums I've visited during my trip.  What makes them work (or not), from my uninformed perspective as a simple museum-goer?

Science and Optimism - A response to the eminent Joe Spotts's recent post, Science is Optimism.  I would tell you more, but I haven't actually read the whole thing yet (I've been busy, and it is tagged with "absurdly long winded posts").  Anyway, don't tell him and maybe I can get away with writing a response without reading it.  You know, kind of like everyone else on the Internet.

Watson, Computer Overlord - I did recently watch the IBM computer Watson "compete" on Jeopardy.  I say "compete" because, frankly, it completely crushed its opposition, which included two of the most successful Jeopardy contestants ever.  While the whole thing is a little sensationalist and, of course, not nearly as big a jump in computing as the IBM people make it sound, a computer that can deal with common language statements has profound implications.

Baseball Team Names - Inspired in part by a Pitchers and Poets post (which in turn was inspired by a Cardboard Connection post) about current MLB hats, I think it would be fun to do a run down of MLB team names.  There are a lot of potential angles here, but the ones that interest me most are:

1) Pure Poetry - wherein we lament the loss of the sonorous Montreal Expos and shame the atrocity that is the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
2) Appropriateness - wherein the Los Angeles Dodgers don't make a bit of sense, while the Philadelphia Phillies is perhaps a bit too obvious.
3) Historical Significance - wherein the New York Yankees are as iconic as they come, whereas the Tampa Bay (Devil?) Rays can't even decide who they are.

Nuclear Power - In the aftermath of the Japan earthquake and Nuclear disaster, public opinions is quickly turning against expanded nuclear power (not that it matters, since big wigs from both major parties are still firmly in favor).  The problem is, people are changing their minds for all the wrong reasons.  Nuclear power is terrible, but not because of the threat of meltdown.  How is it terrible, then?  Let me count the ways (and, of course, we'll also count the not inconsequential ways in which it is not terrible).

The FEC vs. Citizens United - For those of you who aren't aware, the Supreme Court ruled prior to the 2010 elections that corporations could effectively give infinite sums of money to political campaigns.  The truth of the matter is, most people from both parties believe that corporations have too much influence in politics already, and that influence is only growing.  So let's talk about corporations, law, precedent, and the effort to reverse the trend.

The Man Who Arranges the Blocks - I don't know if there's a post in this, but I love it.

So there you have it, almost 20 ideas for posts.  I'd say the odds are roughly even that my next post is none of these.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Lacertilian Politics

In the process of rereading (for the so-embarrassingly-many-I-can't-remembereth time) the 5-book long Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy "trilogy," I stumbled across a passage I did not particularly remember, but which I think is as good a summary of electoral politics as you'll find anywhere.  It goes thus:

[A giant robot from outer space] held up a hand.
"I come in peace," it said, adding after a long moment of further grinding, "take me to your Lizard."
Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this ...
"It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see."
[Arthur Dent speaking] "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?"
"No," said Ford ... "nothing so simple.  Nothing anything like so straightforward.  On its world, the people are people.  The leaders are lizards.  The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people."
"Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy."
"I did," said Ford.  "It is."
"So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't the people get red of the lizards?"
"It honestly doesn't occur to them," said ford.  "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want."
"You mean they actually vote for the lizards?"
"Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course."
"But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?"
"Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in."

Needless to say, the next time I'm accused of "wasting my vote" on a third party candidate who has no hope of winning, I think I'll refer the accuser to this passage.  At a certain point you just have to stop voting for the lizards, don't you?

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

The Littered Streets

It's easy to forget what "urban" means when you spend enough time in a place like Honolulu.  Sure, it's a city, and sure, it has a downtown complete with massive office and apartment buildings, littered streets and homeless and/or crazy people wandering aimlessly asking for change.  Indeed, I would argue that there is very much an urban part of Honolulu.  It's just not very big.

Compare that with San Francisco, a city that is no New York or Los Angeles, but is a city nonetheless.  Living in Honolulu it is easy to forget that, in cities there is little grass, few bushes, and trees only where they are planted along the side of the street.  It's a far cry from the greenery (and, let's not forget, blue-ry) of even the most urban parts of Hawaii.  That San Francisco is one of the more environmental, progressive cities in the country just goes to show.

Perhaps the most stunning thing about being in a "real" city, however, is the trash.  There's trash everywhere, to a degree that is unthinkable in Honolulu.  Oh sure, the streets of Waikiki are often littered with cigarette butts and advertisements, but not like in San Francisco.  In Honolulu those dirty denizens of the gutters and alleyways appear as guilty children, just removing their hands from the cookie jar.  They don't mean to be there, and they'll be picked up (or, sadly, washed into the ocean) soon enough.  In San Francisco, by contrast, the garbage is at home on the street, daring you to ask it what it's doing there.  Instead of menehune, the trash is the ali'i, unapproachable and in charge.

I think, perhaps, that's because people are so much less personable in big cities.  Oh, they're friendly enough once you get them in a restaurant or cafe, or if they deliver your pizza.  On the street, though, it's a different story.  One must avert one's eyes at all times, and the friendly nod and "Howzit" that is an accepted and expected part of being a Honolulu pedestrian is noticeably absent.  Instead, walking the streets of San Francisco - or any city, I suspect - is a time to worship the trash gods littering the streets, eyes cast downward, darting from tattered magazine to used bus pass to empty plastic cup in reverence.

Don't get me wrong, San Francisco is a wonderful place.  Where Honolulu couldn't be bothered to pay for its symphony, San Francisco boasts one of the finest in the world, with multiple art museums and science museums, an amazing ballpark, and an embarrassment of great cafes and restaurants.  San Francisco, in many ways, is the cultural center of the whole Western United States, a city with quirky personality, where just about anything is allowed and freedom is not just a concept, but a reality.  Honolulu is stuffy and, ironically considering its electoral history, deeply conservative by comparison, so stuck up on its own multiculturalism that half the time it ends up being more bigoted because of it.

I do wonder, though, if maybe we've gotten too used to city life.  It's easy, in the city, to forget where food comes from, to lose track of the long pathway from farm to the dinner plate.  It's easy, also, to settle for processed, preserved, never-goes-bad stuff that eats you more than you eat it.  It's easy to ignore that the trash on the streets here, just like the trash in Honolulu, ends up in the ocean (it just takes a little longer), and becomes a part of the great pacific trash island that is perhaps the most honest symbol for humanity that we have.  Our most monumental achievement.

Again, I don't mean to sound pessimistic.  Though I don't fully know what I mean.  The truth of the matter is, it's easy to see why this place - while the rain falls on a Tuesday evening - is a place of would-be poets and idealistic politicos, a place where men and women and men and men and women and women (and anyone in between) believe in love for real.  And yet, behind all that striving and ambition of the young idealist, behind the desperation and hope of the homeless man, behind the green-washing of the grocery store and behind the bedazzled faces of the tourists (like me) there's still all that trash on the ground.  I still wonder, walking the streets of a great city - which is exuberant and desperate all at once, and everything in between - when will we learn to take care of the little stuff, much less a city?

Friday, March 11, 2011

The Grade Band Paradox

Ok, so I'm inventing a term here.  The term is the title: the "grade band paradox."  It refers to an inherent problem in K-12 curricula that no one seems to acknowledge when they're doing research, making policy, or framing standards and tests.  In reality, I'm sure I'm not the first to notice this, but it was particularly striking to me as I watched a presentation about ongoing work the National Research Council is doing along with achieve.org on new standards.  One of the chief goals of these new standards is "grade bands."  In short, the science education pooh-bahs think that there should be logical, rational, cohesive progress from grade to grade, with students from all over the place mirroring each other.

The problem is this*: we are always trying to create a cohesive, comprehensive K-12 curriculum.  We want second grade to build on first, first to build on kindergarten, and the same up the chain.  High school science classes should be able to rely - in theory - on the work done in the middle school.

*We're going to ignore, for now,** that different places - like Hawaii and New York - might have vastly different cultural and environmental needs in their curricula.  A simple example is how much more vital it is to instill an understanding of coral life cycles at a young age in Hawaii, whereas the Hawaiian student will struggle to understand the equally important concepts of continental drift (for example) and the creation and erosion of mountains (like the Appalachians) and how that lends itself to mining.

**We're also going to ignore that individual students might differ from each other.

Wait, that's not the problem yet.  That's just good curriculum design.  After all, wouldn't we rather have a cohesive experience for our students?  No, the problem comes from the continuous reinventing and tweaking that necessarily goes along with these efforts.  Rarely does a given set of standards really last all that long.  Or, even if the standards stay the same, the state-adopted standard-aligned curriculum changes.  Or, even if that stays the same, schools change, teachers are hired and fired, students move around...

The result is that, despite good intentions and sound principles, no student actually receives a coherent K-12 experience.  We decide so quickly that there are flaws and policy problems and teacher problems and learner problems and so on that we never actually give our comprehensive K-12 plans the thirteen years they need to run (not to mention the X years after that for the lessons to really take hold).

An example will serve to elucidate the problem:

Johnny is five years old, and will enter kindergarten this fall, in September of 2011.  As he begins at his local public school, he'll be operating under the standards and procedures of No Child Left Behind.

Come 2013, the NRC framework and new standards have been published, and the Federal Government moves to adopt them.  States slowly follow suit, meaning Johnny's elementary school makes the switch as he enters the fourth grade at the end of 2015.

After a couple of years, Johnny's home state is starting to recognize flaws in the current program, and so they do an internal revision and change testing procedures state wide.  As a result, Johnny's state (and school district) adopt a new text book and new curriculum in 2018.  Johnny enters seventh grade already having faced NCLB, the new standards, and a revision and curriculum change.

Of course, in 2018 a new President enters office with a new plan for education.  He appoints a revolutionary new Secretary of Ed who makes sweeping changes to science curricula in particular, integrating more even more technology and engineering studies than were in the NRC standards of 2013.  This process takes three years to come to fruition, and so as Johnny enters his junior year of high school in 2021, he confronts his fourth new integrated, cohesive K-12 system.

And so on.  The point being, you can't really have a grade-by-grade curricular arc when the arc changes every three to five years.  Kids in America are in school for 13 years, and radical education policy changes - or even small tweaks - lead to a disjointed pathway through the education system.

Of course, policy people don't see past the next election, nor do they see past theory and into reality.  To them, the K-12 system they approve in 2013 means that all kids in school in 2013 are receiving a cohesive curricular experience when, in fact, they are not.  Most of them will be facing, instead, yet another variation on the standards theme, a variation that throws out much - or at least some - of what they have learned heretofore.

It's hardly surprising, then, when a new system is put in place, but high school students don't seem to perform any better within a year or two, or even four, or even seven.  If the new system really works - or if it doesn't - you won't really know for at least 13 years, and there's no getting around it.

A better approach, then, would be to institute new educational policies starting at the kindergarten level, and then working up through the high school.  Unless there is a broad consensus that the current system is obviously and demonstrably messed up so badly that it ought to be thrown out (and NCLB might just be such a case), it's probably better to give students an older, but more cohesive experience than a newer, but fragmented and confusing one.

Actually, I should phrase that as a question.  I don't know which is better, and I don't know if anyone does, because generally new policy is implemented across the grades, all at once, without any regard for the experiences of students who have been in the current system, operating under its rules and its expectations and its standards for as much as a decade.  I would submit that, at some point, it might behoove us to remember the Grade Band Paradox, to remember that your shiny new K-12 framework will never be experienced by a student all the way from K to 12.